независимая газета - Экономическая экспертная группа

G?A:<BKBF:Y=:A?L:
OjZgblv^_gv]bijb^_lky\jm[eyo
P;\jy^ebhldZ`_lkyhlj_]mebjh\Zgby\Zexlgh]hdmjkZ
?\]_gbyH[moh\Z
^_dZ[jy
< ke_^mxs_f ]h^m jm[ev [m^_l mdj_ieylvky kbevg__ q_f lh]h h`b^Z_l P; b ^ey
jhkkbckdhcwdhghfbdbwlh[m^_lk_jv_agufbkiulZgb_fLZdh\u\u\h^u\q_jZrg_cdhgn_j_gpbb
I_jki_dlb\ujm[ey\]h^m
K gZqZeZ `_ l_dms_]h ]h^Z dmjk ^heeZjZ d jm[ex kgbabeky m`_ gZ GZ ^gyo
jmdh\h^bl_evWdhghfbq_kdhcwdki_jlghc]jmiiu?\k_c=mj\bqhp_gbej_ZevgucdmjkdZd
jm[e_c aZ ^heeZj GZihfgbf qlh _s_ \ bxg_ ]h^Z wdk]eZ\Z P_gljh[ZgdZ <bdlhj
=_jZs_gdh aZy\eye qlh j_Zevguc dmjk ^heeZjZ d ihdmiZl_evghc kihkh[ghklb khklZ\ey_l jm[e_c<ijhq_fZgZeblbd[ZgdZLjZklGbdheZcDhs__\khfg_\Z_lky\wlbopbnjZobhlf_qZ_l
qlh^Z`_iZjbl_lihdmiZl_evghckihkh[ghklbZj]mf_gl^Ze_dhg_[_kkihjguc
<[m^ms_f]h^mjm[evijh^he`blmdj_ieylvkyIhhp_gd_jmdh\h^bl_ey[Zgdh\kdhc]jmiiu
P_gljZfZdjhwdhghfbq_kdh]hZgZebaZbdjZldhkjhqgh]hijh]ghabjh\ZgbyHe_]ZKhegp_\Z\
]h^mjm[e_\u_\eh`_gby[m^ml[he__^hoh^gufbq_f^heeZjh\u_>_g_`ghdj_^blgZyiheblbdZ
gZ ]h^ ij_^iheZ]Z_l qlh P; [m^_l klj_fblvky g_ ^himklblv mdj_ie_gby j_Zevgh]h
wnn_dlb\gh]hdmjkZjm[ey[hevr_q_fgZaZ]h^H^gZdh[m^_lklj_fblvkybg_^himklbl
jZagu_ \_sb aZf_qZ_l Khegp_\ >_eh \ lhf qlh ]eZ\gZy p_ev ^_g_`ghdj_^blghc iheblbdb kgb`_gb_bgneypbbIhwlhfmwdki_jl^himkdZ_lqlhP;ij_^ihql_l^himklblvmdj_ie_gb_jm[ey
k\_joghjfZlb\gh]hqlh[ukgbablvwfbkkbxb\ibkZlvky\aZ^Zggu_hjb_glbjuihbgneypbb
Ijb wlhf \ k\h[h^gh_ ieZ\Zgb_ P; jm[ev \k_ `_ g_ hlimklbl Dhs__\ hlf_qZ_l qlh
wdhghfbdZdwlhfmg_]hlh\Z:ZgZeblbdIjhfure_gghkljhbl_evgh]h[ZgdZ?dZl_jbgZFZl\__\Z
kqblZ_lqlhP;[m^_l\f_rb\Zlvky\dmjkhh[jZah\Zgb_ihdZg_bkq_jiZ_l\k_o\hafh`ghkl_cih
kl_jbebaZpbb ^_g_`gh]h ij_^eh`_gby Ihgylgh qlh m`_ g_ i_j\uc ]h^ P; aZy\ey_l h k\hbo
]jZg^bhaguoieZgZobg_bkihegy_lbogh\ihke_^g__\j_fykblmZpbyklZeZf_gylvky\emqrmx
klhjhgmP;klZe[he__^bgZfbqgufbijhn_kkbhgZevgufLZdqlhih\lhj_gbykblmZpbbl_dms_]h
]h^Zdh]^Zjm[evd^heeZjmmdj_iblky\ghfbgZevghf\ujZ`_gbbgZZ\j_Zevghfijbf_jgh
gZ\[eb`Zcrb_iZjme_lg_[m^_l
IjZ\^Z mkbeby P; fZeh q_f fh]ml ihfhqv kblmZpbb wdhghfbklu mdZau\Zxl gZ lh qlh
ij_^eh`_gb_^_g_]\wdhghfbd_kebrdhfkbevghaZ\bkblhl\g_rg_lhj]h\h]h[ZeZgkZZkijhkgZ
^_gv]b\gmljbkljZguaZf_lghh]jZgbq_gIjbwlhfg_ihgylghdZdhcj_Zdpbb`^ZlvhlgZk_e_gby
dhlhjh_ [hevrmx qZklv k[_j_`_gbc ijh^he`Z_l ojZgblv \ ^heeZjZo JZgvr_ ikboheh]bq_kdb
\Z`ghc kqblZeZkv hlf_ldZ \ jm[e_c aZ ^heeZj l_i_jv H^gZdh ih fg_gbx wdki_jlZ
F>F[ZgdZ I_ljZ G_cfur_\Z iZgbq_kdbc k[jhk gZk_e_gb_f gZebqguo ^heeZjh\ fh`_l
kijh\hpbjh\Zlvg_^hklb`_gb_^heeZjhfdhgdj_lghchlf_ldbZkdhjhklv_]h^\b`_gby\gbabeb
`_dZdh_lhkh[ulb_gZih^h[b_k_gly[jy
Ijb g_ba[_`ghf mdj_ie_gbb jm[ey ieZgu ih m^\h_gbx <<I fh]ml b g_ k[ulvky LZd
Dhs__\hlf_qZ_lqlhm`_k_cqZkgZ[ex^Z_lkyj_adh_mom^r_gb_wdhghfbq_kdhcdhgtxgdlmju<
qZklghklb m\_ebqbebkv aZiZku ]hlh\hc ijh^mdpbb qlh k\b^_l_evkl\m_l h k`Zlbb \gmlj_gg_]h
kijhkZ D wlhfm ^h[Z\behkv g_dhlhjh_ mom^r_gb_ nbgZgkh\h]h khklhygby ij_^ijbylbc b
ijh^he`Zxs__ky iZ^_gb_ p_gh\hc dhgdmj_glhkihkh[ghklb jhkkbckdbo ijhba\h^bl_e_c <hl \Zf
j_Zevgh_mdj_ie_gb_jm[ey]h\hjblZgZeblbd
Ijbwlhfkgb`_gb_dmjkZ^heeZjZfh`_lijb\_klbdkljmdlmjgufbaf_g_gbyf wdhghfbdb
ihkdhevdmbfihjlgu_l_ogheh]bb[m^ml^_r_\e_H^gZdhihdZmdj_ie_gb_jm[eylhevdhkgb`Z_l
^hoh^uwdkihjl_jh\
IhdZ jm[ev ijh^he`Z_l [ukljh ^hjh`Zlv k_]h^gy dmjk m`_ khklZ\ey_l jm[ey aZ
^heeZj:ihhp_gdZfwdki_jlh\P_gljZwdhghfbq_kdh]hZgZebaZZ]_glkl\ZBgl_jnZdkddhgpm
]h^Z^heeZjhimklblky^hjm[ey