Сравнительная таблица сталинского Приказа №227 и

%"' /"1 ' * &' "&## % 2227
&##''&'(0-) !( #&'"# " $%!"1!.) %#&&&# !$%'#%&# %! # 1917 #.
''/ #"#, +'!. $%
$%" $%&1.
" XXII # #"".)
#&'"# "
% 227 « ,( "!»
:
http://www.buza.ru/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=49
31&view=next&sid=69a1a3bbd25d8849c4d8d8
02c5b6b490
28 +@.A 1942 &.
&. 14-%#
243.+01%0=, % 42141$45%1%#0++
+.+ $.#&123+A545%1%#0++
0(23+A5(.@ % (&1 %1(00=8 +.+ +0=8
%3#)'($0=8 2315+% 144++
'(,45%+A8 23+*0#(54A
&146'#345%(00=/ +*/(00+-1/ +
21'%(3&#(54A : .+;(0+@ %4(8 23#%
41451A0+A + 4/(3501, -#*0+.
244.+01%0=, % .+:01, +.+ :(3(*
'36&+8 .+9 2(3(2+4-(, +.+ +01/
401;(0++, 4 -(/-.+$1 0#81'A<(/4A
% 0(23+A5(.>4-1, #3/++ %1
%.#'(0+A8 0(23+A5(.A, % /(450145+,
*#0A51, %1,4-#/+ 0(23+A5(.A, +.+
%11$<( % 5#-1, /(450145+, -6'#
$6'(5 *#23(<(01 2+4#5> 2+4>/#,
21'%(3&#(54A : .+;(0+@ %4(8
141$(00=8, .+:01 + 21 41451A0+@
23+4%1(00=8, 23#% + 23(+/6<(45% +
15'#:( % +423#%+5(.>0=(
#3(45#054-+( 15'(.(0+A 0# 431- 15
53(8 '1 ;(45+ .(5 ; # (4.+ 23+ ?51/
%+01%0=, 411$<+. 4%('(0+A,
/1&6<+( +/(5> -#-1(-.+$1
1501;(0+( - %1(00=/ '(,45%+A/, 51
.+;(0+@ %4(8 23#% 41451A0+A +
44=.-( % -#513)0=( 3#$15= 0# 43115 :(5=3(8 '1 '%#'9#5+ .(5, +.+ $(*
431-#.
%#"## #!&&% ##%#". #0 2227
:
http://www.geocities.com/CapitolHill/Parliament/7231/pr_227.htm
3#& $314#(5 0# 73105 %4( 01%=( 4+.= +, 0( 4:+5#A4> 4 $1.>;+/+ '.A 0(&1 215(3A/+, .(*(5 %2(3(', 3%(54A %&.6$> 1%(54-1&1 1@*#,
*#8%#5=%#(5 01%=( 3#,10=, 126451;#(5 + 3#*13A(5 0#;+ &131'# + 4(.#, 0#4+.6(5, &3#$+5 + 6$+%#(5 41%(54-1( 0#4(.(0+(. 1+ +'65 %
3#,10( 1310()#, 0# 106, 0# @&( 6 %1315 (%(301&1 #%-#*#. (/(9-+( 1--62#05= 3%654A - 5#.+0&3#'6, - 1.&( + 815A5 .@$1,
9(01, *#8%#5+5> 6$#0>, (%(30=, #%-#* 4 +8 0(75A0=/+ + 8.($0=/+ $1&#545%#/+. 3#& 6)( *#8%#5+. 131;+.1%&3#', 5#31$(.>4-,
1441;>, 62A04-, #.6,-+, 1%1:(3-#44-, 1451%-0#-106, 21.1%+06 1310()#. #45> %1,4- ")01&1 73105#, +'A *# 2#0+-(3#/+,
145#%+.# 1451% + 1%1:(3-#44- $(* 4(3>(*01&1 412315+%.(0+A + $(* 23+-#*# +* 14-%=, 21-3=% 4%1+ *0#/(0# 21*131/.
#4(.(0+( 0#;(, 453#0=, 4 .@$1%>@ + 6%#)(0+(/ 15014A<((4A - 3#401, 3/++, 0#:+0#(5 3#*1:#31%=%#5>4A % 0(,, 5(3A(5 %(36 %
3#406@ 3/+@, # /01&+( +* 0+8 231-.+0#@5 3#406@ 3/+@ *# 51, :51 10# 15'#(5 0#; 0#31' 21' A3/1 0(/(9-+8 6&0(5#5(.(,, # 4#/#
65(-#(5 0# %1451-.
(-1513=( 0(6/0=( .@'+ 0# 73105( 65(;#@5 4($A 3#*&1%13#/+ 1 51/, :51 /= /1)(/ + '#.>;( 154562#5> 0# %1451-, 5#- -#- 6 0#4 /01&1
5(33+513++, /01&1 *(/.+, /01&1 0#4(.(0+A + :51 8.($# 6 0#4 %4(&'# $6'(5 % +*$=5-(. !5+/ 10+ 815A5 123#%'#5> 4%1( 21*1301(
21%('(0+( 0# 73105#8. 1 5#-+( 3#*&1%13= A%.A@54A 0#4-%1*> 7#.>;+%=/+ + .)+%=/+, %=&1'0=/+ .+;> 0#;+/ %3#&#/.
#)'=, -1/#0'+3, -#)'=, -3#401#3/((9 + 21.+53#$150+- '1.)0= 210A5>, :51 0#;+ 43('45%# 0($(*&3#0+:0=. (33+513+A 1%(54-1&1
1@*# - ?51 0( 2645=0A, # .@'+ - 3#$1:+(, -3(45>A0(, +05(..+&(09+A, 0#;+ 159= + /#5(3+, )(0=, $3#5>A, '(5+. (33+513+A ,
-15136@ *#8%#5+. + 453(/+54A *#8%#5+5> %3#&, - ?51 8.($ + '36&+( 231'6-5= '.A #3/++ + 5=.#, /(5#.. + 512.+%1 '.A 231/=;.(00145+,
7#$3+-+, *#%1'=, 40#$)#@<+( #3/+@ %1136)(0+(/ + $1(23+2#4#/+, )(.(*0=( '131&+. 14.( 215(3+ -3#+0=, (.13644++,
3+$#.5+-+, 10$#44# + '36&+8 1$.#45(, 6 0#4 45#.1 /(0>;( 5(33+513++, 45#.1 $=5>, 45#.1 0#/01&1 /(0>;( .@'(,, 8.($#, /(5#..#,
*#%1'1%, 7#$3+-. = 215(3A.+ $1.(( 70 /.0. 0#4(.(0+A, $1.(( 80 /.0. 26'1% 8.($# % &1' + $1.(( 10 /.0. 5100 /(5#..# % &1'. 0#4 0(5
6)( 23(1$.#'#0+A 0#' 0(/9#/+ 0+ % .@'4-+8 3(4634#8, 0+ % *#2#4#8 8.($#. 54562#5> '#.>;( - *0#:+5 *#&6$+5> 4($A + *#&6$+5> %/(45( 4
5(/ 0#;6 1'+06. #)'=, 01%=, -.1:1- 145#%.(001, 0#/+ 5(33+513++ $6'(5 %4(/(301 64+.+%#5> %3#&# + %4(/(301 14.#$.A5> 0#;6
1$13106, 0#;6 1'+06.
1?51/6 0#'1 % -130( 23(4(-#5> 3#*&1%13= 1 51/, :51 /= +/((/ %1*/1)0145> $(* -109# 154562#5>, :51 6 0#4 /01&1 5(33+513++, 453#0#
0#;# %(.+-# + $1&#5#, 0#4(.(0+A /01&1, 8.($# %4(&'# $6'(5 % +*$=5-(. #-+( 3#*&1%13= A%.A@54A .)+%=/+ + %3('0=/+, 10+ 14.#$.A@5
0#4 + 64+.+%#@5 %3#&#, +$1 (4.+ 0( 23(-3#5+/ 154562.(0+A, 145#0(/4A $(* 8.($#, $(* 512.+%#, $(* /(5#..#, $(* 4=3>A, $(* 7#$3+- +
*#%1'1%, $(* )(.(*0=8 '131&.
* ?51&1 4.('6(5, :51 213# -10:+5> 154562.(0+(.
+ ;#&6 0#*#'! #-+/ 5(2(3> '1.)(0 $=5> 0#; &.#%0=, 23+*=%.
2
245.,12&1>- & 5$02&2/?120
256$&/)1,, &2 &4)0B %2B
.20$1(2&$1,B ;$56?A, 5&2)'2 0)56$
,/, 32+,:,,, 32 34,;,1$0, 1)
&>+>&$)0>0 ,532/1)1,)0 (2/'$
5/7*%> , &2+/2*)11>0, 1$ 5/7;$%2B ,/, &2 &4)0B %2B 2%B+$11256B0,,
32(&)4'$)65B : /,<)1,A &5)9 34$&
52562B1,B , 50)4612- .$+1,, ,/,
55>/.) & .$624*1>) 4$%26> 26
;)6>4)9 (2 3B61$(:$6, /)6.
245. !./21,&<,-5B 26 ,532/1)1,B
34,.$+$1,B 34,1B6? 7;$56,) & %2A,
,/, & 26()/?1>9 %2)&>9 ()-56&,B9,
32(&)4'$)65B : /,<)1,A &5)9 34$&
52562B1,B , 50)4612- .$+1,.
246. ,12&1>- & &2+%7*()1,, &2
&4)0B %2B (47',9 5/2&$0,,
34,0)420 ,/, ,1>0, ()-56&,B0, .
%)'56&7, 5($;) ,/, ,1207 7./21)1,A
26 %2B, 926B %> 6$.2) &2+%7*()1,) ,
1) ,0)/2 325/)(56&,-, 32(&)4'$)65B
: /,<)1,A &5)9 34$& 52562B1,B ,
50)4612- .$+1,.
246. ,12&1>- & 70></)1120
4$5342564$1)1,, 54)(, 5&2,9 &2-5.
5/792&, +$&)(202 02'7=,9 &>+&$6?
42%256? ,/, %)5324B(2. & &2-5.$9,
32(&)4'$)65B : /,<)1,A &5)9 34$&
52562B1,B , 50)4612- .$+1,, ,/,
55>/.) & .$624*1>) 4$%26> 26
;)6>4)9 (2 (&$(:$6, /)6, ,/, %)+
542.$.
5/, *) 2+1$;)112) ()B1,)
52&)4<)12 32 1)250264,6)/?1256,,
62 &,12&1>- 32(&)4'$)65B :
+$./A;)1,A & .4)3256, 26 2(12'2
'2($ ;)6>4)9 0)5B:)& (2 ;)6>4)9
/)6, ,/, 2(,12;1207 +$./A;)1,A &
&2)112- 6A4?0) 26 2(12'2 (2
;)6>4)9 0)5B:)&.
$(2 732412, (2 325/)(1)- .$3/, .42&, +$=,=$6? .$*(7A 32+,:,A, .$*(>- 0)64 52&)65.2- 6)44,624,,, :)3/B6?5B +$ .$*(>- ./2;2.
52&)65.2- +)0/, , 2656$,&$6? )'2 (2 325/)(1)- &2+02*1256,.
$<$ 2(,1$ 3)4)*,&$)6 6B*)/>) (1,. > (2/*1> 256$12&,6?, $ +$6)0 26%425,6? , 4$+'420,6? &4$'$, ;)'2 %> @62 1$0 1, 562,/2.
)0:> 1) 6$. 5,/?1>, .$. @62 .$*)65B 3$1,.)4$0. 1, 1$34B'$A6 325/)(1,) 5,/>. >()4*$6? ,9 7($4 5)-;$5 - @62 +1$;,6 2%)53);,6?
+$ 1$0, 32%)(7.
2*)0 /, 0> &>()4*$6? 7($4, $ 32620 26%425,6? &4$'$ 1$ +$3$(? $, 02*)0, ,%2 1$<, 8$%4,., , +$&2(> & 6>/7 4$%26$A6 6)3)4?
34).4$512 , 1$< 84216 32/7;$)6 &5) %2/?<) , %2/?<) 5$02/)62&, 6$1.2&, $46,//)4,,, 0,120)62&.
")'2 *) 7 1$5 1) 9&$6$)6?
) 9&$6$)6 324B(.$ , (,5:,3/,1> & 426$9, 32/.$9, (,&,+,B9, & 6$1.2&>9 ;$56B9, & $&,$@5.$(4,/?B9. @620 6)3)4? 1$< '/$&1>1)(256$62.. > (2/*1> 756$12&,6? & 1$<)- $40,, 5642*$-<,- 324B(2. , *)/)+17A (,5:,3/,17, )5/, 0> 926,0 53$56, 32/2*)1,) ,
26562B6? 5&2A 2(,17.
)/?+B ($/?<) 6)43)6? .20$1(,42&, .20,55$42&, 32/,64$%261,.2&, ;$56, , 52)(,1)1,B .2624>9 5$02&2/?12 256$&/BA6 %2)&>)
32+,:,,. )/?+B 6)43)6? ($/?<), .2'($ .20$1(,4>, .20,55$4>, 32/,64$%261,., (2375.$A6, ;62%> 1)5.2/?.2 3$1,.)42& 234)()/B/,
32/2*)1,) 1$ 32/) %2B, ;62%> 21, 7&/).$/, & 265673/)1,) (47',9 %2-:2& , 26.4>&$/, 84216 &4$'7.
$1,.)4> , 6475> (2/*1> ,564)%/B6?5B 1$ 0)56).
61>1) *)/)+1>0 +$.2120 (,5:,3/,1> (/B .$*(2'2 .20$1(,4$, .4$512$40)-:$, 32/,64$%261,.$ (2/*12 B&,6?5B 64)%2&$1,) - 1, <$'7
1$+$( %)+ 34,.$+$ &>5<)'2 .20$1(2&$1,B.
20$1(,4> 426>, %$6$/?21$, 32/.$, (,&,+,,, 5226&)656&7A=,) .20,55$4> , 32/,64$%261,.,, 265673$A=,) 5 %2)&2- 32+,:,, %)+
34,.$+$ 5&><), B&/BA65B 34)($6)/B0, 2(,1>. 6$.,0, .20$1(,4$0, , 32/,64$%261,.$0, , 325673$6? 1$(2 .$. 5 34)($6)/B0,
2(,1>.
$.2& 34,+>& 1$<)- 2(,1>.
>32/1,6? @626 34,.$+ - +1$;,6 26562B6? 1$<7 +)0/A, 53$56, 2(,17, ,564)%,6? , 32%)(,6? 1)1$&,5612'2 &4$'$.
25/) 5&2)'2 +,01)'2 265673/)1,B 32( 1$32420 4$512- 40,,, .2'($ & 1)0):.,9 &2-5.$9 4$5<$6$/$5? (,5:,3/,1$, 1)0:> (/B
&2556$12&/)1,B (,5:,3/,1> 34,1B/, 1).2624>) 5742&>) 0)4>, 34,&)(<,) . 1)3/29,0 4)+7/?6$6$0. 1, 58240,42&$/, 100 <64$81>9
426 ,+ %2-:2& 342&,1,&<,95B & 1$47<)1,, (,5:,3/,1> 32 6475256, ,/, 1)7562-;,&256,, 3256$&,/, ,9 1$ 23$51>) 7;$56., 84216$ ,
34,.$+$/, ,0 ,5.73,6? .42&?A 5&2, '4)9,. 1, 58240,42&$/,, ($/)), 2.2/2 ()5B6.$ <64$81>9 %$6$/?212& ,+ .20$1(,42&,
342&,1,&<,95B & 1$47<)1,, (,5:,3/,1> 32 6475256, ,/, 1)7562-;,&256,, /,<,/, ,9 24()12&, 3256$&,/, ,9 1$ )=) %2/)) 23$51>)
7;$56., 84216$ , 34,.$+$/, ,0 ,5.73,6? 5&2, '4)9,. 1, 58240,42&$/,, 1$.21):, 53):,$/?1>) 264B(> +$'4$*()1,B, 3256$&,/, ,9
32+$(, 1)7562-;,&>9 (,&,+,- , &)/)/, ,0 4$5564)/,&$6? 1$ 0)56) 3$1,.)42& & 5/7;$) 323>6., 5$02&2/?12'2 256$&/)1,B 32+,:,- , &
5/7;$) 323>6., 5($6?5B & 3/)1. $. ,+&)5612, @6, 0)4> &2+>0)/, 5&2) ()-56&,), , 6)3)4? 1)0):.,) &2-5.$ ()4765B /7;<), ;)0 21,
(4$/,5? +,02-. &26 32/7;$)65B, ;62 1)0):.,) &2-5.$ ,0)A6 9242<7A (,5:,3/,17, 926B 7 1,9 1)6 &2+&><)112- :)/, +$=,6> 5&2)42(,1>, $ )56? /,<? 2(1$ '4$%,6)/?5.$B :)/? - 32.24,6? ;7*7A 564$17, $ 1$<, &2-5.$, ,0)A=,) :)/? +$=,6> 5&2)- 3247'$1122(,1>, 1) ,0)A6 6$.2- (,5:,3/,1> , 6)43B6 &&,(7 @62'2 324$*)1,).
) 5/)(7)6 /, 1$0 327;,6?5B & @620 ()/) 7 1$<,9 &4$'2&, .$. 7;,/,5? & 342</20 1$<, 34)(., 7 &4$'2& , 2()4*,&$/, 32620 1$( 1,0,
32%)(7?
# (70$A, ;62 5/)(7)6.
3
247.& 548+6C ( '4C -3&2+3. .1.
>8&3*&68&, +71. 042&3*&, 04+/ 43.
56.7(4+3@, 3+ 95486+'.1& (7+;
76+*78( 0 75&7+3.C .;, 8+, 04.2
56+.29?+78(+334 '@14 ((+6+34
4;6&3+3.+ -3&2+3. .1. >8&3*&68&,
56.)4(&6.(&C87D : 0 1.>+3.C (7+;
56&( 74784D3.D . 72+6834/ 0&-3.
6&7786+1D3.+2, & 564=.+,
56.3&*1+,&?.+ 0 7478&(9 7+/
042&3*@ =.3@, .2+(>.+
(4-24,3478A 75474'78(4(&8A
75&7+3.C -3&2+3. .1. >8&3*&68&,
54*(+6)&C87D : 3&0&-&3.D2 54 2+6+
(.3@, 3& 4734(&3.. 56&(.1,
5478&34(1+33@; ( 78.75 7+)4 978&(&.
248.4+334719,&?./, 7*&(>./7D (
51+3, .1. 5414,.(>./ 469,.+ 56+*
3+56.D8+1+2, 3+ .75413.( 7(4+/
4'D-&33478. 76&,&8A7D 54 *41)9
719,'@ . 56.7D)., 54*(+6)&+87D :
1.>+3.C (7+; 56&( 74784D3.D .
72+6834/ 0&-3..
!$ !" !
!%#:
1. 4+33@2 74(+8&2 :64384( . 56+,*+ (7+)4 042&3*9C?.2 :6438&2.:
&) '+-9714(34 1.0(.*.64(&8A 487895&8+1A3@+ 3&7864+3.D ( (4/70&; . ,+1+-34/ 6904/ 56+7+0&8A 5645&)&3*9 4 842, =84 2@ 24,+2 .
*41,3@ D04'@ 487895&8A . *&1A>+ 3& (47840, =84 48 8&04)4 4878951+3.D 3+ '9*+8 D04'@ (6+*&;
') '+-9714(34 73.2&8A 7 5478& . 3&56&(1D8A ( "8&(09 *1D 56.(1+=+3.D 0 (4+33429 79*9 042&3*9C?.; &62.D2., *45978.(>.;
7&24(41A3@/ 48;4* (4/70 7 -&3.2&+2@; 54-.<./, '+- 56.0&-& 042&3*4(&3.D :6438&;
() 7:462.64(&8A ( 56+*+1&; :6438& 48 1 *4 3 (72486D 54 4'78&34(0+) >86&:3@; '&8&1A434( (54 800 =+14(+0), 09*& 3&56&(1D8A 76+*3.;
. 78&6>.; 042&3*.64( . 7448(+878(9C?.; 541.86&'483.04( (7+; 64*4( (4/70, 564(.3.(>.;7D ( 3&69>+3.. *.7<.51.3@ 54 8697478.
.1. 3+9784/=.(478., . 5478&(.8A .; 3& '41++ 869*3@+ 9=&780. :6438&, =84'@ *&8A .2 (4-24,3478A .7095.8A 064(AC 7(4. 56+78951+3.D
5648.( !4*.3@.
2. 4+33@2 74(+8&2 &62./ . 56+,*+ (7+)4 042&3*9C?.2 &62.D2.:
&) '+-9714(34 73.2&8A 7 54784( 042&3*.64( . 042.77&64( 0465974( . *.(.-./, *45978.(>.; 7&24(41A3@/ 48;4* (4/70 7 -&3.2&+2@;
54-.<./ '+- 56.0&-& 042&3*4(&3.D &62.., . 3&56&(1D8A .; ( (4+33@/ 74(+8 :6438& *1D 56+*&3.D (4+33429 79*9;
') 7:462.64(&8A ( 56+*+1&; &62.. 3-5 ;464>4 (4469,+33@; -&)6&*.8+1A3@; 486D*4( (54 200 =+14(+0 ( 0&,*42), 5478&(.8A .; (
3+5476+*78(+3342 8@19 3+9784/=.(@; *.(.-./ . 4'D-&8A .; ( 719=&+ 5&3.0. . '+7546D*4=34)4 48;4*& =&78+/ *.(.-.. 6&7786+1.(&8A 3&
2+78+ 5&3.0+64( . 86974( . 8+2 5424=A =+783@2 '4/<&2 *.(.-./ (@5413.8A 7(4/ *41) 5+6+* !4*.34/;
() 7:462.64(&8A ( 56+*+1&; &62.. 48 5 *4 10 (72486D 54 4'78&34(0+) >86&:3@; 648 (48 150 *4 200 =+14(+0 ( 0&,*4/), 09*& 3&56&(1D8A
6D*4(@; '4/<4( . 21&*>.; 042&3*.64(, 564(.3.(>.;7D ( 3&69>+3.. *.7<.51.3@ 54 8697478. .1. 3+9784/=.(478., . 5478&(.8A .; 3&
869*3@+ 9=&780. &62.., =84'@ *&8A .2 (4-24,3478A .7095.8A 064(AC 7(4. 56+78951+3.D 5+6+* !4*.34/.
3. 42&3*.6&2 . 042.77&6&2 0465974( . *.(.-./;
&) '+-9714(34 73.2&8A 7 54784( 042&3*.64( . 042.77&64( 54104( . '&8&1A434(, *45978.(>.; 7&24(41A3@/ 48;4* =&78+/ '+- 56.0&-&
042&3*.6& 046597& .1. *.(.-.., 48'.6&8A 9 3.; 46*+3& . 2+*&1. . 3&56&(1D8A ( (4+33@+ 74(+8@ :6438& *1D 56+*&3.D (4+33429 79*9:
') 40&-@(&8A (7D=+709C 5424?A . 54**+6,09 -&)6&*.8+1A3@2 486D*&2 &62.. ( *+1+ 906+51+3.D 546D*0& . *.7<.51.3@ ( =&78D;.
6.0&- 564=+78A (4 (7+; 648&;, B70&*643&;, '&8&6+D;, B70&*6.1AD;, 042&3*&;, >8&'&;.
.