СООБЩЕСТВА ЗООБЕНТОСА ДАГЕСТАНСКОГО РАЙОНА

реклама
;BHEH=BYFHJYlhf‹k±
M>D
WDHEH=BY
KHH;S?KL<:AHH;?GLHK:>:=?KL:GKDH=HJ:CHG:
D:KIBCKDH=HFHJY
‹]FD=mk_cgh\
IjbdZkibckdbcbgklblml[bheh]bq_kdboj_kmjkh\>GPJ:GFZoZqdZeZ
HPDLOSLEUGQFUDQ#LZWUX
KlZlvyijbgylZdi_qZlb]
Ij_^klZ\e_guj_amevlZlubkke_^h\Zgbc^hgguo[bhp_ghah\^Z]_klZgkdh]hjZchgZDZkibyhlf_q_gu\Z`
g_crb_nZdlhjukj_^u\ha^_ckl\mxsb_gZbonhjfbjh\Zgb_Hkh[h_\gbfZgb_m^_e_gh\hkklZgh\e_gbxoZjZd
l_jgh]h^eyijb[j_`guo\h^[bhp_ghaZZfnbih^u3RQWRJDPPDUXVPDHRWLFXVjZajmr_ggh]h\j_amevlZl_ih^gy
lbymjh\gyfhjyMklZgh\e_ghqlh[bhfZkkZ[_glhkZ\i_jbh^ih^t_fZmjh\gyfhjyagZqbl_evgh\ur_q_f\]h
^u_]hgbadh]hmjh\gy
Dexq_\u_keh\ZDZkibckdh_fhj_[bhp_gha[_glhk[bhfZkkZmjh\_gv
=RREHQWKRVFRPPXQLWLHVRIWKH'DJHVWDQDUHDRIWKH&DVSLDQ6HD0.*XVHLQRY&DVSLDQ,QVWLWXWHRI%LR
ORJLFDO5HVRXUFHV'DJHVWDQ6FLHQWLILF&HQWHU5XVVLDQ$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHV0DNKDFKNDOD
%HQWKLFELRFHQRVHVRIWKH'DJHVWDQDUHDRIWKH&DVSLDQ6HDZHUHVWXGLHG7KHPRVWLPSRUWDQWHQYLURQPHQWDOIDF
WRUVWKDWLQIOXHQFHWKHLUIRUPDWLRQDUHGLVFXVVHG6SHFLDODWWHQWLRQLVJLYHQWRWKHUHHVWDEOLVKPHQWRIW\SLFDOFRDVWDOELR
FHQRVLVRIWKHDPSKLSRG3RQWRJDPPDUXVPDHRWLFXVZKLFKZDVGHVWUR\HGDVDUHVXOWRIVHDOHYHOULVH%HQWKRVELRPDVVDW
WKHSHULRGRILQFUHDVHGVHDOHYHOLVFRQVLGHUDEO\KLJKHUWKDQLQ\HDUVZLWKORZVHDOHYHO%LRORJL\D0RU\D9ODGLYRVWRN
YROQRSS±
.H\ZRUGV&DVSLDQ6HDELRFHQRVLVEHQWKRVELRPDVVVHDOHYHO
DZkibckdh_fhj_±djmig_crbcgZgZr_cieZg_l_
aZfdgmluc _kl_kl\_gguc \h^h_f Ih^ \ha^_ckl\b_f
ijbjh^ghdebfZlbq_kdbo mkeh\bc _]h mjh\_gv i_jbh
^bq_kdbf_gy_lkyKZfZygbadZyhlf_ldZ±faZih
ke_^gb_e_lgZ[ex^ZeZkv\]K]DZkibc
bkiulu\Z_l ljZgk]j_kkbx \ gZklhys__ \j_fy mjh\_gv
\h^u\g_fih^gyeky^hfgb`_mjh\gyhd_ZgZ_
]] ;; \ oZjZdl_jbah\Zebkv agZqbl_evguf aZ]jyag_gb
_f^Z]_klZgkdh]hjZchgZDZkibckdh]hfhjyg_nlygufb
m]e_\h^hjh^Zfb ihklmiZxsbfb\ hkgh\ghf kh klhdhf
jL_j_d;mlZ_\b^j Kihy\e_gb_f\ ] \
DZkibckdhf fhj_ i_eZ]bq_kdh]h obsgbdZ ]j_[g_\bdZ
0QHPLRSVLVOHLG\L\wlhf\h^h_f__s_[hevr_mkbebeZkv
ihl_gpbZevgZy \hafh`ghklv gZjmr_gby bklhjbq_kdb
keh`b\rboky[bhp_ghah\
>Z]_klZgkdbc jZchg DZkibckdh]h fhjy ijhly
`_gghklv[_j_]h\hcebgbbdhlhjh]hkhklZ\ey_ldf
aZgbfZ_l \kx aZiZ^gmx qZklv Kj_^g_]h b x`gmx hdh
g_qghklv K_\_jgh]h DZkiby jbk Kx^Z \oh^yl ljb
aZeb\Z Dbaeyjkdbc :]jZoZgkdbc b KmeZdkdbc bf_x
sb_ [hevrh_ ju[hohayckl\_ggh_ agZq_gb_ >ey wlbo
aZeb\h\ oZjZdl_jgu kjZ\gbl_evgh iheh]b_ [_j_]Z g_
[hevrb_ iehsZ^b r_evnh\hc ahgu fhjy b fZeu_ ]em
[bgu AZ i_jbh^ ih\ur_gby mjh\gy fhjy a^_kv hkh
[_ggh \ KmeZdkdhf aZeb\_ h[jZah\Zebkv gZb[he__ \u
jZ`_ggu_mqZkldbaZlhie_gbyIhwlhfmfukqblZebp_
e_khh[jZaguf jZkkfZljb\Zlv hl^_evgh khklhygb_ kh
h[s_kl\ wlbo f_edh\h^bc <ke_^ aZ im[ebdZpbyfb EZ
luih\ZEZluih\ZbYdh\e_\Zhkmdp_kkb
hgguo ijhp_kkZo ^hgguo khh[s_kl\ gZ aZlhie_gghc
l_jjblhjbb KmeZdkdh]h aZeb\Z \ i_jbh^ ih\ur_gby
mjh\gy fhjy \ureZ gZrZ klZlvy ihk\ys_ggZy nhjfb
jh\Zgbx ^hgguo [bhp_ghah\ gZ aZlhie_gghc kmr_ ih
ke_klZ[bebaZpbbmjh\gyfhjy=mk_cgh\b^j
P_ev ^Zgghc jZ[hlu ± bkke_^h\Zgb_ ^hgguo [bh
p_ghah\^Z]_klZgkdh]hjZchgZDZkiby\mkeh\byobaf_
gb\r_]hky ]b^jheh]bq_kdh]h j_`bfZ b kbevgh]h Zg
ljhih]_ggh]h\ha^_ckl\by
F:L?JB:EBF?LH>BD:
FZl_jbZehf^ey^Zgghc jZ[hlu ihkem`beb k[hju ^hg
ghc nZmgu kh[jZggu_ e_lhf ] \ ^Z]_klZgkdhf jZchg_
DZkibyDbaeyjkdbcaZeb\±mklv_jKZfmjkkm^gZPZ^ZgZ
klZgpbyo jZkiheh`_gguo gZ iZjZee_evguo ^jm] ^jm]m
rbjhlguojZaj_aZogZ]em[bg_hl^hfjbkkihfh
svx^ghq_jiZl_eyHd_ZgiehsZ^vaZo\ZlZf
<klZlvx\dexq_gZgZebafZl_jbZeZdhlhjuckh[bjZeb
\o]]^ghq_jiZl_e_fI_l_jk_gZiehsZ^vaZo\ZlZf
djm]eh]h^bqgh±jZaZ\f_kypgZjZaj_a_^eyfhgblhjbg]Z
jZkiheh`_gghf\jZchg_DZjZfZgZf_`^m]FZoZqdZeZb
mklv_\hcahghcjKmeZdgZ]em[bg_±f
Ba\e_q_ggu_ ^ghq_jiZl_e_f ijh[u ]jmglZ ijhfu\Zeb
q_j_akblhbaf_evgbqgh]h]ZaZ‹Ijh[unbdkbjh\Zeb
nhjfZev^_]b^hf<u[hjdmhj]Zgbafh\bahlfuluoijh[ijh
ba\h^beb ibgp_lhf ihf_sZy ]jmgl fZe_gvdbfb ihjpbyfb \
wfZebjh\Zggu_ \Zgghqdb k lhgdbf keh_f \h^u F_edbo `b
\hlguo \a\_rb\Zeb gZ lhjkbhgguo Z [he__ djmiguo gZ l_o
gbq_kdbo \_kZo I_j_^ \a\_rb\Zgb_f hj]Zgbafu ih^kmrb\Z
ebgZnbevljh\Zevghc[mfZ]_@b\hlguohij_^_eyeb^h\b^Z
>ey \uykg_gby kl_i_gb agZqbfhklb \b^h\ b hp_gdb bo
jheb \[bhp_ghaZo bkihevah\Zeb ihdZaZl_eb [bhfZkku b
\klj_qZ_fhklb <klj_qZ_fhklv hij_^_eyeb ih nhjfme_
P
3 = × ]^_Q±h[s__qbkehklZgpbcijh[ijhZgZeb
Q
abjh\Zgguo ^ey oZjZdl_jbklbdb [bhp_ghaZ P ± qbkeh klZg
pbcgZdhlhjuo\klj_q_g^Zgguc\b^>eydZ`^h]h\b^Z\u
=MK?CGH<
Jbk DZjlZko_fZ ]b^jh[bheh]bq_kdbo jZaj_ah\ b klZgpbc
\^Z]_klZgkdhfjZchg_DZkiby
qbkeyeb ij_^eh`_gguc ^ey ZgZebaZ [_glbq_kdbo dhfie_dkh\
k_\_jguo fhj_c A_gd_\bq_f b ;jhpdhc bg^_dk iehl
ghklb SE ]^_ j ± \klj_qZ_fhklv E ± kj_^gyy [bhfZkkZ
kj_^gyyba[bhfZkkgZhl^_evguoklZgpbyo
JZkiheZ]Zy gZ ]jZnbd_ ih hkb Z[kpbkk \b^u \ ihjy^d_
m[u\Zgby bg^_dkZ iehlghklb \_ebqbgu dhlhjh]h hldeZ^u\Z
xlky ih hkb hj^bgZl ihemqZ_f oZjZdl_jgu_ ihgb`Zxsb_
djb\u_ \ dhlhjuo hlj_adb ihkl_i_ggh]h ihgb`_gby q_j_^m
xlkykmklmiZfb±mqZkldZfb[he__j_adh]hiZ^_gbyIhke_^
gb_hl^_eyxl]jmiiu\b^h\^hfbgZglukm[^hfbgZglu\lh
jhkl_i_ggu_ kj_^b dhlhjuo \klj_qZxlky b j_^db_ \b^u Gh
gZa\Zgbx^hfbgZglZgZau\Zxlb[bhp_gha
>eyoZjZdl_jbklbdbbkjZ\gbl_evgh]hZgZebaZ[bhp_gh
ah\ bkihevah\Zeb dhwnnbpb_gl h[sghklb @ZddZjZ -DFFDUG
fh^bnbpbjh\Zgguc Fbljhihevkdbf b Fhj^moZc
F × ;helh\kdbf & =
]^_ k ± qbkeh \b^h\ h[sbo
G
^ey^\mo[bhp_ghah\G±h[s__qbkeh\b^h\h[gZjm`_gguo\
h[hbo[bhp_ghaZo
J?AMEVL:LUBH;KM@>?GB?
Ijb bkke_^h\Zgbb ^hgghc nZmgu ^Z]_klZgkdh]h
jZchgZ DZkibckdh]h fhjy h[gZjm`_gh k_fv q_ldh \u
jZ`_gguo [bhp_ghah\ \u^_e_gguo ih jmdh\h^ysbf
\b^Zfbeb^hfbgZglZfZfnbih^Z3RQWRJDPPDUXVPDH
RWLFXVfheexkdb$EUDRYDWD0\WLODVWHUOLQHDWXV&HUDVWR
GHUPD ODPDUFNL 'UHLVVHQD URVWULIRUPLV +\SDQLV DOELGD b
mkhgh]bc jZd %DODQXV LPSURYLVXVLZdbfh[jZahf a^_kv
jZkijhkljZg_gu[bhp_ghaufheexkdh\ljbbadhlhjuo
bf_xlkj_^ba_fghfhjkdh_ijhbkoh`^_gb_
F_lh^ \u^_e_gby [bhp_ghah\ ih jmdh\h^ysbf
^hfbgbjmxsbf\b^ZfgZDZkibbbkihevah\Zebebrv
g_kdhevdh Z\lhjh\ <bgh]jZ^h\ ^ey K_\_jgh]h
DZkiby :eb]Z^`b_\ ^ey ^Z]_klZgkdh]h
jZchgZDZkibybGZaZj_gdh^eyDjZkgh\h^kdh]h
aZeb\Z>ey:ah\kdh]hfhjyhg[ueijbf_g_g<hjh[v_
\uf Z ^ey j_qguo ^_evl b ebfZgh\ k_\_jh
aZiZ^gh]h ijbq_jghfhjvy FZjdh\kdbf Ihke_^
g_c jZ[hlhc kh^_j`Zs_c ZgZeba ^hgguo [bhp_ghah\
DZkibyy\ey_lkyfhgh]jZnbyDZjibgkdh]h\dh
lhjhch[km`^Z_lkyfZl_jbZekh[jZgguc\±b
± ]] ;bhp_ghau \u^_e_ggu_ F= DZjibg
kdbf ih jmdh\h^ysbf \b^Zf fheexkdh\ b djmighjZa
f_jguf ij_^klZ\bl_eyf ^jm]bo lZdkhgh\ gZc^_gu b \
bkke_^h\Zgghf gZfb jZchg_ Gh [bhp_ghau f_edbo
nhjflZdbodZd2OLJRFKDHWD&XPDFHD b&RURSKLXPhl
f_q_ggu_ wlbf Z\lhjhf ^ey Kj_^g_]h b X`gh]h DZk
iby Z lZd`_ :eb]Z^`b_\uf ^ey ^Z]_klZgkdh]h
jZchgZ gZfb g_ h[gZjm`_gu DZd ijbagZ_l F= DZj
ibgkdbc\g_dhlhjuokemqZyohghlghkbef_edb_nhj
fu k \ukhdhc qbke_gghklvx djmdh\h^ysbf ohly ih
bg^_dkm iehlghklb hgb g_ ^hfbgbjh\Zeb Hq_\b^gh \
f_lh^bd_ \u^_e_gby [bhp_ghah\ bf_xlky hij_^_e_g
gu_ ih]j_rghklb dhlhju_ hlf_qZe _s_ <hjh[v_\
HggZihfbgZeqlhijb\u^_e_gbbjmdh\h^ys_
]h\b^Zihij_h[eZ^Zgbx[bhfZkku\k_`_g_h[oh^bfh
mqblu\Zlvb_]hqbke_gghklv
;bhp_gha 3RQWRJDPPDUXV PDHRWLFXV < \_k_gg_
e_lgbc i_jbh^ p_gha ihglh]ZffZjmkZ kh \klj_
qZ_fhklvx ^hfbgZglZ h]jZgbq_g madbf [bhlhihf km[
eblhjZeb hldjulh]h i_kqZghjZdmr_qgh]h f_edh\h^vy
Khimlkl\mxsb_ nhjfu p_ghaZ ij_^klZ\e_gu _^bgbq
gufb baj_^dZ ihiZ^Zxsbfbky hkh[yfb hkljZdh^u
KmSULGHV OLWRUDOLV mkhgh]h]h jZdZ <LPSURYLVXV ihk_
eyxs_]hky gZ imkluo jZdh\bgZo ^\mkl\hjqZluo fhe
exkdh\ dmfh\h]h jZqdZ 6WHQRFXPD WHQXLFDXGDZ lZd`_
fgh]hs_lbgdh\h]hq_j\y1HUHLVGLYHUVLFRORU
< hk_gg_abfgbc i_jbh^ k ihgb`_gb_f l_fi_jZ
lmju \h^u ^h ±ƒK ihglh]ZffZjmk f_gy_l e_lgbc
[bhlhigZ[he__]em[hdbckm[eblhjZevguc]^_babfm
_lgZ]em[bg_±f?]hp_ghadZq_kl\_gghh[h]ZsZ_l
kylZddZdgZwlbo]em[bgZoh[blZxlfheexkdb$RYDWD
b & ODPDUFNL g_kdhevdh \b^h\ dmfh\uo jZqdh\ fbab
^u^_dZih^ub^jm]b_[_kiha\hghqgu_Hkh[hke_^m_l
hlf_lblvqlhabfhcijbl_fi_jZlmj_±ƒKgZ]em
[bg_ ± f \ khklZ\_ p_ghaZ ihglh]ZffZjmkZ gZc^_gu
hkh[b jZqdZ 3VHXGDOLEURWXV SODW\FHUDV h[uqgh h[blZx
s_]h\oheh^guo]em[hdh\h^guojZchgZofhjy
GZ[ex^_gby ijh\_^_ggu_ \ ihke_^gb_ ]h^u gZ
jZaj_a_ ^ey fhgblhjbg]Z \ jZchg_ DZjZfZgZ ihdZ
aZebqlh\i_jbh^k^h]p_ghaihglh]ZffZ
jmkZm[_j_]Zihqlbiheghklvxbkq_aWlhfmkihkh[kl
\h\Zeh ihkl_i_ggh_ jZajmr_gb_ [_j_]h\uo kl_g ba
[blhcjZdmrbih^\ha^_ckl\b_f ih^t_fZ mjh\gy fhjy
\ j_amevlZl_ q_]h nZmgZ ijb[j_`vy ihdju\Z_lky fhs
gufb^hggufbhkZ^dZfbKhklZ[bebaZpb_cmjh\gyfh
jy p_gha ihglh]ZffZjmkZ \gh\v \hkklZgZ\eb\Z_lky
jbkKj_^gyy[bhfZkkZwlh]h\b^Z\bkke_^h\Zgghf
jZchg_DZkiby\bxg_]khklZ\eyeZ[he__]f
;BHEH=BYFHJYlhf‹
KHH;S?KL<:AHH;?GLHK:
ijb iehlghklb luk wdaf <klj_qZebkv hkh[b jZa
guojZaf_jh\\lhfqbke_fheh^vbdhimebjmxsb_iZ
ju qlh k\b^_l_evkl\m_l hihklhygghf h[gh\e_gbb ih
imeypbbb__\hkklZgh\e_gbb
;bhp_gha $EUD RYDWD ;bhp_gha wlh]h fheexkdZ
i_j_k_e_ggh]h \DZkibc ba :ah\hQ_jghfhjkdh]h [Zk
k_cgZ\]kp_evxih\ur_gbydhjfh\hc[Zauju[
jZkijhkljZg_ggZ]em[bg_ hl ^h f ]eZ\guf h[jZ
ahf gZ fy]dbo bebkluo ]jmglZo Z lZd`_ gZ aZbe_gguo
i_kdZo k jZdmr_c Y\eyykv w\jb]Zebgghc nhjfhc
$RYDWD rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_gZ ih \k_fm ^Z]_klZgkdh
fm jZchgm DZkiby aZk_eyy [he__ _]h l_jjblhjbb
IehsZ^v aZgbfZ_fZy [bhp_ghahf Z[ju khklZ\ey_l
± jZchgZ bkke_^h\Zgbc a^_kv hlf_q_g hilb
fZevguc^ey__`bag_^_yl_evghklb^bZiZahgkhe_ghklb
±ÅDZji_\bqH[sZy[bhfZkkZ[bhp_
ghaZ Z[ju khklZ\ey_l ]f ijbq_f [he__ ijboh^blkygZfheexkdh\\k_e_gp_\jbk
Jmdh\h^ysbfb \b^Zfb ^hfbgZglZfb b km[^hfb
gZglZfb hij_^_eyxsbfb [bhfZkkm ^Zggh]h [bhp_gh
aZ y\eyxlky h[blZl_eb fy]dbo ]jmglh\ kj_^ba_fgh
fhjkdb_\k_e_gpu1GLYHUVLFRORUbKODPDUFNLZlZd`_
lbibqguc h[jZklZl_ev < LPSURYLVXVHklZevgu_ ij_^
klZ\bl_eb[bhp_ghaZZ[juhlghkysb_kyd]jmii_\lh
jhkl_i_gguobj_^dbo±wlhhdheh\b^h\\hkgh\
ghf dZkibckdbo Z[hjb]_gh\ Ih [bhfZkk_ \klj_qZ_
fhklb b bg^_dkm iehlghklb hgb aZgbfZxl g_agZqb
l_evgh_ f_klh bo [bhfZkkZ \ [bhp_gha_ khklZ\ey_l
ebrvjbk
< [bhp_gha_ $ RYDWD hlf_q_gu hj]Zgbafu hlgh
kysb_ky d jZaebqguf ljhnbq_kdbf ]jmiibjh\dZf
A^_kv\klj_qZxlky]jmglh_^uZ[jZ]biZgbyg_j_bkb
heb]ho_lu bkihevamxsb_ \ ibsm hj]Zgbdm ba ]jmg
lZBo[bhfZkkZjZ\gZ]fqlhkhklZ\ey_l
hl [bhfZkku \k_o dhfihg_glh\ [bhp_ghaZ >h\hevgh
[hevrmx jhev \ wlhf [bhp_gha_ b]jZxl b nbevljZlh
ju bo [bhfZkkZ ]f qlh khklZ\ey_l ij_^klZ\e_ggu_ ]eZ\guf h[jZahf p_jZklh^_jfhc b
[ZeZgmkhf
>hfbgbjmxsbc\b^[bhp_ghaZ$RYDWDaZju\Z_l
ky \ bebkluc ]jmgl gZ g_[hevrmx ]em[bgm b ijb ih
fhsb kbnhgh\ kh[bjZ_l ^_ljbl kih\_joghklb ^gZ
Km[^hfbgZglguc \b^ & ODPDUFNL h[hkgh\Z\rbcky gZ
ih\_joghklghfkeh_]jmglZnbevljm_l^_ljblbf_edb_
ieZgdlhggu_ hj]Zgbafu \a\_r_ggu_ \ \h^_ Lj_lbc
\b^ ± 1 GLYHUVLFRORU lZd`_ y\eyxsbcky ij_^klZ\bl_
e_fbgnZmguaZju\Z_lkyagZqbl_evgh]em[`_q_fZ[jZ
bp_jZklh^_jfZbiblZ_lkyaZ]eZlu\Zy]jmgl
;bhp_gha 0\WLODVWHU OLQHDWXV H[gZjm`_gguc \
^ZgghfjZchg_p_ghafblbeZkl_jZ\k_eb\r_]hky\DZk
ibcbaQ_jgh]hfhjy\±]]aZgbfZ_lg_[hev
rhc ijb[j_`guc Zj_Ze k ]em[bgZfb ± f ijbfu
dZxsbcd]hjh^Zf>_j[_glbBa[_j[Zr>hggu_hkZ^
db±f_edZyjZdmrZkgZe_lhfbeZ±y\eyxlkyoZjZdl_j
guf km[kljZlhf ^ey k_klhghnZ]h\ 0\WLODVWHU 'UHLVVH
QD %DODQXV \_^msbo ijbdj_ie_gguc h[jZa `bagb gZ
g_ih^\b`guo ij_^f_lZo \ qZklghklb gZ imklmxsbo
jZdh\bgZo dZkibckdbo dZj^bb^ b nbevljmxsbo hj]Z
gbafu\a\_r_ggu_\ijb^hgghfkeh_\h^u
;BHEH=BYFHJYlhf‹
Jbk Fgh]he_lgyy ^bgZfbdZ [bhfZkku ]f b qbke_g
ghklblukwdaf3RQWRJDPPDUXVPDHRWLFXVe_lhf\^Z]_
klZgkdhfjZchg_DZkiby
;hevrbgkl\h\b^h\\oh^ysbo\khklZ\wlh]h[bh
p_ghaZ ijbgZ^e_`Zl dZkibckdhc Z\lholhgghc nZmg_
h^gZdh i_j\u_ iylv ihabpbc ih bg^_dkm iehlghklb aZ
gbfZxl kj_^ba_fghfhjkdb_ \k_e_gpu jbk Bgl_
j_kghhlf_lblvqlh\^Zgghf[bhp_gha_khkms_kl\mxl
^\Z ljhnbq_kdbo ZglZ]hgbklZ ± fblbeZkl_j b ^j_ckk_
gZ<hafh`gh\ukhdh_kh^_j`Zgb_\wlhfjZchg_hj]Z
gbq_kdh]h ^_ljblZ :eb]Z^`b_\ kihkh[kl\m_l
kfy]q_gbxbodhgdmj_gpbbaZibsmKe_^mxsZyihagZ
qbfhklb ibs_\Zy ]jmiiZ ij_^klZ\e_gZ ^_ljblhy^gufb
`b\hlgufb<g__\oh^yl\hkgh\ghfZ[jZbg_j_bkkh
[bjZxsb_ibsmkjZaguo]em[bgbeh\uohleh`_gbc
H[sZy [bhfZkkZ [bhp_ghaZ a^_kv ^h\hevgh \ukh
dZy ± ]f \hkgh\ghf aZ kq_l fheexkdh\ kj_^b
a_fghfhjkdh]hijhbkoh`^_gbyjbk
;bhp_gha &HUDVWRGHUPD ODPDUFNL P_jZklh^_jfZ
EZfZjdZ ± h^bg ba ^j_\g_crbo kj_^ba_fghfhjkdbo
\k_e_gp_\\DZkibckdhffhj_Ih^Zgguf:eb]Z^`b_\Z
\ ^Z]_klZgkdhf jZchg_ DZkiby p_jZklh^_jfZ
\klj_qZ_lky \ ijb[j_`ghc qZklb fhjy gZ ]em[bgZo ^h
fGZrbbkke_^h\ZgbyihdZaZebqlhhgZh[blZ_lgZ
]em[bg_hl^hfP_jZklh^_jfZij_^ihqblZ_lfy]
db_]jmglub[_kij_ju\ghi_j_^\b]Z_lkyih^gm\afm
qb\Zy ijb wlhf e_]db_ qZklbpu ih\_joghklgh]h kehy
]jmglZ b nbevljmy bo < [bhp_gha_ ljb km[^hfbgZglZ
Z[jZ g_j_bk [ZeZgmk b g_kdhevdh \lhjhkl_i_gguo b
j_^dbo\b^h\jbk
:j_Ze[bhp_ghaZp_jZklh^_jfuijhklbjZ_lkykk_
\_jZ^Z]_klZgkdh]hjZchgZDZkiby^hmklvyjL_j_d]^_
jZaju\Z_lkyghaZl_fhlFZoZqdZeu^hBa[_j[ZrZjZk
iheZ]Z_lkyihehkhcho\Zlu\Zyijb[j_`gu_mqZkldb^h
bah[Zluf
;bhfZkkZ hkgh\guo dhfihg_glh\ ^hfbgZglh\ b
km[^hfbgZglh\ khklZ\ey_l ]f beb hl h[
s_c[bhfZkku[bhp_ghaZdhlhjZy^hklb]Z_l]f
G_dhlhju_ ij_^klZ\bl_eb [bhp_ghaZ \ qZklghklb fhe
exkdb ^j_ckk_gZ + DOELGD b fblbeZkl_j baaZ g_agZ
qbl_evghc \klj_qZ_fhklb ih bg^_dkm iehlghklb ihiZ
^Zxl\]jmiim\lhjhkl_i_gguo\b^h\H[sZy[bhfZkkZ
wlhc]jmiiukhklZ\ey_l]fbeb
< kha^Zgbb h[s_c [bhfZkku ^Zggh]h [bhp_ghaZ
]eZ\gZy jhev ijbgZ^e_`bl fheexkdZf\k_e_gpZf
=MK?CGH<
Jbk;bhfZkkZhkgh\guo]jmii[_glhkZ\[bhp_ghaZo^Z]_klZgkdh]hjZchgZDZkiby±jZdhh[jZagu_±%DODQXVLPSURYLVXV±fgh
]hs_lbgdh\u_q_j\b±^\mkl\hjqZlu_fheexkdb\k_e_gpu±^\mkl\hjqZlu_fheexkdbZ\lholhgu
jbkDZdb\[bhp_gha_$RYDWD\k_hkgh\gu_ij_^
klZ\bl_eb wlh]h khh[s_kl\Z bkihevamxl ibs_\u_ qZk
lbpu ba jZaguo ]hjbahglh\ \h^u b ]jmglZ b g_ dhgdm
jbjmxl f_`^m kh[hc G_h[oh^bfh hlf_lblv qlh hk
gh\gu_dhfihg_glup_ghaZp_jZklh^_jfu±wlhp_ggu_
dhjfh\u_ h[t_dlu b]jZxsb_ agZqbl_evgmx jhev \
nhjfbjh\Zgbbdhjfh\hc[Zauju[[_glhnZ]h\
;bhp_gha'UHLVVHQDURVWULIRUPLV<h[s_c[bhfZk
k_ bkke_^h\Zggh]h jZchgZ [bhfZkkZ ^j_ckk_gu aZgb
fZ_lZ\[bhp_gha_blh]h\ur_±hdhehIh
wlhfm ih djb\hc bg^_dkh\ iehlghklb ^j_ckk_gZ j_adh
\ha\urZ_lky gZ^ ^jm]bfb ij_^klZ\bl_eyfb ^Zggh]h
[bhp_ghaZjbkAZg_cgZ^h\hevghgbadhfmjh\g_
ke_^m_l h^bg km[^hfbgZgl ± 'LGDFQD EDUERWGHPDUQ\L
aZl_f b^_l ^ebgguc i_j_q_gv ba \lhjhkl_i_gguo b
j_^dbo\b^h\
Jbk KljmdlmjZ [bhp_ghaZ $EUD RYDWD \ ^Z]_klZgkdhf jZc
hg_ DZkiby ± $EUD RYDWD ± &HUDVWRGHUPD ODPDUFNL ±
1HUHLVGLYHUVLFRORU±+\SDQLV+DOELGD+DFXVWLFRVWDWD±
%DODQXV LPSURYLVXV ± 2OLJRFKDHWD ± 'LGDFQD ' ORQJLSHV
'SURWUDFWD±*DPPDULGDH 'LNHURJDPPDUXVKDHPREDSKHV
1LSKDUJRLGHV 3RQWRJDPPDUXV UREXVWRLGHV ± 3VHXGRFXPPD
SHFWLQDWD ± 0\WLODVWHU OLQHDWXV ± &RURSKLXP FKHOLFRUQH
±+\SDQLRODNRZDOHZVNLLA^_kvbgZjbkmgdZo±>±^h
fbgZgluK>±km[^hfbgZglu<L±\lhjhkl_i_ggu_J±j_^
db_\b^u
:\lholhgguc dZkibckdbc fheexkd ' URVWULIRU
PLV± g_ih^\b`guc wib[bhgl h[blZxsbc gZ `_kldbo
km[kljZlZo ih kihkh[m iblZgby y\ey_lky nbevljZlh
jhfHgjZkij_^_e_ggZ]em[bgZohl^hfgZjZ
dmr_qguokm[kljZlZo\p_gljZevghcqZklb^Z]_klZgkdh
]hjZchgZDZkiby?]hhkgh\ghcdhgdmj_glihiblZgbx
fblbeZkl_j \ [bhp_gha_ hlkmlkl\m_l qlh \_jhylgh
kihkh[kl\h\ZehlZdhfmagZqbl_evghfmjZa\blbx^j_ck
k_gu >jm]hc \hafh`guc ibs_\hc dhgdmj_gl ^j_ckk_
gu±[ZeZgmkoZjZdl_jbamxsbckyg_\ukhdbfbdhebq_
kl\_ggufb ihdZaZl_eyfb g_ fh`_l ij_iylkl\h\Zlv
fZkkh\hfmjZa\blbx^hfbgZglZ
<[bhp_gha_ij_h[eZ^Zxl\hkgh\ghfdZkibckdb_
Z\lholhggu_ fheexkdb b jZdhh[jZagu_ [bhfZkkZ dh
lhjuo^hklb]Z_l]fjbkG_\ukhdmx[bhfZk
km ]f kha^Zxl kj_^ba_fghfhjkdb_ \k_e_gpu
<g_[hevrhf dhebq_kl\_ \klj_qZ_fhklv ± lZd`_
ij_^klZ\e_gu \uoh^pu ba Zjdlbq_kdh]h dhfie_dkZ ±
Jbk KljmdlmjZ [bhp_ghaZ 0\WLODVWHU OLQHDWXV \ ^Z]_klZg
kdhf jZchg_ DZkiby ± 0\WLODVWHU OLQHDWXV ± 'UHLVVHQD
URVWULIRUPLV±%DODQXVLPSURYLVXV±$EUDRYDWD±1HUHLV
GLYHUVLFRORU ± 'LGDFQD ORQJLSHV ± +\SDQLV DOELGD ±
&RURSKLXP FKHOLFRUQH ± *DPPDULGDH $PDWKLOLQD VSLQRVD
1LSKDUJRLGHVFDVSLXV3VHXGDOLEURWXVFDVSLXV±2OLJRFKDHWD
±&HUDVWRGHUPDODPDUFNL
;BHEH=BYFHJYlhf‹
KHH;S?KL<:AHH;?GLHK:
Jbk KljmdlmjZ [bhp_ghaZ &HUDVWRGHUPD ODPDUFNL \ ^Z]_
klZgkdhf jZchg_ DZkiby ± &HUDVWRGHUPD ODPDUFNL ± $EUD
RYDWD±%DODQXVLPSURYLVXV±'UHLVVHQDURVWULIRUPLV±+\
SDQLV + DOELGD + DQJXVWLFRVWDWD ± 1HUHLV GLYHUVLFRORU ±
0\WLODVWHUOLQHDWXV±'LGDFQDEDUERWGHPDUQ\L±2OLJRFKDHWD
± &XPDFHD 3WHURFXPD SHFWLQDWD 6WHQDFXPD JUDFLOLV ±
&RURSKLXP&FKHOLFRUQH&QRELOH
Jbk KljmdlmjZ [bhp_ghaZ 'UHLVVHQD URVWULIRUPLV \ ^Z]_
klZgkdhf jZchg_ DZkiby ± 'UHLVVHQD URVWULIRUPLV ± 'L
GDFQD'ORQJLSHV'EDUERWGHPDUQ\L±%DODQXVLPSURYLVXV
±&HUDVWRGHUPDODPDUFNL±&RURSKLXP&FKHOLFRUQHKQR
GLOH ± +\SDQLD LQYDOLGD +\SDQLROD NRZDOHZVNLL ± *DP
PDULGDH 'LNHURJDPPDUXV KDHWREDSKXV *PHOLQD FRVWDWD ±
2OLJRkKDHWD±0HVLGRWHDHQWRPRQ
bahih^Z 0HVLGRWHD HQWRPRQ JODFLDOLV FDVSLD Z lZd`_ Zf
nbih^u3SODW\FHUDVb3RQWRSRUHLDDIILQLVPLFURSKWKDOPD
y\eyxsb_kyh[blZl_eyfb]em[hdh\h^ghcqZklbDZkiby
DZd dhjfh\hc h[t_dl jmdh\h^ysbc \b^ p_ghaZ
'URVWULIRUPLV g_ bf__l [hevrh]h agZq_gby \ k\yab k
l_f qlh __ ihlj_[bl_eyfb y\eyxlky ebrv \h[eZ b
\ajhkeuc hk_lj ;bhfZkkZ jZdhh[jZaguo b fgh]hs_
lbgdh\uoq_j\_c±p_gguodhjfh\uoh[t_dlh\ijhfu
keh\uoju[a^_kvg_^hklb]Z_l[hevrbo\_ebqbg
;bhp_gha+\SDQLVDOELGD:j_Zewlh]h[bhp_ghaZ\
^Z]_klZgkdhf jZchg_ DZkiby hq_gv g_agZqbl_evguc ±
\k_]h±lukdf\x`ghcqZklbK_\_jgh]hDZkiby
gZ ]em[bg_ ± f DZq_kl\_ggZy [_^ghklv [bhp_ghaZ
h[mkeh\e_gZ \_jhylgh ]jmglZfb ± q_jgufb beZfb kh
keZ[uf aZiZohf k_jh\h^hjh^Z :\lholhgguc dZkibc
kdbc fheexkd G DOELGD y\ey_lky lbibqguf khehgh\Z
lh\h^gufh[blZl_e_f^eydhlhjh]hhilbfZevghckhe_
ghklvxkqblZ_lkyÅ;m^mqbij_^klZ\bl_e_fbgnZm
gu hg aZju\Z_lky \ ]jmgl b nbevljm_l \a\_r_gguc \
\h^_ hj]Zgbq_kdbc ^_ljbl Z lZd`_ `b\hc nblhieZgd
lhgKhh[s_gb_:eb]Z^`b_\ZhgZoh^dZoGDOEL
GD gZ fy]dbo beZo g_ kh]eZkm_lky k gZrbfb ^Zggufb
<b^bfhq_jgu_beuk[h]Zlhchj]Zgbdhc± [he__ih^
oh^ysbckm[kljZl^eym^h\e_l\hj_gbyljhnbq_kdboih
lj_[ghkl_c wlh]h fheexkdZ Ih^l\_j`^_gb_f fh`gh
kqblZlv b lh qlh \ khklZ\_ ^jm]bo [bhp_ghah\ aZ bk
dexq_gb_f [bhp_ghaZ $ RYDWD ih bg^_dkm iehlghklb
+DOELGDaZgbfZ_l\lhjhkl_i_ggh_f_klh
;bhfZkkZ ^hfbgZglZ \ [bhp_gha_ G DOELGD jZ\gZ
]f qlh khklZ\ey_l hl h[s_c [bhfZkku
AZwlbf\b^hfb^_l_^bgkl\_gguckm[^hfbgZgl$RYDWD
k[bhfZkkhc]fb\klj_qZ_fhklvxHklZev
gu_\b^Zy\eyxlky\lhjhkl_i_ggufbbagbo1GLYHU
VLFRORU k[bhfZkkhc ebrv ]f y\ey_lky j_^dbf
;bhfZkkZ wlbo \b^h\ \ [bhp_gha_ khklZ\ey_l \k_]h
jbk
Ke_^m_l hlf_lblv qlh ihqlb \k_ ij_^klZ\bl_eb
[bhp_ghaZ G DOELGD y\eyxlky \ukhdhdZehjbcgufb hj
]ZgbafZfbbkem`Zlibs_c^eyijhfukeh\uoju[
;bhp_gha %DODQXV LPSURYLVXV Kj_^ba_fghfhjkdhc
\k_e_g_p [ZeZgmk \^Z]_klZgkdhf jZchg_ DZkiby \klj_
qZ_lky \ khklZ\_ ihqlb \k_o [bhp_ghah\ gh kZfhklhy
l_evguc [bhp_gha h[jZam_l ebrv gZ g_[hevrhc l_jjb
lhjbb k_\_jghc ahgu wlh]h jZchgZ Hg ho\Zlu\Z_l dh
g_qgu_ klZgpbb q_luj_o \_jogbo jZaj_ah\ k jZdmr_q
gufb]jmglZfbjbkdhlhju_g_h[oh^bfu^eyghj
fZevgh]h jZa\blby [ZeZgmkZ A^_kv < LPSURYLVXV ijb
dj_iey_lkyd`_kldbf^hggufhleh`_gbyf\\b^_imk
luo jZdh\bg jZaebqguo ^\mkl\hjqZluo fheexkdh\ Ba
\b^h\ \klj_qZxsboky \ [bhp_gha_ [ZeZgmkZ wdheh]b
q_kdbgZb[he__[ebadb_fmkm[^hfbgZglu±fblbeZkl_j
b ^j_ckk_gZ dhlhjuf lZd`_ lj_[mxlky g_ih^\b`gu_
`_kldb_]jmglu>jm]hckm[^hfbgZgl±fgh]hs_lbgdh
\ucq_j\vg_j_bk±ihoZjZdl_jmiblZgbybh[jZam`ba
gb hlebqZ_lky hl gbo b aZgbfZ_l bgu_ wdheh]bq_kdb_
gbrb DZd hlf_q_gh \ur_ lZdb_ h[jZklZl_eb dZd [Z
eZgmkfblbeZkl_jb^j_ckk_gZy\eyxlkynbevljZlhjZ
fb ihlj_[eyxsbfb \a\_r_ggu_ ibs_\u_ qZklbpu ba
ijb^hgguokeh_\\h^uIjbq_f\k_hj]Zgbafuba]jmi
iu nbevljZlhjh\ bkihevamxl jZagu_ ijb^hggu_ kehb
kha^Z\Zy yjmkghklv wdheh]bq_kdbo gbr b kgb`Zy dhg
;BHEH=BYFHJYlhf‹
Jbk KljmdlmjZ [bhp_ghaZ +\SDQLV DOELGD \ ^Z]_klZgkdhf
jZchg_DZkiby±+\SDQLVDOELGD±$EUDRYDWD±&HUDVWR
GHUPDODPDUFNL±&XPDFHD 3WHURFXPDSHFWLQDWD6WHQRFXPD
JUDFLORLGHV±2OLJRFKDHWD±1HUHLVGLYHUVLFRORU
=MK?CGH<
memqrbeh mkeh\by \hkijhba\h^kl\Z ^hgguo [_kiha\h
ghqguo < lh `_ \j_fy wnn_dlb\ghklv jZafgh`_gby
fheexkdh\ jZkkfZljb\Z_fZy dZd hlghr_gb_ dhebq_kl
\Zhk_\r_cfheh^bddhebq_kl\miheh\haj_euohkh[_c
gZlj_lv_f]h^m\k_e_gby\DZkibcobsgbdZ i_eZ]bq_
kdhc ljhnbq_kdhc p_ib ]j_[g_\bdZ 0QHPLRSVLV OHLG\L
kgbabeZkv \ ± jZaZ < ^Zevg_cr_f wlh fh`_l ijb
\_klbdj_adhfmkgb`_gbx[bhfZkku\ajhkeuofheex
kdh\±hkgh\gh]hdhfihg_glZ^hgghcnZmguDZkiby
KIBKHDEBL?J:LMJU
Jbk KljmdlmjZ [bhp_ghaZ %DODQXV LPSURYLVXV \ ^Z]_klZg
kdhf jZchg_ DZkiby ± %DODQXV LPSURYLVXV ± 0\WLODVWHU
OLQHDWXV±1HUHLVGLYHUVLFRORU± 'UHLVVHQD URVWULIRUPLV±
2OLJRFKDHWD ± *DPPDULGDH >1LSKDUJRLGHV 3RQWRJDPPDUXV
REHVXV 1LSKDUJRLGHV FDVSLXV@ ± +\SDQLD LQYDOLGD ± &X
PDFHD3WHURFXPDSHFWLQDWD6WHQRFXPDJUDFLOLV
dmj_glgmx gZijy`_gghklv >hfbgZgl [bhp_ghaZ [ZeZ
gmkijbdj_ieyykvdjZdh\bgZffblbeZkl_jZb^j_ckk_
gu nbevljm_l ibs_\u_ h[t_dlu ba kha^Z\Z_fuo bfb
lhdh\ \_jogbo keh_\ \h^u lh]^Z dZd kZfb fheexkdb
\ueZ\eb\Zxlk_klhgbagb`gbokeh_\
KljmdlmjZ [bhp_ghaZ [ZeZgmkZ hq_gv [_^gZy ?]h
[bhfZkkZkhklZ\ey_l\k_]h]fbadhlhjuogZ^h
fbgZglijboh^blkyZgZh^bgbakm[^hfbgZglh\
fblbeZkl_j± \klj_qZ_fhklvbf__llhev
dh^hfbgZglZ\klj_qZ_fhklv^jm]bog_fgh]bokhklZ\
eyxsbo[bhp_ghaZdhe_[e_lkyhl^h
Ba\_klghqlh[bhp_ghau\lhcbebbghcf_j_hl
ebqZxlky^jm]hl^jm]ZkhklZ\hf\b^h\ZlZd`_bokh
hlghr_gb_fDhwnnbpb_glh[sghklb\b^h\\[bhp_gh
aZo fh`_l kem`blv ihdZaZl_e_f kl_i_gb bo koh^kl\Z
<^Z]_klZgkdhf jZchg_ DZkibckdh]h fhjy wlhl ihdZaZ
l_ev dhe_[e_lky hl ^h qlh kh]eZkm_lky k
^Zggufb:eb]Z^`b_\Z<ukhdh_koh^kl\h\b^h\
gZ[ex^Z_lky \ [bhp_ghaZo oZjZdl_jguo ^ey bebkluo
]jmglh\ Z[jZ b p_jZklh^_jfZ p_jZklh^_jfZ b
obiZgbk qlhhljZ`Z_l[ebahklvwdheh]bq_kdbo
mkeh\bc bo Zj_Zeh\ FbgbfZevgh_ koh^kl\h \b^h\ h[
gZjm`_gh\[bhp_ghaZo[bhlhiudhlhjuowdheh]bq_kdb
^Ze_db^jm]hl^jm]ZdZdgZijbf_j^j_ckk_gZbobiZ
gbkZ[jZb[ZeZgmk
Ke_^m_l hlf_lblv qlh \ g_dhlhjuo kemqZyo kl_
i_gv koh^kl\Z [bhp_ghah\ g_ hl\_qZ_l wlhfm ijZ\bem
GZijbf_j dhwnnbpb_glu h[sghklb [bhp_ghaZ Z[ju b
fblbeZkl_jZ Z[ju b ^j_ckk_gu ^h
\hevgh\ukhdb_ohlyh^gb\b^uy\eyxlkyh[blZl_eyfb
fy]dbo]jmglh\Z^jm]b_± l\_j^uob`_kldbo^hgguo
hleh`_gbc Wlh \ dZdhclh f_j_ ih^l\_j`^Z_l fg_gb_
Fbljhihevkdh]hbFhj^moZc;helh\kdh]hhlhf
qlh pbnjh\u_ ihdZaZl_eb ohly b fh]ml hoZjZdl_jbah
\Zlv kljmdlmjm [bhp_ghaZ gh \ kmsghklb ebrv k
\g_rg_cklhjhgug_\kdju\Zy\aZbfhhlghr_gbcf_`
^m\b^ZfbZlZd`_f_`^mhj]ZgbafZfbbg_`b\hckj_
^hcqlhh[uqghhq_gvljm^ghijhZgZebabjh\Zlv
H[sZy[bhfZkkZ[_glhkZ]fe_lhf]
\^Z]_klZgkdhfjZchg_DZkiby[ueZ\jZaZ\ur_ih
kjZ\g_gbx k lZdh\hc \ ] =mk_cgh\ dh]^Z
gZ[ex^ZeZkvkZfZygbadZyhlf_ldZZ[khexlgh]hmjh\gy
fhjy <b^bfh ih\ur_gb_ mjh\gy fhjy ihqlb gZ f
:eb]Z^`b_\=:J_dhgkljmdpby^hgghcnZmgu^Z]_klZgkdh]h
jZchgZDZkibckdh]hfhjy\k\yabkfZkkh\ufjZa\blb_f
\g_fZah\hq_jghfhjkdbo\k_e_gp_\Baf_g_gb_[bh
eh]bq_kdbodhfie_dkh\DZkibckdh]hfhjyaZihke_^gb_
^_kylbe_lbyFGZmdZK±
:eb]Z^`b_\ =: ;bheh]bq_kdb_ j_kmjku ^Z]_klZgkdh]h ju
[hohayckl\_ggh]h jZchgZ DZkiby FZoZqdZeZ >Z]dgb
]hba^Zlk
;mlZ_\ $0 FhgZoh\ KD =ZkZgh\ RR Wdheh]bq_kdb_
ijh[e_fuijb[j_`ghcahgu>Z]_klZgZbimlbboj_r_
gbyFZl_jORgZmqghijZdlbq_kdhcdhgnihhojZg_
ijbjh^u >Z]_klZgZ FZoZqdZeZ >Z]dgb]hba^Zl K±
<bgh]jZ^h\E=Hf_kl_1HUHLVVXFFLQHD\[_glhk_K_\_jgh]h
DZkiby Lj Hd_Zgh]j dhfbk :G KKKJ L K±
<hjh[v_\ <I ;_glhk :ah\kdh]h fhjy Lj :aQ_jGBJH
<uiKbfn_jhihevDjufba^Zlk
=mk_cgh\FDAZdhghf_jghklbjZkij_^_e_gby ^hgghc nZmgu
Kj_^g_]h DZkiby ;bheh]by hkgh\guo ijhfukeh\uo
ju[ Kj_^g_]h DZkiby b khklhygb_ bo dhjfh\hc [Zau
FZoZqdZeZBa^\h>GPJ:GK±
=mk_cgh\ FD Oehidh\Z F< :[^mjZofZgh\Z :: =mk_c
gh\DF Nhjfbjh\Zgb_ [_glhkZ gZ aZlhie_gghc kmr_
^Z]_klZgkdh]h jZchgZ DZkiby F_`^mgZjh^ dhgn
Kh\j_f_ggu_ijh[e_fuDZkibyihk\ys_ggZye_
lbxDZkiGBJOZ:kljZoZgvBa^\hDZkiGBJOZ
K±
A_gd_\bq E: ;jhpdZy <: FZl_jbZeu ih wdheh]bb jmdh\h
^ysbonhjf[_glhkZ;Zj_gp_\h]hfhjyMqaZiF=M
<ui‹K±
DZji_\bq :N Hlghr_gb_ ^\mkl\hjqZluo fheexkdh\ K_\_j
gh]h DZkiby b :jZeZ d baf_g_gbx khe_ghklb kj_^u
:\lhj_n^bk^hdl[bhegZmdFF=Mk
DZjibgkdbcF=Wdheh]by[_glhkZKj_^g_]hbX`gh]hDZk
ibyF<GBJHk
EZluih\ XY Mjh\_gv DZkibckdh]h fhjy \gh\v baf_gy_l
ky<_klgJ:GL‹K±
EZluih\ XY Ydh\e_\ XF Kmdp_kkby khh[s_kl\Z ^\m
kl\hjqZlh]h fheexkdZ $EUD RYDWD \ KmeZdkdhf aZeb\_
DZkibckdh]h fhjy ;bhe fhjy L ‹ K±
FZjdh\kdbc FX NZmgZ [_kiha\hghqguo gbah\v_\ j_d Md
jZbgu mkeh\by __ kms_kl\h\Zgby b imlb bkihevah\Z
gbyDb_\QK±
Fbljhihevkdbc<BFhj^moZc;helh\kdhcN>Ahh[_glhkb
^jm]b_ [bhp_ghau k\yaZggu_ k km[kljZlhf FZdjh[_g
lhk F_lh^bdZ bamq_gby [bh]_hp_ghah\ \gmlj_ggbo
\h^h_fh\FGZmdZK±
GZaZj_gdh <; Dhebq_kl\_ggh_ jZkij_^_e_gb_ ahh[_glhkZ
DjZkgh\h^kdh]h aZeb\Z DZkibckdh]h fhjy Dhebq_kl
\_ggh_ b dZq_kl\_ggh_ jZkij_^_e_gb_ [_glhkZ dhjfh
\Zy[ZaZ[_glhkhy^guoju[F<GBJHK±
-DFFDUG 3 'LVWULEXWLRQ GH OD IORUH DOSLQH GDQV OH %DVVLQ GH
'UDQVHVHWGDQVTXHOTXHVUHJLRQVYRLVLQHV%XOOVRFYDXG
VFLQDWXU7‹3±
;BHEH=BYFHJYlhf‹
Скачать