Карлос Кастанеда Отделенная реальность

реклама
DZjehk DZklZg_^ZHl^_e_ggZy j_Zevghklv
Dgb]Z
\lhjZy
Ijh^he`_gb_ [_k_^ k^hghf OmZghf <\_^_gb_
>_kylv e_l gZaZ^ fg_ihkqZkleb\behkv \klj_lblvky \
aZiZ^ghc F_dkbd_ kh^gbf bg^_cp_f baie_f_gb ydbY gZa\Ze
_]h ^hg OmZg< bkiZgkdhfyaud_ ^h g
wlh h[jZs_gb_
\ujZ`Zxs__ m\Z`_gb_
Fh_ agZdhfkl\hk ^hghfOmZghf khklhyehkvijb ke_^mxsbo
h[klhyl_evkl\ZoY kb^_e
k
;beehfk\hbf ^jm]hf\
Z\lh[mkghf ^_ih ih]jZgbqgh]h ]hjh^dZ\ Zjbahg_Fu [ueb
hq_gv kihdhcgu<h \lhjhciheh\bg_ ^gye_lgyy `ZjZdZaZeZkv
aZ ie_qh
<hg q_eh\_dh dhlhjhfy l_[_jZkkdZau\ZekdZaZe
hg lbobf]hehkhf
Hg agZqbl_evgh db\gme\ klhjhgm\oh^ZKlZjbd lhevdh
qlh \hr_e \ihf_s_gb_
Qlh lufg_ jZkkdZau\Zeh g_f"kijhkbe y
Wlh lhl kZfuc bg^__pdhlhjuc agZ_l h i_chl_
ihfgbrv"y \kihfgbedZd fuk ;beehfdZdlh ijh_a^beb\_kv
^_gv gZ fZrbg_jZaukdb\Zy ^hf wdkp_gljbqgh]h bg^_cpZ
dhlhjuc `be \ lhfjZchg_Fu g_gZreb _]h^hfb m f_gy
\hagbdeh hsms_gb_qlh bg^_cpudhlhjuo fukijZrb\Zeb hg_f
gZf_j_ggh ^Z\ZebgZf g_\_jgh_gZijZ\e_gb_;bee kdZaZeqlh
q_eh\_d wlhl[ue ljZ\gbdq_eh\_dkh[bjZxsbc bijh^Zxsbc
e_dZjkl\_ggu_ jZkl_gbyb qlh hg hq_gv fgh]h agZ_l h
]Zeexpbgh]_gghf dZdlmk_i_chl_Hg kdZaZelZd`_qlh fg_
klhbeh [u \klj_lblvkyk gbf;bee [uefhbf ]b^hf ih wlbf
f_klZf \ lh \j_fydh]^Z ykh[bjZe jZaebqgu_ k\_^_gby h
e_dZjkl\_gguo ljZ\Zobkihevam_fuo bg^_cpZfb
;bee ih^gyeky b ih^hr_e d q_eh\_dm iha^hjh\Zlvky
Bg^__p [ue kj_^g_]h jhklZ?]h
\hehku [ueb k_^ufb b
dhjhldbfb b g_fgh]h
gZ\bkZeb
gZ^
mrZfbih^q_jdb\Zy
hdjm]ehklv ]heh\uHg [uehq_gv l_fguf=em[hdb_ fhjsbgugZ
ebp_ ijb^Z\Zeb _fm\b^ ]em[hdh]hklZjpZh^gZdh _]h l_eh
dZaZehkv[ueh kbevgufb kh[jZggufY kfbgmlm gZ[ex^Ze aZ
gbfHg i_j_^\b]Zeky k e_]dhklvxdhlhjmx y kqblZe [u
g_\hafh`ghc ^eyklZjbdZ;bee k^_eZefg_ agZdih^hclb dgbf
Hg ohjhrbciZj_gvkdZaZe fg_;beegh yg_ fh]m
ihgbfZlv _]h?]h bkiZgkdbcihfh_fmbkdh\_jdZg b ihehg
k_evkdbo jZa]h\hjguo\ujZ`_gbc
KlZjbd ]eygme gZ;beeZ bmeu[gmeky: ;beedhlhjuc
agZe ihbkiZkdb ebrvg_kdhevdh keh\ijhbag_k gZwlhf yaud_
dZdmxlh Z[kmj^gmx njZamHg ihkfhlj_egZ f_gydZd [u
kijZrb\Zybf__l ebwlZ njZaZdZdhcgb[m^v kfukegh y g_
agZeqlh hgohl_e kdZaZlvlh]^Z hgkfms_ggh meu[gmeky b
hlhr_eKlZjbd \a]eygmegZ f_gyb gZqZekf_ylvkyY h[tykgbe
_fmqlh fhc ^jm] bgh]^ZaZ[u\Z_lqlh hg g_ ]h\hjbl
ihbkiZgkdb
Y ^mfZx lZd`_qlh hgaZ[ue ij_^klZ\blv gZk ^jm]
^jm]mkdZaZe yb gZa\Zek\h_ bfy
: yOmZg fZlmkd \Zrbfmkem]ZfkdZaZe hg
Fu ih`Zeb^jm] ^jm]mjmdb bg_dhlhjh_ \j_fyfheqZebY
gZjmrbe fheqZgb_b jZkkdZaZeh klhys_ci_j_^h fghcaZ^Zq_Y
kdZaZe _fmqlh bsmex[h]h jh^ZbgnhjfZpbx h jZkl_gbyo
hkh[_ggh h i_chl_Y g_dhlhjh_\j_fy ijh^he`Ze gZihjbklh
]h\hjblv bohly y[ue ihqlbiheguf g_\_`^hc\ wlhf\hijhk_
l_f g_ f_g__ ykdZaZe _fmqlh m`_hq_gv fgh]h_ agZx h
i_chl_Y kqblZeqlh _keby iho\ZklZxkvk\hbf agZgb_flh
_fm [m^_lbgl_j_kgh jZa]h\Zjb\Zlvkh fghcGh hgg_ kdZaZe
gbq_]hHg l_ji_eb\h kemrZeAZl_f hgf_^e_ggh db\gme b
mklZ\beky gZ f_gy_]h ]eZaZdZaZehkvk\_lbebkv k\hbf
kh[kl\_gguf k\_lhfY ba[_]Ze_]h \a]ey^ZY qm\kl\h\Ze
g_m^h[kl\hM f_gy[ueZ m\_j_gghklv\ lhlfhf_glqlh hg
agZ_lqlh y]h\hjx q_imom
AZoh^b dZdgb[m^v dhfg_ ^hfhckdZaZe hggZdhg_p
hl\_^y k\hb ]eZaZ hl f_gyfh`_l [ulv fu kfh`_f lZf
ih]h\hjblv [he__e_]dh
Y g_ agZeqlh _s_kdZaZlvY qm\kl\h\Ze g_m^h[kl\h
Q_j_a g_dhlhjh_\j_fy ;bee\ha\jZlbeky \aZeHg ihgye fh_
g_m^h[kl\h bgb keh\Zg_ kdZaZeG_dhlhjh_ \j_fyfu kb^_eb\
gZijy`_gghf fheqZgbbAZl_f klZjbdih^gyeky?]h Z\lh[mk
ijb[ueHg ihijhsZeky
G_ hq_gv ohjhrh ihreh"kijhkbe
;bee>Z
G_\ughkbfuc<g_aZigh ;beegZdehgbeky dhfg_ bljhgme f_gy
lu kijZrb\Ze_]h hjZkl_gbyo"
>ZkijZrb\Zegh y^mfZxqlh kijhkbeg_ lZd
Y `_]h\hjbe l_[_qlh hghq_gv wdkp_gljbq_gBg^_cpu
\ hdj_klghklyoagZxl _]hgh hgbgbdh]^Z hg_f g_]h\hjyl:
wlh m`_dh_qlh
<k_ `_hg kdZaZeqlh yfh]m aZclbd g_fm^hfhc
Hg gZ^mel_[yDhg_qghlu fh`_rvaZclb dg_fm ^hfhc
gh qlhwlh agZqbl"Hg gbdh]^Zgbq_]h l_[_g_ kdZ`_l>Z`_
_keb luihijhkbrv _]hh q_flhhg aZfg_lkydZd _keb[ lu
[ue b^bhlhfg_kmsbf hdhe_kbpm
;bee m[_`^_ggh ]h\hjbeqlh hg\klj_qZe jZg__ ex^_c
lZdh]h jh^Zdhlhju_ ijhba\h^yl\i_qZle_gb_ hq_gv agZxsbo
GZ _]h\a]ey^kdZaZe hglZdb_ ex^bg_ klhylaZ[hllZd dZd
jZgh beb iha^gh fh`gh
ihemqblv
lm `_ bgnhjfZpbx hl
dh]hgb[m^v _s_dlh g_kljhbl bak_[y ljm^gh^hklmigh]hHg
kdZaZeqlh m g_]h g_lgb \j_f_gbgb l_ji_gbyqlh[u
jZkimlu\Zlv lmfZgklZjbdh\b qlh\hafh`ghklZjbd lhevdh
^_eZ_l \b^qlh agZ_l qlhlh
h ljZ\Zolh]^Z dZd \
^_ckl\bl_evghklb hgagZ_l g_[hevr_ ex[h]h^jm]h]h
;bee ijh^he`Ze]h\hjblvgh yg_ kemrZeFhb fukeb\k_
_s_ [ueb aZgylu klZjufbg^_cp_fHg agZeqlh y e]mY
\kihfgbe _]h]eZaZHgb ^_ckl\bl_evghkbyeb
Q_j_a iZjmf_kyp_\ y\_jgmekyqlh[u gZ\_klblv_]hg_
klhevdh
dZd
klm^_gl
Zgljhiheh]bbbgl_j_kmxsbcky
e_dZjkl\_ggufb
jZkl_gbyfbkdhevdh
dZd
q_eh\_d
k
g_h[tykgbfuf ex[hiulkl\hfLhdZd hglh]^Z \a]eygme gZ
f_gy[ueh [_kij_p_^_glgufy\e_gb_f \fh_c `bagbY ohl_e
agZlvqlh kdju\Zehkvih^ wlbf\a]ey^hfWlh klZeh^ey f_gy
ihqlb lhqdhc ij_ldgh\_gbyY jZafureyeh[ wlhfbq_f
^hevr_ y^mfZel_f [he__g_h[uqguf fg_wlh dZaZehkv
Fu klZeb k^hghf OmZghf^jmavyfbb \l_q_gb_ ]h^Z y
gZ\_klbe _]h[_kqbke_ggh_ dhebq_kl\hjZaY gZr_e_]h fZg_ju
hq_gv m\_j_ggufbZ _]hqm\kl\h xfhjZ ij_\hkoh^gufgh
ij_`^_ \k_]hy qm\kl\h\Zeqlh [uehkdjulh_ kh^_j`Zgb_\ _]h
ihklmidZokh^_j`Zgb_dhlhjh_ y\eyehkv^ey f_gykh\_jr_ggh
g_\b^bfufY qm\kl\h\Ze
kljZggh_
m^h\hevkl\b_
\ _]h
ijbkmlkl\bbb\ lh`_ kZfh_\j_fyy bkiulu\Ze kljZggh_
g_m^h[kl\hH^gh lhevdh_]h h[s_kl\haZklZ\eyeh f_gy^_eZlv
h]jhfgmx i_j_hp_gdmfhbo fh^_e_cih\_^_gbyY [ue\hkiblZg
ih`ZemcdZd b ex[hc^jm]hcijbgbfZlv q_eh\_dZdZd\
kmsghklb k\h_ckeZ[h_ bih^\_j`_ggh_ hrb[dZfkms_kl\h<
^hg_ OmZg_ f_gy ihjZ`Zeh
lhqlh
hg g_ ijhba\h^be
\i_qZle_gby keZ[h]h b[_aaZsblgh]hb ijhklh_ gZoh`^_gb_
jy^hf k gbf jh`^Zehg_[eZ]hijbylgh_ kjZ\g_gb_ f_`^m _]h
h[jZahf `bagbb fhbfIh`Zemch^gbf bakZfuo ihjZabl_evguo
ml\_j`^_gbcdhlhju_ hg k^_eZe\ wlhl i_jbh^dZkZehkv
gZr_]h \jh`^_ggh]hjZaebqbyI_j_^ h^gbfba fhbo\bablh\ y
qm\kl\h\Ze k_[yhq_gv g_kqZklghbaaZ h[s_]hl_q_gby k\h_c
`bagb b baaZ jy^Z^Z\ysbo ebqguodhgnebdlh\dhlhju_ y
bf_eDh]^Z yijb[ue \_]h ^hfy qm\kl\h\Zek_[y \ iehohf
gZkljh_gbb bhq_gv g_j\gh
Fu ]h\hjbebh fh_fbgl_j_k_ dagZgbxghdZd h[uqgh
fu rebih ^\mfjZaguf ^hjh]ZfY bf_e\ \b^m ZdZ^_fbq_kdh_
agZgb_dhlhjh_ i_j_^Z_lhiul\ lh\j_fy dZdhg ]h\hjbe h
ijyfhf agZgbbfbjZ
AgZ_rv eblu qlhgb[m^v h[hdjm`Zxs_f l_[yfbj_"
kijhkbe hg
Y agZx\kydh]h jh^Z\_sbkdZaZe y
Y bf_x\ \b^mlu dh]^Zgb[m^v hsmsZ_rvfbj \hdjm]
l_[y"
Y hsmsZx\ fbj_klhevdhkdhevdh fh]m
Wlh]h g_^hklZlhqghLu ^he`_gqm\kl\h\Zlv \k_bgZq_
fbj l_jy_lk\hc kfuke
Y \ukdZaZe deZkkbq_kdbc ^h\h^qlh fg_ g_ gm`gh
ijh[h\Zlv kmi^ey lh]hqlh[u magZlv_]h j_p_ilb g_gm`gh
ih^\_j]Zlv k_[ym^Zjm we_dljhlhdZ^ey lh]hqlh[u magZlvh[
we_dljbq_kl\_
Lu aZklZ\ey_rv wlha\mqZlv ]emihkdZaZe hg
gZkdhevdh y \b`mlu ohq_rvp_ieylvky aZ k\hb ^h\h^u
g_kfhljy gZlhl nZdlqlh hgbgbq_]h l_[_g_ ^ZxlLu ohq_rv
hklZlvky l_f`_ kZfuf^Z`_ p_ghck\h_]h [eZ]hihemqby
Y g_agZxh q_flu ]h\hjbrv
Y ]h\hjxh lhfnZdl_qlh lug_ p_evgucM l_[y g_l
fbjZwlh ml\_j`^_gb_jZa^jZ`beh f_gyY ihqm\kl\h\Zek_[y
aZ^_lufY ih^mfZeqlh hg g_^hklZlhqgh d\Zebnbpbjh\Zg
qlh[u km^blvh fhboihklmidZo bebh fh_cebqghklb
Lu aZjZ`_gijh[e_fZfbkdZaZe hgihq_fm"
Y \k_]hebrv q_eh\_d^hg OmZgkdZaZe ydZd kZfh
kh[hc jZamf_xs__kyY k^_eZewlh ml\_j`^_gb_ k l_fb `_
bglhgZpbyfbdhlhju_ ^_eZefhc hl_pdh]^Z ijhbaghkbe _]h
Dh]^Z hg ]h\hjbeqlh hg\k_]h ebrvq_eh\_dlh hg \k_]^Z
ih^jZamf_\Zeqlh hgkeZ[ b[_aaZsbl_gb _]h ml\_j`^_gb_
lZd`_dZd b\k_[ueh ihegh[_af_jgh]h qm\kl\ZhlqZygby
>hg OmZgmklZ\beky gZf_gy lZd`_dZd blh]^Zdh]^Z
fu \i_j\u_\klj_lbebkv
Lu ^mfZ_rv h k_[_kebrdhf fgh]hkdZaZe hg b
meu[gmekyZ wlh^Z_l l_[_kljZggmx mklZehklvdhlhjZy
aZklZ\ey_l l_[yaZdju\Zlvky hlhdjm`Zxs_]h fbjZb p_ieylvky
aZ k\hb Zj]mf_gluIhwlhfm ijh[e_fuwlh \k_qlh m l_[y
_klvY \k_]hebrv q_eh\_dlh`_gh g_bf_x a^_kv \ \b^m
lh]hqlh bf__rvlu
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m"
Y ba[Z\bekyhl k\hboijh[e_fHq_gv iehohqlh `bagv
lZd dhjhldZqlh y g_fh]m mo\ZlblvkyaZ \k_ \_sbaZ
dhlhju_ fg_ihgjZ\behkv [uko\ZlblvkyGh wlhg_ ijh[e_fZ
Wlh ijhklhkh`Ze_gb_
Fg_ ihgjZ\beky lhg _]h\ukdZau\Zgby< g_f g_ [ueh
hlqZygby beb`Zehklb dkZfhfm k_[_
< ]h^mq_j_a ]h^ihke_ gZr_ci_j\hc \klj_qb^hg
OmZg hldjue fg_qlh hgh[eZ^Z_l k_dj_lguf agZgb_f ih
e_dZjkl\_gguf ljZ\ZfHg kdZaZefg_qlh y\ey_lky [jmoh
BkiZgkdh_ keh\h [j mo h
fh`ghi_j_\_klbdZd fZ ]
a gZ oZ jv d he ^m gK wlh]hfhf_glZ hlghr_gby
f_`^m gZfb baf_gbebkvY klZe_]h mq_gbdhfb \ l_q_gb_
ke_^mxsbo q_luj_oe_l hgiulZeky mqblvf_gy lZcgZffZ]bbH[
wlhf mq_gbq_kl\_y gZibkZedgb]mmq_gb_ ^hgZOmZgZimlv
agZgby bg^_cp_\ie_f_gb ydb
GZrb jZa]h\hju ijhoh^beb
gZ
bkiZgkdhf yaud_b
[eZ]h^Zjy lhfmqlh ^hgOmZg [e_klys_\eZ^_e wlbfyaudhfy
ihemqbe ^_lZevgu_ h[tykg_gbykeh`guo agZq_gbc_]h kbkl_fu
ih\_jbcY gZau\Zewlm keh`gmxb ohjhrhkbkl_fZlbabjh\Zggmx
\_l\v agZgbyfZ]b_cZ _]hkZfh]h fZ]hfihlhfm qlhbf_ggh
lZdb_ dZl_]hjbb
hg
kZf
bkihevah\Ze
\ g_hnbpbZevghf
jZa]h\hj_H^gZdh\ dhgl_dkl_[he__ k_jv_agh]hhk\_s_gby hg
bkihevah\Ze l_jfbgu agZgb_qlh[ h[hagZqblv fZ]bxb
q_eh\_d agZgbybeb lhldlh agZ_lqlh[ h[hagZqblv
fZ]Z
>ey lh]hqlh[ mqblvb i_j_^Z\Zlvk\h_ agZgb_^hg OmZg
bkihevah\Ze ljb ohjhrh ba\_klguo ikbohljhiguo jZkl_gby
i_chl O_jghjghUXZLOOLZfb_LO^mjfZg GZlbUZ LihoLZ b \b^
]jb[h\hlghkysbcky djh^m jV\OhV_\_
Iml_f jZa^_evgh]h ijbgylby \gmljv dZ`^h]h ba wlbo
]Zeexpbgh]_gh\hg ijh^mpbjh\Ze\h fg_dZd k\h_f mq_gbd_
g_dhlhju_ ex[hiulgu_ khklhygbygZjmr_ggh]h \hkijbylby beb
baf_g_ggh]h
khagZgbydhlhju_
y
gZau\Ze
khklhygb_
g_h[uqZcghc j_ZevghklbY
bkihevah\Ze
keh\h
j_ Z
e vg hk lv ihlhfm qlh\ kbkl_f_\_jh\Zgbc ^hgZOmZgZ
hkgh\guf imgdlhf
[ueh
lhqlh
khklhygby
khagZgby
ijh^mpbjm_fu_ ijbgylb_fex[h]h bawlbo lj_ojZkl_gbc[ueb
g_ ]ZeexpbgZpbyfbZ p_evgufbohly bg_h[uqgufbZki_dlZfb
j_Zevghklb ih\k_^g_\ghc `bagb>hg
OmZg
\_e k_[y ih
hlghr_gbx dwlbf khklhygbyfg_h[uqghc j_Zevghklbg_ lZddZd
_keb [uhgb g_[ueb jZ_evgugh dZdd j_Zevguf
DeZkkbnbpbjh\Zlv wlb jZkl_gbydZd ]Zeexpbgh]_guZ
khklhygbydhlhju_
hgb
ijh^mpbjmxldZd
g_h[uqgmx
j_Zevghklv[uehdhg_qghfhbf kh[kl\_gguf bah[j_l_gb_f
>hg OmZgihgbfZe bh[tykgye wlbjZkl_gbydZd ljZgkihjlgu_
kj_^kl\Zdhlhju_ ^he`guijb\h^blv b^hklZ\eylv q_eh\_dZ d
g_dbf [_aebqgufkbeZfZ khklhygb_dhlhjh_ hgbijh^mpbjmxl
dZd \klj_qbdhlhju_ fZ]^he`_g bf_lvk wlbfbkbeZfb ^ey
lh]hqlh[ ihemqblvgZ^ gbfbdhgljhev
Hg gZau\Ze i_chl f_kdZeblhb h[tykgbeqlh hg
y\ey_lky ^h[jh\hevgufmqbl_e_f baZsblgbdhf ex^_cF_kdZeblh
mqbl lhfmdZd ijZ\bevgh`blvI_chl h[uqghijbgbfZ_lky gZ
kh[jZgbb
fZ]h\gZau\Z_fuo
fblhlu]^_
mqZklgbdb
kh[bjZxlky k hij_^_e_gghcp_evx ihemqblvmjhd \ lhfdZd
ijZ\bevgh `blv
>hg OmZgkqblZe ^mjfZgb ]jb[ukbeZfb ^jm]h]hjh^ZHg
gZau\Ze bo heebb kdZaZeqlh bfb fh`gh mijZ\eylv
nZdlbq_kdbfZ] ihemqZek\hx kbemfZgbimebjmy heebBa wlbo
^\mo kbe^hg OmZgij_^ihqblZe ]jb[uHg ml\_j`^Zeqlh kbeZ
kh^_j`ZsZyky \]jb[Zo[ueZ _]hebqguf heebb hggZau\Ze __
^ufbeb ^ufhd
Ijhp_^mjZ bkihevah\Zgby]jb[h\ m^hgZ OmZgZkhklhyeZ \
lhfqlh[u ^Zlvbf \ukhogmlv\ f_evqZcrbcihjhrhdihdZ hgb
gZoh^ylky \gmljb g_[hevrh]h dm\rbgZHg ^_j`Ze dm\rbg
aZi_qZlZgguf \ l_q_gb_]h^ZaZl_f kf_rb\Ze ihemqb\rbcky
ihjhrhd k iylvx^jm]bfb kmobfbjZkl_gbyfb bihemqZe kf_kv
^ey dmj_gby\ ljm[d_
>ey lh]hqlh[u
klZlv
q_eh\_dhf
agZgby
gm`gh
\klj_lblvkyk heebdZd fh`gh[hevr__ dhebq_kl\hjZaGm`gh
klZlv agZdhfufk heebWlZ aZ^ZqZkhklhyeZdhg_qgh\
lhfqlh[u dmjblv]Zeexpbgh]_ggmx kf_kvhq_gv qZklhIjhp_kk
dmj_gbyaZdexqZeky \
ijh]eZlu\Zgbb
f_edh]h ihjhrdZ
dhlhjuc g_ k]hjZeb \^uoZgby^ufZ ^jm]bo iylb jZkl_gbc
dhlhju_ khklZ\eyebdmjbl_evgmx kf_kv
>hg OmZg h[tykgye]em[hdbc wnn_dldhlhjuc \uau\Zeb
]jb[u \kihkh[ghklyo \hkijbylbydZd lhqlh heeb m[bjZ_l
l_eh
F_lh^ mq_gby^hgZ OmZgZlj_[h\Ze g_h[uqZcguomkbebc kh
klhjhgu mq_gbdZNZdlbq_kdbg_h[oh^bfZy kl_i_gvmqZklby b
\h\e_q_gghklb [ueZ klhev\_ebdZ bgZijy`_ggZqlh d dhgpm
]h^Z y\ugm`^_g [ue[jhkblv mq_gbq_kl\hL_i_jvdh]^Z
ijhreh m`_e_l kl_o ihjy fh]mkdZaZlvqlh \lh \j_fy
mq_gb_ ^hgZOmZgZ gZqZehij_^klZ\eylv kh[hck_jv_agmx m]jham
fh_c b^__ fbjZY klZel_jylv m\_j_gghklvdhlhjmx \k_fu
bf__f\ lhfqlh j_Zevghklvih\k_^g_\ghc `bagb y\ey_lky
q_flh lZdbfqlh fufh`_f kqblZlv]ZjZglbjh\Zgguf b kZfh
kh[hc jZamf_xsbfky
<h \j_fy moh^Zy [uem[_`^_g \lhfqlh fh_ j_r_gb_
hdhgqZl_evgh_y g_ohl_e [he__\b^_lv ^hgZOmZgZH^gZdh \
Zij_e_ ]h^Z y ihemqbei_j\mx dhibx k\h_c dgb]b b
ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[yh[yaZgguf ihdZaZlv__ _fmY gZ\_klbe_]h
GZrZ k\yav mqbl_evmq_gbd aZ]Z^hqgh\hkklZgh\beZkvb y
fh]m kdZaZlvqlh klh]h \j_f_gby gZqZe\lhjhc pbdek\h_]h
mq_gbq_kl\Zhq_gv hlebqZxsbckyhl i_j\h]h
Fhc kljZog_ [ueklhev hkljufdZdbf hg[ue \ijhrehf
H[s__ gZkljh_gb_ mq_gby^hgZ OmZgZ[ueh jZkkeZ[e_ggufHg
hq_gv fgh]hkf_yeky bkf_rbe f_gyDZaZehkvk _]h klhjhgu
[ueh khagZl_evgh_ gZf_j_gb_
k\_klb
d
fbgbfmfm h[smx
k_jv_aghklvHg rmlbe\ ^_ckl\bl_evghdjblbq_kdb_ fhf_glu
wlh]h \lhjh]hpbdeZ blZdbf h[jZahfihfh] fg_ijhclb lZdb_
hiuludhlhju_ e_]dhfh]eb klZlvij_iylkl\b_f
?]h hlijZ\ghclhqdhc [uehlhqlh g_h[oh^bfhe_]dh_ b
kihdhcgh_ jZkiheh`_gb_^moZ ^eylh]hqlh[u mk\hblvgZihj b
qm`_jh^ghklv lh]hagZgbydhlhjhfm hgf_gy mqbe
IjbqbgZ lh]hqlh lubkim]Zeky bm^jZekhklhbl \
lhfqlh luqm\kl\h\Ze k_[yq_jlh\kdb \Z`gufkdZaZe hg
h[tykgyy fhcij_^u^msbc moh^qm\kl\h kh[kl\_gghc\Z`ghklb
^_eZ_l q_eh\_dZly`_eufg_mdex`bf bimkluf gZijZkguf>ey
lh]hqlh[u klZlv q_eh\_dhfagZgbygZ^h [ulv e_]dbf b
l_dmqbf
Hkh[uc bgl_j_k ^hgZ OmZgZ
\h \lhjhf pbde_ fh_]h
mq_gbq_kl\Z khklhye \ lhfqlh[u gZmqblv f_gy \b^_lv
Hq_\b^gh\ _]hkbkl_f_ agZgby[ueZ \hafh`ghklv ijh\_klb
k_fZglbq_kdh_ jZaebqb_ f_`^m \b^_lvb kfhlj_lvdZd
f_`^m ^\mfy jZaebqgufb kihkh[Zfb \hkijbylbyKfhlj_lv
hagZqZeh lhl h[uqguckihkh[dhlhjuf fu ijb\udeb hsmsZlv
fbj\ lh \j_fy dZd\b^_lvaZdexqZeh \ k_[_ keh`guc
ijhp_kkiml_f dhlhjh]hq_eh\_d agZgbyfh] g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh
\hkijbgbfZlv kmsghklv\_s_c fbjZ
>ey lh]hqlh[u ij_^klZ\blvaZimlZgghklv wlh]hmq_[gh]h
ijhp_kkZ \ m^h[h\Zjbfhc nhjf_y k`Ze ^ebggu_ p_ihqdb
\hijhkh\ bhl\_lh\ blZdbf h[jZahfba^Ze fhbhjb]bgZevgu_
ihe_\u_ aZibkbH^gZdh y\_jxqlh gZwlhl jZafh_ baeh`_gb_
g_ jZkoh^blky kh agZq_gb_f
^hgZ OmZgZJ_^Zdpby [ueZ
gZijZ\e_gZ gZlhqlh[ fhbaZibkb l_debdZd l_q_ljZa]h\hj
qlh[ hgbbf_eb lhkh^_j`Zgb_dhlhjh_ y`_eZebgZq_ ]h\hjy
y ohl_ekj_^kl\Zfb j_ihjlZ`Zi_j_^Zlv qblZl_ex^jZfZlbaf b
gZijZ\e_gghklv ihe_\hckblmZpbbDZ`^uc bajZa^_eh\dhlhjuc
y h[hagZqZe ]eZ\hcy\ey_lky k_kkb_ck ^hghf OmZghfDZd
ijZ\behhg \k_]^ZaZdZgqb\Ze gZrjZa]h\hj gZ h[hj\Zgghc
ghl_lZdbf h[jZahf^jZfZlbq_kdbc lhghdhgqZgby dZ`^hc]eZ\u
g_ fh_ kh[kl\_ggh_ ebl_jZlmjgh_
bah[j_l_gb_wlh [ueh
k\hckl\_ggh jZa]h\hjghcfZg_j_ ^hgZOmZgZIh\b^bfhfmwlh
[ueh ZiiZjZlhf ^ey
aZihfbgZgbydhlhjuc
ihfh]Ze fg_
m^_j`b\Zlv ^jZfZlbq_kdbcoZjZdl_j b\Z`ghklv mjhdh\
H^gZdh^ey lh]hqlh[u k^_eZlvfhc j_ihjlZ`ihgylguf
g_h[oh^bfu
g_dhlhju_
h[tykg_gbyihkdhevdm
ykghklv
baeZ]Z_fh]h fZl_jbZeZ
aZ\bkbl
hl
hk\_s_gby
dexq_\uo
dhgp_ipbc beb dexq_\uo _^bgbpdhlhju_ fg_ ohl_ehkv [u
ih^q_jdgmlvWlhl \u[hjm^Zj_gby hkgh\ZggZ fh_fbgl_j_k_ d
h[s_kl\_gguf gZmdZf<_kvfZ \hafh`ghqlh ^jm]hcq_eh\_dk
^jm]bf gZ[hjhf p_e_c b
h`b^Zgbc \u^_eye [u dhgp_ipbb
iheghklvx hlebqgu_hl l_odhlhju_ \u[jZey kZf
< i_jbh^\lhjh]h pbdeZmq_gbq_kl\Z ^hgOmZg k^_eZemihj
gZ lhfqlh[u m[_^blvf_gyqlh bkihevah\Zgb_ dmjbl_evghc
kf_kb y\eyehkvg_h[oh^bfuf mkeh\b_f^ey \b^_gvyIhwlhfm y
^he`_g dmjblv__ dZdfh`gh qZs_
Lhevdh ^uffh`_l ^Zlvl_[_ g_h[oh^bfmxkdhjhklv ^ey
lh]hqlh[u meh\blvhl[e_kd lh]hl_dms_]h fbjZkdZaZe hg
K ihfhsvx ikbohljhighckf_kb hgijh^mpbjh\Ze \h fg_
k_jbb khklhygbc g_h[uqZcghc j_ZevghklbHkgh\ghc q_jlhc
lZdbo khklhygbc\ hlghr_gbbd lhfmq_fdZaZehkvaZgbfZeky
^hg OmZg[ueh khklhygb_g_ijbeh`bfhklbLhqlh yhsmlbe
\ wlbokhklhygbyo baf_g_ggh]hkhagZgby[ueh g_\hkijb_febfuf
b
g_\hafh`guf
^ey
bklhedh\Zgby
kj_^kl\Zfb
gZr_]h
ih\k_^g_\gh]h f_lh^Z ihgbfZgby
fbjZ>jm]bfb keh\Zfb
khklhygb_ g_ijbeh`bfhklb \e_deh
aZ
kh[hc bkq_agh\_gb_
k\yaghklb \fh_f fbjh\haaj_gbb
>hg OmZgbkihevah\Ze wlhkhklhygb_ g_ijbeh`bfhklbbeb
khklhygb_ g_h[uqghcj_Zevghklb^ey lh]hqlh[u \\_klbk_jbx
ij_^\Zjbl_evgh mk\h_gguogh\uo _^bgbp agZq_gby?^bgbpZfb
agZq_gby [ueb\k_ hl^_evgu_we_f_gluoZjZdl_jgu_ ^ey lh]h
agZgbydhlhjhfm ^hgOmZg klZjZekyf_gy h[mqblvY gZa\Zebo
_^bgbpZfb
agZq_gby
ihlhfmqlh
hgb
[ueb
hkgh\guf
dhg]ehf_jZlhf k_gkhjguo^Zgguo bbo h[tykg_gbcba dhlhjuo
dhgkljmbjh\Zebkv [he__keh`gu_ agZq_gbyH^gbf ba ijbf_jh\
lZdbo _^bgbp
agZq_gby
y\ey_lky
kihkh[ih dhlhjhfm
ihgbfZ_lky nbabheh]bq_kdbc wnn_dlikbohljhighc kf_kbHgZ
ijh^mpbjm_l hg_f_gb_ bihl_jx ^\b]Zl_evgh]hdhgljheyqlh
i_j_\h^behkv \kbkl_f_ ^hgZOmZgZdZd ^_ckl\b_\uihegy_fh_
^ufdhfdhlhjuc \wlhf kemqZ_gZau\Zeky heeb^ey lh]hqlh[
m[jZlv l_ehmqZklgbdZ
?^bgbpu agZq_gby[ueb hkh[ufh[jZahf h[t_^bg_gu\f_kl_
b dZ`^Zykha^ZggZy lZdbfh[jZahf ]jmiiZy\eyeZkv l_fqlh
y gZa\Ze qm\kl\_ggZy bgl_jij_lZpbyHq_\b^ghqlh fh]eh
kms_kl\h\Zlv
[_kdhg_qgh_
dhebq_kl\h
lZdbo
\hafh`guo
qm\kl\_gguo bgl_jij_lZpbckms_kl\_gguo \fZ]bbdhlhju_ fZ]
^he`_g gZmqblvky kha^Z\Zlv< gZr_cih\k_^g_\ghc `bagb fu
klZedb\Z_fky
k
[_kqbke_gguf
dhebq_kl\hf
qm\kl\_gguo
bgl_jij_lZpbck\yaZgguo kwlbfIjhklhc ijbf_jdhlhjuc fu
[he__ g_bkihevam_fdZd khagZl_evgmxbgl_jij_lZpbxwlh
kljmdlmjZdhlhjmx fugZau\Z_f dhfgZlZHq_\b^ghqlh fu
gZmqbebkv bklhedh\u\Zlv kljmdlmjm
dhfgZlZ\ l_jfbgZo
dhfgZlulZdbf
h[jZahfdhfgZlZ
y\ey_lky qm\kl\_gghc
bgl_jij_lZpb_cihlhfm qlhhgZ lj_[m_lqlh[u \lhl fhf_gl
dh]^Z fu__ gZau\Z_ffu l_fbeb bgufh[jZahf hkhagZ\Zeb[u
\k_ l_ we_f_gludhlhju_ \oh^yl\ wlhihkljh_gb_Kbkl_fZ
qm\kl\_gguo
bgl_jij_lZpbc
y\ey_lkybgufb
keh\Zfb
ijhp_kkhfijb ihfhsbdhlhjh]h ijZdlbdmxsbc hkhagZ_l \k_
_^bgbpu agZq_gbyg_h[oh^bfu_ ^ey
lh]hqlh[u k^_eZlv
aZdexq_gby\u\h^uij_^kdZaZgby bliH[h \k_okblmZpbyo
k\yaZgguo k_]h Zdlb\ghklvx
Ih^ ijZdlbdmxsbfy ih^jZamf_\ZxmqZklgbdZbf_xs_]h
Z^_d\Zlgh_ agZgb_ h[h \k_obeb ihqlb h[h \k_o _^bgbpZo
agZq_gby\oh^ysbo \ _]hdhgdj_lgmx kbkl_fm qm\kl\_gguo
bgl_jij_lZpbc>hg OmZg[ue ijZdlbdmxsbfLh _klv hg [ue
fZ]hfdhlhjuc agZe\k_ rZ]bk\h_c fZ]bb
DZd ijZdlbdmxsbchg ihiulZekyk^_eZlv k\hx kbkl_fm
qm\kl\_gguo bgl_jij_lZpbc
^hklmighc
^ey
f_gyLZdZy
^hklmighklv \ wlhf
kemqZ_
[ueZ
jZ\ghkbevgZ ijhp_kkm
^_khpbZebaZpbb\
dhlhjhf
ijb\b\Zebkv
gh\u_
imlb
bgl_jij_lbjh\Zgby bgnhjfZpbbihemqZ_fhc
q_j_a
hj]Zgu
qm\kl\
Y [ue qm`bflh _klvl_fdlh g_ bf_e kihkh[ghklb
^_eZlv jZamfgu_b k\yaZggu_bgl_jij_lZpbb _^bgbp agZq_gby
hlghkysboky dfZ]bb
AZ^ZqZ ^hgZ OmZgZdZd ijZdlbdmxs_]h^_eZxs_]h k\hx
kbkl_fm ^hklmighc ^ey f_gy[ueh jZajmrblv hij_^_e_ggmx
m\_j_gghklvdhlhjmx yjZa^_eyx kex[uf ^jm]bfm\_j_gghklv
\ lhfqlh gZrbhkgh\Zggu_ gZa^jZ\hf kfuke_\a]ey^u gZ
fbj hdhgqZl_evguBkihevamy ikbohljhigu_jZkl_gby b lhqgh
gZijZ\e_ggu_ klhedgh\_gbyf_`^m fghxb qm`^ufbkbkl_fZfbhg
^h[beky mki_oZ \lhfqlh ihdZaZefg_qlh fhb\a]ey^u gZ
fbj g_fh]ml [ulvdhg_qgufblZd dZdwlh lhevdhbgl_jij_lZ
pby
>ey Zf_jbdZgkdbo
bg^_cp_\\hafh`gh\
l_q_gb_
lukyq_e_lbc lhlimklhc n_ghf_gdhlhjuc fugZau\Z_f fZ]b_c
y\ey_lky k_jv_aghc^hklh\_jghc
ijZdlbdhcaZgbfZ\r_c
ijbf_jgh lh`_ iheh`_gb_dhlhjh_ aZgbfZ_lgZrZ gZmdZGZrb
ljm^ghklb \ihgbfZgbb __[_a khfg_gbyijhbkl_dZxl baqm`^uo
gZf _^bgbpagZq_gbyk dhlhjufbhgZ bf__l^_eh
H^gZ`^u ^hg OmZg kdZaZe
fg_qlh q_eh\_d bf__l
ij_^jZkiheh`_gbyY
ihijhkbe
_]h
h[tykgblv
fg_ wlh
ml\_j`^_gb_
Fh_ ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_ \b ^_ lv kdZaZe hg
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m"
Fg_ gjZ\blky \b ^_ lv kdZaZe hgihlhfm
qlh lhevdhijb ihfhsb \b ^_ gb y
q_eh\_dagZgby fh`_l
agZlv
DZdh]h jh^Z\_sb lu \b ^b rv "
<k_
Gh ylh`_ \b`m\k_Z yg_ q_eh\_dagZgby
G_llu g_ \b ^b rv Y kqblZxqlh \b`m
=h\hjx l_[_qlh lu g_
\b ^b rv Qlh l_[yaZklZ\ey_l lZd]h\hjblv^hg OmZg"
Lu lhevdhkfhljbrv gZih\_joghklv \_s_c
Lu ohq_rv kdZaZlvqlh
dZ`^uc q_eh\_d agZgby
^_ckl\bl_evgh \b^blgZkd\hav \k_gZ qlhkfhljbl"
G_lwlh g_lhqlh ybf_e \\b^mY kdZaZeqlh m
q_eh\_dZ agZgby_klv k\hbkh[kl\_ggu_ ij_^jZkiheh`_gbyFh_
khklhbl \lhfqlh[u ijhklh \b ^_ lv
bagZlv^jm]b_
^_eZxl ^jm]b_\_sb
GmgZijbf_jdZdb_ ^jm]b_\_sb"
<havf_f kZdZl_dmhg
q_eh\_d
agZgbyb _]h
ij_^jZkiheh`_gb_ lZgp_\ZlvIhwlhfm hglZgpm_l bagZ_l
AgZqblij_^jZkiheh`_gb_ q_eh\_dZagZgby wlh g_qlh
lZdh_qlh hg^_eZ_l ^eylh]hqlh[u agZlv"
>Zwlh ijZ\bevgh
Gh dZdfh`_l lZg_pihfhqv kZdZl_d_agZlv"
Fh`gh kdZaZlvqlh kZdZl_dZlZgpm_l \k_fqlh mg_]h
_klv
Hg lZgpm_llZd `_dZd y"Y ohqmkdZaZlvlZddZd
lZgpmxl"
KdZ`_fqlh hglZgpm_l lZd`_dZd y \b `m Z
g_ lZddZd lufh`_rv lZgp_\Zlv
< b^ bl
ebhg lh`_lZd`_dZd lu"
>Zgh hglZd`_ blZgpm_l
DZd lZgpm_lkZdZl_dZ"
Wlh ljm^ghh[tykgblvWlh hkh[h]hjh^Z lZg_pdhlhjuc
hg bkihegy_ldh]^Z hgohq_l agZlvGh \k_qlh yfh]m h[
wlhf kdZaZlvl_[_ wlh lhqlh_keb lug_ ihgbfZ_rviml_c
q_eh\_dZdhlhjuc agZ_llh
g_\hafh`gh
b ]h\hjblv h
\ b^ _g vb
beblZgp_
: lu \b ^_ edZd hglZgpm_l k\hclZg_p"
>ZH^gZdhwlh g_\hafh`gh^ey ex[h]hdlh kfhljblgZ
_]h lZg_p\ b^ _l vqlh wlh _]h hkh[uc kihkh[
ihagZgby
Y agZe kZdZl_dmbebih djZcg_cf_j_y agZedlh hg
lZdhcFu \klj_qZebkvb h^gZ`^uy ihdmiZe_fm ib\hHg [ue
hq_gv \_`eb\b kdZaZeqlh yfh]m k\h[h^ghhklZgZ\eb\Zlvky \
_]h ^hf_dh]^Z fg_wlh ihgZ^h[blkyY ^he]haZ[Z\eye k_[y
fukevx h lhfqlh[u ihk_lblv_]hgh ^hgmOmZgm gbq_]h h[
wlhf g_]h\hjbe
< ihe^_gv fZy ]h^Z yih^t_oZe d^hfm kZdZl_db
Hg jZkkdZaZe fg_dZd ^hg_]h ^h[jZlvkyb y e_]dh gZr_e
wlhl ^hfHg klhyegZ m]emb [uekh \k_o klhjhg hdjm`_g
ba]hjh^vx<hjhlZ [ueb aZdjuluY h[hr_e ^hf djm]hf
\ubkdb\Zyg_evay eb]^_gb[m^v aZ]eygmlv\gmljvDZaZehkv
qlh ^hfimkl
>hg Wevykdjbdgme y]jhfdh
Dmju i_j_im]Zebkv b jZkkuiZebkv
ih ^\hjmm`Zkgh
dm^ZoqZG_[hevrZy kh[ZqdZih^hreZ daZ[hjmY h`b^Zeqlh
hgZ aZeZ_l gZ f_gy\f_klh wlh]h hgZ ijhklh mk_eZkv
gZ[ex^Zy aZfghcY iha\Ze_s_ jZab dmjujZajZabebkv gh\uf
dm^ZolZgv_fKlZjZy `_gsbgZ\ureZ ba^hfmY ihijhkbe __
iha\Zlv ^hgZWevykZ
?]h a^_kvg_lkdZaZeZ hgZ
=^_ yfh]m _]hgZclb"
Hg \iheyo
=^_ \iheyo"
Y g_agZxIjboh^bl_ d\_q_jmHg [m^_l^hfZ hdheh
iylb
<u `_gZ^hgZ WevykZ"
>Zy _]h`_gZkdZaZeZ hgZb meu[gmeZkv
Y ihiulZeky jZkkijhkblv
__
h
kZdZl_d_gh hgZ
ba\bgbeZkv bkdZaZeZqlh iehohagZ_l bkiZgkdbcyaudY k_e
\ fZrbgmb m_oZe
<_jgmeky y hdheh r_klbqZkh\Y ih^t_oZed ^\_jb b
\udjbdgme bfy kZdZl_dbGZ wlhljZa hg\ur_e ba ^hfZY
\dexqbe k\hcfZ]gblhnhgdhlhjuc \dhjbqg_\hc dh`Zghckmfd_
k\bkZe k fh_]hie_qZdZd nhlhZiiZjZlDZaZehkvhg magZe
f_gy
Hwlh lukdZaZe hgmeu[ZykvdZd OmZg"
Hg a^hjh\: dZd\Zr_ a^hjh\v_^hg Wevyk"
Hg g_hl\_qZeDZaZehkvqlh hgg_j\gbqZ_l<g_rg_ hg
[ue hq_gvkh[jZggh yqm\kl\h\Zeqlh _fm[ueh g_ih k_[_
OmZg ijbkeZel_[y kx^Zk dZdbfgb[m^v ^_ehf"
G_ly kZfijb_oZe
Gh q_]h`_ jZ^b"
?]h
\hijhkdZaZehkv\u^Z\Ze
hq_gv
bkdj_gg__
m^b\e_gb_
Y ijhklh ohl_e ih]h\hjblvk \ZfbkdZaZe y
klZjZykvqlh[u \hijhka\mqZe lZd_kl_kl\_gghdZd lhevdh
fh`gh^hg OmZgjZkkdZau\Ze fg_h \Zkqm^_kgu_ \_sby
aZbgl_j_kh\Zeky baZohl_e aZ^Zlv\Zf g_kdhevdh\hijhkh\
KZdZl_dZ klhye i_j_^h fghc?]h l_eh [ueh lhsbf b
`bebklufHg ghkbejm[Zrdm b[jxdb p\_lZoZdb?]h ]eZaZ
[ueb ihemaZdjuluHg dZaZekykhgguf bebfh`_l [ulvivyguf
?]h jhl [ue ke_]dZijbhldjulb gb`gyy]m[Z hl\bkZeZY
aZf_lbeqlh
hg
]em[hdh
^urbl
bdZaZehkvihqlb
ihojZiu\Z_lFg_ ijbreZfukevqlh kZdZl_dZg_khfg_ggh \u`be
ba mfZGh wlZfukev dZaZeZkvhq_gv g_mf_klghcihlhfm qlh
ebrv g_kdhevdhfbgml gZaZ^dh]^Z hg\ur_e ba^hfZhg [ue
hq_gv Ze_jl_gb \iheg_hkhagZ\Ze fh_ijbkmlkl\b_
H q_flu ohq_rv]h\hjblv"kdZaZe hggZdhg_p
M g_]h [ue hq_gv mklZeuc]hehkDZaZehkvqlh hg
\u^Z\eb\Z_l ba k_[ykeh\Z h^ghaZ ^jm]bfY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y hq_gv g_eh\dhDZaZehkvqlh _]h mklZehklv [ueZ
aZjZaghc bho\Zlu\ZeZ f_gy
Gbq_]h hkh[_ggh]hhlq_lbe yy ijhklh ijb_oZe
ih[helZlv k\Zfb ih^jm`_kdb<u h^gZ`^uijb]eZrZeb f_gy d
k_[_ ^hfhc
>Zijb]eZrZegh k_cqZkwlh g_lh
Gh ihq_fm`_ g_lh"
JZa\_ lug_ ]h\hjbek OmZghf"
>Z]h\hjbe
Gh lh]^Zq_]h `_lu ohq_rvhl f_gy"
Y ^mfZeqlhfh`_ly kfh]maZ^Zlv \Zf g_kdhevdh
\hijhkh\
AZ^Zc boOmZgmJZa\_ hgg_ mqbll_[y"
Hg mqblgh \k_jZ\gh fg_ohl_ehkv [ukijhkblv \Zkh
lhfq_fm hgf_gy mqblb magZlv\Zr_ fg_gb_LZdbf h[jZahfy
[u agZeqlh fg_^_eZlv
Ihq_fm luohq_rv k^_eZlvwlh"Lu g_\_jbrv OmZgm"
Y \_jx
Lh]^Z ihq_fmlu g_ihijhkbrv _]hjZkkdZaZlv l_[_ h
lhfqlh luohq_rv magZlv"
Y lZdb ^_eZxB hgfg_ jZkkdZau\Z_lGh _keb\u lh`_
jZkkdZ`_l_ fg_h lhfq_fm hgf_gy mqbllhfh`_l [ulvy
emqr_ wlhihcfm
OmZg fh`_ljZkkdZaZlv l_[_h[h \k_fLhevdh hgfh`_l
k^_eZlv wlhJZa\_ luwlh]h g_ihgbfZ_rv"
IhgbfZxGh y lZd`_ ohqm ih]h\hjblv k ex^vfb
ih^h[gufb \Zf^hg WevykG_ dZ`^uc^_gv \klj_qZ_rvky k
q_eh\_dhf agZgby
OmZg q_eh\_d agZgby
Y agZxwlh
Lh]^Z ihq_fmlu ]h\hjbrvkh fghc"
Y kdZaZeqlh yijb_oZeqlh[ fu[ueb ^jmavyfb
G_llu g_^ey wlh]hijb_oZeGZ wlhljZa \l_[_ _klv
qlhlh ^jm]h_
Y ohl_eh[tykgblvgh \k_qlh ykfh] k^_eZlvlZd wlh
g_jZa[hjqb\h [hjfhlZlvKZdZl_dZ fheqZeDZaZehkvhg
\gbfZl_evgh kemrZe?]h ]eZaZ[ueb \gh\vihemaZdjuluGh y
qm\kl\h\Zeqlh hgkfhljbl gZf_gyHg _^\Zmeh\bfh db\gme
AZl_f _]h \_db jZkdjuebkv b y m\b^_e _]h ]eZaZHg
dZaZehkvkfhlj_e fbfhf_gyHg [_kkhagZl_evghihlhilu\Ze ih
ihem ghkdhfijZ\hc gh]bdZd jZaihaZ^b e_\hciyldb?]h gh]b
[ueb ke_]dZ kh]gmlujmdb [_a`bag_ggh\bk_eb \^hev l_eZ
AZl_f hg ih^gye ijZ\mxjmdm_]h eZ^hgv [ueZ hldjulZ b
i_ji_g^bdmeyjgZ a_fe_iZevpu [uebjZkklZ\e_gu b mdZau\Zeb
gZ f_gyHg iha\hebek\h_c jmd_iZjm jZadheuogmlvky ij_`^_
q_f \u\_e __gZ mjh\_gvfh_]h ebpZ< lZdhf iheh`_gbb hg
^_j`Ze __k k_dmg^mZ aZl_fkdZaZe fg_g_kdhevdh keh\?]h
]hehk [uehq_gv ykgufb \k_`_ ykeh\ g_jZah[jZe
Q_j_a k_dmg^m hg mjhgbejmdm \^hev l_eZ b hklZeky
g_ih^\b`_gijbgy\ kljZggmx ihamHg klhyehibjZykv gZ
sbdhehldm e_\hc gh]b?]h ijZ\Zygh]Z h]b[ZeZiyldm e_\hc
gh]bb __ghkhd fy]dhb jblfbqghihlhiu\Ze ihihem
F_gy ho\Zlbeh g_h`b^Zggh_ hsms_gb_
k\h_]h jh^Z
[_kihdhckl\hFhb fukebdZaZehkv[ueb g_k\yagufbY ^mfZe
h g_hlghkysboky d ^_em[_kkfuke_gguo \_sZog_ bf_xsbo
gbdZdh]h hlghr_gby
d
ijhbkoh^ys_fmY
aZf_lbe k\h_
g_m^h[kl\h b ihiulZeky \uijZ\blv
fukeb\_jgm\ bo d
j_Zevghklbgh g_fh] wlh]hk^_eZlvg_kfhljy gZ h]jhfgu_
mkbebyDZaZehkvqlh dZdZylh kbeZf_rZeZ fg_dhgp_gljbjh
\Zlv fukebb ^mfZlvk\yagh
KZdZl_dZ g_ kdZaZe gbkeh\Zb yg_ agZeqlh _s_
kdZaZlv bebk^_eZlvKh\_jr_ggh Z\lhfZlbq_kdbih\_jgmeky b
mr_e
Iha^g__ yihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[yh[yaZgguf jZkkdZaZlv ^hgm
OmZgm hfh_c \klj_q_k kZdZl_dhc>hg OmZgjZkohohlZeky
Qlh `_\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklblh]^Z ijhbahreh"kijhkbe
y
KZdZl_dZ lZgp_\ZekdZaZe hghg
m\ b^ _e
l_[yZ aZl_fhg lZgp_\Ze
Qlh hgk^_eZe khfghc"Y qm\kl\h\Zeoheh^ b^jh`v
Hq_\b^ghlu _fmg_ ihgjZ\bekyb hghklZgh\be l_[y
[jhkb\ gZl_[y keh\h
DZdbf h[jZahfhg kfh]wlh k^_eZlv"\hkdebdgme y
g_^h\_jqb\h
Hq_gv ijhklhHg hklZgh\bel_[y k\h_c\he_c
Qlh lukdZaZe"
Hg hklZgh\bel_[y k\h_c\he_c
H[tykg_gb_ [ueh g_m^h\e_l\hjbl_evguf?]h aZdexq_gb_
a\mqZeh ^eyf_gy [_eb[_j^hcY ihiulZeky_s_ ihjZkkijZrb\Zlv
_]hgh hgg_ kfh]h[tykgblv wlhlkemqZc lZdqlh[u y [ue
m^h\e_l\hj_g
Hq_\b^ghqlh wlhlkemqZcdZd bex[hc kemqZc\ wlhc
qm`^hc kbkl_f_qm\kl\_gguo bgl_jij_lZpbcfh`_l [ulvh[tykg_g
beb ihgyllhevdh \l_jfbgZo _^bgbpagZq_gbyhlghkysboky d
wlhc kbkl_f_LZdbf h[jZahfwlZ dgb]Zy\ey_lky j_ihjlZ`_f
b __ ke_^m_l qblZlvdZd j_ihjlZ`Kbkl_fZdhlhjmx y
aZibku\Ze[ueZ ^ey f_gy g_\hkijb_fe_fZlZdbf h[jZahf
ij_l_gaby gZ qlheb[h bgh_djhf_ j_ihjlZ`Z[ueZ [u
h[fZgqb\Z bg_khklhyl_evgZ< wlhfhlghr_gbb yijb^_j`b\Zeky
n_ghf_gheh]bq_kdh]h f_lh^Z bklZjZeky h[jZsZlvky \ k\hbo
aZibkyo k fZ]b_c lhevdh dZdk y\e_gbyfbk dhlhjufb y
klhedgmekyYdZd \hkijbgbfZxsbcaZibkZe lhqlh y
\hkijbgbfZeb \fhf_gl aZibku\Zgbyy klZjZekym^_j`b\Zlvky
hl km`^_gbc
Q:KLV I?J<:YIj_^^\_jb_ d\b^_gvx =eZ\Z
i_ j\ Zy
Zij_ey ]
>hg OmZggZ k_dmg^m\a]eygme bdZaZehkvkh\k_f g_[ue
m^b\e_g l_fqlh m\b^_ef_gyg_kfhljy gZlhqlh ijhrehm`_
[he__ ^\mo e_lk l_oihjdZd yihke_^gbc jZa ijb_a`Ze d
g_fmHg iheh`bejmdm fg_gZ ie_qhmeu[gmeky bkdZaZeqlh
y baf_gbekyb \u]ey`mlhekluf bfy]dbf
Y ijb\_awda_fieyj k\h_cdgb]b;_ah \kydbo\klmie_gbc
y \ugme__ baihjln_ey b\jmqbe _fm
Wlh dgb]Zh l_[_^hg OmZgkdZaZe y
Hg \aye__ bijh\_e jmdhcih kljZgbpZfdZd _keb[u wlh
[ueZ dheh^ZdZjl?fm ihgjZ\bekya_e_guc hll_ghdi_j_ie_lZ b
\ukhlZ dgb]bHg hsmiZei_j_ie_l eZ^hgyfbiZjm jZaih\_jgme
_]h baZl_f \jmqbefg_ dgb]mh[jZlghY qm\kl\h\Ze [hevrhc
ijbeb\ ]hj^hklb
Y ohqmqlh[u luhklZ\be __k_[_kdZaZe y
Hg ihljyk]heh\hc \[_aa\mqghf kf_o_
Y emqr_ g_ [m^mkdZaZe hgb aZl_f ^h[Z\be k
rbjhdhc meu[dhclu agZ_rvqlh fu^_eZ_f k [mfZ]hc \
F_dkbd_
Y jZkkf_yekyFg_ ihdZaZeZkvij_djZkghc _]h e_]dZy
bjhgby
Fu kb^_eb gZ kdZf_cd_iZjdZ \ g_[hevrhf ]hjh^d_ \
]hjghf jZchg_p_gljZevghc F_dkbdbM f_gyg_ [uehZ[khexlgh
gbdZdhc \hafh`ghklb^Zlv _fmagZlv hfh_f gZf_j_gvbihk_lblv
_]hgh y [uem\_j_gqlh gZc^m_]hb ygZr_eY hq_gv
g_^he]h ijh`^Ze\ wlhf]hjh^_ ij_`^_q_f ^hgOmZg ijb[uek
]hjb y gZr_e _]hgZ [ZaZj_m ijbeZ\dZ h^gh]h ba _]h
^jma_c
>hg OmZgkdZaZe fg_dZd kZfhkh[hc jZamf_xs__kyqlh y
lml dZdjZa \h\j_fyqlh[u ^hklZ\blv_]h h[jZlgh\ khghjm
b fu mk_ebkv
\
iZjd_qlh[u
ih^h`^Zlv _]h ^jm]Z
fZkZl_dkdh]h bg^_cpZm dhlhjh]hhg `be
Fu `^Zeb hdheh lj_o qZkh\Fu ]h\hjbeb h jZaguo
g_\Z`guo \_sZob ddhgpm ^gydZd jZai_j_^ l_fdZd ijbr_e
_]h ^jm]y jZkkdZaZe_fm hg_kdhevdbo kemqZyok\b^_l_e_f
dhlhjuo y[ue g_kdhevdh^g_c gZaZ^
<h \j_fy fh_c ih_a^db mf_gy kehfZeZkv fZrbgZ gZ
hdjZbg_ ]hjh^Zb \l_q_gb_ lj_o^g_c fg_ijbrehkv hklZ\Zlvky
\ g_fihdZ ^ebekyj_fhglGZijhlb\ Z\lhfZkl_jkdhc [ue
fhl_evgh ijb]hjh^\k_]^Z ^_ckl\h\ZegZ f_gy m^jmqZxs_
ihwlhfm y hklZgh\beky\ \hkvfbwlZ`ghc]hklbgbp_ \ p_glj_
]hjh^Z
FZevqbddmjv_j kdZaZefg_qlh \hl_e_ _klv j_klhjZg
bdh]^Z y kimklbekylm^Z ih_klvy h[gZjm`beqlh lZf
bf_xlky klhebdb kgZjm`b gZmebp_Hgb ^h\hevgh djZkb\h
jZkiheZ]Zebkv gZ m]em mebpuih^ gbadhc dbjibqghc Zjdhc
kh\j_f_gguo ebgbcKgZjm`b [ueh
ijhoeZ^gh b lZf [ueb
k\h[h^gu_ klhebdbh^gZdh y ij_^ihq_e kb^_lv \ ^mrghf
ihf_s_gbb<oh^y yaZf_lbeqlh gZ[j_\g_ i_j_^ j_klhjZghf
kb^bl ]jmiiZfZevqbr_d qbklbevsbdh\ h[m\bb y[ue m\_j_g
qlh hgb klZgmlij_ke_^h\Zlv f_gy_keb yky^m aZ h^bg ba
gZjm`guo klhebdh\
K lh]hf_klZ]^_ ykb^_efg_ [ueZ\b^gZ q_j_akl_deh
wlZ ]jmiiZ fZevqbr_dIZjZ fheh^uoex^_c aZgyeZ klhebd b
fZevqbrdb hdjm`beb boijhky ihqbklblvbo h[m\vFheh^u_
ex^b hldZaZebkvb y[ue m^b\e_gm\b^_\qlh fZevqbrdb g_
klZeb gZklZb\ZlvZ \_jgmebkvb k_ebgZ k\h_f_klhQ_j_a
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fyljh_ fm`qbg\ ^_eh\uodhklxfZo ih^gyebkv b
\urebb fZevqbrdbih^[_`Z\ dbo klhebdmgZqZeb _klv
hklZldb ibsbQ_j_a g_kdhevdhk_dmg^ lZj_edb[ueb qbklufb
Lh `_ kZfh_ ih\lhjbehkv kh[t_^dZfb gZ \k_o hklZevguo
klheZo
Y aZf_lbeqlh ^_lb[ueb \_kvfZZddmjZlgu_keb hgb
ijheb\Zeb \h^mlh hgbijhfhdZeb __ k\hbfb kh[kl\_ggufb
neZg_evdZfb ^eyqbkldb h[m\bY lZd`_hlf_lbe lhlZevghklv
bo m[hjdb kt_klgh]hHgb
kt_^Zeb
^Z`_ dm[bdb ev^Z
hklZ\rb_ky \klZdZgZoebfhggu_ ^hevdbba qZydh`mjm bli
G_ [uehkh\_jr_ggh gbq_]hqlh [uhgb hklZ\eyeb
AZ lh\j_fyqlh y[ue \hl_e_y h[gZjm`beqlh f_`^m
^_lvfb b ohaybghfj_klhjZgZ kms_kl\m_l kh]eZr_gb_^_lyf
[ueh iha\he_gh hdheZqb\Zlvky m aZ\_^_gby k l_fqlh[u
aZjZ[hlZlv g_fgh]h ^_g_] mihk_lbl_e_cZ lZd`_ ^h_^Zlv
hklZldb ibsbgZ klhebdZok l_fmkeh\b_fqlh hgbgbdh]h g_
jZkk_j^yl bgbq_]h g_jZah[vxlBo [uehh^bggZ^pZlv q_eh\_d
\ \hajZkl_hl iylb^h ^\_gZ^pZlbe_lh^gZdh kZfuc klZjrbc
^_j`Zeky hkh[gydhf hl hklZevghc
]jmiiuHgb gZf_j_ggh
hllZedb\Zeb _]h^jZagy _]hqZklmrdhcqlh m g_]h _klv
eh[dh\u_ \hehku bhg kebrdhfklZjqlh[u gZoh^blvky kj_^b
gbo
Ihke_ lj_o ^g_c gZ[ex^_gbyaZ l_fdZd hgb ih^h[gh
kl_j\ylgbdZf [jhkZebkvgZ kZfu_g_ijb\e_dZl_evgu_ h[t_^dby
bkdj_gg_ jZkkljhbeky bihdbgme ]hjh^k qm\kl\hfqlh g_l
gbdZdhc gZ^_`^u^ey wlbo^_l_cq_c fbj[ue m`_jZa^Z\e_g bo
dZ`^h^g_\ghc [hjv[hcbaaZ dmkdZibsb
Lu bo `Ze__rv"\hkdebdgme ^hg OmZg \hijhrZxsbf
lhghf
Dhg_qgh`Ze_xkdZaZe y
Ihq_fm"
Ihlhfm qlhy haZ[hq_g[eZ]hkhklhygb_f hdjm`Zxsbof_gy
ex^_cWlb fZevqbdb^_lbZ bofbj lZdg_djZkb\ bf_ehd
Ih^h`^bIh^h`^bDZd lufh`_rv ]h\hjblvqlh bofbj
g _d jZ kb \
b
f_ eh d"kdZaZe ^hg OmZg
i_j_^jZagb\Zy fh_ \ujZ`_gb_Lu ^mfZ_rvqlh l\hc fbj
emqr_g_ lZdeb"
Y kdZaZeqlh lZdb ^mfZxb hgkijhkbe f_gyihq_fmB
y kdZaZe _fmqlh ihkjZ\g_gbx kfbjhf wlbo^_l_c fhc fbj
[_kdhg_qgh [he__ jZaghh[jZa_g b
[h]Zl jZa\e_q_gbyfb b
\hafh`ghklyfb ^ey ebqgh]hm^h\e_l\hj_gby bjZa\blbyKf_o
^hgZ OmZgZ [ue bkdj_ggbfb ^jm`_kdbfHg kdZaZeqlh y
g_hklhjh`_g kl_fqlh y]h\hjxqlh mf_gy g_l\hafh`ghklb
baf_jblv [h]Zlkl\hb \hafh`ghklbfbjZ wlbo^_l_c
Y ih^mfZeqlh OmZgijhklh mijyfblkyY ^_ckl\bl_evgh
^mfZeqlh hgklZgh\blky gZijhlb\hiheh`gmx lhqdm aj_gby
ijhklh ^ey lh]hqlh[u jZa^jZ`Zlvf_gyY bkdj_gg_ \_jbe
qlh m wlbo^_l_c g_lgb fZe_cr_]hrZgkZ ^ey bgl_ee_dlmZ
evgh]h jhklZ
Y _s_ g_dhlhjh_\j_fy hlklZb\Zek\hx lhqdmaj_gbyZ
aZl_f ^hgOmZg kihdhcghkijhkbe f_gy
JZa\_ lug_ ]h\hjbefg_ h^gZ`^uqlh ihl\h_fm fg_gbx
\_ebqZcrbf ^hklb`_gb_f ^eyq_eh\_dZ [m^_lklZlv q_eh\_dhf
agZgby"
Y ]h\hjbe lZdb ih\lhjbe\gh\vqlhihfh_fmklZlv
q_eh\_dhf agZgbywlh h^ghba \_ebqZcrbo bgl_ee_dlmZevguo
^hklb`_gbc
LZd lu ^mfZ_rvqlh
l\hc
hq_gv [h]Zluc fbj
dh]^Zgb[m^v ihfh`_ll_[_ klZlvq_eh\_dhf agZgby"kijhkbe
^hg OmZgk e_]dbfkZjdZafhf
Y g_ hl\_lbeb lh]^Zhg aZ^Zelhl `_\hijhk ^jm]bfb
keh\Zfb h[hjhldhlhjuc y\k_]^Z ijbf_gyed g_fmdh]^Z
kqblZeqlh hgg_ ihgbfZ_l
>jm]bfb keh\ZfbkdZaZe hgrbjhdh meu[Zykv b
hq_\b^gh \b^yqlh yhkhagZx _]hb]jmfh]ml eb l\hy
k\h[h^Z b l\hb \hafh`ghklbihfhqv l_[_ klZlv q_eh\_dhf
agZgby"
G_lkdZaZe yk m^Zj_gb_f
Lh]^Z dZd`_ lufh`_rv qm\kl\h\Zlv`Zehklv d wlbf
^_lyf"kijhkbe hgk_jv_aghex[hc bagbo fh`_l klZlv
q_eh\_dhf agZgby<k_ ex^bagZgbydhlhjuo y agZx[ueb
^_lvfbih^h[gufb l_fdhlhjuo
lu \b^_eih^t_^Zxsbfb
h[t_^db b\uebau\Zxsbfb klhebdb
:j]mf_gl ^hgZOmZgZ ^Zefg_ g_ijbylgh_hsms_gb_Y g_
qm\kl\h\Ze `Zehklb d wlbfh[^_e_gguf ijb\_e_]byfb ^_lyf
hllh]hqlh bfg_ o\ZlZ_libsbgh `Ze_ebo aZlhqlh ih
fhbf jZkq_lZf fbj m`_ijb]h\hjbe bo d bgl_ee_dlmZevghc
g_Z^_d\ZlghklbBh^gZdh `_ih jZkq_lZf^hgZ OmZgZdZ`^uc
ba gbofh] ^hklbqvlh]hqlh ykqblZe \_jrbghcq_eh\_q_kdbo
bgl_ee_dlmZevguo ^hklb`_gbc klZlv q_eh\_dhfagZgbyFhb
ijbqbgu dlhfmqlh[u `Ze_lvbo[ueb g_h[hkgh\Zgu>hg OmZg
lhqgh ih^^_ef_gy
Fh`_l [ulvlu bijZ\kdZaZe ygh dZd fh`gh
ba[_`Zlv `_eZgbybkdj_gg_]h `_eZgbyihfhqv hdjm`Zxsbfl_[y
ex^yf"
DZd `_lu ^mfZ_rvbf fh`ghihfhqv"
H[e_]qZy boghrmKZfh_ fZe_gvdh_qlh fh`ghk^_eZlv
^ey hdjm`ZxsbogZk ex^_clZd wlhihiulZlvky baf_gblvboLu
\_^v bkZf aZgbfZ_rvkywlbfJZa\_ g_lZd"
G_lWlh]h yg_ ^_eZxY g_agZxqlh f_gylvb aZq_f
f_gylv qlheb[h \hdjm`Zxsbo f_gyex^yo
: dZdgZkq_l f_gy^hg OmZg"JZa\_ lug_ mqbe f_gy
^ey lh]hqlh[u ybaf_gbeky"
G_lY g_iulZxkv baf_gblvl_[yFh`_l kemqblvkyqlh
h^gZ`^u lu klZg_rvq_eh\_dhf agZgbywlh]h gbdZd g_evay
magZlv gh wlhg_ baf_gbll_[yDh]^Zgb[m^v lu\hafh`gh
kfh`_rv
m\ b^ _l v
ex^_c\ ^jm]hfieZg_b lh]^Z lu
ihcf_rvqlh g_lkihkh[Z baf_gblvqlheb[h \gbo
Qlh wlhaZ ^jm]hcieZg \b^_gvyex^_c^hg OmZg"
Ex^b \u]ey^ylih^jm]hfm_keb bo
\b ^b rv FZe_gvdbc ^ufhd ihfh`_ll_[_ m\ b^ _l v
ex^_cdZd
gblb k\_lZ
Gblb k\_lZ"
>ZgblbdZd lhgdZyiZmlbgZHq_gv lhgdb_ \hehdgZ
dhlhju_ pbjdmebjmxl hl ]heh\u d imidmLZdbf h[jZahf
q_eh\_d \u]ey^bldZd ycphba pbjdmebjmxsbo\hehdhg: _]h
jmdb bgh]b ih^h[guk\_lysbfky ijhlm[_jZgpZf\uju\Zxsbfky \
jZagu_ klhjhgu
B lZd\u]ey^bl dZ`^uc"
DZ`^ucDjhf_ lh]hq_eh\_d gZoh^blky\ dhglZdl_ kh
\k_f hklZevgufg_ q_j_ajmdbijZ\^ZZ q_j_aimqhd ^ebgguo
\hehdhg\uju\Zxsboky ba p_gljZ_]h `b\hlZWlb \hehdgZ
ijbkh_^bgyxl q_eh\_dZ dh\k_fm hdjm`Zxs_fmhgb khojZgyxl
_]h jZ\gh\_kb_hgb ijb^Zxl_fm mklhcqb\hklvIhwlhfmdZd
lu kfh`_rv
m\ b^ _l v
dh]^Zgb[m^vq_eh\_d wlh
k\_lys__ky ycph[m^v hggbsbf bebdhjhe_fb g_l kihkh[Z
baf_gblv qlheb[hbeb\_jg__qlh fh`gh baf_gblv \
k\_lys_fky ycp_Z"
=eZ\Z
Fg_
\l hj Zy
Fh_ ihk_s_gb_^hgZ OmZgZiheh`beh gZqZehgh\hfm pbdem
g_ ihlj_[h\ZehkvgbdZdbo mkbebc^ey lh]hqlh[u \gh\v
ihiZklv \ klZjh_
jmkeh
m^h\hevkl\by
hl _]h qm\kl\Z
^jZfZlbafZ_]h xfhjZ bl_ji_gby khfghcY hij_^_e_ggh
qm\kl\h\Zeqlh fg_ gm`ghihk_sZlv _]h [he__ qZklhG_
\b^_lv ^hgZ OmZgZ[ueh ^_ckl\bl_evgh[hevrhc `_jl\hc ^ey
f_gydjhf_ lh]hm f_gy[ueh dh_qlhij_^klZ\eyxs__ ^ey
f_gy hij_^_e_ggucbgl_j_kqlh yohl_e kgbf h[km^blv
Ihke_ lh]hdZd yaZdhgqbe dgb]mh _]hmq_gbby gZqZe
i_j_[bjZlv l_k\hb ihe_\u_aZibkbdhlhju_ yg_ bkihevah\Ze
\ dgb]_Y \uimklbeba dgb]bhq_gv fgh]h^Zgguoihlhfm qlh
fh_ \gbfZgb_ [ueh
gZijZ\e_gh
gZ
khklhygby g_h[uqghc
j_ZevghklbIjhkfZljb\Zy k\hbklZju_ aZibkdby ijbr_e d
aZdexq_gbxqlh mf_eucfZ] fh`_lkha^Zlv kZfuc ki_pbZebab
jh\Zgguc Zj_Ze
\hkijbylby
\
k\h_f
mq_gbd_ijhklh
fZgbimebjmy h[s_kl\_ggufb dexqZfb<k_ fh_ ihkljh_gb_
dZkZxs__ky
ijbjh^u
wlbo
fZgbimeypbhgguo
ijhp_^mj
hkgh\u\Zehkv gZij_^iheh`_gbbqlh ^eylh]hqlh[u kha^Zlv
g_h[oh^bfuc Zj_Ze
\hkijbylbyg_h[oh^bf
\_^msbcDZd
dhgdj_lguc l_kl y\aye kemqZci_chlguo kh[jZgbc fZ]h\Y
kh]eZrZeky k l_fqlh gZwlbo kh[jZgbyofZ]b ijboh^beb d
kh]eZr_gbx hlghkbl_evghijbjh^u j_Zevghklb[_a dZdh]heb[h
h[f_gZ keh\Zfbbeb agZdZbb ihwlhfmy ijbr_ed aZdexq_gbx
qlh lml bkihevah\Zekyhq_gv fm^j_gucdh^ ^ey lh]hqlh[u
mqZklgbdb ijbrebd lZdhfmkh]eZr_gbxY jZajZ[hlZe keh`gmx
kbkl_fm ^ey lh]hqlh[u h[tykgblvwlb dh^ub ijhp_^mjub
ihwlhfm y \_jgmekyqlh[u gZ\_klblv^hgZ OmZgZb kijhkblv
_]h ebqgh_fg_gb_ bkh\_l hlghkbl_evghfh_c jZ[hlu
fZy ]
Gbq_]h g_h[uqgh]h
g_
ijhbahreh
\h
\j_fy fh_]h
iml_r_kl\by d ^hgmOmZgmL_fi_jZlmjZ \imklug_ ij_\urZeZ
b [ueZ hq_gv mlhfbl_evgZIhke_ h[_^Z `ZjZ klZeZ
kiZ^Zlvbdh]^Z y\ gZqZe_\_q_jZ ih^t_oZed ^hfm ^hgZ
OmZgZih^me ijhoeZ^guc\_l_jhdY g_hq_gv mklZeihwlhfm
fu kb^_eb \ _]hdhfgZl_ bjZa]h\Zjb\ZebWlh [ue g_ lhl
jZa]h\hjdhlhjuc fg_ohl_ehkv [uaZibku\ZlvnZdlbq_kdby
g_ iulZeky \deZ^u\Zlv \ k\hb keh\Z [hevrhc kfuke beb
agZq_gb_Fu ]h\hjbebh ih]h^_mjh`Z__]h \gmd_bg^_cpZo
ydbf_dkbdZgkdhf ijZ\bl_evkl\_Y kdZaZe^hgm OmZgmdZd
kbevgh fg_gjZ\blky lhhkh[h_ hsms_gb_dhlhjh_ ihemqZ_rv
dh]^Z jZa]h\Zjb\Z_rv\ l_fghl_
Hg kdZaZeqlh wlhfh_ m^h\hevkl\b_hkgh\Zgh gZ fh_c
[heleb\hc gZlmj_qlh fg_e_]dh ex[blv[helh\gx \ l_fghl_
ihlhfm qlh[helh\gy wlh _^bgkl\_ggh_qlh yfh]m ^_eZlv\
lZdh_ \j_fykb^y jy^hfk gbfY \hajZabeqlh wlh [hevr_
q_f ijhklhcZdl jZa]h\hjZlhqlh fg_gjZ\blkyY kdZaZe
qlh f_gygZkeZ`^Z_l m[Zxdb\Zxs__l_ieh l_fghlu\hdjm] gZk
Hg kijhkbef_gyqlh y^_eZx ^hfZdh]^Z klZgh\blkyl_fghY
hl\_lbeqlh \k_]^Z\dexqZx k\_lbeb \uoh`mgZ hk\_s_ggu_
mebpu ^hl_o ihjihdZ g_ijb^_l \j_fykiZlv
HkdZaZe hgk g_^h\_jb_fy ^mfZeqlh lu
gZmqbeky bkihevah\Zlvl_fghlm
>ey q_]h__ fh`ghbkihevah\Zlv"kijhkbe y
Hg kdZaZeqlh l_fghlZhg gZa\Ze__ l_fghlZ ^gy
wlh emqr__ \j_fy ^ey
lh]hqlh[u
\b ^_ lv Hg
ih^q_jdgme keh\h
\ b^ _l vhkh[hc bglhgZpb_cY
aZohl_e magZlvqlh hgohq_l wlbfkdZaZlvGh hg hl\_lbe
qlh m`_kebrdhf iha^ghqlh[u \^Z\Zlvky\ wlhl\hijhk
fZy ]
DZd lhevdhy mljhfijhkgmekyy [_ah\kydbo \klmie_gbc
jZkkdZaZe
^hgm
OmZgmqlh
kdhgkljmbjh\Ze
kbkl_fm
h[tykgyxsmx lhqlh bf__lf_klh gZ i_chlghf kh[jZgbb fblhl_Y \ayek\hb aZibkbb ijhq_e_fm lhqlh jZajZ[hlZe
Hg l_ji_eb\hkemrZeihdZ yklZjZeky jZatykgblvk\hx ko_fm
Y kqblZeqlh g_h[oh^bflZcguc ^bjb`_j^ey lh]hqlh[u
lZdbf h[jZahf gZkljhblv\k_o mqZklgbdh\qlh hgbijb^ml d
ex[hfm aZ^Zgghfmkh]eZr_gbxY mdZaZeqlh ex^bijbkmlkl\mxl
gZ fblhl_ ^ey lh]hqlh[u gZclbf_kdZeblh b _]h mjhdb
hlghkbl_evgh ijZ\bevgh]hh[jZaZ `bagbIjb wlhf\k_ wlbex^b
g_ h[f_gb\Zxlkyf_`^m kh[hcgb _^bgufkeh\hf beb`_klhfb
\k_ `_ hgbgZoh^ylky \kh]eZkbb hlghkbl_evgh ijbkmlkl\by
f_kdZeblh b_]h ki_pbnbq_kdh]hmjhdZIh djZcg_cf_j_ bf_ggh
lZd [ueh gZ lhffblhl_gZ dhlhjhfy ijbkmlkl\h\Ze\k_
kh]eZkbebkvqlh f_kdZeblh ihy\bekyi_j_^ gbfbb ^Ze bf
mjhd< k\h_febqghf hiul_y gZr_eqlh lZnhjfZdhlhjmx
ijbgbfZ_l bg^b\b^mZevgh_
ihy\e_gb_
f_kdZeblhb
_]h
ihke_^mxsbc mjhd
[ueb
ihjZabl_evgh
h^ghh[jZaguohly
\Zjvbjh\Zeb ihkh^_j`Zgbx hlq_eh\_dZ dq_eh\_dmY g_ fh]
bgZq_ h[tykgblv
lZdhc
]hfh]_gghklbdZd
ijbgy\
__
j_amevlZlhf kdjulhcb keh`ghcgZkljhcdb
M f_gy mreh ihqlb^\Z qZkZgZ lhqlh[u ijhq_klv b
h[tykgblv ^hgmOmZgm lmko_fmqlh ydhgkljmbjh\ZeDhgqbe y
l_fqlh ihijhkbe _]h
kdZaZlv k\hbfb keh\ZfbdZdh\Z
^_ckl\bl_evgh ijhp_^mjZ^ey ijb\_^_gbymqZklgbdh\ fblhlZ d
kh]eZr_gbx
Dh]^Z y aZdhgqbehg kdjb\bekyY ih^mfZeqlh hg
^he`gh [ulvkqblZ_l
fhb
h[tykg_gby \uau\Zxsbfbhg
dZaZehkv[ue
]em[hdh
ih]ehs_g
jZafure_gbyfbIhke_
[eZ]hijbklhcgh]h fheqZgby ykijhkbe _]hqlh hg ^mfZ_l h
fh_c b^__
Fhc \hijhk \g_aZighbaf_gbe _]h]jbfZkm gZmeu[dmZ
aZl_f gZ jZkdZlbklucohohlY lh`_ihiulZeky aZkf_ylvky b
g_j\gh kijhkbeqlh lmllZdh]h kf_rgh]h
Lu mr_e\ klhjhgm\hkdebdgme hgaZq_f dlhlh
[m^_l klZjZlvky dh]hlh gZkljZb\Zlv\ lZdh_\Z`gh_ \j_fy
dZd fblhl"Lu ^mfZ_rvqlh \k_]^Z^mjZqZl kf_kdZeblh"
GZ k_dmg^my ih^mfZeqlh hgmdehgqb\hgnZdlbq_kdb
g_ hl\_qZegZ fhc\hijhk
AZq_f dhfmeb[h gZkljZb\Zlv"kijhkbe mijyfh ^hg
OmZgLu [uegZ fblhlZoLu ^he`_gagZlvqlh gbdlh g_
h[tykgye l_[_dZd qm\kl\h\Zlvbeb qlh^_eZlvgbdlhdjhf_
kZfh]h f_kdZeblh
Y gZklZb\ZegZ lhfqlh lZdh_h[tykg_gb_ g_\hafh`ghb
\gh\v ihijhkbe_]h jZkkdZaZlvfg_dZdbf h[jZahf^hklb]Z_lky
kh]eZr_gb_
Y agZxaZq_f lu
ijb_oZekdZaZe ^hg OmZg
aZ]Z^hqguf lhghfy g_
fh]m
ihfhqv l_[_ \ l\h_f
aZljm^g_gbbihlhfm qlh g_
kms_kl\m_l gbdZdhc kbkl_fu
gZkljhcdb
Gh dZd `_ \k_wlb ex^b kh]eZrZxlky k l_fqlh
f_kdZeblh ijbkmlkl\m_l"
Hgb kh]eZrZxlkyihlhfmqlh \b ^y lkdZaZe
^hg OmZg^jZfZlbq_kdbIhq_fm [ul_[_ g_ihijbkmlkl\h\Zlv
_s_ gZh^ghf fblhl_b g_ m\ b^ _l v
kZfhfm"
Y ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh wlh[ueZ eh\mrdZY g_ kdZaZe
gbq_]h bhleh`be k\hbaZibkbHg g_gZklZb\Ze
G_dhlhjh_ \j_fykimkly hgihijhkbe f_gyhl\_alb _]h d
^hfm h^gh]hba _]h^jma_c;hevrmx qZklv^gy fuijh\_eb lZf
< oh^_ jZa]h\hjZ_]h ^jm]>`hg kijhkbef_gyqlh klZeh k
fhbf bgl_j_khfd i_chlmIhqlb \hk_fve_l gZaZ^>`hg ^Z\Ze
fg_ [Zlhgqbdbi_chlZ ijbfh_f i_j\hfhiul_>hg OmZgijbr_e
fg_ gZihfhsv bkdZaZeqlh y^_eZx mki_ob
Ih imlb gZaZ^ d^hfm ^hgOmZgZ y ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
h[yaZgguf k^_eZlvaZf_qZgb_ hlghkbl_evgh\hijhkZaZ^Zggh]h
>`hghfb ykdZaZe kj_^bijhq_]hqlh mf_gy g_l gZf_j_gvy
mqblvky q_fmeb[h ^Ze__h i_chl_ihlhfm qlh wlh lj_[m_l
fm`_kl\Z lZdh]hkhjlZdhlhjh]h mf_gy g_lb qlhykdZaZ\
h k\h_f j_r_gbbdhgqblv mq_gb_^_ckl\bl_evgh wlh bf_e \
\b^m>hg OmZgmeu[gmeky bgbq_]h g_kdZaZeY ijh^he`Ze
]h\hjblvihdZ fug_ ih^t_oZebd ^hfm
Fu k_ebgZ qbklh_f_klh i_j_^^\_jvx;ue l_ieucykguc
^_gvgh \_q_jhf [ue^hklZlhqgh hsmlbfuc \_l_jhdqlh[u
qm\kl\h\Zlv k_[yijbylgh
Ihq_fm l_[_gZ^h lZdmk_j^gh gZklZb\ZlvgZ wlhf"
\g_aZigh kdZaZe^hg OmZgkdhevdh e_llu m`_]h\hjbrvqlh
g_ ohq_rv[hevr_ mqblvky"
Ljb
Ihq_fm lulZd [_kihdhbrvkygZkq_l wlh]h"
Y qm\kl\mxqlh ij_^Zxl_[y^hg OmZgGZ\_jgh
ihwlhfm y\k_ \j_fyh[ wlhf]h\hjx
Lu f_gyg_ ij_^Z_rv
Lu h[fZgmeky \hfg_Y m[_`ZeY qm\kl\mxqlh y
ih[_`^_g
Lu ^_eZ_rvlhqlh fh`_rvDjhf_ lh]hlu _s_g_ [ue
ih[_`^_gLhq_fm fg_gZ^h l_[ymqblvhq_gv ljm^ghIh
djZcg_c f_j_y gZr_ewlhih`Zemc_s_ [he__ljm^gufq_f
lu
Gh lu^_j`Zeky aZwlh^hg OmZgFhc `_kemqZc bghc
Y k^Zekyb ijbr_el_[y gZ\_klblvg_ ihlhfmqlh y ohqm
mqblvkygh ebrv ihlhfmqlh
y ohl_e ihijhkblv l_[y
ijhykgblv g_dhlhju_fhf_glu \fh_c jZ[hl_
>hg OmZgk_dmg^m kfhlj_egZ f_gyZ aZl_fhl\_e \a]ey^
Lu ^he`_giha\heblv ^ufdmm\_klb l_[ykdZaZe hgk
gZ`bfhf
G_l^hg OmZgy g_fh]m [hevr_ bkihevah\Zlv l\hc
^ufhdY ^mfZxqlh y\u^hoky m`_
Lu _s_^Z`_ g_gZqZe
Y kebrdhf[hxkv
AgZqbllu [hbrvkyG_l gbq_]hgh\h]h \kljZo_G_
^mfZc h lhfqlh lu[hbrvky>mfZc h qm^_kZo
\b ^_
g vy Y bkdj_gg_ohl_e [u^mfZlv h[wlbo qm^_kZogh y g_
fh]mDh]^Z y^mfZx hl\h_f ^ufd_lh yqm\kl\mx k\h_]hjh^Z
lvfmgZieu\Zxsmx gZf_gyWlh dZd_keb [ugZ a_fe_g_ [ueh
[hevr_ ex^_cgbdh]hd dhfm[u ih\_jgmlvkyL\hc ^ufhd
ihdZaZe fg_[_a^hgghklv h^bghq_kl\Z^hg OmZg
Wlh g_\_jgh<havfbgZijbf_jf_gy>ufhd fhc
heebZ yg_ hsmsZxlZdh]h h^bghq_kl\Z
Gh lu^jm]hcLu ih[_^bek\hc kljZo
>hg OmZgg_`gh ihoehiZef_gy ihie_qm
Lu g_[hbrvkykdZaZe hgfy]dh?]h ]hehk g_k \
k_[_ kljZggh_h[\bg_gb_
JZa\_ ye]m hk\h_f kljZo_^hg OmZg"
Fg_ g_l^_eZ ^he`bkdZaZeZ hgj_adhfg_ _klv
^_eh ^h dh_q_]h bgh]hIjbqbgZ lh]hqlh lu g_ ohq_rv
mqblvkye_`bl g_\ lhfqlh lu[hbrvkyWlh qlhlh ^jm]h_
Y gZklhcqb\h ih^lZedb\Ze_]h kdZaZlvfg_qlh `_ wlh
lZdh_Y kihjbek gbfgh hggbq_]h g_kdZaZehg ijhklh
ljyk ]heh\hcdZd [ug_ \kbeZo ih\_jblvqlh yg_ agZxwlh
kZf
Y kdZaZe_fmqlhfh`_lwlh bg_jpbym^_j`b\Z_l f_gy
hl mq_gbyHg aZohl_emagZlv agZq_gb_ keh\Z bg_jpbyY
ijhq_e _fm \keh\Zj_l_g^_gpby fZl_jbbkhojZgylv ihdhc
_keb hgZ\ ihdh_beb_keb hgZ^\b`_lkykhojZgylv ^\b`_gb_
\ lhf`_ gZijZ\e_gbb_keb gZg__ g_^_ckl\m_l dZdZygb[m^v
ihklhjhggyy kbeZ
?keb gZg__ g_^_ckl\m_l dZdZygb[m^v ihklhjhggyy
kbeZih\lhjbe hgWlhih`Zemcemqrb_ keh\Zdhlhju_
lu gZr_eY m`_]h\hjbe l_[_qlh lhevdh ^ujy\uc ]hjrhd
fh`_l \aylv gZk_[y aZ^ZqmklZlv q_eh\_dhf agZgby k\hbfb
kh[kl\_ggufb kbeZfbQ_eh\_dZ klj_a\hc ]heh\hcgZ^h aZ\_klb
\ mq_gb_obljhklyfb ljxdZfb
Gh y m\_j_ggZreZkv [ufZkkZ ex^_cdhlhju_ k
jZ^hklvx \ayeZ[u gZk_[y lZdmxaZ^ZqmkdZaZe y
>Zgh \k_hgb g_\ kq_lHgb h[uqghm`_ klj_sbghc
Hgb ih^h[gu ]ebgyguf omfZf[hevrb_ dm\rbgu ^ey \h^u
dhlhju_ kgZjm`b\u]ey^yl p_eufbgh ihl_dml\ lm`_ fbgmlm
dZd lhevdhijbeh`blv dgbf ^Z\e_gb_dZd lhevdhgZihegblv bo
\h^hcFg_ h^gZ`^uijbrehkv \\_klbl_[y \mq_gb_ obljhklvx
l_f `_ kZfufkihkh[hfdZdbf fhc[_g_nZdlhj \\_e f_gy<
ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ lu g_ gZmqbeky[u b lhfmqlh agZ_rv
k_cqZkFh`_l [ulvijbreh \j_fy\gh\v ijbf_gblv d l_[_
obljhklv
Obljhklvh dhlhjhchg gZihfgbe[ueZ h^gbfba kZfuo
gZijy`_gguo wlZih\ fh_]h mq_gbq_kl\ZWlh ijhbahreh m`_
g_kdhevdh e_lgZaZ^gh \fh_f fha]m\k_ wlh_s_ klhev`b\h
dZd _keb [u kemqbehkvlhevdh qlhIml_f hq_gv bkdmkguo
fZgbimeypbc ^hgOmZg aZklZ\bef_gy h^gZ`^u\hclb \ijyfh_ b
m`Zkgh_ klhedgh\_gb_k `_gsbghcbf_\r_c j_imlZpbxdhe^mgvb
Klhedgh\_gb_ ijb\_ehd ]em[hdhc\jZ`^_[ghklb k__ klhjhgu
>hg OmZg ihevah\Zeky fhbf
kljZohf
wlhc `_gsbgudZd
fhlb\bjh\dhc ^eylh]hqlh[u ijh^he`Zlvmq_gb_ml\_j`^Zy
qlh y^he`_g mqblvky^Zevr_ fZ]bb^ey lh]hqlh[u aZsbsZlv
k_[y hl __ fZ]bq_kdbogZiZ^_gbcDhg_qguc j_amevlZl _]h
obljhklb[ue
klhev
m[_^bl_evgufqlh
y
bkdj_gg_
ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh g_ bf_xgbdZdh]h ^jm]h]h \uoh^ZdZd
lhevdh mqblvky \k_ [hevr_ b [hevr__keb lhevdh ohqm
hklZlvky \`b\uo
?keb luohq_rv im]Zlvf_gy hiylvwlhc `_gsbghclh y
ijhklh g_ijb_^m [hevr_kdZaZe y
Kf_o ^hgOmZgZ [uehq_gv \_k_euf
G_ ]hjxckdZaZe hgh[h^jyxs_Ljxdb kh kljZohf
[hevr_ g_ ijhc^mlk lh[hcLu [hevr_g_ [hbrvkyGh _keb
ihgZ^h[blkylh dl_[_ fh`ghijbf_gblv obljhklv]^_ m]h^gh
L_[_ ^Z`_g_ gZ^hijbkmlkl\h\Zlv ijbwlhf
Hg aZeh`be jmdbaZ ]heh\mb e_]kiZlvY jZ[hlZe gZ^
k\hbfb aZibkyfbihdZ hgg_ ijhkgmekyq_j_a iZjmqZkh\D
wlhfm \j_f_gb klZehihqlb l_fghAZf_lb\qlh yibkZehg
k_e ijyfhbmeu[Zykvkijhkbe f_gy\uibkZeky eby bak\h_c
ijh[e_fu
fZy ]
Fu jZa]h\Zjb\Zeb h[HZdkZd_Y jZkkdZaZe^hgm OmZgm
qlh h^gZ`^u yijb[ue \wlhl ]hjh^\ [ZaZjguc ^_gv^_gv
dh]^Z lheiubg^_cp_\ kh\k_c hdjm]bkl_dZxlky \]hjh^qlh[u
ijh^Z\Zlv ibsmb jZagh]hjh^Z f_ehqb
Y mihfygmeqlh
hkh[h
aZbgl_j_kh\Zeky q_eh\_dhf
ijh^Zxsbf e_dZjkl\_ggu_jZkl_gbyHg ghkbe^_j_\ygguc ehlhd
\ dhlhjhf [ue p_euc jy^ [Zghq_dfZe_gvdbok kmobfb
lheq_gufb jZkl_gbyfbhg klhyeihkj_^b mebpu^_j`Z h^gm
[Zghqdm b\udjbdb\Zy hq_gvaZ[Z\gmx i_k_gdm
KhklZ\ ijhlb\fmodhfZjh\ bde_s_c
KhklZ\u ^eydhadhjh\ehrZ^_c bk\bg_c
E_dZjkl\Z hl\k_o [he_ag_cex^_c
Bkp_eyxl dZr_evijhklj_ej_\fZlbaf bm]jb
?klv e_dZjkl\Z^ey i_q_gbk_j^pZ`_em^dZ]jm^b
Ih^oh^bl_ [eb`_e_^b b^`_gl_evf_gu
KhklZ\ ijhlb\fmo[ehodhfZjh\ bde_s_c
Y ^he]h_ \j_fy kemrZe_]h?]h j_deZfZ khklhyeZ ba
^ebggh]h i_j_qgyq_eh\_q_kdbo [he_ag_cijhlb\ dhlhjuodZd
hg ml\_j`^Zem g_]h_klv p_e_[gu_kj_^kl\Z^ey lh]hqlh[u
ijb^Zlv jblf
k\h_c
i_k_gd_hg
^_eZe
iZmam ihke_
i_j_qbke_gby dZ`^uoq_luj_o [he_ag_c
>hg OmZg lh`_
ijh^Z\Ze
e_dZjkl\_ggu_ jZkl_gby \
HZdkZd_dh]^Z [uefheh^ufHg kdZaZeqlh _s_ihfgbl k\hx
j_deZfgmx i_k_gdmb ijhdjbqZe__ fg_Hg kdZaZeqlh kh
k\hbf ^jm]hf<bk_glhf hgbh[uqgh khklZ\eyeb^mwlu
Y jZkkdZaZe ^hgmOmZgmqlh \h\j_fy h^ghc ba k\hbo
ih_a^hd ihF_dkbd_y \klj_lbe_]h ^jm]Z<bk_glZ>hg OmZg
dZaZehkv[ue m^b\e_gb aZohl_emagZlv h[wlhf ih[hevr_
Y _oZeq_j_a ^mjZg]h\ lhljZa b\kihfgbeqlh ^hgOmZg
jZkkdZau\Ze fg_ h^gZ`^uqlh dh]^Zgb[m^v fg_ gZ^h [m^_l
ih\b^Zlv _]h ^jm]Zdhlhjuc `be\ wlhf]hjh^d_Y ihbkdZe
_]h bgZr_e bg_dhlhjh_ \j_fyk gbfjZa]h\Zjb\ZeI_j_^ fhbf
hlt_a^hf hg^Ze fg_k_ldm kg_kdhevdbfb jZkl_gbyfbb k_jbx
gZklZ\e_gbc hlghkbl_evghlh]hdZd ihkZ^blvbo
Ih imlb\ ]hjh^Z]mZk dZev_gl_ky hklZgh\befZrbgmY
m[_^bekyqlh \hdjm]gbdh]h g_lIh djZcg_cf_j_ \ l_q_gb_
fbgml yke_^be aZ^hjh]hc bhdjm`ghklvx< \b^mg_ [ueh
gb h^gh]h^hfZ bgbdZdh]h kdhlZiZkms_]hky \[ebab^hjh]bY
hklZgh\beky gZ \_jrbg_ g_[hevrh]h ohefZhlkx^Z y fh]
gZ[ex^Zlv \kx ^hjh]m \i_j_^b b ihaZ^b f_gyHgZ [ueZ
imkluggZ \h[hbo gZijZ\e_gbyogZklhevdhgZkdhevdh yfh] __
\b^_lv
Y ih^h`^Ze g_kdhevdhfbgmlqlh[u khjb_glbjh\Zlvky b
\kihfgblv bgkljmdpbb^hgZ <bk_glZ
Y \ayeh^gh bajZkl_gbcijhr_e gZdZdlmkh\h_ ihe_ gZ
djZx ^hjh]bb ihkZ^be_]h lZfdZd kdZaZefg_ ^hg<bk_glM
f_gy [ueZ k kh[hc [mluedZfbg_jZevghc \h^udhlhjhc y
gZf_j_\Zeky iheblvjZkl_gb_Y ihiulZekyhldjulv __hl[b\
]hjeurdh `_e_adhcdhlhjhc ydhiZe yfmb hkdhehd kl_deZ
aZ^_e fhx\_jogxx ]m[maZklZ\b\ __djh\hlhqblv
Y ihr_egZaZ^ dfZrbg_ aZ^jm]hc [mluedhc fbg_jZevghc
\h^uDh]^Z y \ugbfZe
__
ba
[Z]Z`gbdZhdheh f_gy
hklZgh\beky Z\lhfh[bevnhevdk\Z]_gb \h^bl_evkijhkbeg_
gm`gZ eb fg_ ihfhsvY kdZaZeqlh \k_\ ihjy^d_b hg
m_oZeY \_jgmekyiheblv jZkl_gb_Z aZl_fkjZam ihr_egZaZ^
d k\h_cfZrbg_
Dh]^Z y [uehl g__f_ljZo \lh \g_aZigh mkeurZe
]hehkZY ihki_rbeih kdehgmgZ rhkk_b m\b^_ehdheh fZrbgu
ljhbo f_dkbdZgp_\ ^\mo fm`qbgb h^gm`_gsbgmH^bg ba
fm`qbg kb^_egZ i_j_^g_f[Zfi_j_?fmih`Zemc[ueh hdheh
e_lhg [uekj_^g_]h jhklZk q_jgufb\vxsbfbky \hehkZfb
GZ kibg_ hg g_k k\_jlhdgZ g_f [ueb klZju_ [jxdb b
baghr_ggZy jhah\ZlZyjm[ZrdZ?]h [hlbgdb[ueb g_ aZ\yaZgu
bih`Zemckebrdhf \_ebdb^ey g_]hHgb dZaZebkvoey[Zxsbfb
b g_m^h[gufbHg h[eb\Zekyihlhf>jm]hc fm`qbgZ klhye
f_ljZo \ r_klbhl fZrbguHg [ue[he__ lhgdhdhklgucq_f
i_j\ucb gb`__]h?]h \hehku[ueb ijyfu_b aZq_kZgugZaZ^
Hg g_kaZ kibghck\_jlhd ihf_gvr_b [ueklZjr_ih`Zemce_l
ih^ iylv^_kylHg kh\k_fg_ \kihl_eb dZaZekyhlj_r_gguf b
g_aZbgl_j_kh\Zgguf
@_gsbg_dZaZehkvlh`_ [uehaZ khjhdHgZ [ueZlheklZy
b l_fgZyH^_lZ hgZ[ueZ \q_jgmx x[dm[_euc k\bl_j b
hkljhdhg_qgu_ lmnebM g_c
g_
[ueh k\_jldZgh [ue
ljZgabklhjguc ijb_fgbdHgZ dZaZeZkvhq_gv mklZehcb ebph__
[ueh ihdjulhdZieyfb ihlZ
Dh]^Z y ih^hr_elh
`_gsbgZ
b fm`qbgZ ihfheh`_
h[jZlbebkv dh fg_Hgb ohl_ebqlh[ boih^\_aebY kdZaZe
bfqlh mf_gy \fZrbg_ g_lf_klZY ihdZaZebfqlh aZ^g__
kb^_gv_ m f_gyiheghklvx aZ]jm`_ghb f_klZ ^_ckl\bl_evgh
kh\k_f g_ hklZ\ZehkvFm`qbgZ ij_^eh`beqlh _keby ih_^m
f_^e_gghlh hgbfh]ml ijbfhklblvkygZ aZ^g_f[Zfi_j_ beb
_oZlve_`Z gZ i_j_^g_f dZihl_Y ihkqblZe wlm b^_x
g_\uihegbfhcH^gZdh\ boijhkv[_ [ueZlZdZy kjhqghklvqlh
y ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[y hq_gv g_m^h[ghY ^Ze bf ^_g_] gZ
Z\lh[mkgu_ [be_lu
Fm`qbgZ ihfheh`_ \aye^_gv]bih[eZ]h^Zjb\ f_gygh
klZjrbc kg_ijbyagvx ih\_jgmekydh fg_kibghc
Y ohqmqlh[ f_gyih^\_aebkdZaZe hgy g_
aZbgl_j_kh\Zg \^_gv]Zo
AZl_f hgih\_jgmeky dhfg_
Fh`_l_ \u^Zlv gZfg_fgh]h ibsbb \h^u"kijhkbe hg
M f_gy^_ckl\bl_evgh g_q_]h[ueh bf^ZlvHgb ihklhyeb
g_fgh]h]ey^y gZf_gyZ aZl_fihreb ijhqv
Y aZe_a\ fZrbgmb ihiulZekyaZ\_klb fhlhj@ZjZ [ueZ
hq_gv kbevghcb y\b^bfhi_j_dZqZe [_gabgFm`qbgZ
ihfheh`_ hklZgh\bekymkeurZ\ kdj_`_l klZjl_jZ\_jgmeky
gZaZ^ b \klZe ihaZ^bfZrbgu]hlh\uc ih^lhedgmlv __Y
qm\kl\h\Ze h]jhfgh_ g_m^h[kl\hY gZqZe aZ]gZggh ^urZlv
GZdhg_pfhlhj aZjZ[hlZeb ymdZlbe
Ihke_ lh]hdZd yhdhgqbe k\hcjZkkdZa^hg OmZg^he]h
fheqZe
Ihq_fm lug_ jZkkdZaZefg_ h[wlhf jZgvr_"kijhkbe
hgg_ ]ey^ygZ f_gy
Y g_agZeqlh kdZaZlvY ih`Zeie_qZfb bkdZaZe _fm
qlh gbdh]^Zg_ kqblZeqlh lml_klv qlheb[h \Z`gh_wlh
q_jlh\kdb \Z`ghkdZaZe hg<bk_gl i_j\hdeZkkguc fZ]
Hg ^Zel_[_ qlhlh ihkZ^blvihlhfm qlhm g_]h[ueb gZ wlh
k\hb ijbqbguB _keblu \klj_lbelj_o q_eh\_ddhlhju_
dZaZehkv\ukdhqbeb bagbhldm^ZkjZam ihke_lh]hdZd lu
ihkZ^be wlhlh wlhfmlZd`_ [ueZk\hy ijbqbgZGh lhevdh
lZdhc ^mjZddZd lug_ h[jZlblgZ bgpb^_gl\gbfZgby b[m^_l
kqblZlvqlh gbq_]h\Z`gh]h g_[ueh
Hg aZohl_emagZlv lhqghqlh bf_gghbf_eh f_klhdh]^Z
y gZ\_klbe<bk_glZ
Y jZkkdZaZe _fmqlh y_oZe q_j_a]hjh^ b ijh_a`Ze
[ZaZjFg_ ijbreZ\ ]heh\mfukev \a]eygmlvgZ ^hgZ<bk_glZ
Y ijhr_e gZ [ZaZj b
ih^hr_e
d jy^m]^_ lhj]h\Zeb
e_dZjkl\_ggufb jZkl_gbyfbLZf [uehljb klheZ\ jy^gh
lhj]h\Zeb lZfljb lheklu_`_gsbguY ijhr_e^h dhgpZijhoh^Z
b h[gZjm`be _s_h^gm klhcdmaZ m]ehfLZf ym\b^_e lhs_]h
lhgdhdhklgh]h k_^h]h fm`qbgm< wlhlfhf_gl hg ijh^Z\Ze
`_gsbg_ ilbqvxde_ldm
Y ih^h`^ZeihdZ hgg_ hk\h[h^bekyb aZl_fkijhkbeg_
agZ_l eb hg^hgZ <bk_glZF_^jZghHg kfhlj_egZ f_gyg_
hl\_qZy
Qlh \uohlbl_ hlwlh]h <bk_glZF_^jZgh"kijhkbe hg
gZdhg_p
Y kdZaZeqlh yijbr_e gZ\_klblv_]h hl_]h ^jm]Z b
gZa\Ze _fmbfy ^hgZOmZgZKlZjbd k_dmg^mkfhlj_e gZf_gyZ
aZl_f hg kdZaZeqlh hgb _klv<bk_gl F_^jZghb qlh hg d
fhbf mkem]ZfHg ihijhkbef_gy k_klvHgdZaZehkv[ue
^h\he_ghq_gv jZkkeZ[e_gb bkdj_gg_^jm`_kl\_g_gY kdZaZe
_fm hfh_c ^jm`[_k ^hghfOmZghfY ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh f_`^m
gZfb lml`_ \hagbdebmau kbfiZlbbHg kdZaZeqlh agZ_l^hgZ
OmZgZ kl_o ihjdZd bfh[hbf [uehih e_lM ^hgZ<bk_glZ
[ueb lhevdh keh\Z iho\Zeuh ^hg_OmZg_D dhgpm gZr_]h
jZa]h\hjZ hgkdZaZe k^jh`vx \]hehk_
>hg OmZg bklbgguc q_eh\_dagZgbyKZf y ebrv
g_fgh]h aZgbfZekykbeZfb jZkl_gbcY \k_]^Zbgl_j_kh\Zeky bo
e_q_[gufb k\hckl\ZfbY ^Z`_kh[bjZe [hlZgbq_kdb_ dgb]b
dhlhju_ ijh^Zeebrv g_^Z\gh
Fbgmlm hg fheqZeHg iZjmjZa ihl_jk\hc ih^[hjh^hd
DZaZehkvhg ih^ukdb\Z_lgm`gh_ keh\h
Fh`gh kdZaZlvqlh y\k_]h ebrvq_eh\_d ebjbq_kdh]h
agZgbykdZaZe hgY g_dZd ^hgOmZgfhc bg^_ckdbc
[jZl
>hg <bk_gl fheqZe _s_fbgmlm?]h ]eZaZ [e_kl_eb b
kfhlj_eb gZa_fex ke_\Zhl f_gyAZl_f hgih\_jgmeky dhfg_
b kdZaZeihqlb r_ihlhf
HdZd \ukhdhiZjbl fhcbg^_ckdbc kh[jZl
>hg <bk_glih^gyekyDZaZehkvgZr jZa]h\hj aZdhgq_g
?keb [u
dlhgb[m^v
^jm]hc
^_eZe
ml\_j`^_gby gZkq_l
bg^_ckdh]h [jZlZlh yijbgye [uwlh ijhklh aZ ^_r_\h_
debr_H^gZdhlhg ^hgZ<bk_glZ [ueklhev bkdj_g_gb ]eZaZ
_]h [ueb klhev ykguqlh hgaZo\Zlbe f_gy dZjlbghc _]h
bg^_ckdh]h [jZlZiZjys_]h klhev\ukhdhB yih\_jbeqlh hg
kdZaZe bf_gghlhqlh bf_e\ \b^m
Ebjbq_kdh_ agZgb_\hkdebdgme ^hgOmZgdh]^Z y
jZkkdZaZe _fm\k_<bk_gl [jmohAZq_f luihr_e gZ\_sZlv
_]h"
Y gZihfgbe_fm _]hkeh\Zqlh fg_gZ^h gZ\_klblv ^hgZ
<bk_glZ
Wlh Z[kmj^\hkdebdgme hg^jZfZlbq_kdby kdZaZe
l_[_ dh]^Zgb[m^vdh]^Z lu[m^_rv agZlvdZd
\b
^ _l vlu gZ\_klbrvfh_]h ^jm]Z<bk_glZ<hlqlh y
kdZaZeHq_\b^ghqlh lug_ kemrZe
Y \hajZabeqlh g_\b`m \j_^Z\ lhfqlh gZ\_klbe^hgZ
<bk_glZqlh y[ue hqZjh\Zg_]h fZg_jZfbb _]h^h[jhlhc>hg
OmZg ihljyk]heh\hc baklhjhgu \klhjhgmb ihemj_[yq_kdbf
lhghf \ujZabe k\h_ m^b\e_gb_ lhfmqlh hg gZa\Ze fh_c
ke_ihc m^Zq_cHg kdZaZeqlh fhc\babl d ^hgm <bk_glm
kjZ\gbf k \oh`^_gb_f
\
ev\bgmx
de_ldm\hhjm`_gghfm
ijmlbdhf>hg OmZg dZaZeky\ha[m`^_gguf bh^gZdh `_y
gbdZd g_ \b^_e lhfm ijbqbg>hg <bk_gl [ue ij_djZkguc
q_eh\_dHg dZaZekylZdbf ojmidbf?]h kljZggh hohlysb_ky
]eZaZdZaZehkv^_eZeb _]hihqlb wn_f_jgufY kijhkbe^hgZ
OmZgZdZdbf h[jZahflZdhc ij_djZkgucq_eh\_d fh`_l [ulv
hiZkguf
Lu g_bae_qbfuc^mjZdkdZaZe hgb \a]eygme `_kldh
gZ k_dmg^mKZf ihk_[_ hgg_ klZg_l ijbqbgylv l_[_
gbdZdh]h \j_^ZGh agZgb_wlh kbeZB _kebq_eh\_d \klZe
gZ ^hjh]m agZgbylh hg[hevr_ g_hl\_lkl\_g_g aZlhqlh
fh`_l kemqblvky k l_fbdlh \oh^blk gbf \ dhglZdlLu
^he`_g [ue gZ\_klblv_]h lh]^Zdh]^Z magZ_rv ^hklZlhqgh
qlh[u aZsblblvk_[yg_ hlg_]hgh hllhc kbeudhlhjmx hg
kdhgp_gljbjh\Ze bdhlhjZydklZlbg_ ijbgZ^e_`blgb _fm b
gbdhfm ^jm]hfmMkeurZ\qlh lufhc ^jm]<bk_gl aZdexqbe
qlh lufh`_rv aZsblblvk_[y bk^_eZe l_[_ih^Zjhd<_jhylgh
lu _fmihgjZ\bekyb hgk^_eZe l_[_\_ebdbc ih^ZjhdZ lug_
\hkihevah\Zeky bfDZdZy `Zehklv
fZy ]
Y gZ^h_^Ze^hgm OmZgmihqlb \_kv^_gvijhkyqlh[u hg
jZkkdZaZe fg_ hih^Zjd_ ^hgZ<bk_glZY kZfufb jZaebqgufb
kihkh[Zfb ihdZau\Ze_fmqlh hg^he`_g mq_klvjZaebqby f_`^m
gZfblhqlh kZfh kh[hcihgylgh ^ey g_]hfh`_l [ulv
kh\_jr_ggh g_\hkijbgbfZ_fuf^ey f_gy
Kdhevdh jZkl_gbc hgl_[_ ^Ze"kijhkbe hg f_gy
gZdhg_pY kdZaZe q_luj_gh \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb y g_
aZihfgbeLh]^Z ^hgOmZg aZohl_emagZlv lhqghqlh ijhbahreh
ihke_ lh]hdZd yihdbgme ^hgZ<bk_glZ b^h lh]hdZd y
hklZgh\beky m^hjh]b
<Z`gh dhebq_kl\hjZkl_gbcZ lZd`_ihjy^hd kh[ulbc
kdZaZe hgdZd yfh]m l_[_kdZaZlvqlh wlh [ue aZ
ih^Zjhd_keb lug_ ihfgbrvlh]hqlh kemqbehkv
Y [_amki_rghiulZeky \bamZebabjh\Zlvihke_^h\Zl_evghklv
kh[ulbc
?keb [ulu ihfgbe\k_qlh kemqbehkvkdZaZe hg
lh yih djZcg_cf_j_fh] [ul_[_ kdZaZlvdZd luhl[jhkbe
k\hc ih^Zjhd
>hg OmZgdZaZehkv[ue hq_gvjZkkljh_gHg g_l_ji_eb\h
lhjhibe f_gy\kihfgblvgh iZfylvfhy [ueZkh\_jr_ggh imklZ
DZd lu^mfZ_rvqlh yk^_eZe g_ijZ\bevgh^hg OmZg"
kdZaZe yijhklh ^eylh]hqlh[u ijh^he`blvjZa]h\hj
<k_
Gh yke_^h\Ze bgkljmdpbyf^hgZ <bk_glZ[md\Zevgh
Qlh `ba wlh]h"JZa\_ lug_ ihgbfZ_rvqlh ke_^h\Zlv
_]h bgkljmdpbyf[ueh [_kkfuke_ggh"
Ihq_fm"
Ihlhfm qlhwlb bgkljmdpbb[ueb ^eylh]hdlh mf__l
\ b^ _l vZ g_ ^ey
b^bhlZdhlhjuc \uj\Zeky ba
kblmZpbbg_ ihl_jy\k\hx `bagvlhevdh [eZ]h^Zjy\_a_gbxLu
ijb_oZe ih\b^Zlv<bk_glZ [_aih^]hlh\dbLu _fmihgjZ\beky
b hg k^_eZel_[_ ih^ZjhdB wlhlih^Zjhd e_]dhfh] klhblv
l_[_ `bagb
Gh aZq_f`_ hg^Ze fg_qlhlh klhevk_jv_agh_"?keb
hg fZ]lh hg^he`_g [ue[u agZlvqlh ygbq_]h g_agZx
G_lhg g_fh] wlh]hm\b^_lvLu \u]ey^brvlZddZd
[m^lh luagZ_rvgh \^_ckl\bl_evghklb luagZ_rv g_fgh]h
Y kdZaZeqlh bkdj_gg_m[_`^_gqlh gb]^_ gbq_]h g_
kljhbe bak_[yih djZcg_cf_j_khagZl_evgh
Y g_ wlhbf_x \\b^mkdZaZe hg_keb [u lu
qlhlh ba k_[y kljhbelh <bk_glm\b^_e [uwlhDh]^Z y
\ b` m
l_[ylh lu\u]ey^brv ^eyf_gy lZddZd _keb[u lu
agZe hq_gvfgh]h_bh^gZdhy kZfagZxqlh wlhg_ lZd
Qlh ydZaZehkv [uagZx^hg OmZg"
K_dj_lu kbeudhg_qghagZgb_ [jmohIhwlhfmdh]^Z
<bk_gl
m\ b^ _e
l_[ylh hgk^_eZe l_[_ih^ZjhdZ lu
^_ckl\h\Ze k wlbfih^ZjdhfdZd kh[ZdZ^_ckl\m_l k ibs_c
dh]^Z [jxoh __ iheghKh[ZdZ kkulgZ ibsmdh]^Z hgZ g_
ohq_l [hevr_ _klv^ey lh]hqlh[u ^jm]b_kh[Zdb g_ kt_eb
__LZd blu ihkkZegZ ih^ZjhdL_i_jv fugbdh]^Z g_magZ_f
qlh bf_ehf_klh \^_ckl\bl_evghklbLu fgh]h_ihl_jyeDZdZy
`Zehklv
G_dhlhjh_ \j_fy hg [ue
kihdh_gAZl_f i_j_^_jgme
ie_qZfb bmeu[gmeky
G_l ihevauhl `ZehklbkdZaZe hgIh^Zjdb kbeu
\klj_qZxlky \`bagb lZdj_^dhhgb mgbdZevgub ^jZ]hp_ggu
<havfbgZijbf_j f_gygbdlh gbdh]^Zg_ ^Z\Ze fg_ lZdbo
ih^Zjdh\B yagZx hq_gvg_fgh]h ex^_cdhlhju_ dh]^Zeb[h
ihemqZeb lZdhcih^Zjhd;jhkZlvky q_flh klhevmgbdZevguf klu^gh
Y \b`mqlh luohq_rv kdZaZlv^hg OmZgkdZaZe y
?klv eb qlheb[hqlh yfh]m k^_eZlvqlh[u \ujmqblv
ih^Zjhd"
Hg aZkf_yeky b
g_kdhevdh
jZa ih\lhjye\_jgmlv
ih^Zjhd
Wlh a\mqbla^hjh\hkdZaZe hgfg_ wlhgjZ\blky
H^gZdhg_l gbq_]hqlh [ufh`gh [uehk^_eZlvqlh[u \_jgmlv
l\hc ih^Zjhd
fZy ]
K_]h^gy ^hgOmZg ihljZlbeihqlb \k_\j_fy gZlhqlh[u
ihdZaZlv fg_dZd kh[bjZlvijhklu_ eh\mrdb ^ey fZe_gvdbo
`b\hlguoIhqlb \k_mljh fukj_aZeb bhqbsZeb \_ldbM f_gy
\ ]heh\_\_jl_ehkv fgh`_kl\h\hijhkh\Y iulZeky]h\hjblv k
gbfihdZ fujZ[hlZebgh hgihrmlbekdZaZ\qlh ba gZk
^\hbo lhevdhy fh]mh^gh\j_f_ggh ^\b]Zlvb jmdZfbb jlhf
GZdhg_pfu k_ebhl^hogmlvb y\ahj\Zeky \hijhkZfb
Qlh wlhlZdh_ agZqbl \b ^_ lv ^hg OmZg"
Hg klZe]h\hjblv h \b ^_ gv bdZd h ijhp_kk_
g_aZ\bkbfhf hl heeb bhl l_ogbdbfZ]bbFZ] [ueh ebph
dhlhjh_
fh]eh
dhfZg^h\Zlv
heeb
blZdbf
h[jZahf
fZgbimebjh\Zlv heeb k_[_gZ ihevamGh lhlnZdlqlh fZ]
dhfZg^m_l heebg_ hagZqZeqlh hgfh`_l \b ^_ lv Y
gZihfgbe _fmqlh hg
]h\hjbe
jZgvr_qlh g_\hafh`gh
\ b^ _l v_keb g_ bf__rvheeb>hg OmZg kihdhcgh
aZf_lbeqlh hgijbr_e d\u\h^mqlh \hafh`gh \b ^_ lv
b g_ dhfZg^h\Zlv heebHg qm\kl\h\Zeqlh g_l gbdZdhc
ijbqbguihq_fm [ug_ lZdihlhfm qlh \b ^_ gv _
g_
bf__l gbq_]h h[s_]h k
fZgbimeypbhgghc l_ogbdhc fZ]bb
dhlhjZy kem`bl ebrv ^ey lh]hqlh[u \ha^_ckl\h\Zlv gZ
hdjm`Zxsbo ex^_c
DZd wlhlZdqlh l_ogbdZ\b^_gvy g_\ha^_ckl\m_l gZ
hdjm`Zxsbo ex^_c^hg OmZg"
Y m`_]h\hjbe l_[_qlh \b ^_ gv _
wlh g_
fZ]byB h^gZdh`_bo e_]dhkimlZlvihlhfm qlh q_eh\_d
dhlhjuc
\b ^b lfh`_l gZmqblvkymijZ\eylv heeb b
klZlv fZ]hf ijZdlbq_kdb
kjZamg_ aZljZlb\ gbkdhevdh
\j_f_gbK
^jm]hc
klhjhguq_eh\_d
fh`_l gZmqblvky
hij_^_e_gghc l_ogbd_ ^ey lh]hqlh[u dhfZg^h\Zlv heeb b
lZdbf h[jZahf klZlv fZ]hfb \k_`_ hgfh`_l gbdh]^Z g_
gZmqblvky
\b ^_ lv D
lhfm
`_
\b ^_ gv _
ijhlb\hiheh`gh
fZ]bb< b^ _g v_
^Z_l
ihgylv
g_\Z`ghklv \k_]hwlh]h
G_\Z`ghklv q_]h^hg OmZg"
G_\Z`ghklv \k_]h
>hg OmZg [jhkbe \_kv
wlhl jZa]h\hjkdZaZ\qlh
\ b^ _g v_ h dhlhjhfhg ]h\hjblwlh g_ ijhklh_
kfhlj_gb_ gZ\_sb bqlh fh_g_ihgbfZgb_ ijhbajZklZ_lba fh_c
gZklhcqb\hklb ]h\hjblv
G_kdhevdh qZkh\kimkly ^hgOmZg hiylv\_jgmeky d l_f_
heebY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh _]hdZdbflh h[jZahfjZa^jZ`Zxl fhb
\hijhkuihwlhfm y [hevr_g_ gZ`bfZegZ g_]hHg lh]^Z
ihdZau\Ze fg_dZd ^_eZlveh\mrdm ^eydjhebdh\fg_ gZ^h
[ueh ^_j`Zlv ^ebggmx iZedmb k]b[Zlv__ gZkdhevdh fh`gh
kbevg__lZdqlh[u hgfh] ijb\yaZlvd dhgpZfiZedb rgmj
IZedZ [ueZ ^h\hevgh
lhgdhcgh
\k_
`_ lj_[h\ZeZkv
agZqbl_evgZy kbeZqlh[u kh]gmlv__Fhb jmdb b ]heh\Z
^jh`Zeb hlgZijy`_gbyb yihqlb \u^hokyd lhfm\j_f_gbdZd
hg ijb\yaZegZdhg_prgmj
Fu mk_ebkvb hggZqZe ]h\hjblvHg kdZaZeqlh _fm
ykghqlh ygbq_]h g_fh]m mjZamf_lv^h l_oihjihdZ g_
h[]h\hjx wlhb ihwlhfmhg g_\hajZ`Z_l ijhlb\fhbo \hijhkh\
b kh[bjZ_lkyjZkkdZaZlv fg_h[ heeb
Heeb g_ \^ufd_kdZaZe hg^ufhd [_j_l l_[y
lm^Z]^_ gZoh^blkyheebZ dh]^Zlu klZg_rvk heeb h^gbf
p_euflh l_[_[hevr_ g_ihgZ^h[blky dmjblvK wlboihj lu
kfh`_rv ijbau\Zlv k\h_]hheeb ih`_eZgbx baZklZ\eylv _]h
^_eZlv \k_qlh ih`_eZ_rvHeeb g_iehob_ bg_ ohjhrb_gh
bkihevamxlky fZ]Zfb ^eylhc p_eb^ey dZdhchgb gZc^ml bo
ijb]h^gufbFg_ gjZ\blky^ufhddZd heebihlhfm qlhhg g_
lj_[m_l hlf_gy fgh]h]hHg ihklhyg_gb q_kl_g
DZdbf lu \b^brv heeb^hg OmZg"L_ ljh_ ex^_c
dhlhjuo ygZijbf_j\b^_e\u]ey^_eb ^ey f_gy h[uqgufb
ex^vfbdZd [uhgb \u]ey^_eb^ey l_[y"
Hgb \u]ey^_eb[u h[uqgufbex^vfb
Gh lh]^Z dZd`_ lufh`_rv hlebqblvbo hl h[uqguo
ex^_c"
H[uqgu_ ex^b\u]ey^yl k\_lysbfbkyycpZfbdh]^Z lu
\ b^ br v
boG_ ex^b\k_]^Z \u]ey^yldZd ex^b<hl qlh
y bf_e \ \b^mdh]^Z kdZaZeqlh lu g_ fh`_rv
m\ b
^ _l v
heebHeeb ijbgbfZxljZagmx nhjfmHgb \u]ey^yl
dZd kh[Zdbdhchluilbpu^Z`_ dZdj_i_cgbdb bebqlh m]h^gh
^jm]h_?^bgkl\_ggh_ jZaebqb_
\
lhfqlh
dh]^Z lu
\ b^ br v
bolh hgb\u]ey^yl kh\_jr_gghlZddZd lh
nhjfm q_]hhgb ijbgbfZxl<k_ bf__lk\hx kh[kl\_ggmx nhjfm
[ulbydh]^Z lu
\b ^b rv Lhqgh lZd`_dZd ex^b
\u]ey^yl ycpZfb^jm]b_ \_sb\u]ey^yldZd qlheb[h _s_gh
heeb fh`gh \b^_lv lhevdh
\
lhc
nhjf_dhlhjmx hgb
bah[jZ`ZxlWlZ nhjfZ ^hklZlhqghohjhrZqlh[u h[fZgmlv
]eZaZgZrb ]eZaZlh _klvKh[ZdZ gbdh]^Zg_ h[fZg_lky b
lhqgh lZd`_\hjhgZ
Gh aZq_fhgb ohlylgZk h[fZgu\Zlv"
Y kqblZxgZk rmlZfbFu h[fZgu\Z_fkZfb k_[yHeeb
ijhklh ijbgbfZxl \g_rgxx nhjfmlh]hqlh _klv \hdjm]Z
aZl_f fu ijbgbfZ_f boaZ lhq_f hgbg_ y\eyxlkyG_ bo
\bgZqlh fuijbmqbeb gZrb]eZaZ lhevdhkfhlj_lv gZ\_sb
Fg_ g_ykgZ bonmgdpby^hg OmZgQlh ^_eZxlheeb \
fbj_"
Wlh \k_ jZ\ghqlh kijhkblvf_gyqlh fuex^b
^_eZ_f \fbj_Y ^_ckl\bl_evghg_ agZxFu a^_kvb wlh\k_
B heeba^_kv lZd`_dZd fubfh`_l [ulv[ueb a^_kvb ^h
gZk
Qlh luohq_rv wlbfkdZaZlv^hg OmZg^h gZk"
Fuex^bg_ \k_]^Z[ueb a^_kv
Lu bf__rv\ \b^ma^_kv \kljZg_ beba^_kv \fbj_"
Fu \hreb \^ebl_evguc kihj>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh ^ey
g_]h kms_kl\m_llhevdh h^bgfbj lh f_klhdm^Z hg klZ\bl
k\hb gh]bY kijhkbe_]hhldm^Z hgagZ_lqlh fug_ \k_]^Z
[ueb \fbj_
Hq_gv ijhklhkdZaZe hgfuex^bhq_gv fZeh
agZ_f hfbj_Dhchl agZ_lgZfgh]h [hevr_gZkDhchl _^\Zeb
dh]^Zgb[m^v h[fZgu\Z_lky\g_rgbf \b^hffbjZ
DZd `_fu lh]^Zmobljy_fky boeh\blv b m[b\Zlv"
kijhkbe y?keb hgbg_ h[fZgu\Zxlky\g_rgbf \b^hflh dZd
`_ hgblZd e_]dhmfbjZxl"
>hg OmZg kfhlj_e gZ f_gy ^hl_o ihjihdZ y g_
ihqm\kl\h\Ze aZf_rZl_evkl\Z
Fu fh`_fihcfZlv bebhljZ\blvbeb aZklj_eblvdhchlZ
KdZaZe hghg ^eygZk e_]dZy`_jl\Zihlhfm qlhhg g_
agZdhf kfZgbimeypbyfb q_eh\_dZH^gZdh_keb dhchl\u`b\_l
lh fh`_rv[ulv m\_j_gqlh fu_]h g_ihcfZ_f \h\lhjhc jZa
Ohjhrbc hohlgbdagZ_l wlhb gbdh]^Zg_ klZ\blk\hb eh\mrdb
^\Z`^u gZh^gh blh `_f_klhIhlhfm qlh_keb dhchlmf_j \
eh\mrd_lh dZ`^ucdhchl fh`_l \b ^_ lv
_]h kf_jlv
dhlhjZy hklZ_lky lZfb ^Ze__blZdbf h[jZahfhgb [m^ml
ba[_]Zlv eh\mrdb beb^Z`_ \k_]hlh]h f_klZ]^_ hgZ [ueZ
ihklZ\e_gZFuk ^jm]hcklhjhgugbdh]^Z g_
\b ^b f
kf_jlbdhlhjZy hklZ_lky gZlhf f_kl_]^_ mf_j h^bg ba
hdjm`Zxsbo gZk ex^_cfu fh`_f^h]Z^u\Zlvky hg_cgh fu
gbdh]^Z __g_ \b^bf
Fh`_l ebdhchl \b^_lvheeb"
Dhg_qgh
DZd \u]ey^blheeb ^eydhchlZ"
Fg_ gm`gh[ueh [u[ulv dhchlhfqlh[u agZlvwlhY
fh]m kdZaZlv l_[_h^gZdhqlh \hjhg_wlh \b^blky ih^h[gh
hkljhdhg_qghc rZid_Djm]eZy brbjhdZy \gbamhdZgqb\ZxsZyky
hkljuf dhgphfG_dhlhju_ bagbo k\_lylkygh [hevrbgkl\h
lmkdeu_ b dZ`mlky fjZqgufbHgb ihoh^ylgZ fhdjuc dmkhd
ldZgbHgb y\eyxlkyij_^\_sZxsbfb ijbajZdZfb
DZd hgb\u]ey^yldh]^Z \u \b ^b l_
bo^hg
OmZg"
Y kdZaZe l_[_
m`_hgb
\u]ey^yldZd [m^lh
ijbl\hjyxlkyHgb ijbgbfZxlex[hc jZaf_jbeb nhjfmdhlhju_
ih^oh^yl bfHgb fh]mlijbgylv nhjfmdZfgy beb]hju
JZa]h\Zjb\Zxl ebhgbkeurZl ebbeb ijhba\h^yl eb
hgb dZdhcgb[m^v rmf"
< h[s_kl\_ex^_c hgb\_^ml k_[ydZd ex^b< h[s_kl\_
`b\hlguo hgb \_^mlk_[y ih^h[gh`b\hlguf@b\hlgu_ h[uqgh
[hylky boh^gZdh_keb hgbijb\udZxl d \b^m heebhgb
hklZ\eyxl boh^gboFu kZfb^_eZ_f g_qlhih^h[gh_Fu bf__f
fgh`_kl\h heeb kj_^bgZkgh fug_ [_kihdhbfboLZd dZd
gZrb ]eZaZfh]ml lhevdh\b^_lv \_sbfu g_aZf_qZ_f bo
Wlh agZqblqlh g_dhlhju_ba ex^_cdhlhjuo y\b`m gZ
mebp_gZ kZfhf ^_e_ g_y\eyxlky ex^vfb"kijhkbe y
ihbklbg_ k[bluck lhedm_]h ml\_j`^_gb_f
>Zg_dhlhju_ g_y\eyxlkykdZaZe hg\ujZabl_evgh
?]h ml\_j`^_gb_ ihdZaZehkvfg_ g_khh[jZagufb y \k_
_s_ g_ fh]ijbgylv \k_jv_akeh\Z ^hgZOmZgZiheZ]Zyqlh
hgb jZkkqblZgugZ wnn_dlY kdZaZe_fmqlh wlha\mqbldZd
gZmqghnZglZklbq_kdbc jZkkdZah kms_kl\Zok ^jm]bo ieZg_l
Hg hl\_lbefg_qlh hgg_ [_kihdhblkyh lhfdZd wlha\mqbl
gh g_dhlhju_ex^b gZmebp_ g_y\eyxlky ex^vfb
Ihq_fm lu^he`_g ^mfZlvqlh dZ`^h_ebph \^\b`ms_cky
lhei_ y\ey_lkyq_eh\_q_kdbf kms_kl\hf"kijhkbe hgk kZfuf
k_jv_aguf \b^hf
Y \kZfhf ^_e_g_ fh]h[tykgblv ihq_fmaZ bkdexq_gb_f
lh]hqlh ijb\ud\_jblv \wlhdZd \Zdl g_ij_eh`ghc\_ju k
fh_c klhjhgu
Hg ijh^he`Ze ^Zevr_qlh qZklhhg hohlgh gZ[ex^Ze \
h`b\e_gguo f_klZo kdhie_gby ex^_cb fh]
\b ^_ lv
bgh]^Z lheimex^_cdhlhju_ \u]ey^_ebgZih^h[b_ ybpb kj_^b
fZkku ycp_ih^h[guo kms_kl\hg fh]aZf_lblv lhevdh h^gh]h
dhlhjuc \u]ey^_edZd q_eh\_d
Hq_gv ijbylghaZgbfZlvky wlbfkdZaZe hgkf_ykv
bebih djZcg_cf_j_ijbylgh ^eyf_gyY ex[ex kb^_lv \
iZjdZo bgZ Z\lhklZgpbyob gZ[ex^ZlvBgh]^Z yfh]m kjZam`_
aZf_lblv heeb\ ^jm]h_\j_fy y \b `m
lhevdhgZklhysbo
ex^_cH^gZ`^u ym\b^_e ^\moheebkb^ysbo \Z\lh[mk_ [hdh
[hdLhevdh h^bgjZa \`bagb y\b^_e ^\moheeb \f_kl_
Wlh bf_eh^ey l_[yhkh[h_ agZq_gb_m\b^_lv ^\mo"
Dhg_qgh<k_qlh hgb^_eZxlbf__l agZq_gb_Ba bo
^_ckl\bc [jmoh fh`_lbgh]^Z ba\e_qvk\hx kbem>Z`_ _keb
[jmoh g_ bf__l k\h_]hkh[kl\_ggh]h heebdhev kdhjh hg
agZ_ldZd \b ^_ lv hg fh`_lihemqblv kbemgZ[ex^Zy
^_ckl\by heebFhc [_g_nZdlhj gZmqbef_gy wlhfmb aZ
g_kdhevdh e_l^h lh]hdZd yklZe bf_lvk\h_]h kh[kl\_ggh]h
heeby hlukdb\Ze heeb \
lheiZo ex^_c b dZ`^uc jZa
\ b^ _e
h^gh]hdhlhjuc mqbef_gy q_fmgb[m^vLu gZr_e
lj_o \f_kl_DZdhc \_ebdhe_igucmjhd luijha_\Ze
;hevr_ hg gbq_]h g_ ]h\hjbeihdZ fu g_ dhgqbeb
kh[bjZlv djhebqvb eh\mrdbIhlhf hgih\_jgmeky dh fg_ b
kdZaZe \^jm]dZd [m^lh[u hglhevdh qlh \kihfgbeqlh
^jm]Zy \Z`gZy\_svhlghkysZyky dheebwlh lhqlh _kebhg
\b^_e ^\moheebwlh \k_]^Z[ueb ^\Zh^gh]h blh]h `_\b^Z
>\Z heebdhlhjuo \b^_ehg[ueb fm`qbgZfbkdZaZe hgb ba
lh]hqlh y\b^_e ^\mofm`qbg bh^gm `_gsbgmhg aZdexqbe
qlh fhchiul [uehkh[_ggh g_h[uqguf
Y kijhkbe_]hfh]ml ebheeb ijbgbfZlv\b^ ^_l_cfh]ml
eb ^_lb [ulv h^gh]h beb jZaguo iheh\fh]ml eb heeb
bah[jZ`Zlv ex^_c jZaebqguo jZkfh]ml eb hgb bf_lv \b^
k_fvbkhklhys_c bafm`qbgu`_gsbgu bj_[_gdZbgZdhg_p
y kijhkbe _]hfh`_l
eb
heeb
bf_lv \b^ q_eh\_dZ
mijZ\eyxs_]h Z\lhfh[be_fbeb Z\lh[mkhf
>hg OmZggbq_]h g_hl\_qZe gZwlhHg meu[ZekyihdZ y
]h\hjbe \k_wlhDh]^Z hgmkeurZe fhcihke_^gbc \hijhklh
hg jZkohohlZeky b kdZaZeqlh y g_hklhjh`_g kh k\hbfb
\hijhkZfbqlh [he__mf_klguf [ueh[u kijhkblv\ b^ _e
eb hgdh]^Zgb[m^v heebmijZ\eyxs_]h Z\lhfh[be_f
Lu g_ aZ[ue ijhfhlhpbdeu^Z"kijhkbe hg k
ij_^Zl_evkdbf [e_kdhf \]eZaZoY gZr_e_]h gZkf_rdb gZ^
fhbfb \hijhkZfbaZ[Z\gufb bg_ h[b^gufbb aZkf_yeky\f_kl_ k
gbf
AZl_f hg h[tykgbeqlh
heeb
g_ fh]ml ijbgbfZlv
jmdh\h^kl\h ^_ckl\byfbbeb \ha^_ckl\h\ZlvgZ qlheb[h ijyfh
h^gZdh hgb fh]ml\ha^_ckl\h\Zlv gZq_eh\_dZ dhk\_ggh>hg
OmZg kdZaZeqlh ijboh^blv\ dhglZdlk heebhiZkghlZd dZd
heeb fh]ml\u\_klb gZjm`mkZfh_ om^r__qlh _klv\ q_eh\_d_
Mq_gbq_kl\h a^_kv[u\Z_l ^he]bfb ljm^gufkdZaZe hgihlhfm
qlh g_h[oh^bfh k\_klb d fbgbfmfm\k_qlh g_ y\ey_lky
g_h[oh^bfuf \`bagb ^eylh]hqlh[u \u^_j`ZlvgZ]jmadm lZdhc
\klj_qb>hg OmZg kdZaZeqlh _]h [_g_nZdlhjdh]^Z hg
\i_j\u_ ijbr_e \dhglZdl kheeb[ue \ugm`^_g h[`_qvky b
ihemqbe lZdb_rjZfudZd [m^lh]hjguc e_\gZiZ^Ze gZ g_]h
Qlh dZkZ_lky_]h kZfh]hkdZaZe ^hgOmZglZd heeb lhedgme
_]h \ dmqm ]hjysbo m]e_cb hgg_fgh]h h[`_] dhe_gh b
ehiZldmgh rjZfubkq_aeb kh\j_f_g_fdh]^Z hgklZe kheeb
h^gbf p_euf
bxgy ]Y hlijZ\bekyk ^hghfOmZghf \ ^Zevg__
iml_r_kl\b_qlh[u mqZkl\h\Zlv\ fblhl_Y g_kdhevdhf_kyp_\
m`_ `^Ze lZdhc\hafh`ghklbh^gZdh yg_ [ue hdhgqZl_evgh
m\_j_gqlh yohqm _oZlvY ^mfZeqlh fhbdhe_[Zgby [ueb
\ua\Zgu kljZohfqlh gZfblhl_ y [m^m \ugm`^_g ]ehlZlv
i_chlZ m f_gy kh\k_f
g_ [ueh lZdh]h gZf_j_gbyY
g_h^ghdjZlgh jZatykgyek\hb qm\kl\Z^hgm OmZgmKgZqZeZ hg
l_ji_eb\h kf_yekyghgZdhg_phg l\_j^haZy\beqlh g_
`_eZ_l kemrZlv[hevr_ gbh^gh]h keh\Zh fhbokljZoZo
GZklhevdhgZkdhevdh y agZefblhl [ue b^_Zevguf
iheb]hghf ^ey lh]hqlh[u yfh] ijh\_jblvlm k\hx ko_fm
dhlhjmx y khklZ\beY \k_lZdb lZdb g_ [jhkbe iheghklvx
k\hx b^_x h kdjulhfeb^_j_ gZ lZdbo k[hjbsZoDZdbflh
h[jZahf mf_gy [ueZfukevqlh ^hgOmZg hl[jhkbefhx b^_xba
dZdbolh k\hbo
kh[kl\_gguo
khh[jZ`_gbcihkdhevdm hg
klj_fbeky h[tykgblv \k_qlh bf__lf_klh gZ fblhlZo\
l_jfbgZo
\b ^_ gv yY ^mfZeqlh fhcbgl_j_k \lhf
qlh[u gZclb ih^oh^ys__ h[tykg_gb_
\ k\hbo kh[kl\_gguo
l_jfbgZog_ khhl\_lkl\h\Ze lhfmqlh hgohl_e hl f_gy
ihwlhfm _fmb ijbrehkvhl[jhkblv fhb\u\h^udZd hg ijb\ud
^_eZlv kh\k_f l_fqlh g_ih^l\_j`^Zeh _]hkbkl_fm
DZd jZa i_j_^l_fdZd fuhlijZ\bebkv \ iml_r_kl\b_
^hg OmZgh[e_]qbe fhbkhfg_gby hlghkbl_evghih_^Zgby i_chlZ
kdZaZ\qlh y [m^mijbkmlkl\h\Zlv gZ\klj_q_ lhevdh ^ey
lh]hqlh[u gZ[ex^ZlvY ihqm\kl\h\Zeih^t_f< lh\j_fy y
[ue ihqlbm\_j_gqlh jZkdjhxkdjulmx ijhp_^mjmijb ihfhsb
dhlhjhc mqZklgbdbijboh^yl dkh]eZkbx
<j_fy reh m`_d \_q_jmdh]^Z fuhlijZ\bebkvKhegp_
ihqlb dhkgmehkv]hjbahglZy qm\kl\h\Ze_]h gZk\h_c r__ b
`Ze_eqlh mf_gy g_l\_g_pbZgkdhc rlhjdbgZ aZ^g_f kl_de_
fZrbguK \_jrbgu ohefZy fh]kfhlj_lv \gba gZ h]jhfgmx
jZ\gbgm^hjh]Z [ueZihoh`Z gZq_jgmx e_glmjZkkl_e_ggmx gZ
a_fe_\\_jo b\gba ih[_kqbke_gguf ohefZfY aZ k_dmg^m
ijhke_^be __]eZaZfb ij_`^_q_f fugZqZeb kimkdZlvkyhgZ
[_`ZeZ ijyfh gZ x] bbkq_aZeZ aZ jy^hf gbadbo ]hj gZ
]hjbahgl_
>hg OmZg kb^_ekihdhcgh]ey^y ijyfh \i_j_^>he]h_
\j_fy fug_ ijhjhgbebgb keh\ZFg_ [uehg_m^h[gh hl`Zju \
Z\lhfh[be_Y hldjue\k_ hdgZgh wlhg_ ihfh]ehihlhfm qlh
^_gv
[ue
bkdexqbl_evgh
`ZjdbfY
qm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y
bkdexqbl_evgh jZa^jZ`_ggufb [_kihdhcgufY klZe`Zeh\Zlvky
gZ `Zjm
>hg OmZgk^_eZe ]jbfZkmb \a]eygmegZ f_gybkiulmxs_
< wlh\j_fy ]h^Zih\kx^m \F_dkbd_ `ZjdhkdZaZe
hgk wlbfgbq_]h g_evayih^_eZlv
Y g_kfhlj_e gZg_]hgh agZeqlh hgke_^bl aZ fghc
FZrbgZ gZ[jZeZ kdhjhklvkdhevay \gbaih kdehgmY kfmlgh
m\b^_e ^hjh`gucagZd YZGh\u[hbgZDh]^Z y^_ckl\bl_evgh
m\b^_e moZ[y _oZe kebrdhf[ukljh bohly y k[jhkbe
kdhjhklvfu \k_`_ hsmlbeb_]h bih^kdhqbeb gZkb^_gvyoY
agZqbl_evgh mf_gvrbekdhjhklvfu _oZebq_j_a f_klghklv]^_
kdhl k\h[h^gh iZk_lkyih klhjhgZf^hjh]bf_klghklv]^_
ljmi ehrZ^b beb dhjh\uk[blhc Z\lhfh[be_f[ue h[uqguf
y\e_gb_f< h^ghff_kl_ fg_ijbrehkv hklZgh\blvky kh\k_f
qlh[u iha\heblvehrZ^b i_j_clb^hjh]m
Y klZe _s_[he__ [_kihdh_gb jZa^jZ`bl_e_gY kdZaZe
^hgm OmZgmqlh wlh`ZjZy kdZaZe_fmqlh fg_\k_]^Z g_
gjZ\beZkv `ZjZk kZfh]h^_lkl\Zihlhfm qlhdZ`^h_ e_lh y
qm\kl\h\Ze ^mohlmb _^\Zfh] ^urZlv
Gh l_i_jvlu g_j_[_ghdkdZaZe hg
@ZjZ \k__s_ m^mrZ_lf_gy
Qlh `]heh^ h[uqgh^mrbe f_gydh]^Z y[ue j_[_gdhf
kdZaZe hgfy]dh;ulv hq_gv]heh^guf wlh _^bgkl\_ggh_
qlh yagZe[m^mqb j_[_gdhfbeb `_fg_ kemqZehkvgZ_^Zlvky
lZdqlh yjZa^m\Zeky bg_ fh]^urZlvGh wlh[uehdh]^Z y
[ue j_[_gdhfL_i_jv y g_ fh]m aZ^uoZlvky b g_ fh]m
jZa^m\ZlvkydZd ]heh\Zklbddh]^Z y]heh^_g
Y g_agZeqlh kdZaZlvY aZ[bjZeky\ g_\_jgmxihabpbx
BlZd\kdhj_ fg_ijb^_lky hlklZb\ZlvlZdb_ lhqdbaj_gby^h
dhlhjuo fg_\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbg_l gbdZdh]h^_eZ@ZjZ [ueZ
g_ gZklhevdhm` g_kl_jibfZQlh f_gym^jmqZeh gZkZfhf ^_e_
lZd wlh i_jki_dlb\Z\_klb fZrbgmg_kdhevdh lukyq fbev ^h
p_eb gZr_]himl_r_kl\byY qm\kl\h\ZejZa^jZ`_gb_ ijbfukeb
qlh ijb^_lkymlhfeylvky
>Z\Zc hklZgh\bfkyb dmibfqlhgb[m^v ih_klvkdZaZe
yFh`_l [ulvdh]^Z khegp_ky^_llZdhc `Zjug_ [m^_l
>hg OmZg \a]eygmegZ f_gymeu[Zykvb kdZaZeqlh \
l_q_gb_ ^ebl_evgh]h hlj_adZ \j_f_gbg_ [m^_l gb h^gh]h
]hjh^dZ b qlhhg ihgbfZ_lfhx iheblbdmdhlhjZy khklhbl \
lhfqlh[u g__klv gbq_]h\ ijb^hjh`guo[mn_lZo
JZa\_ lu[hevr_ g_[hbrvky ^ba_gl_jbb"kijhkbe hg
Y agZeqlh wlh _]hkZjdZafh^gZdhhg khojZgye
\hijhkbl_evguc b\ lh`_ \j_fyk_jv_aguc \a]ey^
LhdZd luihklmiZ_rvkdZaZe hggZ\h^bl gZfukev
qlh ^ba_gl_jby lZd b jukdZ_l\hdjm]h`b^Zydh]^Z lu
\uc^_rv bafZrbguqlh[u gZ[jhkblvkygZ l_[yLu \ m`Zkghf
iheh`_gbb_keb l_[_ m^Zklky m[_`Zlvhl `Zjulh l_[y
gZ\_jgydZ ihcfZ_l^ba_gl_jby
Lhg ^hgZ OmZgZ [uegZklhevdh k_jv_a_gqlh y gZqZe
kf_ylvkyAZl_f fu ^he]h_ \j_fy_oZeb fheqZDh]^Z fu
ijb[ueb gZ klhygdmZ\lhfZrbg ih^gZa\Zgb_f Ehk <b^jbhk kl_deh[ueh m`_l_fgh
>hg OmZgaZdjbqZe bafZrbgu
Qlh m\Zk _klvk_]h^gy gZm`bg"
K\bgbgZdjbdgmeZ `_gsbgZbagmljb
JZ^b l_[yy gZ^_xkvqlh k\bgvyihiZeZ ih^ fZrbgm
k_]h^gykf_ykv kdZaZefg_ ^hgOmZg
Fu \ureb ba fZrbgu>hjh]Z
k h[_bo klhjhg [ueZ
h]jZ`^_gZ p_iyfb gbadbo ]hjdhlhju_ dZaZebkv aZklu\r_c
eZ\hc dZdh]hlh ]b]Zglkdh]h\medZgbq_kdh]h ba\_j`_gby<
l_fghl_ q_jgu_am[qZlu_ kbemwluibdh\ gZnhg_ g_[ZdZaZebkv
h]jhfgufb m]jh`ZxsbfbhkdhedZfb kl_deZ
IhdZ fu _eby kdZaZe^hgm OmZgmqlh m\b^_e ijbqbgm
lh]hqlh wlhf_klh gZau\Z_lkykl_dehY kdZaZeqlh fg_
ykghqlh wlh gZa\Zgb_ h[yaZgh nhjf_ ]hjihoh`bo gZ
h]jhfgh_ kl_deh
>hg OmZg kdZaZem[_`^_gghqlh f_klh gZau\Z_lky Ehk
<b^jbhkihlhfm qlh]jmah\bd khkl_dehf i_j_\_jgmekygZ wlhf
f_kl_b [blh_kl_deh ^he]b_]h^u hklZ\Zehkva^_kv \Zeylvky
Y qm\kl\h\Zeqlh hgrmlblb ihijhkbe_]h kdZaZlvfg_
^_ckl\bl_evgh ebijbqbgZ gZa\Zgby[ueZ \wlhf
Ihq_fm lu g_kijhkbrv dh]hgb[m^v ba f_klguo"
kijhkbe hg
Y kijhkbeq_eh\_dZdhlhjuc kb^_eaZ khk_^gbfklhebdhf
Hg ba\bgyxsbfkylhghf kdZaZeqlh g_agZ_lY ihr_egZ
dmogx bkijhkbe `_gsbg[u\rbo lZfagZxl ebhgbgh \k_hgb
g_ agZebijhklh wlhf_klhfhegZau\Z_lky kl_deh
Y iheZ]Zxqlh y ijZ\kdZaZe ^hg OmZg
f_dkbdZgpu g_ h^Zj_gu kihkh[ghklvxaZf_qZlv \_sb \hdjm]
k_[yY m\_j_gqlh hgbg_ fh]ebaZf_lblv kl_deygguo]hjgh
hgb gZ\_jgydZ fh]ebhklZ\blv ]hjm[blh]h kl_deZ \Zeylvky
g_kdhevdh e_l
H[Z fugZreb dZjlbgmaZ[Z\ghc bjZkkf_yebkvDh]^Z fu
dhgqbeb _klv^hg OmZgkijhkbe f_gydZd yk_[y qm\kl\mxY
kdZaZeohjhrhgh gZkZfhf ^_e_ y qm\kl\h\Ze dZdmxlh
g_eh\dhklv>hg OmZg ijbklZevgh
ihkfhlj_e gZ f_gy b
dZaZehkvaZf_lbe fh_qm\kl\h g_m^h[kl\Z
JZa luijb_oZe \F_dkbdmlu ^he`_ghleh`blv \k_k\hb
ex[bfu_ kljZob ijhqvkdZaZe hghq_gv `_kldhl\h_
j_r_gb_ ijb_oZlv^he`gh [uehjZa\_ylv boLu ijb_oZeihlhfm
qlh luohl_e ijb_oZlvWlh imlv\hbgZY ]h\hjxl_[_ \gh\vb
\gh\vkZfuc wnn_dlb\guckihkh[ `blvwlh `blvdZd \hbg
=hjxc b^mfZc ij_`^_q_f luk^_eZ_rv dZdh_eb[h j_r_gb_gh
_keb lu_]h k^_eZelh [m^vgZ k\h_fimlb k\h[h^gufhl aZ[hl
b fuke_c;m^_l fbeebhg^jm]bo j_r_gbc_s_ h`b^Zlvl_[y<
wlhf imlv\hbgZ
Y ^mfZxqlh lZd b ^_eZx^hg OmZgohly [u
\j_f_gZfbWlh hq_gvljm^gh \k_lZdb ijh^he`Zlv ihfgblv
k_[y
Dh]^Z \_sbklZgh\ylky g_ykgufb\hbg ^mfZ_lh k\h_c
kf_jlb
Wlh _s_ ljm^g__^hg OmZg>ey [hevrbgkl\Z ex^_c
kf_jlv wlh qlhlh hq_gvg_ykgh_ b^Ze_dh_Fu gbdh]^Z h
g_c g_^mfZ_f
Ihq_fm `_g_ ^mfZ_l_"
Gh aZq_fwlh gm`gh"
Hq_gv ijhklhkdZaZe hgihlhfm qlhb^_y kf_jlb
wlh _^bgkl\_ggZy\_svdhlhjZy mdjhsZ_lgZr ^mo
D lhfm\j_f_gbdZd fuihdbgmeb Ehk<b^jbhk[ueh lZd
l_fghqlh am[qZlu_kbemwlu ]hjjZkl\hjbebkv \g_[_;hevr_
qZkZ fu _oZeb \
fheqZgbbY ihqm\kl\h\Ze mklZehklv
DZaZehkvqlh y g_ ohqm]h\hjblvihlhfm qlh g_ h q_f
jZa]h\Zjb\Zlv>\b`_gb_ [uehfbgbfZevgufG_kdhevdh fZrbg
ijhreh gZf gZ\klj_qmDZaZehkvqlh fu[ueb _^bgkl\_ggufb
ex^vfb_^msbfb ih rhkk_gZ x]Fg_ ih^mfZehkvqlh wlh
kljZgghb yijh^he`Ze ih]ey^u\Zlv\ a_jdZehaZ^g_]h h[ahjZ
qlh[u m\b^_lvg_l eb^jm]bo fZrbgb^msbo kaZ^bgh bo g_
[ueh
Q_j_a g_dhlhjh_ \j_fyy i_j_klZe\ubkdb\Zlv fZrbgu b
\gh\v klZe ^mfZlv hi_jki_dlb\Zo gZr_cih_a^dbAZl_f y
aZf_lbeqlh k\_l fhbonZj kebrdhfyjdbc ih kjZ\g_gbx k
l_fghlhc \hdjm]b yhiylv \a]eygme\ a_jdZehKgZqZeZ y
m\b^_e yjdh_kbygb_Z aZl_f^\_ b]euk\_lZ \uj\ZebkvdZd [u
baih^ a_febWlh [uebnZju fZrbgugZ \_jrbg_ohefZ ihaZ^b
gZkG_dhlhjh_ \j_fy hgb [ueb \b^guaZl_f bkq_aeb \
l_fghl_dZd _keb[u hgb[ueb \udexq_guq_j_a k_dmg^m hgb
ihy\bebkv gZ^jm]hf [m]j_Z aZl_fbkq_aeb \gh\vY ^he]h_
\j_fy ke_^be aZbo ihy\e_gbyfbb bkq_agh\_gbyfbJZa fg_
klZeh \b^ghqlh fZrbgZ gZ]hgy_l gZkHgZ hij_^_e_ggh
ijb[eb`ZeZkvH]gb [ueb [hevr_b yjq_Y klZe gZ`bfZlv
kbevg__ gZi_^Zev ]ZaZM f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hg_eh\dhklb>hg
OmZgdZaZehkvaZf_lbegZ qlhy h[jZsZx \gbfZgb_Z
fh`_lhg aZf_lbe lhevdhlhqlh y m\_ebqb\Zx kdhjhklv
KgZqZeZ hg\a]eygme gZf_gyaZl_f hgih\_jgmeky bihkfhlj_e
gZ h]gbnZj \hl^Ze_gbb
Hg kijhkbe\k_ ebkh fghc\ ihjy^d_Y kdZaZe_fmqlh
y ^he]h_ \j_fy g_ aZf_qZeihaZ^b gZk gbdZdbo fZrbgb
\g_aZigh aZf_lbe nZju fZrbgudhlhjZy gZ]hgy_l gZkHg
ofudgme b kijhkbef_gy^_ckl\bl_evgh eby ^mfZxqlh wlh
fZrbgZY hl\_lbeqlh wlh^he`gZ [ulvfZrbgZb hgkdZaZe
qlh fh_ hlghr_gb_ dwlhfm k\_lmihdZau\Z_l _fmqlh y
^he`gh [ulvdZdlh ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh qlh[u lZf gb [ueh
ihaZ^b gZkgh wlh[hevr_q_f ijhklhfZrbgZY gZklZb\Ze
qlhfg_ dZ`_lkywlh ijhklh^jm]Zy fZrbgZgZ rhkk_ beb
fh`_l]jmah\bd
Qlh `__s_ wlhfh`_l [ulv"]jhfdh kdZaZey
GZf_db ^hgZOmZgZ ijb\_ebf_gy gZ]jZgv kju\Z
Hg ih\_jgmeky b ihkfhlj_eijyfh gZ f_gyaZl_f hg
f_^e_ggh db\gmedZd _keb[u baf_jyelhqlh kh[bjZ_lky
kdZaZlv
Wlh h]gb gZ]heh\_ kf_jlbkdZaZe hg fy]dh
kf_jlv gZ^_\Z_l bodZd reyimZ aZl_f[jhkZ_lky \ ]Zehi
Wlh h]gb kf_jlbg_kms_cky ]ZehihfgZklb]Zxs_c gZk b
klZgh\ys_cky \k_[eb`_ b[eb`_
M f_gyih kibg_ih[_`Zeb fmjZrdbQ_j_a g_dhlhjh_\j_fy
y \gh\v\a]eygme \a_jdZeh aZ^g_]hh[ahjZgh h]g_c [hevr_
g_ [uehY kdZaZe^hgm OmZgmqlh fZrbgZ^he`gh [ulv
hklZgh\beZkv beb k\_jgmeZ k^hjh]bHg g_ klZe kfhlj_lv
gZaZ^hg ijhklh\ulygme jmdbb a_\gme
G_lkdZsZe hgkf_jlv gbdh]^Zg_ hklZgZ\eb\Z_
lkyBgh]^Z hgZ\udexqZ_l k\hbh]gblhevdh b\k_]h
Fu ijb_oZeb \k_\_jh\hklhqgmx F_dkbdmbxgy>\_
ihoh`b_ ^jm]gZ ^jm]Z`_gsbgudZaZ\rb_ky k_kljZfbb q_luj_
^_\hqdb kh[jZebkvm ^\_j_cg_[hevrh]h kZfZggh]h^hfZIhaZ^b
^hfZ [ueb ijbkljhcdZ b kZjZc k ^\mkdZlghc djur_chl
dhlhjh]h hklZebkv ebrvqZklv djurbb h^gZkl_gZ@_gsbgu
hq_\b^gh`^Zeb gZkhgb\b^bfhaZf_lbeb fZrbgmih klhe[m
iuebdhlhjuc hgZih^gbfZeZ gZ]jmglh\hc ^hjh]_ihke_ lh]h
dZd g_kdhevdhfbev jZg__y k\_jgmek rhkk_>hf gZoh^beky\
]em[hdhc ^hebg_b_keb kfhlj_lvhl g_]h^hjh]Z dZaZeZkv
^ebgguf rjZfhfih^gbfZ\rbfky \ukhdh\\_jo ihkdehgm a_e_guo
ohefh\
>hg OmZg \ur_eba fZrbgub kfbgmlm jZa]h\Zjb\Ze kh
klZjufb `_gsbgZfbHgb ihdZaZebgZ ^_j_\yggu_klmevy i_j_^
^\_jvx>hg OmZgk^_eZe fg_agZd ih^hclbb k_klvH^gZ ba
klZjuo `_gsbg k_eZ k gZfbhklZevgu_ \hreb \ ^hf>\_
^_\mrdb hklZgh\bebkvhdheh ^\_jbk ex[hiulkl\hfjZa]ey^u\Zy
f_gyY ihfZoZebfHgb obobdgmebb m[_`Zeb\gmljvQ_j_a
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy\ureb ^\h_fheh^uo ex^_cb iha^hjh\Zebkv k
^hghf OmZghfHgb g_]h\hjbeb khfghc b^Z`_ g_kfhlj_eb gZ
f_gyHgb dhjhldhqlhlh jZkkdZaZeb^hgm OmZgmaZl_f hg
ih^gyekyb \k_fu\dexqZy `_gsbgihreb d^jm]hfm ^hfm
\_jhylgh \ihemfbe_ hlwlh]h
LZf fu \klj_lbebkvk ^jm]hc]jmiihc ex^_c>hg OmZg
\hr_e \gmljvgh fg_\_e_e hklZlvkym ^\_jbY aZ]eygme
\gmljv b m\b^_eklZjh]h bg^_cpZijbf_jgh \ \hajZkl_ ^hgZ
OmZgZdhlhjuc kb^_egZ ^_j_\ygghfklme_
;ueh _s_ g_kh\k_f l_fgh=jmiiZ fheh^uo bg^_cp_\ b
bg^_Zghd kihdhcgh klhyeZ \hdjm]klZjh]h ]jmah\bdZ hdheh
^hfZY aZ]h\hjbe kgbfb ihbkiZgkdbgh hgb gZf_j_ggh
ba[_]Zeb hl\_qZlvfg_`_gsbgu obobdZebdZ`^uc jZadh]^Z y
qlheb[h ]h\hjbeZ fm`qbgu\_`eb\h meu[Zebkv b hl\h^beb
]eZaZDZaZehkvhgb f_gy g_ihgbfZebb \k_ `_ y [ue
m\_j_gqlh g_dhlhju_ba gbo]h\hjyl ihbkiZgkdblZd dZdy
keurZe bojZa]h\hj f_`^mkh[hc
Q_j_a g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy^hg OmZgb ^jm]hcklZjbd \ureb
gZjm`maZ[jZebkv \]jmah\bd bk_eb jy^hfk rhn_jhfWlh
hdZaZehkv agZdhf^ey \k_ohklZevguo aZ[jZlvky\ dmah\LZf
g_ [ueh[hdh\h]h h]jZ`^_gbyb dh]^Z]jmah\bd ljhgmekyfu
\k_ mp_ibebkv aZ ^ebggmx\_j_\dmijb\yaZggmx d djxqdZf
\hdjm] ieZlnhjfu
=jmah\bd f_^e_ggh^\b]Zeky ih]jmglh\hc ^hjh]_< h^ghf
f_kl_ gZhq_gv djmlhfkdehg_ hghklZgh\bekyb \k_khkdhqbeb
b ihreb aZ gbfaZl_f ^\h_ fheh^uo ex^_c \kdhqbeb gZ
ieZlnhjfm b k_eb gZ djZx^_j`Zkv aZ \_j_\dm@_gsbgu
kf_yebkv b ih^[Z^jb\Zeb boqlh[
l_ m^_j`b\Zeb k\h_
g_mklhcqb\h_ jZ\gh\_kb_
>hg OmZg bklZjbdd dhlhjhfmh[jZsZebkvdZd d ^hgm
Kbev\bhreb lh`_ihaZ^bb bfdZaZehkvg_ [ueh^_eZ ^h
\udjmlZkh\ fheh^uoDh]^Z ^hjh]Z\ujh\gyeZkv\k_ kgh\Z
aZ[jZebkv gZ]jmah\bd
Fu _oZeb hdhehqZkZIhe [uebkdexqbl_evgh l\_j^uf b
g_m^h[gufihwlhfm yklhye b^_j`Zeky aZdjurm dZ[bgdb b
_oZe lZdbfh[jZahf ^hl_o ihjihdZ fug_ hklZgh\bebkvi_j_^
]jmiihc ob`bgLZf [ueb_s_ ex^bD wlhfm \j_f_gb klZeh
^h\hevgh l_fghb yfh] jZa]ey^_lvlhevdh g_kdhevdboba gbo
\ lmkdehf`_elh\Zlhf k\_l_d_jhkbgh\hc eZfiudhlhjZy \bk_eZ
m hldjulhc^\_jb
<k_ khreb kfZrbgu bkf_rZebkv kex^vfb \^hfZo>hg
OmZg hiylv \_e_efg_ hklZ\ZlvkykgZjm`bY h[ehdhlbeky h
i_j_^g__ djueh ]jmah\bdZb q_j_ah^gm^\_ fbgmlu dh fg_
ijbkh_^bgbebkv _s_ ljh_ fheh^uoex^_cH^gh]h ba gbo y
\klj_qZe q_luj_ ]h^ZgZaZ^ gZij_^u^ms_f fblhl_Hg h[gye
f_gy\ay\ aZie_qb
Lu fheh^_pijhr_ilZe hgfg_ ihbkiZgkdb
Fu hq_gv lbohklhyeb hdheh]jmah\bdZY fh] keurZlv
fy]dh_ [mevdZgv_jmqvy ih[ebahklbFhc ijbyl_evkijhkbe f_gy
r_ihlhfg_l eb mf_gy kb]Zj_lY ij_^eh`be hdjm`Zxsbf
iZqdmIjb k\_l_ kb]Zj_luy \a]eygmegZ k\hb qZku;ueh
qZkh\
=jmiiZ ex^_c\ureZ ba^hfZ \kdhj_ihke_ wlh]hb ljh_
fheh^uo ex^_cmreb>hg OmZgih^hr_e dhfg_ bkdZaZeqlh hg
h[tykgbe fh_ ijbkmlkl\b_a^_kv dh[s_fm m^b\e_gbxb qlh
f_gy ijb]eZrZxl h[kem`b\Zlv \h^hcmqZklgbdh\ fblhlZHg
kdZaZeqlh fuk_cqZk \uoh^bf
=jmiiZ ba `_gsbg bfm`qbg \ureZ ba ^hfZBo
ij_^\h^bl_ev [ue ^h\hevghdjy`bkluce_l fm`qbgZHgb
gZau\Zeb _]h fhqhijha\bs_dhlhjh_ hagZqZ_l mk_q_ggucHg ^\b]Zekyklj_fbl_evgufb l\_j^ufbrZ]ZfbHg
g_k d_jhkbgh\ucnhgZjv bihfZob\Ze bfba klhjhgu\ klhjhgm
gZ oh^mKgZqZeZ y^mfZeqlh hgfZr_l nhgZj_fijhklh lZd
aZl_f aZf_lbeqlh
\afZohf
nhgZjy
hg
mdZau\Z_l gZ
dZdh_gb[m^v ij_iylkl\b_beb ljm^gh_f_klh gZ^hjh]_Fu reb
[hevr_ qZkZ@_gsbgu [helZebb \j_fyhl \j_f_gb kf_yebkv
>hg OmZgb \lhjhcklZjbd [ueb\h ]eZ\_ijhp_kkbby `_[ue \
kZfhf dhgp___Y g_kimkdZe ]eZak ^hjh]biulZykv m\b^_lv
dm^Z klmiZxIjhreh m`_]h^Z kl_o ihjdZd ^hgOmZg b y
[ueb \ ]hjZo ghqvxb yihl_jye hq_gv fgh]h nbabq_kdhc
\ughkeb\hklbY g_ij_ju\ghkihludZekyb baih^ gh]m f_gy
e_l_eb dZfgbFhb dhe_gbkh\k_f ihl_jyeb]b[dhklv^hjh]Z
dZaZehkv [jhkZeZkvgZ f_gydh]^Z ymibjZeky \[m]hjhdbeb
ijh\Zeb\ZeZkv ih^hfghcdh]^Z ygZklmiZe \\u[hbgmY [ue
kZfuf rmfguf i_r_oh^hfb wlhg_\hevgh ^_eZeh ba f_gy
dehmgZDlhgb[m^v \]jmii_ h[yaZl_evgh]h\hjbe modh]^Z
y kihludZekyb \k_kf_yebkvH^bg jZadZf_gvdhlhjuc y
g_qZyggh igme gh]hcihiZe \iyldm `_gsbg_b hgZ ]jhfdh
kdZaZeZ dh \k_h[s_fmm^h\hevkl\bx^Zcl_ k\_qdm [_^ghfm
fZevqbdmGh ihke_^gbfbkiulZgb_f ^eyf_gy [uehdh]^Z y
hklmibeky b\ugm`^_g [ueko\Zlblvky aZb^ms_]h \i_j_^bhg
qmlv g_ ihl_jye jZ\gh\_kb_ ih^ fh_c ly`_klvx b ba^Ze
kh\_jr_ggh g_Z^_d\Zlguc gZjhqbluc\ba]<k_ lZd kf_yebkv
qlh ]jmiiZ^he`gZ [ueZgZ \j_fyhklZgh\blvky
GZdhg_p q_eh\_ddhlhjuc [ue\_^msbffZogme k\h_c
eZfihc \\_job \gbaWlhdZaZehkv[ue agZdqlh fuijb[ueb
d f_klm gZagZq_gbyKijZ\Z hlf_gyg_ih^Ze_dm [ue l_fguc
kbemwl gbadh]h ^hfZ<k_ ijbr_^rb_ jZahrebkv \ jZaguo
gZijZ\e_gbyoY ihbkdZe^hgZ OmZgZ?]h [uehljm^gh gZclb\
l_fghl_Y g_dhlhjh_\j_fy [jh^bermfgh gZludZykvgZ \k_
ihdZ g_aZf_lbeqlh hgkb^bl gZdZfg_Hg hiylvkdZaZe fg_
qlh fhc ^he] [m^_l\ lhfqlh[u ih^ghkblv\h^m l_fdlh
mqZkl\m_l \ fblhl_Wlhc ijhp_^mj_hg h[mqbe f_gy m`_
g_kdhevdh e_lgZaZ^Y ihfgbedZ`^mx ^_lZevgh hggZklZb\Ze
gZ lhfqlh[ hk\_`blviZfylv b\gh\v ihdZaZefg_dZd wlh
^_eZ_lky
AZl_f fuijhreb \aZ^gxx qZklv^hfZ]^_ kh[jZebkv\k_
Hgb jZa\_ebdhkl_jIjbf_jgh \f_ljZo hldhkljZ [ueqbkluc
mqZklhdihdjuluc khehf_ggufbpbgh\dZfbFhqh q_eh\_d
dhlhjuc gZk \_ek_e gZpbgh\dm i_j\ufy aZf_lbeqlh m
g_]h hlkmlkl\m_l\_jogyy iheh\bgZe_\h]h moZqlh h[tykgyeh
ijbqbgm ihy\e_gby _]hijha\bsZ>hg Kbev\bhk_e kijZ\Z hl
g_]hZ ^hgOmZg ke_\Z
Fhqh kb^_eebphf dh]gxFheh^hc q_eh\_dijb[ebabeky d
g_fm b iheh`be i_j_^gbf iehkdmx dhjabgm k [ZlhgqbdZfb
i_chlZaZl_f wlhlfheh^hc q_eh\_dk_e f_`^mfhqh b ^hghf
Kbev\bh>jm]hc fheh^hcq_eh\_d ijbg_k^\_ [hevrb_dhjabgdb
ihklZ\be bojy^hf ki_chlgufb [ZlhgqbdZfbb k_ef_`^m fhqhb
^hghf OmZghfAZl_f _s_^\h_ fheh^uoex^_c k_eb ih [hdZf
^hgZ Kbev\bhb ^hgZOmZgZh[jZah\Z\ djm`hdba k_fbq_eh\_d
@_gsbgu hklZebkv \gmljb^hfZH[yaZgghklvx ^\hbo fheh^uo
ex^_c [ueh ih^^_j`b\Zlv h]hgv dhkljZ\kx ghqvZ h^bg
ih^jhklhd by ^he`gu[ueb ojZgblv\h^mdhlhjZy ^he`gZ[ulv
^ZgZ k_fb mqZklgbdZf ihke_ bo
ghqgh]h jblmZeZFu k
fZevqbdhf k_ebm dZfgyH]hgv bkhkm^ k\h^hc gZoh^bebkvgZ
jZ\ghf jZkklhygbbhl djm]ZmqZklgbdh\
Fhqh \_^msbc aZi_e k\hxi_chlgmx i_kgx_]h ]eZaZ
[ueb aZdjulu_]h l_ehihdZqb\Zehkv \\_job \gbaWlh [ueZ
hq_gv ^ebggZyi_kgyYaudZ yg_ ihgbfZeAZl_f \k_hklZevgu_
ijhi_eb k\hb i_chlgu_i_kgbHgbhq_\b^ghg_ ke_^h\Zeb
gbdZdhfm ij_^mklZgh\e_gghfmihjy^dmHgb y\ghi_ebdZ`^uc
lh]^Zdh]^Z hgqm\kl\h\Ze dwlhfm ihlj_[ghklv
AZl_f fhqh\aye dhjabgmk i_chlgufb[ZlhgqbdZfb\aye
^\Z bagbo biheh`be __hiylv \p_glj_ djm]ZKe_^mxsbf [ue
^hg Kbev\bhZ aZl_f ^hgOmZgQ_l\_jh fheh^uo ex^_c
dhlhju_dZaZehkv[ueb hl^_evghc]jmiihc\ayeb dZ`^uc ih
^\Z [ZlhgqbdZih hq_j_^bijhlb\ qZkh\hcklj_edb
DZ`^uc ba k_fbmqZklgbdh\ ki_eb kt_eih [ZlhgqbdZ
i_chlZ ihke_^h\Zl_evgh jZaZAZl_f hgbimklbeb ih djm]m
^jm]b_ ^\_ fZe_gvdb_dhjabgdb kkmobfb njmdlZfbb kmr_guf
fykhf
Wlhl pbdehgb ih\lhjyeb\ jZaebqgh_\j_fy ghqbh^gZdh
y g_ kfh] mkfhlj_lvdZdh]hgb[m^v kdjulh]hihjy^dZ \ bo
bg^b\b^mZevguo ^\b`_gbyoHgb g_
jZa]h\Zjb\Zeb ^jm] k
^jm]hfhgb kdhj__[ueb kZfbih k_[_b kZfb^ey k_[yY gb
jZam g_ \b^_eqlh[u dlhgb[m^v bagbo ohly[u h^bg jZa
h[jZlbe \gbfZgb_gZ lhqlh ^_eZxlhklZevgu_
I_j_^ jZkk\_lhf hgbih^gyebkvb fuk fheh^uf iZjg_f
^Zeb bf \h^mIhke_ wlh]hy \ur_eijhclbkv \hdjm]qlh[u
khjb_glbjh\Zlvky>hf [ue h^ghdhfgZlghc ob`bghcgbadbf
kZfZgguf khhjm`_gb_fk djur_cba o\hjhklZHdjm`Zxsbc i_caZ`
[ue hq_gvih^Z\eyxsbfOb`bgZ [ueZjZkiheh`_gZ \ ohefbklhc
jZ\gbg_ khkf_rZgghc jZklbl_evghklvxDmklZjgbdb b dZdlmku
jhkeb \i_j_f_`dmgh ^_j_\v_\g_ [ueh kh\_jr_gghY g_
bkiulu\Ze `_eZgbym^Zeylvky hl^hfZ
Mljhf `_gsbgu mrebFm`qbgu \fheqZgbb i_j_^\b]Zebkv
\[ebab ^hfZHdheh ihem^gy \k_fu hiylvk_eb \ lhf `_
ihjy^d_dZd bij_^u^ms_c ghqvx
DhjabgZ kkmr_guf fykhfgZj_aZgguf gZdmkdb lZdhc `_
\_ebqbguqlh b[Zlhgqbdb i_chlZihreZ ihdjm]mG_dhlhju_
ba fm`qbgi_eb k\hbi_chlgu_ i_kgbQ_j_a qZkbeb hdhehlh]h
\k_ hgbih^gyebkv bjZahrebkv \jZagu_ klhjhgu
@_gsbgu hklZ\beb ]hjrhddZrb ^eyl_odlh ke_^bl aZ
h]g_f b\h^hcY g_fgh]hih_eZ aZl_fijhkiZe [hevrmxqZklv
\lhjhc iheh\bgu^gy
Ihke_ lh]hdZd kl_fg_ehfheh^u_ ex^bhl\_lkl\_ggu_
aZ h]hgvjZa\_eb hiylvdhkl_jb pbde ih_^Zgby i_chlZ
gZqZeky \gh\vHg ijbf_jghr_e ihlhfm `_ihjy^dmqlh b
ij_^u^ms_c ghqvxb dhgqbekygZ jZkk\_l_
< l_q_gb_\k_c ghqby klZjZekygZ[ex^Zlv b aZibku\Zlv
dZ`^h_ hl^_evgh_ ^\b`_gb_ dZ`^h]hba k_fb mqZlkgbdh\ \
gZ^_`^_ jZkdjulv fZe_crmxnhjfm \b^bfhckbkl_fu keh\_kghc
beb [_kkeh\_kghck\yab f_`^mgbfbH^gZdh\ bo^_ckl\byo g_
[ueh gbq_]hqlh mdZau\Zeh[u gZkdjulmx kbkl_fm
< gZqZe_ \_q_jZ pbde ih_^Zgby i_chlZ \hah[gh\beky
hiylvD mljmy agZeqlh ihl_ji_eihegmx g_m^Zqm\ ihiuldZo
gZclb dexqbmdZau\Zxsb_ gZkdjulh]h eb^_jZbeb jZkdjulv
ohlv dZdmxgb[m^v nhjfmkdjulhc dhffmgbdZpbbf_`^m gbfbbeb
dZdb_eb[h ke_^ubo kbkl_fukh]eZr_gby<_kv hklZlhd^gy y
kb^_eijb\h^y \ihjy^hd k\hbaZibkb
Dh]^Z fm`qbgukh[jZebkv hiylv^ey q_l\_jlhcghqblh y
dZdbflh h[jZahf agZeqlh wlZ\klj_qZ [m^_l ihke_^g_c
Gbdlh gbq_]hh[ wlhfg_ ]h\hjbefg_h^gZdh yagZeqlh gZ
ke_^mxsbc ^_gv hgb\k_ jZat_^mlkyY \gh\vk_e m \h^ub
dZ`^uc aZgyek\h_ f_klh\ lhfihjy^d_dZdhc [uemklZgh\e_g
jZg__
Ih\_^_gb_ k_fbq_eh\_d \djm]m [uehih\lhj_gb_f lh]h
qlh y\b^_e ljbij_^u^msb_ ghqbY mr_e\ gZ[ex^_gb_aZ bo
^\b`_gbyfblZd`_dZd y^_eZe jZg__Y ohl_eaZibkZlv \k_
qlh hgb^_eZebdZ`^h_ ^\b`_gb_dZ`^uc `_kldZ`^uc a\md
< dZdhclh fhf_gly mkeurZek\h_]h jh^Z]m^_gb_ \mrZo
Wlh [uehh[uqguf a\hghf\ mrZob yg_ ijb^Ze_fm agZq_gby
=m^_gb_ klZeh ]jhfq_h^gZdh hgh\k_ _s_[ueh \ ]jZgbpZo
fhbo l_e_kguo hsms_gbcY ihfgxqlh klZe ^_eblv k\h_
\gbfZgb_ f_`^m ex^vfbaZ dhlhjufby gZ[ex^Zeb a\mdhf
dhlhjuc y keurZeAZl_f \hij_^_e_gguc fhf_gl ebpZ ex^_c
klZebdZaZehkvyjq_dZd [m^lh[u \dexqbebk\_lGh wlh
[ueh g_kh\k_f lZddZd _keb[u \dexqbebwe_dljbq_kdbc k\_l
beb aZ`]eb eZfimbeb dZd_keb [ubo ebpZ hk\_sZe k\_l
dhkljZWlh kdhj__[ueh ihoh`_gZ exfbgbkp_gpbxjhah\h_
k\_q_gb_hq_gv jZafulh_gh aZf_lgh_k lh]hf_klZ]^_ y
kb^_e=medZaZehkvm\_ebqbekyY \a]eygmegZ ih^jhkldZ
dhlhjuc [uekh fghcgh lhlkiZe
D lhfm \j_f_gb jhah\h_
k\_q_gb_ klZeh _s_ [he__
aZf_lgufY \a]eygmegZ ^hgZOmZgZ?]h ]eZaZ[ueb aZdjulu
lZd `_[ueb aZdjulu]eZaZ m^hgZ Kbev\bhb mfhqhY g_fh]
\b^_lv ]eZaZq_luj_o fheh^uoex^_cihlhfm qlh^\h_ ba gbo
kdehgbebkv \i_j_^Z ^\h_kb^_eb kibghcdh fg_
Y _s_[hevr_ mr_e\ gZ[ex^_gb_H^gZdhy _s_iheghklvx
g_ ihgyeqlh y^_ckl\bl_evgh keurm]m^_gb_ b^_ckl\bl_evgh
\b`m jhah\h_ k\_q_gb_ho\Zlu\Zxs__ ex^_cQ_j_a fbgmlm y
khh[jZabeqlh jZafulucjhah\uc k\_lb ]m^_gb_[ueb hq_gv
ihklhygguY i_j_`befhf_gl kbevg_cr_]haZf_rZl_evkl\ZZ
aZl_f fg_ijbreZ \]heh\m fukevgbq_]h h[s_]hg_ bf_xsZyk
hdjm`Zxsbf b ijhbkoh^ysbfdZd bk lhcp_evxdhlhjmx y
ihklZ\be k_[_gZoh^ykv lmlY \kihfgbeh^gm \_svdhlhjmx
fhy fZlvkdZaZeZ fg_dh]^Z y[ue j_[_gdhf
Fukev [ueZhl\e_dZxs_c bhq_gv g_mf_klghcy ihiulZeky
hlh]gZlv __ b\gh\v aZgylvkygZ[ex^_gb_fgh g_fh] wlh]h
k^_eZlvFukev \ha\jZsZeZkvHgZ klZgh\beZkvkbevg__ b[he__
lj_[h\Zl_evghcb aZl_fy y\ghmkeurZe ]hehkfh_c fZl_jb
dhlhjZy iha\ZeZf_gyY mkeurZere_iZgv_ __lZihq_d baZl_f
__ kf_oY h]eygmekybsZ __Fg_ ij_^klZ\behkvqlh
[eZ]h^Zjy dZdhfmlh fbjZ`m beb ]ZeexpbgZpbb y ihg_kmkv
k_cqZk \h \j_f_gbb ijhkljZgkl\_b m\b`m__gh y m\b^_e
lhevdh kb^ys_]h ih^jhkldZLhqlh ym\b^_e _]h jy^hf k
kh[hc\kljyogmeh f_gyb ybkiulZe dhjhldbcfhf_gl e_]dhklb
b lj_a\hklb
Y hiylv ihkfhlj_e gZ]jmiim fm`qbgHgb kh\k_f g_
baf_gbeb k\h_]h iheh`_gbyH^gZdh k\_l ijhiZe b lZd`_
ijhiZeh ]m^_gb_m f_gy\ mrZoY ihqm\kl\h\Zeh[e_]q_gb_Y
ih^mfZeqlh ]ZeexpbgZpby\ dhlhjhcy keurZe]hehk k\h_c
fZl_jbijhreZ?_ ]hehk[ue lZdbfykguf b`b\ufY \gh\vb
\gh\v ^mfZeqlh gZf]gh\_gb_ wlhl]hehk qmlv g_ ihcfZe
f_gyY f_evdhfaZf_lbeqlh ^hgOmZg kfhljblgZ f_gygh
wlh g_bf_eh agZq_gby
F_gy ]bighlbabjh\Zeh\hkihfbgZgb_ h]hehk_ fh_cfZl_jb
iha\Z\r_f f_gyY hlqZyggh klZjZeky ^mfZlv h q_feb[h
^jm]hfB ihlhfy \gh\vmkeurZe __]hehk lZdykghdZd _keb
[u hgZklhyeZ mf_gy aZkibghcHgZ iha\ZeZf_gy ihbf_gbY
[ukljh ih\_jgmekygh \k_qlh ym\b^_elZd wlh kbemwl
ob`bgu bdmklh\ aZg_c
Lhqlh ymkeurZe k\h_bfyijb\_eh f_gy \ ]em[hdh_
aZf_rZl_evkl\hY g_\hevghaZklhgZeY ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
oheh^gh b hq_gvh^bghdh bgZqZe ieZdZlv< wlhl fhf_gl m
f_gy ihy\behkvhsms_gb_qlh ygm`^Zxkv \dhflhdlh [uh[h
fg_ aZ[hlbekyY ih\_jgme]heh\mqlh[u ihkfhlj_lvgZ ^hgZ
OmZgZhg kfhlj_egZ f_gyY g_ohl_e _]h\b^_lv b ihwlhfm
aZdjue ]eZaZB lh]^Z ym\b^_e k\hx fZlvWlh g_ [ue
fuke_gguc h[jZafh_c fZl_jblZddZd yh[uqgh hg_c ^mfZe
Wlh [ueh ykgh_\b^_gb_ __klhys_c jy^hfY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
hlqZygv_Y ^jh`Zeb ohl_em[_`Zlv<b^_gv_ fh_cfZl_jb [ueh
kebrdhf [_kihdhysbfkebrdhf qm`^uflhfmqlh y bkdZe gZ
wlhf i_chlghf kh[jZgbbH^gZdh g_[uehih`Zemckihkh[Z
ba[_`Zlv wlh]h
<_jhylghy fh][u hldjulv]eZaZ_keb [^_ckl\bl_evgh
ohl_eqlh[ \b^_gb_ bkq_aehgh \f_klhwlh]h y klZe _]h
^_lZevgh jZkkfZljb\ZlvFh_ jZkkfZljb\Zgb_[ueh [hevr_q_f
ijhklh_ kfhlj_gb_
gZ
g__wlh
[ueZ ih^khagZl_evgZy
kdmjime_aghklv b lsZl_evghklvHq_gv ex[hiulgh_ qm\kl\h
ho\Zlbeh f_gydZd _keb [wlh [ueh\g_rg_c kbehcb y
\g_aZigh ihqm\kl\h\Zem`ZkZxsmx ly`_klvex[\b fh_c fZl_jb
Dh]^Z ymkeurZe k\h_bfyy dZd[u jZahj\ZekyiZfylv hfh_c
fZl_jb gZihegbeZf_gy g_j\haghklvxb f_eZgoheb_cgh dh]^Zy
jZkkfhlj_e __lh yihgyeqlh gbdh]^Zg_ ex[be__Wlh [ueh
rhdbjmxs__ hldjulb_Fukeb b\b^_gby oeugmebgZ f_gydZd
h[\Ze<b^_gb_ fh_cfZl_jb ^he`gh[ulv l_f\j_f_g_f bkq_aeh
Hgh [he__ g_[ueh \Z`gufY g_[ue [he__ aZbgl_j_kh\Zg \
lhfqlh lZf^_eZeb bg^_cpuNZdlbq_kdby aZ[ueh fblhl_Y
[ue ih]jm`_g\ k_jbxg_h[uqguo fuke_cg_h[uqguoihlhfm qlh
wlh [ueh [hevr_q_f ijhklhfukebwlh [ueb aZdhgq_ggu_
_^bgbpu hsms_gbcy\ey\rboky wfhpbhgZevgufbhij_^_e_ggufb b
[_kkihjgufb
^hdZaZl_evkl\Zfb
bklbgghc
ijbjh^u
fhbo
\aZbfhhlghr_gbc kfh_c fZl_jvx
< hij_^_e_gguc fhf_gl ijblhdwlbo g_h[uqguo fuke_c
ij_djZlbekyY aZf_lbeqlh hgbihl_jyeb k\hxl_dmq_klv b
k\h_ dZq_kl\h p_ehklguo_^bgbp hsms_gbyY gZqZe^mfZlv h
^jm]bo \_sZoFhc fha]aZibgZekyY ih^mfZeh ^jm]boqe_gZo
fh_c k_fvbgh wlbfukeb g_khijh\h`^Zebkv m`_ \b^_gbyfb
Lh]^Z y\a]eygme gZ^hgZ OmZgZHg klhyeHklZevgu_ fm`qbgu
lh`_ klhyebb aZl_fhgb \k_ihreb d\h^_Y ih^\bgmeky b
lhedgme iZj_gvdZdhlhjuc \k__s_ kiZe
Y jZkkdZaZe ^hgm OmZgm\kx ihke_^h\Zl_evghklv fhbo
ihjZabl_evguo \b^_gbcihqlb kjZam`_dZd lhevdhfu k_eb \
fhx fZrbgmHg aZkf_yekyk [hevrbfm^h\hevkl\b_f b kdZaZe
qlh fh_\b^_gb_ [uehagZdhfmdZaZgb_f lZdbf`_ \Z`gufdZd
b fhc i_j\uc hiulk f_kdZeblhY \kihfgbeqlh ^hg OmZg
bklhedh\Ze l_ j_Zdpbbdhlhju_
y bf_edh]^Z \i_j\u_
ihijh[Ze i_chldZd
i_j\hkl_i_gghc
\Z`ghklb mdZaZgby
nZdlbq_kdb[eZ]h^Zjy wlhfmhg bj_rbe mqblvf_gy
>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh \l_q_gb_ ihke_^g_cghqb fblhlZ
f_kdZeblh lZd y\ghmdZaZe gZf_gyqlh \k_[ueb \ugm`^_gu
ih\_jgmlvky dhfg_ bihwlhfmlh hgb kfhlj_egZ f_gydh]^Z
y \a]eygme\ _]hklhjhgm
Y aZohl_emagZlv _]hbklhedh\Zgb_ fhbo\b^_gbcgh hg
h[ wlhf g_ohl_e ]h\hjblvHg kdZaZeqlh qlh[u lZfy gb
m\b^_e wlh q_imoZih kjZ\g_gbxk mdZaZgb_f
>hg OmZgijh^he`Ze ]h\hjblvh lhfdZd k\_l f_kdZeblh
ihdjue f_gyb dZd\k_ wlhm\b^_eb
Wlh ^_ckl\bl_evgh[ueh dh_qlhkdZaZe hgy
ih`Zemcg_ fh][u ihlj_[h\Zlvemqr_]h agZdZ
Fu k ^hghfOmZghf y\ghreb ih^\mf jZaguf ijhki_dlZf
fukebHg [ue aZgyl \Z`ghklvxl_o kh[ulbcdhlhju_ hg
bklhedh\u\ZedZd mdZaZgb_Z f_gyaZgbfZeb ^_lZeblh]hqlh
y m\b^_e
Fg_ g_l^_eZ ^hmdZaZgbckdZaZe yy ohqmagZlv
qlh lZdh_kemqbehkv khfghc
Hg k^_eZe]jbfZkmdZd _keb[u [ueh]hjq_gb hklZ\Zeky
fbgmlm hq_gvg_ih^\b`guf bhdZf_g_\rbfAZl_f hg\a]eygme gZ
f_gy?]h lhg [ue hq_gv
ihehg kbeuHg kdZaZeqlh
_^bgkl\_ggh \Z`guffhf_glhf [uehlhqlh f_kdZeblh[ue lZd
[eZ]hkdehg_g dh fg_b ihdjuef_gy k\hbfk\_lhfb ^Ze fg_
mjhdohly yg_ k^_eZekh k\h_cklhjhgu ^eywlh]h gbdZdbo
mkbebcZ ijhklhgZoh^beky ih[ebahklb
=eZ\Z
q_ l\ _j lZ y
k_gly[jy ]h^Z yih_oZe \Khghjm gZ\_klblv ^hgZ
OmZgZ<uihegyy _]h ijhkv[mdhlhjmx hg k^_eZe \ fhc
ij_^u^msbc \babld g_fmy ihimlb hklZgh\beky\ ?jfhkbevh
qlh[u dmiblv _fmkZfh]hgdm baebklv_\ Z]Z\uih^ gZa\Zgb_f
[ZdZghjZ< wlhl jZa _]hijhkv[Z ihdZaZeZkv fg_ hq_gv
kljZgghcihkdhevdm yagZeqlh hgg_ ex[bliblvh^gZdh y
dmibe q_luj_ [mluedb bkmgme bo\ ysbd\f_kl_ k ^jm]bfb
\_sZfbdhlhju_ y\_a _fm
AZq_f ludmibe q_luj_[mluedb"kdZaZe hgkf_ykv
dh]^Z y hldjue ysbdy ijhkbel_[y dmiblv fg_ h^gm
GZ\_jghlu ih^mfZeqlh [ZdZghjZ^ey f_gygh wlh^ey fh_]h
\gmdZ Exkbhb l_[_gm`gh [m^_l^Zlv wlh_fmdZd _keb[ wlh
[ue l\hckh[kl\_gguc ih^Zjhd
Y \klj_qZekyk \gmdhf^hgZ OmZgZ^\mfy ]h^Zfb jZgvr_
_fm [uehlh]^Z e_lHg [uehq_gv \ukhdbc\ur_ kfb
\k_]^Z [uewdkljZ\Z]Zglgh ohjhrhh^_l ^eyk\hbo kj_^kl\b ih
kjZ\g_gbx k hdjm`Zxsbfb_]h< lh\j_fydZd [hevrbgkl\h
bg^_cp_\ ydb ghkbeb^`bgkukhehf_ggu_ reyiu b ^hfZrg_]h
ba]hlh\e_gby kZg^Zebb]ZjZq_kh^_`^m Exkbh khklZ\eyeb
^hjh]hc q_jghcdh`b `be_lkh fgh`_kl\hfq_j_iZoh\uo im]h\bp
l_oZkkdZy dh\[hckdZy reyiZb iZjZkZih] k fhgh]jZffZfb b
jmqghc hl^_edhc
Exkbh [ueh[jZ^h\Zg ihemq_gb_fkZfh]hgdb b g_f_^e_ggh
mlZsbe [mluedb \^hfhq_\b^ghqlh[u bom[jZlv>hg OmZg
agZqbl_evgh aZf_lbeqlh gbdh]^Zg_ ke_^m_lijylZlv gZibldb
b iblvbo h^ghfmExkbh hl\_lbeqlh g_ijyq_l boZ m[bjZ_l
^h lh]h\_q_jZdh]^Z hgijb]eZkbl k\hbo^jma_c b\uiv_l k
gbfb
L_f `_ \_q_jhfhdheh k_fbqZkh\y \_jgmeky d ^hfm
Exkbh;ueh l_fghY kfmlghjZa]ey^_e kbemwlu^\mo ex^_c
klhysbo ih^ ^_j_\hfWlh [ueExkbh bh^bg ba _]h ^jma_c
dhlhju_ `^Zeb f_gy bijh\_eb \^hf ijb k\_l_ dZjfZggh]h
nhgZjbdZ
>hf Exkbh
ij_^klZ\eye
kh[hc
kZfZggh_
g_mdex`__
khhjm`_gb_ ka_feyguf ihehfb ^\mfydhfgZlZfb>ebghc hg[ue
hdheh f_ljh\ bih^^_j`b\Zeky ^h\hevghlhgdbfb ^_j_\yggufb
klhcdZfb ba f_kdZclh\h]h^_j_\ZHg bf_edZd b^hfZ \k_o
bg^_cp_\ ydbiehkdmx ihdZlmx djurm b jZfZ^mdhlhjZy
ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc
k\h_]h
jh^Z
\_jZg^m
\^hev
\k_c
njhglZevghc qZklb ^hfZDjurZ jZfZ^u gbdh]^Z g_ [u\Z_l
ihdZlhchgZ ^_eZ_lkyba ijmlv_\meh`_gguo k ijhf_`mldZfb
lZdqlh djurZ ^Z_l ^hklZlhqgh l_gbb \ lh `_ \j_fy
iha\hey_l \ha^momk\h[h^gh pbjdmebjh\Zlv
Dh]^Z y \hr_e \^hflh y\dexqbe k\hc fZ]gblhnhg
dhlhjuc [uem f_gy\ ihjln_e_Exkbh ij_^klZ\bef_gy k\hbf
^jmavyf<dexqZy ^hgZOmZgZ\ ^hf_[ueh \hk_fvfm`qbgHgb
kb^_eb dlh]^_ \p_glj_ dhfgZluih^ yjdbfk\_lhf [_gabgh\hc
eZfiuk\bkZ\r_c ki_j_deZ^bgu ihlhedZ>hg OmZgkb^_e gZ
ysbd_Y k_e ebphfd g_fmgZ djZx lj_of_ljh\hc kdZfvb
k^_eZgghc ba lheklhc ^hkdbijb[blhc d ^\mf qmj[ZdZf
\dhiZgguf \a_fex
>hg OmZg iheh`bek\hx reyimgZ a_fexjy^hf k kh[hc
K\_l [_gabgh\hc eZfiu ^_eZe _]h dhjhldb_ k_^u_ \hehku
k\_jdZxs_ [_eufbY \a]eygme _fm
\ ebphK\_l lZd`_
ih^q_jdgme ]em[hdb_fhjsbgu gZ_]h r__b e[mb aZklZ\be_]h
\u]ey^_lv l_fg__b klZjr_
Y \a]eygme gZhklZevguo fm`qbgIjb a_e_gh\Zlh[_ehf
k\_l_ [_gabgh\hceZfiu \k_hgb \u]ey^_ebmklZeufb bklZjufb
Exkbh h[jZlbeky dh\k_f ihbkiZgkdb bkdZaZe ]jhfdbf
]hehkhfqlh fuk_cqZk jZahiv_f[mluedm [ZdZghjudhlhjmx y
ijb\_a _fmba ?jfhkbevhHg ihr_e\ ^jm]mxdhfgZlmijbg_k
[mluedmhldjue __ bi_j_^Ze __fg_ \f_kl_ k fZe_gvdhc
`_klyghc qZrdhcY gZebehq_gv g_fgh]h\ qZrdm b \uibe
;ZdZghjZ hdZaZeZkvfgh]h [he__]mklhcq_f h[uqguckZfh]hg
^Z bdj_iq_ lh`_Y aZdZreyekyY i_j_^Ze[mluedm b dZ`^uc
gZebe k_[_ g_[hevrmx ^hamdZ`^ucaZ bkdexq_gb_f ^hgZ
OmZgZHg ijhklh\aye [mluedmb ihklZ\be__ i_j_^ Exkbh
dhlhjuc [ueihke_^gbf ihdjm]m
<k_ h[f_gyebkv aZf_qZgbyfbh [h]Zlhf[md_l_ b \dmk_
kh^_j`bfh]h wlhc [mluedbb \k_kh]eZkbebkvqlh gZiblhd
^he`gh [ulvijb]hlh\eyeky \ukhdh\ ]hjZoQbomZomZ
;mluedZ ijhreZih djm]m_s_ jZaFm`qbgu h[ebaZeb]m[u
ih\lhjbeb k\hb iho\Zeub gZqZeb`b\hc jZa]h\hjh aZf_lghc
jZagbp_ f_`^mkZfh]hghfba]hlh\ey_fuf hdheh=mZ^ZeZoZjZ b
l_fqlh ijboh^blk \ukhlQbomZomZ
<h \j_fy\lhjh]h djm]Z^hg OmZghiylv g_ibeb ygZebe
k_[_ ebrv gZ]ehlhdgh \k_hklZevgu_ gZihegbeb qZrdm ^h
djZ_\;mluedZ ijhreZlj_lbc djm]b himkl_eZ
Ijbg_kb hklZevgu_[mluedbExkbhkdZaZe ^hgOmZg
ExkbhdZaZehkvdhe_[Zekyb
^hg
OmZgdZd [u
g_\agZqZch[tykgbe hklZevgufqlh yijb\_a q_luj_ [mluedb
^ey Exkbh
;_gbgvhfheh^hc q_eh\_d\ \hajZkl_Exkbhihkfhlj_e gZ
ihjln_evdhlhjuc y[_kkhagZl_evgh ihklZ\beihaZ^b k_[yb
kijhkbeg_ y\eyxkv eb yijh^Z\phf kZfh]hgZ>hg OmZg
kdZaZeqlh wlhg_ lZdb qlhy ijb_oZegZ\_klblv _]h
DZjehk bamqZ_lf_kdZeblhb y_]h mqmkdZaZe ^hg
OmZg<k_ \a]eygmebgZ f_gyb \_`eb\hmeu[gmebkv
;Zo_Z^jh\hk_dg_[hevrh]h jhklZ lhsbc q_eh\_d k
hkljufb q_jlZfbebpZijbklZevgh kfhlj_egZ f_gyk_dmg^mZ
aZl_f kdZaZeqlh deZ^h\sbdh[\bgye f_gy\ lhfqlh yribhg
Zf_jbdZgkdhc dhfiZgbbdhlhjZy kh[bjZ_lkyhldjulv jm^gbdbgZ
a_fe_ ydb<k_ j_Z]bjh\ZebdZd [m^lh g_ ijbqZklgu d
ih^h[ghfm h[\bg_gbxDjhf_ lh]hhgb \k_ g_^hex[eb\Zeb
deZ^h\sbdZdhlhjuc [uef_dkbdZgp_f bebdZd ]h\hjyl ydb
chjb
Exkbh ijhr_e \ ^jm]mxdhfgZlm b \_jgmeky k ^jm]hc
[mluedhc [ZdZghjuHg hldjue__gZebe k_[_ ih[hevr_Z
aZl_f i_j_^Ze__ ihdjm]mJZa]h\hj i_j_r_egZ \_jhylghklv
lh]hqlh Zf_jbdZgkdZydhfiZgby h[hkgm_lky\ Khghj_b h
\hafh`guo ihke_^kl\byowlh]h ^eyydb
;mluedZ \_jgmeZkvd ExkbhHg ih^gye__ bihkfhlj_e gZ
kh^_j`bfh_kdhevdh lZf_s_ hklZehkv
KdZ`b _fmimklv g_]hjx_lijhr_ilZe fg_^hg OmZg
kdZ`b _fmqlh luijb\_a_rv \ke_^mxsbc jZa_s_
Y gZdehgbekyd Exkbhb aZ\_jbe_]hqlh \ke_^mxsbc jZa
y kh[bjZxkvijb\_alb _fmg_ f_g__ihem^x`bgu [mluehd
GZdhg_pjZa]h\hjdZaZehkv [u\u^hoky
Ihq_fm [ul_[_ g_jZkkdZaZlv j_[ylZfh k\h_c\klj_q_
k f_kdZeblh"Y ^mfZxqlh wlh[m^_l gZfgh]hbgl_j_kg_cq_f
wlhl gbdq_fgucjZa]h\hj hlhfqlh kemqblky_keb Zf_jbdZgpu
ijb^ml \Khghjm
F_kdZeblh wlh i_chl^_^"kijhkbe Exkbh k
ex[hiulkl\hf
G_dhlhju_ ah\ml_]h lZdkmoh kdZaZe^hg OmZgy
ij_^ihqblZx gZau\Zlv_]h f_kdZeblh
WlZ ijhdeylZyrlmdZ \uau\Z_lkmfZkr_kl\b_kdZaZe
O_gZjh\ukhdbc m]eh\Zlucfm`qbgZ kj_^g_]h\hajZklZ
Y iheZ]Zx]emih ]h\hjblvqlh f_kdZeblh \uau\Z_l
kmfZkr_kl\b_fy]dh kdZaZe^hg OmZgihlhfm qlh_keb [u
wlh [uehlZdlh DZjehkg_ ]h\hjbe[u k_cqZkk \ZfblmlZ
[ue [u m`_ \ kfbjbl_evghcjm[Zrd_Hg ijbgbfZe _]hb
\a]eygbl_dZ hg a^hjh\[Zo_Z meu[gmeky b kfms_ggh
kdZaZedlh fh`_lagZlv"b \k_jZkkf_yebkv
Lh]^Z \a]eygbl_gZ f_gykdZaZe ^hgOmZgy agZe
f_kdZeblh ihqlb\kx `bagvb hggbdh]^Z g_ih\j_^be fg_gb \
q_fFm`qbgu g_kf_yebkvgh [uehhq_\b^ghqlh hgb g_
ijbgbfZxl _]h\k_jv_a
K ^jm]hcklhjhguijh^he`Ze ^hgOmZgkijZ\_^eb\h
lhqlh f_kdZeblhk\h^bl ex^_ck mfZdZd lukdZaZegh ebrv
lh]^Zdh]^Z hgbijboh^yl dg_fmg_ agZyqlh hgb^_eZxl
Wkdm_j_klZjbdijb[ebabl_evgh \\hajZkl_ ^hgZOmZgZ
ke_]dZ ofudgmeihdZqZ\ ]heh\hc
Qlh luohq_rvOmZgkdZaZlv wlbfagZy"kijhkbe
hgIjhreuc jZadh]^Z yl_[y \b^_elu ]h\hjbe lh `_
kZfh_
Ex^b koh^ylk mfZdh]^Z gZ]ehlZxlkywlh]h i_chlgh]h
kgZ^h[vyijh^he`Ze O_gZjhY \b^_edZd bg^_cpu Mbqhe
_eb _]hHgb ^_ckl\h\Zeb lZddZd [m^lh[u m gbo [ueZ
]hjyqdZHgb ^_j]Zebkvb
i_j^_ebb kkZeb ih\kx^m
Mihlj_[eyy wlhijhdeylh_ kgZ^h[v_fh`gh ihemqblvwibe_ikbx
Bf_ggh lZdkdZaZe fg_h^gZ`^u fbkl_jkZeZkijZ\bl_evkl\_g
guc bg`_g_j: \_^vwibe_ikby wlh gZ\kx `bagvaZf_lvl_
Wlh agZqbl [ulvom`_ `b\hlguofjZqgh ^h[Z\be
;Zo_Z
Lu \b^_e lhevdh lhm bg^_cp_\ Mbqheqlh ohl_e
\b^_lvO_gZjhkdZaZe ^hgOmZggZijbf_jlu kh\k_fg_
^Ze k_[_ljm^Z \uykgblvm gboqlh wlhagZqbl [ulvagZdhfuf
k f_kdZeblhGZkdhevdh yagZxf_kdZeblh gbdh]^Zgbdh]h g_
k^_eZe wibe_ilbdhfIjZ\bl_evkl\_gguc bg`_g_jchjbb y
khfg_\Zxkvqlh[u chjbagZe qlheb[h h[wlhfLu\_jghg_
^mfZ_rvqlh \k_l_ lukyqbex^_cdhlhju_ agZxlf_kdZeblh
kmfZkr_^rb_beb g_lZd"
Hgb ^he`gu[ulv kmfZkr_^rbfbbeb hq_gv[ebadh dlhfm
qlh[ ^_eZlvih^h[gu_ \_sbhl\_lbe O_gZjh
Gh _keb\k_ wlblukyqb ex^_ckmfZkr_^rb_ \h^gh blh
`_ \j_fylh dlh[m^_l ^_eZlvbo jZ[hlm"DZd hgbmobljyxlky
\u`blv"kijhkbe ^hgOmZg
FZdZjbhdhlhjuc ijb_oZek lhcklhjhgu ba KR: jZkkdZau\Ze fg_qlh \kydbcdlh ijbgbfZ_li_chlevhlf_q_g
gZ \kx`bagvkdZaZe Wkdm_j_
FZdZjbh e`_l_keb hglZd ]h\hjblkdZaZe ^hgOmZg
y m\_j_gqlh hgg_ agZ_llh]hh q_f]h\hjbl
Hg ^_ckl\bl_evgh]h\hjbl hq_gvfgh]h e`bkdZaZe
;_gbgvh
Dlh lZdhcFZdZjbh"kijhkbe y
Hg bg^__pydbdhlhjuc `b\_la^_kvkdZaZe Exkbh
hg ]h\hjblqlh hgba :jbahgub qlh\h \j_fy\hcgu hg[ue \
?\jhi_Hg jZkkdZau\Z_l\kydh_
Hg ]h\hjblqlh [ueihedh\gbdhfkdZaZe ;_gbgvh
<k_ jZkkf_yebkvb jZa]h\hj
g_gZ^he]h i_j_r_e gZ
g_\_jhylgu_ jZkkZauFZdZjbhgh ^hgOmZg \gh\v\_jgme _]hd
l_f_ f_kdZeblh
?keb \k_\u agZ_l_qlh FZdZjbhe`_plh dZd`_ \u
fh`_l_ \_jblv_fmdh]^Z hg]h\hjbl hf_kdZeblh"
Lu bf__rv\ \b^mi_chl^_^"kijhkbe ExkbhdZd
_keb [uhg ^_ckl\bl_evghiulZeky hij_^_eblvkfuke l_jfbgZ
>ZQ_jl \havfb
Lhg ^hgZ OmZgZ [uehkljuf bj_adbfExkbh g_\hevgh
jZkijyfbekyb gZ k_dmg^m yihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh \k_ hgb
bkim]Zebkv
AZl_f ^hgOmZg meu[gmekyb ijh^he`Zekihdhcguf ]hehkhf
JZa\_ \u^jmavyg_ \b^bl_qlh FZdZjbhg_ agZ_l
lh]hh q_f]h\hjbl"JZa\_ \ug_ \b^bl_qlh ^eylh]hqlh[
]h\hjblv hf_kdZeblhgm`gh agZlv"
Hiylv luijbr_e lm^Z`_kdZaZe Wkdm_j_qlh
q_jl \havfbagZqbl wlhagZgb_Lu om`_q_f FZdZjbhLhl
ih djZcg_cf_j_]h\hjbl lhqlh mg_]h gZmf_agZ_l hgwlh
beb g_ agZ_lM`_ fgh]he_l ykeurZedZd lu]h\hjbeqlh
gZf gm`ghagZlvQlh gZfgm`gh agZlv"
>hg OmZg]h\hjbeqlh \i_chl_ _klv^mokdZaZe
;_gbgvh
Y \b^_ei_chl \ihe_gh ygbdh]^Z g_\b^_e gb^moh\
gb qlheb[h \jh^_lh]h^h[Z\be ;Zo_Z
F_kdZeblh ihoh`gZ ^moih`Zemch[tykgbe ^hgOmZg
Gh q_f[u hggb [uewlh g_klZgh\blky ykgh^h l_o ihj
ihdZ g_ magZ_rvh g_fWkdm_j_ `Zem_lkyqlh y]h\hjx wlh
m`_ fgh]he_lQlh `^_ckl\bl_evgh wlhlZdGh g_fhy \bgZ
\ lhfqlh \ug_ ihgbfZ_l_;Zo_Z ]h\hjbeqlh lhldlh
ijbf_l _]hklZgh\blky ihoh`gZ `b\hlgh_Qlh `y lZd g_
^mfZx>ey f_gyl_dlh ^mfZxlqlh hgb\ur_ `b\hlguo`b\ml
om`_q_f `b\hlgu_<a]eygb gZ fh_]h \gmdZ a^_kvHg
jZ[hlZ_l [_a hl^uoZY [ukdZaZeqlh hg`b\_l ^ey lh]h
qlh[u jZ[hlZlvdZd fmeB \k_qlh hg^_eZ_l g_`b\hlgh]h lZd wlhgZib\Z_lky
<k_ jZkkf_yebkv<bdlhjhq_gv
fheh^hc q_eh\_d
dhlhjucdZaZehkv_s_ g_\ur_e baih^jhkldh\h]h \hajZklZ
kf_yeky a\hgq_\k_oWebobhfheh^hc n_jf_j^h kboihj g_
ijhbag_k gbkeh\ZHg kb^_egZ ihemkijZ\Z hlf_gyhi_jrbkv
kibghc gZf_rdb kobfbq_kdbfb m^h[j_gbyfbkeh`_ggufb \gmljb
^hfZ hl ^h`^yHg [ueh^gbf ba ^jma_c ^_lkl\Z Exkbh
\u]ey^_e kbevguf bohly [uegb`_ Exkbhjhklhf[ue [he__
ih^lygml bemqr_ keh`_g
WebobhdZaZehkvbgl_j_kh\Zeb keh\Z^hgZ OmZgZ;Zo_Z
iulZeky hiylv[jhkblv aZf_qZgb_gh Webobh_]h i_j_[be
DZdbf h[jZahfi_chl baf_gbe[u \k_wlh"kijhkbe hg
Fg_ dZ`_lkyqlh q_eh\_djh`^_g jZ[hlZlv\kx k\hx `bagv
dZd jZ[hlZxlfmeu
F_kdZeblh f_gy_l\k_kdZaZe ^hgOmZgbh^gZdh
`_gZf \k_jZ\gh ijb^_lkyjZ[hlZlv dZdb \k_f hklZevguf
dZd fmeZfY kdZaZeqlh \gmljbf_kdZeblh _klv^moihlhfm
qlh wlh qlhlh \jh^_^moZqlh \ghkblbaf_g_gby \ ex^_c
>modhlhjuc fu fh`_fm\b^_lv bihljh]Zlv^modhlhjuc
f_gy_l gZkbgh]^Z ^Z`_ijhlb\ gZr_c\heb
I_chl k\h^bll_[y kmfZkdZaZe O_gZjhZ aZl_f
ludhg_qgh\_jbrvqlh baf_gbeky<_jgh"
DZd hgfh`_l baf_gblvgZk"gZklZb\Ze Webobh
Hg h[mqZ_lgZk ijZ\bevghfmh[jZam `bagbkdZaZe ^hg
OmZghg ihfh]Z_lb aZsbsZ_ll_odlh _]hagZ_lLZ `bagv
dhlhjmx \uj_[ylZ\_^_l_ g_ `bagvkh\k_f\u g_ agZ_l_
lh]h kqZklvydhlhjh_
ijhbkl_dZ_l
ba
^_eZgvy \_s_c
hkhagZgghM \Zkg_l aZsblgbdZ
Qlh luih^jZamf_\Z_rv"kijhkbe O_gZjhh[b`_gghm
gZk _klv gZr ]hkih^vBbkmk Ojbklhkb gZrZ fZlv >_\Zb
fZe_gvdZy ^_\Z=\Z^_emikdZyJZa\_ hgbg_ gZrbaZsblgbdb"
OhjhrZy dmqZ
aZsblgbdh\kdZaZe
^hg OmZg
gZkf_reb\hjZa\_ hgbgZmqbeb l_[yemqr_fm h[jZam`bagb"
Wlh ihlhfmqlh ex^bbo g_kemrZxlaZijhl_klh\Ze
O_gZjhhgb h[jZsZxlk\h_ \gbfZgb_lhevdh d^vy\hem
?keb [u hgb[ueb gZklhysbfb aZsblgbdZfbhgb [u
aZklZ\beb l_[ykemrZlvkdZaZe ^hgOmZg_keb f_kdZeblh
klZg_l l\hbf aZsblgbdhflh l_[_ ijb^_lky kemrZlv _]h
ihgjZ\blky l_[_ wlh beb g_lihlhfm qlh lu fh`_rv _]h
\b^_lvb lu ^he`_g ke_^h\Zlvlhfmqlh hg kdZ`_lHg
aZklZ\bl l_[y ih^oh^blvd g_fmk m\Z`_gb_f: g_lZddZd
\uj_[ylZijb\udeb ijb[eb`Zlvkyd k\hbfaZsblgbdZf
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^mOmZg"kijhkbe wkdm_j_
Y bf_x\ \b^mqlh ^ey\Zk ijbclbd \ZrbfaZsblgbdZf
hagZqZ_lqlh h^ghfmba \Zkgm`gh b]jZlvgZ kdjbid_ \ lh
\j_fydZd lZgphj^he`_g gZ^_lvk\hx fZkdmb gZdhe_ggbdb b
]j_f_lv b lZgp_\Zlv \ lh\j_fydZd hklZevgu_ ba \Zk
ivygkl\mxl kj_^b bg^_cp_\ P_gljZevghc b X`ghc :f_jbdb
dZlhebq_kdb_
ijZa^gbdb
ijhl_dZxldZd
dZjgZ\Zeu
k
h[yaZl_evgufb dhklxfbjh\Zggufb lZgpZfb^eysbfbky bgh]^Z
g_kdhevdh ^g_cLZgphju
ij_^\Zjbl_evghdZd ijZ\beh
ijhoh^yl dmjkh[mq_gby \fhgZklujyo wlb ^Zggu_y ijb\h`m
ba ebl_jZlmju bnbevfh\ <F<hl lu;_gbgvhlu [ue
lZgphjhf dh]^ZlhjZkkdZ`b gZfh[ wlhf
Y [jhkbewlh q_j_aljb ]h^ZkdZaZe ;_gbgvhwlh
ly`_eZy jZ[hlZ
Kijhkb ExkbhkdZaZe Wkdm_j_k kZjdZafhfhg
[jhkbe wlh^_eh q_j_ag_^_ex
<k_ jZkkf_yebkv<k_djhf_ ^hgZOmZgZExkbh aZkf_yeky
y\gh jZa^jZ`_gghb \uibe^\Z h]jhfguo]ehldZ [ZdZghju
Wlh g_ljm^ghwlh ]emihkdZaZe ^hgOmZgkijhkb
<Ze_gkbhlZgphjZgjZ\blky eb
_fm lZgp_\Zlv?fm g_
gjZ\blkyHg ijb\udd wlhfmb \k_Y fgh]he_l \b^_edZd
hg lZgpm_lb dZ`^uc jZa y\b^_e h^gb b l_ `_ iehoh
\uihegy_fu_ ^\b`_gbyHg g_]hj^blky k\hbf bkdmkkl\hf aZ
bkdexq_gb_f l_okemqZ_\dh]^Z hg]h\hjbl hg_fHg g_ex[bl
_]hihwlhfm ]h^ aZ ]h^hf hgih\lhjy_l h^gb b l_ `_
^\b`_gbyLhqlh [uehiehoh]h \_]h lZgpZo\ kZfhfgZqZe_
klZeh nbdkbjh\ZggufHg g_fh`_l [hevr_\b^_lv wlh]h
?]h gZmqbeblZd lZgp_\ZlvkdZaZe Webobhy lh`_
[ue lZgphjhf\ ]hjh^_LhjbfY agZxqlh lZgp_\ZlvgZ^h lZd
dZd l_[ymqZl
<h \kydhfkemqZ_ <Ze_gkbhwlh g_emqrbc lZgphj
kdZaZe Wkdm_j__klv b^jm]b_DZd gZkq_lKZdZl_db"
KZdZl_dZ q_eh\_d agZgbyHg g_hlghkblky dlhfm `_
deZkkmqlh b \uj_[ylZkdZaZe ^hgOmZg j_adhhg
lZgpm_lihlhfm qlhlZdh\Z kdehgghklv_]h gZlmju<k_qlh y
ohl_e kdZaZlvlZd wlhlhqlh \udhlhju_ g_ y\ey_l_kv
lZgphjZfbg_ gZkeZ`^Z_l_kvlZgp_fFh`_l [ulv_keb lZg_p
ohjhrh \uiheg_glh g_dhlhju_ba \ZkihemqZl m^h\hevkl\b_
H^gZdh fZeh dlhba \ZkgZklhevdh agZ_llZg_pIhwlhfm \Zf
hklZ_lky \_kvfZ beexahjgZy djhrdZ jZ^hklb<hl ihq_fm
^jmavy\k_ \uivygbpu<a]eygbl_ kx^ZgZ fh_]h\gmdZ
;jhkv wlh^_^aZijhl_klh\Ze Exkbh
Hg g_e_gb\ bg_ ]emiijh^he`Ze ^hgOmZggh qlh
_s_ hg^_eZ_ldjhf_ dZdiv_l"
Hg ihdmiZ_ldh`Zgu_ `be_luaZf_lbe O_gZjhb \k_
kemrZl_eb aZohohlZeb
Exkbh \uibe_s_ [ZdZgZju
B dZd `_fh`_l i_chlbaf_gblv \k_wlh"kijhkbe
Webobh
?keb [ ExkbhklZe bkdZlvaZsblgbdZkdZaZe ^hg
OmZglh _]h`bagv baf_gbeZkv[uY g_agZx \ lhqghklb
dZd bf_gghgh ym\_j_gqlh hgZklZeZ [ubghc
Hg [jhkbliblvwlh luohq_rv kdZaZlv"gZklZb\Ze
Webobh
Fh`_l [ulvhg [jhkbe[u?fm gm`ghqlhlh _s_ihfbfh
kZfh]hgZqlh[u _]h`bagv klZeZm^h\e_l\hjbl_evghcB wlh
qlhlhq_f [u hgh gb [uehfh`_l [ulv ij_^hklZ\e_gh
aZsblgbdhf
Lh]^Z i_chl ^he`_g[ulv hq_gv \dmkgufkdZaZe
Webobh
Y [uwlh]h g_kdZaZekdZaZe ^hgOmZg
Gh dZd`_q_jl \havfbfh`gh gZkeZ`^Zlvkyl_fqlh
g_\dmkgh"kijhkbe Webobh
Hg ^Z_l \hafh`ghklvemqr_ gZkeZ`^Zlvky `bagvx
kdZaZe ^hgOmZg
Gh _kebhg g_\dmkguclh dZd`_ hgfh`_l aZklZ\blv
gZk emqr_gZkeZ`^Zlvky `bagvx"gZklZb\Ze Webobhwlh g_
bf__l kfukeZ
Kfukedhg_qgh_klvkdZaZe O_gZjhk m[_`^_gb_f
i_chl ^_eZ_l l_[y kmfZkr_^rbfb_kl_kl\_gghqlh lu
^mfZ_rvqlh bf__rvemqr__ \j_fyk\h_c `bagbqlh [ulu gb
^_eZe
Hiylv \k_aZkf_yebkv
Kfuke _klvijh^he`Ze ^hgOmZgdZd gb\ q_f g_
[u\Zeh_keb \uih^mfZ_l_ hlhfdZd fZehfu agZ_fb dZd
fgh]h _klv q_]h\b^_lvWlh [jZ]Z^_eZ_l ex^_c [_amfgufb
HgZ ih^h]j_\Z_l\hh[jZ`_gb_F_kdZeblhgZijhlb\h[hkljy_l
\k_Hg ^Z_l \Zf\hafh`ghklv \b^_lv\k_ lZd ohjhrhLZd
ohjhrh
Exkbh b;_gbgvh \a]eygmeb^jm] gZ^jm]Z b meu[gmebkv
dZd _keb[ hgb\k_ wlhm`_ keurZebjZgvr_O_gZjh bWkdm_j_
klZeb [he__ [_kihdhcgufb bklZeb ]h\hjblv h^gh\j_f_ggh
<bdlhj kf_yekyihdju\Zy \k_hklZevgu_ ]hehkZDZaZehkv
_^bgkl\_gguf aZbgl_j_kh\Zgguf[ue Webobh
DZd fh`_li_chl \k_wlh k^_eZlv"kijhkbe hg
< i_j\mxhq_j_^vh[tykgbe ^hgOmZglu ^he`_g
aZohl_lv ihagZdhfblvky k gbfB y^mfZxqlh wlh kZfuc
\Z`guc fhf_glAZl_f lu^he`_g [ulvij_^klZ\e_g _fmb lu
^he`_g \klj_qZlv _]h fgh]h jZaij_`^_q_f lu kfh`_rv
kdZaZlvqlh agZ_rv_]h
B qlhkemqblvky lh]^Z"kijhkbe Webobh
O_gZjh \f_rZeky
Lu [m^_rveZaZlv ihdjur_Z `hiZhklZg_lky gZa_fe_
Ijbkmlkl\mxsb_ ihdZlbebkvhl kf_oZ
Qlh kemqblkyihlhfiheghklvx aZ\bkblhl l_[ykZfh]h
Ijh^he`Ze ^hg OmZgg_ l_jyydhgljhey gZ^kh[hcLu
^he`_g ijboh^blvd g_fm[_a kljZoZb fZehihfZem hggZmqbl
l_[ydZd `blvemqr_c `bagvx
GZklmibeZ ^ebggZy iZmaZFm`qbgudZaZehkvmklZeb
;mluedZ [ueZ imklZExkbh ky\guf \gmlj_ggbf kh`Ze_gb_f
ijbg_k bhldjue ^jm]mx
M DZjehkZi_chl lh`_y\ey_lky aZsblgbdhf"kijhkbe
Webobh rmleb\uflhghfy g_magZe [uwlh]hkdZaZe ^hg
OmZgHg ijbgbfZe_]h ljbjZaZihijhkb _]h jZkkdZaZlv
l_[_ h[wlhf
<k_ k ex[hiulkl\hf ih\_jgmebkv
dh fg_b Webobh
kijhkbe
Lu ^_ckl\bl_evghijbgbfZe _]h"
>ZIjbgbfZe
DZaZehkv^hg OmZg\ub]jZe jZmg^m k\hbo kemrZl_e_c
hgb [ueb beb aZbgl_j_kh\Zgu\ fh_fjZkkdZa_ beb kebrdhf
\_`eb\uqlh[u jZkkf_ylvkyfg_ \ebph
Hg kdjb\bel_[_ jhl"kijhkbe Exkbh
>ZM g_]hm`Zkguc \dmk
AZq_f `_lu lh]^Z_]h ijbgbfZe"kijhkbe ;_gbgvh
Y gZqZe jZkkdZau\Zlv bfih^[bjZy keh\Zqlh ^ey
aZiZ^gh]h q_eh\_dZagZgb_ ^hgZOmZgZ hi_chl_ y\ey_lkyh^ghc
ba kZfuo aZo\Zlu\Zxsbo\_s_cdZdb_ lhevdhfh`gh gZclbY
kdZaZeqlh \k_jZkkdZaZggh_ bfh[ wlhf\_jgh bqlh dZ`^uc
ba gZkfh`_l ijh\_jblvbklbgm kdZaZggh]hgZ kZfhfk_[_
Y aZf_lbeqlh \k_hgb meu[ZxlkydZd [ukdju\Zy k\h_
hlghr_gb_Y ijbr_e\ kbevgh_jZa^jZ`_gb_Y khagZ\Ze k\hx
g_mdex`_klv \i_j_^Zq_ lh]hqlh y\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb bf_e
gZ mf_Y ih]h\hjbe_s_gh ihl_jyegblv bih\lhjye lhqlh
m`_ kdZaZe^hg OmZg>hg OmZgijbr_e fg_gZ ihfhsvb kijhkbe
h[h^jyxs_
Lu \_^vg_ bkdZeaZsblgbdZdh]^Z \i_j\u_ijbr_e d
f_kdZeblhg_ lZdeb"
Y kdZaZebfqlh yg_ agZeqlh f_kdZeblhfh`_l [ulv
aZsblgbdhf bqlh fghx^\b]Zeh lhevdhex[hiulkl\h b [hevrh_
`_eZgb_ agZlv _]h>hg OmZgih^l\_j^beqlh fhb gZf_j_gvy
[ueb [_amdhjbag_ggu b kdZaZeqlh baaZ wlh]h f_kdZeblh
hdZaZe [eZ]hijbylgucwnn_dl gZf_gy
Gh hg aZklZ\eye l_[yimdZlv b ibkZlv ih \k_fm
ihf_s_gbxg_ lZdeb"gZklZb\Ze O_gZjh
Y kdZaZeqlh hg^_ckl\bl_evgh \ha^_ckl\h\ZegZ f_gy
lZdbf h[jZahf<k_ jZkkf_yebkvk h[e_]q_gb_fY ihqm\kl\h
\Zeqlh hgbklZeb _s_[he__ ij_^m[_`^_gudh fg_Hgb g_
dZaZebkv aZbgl_j_kh\Zggufbdjhf_ Webobhdhlhjuc kfhlj_egZ
f_gy
Qlh lu\b^_e"kijhkbe hg
>hg OmZg\_e_e i_j_kdZaZlvbf \k_beb ihqlb\k_ ^_lZeb
fh_]h hiulZihwlhfm yjZkkdZaZe ihke_^h\Zl_evghklvb nhjfm
lh]hqlh hsmlbeDh]^Z ydhgqbe ]h\hjblvExkbh k^_eZe
aZf_qZgb_
?keb i_chllZdhc ^vy\helh yjZ^qlh gbdh]^Zg_ _e
_]h
<k_ lZddZd ykdZaZekdZaZe O_gZjh[Zo_ZwlZ
rlmdZ ^_eZ_ll_[y g_ghjfZevguf
Gh DZjehkk_cqZk ghjfZevgucdZd luh[tykgbrv wlh"
kijhkbe ^hgOmZg mO_gZjh
Hldm^Z fuagZ_fqlh hgghjfZevguc"hl\_lbe O_gZjh
<k_ jZkkf_yebkv\dexqZy ^hgZOmZgZ
Lu [hyeky"kijhkbe ;_gbgvh
Yhij_^_e_ggh[hyeky
Lh]^Z aZq_flu ^_eZewlh"kijhkbe Webobh
Hg kdZaZeqlh ohl_eagZlvhl\_lbe aZf_gy Exkbh
Y ^mfZxqlh DZjehkkh[bjZ_lky klZlvlZdbf `_dZd fhc
^_^H[Z ]h\hjbebqlh hgbohlyl agZlvgh gbdlhg_ agZ_l
qlhq_jl \havfbhgb ohlylagZlv
G_\hafh`gh h[tykgblvwlh agZgb_kdZaZe ^hg OmZg
Webobhihlhfmqlh
hgh
jZagh_ ^ey jZaguo ex^_c
?^bgkl\_ggh h[sbf ^ey \k_o y\ey_lky lhqlh f_kdZeblh
jZkdju\Z_l k\hbk_dj_lu qZklgufh[jZahf dZ`^hfm hl^_evghfm
q_eh\_dmAgZydZd qm\kl\m_lO_gZjhy g_j_dhf_g^h\Ze [u
_fm \klj_qZlvkyk f_kdZeblhB \k_`_g_kfhljy gZfhb keh\Z
beb _]h
qm\kl\Zf_kdZeblh
fh`_l
hdZaZlv iheghklvx
[eZ]hijbylguc wnn_dl gZg_]hGh lhevdh hg
fh`_l wlh
magZlvb wl h
b_klv lhagZgb_h dhlhjhfy ]h\hjx
>hg OmZgih^gyeky
<j_fy b^lb^hfhckdZaZe hgExkbh ivygZ <bdlhj
kibl
>\mfy ^gyfbiha`_k_gly[jyExkbh;_gbgvh bWebobh
ijbreb d ^hfm]^_ yhklZgh\bekyqlh[u ihclbkh fghc gZ
hohlmG_dhlhjh_ \j_fyihdZ yijh^he`Ze ^_eZlvk\hb aZibkb
hgb ojZgbebfheqZgb_AZl_f ;_gbgvh\_`eb\h aZkf_yekydZd
[u ij_^mij_`^Zyqlh hgkh[bjZ_lky kdZaZlvg_qlh \Z`gh_
Ihke_ ij_^\Zjbl_evgh gZjmr_gghclbrbgu hg aZkf_yeky
hiylv bkdZaZe
<hl Exkbh]h\hjblqlh klZe[u ]ehlZlvi_chl
Wlh ijZ\^Z"kijhkbe y
>Zy g_\hajZ`Zx
Kf_o ;_gbgvhhiylv klZekiZafZlbq_kdbf
Exkbh ]h\hjblqlh hg[m^_l _klv i_chl_keb lu
dmibrv _fmfhlhpbde
Exkbh b ;_gbgvh \a]eygmeb^jm] gZ ^jm]Z b aZrebkv
kf_ohf
Kdhevdh klhbl fhlhpbde \ Kh_^bg_gguo RlZlZo"
kijhkbe Exkbh
<_jhylghfh`gh aZklh ^heeZjh\gZclbkdZaZe y
Wlh \_^vlZf g_hq_gv fgh]h\_jgh"Lu e_]dh fh`_rv
^hklZlv h^bg^ey g_]hjZa\_ g_lZd"kijhkbe ;_gbgvh
Ohjhrhgh kgZqZeZy kijhrmm l\h_]h^_^ZkdZaZe y
Exkbh
G_lG_laZijhl_klh\Ze hg_fm lugbq_]h h[wlhf
g_ ]h\hjbHg \k_ bkihjlblHg qm^ZdBdjhf_ lh]h
keZ[hmfguc bg_ agZ_lqlh ^_eZ_l
Hg dh]^Zlh [uegZklhysbf fZ]hf^h[Z\be ;_gbgvh
Y ohqmkdZaZlv^_ckl\bl_evgh fZ]hfGZjh^ ]h\hjblqlh hg
[ue emqrbfGh hgijbkljZklbeky di_chlm b klZe gbdlh
L_i_jv hgkebrdhf klZj
B hg\gh\v b\gh\v ih\lhjy_ll_ `_djZie_gu_ bklhjbb
h i_chl_kdZaZe Exkbh
Wlhl i_chlqbklh_ `mevgbq_kl\hkdZaZe ;_gbgvh
agZ_rvfu h^gZ`^u_]h ihijh[h\ZebExkbh mlZsbep_euc f_rhd
_]h m k\h_]h ^_^ZH^gZ`^u ghqvxih imlb \ ]hjh^ fu
ihijh[h\Zeb _]h `_\ZlvKmdbg kughg jZahj\Zefg_ jhl gZ
qZklbIh \dmkmwlh ijyfhZ^
<u ijh]ehlbeb_]h"kijhkbe y
Fu \uiexgmeb_]hkdZaZe Exkbhb \u[jhkbeb\_kv
ijhdeyluc f_rhd
Bf h[hbf kemqZcihdZaZeky hq_gvaZ[Z\gufWebobh l_f
\j_f_g_f g_kdZaZe gbkeh\ZM g_]h[ue hlkmlkl\mxsbcdZd
h[uqgh\b^Hg ^Z`_g_ kf_yeky
Ohl_e [ulu ihijh[h\Zlv_]hWebobh"kijhkbe y
G_lLhevdh g_y>Z`_ aZfhlhpbde
Exkbh b;_gbgvh gZrebml\_j`^_gb_ qj_a\uqZcghaZ[Z\guf
b \gh\vaZohohlZeb
L_f g_f_g__ijh^he`Ze Webobhy ^he`_gkdZaZlv
qlh ^hgOmZg haZ^Zqbef_gy
Fhc ^_^kebrdhf klZjqlh[u qlheb[h agZlvkdZaZe
Exkbh k[hevrbf m[_`^_gb_f
>Zhg hq_gvklZjwohf hlha\Zeky;_gbgvh
Y ih^mfZeqlh fg_gb_\ukdZaZggh_ h ^hg_ OmZg_
fheh^ufb ex^vfb [ueh
j_[yq_kdbf
b
g_h[hkgh\ZggufY
qm\kl\h\Ze k\hbf^he]hf aZsblblv_]hb kdZaZebfqlhgZ
fhc \a]ey^^hg OmZg y\ey_lkylZd`_dZd b \ ijhrehf
\_ebdbf fZ]hffh`_l [ulv^Z`_ \_ebqZcrbf ba \k_oY
kdZaZeqlh qm\kl\mx_klv \g_f qlhlh lZdh_^_ckl\bl_evgh
g_h[uqgh_Y gZihfgbe bfqlh _fmm`_ aZ bl_f g_
f_g__hg [he__wg_j]bq_g b[he__ kbe_gq_f \k_fu \f_kl_
\aylu_Y \uau\Ze fheh^uo ex^_cijh\_jblv wlh kZfbf b
ihijh[h\Zlv ke_^blvaZ ^hghfOmZghf
Lu ijhklhg_ kfh`_rvke_^blv aZfhbf ^_^hfkdZaZe
Exkbh k]hj^hklvxHg [jmoh
Y gZihfgbebfqlh ihbo `_keh\Zfhg kebrdhfklZj b
keZ[hmf_g bqlh keZ[hmfgucq_eh\_d g_agZ_lqlh ijhbkoh^bl
\hdjm] g_]hY kdZaZebfqlh _s_k ^Z\gboihj yg_ i_j_klZx
ihjZ`Zlvky Ze_jlghklvx^hgZ OmZgZ
Gbdlh g_fh`_l ke_^blvaZ [jmoh^Z`_ _kebhg klZj
Z\lhjbl_lgh kdZaZe ;_gbgvhGZ
g_]h \k_ `_ fh`gh
gZ[jhkblvky lheihcdh]^Z hgkiblBf_ggh wlhijhbahreh k
q_eh\_dhf ihbf_gb K_\bdZkex^b mklZebhl _]haehc fZ]bbb
m[beb _]h
Y ihijhkbebo jZkkdZaZlv\k_ ih^jh[ghklbwlh]h kemqZy
gh hgbkdZaZebqlh wlhijhbahreh _s_^h gbobeb `_ lh]^Z
dh]^Z hgb [ueb_s_ kh\k_ffZe_gvdbfbWebobh ^h[Z\beqlh
lZcgh ex^b \_jylqlh K_\bdZk[ue ijhklh ^mjZd b qlh
gZklhys_fm fZ]mgbdlh g_fh`_l ijbqbgblv\j_^Y ihijh[h\Ze
jZkkijZrb\Zlv ^Zevr_h[ bofg_gbyo ihih\h^m fZ]h\h^gZdh
dZaZehkvhgb g_hq_gvlh bgl_j_kh\Zebkvwlbf ij_^f_lhfd
lhfm `_ bfg_ l_ji_ehkvhlijZ\blvky ihklj_eylv ba jm`vy
dhlhjh_ ydmibe
G_dhlhjh_ \j_fy ih imlb
d aZjhkeyf qZiiZjZey fu
fheqZebAZl_f Webobhdhlhjuc r_ei_j\ufih\_jgmeky b
kdZaZe fg_
Fh`_l [ulvwlh fukmfZkr_^rb_Fh`_l [ulv^hg OmZg
ijZ\"IhkfhljbdZd fu`b\_f
Exkbh b;_gbgvh aZijhl_klh\ZebY iulZeky\f_rZlvkyY
kh]eZrZeky kWebobh bkdZaZe bfqlh ykZf qm\kl\h\Zeqlh
h[jZa `bagbdhlhjuc y\_^m\ q_flh g_ijZ\be_g;_gbgvh
kdZaZeqlh fg_g_q_]h `Zeh\ZlvkygZ k\hx`bagvlZd dZd m
f_gy _klv ^_gv]bb _klvfZrbgZY hl\_lbeqlh e_]dh fh]m
kdZaZlvqlh wlh hgbemqr_ `b\mllZd dZdm gbo _klv ih
mqZkldm a_febHgb ohjhf\hajZabebqlh ohaybghf a_feb
y\ey_lky n_^_jZevguc [ZgdY hl\_lbebfqlh y lh`_ g_
\eZ^_x fZrbghcqlh _x\eZ^__l [Zgd\ DZebnhjgbbqlh fhy
`bagv ^jm]Zygh g_emqr_q_f boD lhfm\j_f_gb fu m`_
[ueb \]mkluo aZjhkeyo
Fu g_ gZrebgb he_gygb ^bdbok\bg_cgh m[beb lj_o
djhebdh\
GZ h[jZlghf imlbfu hklZgh\bebkvm ^hfZExkbhb hg
ijh\ha]eZkbeqlh _]h`_gZ kh[bjZ_lkyijb]hlh\blv `Zjdh_ba
djhebdh\;_gbgvh hlijZ\beky\ fZ]Zabgqlh[u dmiblv[mluedm
l_dbeu bkh^h\hc \h^uDh]^Z hg\_jgmekylh kgbf [ue ^hg
OmZg
M` g_gZr_e eblu fh_]h^_^Z \fZ]Zabg_ihdmiZxsbf
ib\hkf_ykvkijhkbe Exkbh
Y g_[ue ijb]eZr_ggZ wlm\klj_qmkdZaZe ^hgOmZg
Y ijhklh aZr_e kijhkblv DZjehkZg_ _^_l eb hg \
?jfhkbevh"
Y kdZaZe_fmqlh kh[bjZekym_oZlv gZke_^mxsbc ^_gvb
ihdZ fu jZa]h\Zjb\Zeb;_gbgvh jha^Ze[mluedbWebobh ^Ze
k\hx ^hgm OmZgmbihkdhevdm kj_^bydb hldZaZlvky^Z`_ ba
\_`eb\hklb agZqbl gZg_klbkf_jl_evgmx h[b^mlh ^hg OmZg
kihdhcgh \aye__Y hl^Zek\hx [mluedmWebobhb hg\ugm`^_g
[ue __\aylvIhwlhfm ;_gbgvh\ k\hxhq_j_^v^Ze f_gk\hx
[mluedmGh Exkbhdhlhjuchq_\b^ghaZjZg__ \bamZebabjh\Ze
\kx ko_fm ohjhrbo fZg_j ydbm`_ aZdhgqblv iblv k\hx
kh^h\mxHg ih\_jgmekyd ;_gbgvhm dhlhjh]hgZ ebp_aZklueh
iZl_lbq_kdh_ \ujZ`_gb_b kdZaZekf_ykv
Hgb gZ^mebl_[y gZ[mluedm
>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh gbdh]^Zg_ ibekh^h\mx bi_j_^Ze
k\hx [mluedm \ jmdb ;_gbgvhFu kb^_eb ih^ jZfZ^hc \
fheqZgbb
Webobh dZaZekyg_j\gufHg l_j_[bedjZy k\h_creyiu
Y ^mfZeh lhfqlh lukdZaZe ijhrehcghqvxkdZaZe
hg ^hgmOmZgmdZd fh`_li_chl baf_gblvgZrm `bagv"DZd"
>hg OmZg g_ hl\_qZeHg g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_e gZWebobhZ aZl_fgZqZe i_lvgZ yaud_ydbKdhj__
wlh [ueZg_ i_kgy^Z`_Z dhjhldh_^_deZfbjh\Zgb_Fu ^he]h_
\j_fy fheqZAZl_f yihijhkbe ^hgZOmZgZ i_j_\_klb^ey f_gy
keh\Z kyaudZ ydb
Wlh [uehlhevdh ^eyydbkdZaZe hgdZd kZfhkh[hc
jZamf_xs__ky
Y ihqm\kl\h\Zek_[y hl\_j]gmlufY [uem\_j_gqlh hg
kdZaZe qlhlh hq_gv\Z`gh_
Webobh bg^__pgZdhg_pkdZaZe fg_^hg OmZgb
dZd bg^__pWebobh g_bf__l gbq_]hFubg^_cpugbq_]h g_
bf__f<k_qlh lu\b^brv \hdjm]ijbgZ^e_`bl chjbYdb
bf_xl lhevdhk\hx yjhklvb lhqlh a_fey^Z_l bf[_kieZlgh
>he]h_ \j_fygbdh g_ijhbag_k gbkeh\ZaZl_f ^hgOmZg
ih^gyekyihijhsZeky b\ur_eFu kfhlj_ebgZ g_]hihdZ hg
g_ kdjueky aZ
ih\hjhlhf
^hjh]b<k_
fudZaZehkv
g_j\gbqZebExkbh g_m\_j_gguf lhghfkdZaZeqlh _]h ^_^
mr_elZd dZd _fmg_ gjZ\blky`Zjdh_ ba djhebdZWebobh
dZaZeky ih]jm`_gguf\ k\hbfukeb;_gbgvh ih\_jgmekydh fg_
b ]jhfdhkdZaZe
Y ^mfZxqlh ]hkih^vgZdZ`_l l_[yb ^hgZOmZgZ aZlh
qlh \u^_eZ_l_
Exkbh gZqZeohohlZlvb ;_gbgvhd g_fmijbkh_^bgbeky
Lu iZykgbqZ_rv;_gbgvhkihdhcgh kdZaZeWebobh
lhqlh lulhevdh qlhkdZaZeg_ klhblb ]jhrZ
k_gly[jy ]
;ueh qZkh\ \_q_jZ km[[hlu>hg OmZg kb^_e i_j_^
Webobh gZjZfZ^_ Exkbh>hg OmZgihklZ\be f_`^mkh[hc b bf
dhjabgm ki_chlgufb [ZlhgqbdZfbb i_eke_]dZ jZkdZqb\Zykv
\i_j_^ bgZaZ^
Exkbh;_gbgvh b ykb^_eb \ihemlhjZ ^\mo f_ljZo
ihaZ^b Webobhhi_jrbkv ]heh\hch kl_gm
KgZqZeZ [ueh kh\k_fl_fghFu kb^_eb\gmljb ^hfZ ih^
eZfihch`b^Zy ^hgZOmZgZHg \ua\ZegZk gZjZfZ^mdh]^Z
ijbr_eb ihdZaZe]^_ dhfmk_klvQ_j_a g_dhlhjh_\j_fy fhb
]eZaZ ijb\udeb d l_fghl_Y fh]ykgh \b^_lv dZ`^h]hY
m\b^_eqlh WebobhdZaZeky kdh\Zggufm`Zkhf<k_ _]h l_eh
ljykehkv_]h
am[u
g_ijhba\hevgh
klmqZeb?]h l_eh
khljykZehkv kiZafZlbq_kdbfbih^_j]b\Zgbyfb ]heh\ub kibgu
>hg OmZgh[jZlbeky dg_fmm]h\Zjb\Zy _]hg_ [hylvkyb
^h\_jblvky aZsblgbdmb g_^mfZlv gbh q_f^jm]hfHg \aye
i_chlguc [Zlhgqbdij_ih^g_k _]hWebobh b\_e_e _fm `_\Zlv
hq_gv f_^e_gghWebobh \a\ba]gmedZd s_ghdb jZkijyfbeky
^uoZgb_ _]h [ueh hq_gv[ukljufhgh a\mqZehdZd \a^hob
dmag_qguo f_oh\Hg kgyereyim b\ul_j _xeh[Hg aZdjue
ebph jmdZfbY ^mfZeqlh hgieZq_lWlh [uehq_gv ^he]bc
gZijy`_gguc fhf_gl ij_`^_q_f hg \hkklZgh\be dZdhclh
dhgljhev gZ^kh[hc
Hg k_eijyfh\k_ _s_ihdju\Zy ebphh^ghc jmdhc\aye
i_chlguc [Zlhgqbd b gZqZe
_]h `_\ZlvY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
h]jhfgh_ h[e_]q_gb_>h wlh]hy g_hl^Z\Ze k_[_ hlq_lZ \
lhfqlh y[hyekyih`ZemclZd`_dZd WebobhM f_gy\h jlm
ihy\beZkv kmohklv \jh^_lhcqlh ^Z_li_chlWebobh `_\Ze
[Zlhgqbd ^he]hFh_ gZijy`_gb_\hajZklZehY gZqZeg_\hevgh
ihdZqb\Zlvkydh]^Z fh_^uoZgb_ m[ukljbehkv
>hg OmZg gZqZe i_lv]jhfq_aZl_f hg ih^g_k Webobh
^jm]hc [Zlhgqbdb ihke_lh]hdZd Webobhhdhgqbe _]h`_\Zlv
^Ze _fmkmobo njmdlh\b \_e_e`_\Zlv hq_gvf_^e_ggh
G_kdhevdh jZaWebobh ih^gbfZekyb moh^be\ dmkluH^bg
jZa hgihijhkbe \h^u>hg OmZg\_e_e _fmg_ ]ehlZlv\h^mgh
lhevdh ijhihehkdZlv _x jhlWebobh
jZa`_\Ze _s_ ^\Z
[ZlhgqbdZZ ^hgOmZg ^Ze_fm kmr_gh]hfykZ
D lhfm\j_f_gbdZd hgjZa`_\Ze ^_kyluc[Zlhgqbdy m`_
[ue ihqlb[he_g hlg_l_ji_gby<g_aZigh WebobhmiZe \i_j_^
b _]h eh[ dhkgmekya_febhg i_j_dZlbekygZ e_\uc [hd b
dhg\mevkb\gh ^_jgmekyY \a]eygmegZ qZku;ueh qZkZ
fbgmlWebobh dZlZekydZqZeky bihklZgu\Ze gZihem [he__
qZkZ
>hg OmZg \k_\ lhf`_ iheh`_gbbkb^_e i_j_^gbf?]h
i_chlgu_ i_kgbi_ebkv ihqlbr_ihlhf;_gbgvhkb^_\rbc ke_\Z
hl f_gykfhlj_e [_a\gbfZgbyExkbh jy^hfkh fghckdehgbeky
gZ [hdb ojZi_e
L_eh Webobh k\_jgmehkv\ dZeZqbdHg e_`ZegZ ijZ\hf
[hdm ebphfdh fg_aZ`Z\ jmdbf_`^m dhe_g_c?]h l_ehkbevgh
ih^iju]b\Zehb hg i_j_\_jgmekygZ kibgmke_]dZ kh]gm\
gh]b?]h e_\ZyjmdZ ihfZob\ZeZhl k_[yb \\_jo bkdexqb
l_evgh k\h[h^gufbb we_]Zglgufb^\b`_gbyfb?]h ijZ\ZyjmdZ
klZeZ ih\lhjylv l_ `_^\b`_gbyb aZl_f h[_ jmdb klZeb
q_j_^h\Zlv h^bgZdh\u_f_^e_ggu_ ihfZob\Zxsb_^\b`_gby \jh^_
l_oqlh \uihegy_lb]jhd gZZjn_Ihkl_i_ggh ^\b`_gbyklZeb
[he__ [ukljufb?]h dbklbhsmlbfh \b[jbjh\Zebb ^\b]Zebkv
\\_jo b\gbadZd ihjrgb< lh`_ kZfh_\j_fy _]hij_^ie_qvy
kh\_jrZeb djm]h\u_^\b`_gby gZk_[yb _]hiZevpu ihhq_j_^gh
k]b[Zebkv b jZa]b[ZebkvWlh [ueh ij_djZkgh_ ]Zjfhgbqgh_
]bighlbabjmxs__ aj_ebs_Y ^mfZxqlh _]hjblf bfmkdmevguc
dhgljhev [uebg_kjZ\g_ggufb
AZl_f Webobhf_^e_ggh ih^gyekydZd _keb[u hibjZykvgZ
h[\heZdb\Zxsmx kbem?]h l_eh^jh`ZehHg dZqgmekyZ aZl_f
lheqdhf \uijyfbeky?]h jmdblmeh\bs_ b]heh\Z ljykebkv
dZd _keb[u q_j_agbo ijhimkdZebij_ju\bkluc we_dljbq_kdbc
lhdDZaZehkvkbeZ\g_ _]hdhgljheyk`ZeZ _]hb ih^ufZeZ
I_gb_ ^hgZOmZgZ klZehhq_gv ]jhfdbfExkbh b ;_gbgvh
ijhkgmebkvg_dhlhjh_ \j_fy
[_a
bgl_j_kZ kfhlj_eb gZ
ijhbkoh^ys__ b aZkgmebkgh\ZWebobhdZaZehkv^\b]Zeky
dm^Zlh \\_job \\_joHg y\ghdZjZ[dZekyHg \uly]b\Zejmdb
b o\ZlZeky aZ qlhlhfg_ g_\b^bfh_Hg ih^ly]b\Zeky b
aZfbjZeqlh[u i_j_\_klb^uoZgb_
Y ohl_em\b^_lv _]h]eZaZ b^\bgmeky [eb`_d g_fmgh
^hg OmZg k\bj_ihihkfhlj_e gZf_gyb y\_jgmeky gZ k\h_
f_klh
AZl_f Webobhiju]gmeWlh [ueihke_^gbc m`Zkguciju`hd
Hghq_\b^gh^hklb] k\h_cp_ebHg hl^m\Zekyb \koebiu\Ze
hl i_j_gZijy`_gbyHgdZaZehkv^_j`Zeky aZ dZdhclh
\uklmiGh qlhlh _]hi_j_kbeb\ZehHg \kdjbdgme\ hlqZygbb
?]h o\ZldZ khkdhevagmeZb hg gZqZe iZ^Zlv?]h l_eh
\u]gmehkv gZaZ^ b khljykZehkv k]heh\u ^h iZevp_\ gh]
bkdexqbl_evgh djZkb\hcdhhj^bgbjh\Zgghc ^jh`vx<hegZ ^jh`b
ijhreZ q_j_ag_]h g_f_g__ klZjZa ij_`^_q_f l_ehjmogmeh
gZ a_fexdZd [_a`bag_ggucf_rhd
Q_j_a g_dhlhjh_\j_fy hg\ulygme jmdbi_j_^ kh[hcdZd
_keb [uhg aZsbsZek\h_ ebph?]h gh]b[ueb \ulygmlugZaZ^
\ lh\j_fydZd hge_`Ze gZ]jm^bHgb [uebke_]dZ ih^gylu
gZ^ a_fe_cijb^Z\Zy l_emlZdhc \b^dZd [m^lhhgh kdhevabeh
beb e_l_eh k g_\_jhylghckdhjhklvx?]h ]heh\Z [ueZ ^h
ij_^_eZ hldbgmlZ gZaZ^?]h
jmdb [ueb kp_ie_gu i_j_^
]eZaZfbaZsbsZy boY fh]qm\kl\h\ZlvdZd \_l_j k\bklbl
\hdjm] g_]hY Zogmeb ba^Zeg_\hevguc \kdjbdExkbh b
;_gbgvh ijhkgmebkvb kex[hiulkl\hf \a]eygmebgZ Webobh
?keb luh[_sZ_rv dmiblvfg_ fhlhpbdey [m^m k_cqZk
`_\Zlv wlh]jhfdh kdZaZeExkbh
Y \a]eygme
gZ
^hgZ
OmZgZHg
k^_eZe ]heh\hc
ih\_ebl_evguc agZd
Kmdbg kugijh[hjfhlZe Exkbhb hiylvaZkgme
Webobh \klZe bgZqZe oh^blvHg k^_eZeiZjm rZ]h\ b
hklZgh\bekyY fh]\b^_lvqlh hgmeu[Z_lky kh kqZkleb\uf
\ujZ`_gb_fHg ihiulZeky
k\bkl_lvQbklh]h
a\mdZ g_
ihemqbehkvgh ]Zjfhgby[ueZWlh [ueZdZdZylh f_eh^byHgZ
bf_eZ ebrv iZjm i_j_oh^h\dhlhju_ hg ih\lhjye \gh\v b
\gh\vQ_j_a g_dhlhjh_
\j_fy
hlq_leb\h
klZeh keurgh
gZk\bklu\Zgb_b aZl_f hghklZeh ykghc f_eh^b_cWebobh
[hjfhlZe g_\gylgu_keh\ZWlb keh\Z[ueb keh\Zfbi_kgbHg
ih\lhjye bo qZkZfbHq_gv
ijhklZy i_kgy k ih\lhjZfb
fhghlhggZyb \k_`_ kljZgghdjZkb\Zy
WebobhdZaZehkvkfhlj_e gZqlhlh ihdZi_eH^bg jZa
hg ih^hr_e hq_gv [ebadhdh fg_Y \b^_e \ ihemlvf_ _]h
]eZaZHgb [uebkl_deyggufb hklZgh\b\rbfbkyHg meu[Zeky b
ihkf_b\ZekyHg ihoh^be bk_eb ihoh^be_s_b i_eb
klhgZe
<g_aZigh qlhlhdZaZehkvlhedgmeh _]hkaZ^b?]h l_eh
\u]gmehkv ihkj_^bg_dZd _keb[u _]h^\b]ZeZ ijyfZy kbeZ
DZdh_lh \j_fy Webobhm^_j`b\Ze jZ\gh\_kb_gZ ghkdZo gh]
h[jZah\Z\ ba k\h_]h l_eZ ihqlb iheguc djm]?]h jmdb
dZkZebkv a_febAZl_f hg\gh\v miZegZ ihefy]dhgZ kibgm
\ulygmeky \h\kx ^ebgmb aZklue\ kljZgghfhp_i_g_gbb
G_dhlhjh_ \j_fy hg [hjfhlZeb klhgZeaZl_f gZqZe
ojZi_lv>hg OmZgihdjue _]himklufb f_rdZfb;ueh qZkh\
fbgml mljZ
Exkbh b ;_gbgvhkiZeb ie_qhd ie_qmijbkehgb\rbkv d
kl_g_Fu k ^hghfOmZghf hq_gv^he]h kb^_eb fheqZHg
dZaZehkvmklZe
Y gZjmrbe lbrbgmb kijhkbe_]h h[WebobhHg kdZaZe
fg_qlh \klj_qZ Webobhk f_kdZeblh [ueZ bkdexqbl_evgh
mki_rghcF_kdZeblh gZmqbe_]h i_kg_m`_ ijbi_j\hc \klj_q_
Z wlh^_ckl\bl_evgh g_h[uqgh
Y kijhkbe _]hihq_fm hgg_ jZaj_rbe Exkbh ijbgylv
i_chl aZfhlhpbdeHg kdZaZeqlh f_kdZeblhm[be [u Exkbh
_keb [ lhlijb[ebabeky dg_fm gZlZdbo mkeh\byo>hg OmZg
ijbagZeqlh hgijb]hlh\be \k_hq_gv lsZl_evgh ^ey lh]h
qlh[u ijb\e_qvk\h_]h \gmdZHg kdZaZefg_qlh jZkkqblu\Ze
gZ fhx^jm`[m kExkbhdZd gZp_gljZevguc fhf_glkljZl_]bb
Hg kdZaZeqlh Exkbh\k_]^Z [ue_]h [hevrhcaZ[hlhc b qlh
dh]^Zlh hgb `beb\f_kl_ b[ueb hq_gv[ebadbgh Exkbh \
\hajZkl_ k_fbe_l hq_gvk_jv_agh aZ[he_eb kug^hgZ OmZgZ
gZ[h`guc dZlhebd^Ze h[_l]\Z^_emikdhc [h]hfZl_jbqlh
Exkbh ihklmibl \ rdhemk\ys_gguo lZgp_\_keb _]h `bagv
[m^_l kiZk_gZExkbh ihijZ\bekyb \ugm`^_g [ue bkihegblv
h[_sZgb_Hg h^gm g_^_exijh[ue mq_gbdhf b aZl_f j_rbe
gZjmrblv deyl\mHg ^mfZeqlh \ j_amevlZl_ wlh]h _fm
ijb^_lky mf_j_lv b p_euc^_gv `^Ze ijboh^Z kf_jlb<k_
kf_yebkv gZ^fZevqbdhfb kemqZcwlhl g_aZ[ueky
>hg OmZg ^he]h_\j_fy g_]h\hjbeHgdZaZehkv[ue
ih]jm`_g \k\hb fukeb
Fhy klZ\dZ[ueZ gZExkbhkdZaZe hgb \f_klh
g_]h y gZr_eWebobhY agZeqlh wlh[_kihe_aghgh dh]^Z
gZf dlhlh gjZ\blkyfu ^he`gu^he`guf h[jZahf gZklZb\Zlv
dZd _keb[ [ueh\hafh`guf i_j_^_eu\Zlvex^_cM Exkbh [ueh
fm`_kl\hdh]^Z hg [uefZe_gvdbf fZevqbdhfZ aZl_f hg
ihjZkl_jye _]hih ^hjh]_
Fh`_rv eblu hdhe^h\Zlv_]h^hg OmZg"
Hdhe^h\Zlv _]h"AZq_f"
Qlh[u hg\gh\v baf_gbekyb h[j_ek\h_ fm`_kl\h
G_evay hdhe^h\Zlvq_eh\_dZqlh[ hggZr_e fm`_kl\h
Hdhe^h\u\Zxl ^eylh]hqlh[u k^_eZlvex^_c [_a\j_^gufb beb
[hevgufbbeb g_fufbG_evay hdhe^h\ZlvlZdqlh[u ihemqblv
\hbgZ>ey lh]hqlh[u [ulv\hbghfgZ^h [ulv ojmklZevgh
qbklufdZd Webobh<hl l_[_q_eh\_d fm`_kl\Z
Webobh fbjgh ojZi_e ih^imklufb f_rdZfb;ueh m`_
k\_lehG_[h [uehg_aZiylgZgghc kbg_\uG_ [ueh \b^gh gb
h^gh]h h[eZqdZ
Y hl^Ze[u qlhm]h^gh \wlhf fbj_qlh[u magZlvh lhf
iml_r_kl\bbdhlhjh_ ijh^_eZeWebobhLu g_\hajZ`Z_rv_keb
y ihijhrm_]h jZkkdZaZlvfg_ h[wlhf"
Gb ijbdZdbo h[klhyl_evkl\Zolu g_^he`_g ijhkblv_]h
h[ wlhf
Gh ihq_fm`_"Y \_^vjZkkdZau\Zx l_[_\k_ h k\h_f
hiul_
Wlh kh\k_f^jm]h_G_l \l_[_ gZdehgghklb^_j`Zlv \k_
ijb k_[_Webobh bg^__p?]h iml_r_kl\b_wlh \k_qlh hg
bf__lOhl_e [uyqlh[u wlh[ue Exkbh
JZa\_ g_lgbq_]hqlh lufh`_rv k^_eZlv^ey Exkbh
^hg OmZg"
G_lD g_kqZklvxg_l lZdh]hkihkh[Zqlh[u k^_eZlv
dhklb ^eyf_^mauWlh [ueZlhevdh fhy]emihklv
Lu fgh]hjZa ]h\hjbefg_^hg OmZgqlh fZ]g_ fh`_l
bf_lv ]emihklvY gbdh]^Zg_ ^mfZeqlh lufh`_rv __bf_lv
<hafh`gh gZklZb\Zlv^he`guf h[jZahfgZklZb\Zlv
^Z`_ g_kfhljygZ lhqlh fuagZ_fqlh lhqlh fu^_eZ_f [_kihe_aghGh ij_`^_fu ^he`guagZlvqlh gZrb [_ckl\by
[_kihe_agub \k_`_ fu^he`gu boijh^he`ZlvdZd _keb [u
wlh]h
g_
agZebWlh
dh gl jh eb jm _f Zy
] em ih kl v
fZ ]Z =eZ\Z
iy lZ y
Y \_jgmeky \ ^hf ^hgZOmZgZ hdly[jy ]K
_^bgkl\_gghc p_evx jZkkijhkblv_]h h jZaebqguo fhf_glZo
khimlkl\h\Z\rbo ihk\ys_gbxWebobhIhqlb [_kdhg_qguc ihlhd
\hijhkh\ \hagbdm f_gydh]^Z yi_j_qblu\Ze hibkZgb_ lh]h
qlh lh]^Z ijhbahrehY
ohl_e
ihemqblv hq_gv lhqgu_
h[tykg_gbyihwlhfm y aZjZg__khklZ\be kibkhd \hijhkh\
lsZl_evgh ih^[bjZygZb[he__ ih^oh^ysb_keh\Z
Y gZqZek lh]hqlh kijhkbe_]h
>hg OmZgy \b ^_ e
lhcghqvx"
Lu ihqlb \b ^_ e
: lu \b ^_ eqlh y \b `m
^\b`_gbyWebobh"
>Zy
\b ^_ eqlh f_kdZeblh iha\hebe l_[_
\ b^ _l v
qZklv mjhdZWebobhbgZq_ lukfhlj_e [u gZ
q_eh\_dZdhlhjuc kb^bl bebe_`bl<h \j_fy ihke_^g_]h
fblhlZ lug_ aZf_lbeqlh[u ex^blZf qlheb[h ^_eZebg_ lZd
eb"
GZ ihke_^g_f fblhl_y g_aZf_lbeqlh[ dlhgb[m^v ba
fm`qbg \uihegyeqlheb[h g_h[uqgh_Y kdZaZe_fmqlh fh]m
ijyfh ijbagZlvky\k_qlh yaZibkZe \k\hbo aZf_ldZolZd
wlh lhqlh g_dhlhju_ba gbooh^beb \dmklu qZs_^jm]bo
Gh lu ihqlb
m\ b^ _e
\_kv mjhd Webobh
ijh^he`Ze ^hgOmZgih^mfZc h[wlhfIhgbfZ_rv l_i_jvdZd
bkdj_g_g f_kdZeblh klh[hc"F_kdZeblh gbdh]^Zg_ [ue lZd
fy]hd gbk d_fgZkdhevdh yagZxGb kh^gbfB \k_`_ lug_
[eZ]h^Zj_g _fm aZ_]h bkdj_gghklvDZd fh`_rvlu lZd lmih
ih\hjZqb\Zlvky d g_fm kibghc"Bebfh`_lfg_ ke_^m_l
kdZaZlv\ hlf_kldm aZqlh lu ih\hjZqb\Z_rvky kibghc d
f_kdZeblh"
Y ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh ^hgOmZg hiylvaZ]hgy_l f_gy \
m]heY g_fh] hl\_lblvgZ _]h\hijhkY \k_]^ZkqblZeqlh
y ihdhgqbe k mq_gbq_kl\hf^ey lh]hqlh[u kiZklb k_[y
h^gZdh y g_bf_x ij_^klZ\e_gbyhl q_]hy kiZkZxk_[y beb
aZq_fY aZohl_e ih[uklj__ baf_gblv gZijZ\e_gb_ gZr_]h
jZa]h\hjZb ihwlhfm yhklZ\be k\h_gZf_j_gv_ ih ihjy^dm
aZ^Z\Zlv khklZ\e_ggu_fghx aZjZg__\hijhku b\u^\bgme kZfuc
\Z`guc \hijhk
G_ fh`_rveb lujZkkdZaZlv fg_h k\h_cdhgljhebjm_fhc
]emihklb"kdZaZe y
Qlh luohq_rv agZlvh g_c"
Ih`ZemcklZkdZ`b fg_^hg OmZgqlh `_\ lhqghklb
ij_^klZ\ey_l bak_[y dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklv
>hg OmZg]jhfdh jZkohohlZekyb ]jhfdhoehigme k_[y ih
ey`d_ eZ^hgvx
Wlh dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklvb aZkf_yekyb oehigme
k_[y ihey`d_ hiylv
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m"
Y jZ^qlh lugZdhg_pkijhkbe f_gy h fh_c
dhgljhebjm_fhc ]emihklbihke_ klhevdboe_lb \k_`_ fg_g_
[ueh [ujh\guf kq_lhfgbdZdh]h ^_eZ^h wlh]h_keb [lu g_
kijhkbe gbdh]^Z<k_ `_y ba[jZe[ulv kqZkleb\ufhl wlh]h
dZd _keb [fg_ ^hwlh]h [ueh^_ehqlh[u lu kijhkbedZd
_keb [bf_eh agZq_gb_lhqlh fg_[ueh ^hwlh]h ^_ehWlh b
_klv dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklv
Fu h[Z ]jhfdh aZkf_yebkvY h[gye_]hY gZr_e _]h
h[tykg_gb_ ij_\hkoh^gufohly yb g_ihgye _]hiheghklvx
Fu kb^_ebdZd h[uqghi_j_^ ^\_jvfb_]h ^hfZ;ueh
iha^g__ mljhI_j_^ ^hghfOmZghf [ueZdmqZ k_fygb hg
\u[bjZe ba gbofmkhjY ij_^eh`be_fm k\hxihfhsvgh hg
hlkljZgbe f_gyhg kdZaZeqlh k_f_gZwlh ih^Zjhd h^ghfm
ba _]h ^jma_c \ p_gljZevghc
F_dkbd_b m f_gy g_l
^hklZlhqghc kbeuqlh[u ijbdZkZlvkyd gbf
K d_f luijbf_gy_rv dhgljhebjm_fmx ]emihklv^hg
OmZg"kijhkbe yihke_ ^he]h]hfheqZgby
Kh \k_fb\hkdebdgme hgmeu[Zykv
Y qm\kl\h\Zeqlh ^he`_ghklZgh\blvky gZwlhf fhf_gl_
b kijhkbe_]hhagZqZ_l eb_]h dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklvqlh
_]h ihklmidbgbdh]^Z g_[u\Zxl bkdj_ggbfbZ ebrv ^_ckl\by
Zdl_jZ"
Fhb ihklmidbbkdj_ggbgh hgbebrv ^_ckl\byZdl_jZ
Gh lh]^Z
\k_qlh
lu
^_eZ_rv^he`gh [ulv
dhgljhebjm_fhc ]emihklvxkdZaZe yihbklbg_ m^b\e_gguc
>Z\k_
Gh wlhg_ fh`_l[ulv ijZ\^hcqlh dZ`^uchl^_evguc ba
l\hbo ihklmidh\_klv lhevdhdhgljhebjm_fZy ]emihklv
Gh ihq_fmg_l"
Wlh hagZqZeh[uqlh ^eyl_[y\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb
gbdlh bgbqlh gbq_]hg_ agZqZl<havfbgZijbf_jf_gyLu
bf__rv \ \b^mqlh ^eyl_[y g_bf__l agZq_gby[m^m y
q_eh\_dhf agZgby beb g_l`b\m y beb mfjmbeb ^_eZx
qlheb[h"
<_jghfg_ g_l^h wlh]h^_eZLudZd Exkbh beb
dlheb[h _s_\ fh_c`bagb fhy dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklv
Y bkiulZe j_^dh_qm\kl\h imklhluHq_\b^ghg_ [ueh
lZdhc ijbqbgu \ fbj_ihq_fm [u ^hg OmZg ^he`_g [ue
aZ[hlblvky h[h fg_ghk ^jm]hcklhjhguy [ue ihqlb
m\_j_gqlh _fm_klv ^_eh^h f_gyebqghy ^mfZeqlh bgZq_b
[ulv g_ fh`_lihkdhevdm
hg
\k_]^Z m^_eye fg_ k\h_
g_jZa^_e_ggh_ \gbfZgb_\ ex[hcfhf_gldhlhjuc yijh\h^be k
gbfFg_ ih^mfZehkvqlhfh`_l [ulv^hg OmZglZd ]h\hjbl
ijhklh ihlhfmqlh y_fm gZ^h_e< dhgp_dhgph\\_^v y
hldZaZeky hl_]h mq_gby
Y qm\kl\mxqlh fu]h\hjbf hjZaguo \_sZokdZaZe
yFg_ g_ke_^h\Zeh ijb\h^blv\ ijbf_jkZfh]h k_[yY bf_e
\ \b^mqlh ^he`gh[ulv \fbj_ qlhgb[m^v^h q_]hl_[_ _klv
^_eh\ lhfkfuke_qlh wlhg_ dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklvY g_
^mfZxqlh[ fh`gh
[ueh
ijh^he`Zlv
`blv_keb gZf
^_ckl\bl_evghgb ^hq_]h g_[m^_l ^_eZ
Wlh hlghkblky d
l_ [_ <_sb bf_xl agZq_gby
^ ey
l_ [y Lu kijhkbef_gy hfh_c dhgljhebjm_fhc
]emihklbb ykdZaZe l_[_qlh \k_qlh y^_eZx ihhlghr_gbx
d k_[_b d^jm]bf ex^yf_klv ]emihklvihlhfm qlhgbq_]h
g_ bf__lagZq_gby
Y ohqmkdZaZlv^hg OmZgqlh _keb^ey l_[ygbq_]h g_
bf__l agZq_gbylh dZdlu fh`_rv ijh^he`Zlv `blvY
^_ckl\bl_evghohqm agZlvlZ ^he`_gh[tykgblv fg_qlh lu
bf__rv \\b^m
Fh`_l [ulvwlh bg_\hafh`gh h[tykgblvG_dhlhju_
\_sb \l\h_c `bagbbf_xl ^eyl_[y agZq_gb_ihlhfm qlh hgb
\Z`guL\hb ihklmidbhij_^_e_ggh\Z`gu ^eyl_[ygh ^ey
f_gy gb _^bgZy\_sv g_y\ey_lky [he__\Z`ghc bgb h^bg ba
fhbo ihklmidh\b gbh^bg baihklmidh\ ex^_cL_f g_f_g__
y ijh^he`Zx `blvlZd dZdy bf_xk\hx \hexihlhfm qlh y
gZkljhbe k\hx\hexijhoh^y q_j_a`bagv^h lZdboihjqlh
hgZ klZeZhllhq_gghc bp_evghcb l_i_jv^ey f_gygbq_]h g_
agZqbl lhqlh gbq_]h
g_
bf__l
agZq_gbyFhy \hey
dhgljhebjm_l ]emihklvfh_c `bagb
Y kdZaZe_fmqlhihfh_fmg_dhlhju_ ihklmidb ex^_c
[ueb hq_gv\Z`guy kdZaZeqlh y^_jgZy\hcgZhij_^_e_ggh
[ueZ kZfuf^jZfZlbq_kdbf ijbf_jhflZdbo ihklmidh\Y kdZaZe
qlh ^ey f_gymgbqlh`_gb_ `bagbgZ a_fe_[ueh [u ihklmidhf
qj_a\uqZcgh g_ghjfZevguf
Lu \_jbrvwlhfmihlhfm qlh^mfZ_rvLu ^mfZ_rv h
`bagbL u
g_
\b ^b rv JZa\_ y qm\kl\h\Ze [u
bgZq__keb [u y fh]
\ b^ _l v"
DZd lhevdh q_eh\_d gZmqblky
\b ^_ lv hg
hdZ`_lky h^bg \ fbj_]^_ _klv lhevdh ]emihklvL\hb
ihklmidblhqgh lZd`_dZd ihklmidb^jm]bo ex^_c\ h[s_f
dZ`_lky \Z`gufb^ey l_[yihlhfm qlhlu gZmqbeky^mfZlvqlh
hgb \Z`guFu \umqb\Z_fky^mfZlv h[h\k_fb aZl_fijbmqZ_f
gZrb ]eZaZ \b^_lvlZddZd fu^mfZ_f h\_sZogZ dhlhju_
kfhljbfFu kfhljbfgZ k_[ym`_ ^mfZyqlh fu\Z`guB lZd
hdZau\Z_lkyqlh fuqm\kl\m_f k_[y\Z`gufbGh lh]^Zdh]^Z
q_eh\_d gZmqblky \b ^_ lv hg ihcf_lqlh hgg_ fh`_l
[hevr_ ^mfZlv h \_sZogZ dhlhju_kfhljblZ _keb hg g_
fh`_l ^mfZlvh \_sZogZ dhlhju_kfhljbllh \k_klZgh\blky
g_\Z`guf
>hg OmZg^he`gh [ulvaZf_lbe fhcm^b\e_gguc \a]ey^b
ih\lhjbe k\h_ ml\_j`^_gb_ ljb
jZaZdZd [u klZjZykv
aZklZ\blv f_gy ihgylvLhqlh hgkdZaZekgZqZeZ a\mqZeh
^ey f_gydZd _jmg^Zgh ihjZafukeb\h[ wlhfy m\b^_eqlh
_]h keh\Zkdhj__ gZihfbgZxlfm^j_gh_ ml\_j`^_gb_h dZdhclh
ba klhjhg\hkijbylby
Y ihiulZekyijb^mfZlv ohjhrbc\hijhkdhlhjuc aZklZ\be
[u _]hijhykgblv k\hxlhqdm aj_gbygh gbq_]hg_ ijb^mfZe
<g_aZigh y ihqm\kl\h\Ze kbevgmxmklZehkv b g_ fh] ykgh
nhjfmebjh\Zlv k\hb fukeb>hg OmZgdZaZehkvaZf_lbe fh_
mlhfe_gb_ bfy]dh ihoehiZef_gy ihkibg_
Ihqbklb \hl wlbjZkl_gbykdZaZe hgZ aZl_f
ihdjhrb bo\ wlhl]hjrhdhg \jmqbefg_ [hevrhc]hjrhd b
\ur_e
Hg \_jgmeky ^hfhc q_j_ag_kdhevdh qZkh\dh]^Z m`_
[ebabeky \_q_jY hdhgqbe djhrblv_]h jZkl_gby b bf_e
^hklZlhqgh \j_f_gbqlh[u aZibkZlvk\hb aZf_ldbY ohl_e
kjZam `_ aZ^Zlv _fm g_kdhevdh \hijhkh\gh [ue g_ \
gZkljh_gbb hl\_qZlv fg_Hg kdZaZeqlh ]heh^_g b ohq_l
kgZqZeZ ijh]ehlblvibsm
Hg jZa`_] h]hgv\ k\h_c]ebgyghc i_qmjd_ b ihklZ\be
]hjrhd k[mevhghfijb]hlh\e_gguf gZdhklyoHg aZ]eygme \
iZd_lu kijh\bab_cb \u[jZeg_dhlhju_ h\hsbgZj_aZe bogZ
f_edb_ dmkhqdb b[jhkbe \dhl_eAZl_f hge_] gZ pbgh\dm
k[jhkbe kZg^Zebbb \_e_efg_ k_klvih[eb`_ di_qd_qlh[u y
fh] ih^^_j`b\Zlvh]hgv
;ueh hq_gv l_fghk lh]hf_klZ]^_ ykb^_ey fh]
\b^_lv g_[hgZ aZiZ^_DjZy g_dhlhjuolhekluo h[eZdh\ [ueb
baj_aZgu ]em[hdbfbfhjsbgZfb\ lh\j_fydZd p_gljh[eZdh\
[ue ihqlbq_jgufY kh[bjZekyk^_eZlv aZf_qZgb_h lhfdZdb_
djZkb\u_ h[eZdZgh hgaZ]h\hjbe i_j\uf
Juoeu_ djZyb iehlgucp_gljkdZaZe hgmdZau\Zy gZ
h[eZdZ
?]h aZf_qZgb_ [ueh klhevkh\iZ^Zxsbf k l_fqlh y
kh[bjZeky kdZaZlvqlh yih^kdhqbe
Y lhevdhqlh kh[bjZekykdZaZlv l_[_h[ h[eZdZo
kdZaZe y
AgZqbllml yih[be l_[ykdZaZe hgb aZkf_yeky k
^_lkdhc g_ihkj_^kl\_gghklvx
Y kijhkbe _]hg_ \gZkljh_gbb ebhg hl\_lblvfg_ gZ
g_kdhevdh \hijhkh\
Qlh luohq_rv agZlv"hl\_lbe hg
Lhqlh lukdZaZe fg_k_]h^gy ^g_fh dhgljhebjm_fhc
]emihklbhq_gv kbevgh\a\hegh\Zeh f_gyY^_ckl\bl_evgh
g_ fh]mihgylvqlh lubf__rv \\b^m
Dhg_qghlu g_fh`_rv ihgylvLu iulZ_rvky^mfZlv h[
wlhfZ lhqlh ykdZaZeg_ kh\iZ^Z_lk l\hbfbfukeyfb
Y iulZxkv^mfZlv h[wlhfihlhfm qlhebqgh ^ey f_gy
wlh _^bgkl\_gguckihkh[ qlheb[h ihgylvGZijbf_j^hg OmZg
lu bf__rv \ \b^mqlh
dZd
lhevdh q_eh\_d gZmqblky
\ b^ _l vlZd kjZam`_ \p_ehf fbj_\k_ ihl_jy_lk\hx
p_gghklv"
Y g_kdZaZeqlh ihl_jy_lp_gghklvY kdZaZeklZg_l
g_\Z`guf<k_ jZ\gh b ihwlhfm g_\Z`ghLZdgZijbf_j
gbdZdbf h[jZahf yg_ fh]mkdZaZlvqlh fhbihklmidb [he__
\Z`guq_f l\hbbeb qlhh^gZ \_sv[he__ kms_kl\_ggZq_f
^jm]Zyb ihwlhfm\k_ \_sbjZ\gub hllh]hqlh hgb jZ\gu
gb h^gZba gbog_ \Z`gZ
Y kijhkbe
_]hg_
y\eyebkv
eb
_]h iheh`_gby
ijh\ha]eZr_gb_f lh]hqlh lhqlh hg gZau\Z_l
\b ^_
g v_ f[uehnZdlbq_kdb[he__ ohjhrbf kihkh[hfq_f
ijhklh kfhlj_gb_ gZ\_sbHg kdZaZeqlh ]eZaZ q_eh\_dZ
fh]ml \uihegylvh[_ nmgdpbbgh gbh^gZ bagbo g_ y\ey_lky
emqr_ ^jm]hch^gZdhijbmqZlv k\hb]eZaZ lhevdh kfhlj_lv
ih _]hfg_gbx[ueh ihl_j_cg_h[oh^bfhc
GZijbf_jgZf gm`gh kf hl j_ lv
]eZaZfb ^ey
lh]hqlh[u kf_ylvkyIhlhfm qlhlhevdh dh]^Zfu kfhljbfgZ
\_sbfu fh`_f ko\Zlblv aZ[Z\gu_]jZgb fbjZK ^jm]hc
klhjhgudh]^Z gZrb]eZaZ \b ^y llh]^Z \k_jZ\gh b
gbq_]h g_aZ[Z\gh
Lu bf__rv \\b^m^hg OmZgqlh q_eh\_ddhlhjuc
\ b^ bl ^Z`_ g_fh`_l kf_ylvky"
<hafh`gh_klv ex^b agZgbydhlhju_ gbdh]^Z g_
kf_xlkyohly yg_ agZxgb h^gh]hba gboL_dh]h y agZx
\ b^ yl gh lZd`_ b kf hl jy lihwlhfm hgb
kf_xlky
Fh`_l ebq_eh\_d agZgbyieZdZlv"
Y iheZ]ZxlZdGZrb ]eZaZkfhljylihwlhfm fu fh`_f
kf_ylvky bebieZdZlv\_k_eblvky bebi_qZeblvkyEbqgh yg_
ex[ex [ulv i_qZevgufihwlhfmdh]^Z ygZ[ex^Zx qlheb[h
qlh \ h[uqghf ihjy^d_aZklZ\beh [u f_gy hi_qZeblvkyy
ijhklh kf_sZxk\hb ]eZaZb \b `m
wlh\f_klh lh]hqlh[u
k fh lj _l v
gZwlhGh dh]^Zy \klj_qZxkvk q_feb[h
aZ[Z\gufy kf hl jx
gZwlhb ykf_xkvgh lh]^Z
^hg OmZgl\hc kf_o ^_ckl\bl_e_gZ g_ dhgljhebjm_fZy
]emihklv
>hg OmZgg_dhlhjh_ \j_fykfhlj_e gZf_gy
Y ]h\hjx klh[hcihlhfm qlhlu f_gy kf_rbrv
kdZaZe hglu gZihfbgZ_rvfg_ l_o imklugguo djuk k
imrbklufb o\hklZfbdhlhju_ ihiZ^Zxlkydh]^Z aZkh\u\Zxl
k\hb o\hklu\ ghju^jm]bo djukqlh[u bkim]Zlvbo bmdjZklv
bo ibsmLu ihiZeky\ k\hbkh[kl\_ggu_ \hijhku;_j_]bkv
Bgh]^Z wlb djukuh[ju\Zxl k_[_o\hkluqlh[u \uj\Zlvky gZ
k\h[h^m
Y gZr_e_]h kjZ\g_gb_aZ[Z\guf bjZkkf_yeky>hg OmZg
h^gZ`^u ihdZau\Ze fg_
g_[hevrbo
]jmamgh\ k imrbklufb
o\hklZfbdhlhju_ [uebihoh`b gZlhekluo [_ehddZjlbgZ]^_
h^gZ ba wlbo `bjguodjuk hldjmqb\Z_l k\hc o\hklqlh[u
\uj\Zlvky gZk\h[h^m[ueZ i_qZevghcb \lh `_\j_fy m`Zkgh
kf_rghc
Fhc kf_odZd b\k_ \hh[s_qlh y^_eZxj_Ze_g
kdZaZe ^hg OmZgb \lh `_ \j_fy wlh dhgljhebjm_fZy
]emihklvihlhfm qlhhg [_kihe_a_gHg gbq_]hg_ f_gy_lb
\k_ `_y kf_xkv
GhdZd yihgye^hg OmZgl\hc kf_og_ [_kihe_a_g
lZd dZdhg ^_eZ_ll_[y kqZkleb\uf
G_lY kqZkleb\ihlhfm qlhij_^ihq_e kfhlj_lv gZ
\_sbdhlhju_ ^_eZxl f_gykqZkleb\ufb lh]^Z fhb ]eZaZ
ko\Zlu\Zxl boaZ[Z\gu_ ]jZgbb ykf_xkvY ]h\hjbel_[_ wlh
m`_ [_kkq_lgh_ qbkehjZa<k_]^Z ke_^m_l\u[bjZlv ljhim k
k_j^p_f ^ey lh]hqlh[u [ulv\ emqr_f ^ey kZfh]h k_[y
iheh`_gbbfh`_l [ulvlh]^Z fh`gh[m^_l \k_]^Zkf_ylvky
Y bklhedh\Ze kdZaZggh_dZd lhqlh ieZq gb`_q_f
kf_obeb\hafh`gh^_ckl\b_dhlhjh_ gZk hkeZ[ey_lHg
kdZaZeqlh lmlg_l \gmlj_gg_cjZagbpu bqlh dZdlhlZd b
^jm]h_ g_\Z`ghHg kdZaZeh^gZdhqlh _]h ij_^ihql_gb_
kf_om \ua\Zghl_fqlh kf_oiha\hey_l _]hl_em qm\kl\h\Zlv
k_[y emqr_\ hlebqb_hl ieZqZGZ wlhy aZf_lbeqlh _keb
_klv ij_^ihql_gb_lh g_ljZ\_gkl\Z_keb ieZqmhg ij_^ihq_e
kf_oagZqbl ihke_^gbc^_ckl\bl_evgh [he__\Z`_gHg mijyfh
ih^^_j`Ze k\h_ \ukdZau\Zgb_qlh
_]h ij_^ihql_gb_ g_
hagZqZ_l lh]hqlh ieZqb kf_og_ jZ\guZ ygZklZb\Zeqlh
gZr kihjfh`_l [ulveh]bq_kdb ijh^e_g^h lh]hqlh[ kdZaZlv
qlh _keb\k_ \_sblZd jZ\gulh ihq_fm[u lh]^Zg_ \u[jZlv
kf_jlv
Fgh]b_ ex^b agZgby^_eZxl wlhH^gZ`^u hgb fh]ml
ijhklh bkq_agmlvEx^b
fh]ml
^mfZlvqlh
hgb [ueb
ih^dZjZme_gu b m[blu aZbo ^_ygbyHgb ba[bjZxl kf_jlv
ihlhfm qlh^ey gbowlh g_bf__l gbdZdh]hagZq_gbyK ^jm]hc
klhjhguy \u[jZe`blv bkf_ylvky g_ihlhfmqlh wlh bf__l
dZdh_eb[h agZq_gb_Z ihlhfmqlh lZdh\Zkdehgghklv fh_c
gZlmjuIjbqbgZih dhlhjhcy ]h\hjxqlh y\u[jZe wlh\
lhfqlh y
\b `m gh wlhg_ agZqblqlh y \u[bjZx
`blvg_kfhljy gb gZqlh balh]hqlh y
\b `m Lu
k_cqZk g_ ihgbfZ_rvf_gy baaZ k\h_cijb\uqdb ^mfZlv lZd
dZd kfhljbrvb ^mfZlvlZddZd ^mfZ_sv
?]h aZy\e_gb_hq_gv f_gyaZbgl_j_kh\ZehY ihijhkbe_]h
h[tykgblvqlh hg bf__l\ \b^mHg ih\lhjbelm `_ kZfmx
dhgkljmdpbx g_kdhevdh jZadZd [u^Z\Zy k_[_\j_fyqlh[u
ihkljhblv __ ^jm]bfbkeh\Zfbb aZl_f\ujZabe k\hx lhqdm
aj_gbykdZaZ\qlh ih^ ^m fZ gv _f
hgbf__l \ \b^m
lm ihklhyggmx b^_xdhlhjmx fubf__f h[h\k_f \ fbj_Hg
kdZaZeqlh
\b ^_ gv _
jZa]hgy_lwlm ijb\uqdmb ^h
l_o ihjihdZ yg_ gZmqmkv \b ^_ lv y g_kfh]m\
^_ckl\bl_evghklbihgylv lhqlh hgbf__l \\b^m
Gh _kebgbq_]h g_bf__l agZq_gby^hg OmZglh ihq_fm
[u bf_lvagZq_gb_ lhfmgZmqmkv y\b^_lv bebg_l"
h^gZ`^u ym`_ kdZaZel_[_qlh gZrZkm^v[ZdZd ex^_c
khklhbl \ lhfqlh[u mqblvky^ey ^h[jZbeb ^ey aeZY
gZmqbeky
\b ^_ lv
b ]h\hjx
l_[_qlh gbq_]h \
^_ckl\bl_evghklb g_ bf__l agZq_gbyL_i_jv l\hc q_j_^
fh`_lh^gZ`^u lu [m^_rv \b ^_ lv b lu magZ_rv
lh]^Zbf_xl \_sbagZq_gb_ bebg_l>ey f_gygbq_]h g_bf__l
agZq_gbyghfh`_l [ulv^ey l_[y\k_ [m^_l_]h bf_lv
D gZklhys_fm\j_f_gb lu^he`_g m`_agZlvqlh q_eh\_d
agZgby `b\_l ^_ckl\byfbZ g_^mfZgv_f h^_ckl\byo b g_
^mfZgv_f hlhfqlh hg[m^_l ^_eZlvihke_ lh]hdZd \uihegbl
^_ckl\b_Q_eh\_d agZgby\u[bjZ_l ljhimk k_j^p_fb ke_^m_l
ih g_cB ihlhfhg kf hl jb l
b \_k_eblkyb kf__lky
b ihlhfhg \b ^b l
b agZ_lHg agZ_lqlh _]h `bagv
[m^_l aZdhgq_gZ\ dhg_qghfkq_l_hq_gv [ukljhHg agZ_l
qlh hglZd`_dZd dlh[u lhgb [ueh_s_g_ b^_lgbdm^ZHg
agZ_lihlhfm qlh
\b ^b lqlh gbq_]h g_l [he__
\Z`gh]hq_f qlheb[h _s_
>jm]bfb keh\Zfbq_eh\_d agZgbyg_ bf__lgb q_klbgb
\_ebqbygb k_fvbgb bf_gbgb kljZguZ lhevdh `bagv
qlh[u __ijh`blvB ijblZdbo h[klhyl_evkl\Zo_^bgkl\_ggh_
qlh k\yau\Z_l _]h k ex^vfbwlh _]h dhgljhebjm_fZy
]emihklvBlZdbf h[jZahfq_eh\_d agZgby ij_^ijbgbfZ_l
mkbeby bihl__lb hl^m\Z_lkyb _keb\a]eygmlv gZg_]hlh
hg lhqgh lZdhc `_dZd
b ex[hc h[uqguc q_eh\_daZ
bkdexq_gb_f lh]hqlh ]emihklv_]h `bagb gZoh^blky ih^
dhgljhe_f
Ijb lhfqlh gbq_]hg_ y\ey_lky [he__ \Z`gufq_f
qlheb[h _s_q_eh\_d agZgby\u[bjZ_l ihklmihdb kh\_jrZ_l
_]h lZddZd _keb[u ihke_^gbcbf_e ^eyg_]h agZq_gb_?]h
dhgljhebjm_fZy ]emihklvaZklZ\ey_l _]h]h\hjblv ^_eZ_l _]h
kdZau\Zxsbf \Fqlh lhqlh hg^_eZ_lbf__l agZq_gb_
b ^_eZ_l _]h ^_ckl\mxsbflZddZd _keb[ lZdh_ agZq_gb_
^_ckl\bl_evgh [uehb \lh `_\j_fy hgagZ_lqlh wlh g_
lZdihwlhfmdh]^Z hg\uihegbl k\hcihklmihdhg hloh^bl\
klhjhgm \ fbj_b lh[ueb eb_]h ihklmidb ohjhrbfb beb
iehobfbijbg_keb hgbj_amevlZlu bebg_lgb \dh_c f_j_g_
y\ey_lky _]haZ[hlhcK ^jm]hcklhjhguq_eh\_d agZgbyfh`_l
ba[jZlv lhqlh hg[m^_l kh\_jr_gghiZkkb\_g bgbdh]^Z g_
[m^_l ^_ckl\h\Zlvb [m^_l\_klb k_[ylZddZd [m^lh [ulv
iZkkb\guf^_ckl\bl_evghbf__l ^eyg_]h agZq_gb_B hg
[m^_l kh\_jr_ggh bkdj_g_g b\ wlhflZd`_ihkdhevdm wlh
lZd`_ [m^_l_]h dhgljhebjm_fhc]emihklvx
Y \h\e_d k_[y\ wlhff_kl_ \hq_gv imlZggu_ ihiuldb
h[tykgblv ^hg OmZgmqlh ybgl_j_kmxkv l_fqlh `_ [m^_l
fhlb\bjh\Zlv q_eh\_dZagZgby ihklmiZlvdZdbflh hij_^_e_gguf
h[jZahfg_kfhljy gZlhqlh hgagZ_lqlh gbq_]hg_ bf__l
agZq_gbyHg fy]dhaZkf_yeky ij_`^_q_f hl\_lblv
Lu ^mfZ_rvh k\hboihklmidZoihwlhfm lu\_jbrv \lh
qlh l\hbihklmidb gZklhevdh\Z`gugZkdhevdh lu^mfZ_rv hgb
\Z`guLh]^Z dZd\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbgbq_]h balh]h g_\Z`gh
qlh dlheb[h ^_eZ_lG bq _] hGh lh]^Z_keb \
^_ckl\bl_evghklb gbq_]h g_ bf__l agZq_gbylh dZdlu
kijZrb\Z_rv f_gyy ijh^he`Zx`blv";ueh [Zijhs_ mf_j_lv
bf_ggh lZd lu]h\hjbrv b\_jbrvihlhfm qlhlu ^mfZ_rv h
`bagb lhqghlZd`_dZd lu^mfZ_rv h[h\k_f hklZevghfdZd lu
l_i_jv ^mfZ_rvgZ qlh`_ ihoh`_
\b ^_ gv _Lu
ohl_eqlh[u yl_[_ _]hhibkZe ^eylh]hqlh[ lufh] gZqZlv
^mfZlv h[ wlhf lhqgh lZd`_dZd lu ^mfZ_rv h[h \k_f
hklZevghf< kemqZ_ \b ^_ gv yh^gZdh^mfZgv_ g_
y\ey_lky khklZ\ghc qZklvxihwlhfm yg_ fh]m jZkkdZaZlv
l_[_qlh wlhlZdh_ \ b^ _l vL_i_jv lu ohq_rv
qlh[ yhibkZe l_[_ijbqbgu fh_cdhgljhebjm_fhc ]emihklbb y
fh]m l_[_lhevdh kdZaZlvqlh dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklv hq_gv
ihoh`Z gZ \b ^_ gv _Wlh g_qlhlZdh_h q_f g_evay
^mfZlvhg a_\gmeLu kebrdhf^he]h hlkmlkl\h\ZeLu
^mfZ_rv kebrdhffgh]h
Hg ih^gyeky b ijhr_e\ aZjhkebqZiiZjZey m ^hfZY
ih^^_j`b\Ze h]hgvqlh[u ]hjrhddbi_eY kh[jZeky [ueh
aZ`_qv d_jhkbgh\mx eZfimgh ihemlvfZ[ueZ hq_gv mxlghc
H]hgv ba i_qb ^Z\Ze^hklZlhqgh k\_lZqlh[u fh`gh [ueh
ibkZlvb kha^Z\Zejhah\h_ kbygb_ih\kx^m \hdjm] f_gyY
iheh`be k\hb aZibkb gZ a_fexb e_]Y qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
mklZeufBa \k_]h jZa]h\hjZk ^hghf OmZghf _^bgkl\_ggZy
ykgZy fukev hklZeZkvm f_gy\ fha]mqlh _fm^h f_gy g_l
gbdZdh]h ^_eZwlh [_kdhg_qgh[_kihdhbeh f_gyAZ ^he]b_
]h^u y ^h\_jbeky_fm?keb [uy g_bf_e ihegh]h^h\_jby d
g_fmlh y[ue [uiZjZebah\Zg kljZohfm`_ ijbh^ghc lhevdh
fukebqlh[u bamqZlv_]h mq_gb_gZ ijZdlbd_LhgZ q_f y
hkgh\u\Ze k\h_^h\_jb_ dg_fm[ueZ b^_yqlh hg aZ[hlblky
h[h fg_ebqghnZdlbq_kdby \k_]^Z[hyeky _]hgh y\k_]^Z
m^_j`b\Ze k\hckljZo \ma^_ihlhfm qlhy \_jbe_fmDh]^Z
hg m[jZewlm hkgh\mlh mf_gy g_hklZehkv gbq_]hgZ qlh[u
fh`gh [ueh hibjZlvky
^Zevr_b
y ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
[_kihfhsguf
Hq_gv kljZggh_g_l_ji_gb_ ho\Zlbehf_gyY klZe hq_gv
\ha[m`^_gguf b gZqZerZ]Zlv \aZ^\i_j_^ i_j_^i_qdhc>hg
OmZg aZ^_j`b\ZekyY kg_l_ji_gb_f `^Ze_]h
Hg \_jgmekyg_fgh]h iha^g__k_e hiylvi_j_^ i_qdhcb
y \ueh`be _fmk\hb kljZobY kdZaZe_fmqlh y haZ[hq_g
ihlhfm qlh g_ fh]mf_gylv gZijZ\e_gb_ihkj_^b ihlhdZY
h[tykgbe _fmqlh ihfbfh^h\_jbydhlhjh_ ybf_e dg_fmy
gZmqbeky lZd`_ m\Z`Zlv _]hh[jZa `bagbdZd kms_kl\_ggh
[he__ jZpbhgZevgucbebih djZcg_cf_j_[he__ ^_ckl\_gguc
q_f fhcY kdZaZeqlh _]hkeh\Z \\_j]ebf_gy \ m`Zkguc
dhgnebdlihlhfm qlhhgb lhedZxlgZ lhqlh[ ykf_gbe k\hb
qm\kl\Z>ey lh]hqlh[u ijhbeexkljbjh\Zlvfhx lhqdmaj_gby
y jZkkdZaZe^hg OmZgmbklhjbx h^gh]hklZjbdZ bafh_]h djm]Z
hq_gv [h]Zlh]h dhgk_j\Zlb\gh]hxjbklZdhlhjuc ijh`be \kx
k\hx `bagv[m^mqb m[_`^_gqlh ih^^_j`b\Z_lijZ\^m
< gZqZe_o ]h^h\hg hdZaZekykljZklgh \h\e_q_gguf\
iheblbq_kdmx ^jZfm lh]h \j_f_gbHg [ue dZl_]hjbq_kdb
m[_`^_gqlh iheblbq_kdh_ baf_g_gb_[m^_l ]b[_evguf ^ey
kljZgub baij_^Zgghklb k\h_fmh[jZam `bagbhg ]hehkh\Zeb
[hjheky ijhlb\lh]hqlh jZkkfZljb\ZedZd iheblbq_kdh_aeh
Gh ijbeb\ \j_f_gb[ue kebrdhfkbe_ghg hkbebe_]hK\ur_
lb e_lhg [hjhekyijhlb\ wlh]hgZ Zj_g_b \k\h_c ebqghc
`bagbaZl_f \lhjZyfbjh\Zy \hcgZh[jZlbeZ \k__]h mkbeby\
ihegh_ ihjZ`_gb_=em[hdZy ]hj_qvy\beZkv ke_^kl\b_f _]h
iheblbq_kdh]h bb^_heh]bq_kdh]h iZ^_gbygZ e_l hg klZe
kZfhba]gZggbdhfDh]^Z y\klj_lbe _]hlh _fm[ueh m`_ ]h^Zb hg\_jgmeky \k\hc jh^ghc]hjh^qlh[u ijh\_klbk\hb
ihke_^gb_ ]h^u \^hf_ ^eyij_klZj_euo>ey f_gy dZaZehkv
g_ihgylgufqlh hglZd fgh]h`bemqblu\Zy lhdZd hglhibe
k\hx `bagv \ ]hj_qb b`Zehklb d kZfhfm k_[_DZdbflh
h[jZahf hggZr_e fh_h[s_kl\h ijbylgufb fuih^he]m k gbf
jZa]h\Zjb\Zeb< ihke_^gbcjZadh]^Z y_]h \klj_lbehg
aZdexqbe gZrjZa]h\hj ke_^mxsbfm f_gy[ueh \j_fyqlh[u
h[_jgmlvky bijh\_jblv k\hx`bagv<hafh`ghqlh y\u[jhkbe
]h^u `bagb
gZ
ij_ke_^h\Zgb_
lh]hqlh
gbdh]^Z g_
kms_kl\h\Zeh< ihke_^g__\j_fy mf_gy [uehqm\kl\hqlh y
\_jbe \dZdhclh nZjkWlh g_klhbeh fhbomkbebcY kqblZx
qlh y agZx wlhH^gZdhy g_fh]m \_jgmlv ihl_jygguo
e_l
Y kdZaZe ^hgmOmZgmqlh fhcdhgnebdl \hagbd ba l_o
khfg_gbc\ dhlhju_f_gy [jhkbeb_]h keh\Zh dhgljhebjm_fhc
]emihklb
?keb gbq_]h\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbg_ bf__lagZq_gby
kdZaZe ylh klZ\q_eh\_dhf agZgbyg_\hevgh hdZ`_rvky
lZdbf
hg
`_imklufdZd fhc^jm]b g_\ emqr_fiheh`_gbbq_f
Wlh g_lZdkdZaZe ^hgOmZg hlju\bklhl\hc ^jm]
h^bghdihlhfm qlhmfj_l [_a \b ^_ gv y< _]h`bagb
hg ijhklhkhklZjbeky bl_i_jv mg_]h ^he`gh[ulv _s_[hevr_
`Zehklb dkZfhfm k_[_q_f dh]^Zeb[h jZg__Hg qm\kl\m_l
qlh \u[jhkbe e_lihlhfm qlh]gZeky aZ ih[_^ZfbZ
gZoh^be ihjZ`_gbyHg
gbdh]^Z
g_
magZ_lqlh [ulv
ih[_^bl_e_f beb [ulvih[_`^_gguf h^gh blh `_AgZqbl
l_i_jv lu [hbrvky f_gylZd dZdy kdZaZe l_[_qlh lu
jZ\ghagZq_g \k_fm hklZevghfmLu \iZ^Z_rv\ ^_lkl\hGZrZ
km^v[ZdZd ex^_cmqblvkyb b^lbd agZgbxke_^m_l lZd`_
dZd b^lbgZ \hcgmY ]h\hjbel_[_ wlh[_kkq_lgh_ qbkehjZa
D agZgbx beb gZ \hcgmb^ml khkljZohfk m\Z`_gb_fk
khagZgb_f lh]hqlh b^ml
gZ
\hcgmB k Z[khexlghc
m\_j_gghklvx \k_[_<eh`b k\hx\_jm ^h\_jb_\ k_[yZ g_
\ f_gy
B ihwlhfm lu l_i_jvbkim]Zg imklhlhc `bagb l\h_]h
^jm]ZGh g_limklhlu \`bagb q_eh\_dZagZgby y ]h\hjx
l_[_<k_ gZiheg_gh^h djZ_\
<k_ gZiheg_gh^h djZ_\b \k_jZ\ghg_ dZd^ey l\h_]h
^jm]Zdhlhjuc ijhklhkhklZjbekyDh]^Z y]h\hjx l_[_qlh
gbq_]h g_bf__l agZq_gbyy bf_x\ \b^mg_ lhqlh bf__lhg
>ey g_]h _]h[bl\Z `bagbg_ klhbeZmkbebcihlhfm qlh hg
ih[_`^_g>ey f_gyg_ kms_kl\m_lgb ih[_^ugb ihjZ`_gbygb
imklhlu<k_ gZiheg_gh^h djZ_\b \k_jZ\ghb fhy [bl\Z
klhbeZ fhbomkbebc>ey lh]hqlh[u klZlvq_eh\_dhf agZgby
gZ^h [ulv\hbghfZ g_ogudZxsbf j_[_gdhfGm`gh [blvkyb g_
k^Z\Zlvky ^h l_oihjihdZ g_klZg_rv \b ^_ lv
ebrv
^ey lh]hqlh[u ihgylvlh]^Zqlh gbq_]hg_ bf__lagZq_gby
>hg OmZgihf_rZe \]hjrd_ ^_j_\ygghceh`dhc?^Z [ueZ
]hlh\ZHg kgye]hjrhd kh]gy bihklZ\be _]hgZ q_luj_om
]hevgh_ dbjibqgh_khhjm`_gb_dhlhjh_ hg\ha\ukbe mkl_gu b
dhlhjh_ kem`behdZd ihedZbeb dZdklheGh]hc hgih^lhedgme
^\Z g_[hevrboysbdZkem`b\rbo m^h[gufbklmevyfbhkh[_ggh
_keb ijbkehgblvkyd kl_g_kibghcHg agZdhfijb]eZkbe f_gy
kZ^blvky b aZl_fgZebe fbkdmkmimHg meu[Zeky?]h ]eZaZ
kbyebdZd _keb [u _fm
\
kZfhf ^_e_ gjZ\behkv fh_
ijbkmlkl\b_
Hg fy]dh ih^h^\bgme fbkdmdh fg_< _]h `_kl_ [ueh
klhevdh l_ieZ b^h[jhluqlh wlhdZaZehkv[ueh ijhkv[hc
\hkklZgh\blv dg_fm fh_^h\_jb_Y qm\kl\h\Zek_[y b^bhlkdb
Y ihiulZekykf_gblv k\h_gZkljh_gb_jZaukdb\Zy k\hxeh`dm
b g_fh] __gZclbKmi [uekebrdhf ]hjyqbfqlh[u iblv _]h
ijyfh ba fbkdbb ihdZhg hklu\Zey kijhkbe ^hgZ OmZgZ
hagZqZ_l eb_]h dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklvqlh q_eh\_dmagZgby
gbdlh [hevr_ g_ fh`_l gjZ\blvkyHg i_j_klZe _klv b
aZkf_yeky
Lu kebrdhfaZ[hlbrvky hlhfqlh[u gjZ\blvky ex^yf
beb qlh[u ex[blvbo kZfhfmkdZaZe hgq_eh\_d agZgby
ex[bl b \k_Hg ex[blqlh ohq_lbeb dh]h ohq_lgh hg
bkihevam_l k\hxdhgljhebjm_fmx ]emihklv^ey lh]hqlh[u g_
aZ[hlblvky h[wlhfIjhlb\hiheh`ghklv lhfmqlh lu ^_eZ_rv
l_i_jvEx[blv ex^_cbeb [ulvex[bfuf ex^vfbwlh ^Ze_dhg_
\k_qlh fh`gh^_eZlvdZd q_eh\_d
Hg g_dhlhjh_\j_fy kfhlj_egZ f_gykdehgb\ ]heh\m gZ
[hd
>mfZc gZ^wlbfkdZaZe hg
?klv _s_h^gZ \_svh dhlhjhcy ohqmkijhkblv l_[y
^hg OmZgLu ]h\hjbeqlh[u kf_ylvkygZ^h kf hl j_ lv
]eZaZfbgh ykqblZxqlh fukf__fky ihlhfmqlh fu^mfZ_f
<havfb ke_ih]hq_eh\_dZ hg lh`_kf__lky
G_lke_iu_ g_kf_xlkybo l_eZkhljykZxlky g_fgh]hk
lj_kdhf kf_oZHgb gbdh]^Zg_ kfhlj_ebgZ kf_rgu_]jZgb fbjZ
b ^he`gu\hh[jZ`Zlv bok_[_Bo kf_owlh g_ohohl
;hevr_ fug_ ]h\hjbebM f_gy[ueh ohjhr__kZfhqm\kl\b_
b hsms_gb_kqZklvyFu _eb\ fheqZgbbaZl_f ^hgOmZg gZqZe
kf_ylvkyY bkihevah\Zekmohc ijmlbdqlh[u ih^ghkblvh\hsb
dh jlm
hdly[jy ]
K_]h^gy y \u[jZe \j_fy b kijhkbe ^hgZ OmZgZg_
\hajZ`Z_l eb hg ih]h\hjblv_s_ h
\b ^_ gv bHg
dZaZehkvk_dmg^m jZafureyeaZl_f meu[gmekyb kdZaZeqlh y
hiylv \lygmeky \k\hx jmlbgm]h\hjblv \f_klhlh]hqlh[u
^_eZlv
?keb luohq_rv \b ^_ lv l_[_ ke_^m_l ^Zlv
^ufdm mg_klb l_[ykdZaZe hgk m^Zj_gb_fy [hevr_ g_
ohqm ]h\hjblvh[ wlhf
Y ihfh]Ze_fm qbklblvkmob_ jZkl_gby>he]h_ ij_fy fu
jZ[hlZeb \iheghf fheqZgbbDh]^Z y\ugm`^_g ^he]hfheqZlv
y \k_]^Z qm\kl\mx k_[yhq_gv \hkijbbfqb\ufhkh[_ggh \
ijbkmlkl\bb ^hgZOmZgZGZdhg_py g_\u^_j`Ze baZ^Ze _fm
\hijhkdhlhjucdZaZehkvkZf \uj\Zekyba f_gy
DZd q_eh\_dagZgby ijbf_gy_ldhgljhebjm_fmx ]emihklv
_keb kemqblvkyqlh mfj_lq_eh\_ddhlhjh]h hg ex[bl"
kijhkbe y
>hg OmZg ihkfhlj_e gZ
f_gy
\hijhkbl_evgh hg
dZaZehkvhi_rbe ijbfh_f \hijhk_
<havf_f l\h_]h\gmdZ ExkbhkdZaZe y;m^ml eb
l\hb ^_ckl\bydhgljhebjm_fhc ]emihklvx\h \j_fy_]h kf_jlb"
<havf_f fh_]h kugZ wmeZebhwlh [he__ ohjhrbc
ijbf_jkihdhcgh hl\_lbe^hg OmZghg [ue jZa^Z\e_g
dZfgyfbdh]^Z jZ[hlZe gZ kljhbl_evkl\_ iZgZf_jbdZgkdhc
^hjh]bFhb ihklmidbih hlghr_gbxd g_fm\h \j_fy_]h kf_jlb
[ueb dhgljhebjm_fhc ]emihklvxDh]^Z y ijb[ue d f_klm
\aju\Zhg [ue ihqlbf_jl\gh _]h l_eh [ueh gZklhevdh
kbevgufqlh hgh ijh^he`Zeh
^\b]Zlvky b ^_j]ZlvkyY
hklZgh\beky i_j_^gbf bkdZaZe iZjgyfba ^hjh`ghcdhfZg^u g_
ljh]Zlv _]h[hevr_ hgb ihkemrZebkvb klhyebhdjm`b\ fh_]h
kugZ]ey^y gZ_]h bamjh^h\Zggh_l_ehY lh`_klhye lZfgh
y g_kfhlj_eY baf_gbek\hb ]eZaZlZdqlh[u y\b^_edZd
jZkiZ^Z_lky _]hebqgZy `bagvg_dhgljhebjm_fh jZkrbjyykvaZ
k\hb ij_^_euih^h[gh lmfZgmdjbklZeeh\ihlhfm qlh bf_ggh
lZd `bagv b kf_jlvkf_rb\Zxlky bjZkrbjyxlky<hl qlh y
^_eZe \h \j_fykf_jlb fh_]hkugZWlh \k_qlh fh`gh [ueh
^_eZlvb wlhdhgljhebjm_fZy ]emihklv?keb [uy kfhlj_egZ
g_]hlh y gZ[ex^Ze
[u
aZ
l_fdZd hg klZgh\blky
g_ih^\b`gufb yihqm\kl\h\Ze [uieZq \gmljbk_[yihlhfm
qlh gbdh]^Z[hevr_ fg_g_ ijb^_lkykfhlj_lv gZ_]h djZkb\mx
nb]mjmb^msmx iha_fe_<f_klh wlh]hy
\b ^_ e
_]h
kf_jlvb lZfg_ [uehi_qZeb bg_ [uehgbdZdh]h qm\kl\Z?]h
kf_jlv [ueZjZ\ghagZqgZ \k_fmhklZevghfm
>hg OmZgk_dmg^m fheqZeDZaZehkvhg [uei_qZe_ggh
aZl_f hgmeu[gmeky bih]eZ^be f_gyih ]heh\_
LZd qlhfh`_rv kdZaZlvqlhdh]^Z ijhbkoh^blkf_jlv
ex^_cdhlhjuo yex[exlh fhy g_dhgljhebjm_fZy ]emihklv
khklhbl \lhfqlh[u baf_gblvk\hb ]eZaZ
Y ih^mfZe h ex^yodhlhjuo ykZf ex[exb m`ZkgZy
^Z\ysZy \hegZ`Zehklb dkZfhfm k_[_ho\ZlbeZ f_gy
KqZkleb\uc lu^hg OmZgkdZaZe ylu fh`_rv
baf_gblv k\hb]eZaZlh]^Z dZdy fh]mlhevdh kfhlj_lv
Hg gZr_efh_ \ukdZau\Zgb_aZ[Z\guf baZkf_yeky
KqZkleb\ucHk_ekdZaZe hgwlh ljm^gZyjZ[hlZ
Fu hiylvjZkkf_yebkvIhke_ ^he]h]hfheqZgby yhiylv klZe
iulZlv _]hfh`_l [ulvebrv ^eylh]hqlh[ jZa\_ylv k\hx
kh[kl\_ggmx i_qZev
?keb y l_[yihgye lh]^ZijZ\bevgh^hg OmZglh
_^bgkl\_ggu_ ihklmidb \`bagb q_eh\_dZagZgbydhlhju_ g_
y\eyxlky dhgljhebjm_fhc ]emihklvxwlh
l_qlh hg
\uihegy_l khk\hbf heebbeb f_kdZeblhG_ lZdeb"
<_jghfhb heebb f_kdZeblhg_ gZh^ghc ^hkd_k gZfb
ex^vfbFhy dhgljhebjm_fZy]emihklv ijbeh`bfZlhevdh dhfg_
kZfhfm b d ihklmidZfdhlhju_ y \uihegyxgZoh^ykv \
h[s_kl\_ ex^_c
H^gZdheh]bq_kdb\hafh`gh ^mfZlvqlh q_eh\_d
agZgby fh`_l lZd`_ jZkkfZljb\Zlvk\hb ihklmidb kh k\hbf
heeb bebk f_kdZeblhdZd dhgljhebjm_fmx]emihklv\_jgh"
Lu kgh\Z ^mfZ_rvQ_eh\_d agZgby g_ jZafurey_l
ihwlhfm hg g_ fh`_l \klj_lblvky k lZdhc \hafh`ghklvx
<havfbgZijbf_jf_gyY ]h\hjxqlh fhy dhgljhebjm_fZy
]emihklv ijbeh`bfZd ihklmidZfdhlhju_ ykh\_jrZxgZoh^ykv
\ h[s_kl\_ex^_cY ]h\hjx wlhihlhfm qlh y fh]m \b
^ _l v
ex^_cH^gZdhy
g_
fh]m
\b ^_ lv
g Zk d\ ha v
k\h_]hheebb wlh^_eZ_l _]hg_\hkijbgb
fZ_fuf ^eyf_gyIhwlhfmdZd `_y fh]mdhgljhebjh\Zlv k\hx
]emihklv_keb y g_\b`m kd\havg__Kh k\hbf heeb beb
f_kdZeblh y \k_]h
ebrv
q_eh\_ddhlhjuc agZ_ldZd
\ b^ _l vb gZoh^blqlh hgh]emr_g l_fqlh hg
\ b^ bl q_eh\_ddhlhjuc agZ_lqlh hg gbdh]^Z g_
ihcf_l \k_]hqlh _klv\hdjm] g_]h
<havfbgZijbf_jl_[y>ey f_gyg_ bf__l agZq_gby
klZg_rv lu q_eh\_dhf agZgbybeb g_lH^gZdhwlh bf__l
dZdh_lh agZq_gb_ ^eyf_kdZeblhKh\_jr_ggh hq_\b^ghqlh
^ey g_]hwlh bf__lagZq_gb_bgZq_ [uhg g_k^_eZe lZdfgh]h
rZ]h\qlh[u ihdZaZlvk\hx aZ[hlmh l_[_Y fh]m aZf_lblv
_]h aZ[hlmb y^_ckl\mx khhl\_lkl\_gghwlhfmb l_f g_
f_g___]h aZ[hlZg_ihgylgZ ^eyf_gy
=eZ\Z
r_ kl Zy
DZd jZa dh]^Zfu m`_kh[bjZebkv k_klv\ fhx fZrbgm
qlh[ gZqZlv iml_r_kl\b_\ p_gljZevgmxF_dkbdmhdly[jy
]^hg OmZghklZgh\be f_gy
Y ]h\hjbe l_[_ jZgvr_kdZaZe hg k k_jv_aguf
\ujZ`_gb_fqlh gbdh]^Zg_evay jZkdju\Zlvgb bf_gbgb
f_klhgZoh`^_gby fZ]ZY iheZ]Zxlu ihgbfZ_rvqlh lu g_
^he`_g hldju\Zlvgb fh_]hbf_gbgb f_klZ]^_ gZoh^blkyfh_
l_ehK_cqZk ykh[bjZxkv ihijhkblvl_[y k^_eZlvlh `_kZfh_
ih hlghr_gbxd fh_fm^jm]mdhlhjh]h lu[m^_rv a\ZlvO_gZjh
Fu _^_fd _]h^hfmLZf fuijh\_^_f g_dhlhjh_\j_fy
Y aZ\_jbe ^hgZOmZgZqlh ygbdh]^Z g_h[fZgu\Ze _]h
^h\_jby
Y agZxwlhkdZaZe hgg_ f_gyyk\h_]h \ujZ`_gby
B \k_ `_ f_gy aZ[hlbl
lhqlh lu klZgh\brvky lZdbf
jZkk_ygguf
Y aZijhl_klh\Zeb ^hgOmZg kdZaZeqlh _]hp_evx [ueh
lhevdh gZihfgblv fg_qlh dZ`^ucjZadh]^Z klZgh\brvky
jZkk_ygguf \ ^_eZo fZ]bblh b]jZ_rv k [_kqm\kl\_gghc
kf_jlvxdhlhjmx fh`gh hl\jZlblv[m^mqb \gbfZl_evguf b
hkhagZ\Zy k\hbihklmidb
Fu [hevr_g_ [m^_fdZkZlvky wlh]h\hijhkZDZd lhevdh
fu hlt_^_fhlkx^Zfu g_[m^_f mihfbgZlvh O_gZjhb g_[m^_f
^mfZlv hg_fY ohqmqlh[u k_cqZklu ijb\_e\ ihjy^hdk\hb
fukebDh]^Z fu \klj_lbf_]hlu ^he`_g[ulv ykguf b g_
bf_lv khfg_gbc\ mf_
H dZdh]hjh^Z khfg_gbyolu ]h\hjbrv^hg OmZg"
Ex[h]h jh^Zkhfg_gbyo \hh[s_Dh]^Z lu\klj_lbrv _]h
lu ^he`_g [ulvojmklZevgh qbklufHg [m^_l
\b ^_ lv
l_[y
?]h kljZggu_
ij_^mij_`^_gby
k^_eZeb
f_gy
hq_gv
\ha[m^bfufY aZf_lbeqlh fh`_l[ulvfg_ emqr_\hh[s_ g_
\klj_qZlvky k _]h^jm]hfgh ebrvih^t_oZlv d_]h ^hfm b
hklZ\blv ^hgZOmZgZ lZf
Lhqlh ykdZaZe l_[_[ueh \k_]hebrv ij_^hkl_j_`_
gb_fkdZaZe hglu m`_\klj_lbe h^gh]hfZ]Z<bk_glZb
hg qmlvg_ m[bel_[y;_j_]bkv gZwlhl jZa
Ihke_ lh]hdZd fuijb_oZeb \p_gljZevgmx F_dkbdmm
gZk mreh_s_ ^\Z^gyqlh[ ijhclbi_rdhf hllh]h f_klZ]^_
y hklZ\bek\hx fZrbgm^h ^hfZ_]h ^jm]ZfZe_gvdhc ob`bgu
ijbe_ib\r_cky dkdehgm ]hju>jm] ^hgZOmZgZ klhyem ^\_j_c
dZd [u h`b^Zy gZkY lml`_ magZe_]hY m`_ [ue k gbf
agZdhfohly bhq_gv ih\_joghklghdh]^Z yijb\_a k\hxdgb]m
^hgm OmZgm< lhljZa ynZdlbq_kdbb g_kfhlj_e gZ g_]h
djhf_ dZdf_evdhfihwlhfm mf_gy [uehhsms_gb_qlh hglh]h
`_ \hajZklZqlh b^hg OmZgH^gZdhdh]^Z hgklhye m^\_j_c
k\h_]h ^hfZy aZf_lbeqlh hg[ue agZqbl_evghfheh`_?fm
\_jhylghlhevdh i_j_\ZebehaZ iylv^_kylHg [uegb`_ ^hgZ
OmZgZ blhgvr_ _]hHg [uehq_gv l_f_gb `bebkl?]h \hehku
[ueb ]mklufbb k_^h\Zlufbb g_kdhevdh^ebggufbhgb gZ\bkZeb
m g_]h gZ^mrZfb be[hf?]h ebph[ueh djm]eufb l\_j^uf
Hq_gv \uklmiZxsbc ghk ijb^Z\Ze _fm\b^ obsghc ilbpu k
fZe_gvdbfb l_fgufb]eZaZfb
Hg kgZqZeZ aZ]h\hjbe
k
^hghf
OmZghf>hg OmZg
ih^l\_j`^Zxs_ db\gmeHgb djZldhih]h\hjbebHgb ]h\hjbebg_
ihbkiZgkdbihwlhfm yg_ ihgbfZeh q_fb^_l j_qvAZl_f
^hg O_gZjhih\_jgmeky dhfg_
>h[jh ih`Zeh\Zlv\ fhxfZe_gvdmx jZa\Zexomob`bgm
ba\bgyxsbfky lhghfkdZaZe hgihbkiZgkdb
?]h keh\Z [ueb \_`eb\hcnhjfmehcdhlhjmx y keurZe
jZg__ \ jZaguok_evkdbo jZchgZoF_dkbdbH^gZdhdh]^Z hg
kdZaZe wlbkeh\Zhg jZkkf_yekyjZ^hklgh[_a \kydbod lhfm
ijbqbgb y agZeqlh hg ijbf_gy_l k\hx dhgljhebjm_fmx
]emihklv?fm ^_eZg_ [uehgb \fZe_cr_c kl_i_gbqlh _]h
^hf [uejZa\Zexohcob`bghcFg_ hq_gvihgjZ\beky ^hgO_gZjh
< l_q_gb_^\mo ke_^mxsbo^g_c fuoh^beb \]hju kh[bjZlv
jZkl_gby>hg OmZg^hg O_gZjhb yhlijZ\eyebkv dZ`^uc^_gv
gZ jZkk\_l_KlZjbdb moh^beb\f_kl_ \dZdhclh ki_pbZevguc
gh g_hij_^_e_gguc jZchg]hj bhklZ\eyeb f_gyh^gh]h \ahg_
e_kh\M f_gylZf [uehhkh[h_ khklhygb_ klZjZl_evghklb b
\gbfZgbyY g_aZf_qZe oh^Z\j_f_gby g_hsmsZe gbdZdh]h
g_m^h[kl\Z hl lh]hqlh y h^bgG_h[uqZcgh_ khklhygb_
dhlhjh_ ^ebehkv m
f_gy
h[Z
^gy[ueh kihkh[ghklvx
dhgp_gljbjh\Zlvky gZlhgdhc aZ^Zq_gZoh`^_gby hij_^_e_gguo
jZkl_gbcdhlhju_ ^hg
OmZg
^h\_jbe
fg_ kh[jZlvFu
\ha\jZsZebkv ^hfhc d\_q_jmb h[Z^gy ylZd mklZ\Zeqlh
g_f_^e_ggh aZkuiZe
H^gZdhlj_lbc ^_gv[ue ^jm]bfFu \k_ljh_ jZ[hlZeb
\f_kl_b ^hgOmZg ihijhkbe^hgZ O_gZjhgZmqblv f_gydZd
kh[bjZlv hij_^_e_ggu_jZkl_gbyFu \_jgmebkvhdheh ihem^gyb
h[Z klZjbdZ g_kdhevdh qZkh\kb^_eb hdheh ^hfZ \ iheghf
fheqZgbbdZd _keb [hgb [ueb\ ljZgk_H^gZdhhgb g_
kiZebY iZjmjZa ijhr_ei_j_^ gbfb^hg OmZgijh\h^be f_gy
]eZaZfbb lZd`_ k^_eZe^hg O_gZjh
L_[_ gm`gh]h\hjblv hjZkl_gbyo ij_`^_q_f lu bo
khj\_rvkdZaZe ^hgOmZgHg jhgyek\hb keh\ZjZaf_j_ggh b
ih\lhjbe k\h_ \ukdZau\Zgb_ljb jZaZdZd [u^ey lh]hqlh[
ijb\e_qv fh_ \gbfZgb_Gbdlh gZkdZaZe gbkeh\ZihdZ hg
]h\hjbe
>ey lh]hqlh[u \b ^_ lv
jZkl_gbylu ^he`_g
]h\hjblv k gbfbi_jkhgZevghijh^he`Ze hglu ^he`_g
agZlv bo bg^b\b^mZevghlh]^Z jZkl_gby kfh]ml jZkkdZaZlv
l_[_ hgbo \k_qlh luaZohq_rv hgbo magZlv
<j_fy dehgbehkv d\_q_jm>hg OmZgkb^_e gZ iehkdhf
dZfg_ ebphfd aZiZ^guf]hjZf^hg O_gZjhkb^_e jy^hfk gbf
gZ khehf_gghcpbgh\d_ebphf gZk_\_j>hg OmZgkdZaZe fg_\
i_j\uc ^_gvdh]^Z fuijb_oZeb lm^Zqlh wlhbo ihabpbb
b qlhy ^he`_gkZ^blvky gZa_fex \ex[hf f_kl_gZijhlb\ gbo
Hg kdZaZeqlh dh]^Zfu kb^bf\ lZdboihabpbyoy ^he`_g
[ulv ih\_jgmlebphf dx]h\hklhdm bkfhlj_lv gZgbo lhevdh
f_evdhf
>ZlZd h[klhbl^_eh kjZkl_gbyfbg_ lZd eb"
kdZaZe ^hg OmZgih\_jgm\rbkv
d ^hgm O_gZjhdhlhjuc
kh]eZkbeky ih^l\_j`^Zxsbf`_klhf
Y kdZaZeqlh ijbqbghcfh_]h g_\uiheg_gby wlhc _]h
bgkljmdpbb [uehlhqlh yqm\kl\h\Ze k_[yg_kdhevdh ]emih
jZa]h\Zjb\Zy kjZkl_gbyfb
L_[_ g_m^Zehkv ihgylvqlh fZ]g_ rmlblkdZaZe hg
`_kldhlh]^Z fZ]^h[b\Z_lky lh]hqlh[u
\b ^_ lv hg ^h[b\Z_lkylh]hqlh[u ihemqblvkbem
>hg O_gZjhmklZ\beky gZf_gyY ^_eZeaZf_ldbb wlh
dZaZehkvihjZ`Zeh _]hHg meu[gmekyfg_ihljyk ]heh\hc b
qlhlh kdZaZe ^hgmOmZgm>hg OmZgih`Ze ie_qZfb<b^_lv
f_gy ibrmsbf^hgm O_gZjhdZaZehkv \_kvfZkljZgguf>hg OmZg
y iheZ]Zxm`_ ijb\udd lhfmqlh y\k_ aZibku\Zxb lhl
nZdlqlh yibrmdh]^Z hg]h\hjbl[hevr_ g_m^b\eye _]h
Hg fh] ijh^he`Zlv ]h\hjblvdZaZehkvg_ aZf_qZyq_f y
aZgylH^gZdh^hg O_gZjhijh^he`Ze kf_ylvkyb fg_ijbrehkv
ij_djZlblv aZibku\Zlv^ey lh]hqlh[u g_ij_ju\Zlv gZkljhy
jZa]h\hjZ
>hg OmZg _s_ jZaih^l\_j^beqlh ihklmidb fZ]Z g_
ke_^m_l ijbgbfZlvaZ rmldbihlhfm qlhfZ] b]jZ_lkh kf_jlvx
gZ dZ`^hf ih\hjhl_imlbAZl_f hggZqZe jZkkdZau\Zlv ^hgm
O_gZjhdZd h^gZ`^u ghqvx yihkfhlj_e gZ h]gb kf_jlb
ke_^h\Z\r_c aZ gZfb\h \j_fyh^gh]h bagZrbo iml_r_kl\bc
JZkkdZa hdZaZekyhq_gv kf_rguf>hg O_gZjhdZlZeky hlkf_oZ
ih a_fe_
>hg OmZgba\bgbeky i_j_^hfghc bkdZaZeqlh _]h ^jm]
ih^\_j`_g ijbklmiZf kf_oZY \a]eygme gZ ^hgZ O_gZjh
dhlhjucdZd y^mfZe_s_ dZlZekyih a_fe_b m\b^_eqlh hg
^_eZ_l kh\_jr_ggh g_h[uqgmx\_svHg klhyegZ ]heh\_ [_a
ihfhsb jmdZ _]hgh]b [uebkeh`_gu lZddZd _keb [u hg
kb^_eAj_ebs_ ^h lh]hg_ rehgb \dZdb_ \hjhlZqlh y
\kdhqbeDh]^Z y ihgyeqlh hg ^_eZ_l g_qlh kh\_jr_ggh
g_\hafh`gh_ klhqdb aj_gbyf_oZgbdb l_eZhg \_jgmekyhiylv
\ ghjfZevgh_iheh`_gb_H^gZdh ^hgOmZg [ue\b^bfhagZdhf
k l_fqlh ijhbahrehb ijb\_lkl\h\Ze ij_^klZ\e_gb_ ^hgZ
O_gZjh jZkdZlbklufkf_ohf
>hg O_gZjhdZaZehkvaZf_lbe fh_aZf_rZl_evkl\hHg
iZjm jZaoehigme \eZ^hrb bdjmlgmeky iha_fe_hq_\b^ghhg
ohl_eqlh[ yke_^be aZgbfLhqlh kgZqZeZy ijbgye aZ
dZlZgb_ ih a_fe_[uehnZdlbq_kdbjZkdZqb\Zgb_f l_eZ \
kb^yq_f iheh`_gbb lZdqlh ]heh\Z dZkZeZkv a_febHg
\b^bfh^hklb]Ze k\h_cg_eh]bqghc ihaugZ[bjZy djmlysbc
fhf_gljZkdZqb\Zykv g_kdhevdhjZaihdZ bg_jpbyg_ \u\_^_l
_]h l_eh\ \_jlbdZevgh_iheh`_gb_lZd qlhgZ dZdh_lh \j_fy
hg kZ^bekygZ k\hx]heh\m
Dh]^Z bokf_o mlbo^hg OmZgijh^he`Ze k\hc jZa]h\hj
_]h lhg [ue `_kldbfY i_j_f_gbe iheh`_gb_ l_eZqlh[
m^h[g__ [ueh kb^_lvb qlh[m^_eblv _fm\k_ \gbfZgb_Hg
kh\k_f g_meu[ZekydZd ^_eZeh[uqgh lh]^Zdh]^Z yklZjZeky
m^_eylv khagZl_evgh_ \gbfZgb_ lhfmqlh hg ]h\hjbl>hg
O_gZjh ijh^he`Zekfhlj_lv gZf_gydZd _keb[u h`b^Zeqlh
hiylv gZqgm aZibku\Zlvgh y[hevr_ g_ [jZeky aZ k\hb
aZf_ldbKeh\Z ^hgZ OmZgZ[ueb jZaghkhfaZ lhqlh y g_
jZa]h\Zjb\Ze kjZkl_gbyfbkh[bjZy bodZd hg\k_]^Z \_e_e
fg_ ^_eZlvHg kdZaZefg_qlh jZkl_gbydhlhju_ y m[be
fh]ml lZd`_ m[blvb f_gyhg kdZaZeqlh m\_j_gjZgh beb
iha^ghhgb ijbg_kmlfg_ [he_agvHg ^h[Z\beqlh _keb y
aZ[he_x \ j_amevlZl_\j_^Zijbqbg_ggh]h jZkl_gbyflh y
l_f g_ f_g__g_ ijbagZxwlh]h b ij_^ihqlm kqblZlv wlh
]jbiihfH[Z hgbhiylv ijh\_ebfhf_gl \_k_evyaZl_f ^hg
OmZg \gh\v klZek_jv_a_g bkdZaZeqlh _keby g_ ^mfZx h
k\h_c kf_jlblh \kyfhy ebqgZy`bagv [m^_llhevdh ebqguf
oZhkhfHg \a]eygmehq_gv j_adh
Qlh _s_fh`_l [ulvm q_eh\_dZdjhf_ _]h`bagb b_]h
kf_jlb"kdZaZe hgfg_
< wlhlfhf_gl yihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh kh\_jr_gghg_h[oh^bfh
\k_ wlh aZibkZlv b\gh[v \ayekyaZ [ehdghl>hg O_gZjh
mklZ\beky gZ f_gy bmeu[gmekyAZl_f hg kdehgbe ]heh\m
g_fgh]h gZ[hd b
jZkdjue
gha^jbHghq_\b^ghbf_e
aZf_qZl_evguc dhgljhevgZ^ furpZfbmijZ\eyxsbfb gha^jyfb
ihlhfm qlhhgb jZkdjuebkv\ ^\ZjZaZ ijhlb\k\h_]h h[uqgh]h
jZaf_jZ
Qlh [uehgZb[he__ dhfbqguf\ _]hdehmgZ^_lZd wlh g_
klhevdh _]h`_kludZd _]hkh[kl\_ggZy j_ZdpbygZ gboIhke_
lh]hdZd hgjZkrbjbe k\hbgha^jbhg kdehgbeky \i_j_^ b
\gh\v ijb\_e k\h_l_eh \lm `_kljZggmx i_j_\_jgmlmx iham
kb^_gby gZ]heh\_
>hg OmZg kf_yekyihdZ ke_aug_ ihl_deb m g_]h ih
s_dZfY qm\kl\h\Zek_[y g_kdhevdhjZa^jZ`_gguf b kf_yeky
g_j\gh
O_gZjh g_ex[bl ibkZlvkdZaZe hgdZd h[tykg_gb_
Y hleh`bek\hb aZf_ldbgh ^hgO_gZjh kdZaZeqlh \k_\
ihjy^d_ kibkZgb_fihlhfm qlhhg gZkZfhf ^_e_g_ \hajZ`Z_l
ijhlb\ wlh]hHg ih\lhjbel_ `_kZfu_ j_[yqeb\u_^\b`_gbyb
h[Z hgbhiylv j_Z]bjh\ZeblZd `_
>hg OmZg \a]eygmegZ f_gy\k_ _s_kf_ykvb kdZaZe
qlh _]h ^jm] bah[jZ`Z_lf_gyQlh m f_gy _klv ijb\uqdZ
jZa^m\Zlv gha^jbdZd lhevdhy gZqbgZxibkZlvb qlh ^hg
O_gZjh ^mfZ_lqlh iulZlvkyklZlv fZ]hfaZibku\Zy ihmq_gby
lZd`_ Z[kmj^ghdZd kb^_lvgZ ]heh\_ihwlhfm hgb ijbgbfZ_l
lZdmx Z[kmj^gmxihami_j_ghky \_kk\h_]h kb^ys_]hl_eZ gZ
h^gm ]heh\m
Fh`_l [ulvlu g_gZoh^brv wlhaZ[Z\gufkdZaZe ^hg
OmZggh lhevdhh^bg O_gZjhfh`_l kb^_lvgZ ]heh\_b
lhevdh h^bg lu fh`_rv^mfZlv hlhfqlh[u klZlv fZ]hf
aZibku\Zy ihmq_gby
H[Z hgbhiylv bf_eb\aju\ kf_oZb ^hgO_gZjh ih\lhjbe
k\h_ g_\_jhylgh_^\b`_gb_
Fg_ gjZ\bekyhg< _]hihklmidZo [uehlZd fgh]h]jZpbb
b ijyfhlu
Ijbghrm k\hb ba\bg_gby^hg O_gZjhkdZaZe y
mdZau\Zy gZ[ehdghl
<k_ \ihjy^d_kdZaZe hgb hiylvofudgme
Y [hevr_ g_ fh]ibkZlvHgb hq_gv ^he]h ijh^he`Zeb
]h\hjblv hlhfdZd jZkl_gby^_ckl\bl_evgh fh]mlm[blv bdZd
fZ]b bkihevamxl wlhdZq_kl\h jZkl_gbcH[Z hgb ijh^he`Zeb
kfhlj_lv gZf_gydh]^Z ]h\hjbebdZd [uh`b^Zyqlh y[m^m
ibkZlv
DZjehkdZd ehrZ^vdhlhjZy g_ex[bl [ulvhk_^eZgghc
KdZaZe ^hgOmZgK gbfgZ^h [ulvhq_gv ^_ebdZlgufLu
bkim]Ze _]hb l_i_jvhg g_ohq_l ibkZlv
>hg O_gZjhjZkrbjbe k\hbgha^jb bkdZaZe kgZkf_reb\hc
ijhkv[hc]jbfZkgbqZy b\uly]b\Zy ]m[udmjbghc ihidhc
Ijh^he`ZyDZjemrZibrbIbrbihdZ m l_[y g_
hl\Zeblky [hevrhciZe_p
>hg OmZg ih^gyeky\uly]b\Zy jmdbb \u]b[Zy kibgm
G_kfhljy gZ ij_dehgguc \hajZkl_]h l_eh[ueh kbevguf b
]b[dbfHg ihr_e\ dmkluk djZx^hfZb yhklZeky gZ_^bg_k
^hghf O_gZjhHg ihkfhlj_egZ f_gyb yhl\_e ]eZaZihlhfm
qlh hgaZklZ\eye f_gyqm\kl\h\Zlv k_[ykdh\Zgguf
G_ ]h\hjbqlh lu^Z`_ g_ohq_rv kfhlj_lvgZ f_gy
kdZaZe hgk djZcg_j_[yqeb\hc bglhgZpb_c
Hg jZa^me gha^jb b aZklZ\bebo ^jh`ZlvAZl_f hg
ih^gyeky b ih\lhjbe^\b`_gby ^hgZOmZgZ\u]b[Zy kibgm b
\uly]b\Zy jmdbgh ijb wlhf
_]h l_eh ijbgyeh djZcg_
g_\_jhylgh_ iheh`_gb_wlh [ueZ^_ckl\bl_evgh g_hibkm_fZy
ihaZdhlhjZy kh\f_sZeZ \
k_[_ bkdexqbl_evgh_ qm\kl\h
iZglhfbfu bqm\kl\h aZ]Z^hqghklbHgZ [jhkbeZf_gy \^jh`v
Wlh [ueZfZkl_jkdZy dZjbdZlmjZgZ ^hgZOmZgZ
< wlhl fhf_gl ^hgOmZg \_jgmekyb aZf_lbe `_klZ
lZd`_\b^bfhb _]hagZq_gb_Hg k_eihkf_b\Zykv
Dm^Z ^m_l\_l_j"agZqbl_evgh kijhkbe^hg O_gZjh
>hg OmZgmdZaZe ^\b`_gb_f]heh\u gZaZiZ^
Y emqr_ihc^m lm^Zdm^Z \_l_j^m_lkdZaZe ^hg
O_gZjh kk_jv_aguf \ujZ`_gb_fAZl_f hgih\_jgmeky dhfg_ b
ihdZqZe fg_iZevp_f
B g_h[jZsZc \gbfZgby_keb mkeurbrvkljZgguc a\md
kdZaZe hgdh]^Z O_gZjhkj_l ]hju ljykmlky
Hg iju]gme\ dmklub f]gh\_gb_kimkly ymkeurZe hq_gv
kljZgguc a\md]em[hdbc g_a_fghc]jhohlY g_agZedZd _]h
h[tykgblvY \a]eygmegZ ^hgZOmZgZbsZ h[tykg_gbygh hg
kh]gmeky \^\h_hl ohohlZ
hdly[jy ]
Y g_ihfgxqlh ih[m^beh^hgZ O_gZjhjZkkdZaZlv fg_h[
mkljhckl\_ lh]h k\_lZdZd hg_]h gZau\ZeHg kdZaZeqlh
fZkl_jfZ] [u\Z_l hjehf
bebkdhj__qlh
hg fh`_l
ij_\jZsZlvky \ hjeZk ^jm]hcklhjhguaehc fZ] [u\Z_l
kh\hc>hg O_gZjhkdZaZeqlh aehcfZ] wlh ^blyghqbb
^ey lZdh]h q_eh\_dZkZfu_ ihe_agu_`b\hlgu_ wlh imfZ b
^jm]b_ ^bdb_ dhrdbbeb ghqgu_ilbpuhkh[_ggh kh\uHg
kdZaZeqlh [jmohk ebjbdhkebjbq_kdb_ fZ]bbf_y \ \b^m
fZ]h\^be_lZglh\ij_^ihqblZxl ^jm]bo
`b\hlguo\hjhgm
gZijbf_j>hg OmZgaZkf_yekyhg kemrZefheqZ>hg O_gZjh
ih\_jgmeky dg_fm bkdZaZe
Wlh ijZ\^Zlu `_agZ_rv wlhOmZgAZl_f hgkdZaZe
qlh fZkl_jfZ] fh`_l \aylv k\h_]h
mq_gbdZ k kh[hc \
iml_r_kl\b_ bnZdlbq_kdbijhclb q_j_akeh_\ lh]hk\_lZ
FZkl_jbf_y \ \b^mqlh hghj_efh`_l gZqZlv k kZfh]h
i_j\h]h gb`g_]h kehy b
aZl_f
ijhoh^blv q_j_a dZ`^uc
ihke_^mxsbc fbjihdZ g_^hklb]g_l \_jrbguAeu_ fZ]b b
^be_lZglu fh]ml\ emqr_fkemqZ_kdZaZe hgijhoh^blv
lhevdh q_j_aljb kehy
>hg O_gZjh dhkgmekylh]hqlh ij_^klZ\eyxlkh[hc wlb
klmi_gbkdZaZ\
GZqbgZ_rv kkZfh]h ^gZb aZl_fl\hc mqbl_ev [_j_l
l_[y kkh[hc \ihe_lb \kdhj_[mfLu ijhoh^brvkd\hav
i_j\uc kehcAZl_fg_fgh]h ih]h^y[mfLu ijhoh^brv
kd\hav \lhjhcb [mfLu ijhoh^brvkd\hav lj_lbc
>hg O_gZjh ijh\_ef_gy q_j_a[mfh\ ^h ihke_^g_]h
kehy fbjZDh]^Z hghdhgqbe ]h\hjblv^hg OmZgihkfhlj_e gZ
f_gy bihgbfZxs_ meu[gmeky
JZa]h\hj g_ ij_^jZkiheh`_gghklvO_gZjhkdZaZe
hggh _keblu ohq_rvihemqblv mjhdlh hgihmqbl l_[y h
jZ\gh\_kbb \_s_c
>hg O_gZjh ih^l\_j`^Zxs_ db\gmeHg keh`be ]m[u b
ihemijbdjue ]eZaZFg_ _]h`_kl ihdZaZeky qm^_kguf>hg
O_gZjh ih^gyekyb lZd`_k^_eZe ^hgOmZg
EZ^ghkdZaZe ^hgO_gZjhFu fh`_f ih_oZlv b
ih^h`^Zlv G_klhjZb IZ[eblhHgb m`_k\h[h^guIh q_l\_j]Zf
hgb jZghhk\h[h`^Zxlky
H[Z hgbk_eb dhfg_ \fZrbgm^hg OmZgk_e ki_j_^bY
gb h q_fg_ kijZrb\ZeboZ ijhklhaZ\_e fhlhj>hg OmZg
gZijZ\eye f_gyd f_klmdhlhjh_ih _]hkeh\Zf[ueh ^hfhf
G_klhjZ>hg O_gZjh\hr_e \^hf bg_fgh]h ih]h^y \ur_e \
khijh\h`^_gbb G_klhjZb IZ[eblh^\mo fheh^uoex^_cdhlhju_
[ueb _]hmq_gbdZfb
<k_ hgbk_eb dhfg_ \fZrbgmb ^hgOmZg kdZaZeqlh[u
y _oZeih ^hjh]_\_^ms_c daZiZ^guf ]hjZf
Fu hklZ\bebfhx fZrbgmgZ djZx]jmglh\hc ^hjh]bb ihreb
i_rdhf \^hev[_j_]Z j_dbrbjbgZ dhlhjhc[ueZ\_jhylgh
f_ljh\^h \h^hiZ^Z\b^bfh]h m`_k lh]h f_klZ]^_ y
hklZgh\be fZrbgm
;ueh hdhehq_luj_o qZkh\^gyHdjm`Zxsbc \b^[ue \_kvfZ
\gmrbl_evgufIjyfh m gZkgZ^ ]heh\Zfb \bk_eZ h]jhfgZy
q_jgZy kkbg_\hc lmqZdhlhjZy dZaZeZkviZjys_c djur_chgZ
bf_eZ ohjhrh\ujZ`_gguc djZcb nhjfm]jhfZ^gh]h ihemdjm]ZD
aZiZ^m gZkdehgZo \ukhdbop_gljZevguo dhj^bev_j\b^bfhr_e
^h`^vHg \u]ey^_e[_eh\Zlhc aZgZ\_kdhcih\_r_gghc i_j_^
kbgbfb ibdZfbGZ \hklhd_
gZoh^beZkv ]em[hdZy ^ebggZy
^hebgZgZ^ dhlhjhc\bk_eb lhevdhhl^_evgu_ h[eZqdZb kbyeh
khegp_DhgljZkl f_`^m^\mfy wlbfbjZchgZfb [ue\_ebdhe_i_g
Fu hklZgh\bebkv m ih^gh`by \h^hiZ^Z?]h \ukhlZ [ueZ
ih`Zemchdheh f_ljh\j_\ klhyehq_gv ]jhfdbc
>hg O_gZjhgZ^_e \hdjm]lZebb ihykk g_]hk\bkZeh k_fv
ij_^f_lh\dhlhju_ \u]ey^_ebdZd fZe_gvdb_dm\rbgqbdbHg
kgye reyimb ^Ze_c \bk_lvaZ kibghcgZ rgmjd_aZ\yaZgghf
\hdjm] r_bHg ^hklZe]heh\gmx e_glmdhlhjZy [ueZm g_]h\
dhr_evd_k^_eZgghf balheklhc r_jklyghcfZl_jbb=heh\gZy
e_glZ lZd`_ [ueZ ba]hlh\e_gZ ba jZaghp\_lguo r_jklyguo
gblh\Yjdh`_eluc m\_lhkh[_ggh \u^_eyeky\ g_c< ]heh\gmx
e_glm hg \hldgmeljb hjebguoi_jZY aZf_lbeqlh lhqdb
dm^Z hg \hldgmei_jvy[ueb g_kbff_ljbqguH^gh i_jh [ueh
gZ^ aZ^gbfba]b[hf _]hijZ\h]h moZ^jm]h_ [uehgZ g_kdhevdh
^xcfh\ \i_j_^bAZl_f hg
kgye kZg^Zebbijbp_ibe beb
ijb\yaZe bo dihykm rlZgh\b aZkl_]gmeihyk ih\_jo k\h_]h
ihgqhIhykdZaZehkv[ue kie_l_gba ihehkhddh`bY g_
kfh] m\b^_lvaZ\yaZe hg_]h bebaZkl_]gme gZijy`dm>hg
O_gZjh ihr_eih gZijZ\e_gbxd \h^hiZ^m
>hg OmZg mklZgh\be
djm]euc
dZf_gv
\ mklhcqb\h_
iheh`_gb_ bk_e gZg_]hH[Z fheh^uoq_eh\_dZ k^_eZeblh `_
kZfh_ k ^jm]bfb dZfgyfbb k_ebke_\Z hl g_]h>hg OmZg
mdZaZe fg_gZ f_klhjy^hf kkh[hc kijZ\hc klhjhgub kdZaZe
qlh[u yijbg_k dZf_gvb k_e
Fu ^he`gu a^_kv h[jZah\ZlvebgbxkdZaZe hg
ihdZaZ\qlh hgbljh_ k_eb\ h^bgjy^
D wlhfm\j_f_gb ^hgO_gZjh ^hklb]kZfh]h ^gZ\h^hiZ^Z b
gZqZe \a[bjZlvky ih kdZe_ke_\Z hlg_]hHllm^Z]^_ fu
kb^_ebkdZeZ dZaZeZkv \_kvfZhl\_kghcLZf [ueh fgh]h
dmklh\aZ dhlhju_hg o\ZlZekyijb^_j`b\ZykvH^bg jZahg
\b^bfhihl_jye hihjmb qmlvg_ khkdhevagme\gbadZd _keb[
ihq\Z [ueZ kdhevadhcG_fgh]h ih]h^y ih\lhjbehkv lh `_
kZfh_b fg_ijbreZ \]heh\m fukevqlh ^hgO_gZjhih`Zemc
kebrdhf klZjqlh[ eZablv ihkdZeZfY \b^_edZd hg
g_kdhevdh jZaihkdZevau\Zeky bhklmiZeky ij_`^_q_f ^hklb]
lhqdb]^_ jZks_ebgZih dhlhjhchg \a[bjZekydhgqbeZkv
Y bkiulZe qm\kl\h
jZkl_jygghklbdh]^Z hg gZqZe
dZjZ[dZlvky \ur_ih kdZe_Y g_fh] k_[_h[tykgblvqlh hg
kh[bjZ_lky ^_eZlv
Qlh hg^_eZ_l"kijhkbe y^hgZ OmZgZr_ihlhf>hg
OmZg g_\a]eygme gZf_gy
Hq_\b^ghqlh hg\a[bjZ_lkykdZaZe hg
>hg OmZgkfhlj_e ijyfhgZ ^hgZO_gZjh?]h \a]ey^ [ue
hklZgh\b\rbfky?]h ]eZaZ[ueb ihemijbdjuluHg kb^_ehq_gv
ijyfh kjmdZfbkeh`_ggufb f_`^mgh]Y g_fgh]hgZdehgbeky
qlh[u ihkfhlj_lv gZ fheh^uoex^_c^hg OmZg k^_eZe fg_
ih\_ebl_evguc agZd jmdhcqlh[u aZklZ\blv f_gy \_jgmlvky
gZaZ^ \ ebgbxY lhlqZkhldZqgmekyY ebrv f_evdhf \b^_e
fheh^uo ex^_cHgb dZaZebkvlZdbfb `_\gbfZl_evgufbdZd b
hg>hg OmZg k^_eZe _s_ h^bg`_kl jmdhc b ihdZaZe \
gZijZ\e_gbb \h^hiZ^ZY \a]eygme\gh\v>hg O_gZjh\ah[jZeky
m`_ ^h\hevgh ^Ze_dh gZ kdZem< lhl fhf_gldh]^Z y
\a]eygmehg ijbe_ibeky dg_[hevrhfm \uklmimihg_fgh]m
ijhdeZ^u\Zy imlvqlh[u h[h]gmlvdZf_gguc dhauj_d?]h jmdb
[ueb \ulygmlu \klhjhgudZd _keb[u hgh[gbfZe kdZemHg
f_^e_ggh ijh^\b]Zeky \ijZ\hb \g_aZighihl_jye hihjm ih^
gh]ZfbY g_\hevghZogmeGZ f]gh\_gb_\k_ _]hl_eh ih\bkeh
\ \ha^mo_Y [uem\_j_gqlh hgiZ^Z_lgh hgg_ miZe?]h
ijZ\Zy jmdZko\ZlbeZkv aZqlhlh bhq_gv ihkl_i_ggh_]h gh]b
\_jgmebkv gZ\uklmi \gh\vGh ij_`^_q_f ^\bgmlvky^Zevr_
hg ih\_jgmeky d gZf b\a]eygmeWlh [ue lhevdh \a]ey^
f_evdhfgh \ih\hjhl_ _]h]heh\u [ueZlZdZy klbebaZpbyqlh
y gZqZeqm\kl\h\Zlv m^b\e_gb_Y \kihfgbelmlqlh hg^_eZe
lh `_ kZfh_ih\hjZqb\Zeky bkfhlj_e gZgZkdZ`^uc jZa
dh]^Z hgihkdZevau\ZekyM f_gy[ueZ fukevqlh ^hgZO_gZjh
jZa^jZ`Z_l _]hkh[kl\_ggZy g_mdex`_klvb hg ih\hjZqb\Z_lky
ihkfhlj_lv\b^bf ebfu __
Hg _s_ g_fgh]h ijh^\bgmekyd \_jrbg__s_ h^bg jZa
ihl_jye hihjmih^ gh]Zfbb ko\ZlbekyaZ gZ\bkZ\rmxkdZemGZ
wlhl jZa hg m^_j`Zekye_\hc jmdhcDh]^Z hg \hkklZgh\be
jZ\gh\_kb_hg hiylvih\_jgmeky bihkfhlj_e gZgZkHg _s_
^\Z`^u ihkdZevau\Zekyij_`^_q_f hg^hklb] \_jrbgu
Hllm^Z]^_ fukb^_eb\_jogbc djZc\h^hiZ^Z dZaZeky
f_ljh\ rbjbghcK_dmg^m ^hgO_gZjh klhyeg_ih^\b`ghY
kh[bjZeky kijhkblv^hgZ OmZgZqlh ^hgO_gZjh kh[bjZ_lkylZf
^_eZlvgh ^hgOmZgdZaZehkv[ue lZdih]ehs_g gZ[ex^_gb_f
qlh yg_ hkf_ebeky[_kihdhblv _]h
<g_aZigh^hg O_gZjh iju]gme\ \h^mWlh [ue lZdhc
kh\_jr_ggh g_h`b^Zgguc ihklmihdqlh
m f_gy aZo\Zlbeh
^uoZgb_Wlh [ue\_ebdhe_iguc g_a_fghciju`hdGZ f]gh\_gb_
fg_ ihdZaZehkvqlh y\b^_e k_jbxgZeZ]Zxsboky ^jm]gZ ^jm]Z
kgbfdh\ _]h l_eZkh\_jrZxsbo
weebilbq_kdbc ihe_l gZ
k_j_^bgm j_db
Dh]^Z fh_ m^b\e_gb_ me_]ehkvy aZf_lbeqlh hg
ijba_febeky gZ dZf_gv gZ kZfhf djZx \h^hiZ^ZdZf_gv
dhlhjuc [ue_^\Z aZf_l_gk lh]hf_klZ]^_ fukb^_eb
Hg hklZ\ZekylZf ^he]h_\j_fyhgdZaZehkv[hjheky k
i_j_dZlu\Zxs_cky q_j_adZf_gv \h^hc>\Z`^u hgih\bkZe gZ^
ijhiZklvxb yg_ fh]ihgylvqlh _]hm^_j`b\Z_l hliZ^_gby
Hg \hkklZgh\bek\h_ jZ\gh\_kb_b i_j_klmibegZ dZfg_k gh]b
gZ gh]mAZl_f hgiju]gme hiylvdZd lb]jY _^\Zfh] \b^_lv
ke_^mxsbc dZf_gvgZ dhlhjuchg himklbekywlh [uedZd [u
fZe_gvdbc hkljuc\uklmi gZ]j_[g_ \h^hiZ^Z
LZf hghklZ\Zeky ihqlbfbgmlHg [ueg_ih^\b`_g?]h
g_ih^\b`ghklv [ueZ^ey f_gyklhev \gmrbl_evghcqlh ygZqZe
^jh`ZlvY ohl_e\klZlv bijhclbkv>hg OmZg aZf_lbe fhx
g_j\haghklv bih\_ebl_evgh \_e_efg_ mkihdhblvky
G_ih^\b`ghklv ^hgZ O_gZjhijb\_eZ f_gy\ g_h[uqZcguc
fbklbq_kdbc m`ZkY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh _kebhg _s_ hklZg_lky
lZf klhylvlh yg_ kfh]mm^_j`b\Zlv dhgljhev gZ^ kh[hc
<g_aZigh hg iju]gme \gh\vGZ wlhljZa ijyfh ^h ^jm]h]h
[_j_]Z \h^hiZ^ZHg himklbekygZ gh]bb jmdbdZd dhrdZ
hklZ\Zeky \ lZdhf iheh`_gbb k_dmg^maZl_f ih^gyeky b
\a]eygme q_j_a \h^hiZ^gZ ^jm]mxklhjhgmZ aZl_f\gba gZ
gZkHg klhye\ dZf_gghcg_ih^\b`ghklb]ey^y gZgZk?]h
jmdb [ueb ijb`Zlud [hdZflZddZd _keb[u hg^_j`Zeky aZ
g_\b^bfu_ ihjmqgb
;ueh qlhlh ihbklbg_g_ihgylgh_ \lhfdZd hg klhye
_]h l_eh dZaZehkvlZdbf lhgdbflZdbf ojmidbfY ih^mfZe
qlh ^hg O_gZjh kh k\h_c ]heh\ghc ih\yadhckh k\hbfb
hjebgufb i_jvyfbk\hbf l_fgufihgqh bk\hbfb [hkufbgh]Zfb
[ue kZfuf
djZkb\uf
q_eh\_q_kdbf
kms_kl\hfdZdh_ y
dh]^Zgb[m^v \b^_e
<g_aZigh hg\u[jhkbe jmdb\\_joih^gye ]heh\mb [ukljh
[jhkbe k\h_l_eh \klhjhgmgZih^h[b_ [hdh\h]hkZevlh \e_\h
<ZemggZ dhlhjhfhg klhye[ue djm]eucb dh]^Zhg iju]gme
hg bkq_aaZ gbf
< wlhl fhf_glklZeb iZ^Zlvdjmigu_ dZieb ^h`^y>hg
OmZg ih^gyekyb \f_kl_k gbfih^gyebkv ^\h_fheh^uo ex^_c
Bo ^\b`_gb_ [ueh klhev
\g_aZigufqlh y aZf_rdZeky
FZkl_jkdbc ljxd ^hgZO_gZjh \\_ef_gy \khklhygb_ ]em[hdh
wfhpbhgZevgh]h \ha[m`^_gbyY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh hg y\ey_lky
\k_ ho\Zlu\Zxsbf Zjlbklhfb yohl_e lml`_ m\b^_lv_]h b
Zieh^bjh\Zlv _fmY klZjZeky\a]eygmlv gZ e_\mx klhjhgm
\h^hiZ^Zqlh[u m\b^_lvg_ kimkdZ_lkyeb hg\gbagh _]hg_
[uehY gZklZb\ZegZ lhfqlh[u magZlvqlh kgbf klZehkv
>hg OmZgg_ hl\_qZe
GZf emqr_ ihki_rblv hlkx^ZkdZaZe hgwlh
gZklhysbc eb\_gvGZf gZ^haZ\_alb IZ[eblhb G_klhjZd gbf
^hfhcZ ihlhffu gZqg_fk\h_ h[jZlgh_iml_r_kl\b_
Y ^Z`_g_ ihijhsZekyk ^hghfO_gZjh\hajZ`Ze y
Hg m`_ihijhsZeky klh[hchl\_lbe ^hgO_gZjh j_adh
Hg k_dmg^m kfhlj_e gZ
f_gyaZl_f kfy]qbe k\h_
\ujZ`_gb_ ebpZb meu[gmeky
Hg ih`_eZel_[_ lZd`_\k_]h ohjhr_]hHg qm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y ij_djZkghk lh[hc
Gh jZa\_fu g_kh[bjZ_fky ^h`^Zlvky_]h"
G_lkdZaZe j_adh^hg OmZgimklv hg hklZ_lky
]^_ [u hggb [ueFh`_lhg hj_ee_lysbc d ^jm]bf fbjZf
bebfh`_l [ulvhg mf_jlZfWlh g_bf__l k_cqZkagZq_gby
hdly[jy ]
>hg OmZg g_\agZqZc aZf_lbeqlh hg kh[bjZ_lky \
g_^Ze_dhf [m^ms_fkh\_jrblv _s_h^gm ih_a^dm\ p_gljZevgmx
F_dkbdm
Lu kh[bjZ_rvkygZ\_klblv ^hgZO_gZjh"kijhkbe y
<hafh`ghkdZaZe hgg_ ]ey^ygZ f_gy
K gbf \k_\ ihjy^d_g_ lZdeb^hg OmZg"Y ohqm
kdZaZlvqlh k gbfgbq_]h g_kemqbehkv iehoh]h lh]^Z gZ
\_jrbg_ \h^hiZ^Z"
Gbq_]h kgbf g_kemqbehkvHg dj_ihd
G_dhlhjh_ \j_fyfu jZa]h\Zjb\Zebh iml_r_kl\bbdhlhjh_
hg ieZgbjh\ZeAZl_f ykdZaZeqlh fg_hq_gv ihgjZ\behkv \
dhfiZgbb k ^hghf O_gZjhb ihgjZ\bebkv _]h rmldbHg
aZkf_yeky bkdZaZeqlh O_gZjh^_ckl\bl_evghdZd j_[_ghd
Lml [ueZ^ebggZy iZmaZY gZijy]Zek\hc fha]iulZykv gZclb
kihkh[dZd i_j_\_klbjZa]h\hj gZ^Zgguc fg_mjhd>hg OmZg
ihkfhlj_e gZf_gy b`Zehkleb\uf lhghfkdZaZe
L_[_ ^hkf_jlb ohq_lkykijhkblv f_gyh[ mjhd_O_gZjh
g_ lZdeb"
Y gZijy`_ggh aZkf_yekyY g_i_j_klZ\Ze ^mfZlv h[h
\k_fqlh ijhbahrehm \h^hiZ^ZY \gh\vb \gh\v i_j_[bjZe
\k_ ^_lZebdZdb_ lhevdh fh] \kihfgblvb ijboh^be d
aZdexq_gbxqlh y [uek\b^_l_e_f ijhy\e_gby g_\_jhylghc
nbabq_kdhc eh\dhklbY ^mfZeqlh ^hgO_gZjh[_a khfg_gby
y\ey_lky
g_ij_\ahc^_gguf
fZkl_jhf
jZ\gh\_kbyDZ`^h_
hl^_evgh_ ^\b`_gb_dhlhjh_
hg
k^_eZe[ueh \ukhdh
jblmZebah\Zggufm` g_]h\hjy hlhfqlh hgh ^he`gh [ulv
bf_eh dZdh_lh g_h[tykgbfh_kbf\hebq_kdh_ agZq_gb_
>ZkdZaZe yIjbagZxqlh fg_^h kf_jlbohq_lky
magZlv\ q_faZdexqZeky _]hmjhd
Iha\hev fg_kdZaZlv l_[_kdZaZe ^hgOmZgqlh
wlh ^eyl_[y [uehljZlhc \j_f_gb?]h mjhd[ue ^eylh]hdlh
\ b^ bl IZ[eblh bG_klhj meh\bebhl[e_kd wlh]hmjhdZ
ohly hgb_s_ \b ^y l
iehohGh luijbr_e lm^Zkfhlj_lv
Y ]h\hjbeO_gZjhqlh luhq_gv kljZggucgZ[bluc ^mjZdb qlh
fh`_l [ulvl_[y fh`ghhimklhrblv _]hmjhdhfgh k lh[hc
wlh]h g_kemqbehkv<ijhq_fwlh g_\Z`gh< b^ _g v_
Hq_gv ljm^gZy \_svY
g_
ohl_eqlh[u lu ihlhf
jZa]h\Zjb\Ze k O_gZjhihwlhfm gZfijbrehkv m_oZlvHq_gv
iehohH^gZdh[ueh [uom`_ hklZlvkyO_gZjh hq_gvjbkdh\Ze
qlh[u ihdZaZlv l_[_qlhlh ^_ckl\bl_evgh qm^_kgh_Hq_gv
iehohqlh lug_ fh`_rv \b ^_ lv Fh`_l [ulv^hg OmZg_keb lujZkkdZ`_rv fg_\ q_f
khklhye mjhdlh ykfh]m h[gZjm`blvqlh y\ ^_ckl\bl_
evghklb\ b^ _e >hg OmZghl kf_oZkh]gmeky \^\h_
L\hy emqrZyq_jlZ aZ^Z\Zlv \hijhkukdZaZe hg
Hg y\ghkh[bjZeky \gh\vhklZ\blv wlml_fmFu kb^_eb
dZd h[uqghgZ iehsZ^d_ i_j_^_]h ^hfhf<g_aZighhg
ih^gyeky b\hr_e \gmljvY ihr_eke_^hfgZklZb\Zy gZ lhf
qlh[ hibkZlv_fm lhqlh y\b^_e
Y \_jghbaeh`be \kxihke_^h\Zl_evghklv kh[ulbclZddZd
bo ihfgbe<k_ \j_fyihdZ yjZkkdZau\Ze^hg OmZgijh^he`Ze
meu[ZlvkyDh]^Z yaZdhgqbehg ihljyk]heh\hc
< b^ _g v_
hq_gvljm^gZy \_svkdZaZe hg
Y ihijhkbe_]h h[tykgblvk\hx njZam
< b^ _g v_
wlh g_l_fZ ^ey jZa]h\hjh\
kdZaZe hg ih\_ebl_evghHq_\b^ghhg g_ kh[bjZeky [hevr_
gbq_]h fg_jZkkdZau\ZlvIhwlhfm yk^Zeky b\ur_e ba ^hfZ
qlh[u \uihegblvdh_dZdb_ _]hihjmq_gby
Dh]^Z y\_jgmekym`_ kl_fg_ehFu i_j_dmkbebZ aZl_f
\ureb gZjZfZ^mG_ mki_ebfu mk_klvkydZd ^hgOmZg gZqZe
]h\hjblv h[mjhd_ ^hgZO_gZjhHg kh\k_fg_ ^Zefg_ \j_f_gb
qlh[ d wlhfmijb]hlh\blvkyFhb aZibkdb[ueb ijb fg_gh
[ueh kebrdhfl_fghqlh[u ibkZlvb yg_ ohl_ek[b\Zlv _]hk
jZa]h\hjZ l_fqlh[ ihclbaZ d_jhkbgh\hceZfihc
Hg kdZaZeqlh ^hgO_gZjh[m^mqb fZkl_jhfjZ\gh\_kby
fh] \uihegylvhq_gv keh`gu_b ljm^gu_^\b`_gbyKb^_gb_ gZ
]heh\_ [uehh^gbf balZdbo ^\b`_gbcb bfhg ohl_eihdZaZlv
fg_qlh g_\hafh`ghmqblvky \b ^_ lv ^_eZy aZibkb
Kb^_gb_ gZ ]heh\_ [_aihfhsb jmd[ueh\ emqr_f kemqZ_
rmlh\kdbf ljxdhfdhlhjuc ^eblkyebrv k_dmg^mIh fg_gbx
^hgZ O_gZjhibkZlv h \b ^_ gv b
wlh lh`_ kZfh_lh
_klv wlhijhklh ljm^gucfZg_\jlZdhc `_kljZgguc blZdhc `_
g_gm`gucdZd kb^_gv_gZ ]heh\_
>hg OmZg mklZ\beky gZ
f_gy
\
l_fghl_ b hq_gv
^jZfZlbq_kdbf lhghfkdZaZeqlh \lh \j_fydZd ^hg O_gZjh
h[oZ`b\Ze f_gykb^y gZ ]heh\_y [ue gZ kZfhc ]jZgb
\ b^ _g vy >hg O_gZjhaZf_lbe wlhb ih\lhjye k\hc
fZg_\j kgh\Z bkgh\Zgh [_alhedmlZd dZdy m`_ ihl_jye
gZc^_ggmx [uehgblv>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh aZl_f^hg O_gZjh
ljhgmluc ebqghckbfiZlb_c dhfg_ij_^ijbgye ihiuldm \gh\v
\_jgmlv f_gy gZ
]jZgv
\b ^_ gv yIhke_ hq_gv
lsZl_evguo jZafure_gbc hg j_rbeihdZaZlv fg_qlh lZdh_
jZ\gh\_kb_i_j_k_dZy \h^hiZ^Hg qm\kl\h\Zeqlh \h^hiZ^
ih^h[_g lhfm ihjh]mi_j_^ dhlhjufy klhxb \_jbeqlh y
lh`_ kfh]m_]h i_j_k_qv
AZl_f ^hg OmZgh[tykgbe ij_^klZ\e_gb_^Zggh_ ^hghf
O_gZjhHg kdZaZeqlh m`_]h\hjbe fg_qlh q_eh\_q_kdb_
kms_kl\Z y\eyxlky ^eyl_odlh \b ^b lk\_lysbfbky
kms_kl\Zfbkhklhysbfb ba q_]hlh \jh^_ \hehdhg k\_lZ
dhlhju_ djmlylkyki_j_^b gZaZ^b ^Zxl\b^bfhklv ycpZ
Hg kdZaZeqlh
]h\hjbe
fg_
lZd`_qlh kZfhc
ihjZabl_evghc q_jlhcycp_ih^h[guo kms_kl\[ue gZ[hj^ebgguo
\hehdhg k\_lZ\uoh^ysbo bajZchgZ imidZ
>hg OmZg kdZaZeqlh wlb\hehdgZ bf_xlhq_gv [hevrh_
agZq_gb_ \ `bagb q_eh\_dZWlb \hehdgZ [ueb k_dj_lhf
jZ\gh\_kby ^hgZO_gZjhb _]hmjhd g_bf_e gbq_]hh[s_]h k
Zdjh[Zlbq_kdbf iju`dhfq_j_a \h^hiZ^?]h ihdZa jZ\gh\_kby
khklhye \ lhfdZd hgbkihevah\Ze wlb smiZevp_ih^h[gu_
gblb
>hg OmZg ij_djZlbe jZa]h\hj gZ
wlm l_fm lZd `_
\g_aZighdZd hg _]h gZqZeb klZe ]h\hjblv h q_flh
kh\_jr_ggh ^jm]hf
hdly[jy ]
Y aZ]gZe^hgZ OmZgZ\ m]heb kdZaZeqlh y bglmblb\gh
qm\kl\mxqlh gbdh]^Z[hevr_ fg_g_ ^Z^mlmjhdZ jZ\gh\_kby
b qlhhg ^he`_gh[tykgblv fg_\k_ kdjulu_^_lZebdhlhju_\
ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_y gbdh]^Zg_ kfh]mhldjulv kZf>hg OmZg
kdZaZeqlh y ijZ\\ lhfqlh ^hgO_gZjh g_ klZg_l fg_
^Z\Zlv ^jm]h]hmjhdZ jZ\gh\_kby
Qlh _s_ohq_rv luagZlv"kijhkbe hg
Qlh wlhaZ smiZevp_h[jZagu_gblb^hg OmZg"
Wlh smiZevpZdhlhju_ \uoh^ylba l_eZ q_eh\_dZ b
dhlhju_ hq_\b^gu ^ey ex[h]h fZ]Zdhlhjuc fh`_l
\b
^ _l vFZ]b ^_ckl\mxl\ hlghr_gbbex^_c kh]eZkghlhfm
dZd hgb
\b ^y l
bosmiZevpZKeZ[u_ ex^bbf_xl hq_gv
dhjhldb_ihqlb g_aZf_lgu_ smiZevpZkbevgu_ ex^b bf_xl
smiZevpZ ^ebggu_b yjdb_M O_gZjhgZijbf_jhgb gZklhevdh
yjdb_qlh dZ`mlkyl\_j^ufbIh wlbfgblyf fh`gh kdZaZlv
a^hjh\ eb q_eh\_d bebhg [he_gaehc hgbeb ^h[jucbeb
ij_^Zl_evIh wlbf gblyffh`gh kdZaZlv lZd`_fh`_l eb
q_eh\_d
\b ^_ lv H^gZdha^_kv
\klZ_l ljm^gZy
ijh[e_fZDh]^Z O_gZjh m\ b^ _e
l_[ylh hg magZe
kh\_jr_ggh lZd`_dZd bfhc ^jm]<bk_glqlh lu fh`_rv
\ b^ _l vdh]^Z y \b `m
l_[ylh y
\b `m qlh lufh`_rv \b ^_ lv b \lh `_\j_fy yagZx kZf
qlh lu wlh]h g_ fh`_rvDZd h[fZgqb\hO_gZjh g_ fh]
ij_h^he_lv wlh]hY ]h\hjbe_fmqlh lukljZgguc ^mjZdY
^mfZxqlh hgohl_e kZfwlh m\b^_lvb ihwlhfm\aye l_[y gZ
\h^hiZ^
Ihq_fm lukqblZ_rvqlh yijhba\h`m \i_qZle_gb_qlh
fh]m \b ^_ lv "
>hg OmZg g_hl\_lbe fg_Hg ^he]hfheqZeY g_ ohl_e
gbq_]h [hevr_m g_]hkijZrb\ZlvGZdhg_phg aZ]h\hjbehg
kdZaZeqlh hg agZ_lihq_fmgh g_ agZ_ldZd wlh
h[tykgblv
Lu kqblZ_rvqlh \k_\ fbj_e_]dh ihgylvdZaZe hg
Ihlhfm qlh \k_qlh lu^_eZ_rv wlh jmlbgZdhlhjmx
ihgylv e_]dhM \h^hiZ^Zdh]^Z lukfhlj_e gZlhdZd O_gZjh
^\b`_lky q_j_a\h^mlu kqblZeqlh hgfZkl_j kZevlhfhjlZe_
ihlhfm qlh kZevlhfhjlZe_ wlh [ueh\k_h q_f lu fh]
^mfZlvB lu \k_]^Z[m^_rv kqblZlvqlh wlh\k_qlh hg
^_eZeH^gZdhO_gZjh kh\k_fg_ iju]Zeq_j_a \h^m?keb [u
hg iju]gmelh hg[u ih]b[O_gZjh mjZ\gh\_rb\Ze k_[y gZ
k\hbo kh\_jr_gguo yjdbo gblyoHg ^_eZe bo ^ebggufb
^ebggufb gklhevdhqlh hgfh]kdZ`_fi_j_dZlblvky ih gbf
q_j_a \h^hiZ^Hg ^_fhgkljbjh\Ze\_jguc kihkh[dZd ^_eZlv
wlb smiZevpZ^ebggufb bdZd bfbk lhqghklvxfZgbimebjh\Zlv
IZ[eblh
\b ^_ e
ihqlb\k_ ^\b`_gbyO_gZjhG_klhjk
^jm]hc klhjhgu\ b^ _e
lhevdhkZfu_ hq_\b^gu_fZg_\ju
Hg mimklbe f_edb_^_lZebGh lulu kh\_jr_ggh gbq_]h g_
\ b^ _e Fh`_l [ulv_keb [ulu^hg OmZgkdZaZe fg_aZjZg__
gZ qlhkfhlj_lv
Hg ij_j\Zef_gy bkdZaZeqlh wlhlhevdh f_rZeh[u ^hgm
O_gZjh_keb [uhg klZe^Z\Zlv fg_bgkljmdpbb?keb [u y
agZeqlh bf_ggh ^he`ghijhbahclblh fhb gblb [ueb [u
\ha[m`^_gu b\aZbfh^_ckl\h\Zeb [uk gblyfb^hgZ O_gZjh
?keb [ulu fh] \b ^_ lv kdZaZe hglh
l_[_ [ueh[u ykghm`_ ki_j\h]h `_rZ]Zk^_eZggh]h O_gZjh
qlh hg g_ ihkdZevau\Zekydh]^Z
\a[bjZeky d \_jrbg_
\h^hiZ^ZHg hkeZ[eyek\hb smiZevpZ>\Z`^u hgho\Zlu\Ze bfb
dZfgb bih\bkZe gZ]hehc kdZe_dZd fmoZDh]^Z hgih^gyeky
gZ \_jrbgmb [ue]hlh\ i_j_k_qv\h^mhg knhdmkbjh\Zebo gZ
g_[hevrhf dZfg_ gZk_j_^bg_ ihlhdZb dh]^Zhgb [ueb lZf
gZ^_`gh aZdj_ie_guhg
iha\hebe
smiZevpZf i_j_[jhkblv
i_j_lZsblv ju\dhf_]h lm^ZO_gZjh \h\k_ g_ iju]Ze b
ihwlhfm fh] ijba_feylvkygZ kdhevadmx ih\_joghklv kh\k_f
fZe_gvdbo dZfg_c gZ kZfhfdjZx \h^hiZ^Z?]h gblb [ueb
ihklhyggh lsZl_evghh[_jgmlu \hdjm]dZ`^h]h dZfgydhlhjuc
hg bkihevah\Ze
Hg g_ klhyehq_gv ^he]hgZ i_j\hfdZfg_ihlhfm qlh
hklZevgu_ _]h gblb [uebaZdj_ie_gu aZ^jm]hc_s_ [he__
fZe_gvdbc dZf_gv\ lhff_kl_]^_ gZihj\h^u [uegZb[hevrbf
?]h smiZevpZi_j_lZsbeb _]h\gh\vb hgijba_febeky gZg_]h
Wlh [ueZ kZfZy
\u^ZxsZyky
\_svdhlhjmx hg k^_eZe
Ih\_joghklv dZfgy [ueZkebrdhf fZe_gvdhc^ey lh]hqlh[u
q_eh\_d fh] gZg_f klhylvb gZihj\h^u k[jhkbe[u _]h \
ijhiZklv_keb [uhg g_hklZ\be qZklvk\hbo gbl_cgZ i_j\hf
dZfg_
< wlhf\lhjhf iheh`_gbbhg klhye^he]h_ \j_fyihlhfm
qlh _fmgm`gh [uehhiylv \ulygmlvk\hb smiZevpZb ihkeZlvbo
gZ ^jm]mx klhjhgm\h^hiZ^ZDh]^Z hgaZdj_ibe bolZf_fm
gm`gh [uehhk\h[h^blv gblbaZdj_ie_ggu_ gZi_j\hf dZfg_
Wlh [uehhq_gv obljhIh`Zemclhevdh h^bgO_gZjh fh]
k^_eZlv wlhHg qmlvg_ ihl_jyek\hx o\Zldmbeb fh`_lhg
ijhklh ^mjZqbe gZkfu wlh]hgbdh]^Z gZ\_jgydZg_ magZ_f
Ebqgh y ^_ckl\bl_evgh^mfZxqlh hgqmlv g_ ihl_jye k\hx
o\ZldmY agZxwlh ihlhfmqlh hggZijy]ky b\u[jhkbe q_j_a
\h^m \_ebdhe_iguc imqhdih^h[guc
emqm ijh`_dlhjZY
qm\kl\mxqlh h^bgebrv wlhlimqhd fh]i_j_lygmlv _]h gZ
^jm]mx klhjhgmDh]^Z hghdZaZeky gZ^jm]hc klhjhg_hg
\klZe b^Ze k\hbfgblyf kbylvdZd fgh`_kl\hh]g_cWlh hg
k^_eZe ki_pbZevgh ^ey l_[y?keb
[u lu [ue kihkh[_g
\ b^ _l vlh wlhlu [u m\ b^ _e O_gZjh klhyelZf]ey^y gZl_[y blh]^Z magZeqlh lu
g_ \b ^_ e
Q Zk lv
A Z^ Zq Z
\l hj Zy
\ b^ _g vy >hgZ OmZgZ g_ [ueh^hfZdh]^Z yijb_oZe d g_fm \
ihe^_gv ghy[jy ]h^ZY g_bf_e ij_^klZ\e_gby]^_ _]h
bkdZlvihwlhfm ykb^_e b`^ZeIh dZdhclh g_ba\_klghcfg_
ijbqbg_ yagZeqlh hgkdhjh \_jg_lkyG_fgh]h ih]h^y^hg
OmZg \hr_e\ ^hfHg db\gmefg_Fu h[f_gyebkvijb\_lkl\by
fbHgdZaZehkvmklZe be_] gZpbgh\dmHg iZjm jZa
a_\gme
B^_y
\b ^_ gv y
klZeZ
^ey
f_gy
dZfg_f
ij_ldgh\_gbyb
y
j_rbe
\hkihevah\Zlvky
hiylv
_]h
]Zeexpbgh]_gghc dmjbl_evghc kf_kvxK^_eZlv lZdh_ j_r_gb_
[ueh m`Zkghljm^ghihwlhfm yohl_e _s_g_fgh]h h[]h\hjblv
wlhl \hijhk
Y ohqmmqblvky \b ^_ lv ^hg OmZgkdZaZe y
Gh y^_ckl\bl_evgh g_ohqm gbq_]hijbgbfZlvY g_ ohqm
dmjblv l\hxkf_kvDZd lu^mfZ_rv_klv ebdZdhcgb[m^v rZgk
^ey f_gygZmqblvky \b ^_ lv
[_awlh]h
Hg k_ek_dmg^m ijbklZevghkfhlj_e gZf_gyZ aZl_fe_]
hiylv
G_lkdZaZe hgl_[_ ijb^_lky \hkihevah\Zlvky
^ufdhf
Gh lu]h\hjbeqlh y[ue gZ]jZgb \b ^_ gv y
m
^hgZ O_gZjh
Y ohl_ekdZaZlvqlh qlhlh \l_[_ k\_lbehkvdZd
[m^lh lu^_ckl\bl_^vgh hkhagZ\Zelhqlh ^_eZ_lO_gZjhgh
lu ijhklh kfhlj_e< l_[_hq_\b^gh_klv qlhlhqlh
gZihfbgZ_l \b ^_ gv _gh g_y\ey_lky bfLu gZ[bl^h
djZ_\b lhevdh^ufhd fh`_lihfhqv l_[_
Gh aZq_fgm`gh dmjblv"Ihq_fm g_evayijhklh gZmqblvky
\ b^ _l v
kZfhfm"M f_gyhq_gv kbevgh_`_eZgb_jZa\_
wlh]h g_^hklZlhqgh"
G_lwlh]h g_^hklZlhqgh< b^ _g v_
g_ lZd
ijhklhb lhevdhdmj_gb_ fh`_l^Zlv l_[_kdhjhklvdhlhjZy
g_h[oh^bfZ ^eylh]hqlh[u meh\blvhl[e_kd lh]h mkdhevaZx
s_]h fbjZBgZq_ lu[m^_rv lhevdh kf hl j_ lv Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m ih^mkdhevaZxsbf fbjhf"
Fbjdh]^Z lu \b ^b rv g_ lZdh\dZdbf lu
ij_^klZ\ey_rv _]h k_[_k_cqZkWlhkdhj__mkdhevaZxsbc
fbjdhlhjuc ^\b`_lky b baf_gy_lkyFh`_l [ulvfh`gh
gZmqblvky kZfhfm \hkijbgbfZlv wlhlmkdhevaZxsbc fbjgh
^h[jZ ba wlh]hg_ \uc^_lihlhfm qlhl_eh jZajmrZ_lky hl
klj_kkZK ^jm]hcklhjhguk dmj_gb_fgbdh]^Z g_ kljZ^Z_rv
hl mlhfe_gbyDmj_gb_ ^Z_lg_h[oh^bfmx kdhjhklv^ey lh]h
qlh[u ihcfZlv mkdhevaZxs__^\b`_gb_ fbjZb \lh `_ \j_fy
hgh khojZgy_ll_eh b_]h kbeug_aZljhgmlufb
OhjhrhkdZaZe y^jZfZlbq_kdbY g_ohqm [hevr_
oh^blv \hdjm]^Z hdhehY [m^mdmjblv
Hg jZkkf_yekygZ^ fhbfijhy\e_gb_f wfhpbc
<u[jhkb wlh ba]heh\ukdZaZe hgLu \k_]^Z
o\ZlZ_rvky g_aZ lhaZ qlhke_^m_lL_i_jv lukqblZ_rvqlh
ijhklh_ j_r_gb_iha\heblv ^ufdm\_klb k_[yfh`_l ^Zlv l_[_
\ b^ _g v_ Gm`gh _s_fgh]h_>ey q_]hm]h^gh \k_]^Z
gm`gh _s_fgh]h_
GZ k_dmg^mhg klZek_jv_aguf
Y [uek lh[hchq_gv hklhjh`_gb fhbihklmidb [ueb
h[^mfZggukdZaZe hgihlhfm qlhf_kdZeblh aZohl_eqlh[
lu magZefh_ agZgb_Gh yagZxqlh mf_gy g_[m^_l \j_f_gb
qlh[u gZmqblv l_[y\k_fmqlh yohqmM f_gy [m^_l \j_fy
lhevdh gZlhqlh[u ihklZ\blvl_[y gZ^hjh]m b\_jblvqlh
lu [m^_rvbkdZlv lZd`_dZd bkdZey kZfY ^he`_gijbagZlv
qlh lu[he__ mijyfb f_g__\hkijbbfqb\q_f y< lh`_ \j_fy
lu bf__rvbgu_ \a]ey^ub lhdZdh_ gZijZ\e_gb_ijbf_l l\hy
`bagv \_svdhlhjmx yg_ fh]mij_^\b^_lv
?]h jZkkm^bl_evguclhg ]hehkZqlhlh \_]h ih\_^_gbb
\ua\Zeh \hfg_ klZjh_qm\kl\hkf_kv kljZoZh^bghq_kl\Z b
h`b^Zgby
Kdhjh fu magZ_f]^_
lu klhbrvkdZaZe hg
aZ]Z^hqgh
;hevr_ hggbq_]h g_kdZaZeG_fgh]h ih]h^yhg \ur_eba
^hfZY \ur_e ke_^hfb klhyei_j_^ gbfg_ agZylh eb
k_klvlh ebjZkiZdh\Zlv k\_jldbdhlhju_ yijb\_a _fm
Wlh [m^_l hiZkgh"kijhkbe y ijhklhqlh[u
qlhgb[m^v kdZaZlv
<k_ hiZkghkdZaZe hg
>hg OmZg\b^bfhg_ [ue jZkiheh`_g ]h\hjblv fg_
qlhgb[m^v _s_Hg kh[jZedZdb_lh fZe_gvdb_maeue_`Z\rb_
\ m]emb keh`bebo \k_ldmY g_ij_^eZ]Ze _fm ihfhsv
ihlhfm qlhagZe_keb hgZ_fm ihgZ^h[blkylh hgihijhkbl h[
wlhfIhlhf hg e_]gZ khehf_ggmxpbgh\dmHg \_e_e fg_
jZkkeZ[blvky bhl^hogmlvY e_]gZ k\hxpbgh\dm bihiulZeky
aZkgmlvgh yg_ [uemklZeufIj_^u^ms_c ghqvxy hklZgh\beky
\ fhl_e_b ijhkiZe^h ihem^gyagZyqlh ^h^hfZ ^hgZOmZgZ
fg_ _oZlv\k_]h ljbqZkZ
Hg lh`_g_ kiZeOhly _]h]eZaZ [uebaZdjuluy aZf_lbe
ihqlb g_meh\bfu_ jblfbq_kdb_ ^\b`_gby
_]h ]heh\uFg_
ih^mfZehkvqlh hgih`Zemcih_l ijhk_[y
Ih_^bf qlhgb[m^v\g_aZigh kdZaZe^hg OmZgb _]h
]hehk aZklZ\bef_gy ih^kdhqblvL_[_ ihgZ^h[blky\ky l\hy
wg_j]byLu ^he`_g[ulv \ohjhr_c nhjf_
Hg ijb]hlh\bekmigh yg_ [ue]heh^_g
GZ ke_^mxsbc ^_gvghy[jy^hg OmZg iha\hebe fg_
kt_klv ebrvdjhrdm ibsbb \_e_ehl^uoZlvY e_`Ze\k_ mljh
gh jZkkeZ[blvkyg_ fh]Y g_bf_e ij_^klZ\e_gbyqlh m^hgZ
OmZgZ gZ mf_gh qlhom`_ \k_]hy g_[ue m\_j_gb \ lhf
qlh gZmf_ mf_gy kZfh]h
Hdheh lj_oqZkh\ ^gyfu kb^_ebih^ _]hjZfZ^hcY [ue
hq_gv ]heh^_gG_kdhevdh jZay ij_^eZ]Zeqlh[u fuih_ebgh
hg hldZau\Zeky
Lu g_]hlh\be kf_kvm`_ ljb]h^Z\g_aZigh kdZaZe
hgl_[_ ijb^_lkydmjblv fhxkf_kvihwlhfm [m^_fkqblZlv
qlh y kh[jZe __ ^eyl_[yL_[_ ihgZ^h[blky __ kh\k_f
g_fgh]hY h^bgjZa gZ[vxljm[dmLu \kx__ \udmjbrvb aZl_f
hl^hog_rvIhlhf ijb^_lojZgbl_ev ^jm]h]hfbjZLu g_[m^_rv
gbq_]h ^_eZlvlhevdh gZ[ex^ZlvaZ gbfGZ[ex^ZcdZd hg
^\b]Z_lkygZ[ex^Zc aZ\k_fqlh hg^_eZ_lL\hy `bagvfh`_l
aZ\bk_lv hllh]hgZkdhevdh ohjhrhlu ke_^brv
>hg OmZglZd \g_aZighij_j\Ze k\hbbgkljmdpbbqlh yg_
agZeqlh kdZaZlv b^Z`_ qlhih^mfZlvDZdh_lh \j_fy y
[hjfhlZe qlhlh g_jZa[hjqb\h_Y g_fh] ijb\_klb\ ihjy^hd
k\hb fukebGZdhg_py kijhkbei_j\h_qlh ijbreh fg_ \
]heh\m
Dlh lZdhcklhjh`"
Lu m\ b^ br v
_]hkdZaZe hgHg hojZgy_l
^jm]hc fbj
DZdhc fbj"Fbj f_jl\uo"
Wlh g_ fbjf_jl\uo bg_ fbjq_]hgb[m^v _s_Wlh
ijhklh ^jm]hc fbjG_l ihevau]h\hjblv l_[_h[ wlhfLu
m\b^brv wlhkZfK wlbf^hg OmZgihr_e \^hfY ihke_^h\Ze
aZ gbf\ _]hdhfgZlm
Ih^h`^bih^h`^b^hg OmZgQlh lu kh[bjZ_rvky
^_eZlv"
Hg g_hl\_qZeHg \ulZsbeba f_rhqdZk\hx ljm[dmb k_e
gZ khehf_ggucfZl \p_glj_ dhfgZlubgd\bablhjkdb ]ey^y gZ
f_gyDZaZehkvhg `^Zefh_]h kh]eZkby
Lu ^mjZdkdZaZe hgfy]dhLu g_ [hbrvkyLu
ijhklh ]h\hjbrvk_[_qlh lu[hbrvky
Hg f_^e_ggh ihdZqZe]heh\hc k[hdm gZ[hdAZl_f hg
^hklZe g_[hevrhc f_rhq_d k dmjbl_evghc kf_kvx b gZ[be
ljm[dm
Y [hxkv^hg OmZgY ^_ckl\bl_evgh[hxkv
G_lwlh g_kljZo
Y hlqZyggh klZjZeky \ub]jZlv\j_fy b gZqZe ^ebggh_
h[km`^_gb_ ijbjh^ufhbo qm\kl\
Y bkdj_gg_kqblZeqlh [hxkvgh hgmdZaZe fg_gZ lh
qlh ^uoZgb_ fh_ g_ ij_ju\bklhb k_j^p_ fh_ [v_lky g_
[uklj__q_f h[uqgh
Y g_fgh]hih^mfZe hlhfqlh hgkdZaZeHg hrb[Zekym
f_gy [ueh fgh]hnbabq_kdbo baf_g_gbch[uqgh k\yaZgguo kh
kljZohfb y[ue \hlqZygvbQm\kl\h gZ^\b]Zxs_]hky jhdZ
hdjZkbeh \k_\hdjm] f_gy@_em^hd fhc[ue g_kihdh_gb y[ue
m\_j_gqlh ih[e_^g_eeZ^hgb fhbkbevgh \kihl_ebbl_f g_
f_g__y ^_ckl\bl_evgh^mfZeqlh y[hxkv
M f_gyg_ [uehlh]h qm\kl\ZkljZoZd dhlhjhfmy ijb\ud
aZ k\hx `bagvKljZodhlhjuc \k_]^Z[ue g_jZaju\gh fhbf
hlkmlkl\h\ZeY jZa]h\Zjb\ZerZ]Zy \aZ^b \i_j_^ih dhfgZl_
i_j_^ ^hghfOmZghfdhlhjuc \k__s_ kb^_egZ k\h_cpbgh\d_
^_j`Z k\hxljm[dm bbgd\bablhjkdb gZf_gy ]ey^y
GZdhg_pjZkkfhlj_\ \k_wlhy ijbr_ed aZdexq_gbxqlh
lhqlh yqm\kl\h\Ze \f_klhh[uqgh]h kljZoZ[ueh ]em[hdh_
qm\kl\h g_m^h\hevkl\byijb h^ghclhevdh fukebh lhfkf_r_gbb
ihgylbcdhlhjh_ kha^Z_lky ijb ijbgylbb ]Zeexpbgh]_gguo
jZkl_gbc
>hg OmZg ijbklZevgh kfhlj_egZ f_gy\ wlhl fhf_gl
aZl_f hg \a]eygmeihaZ^b f_gyijbsmjb\rbkvdZd [m^lh hg
klZjZ_lky h[gZjm`blvqlhlh gZjZkklhygbb
Y ijh^he`Zeoh^blv \aZ^b \i_j_^i_j_^ gbf^h l_oihj
ihdZ hg l\_j^hg_ kdZaZefg_qlh[u yk_e b jZkkeZ[beky
G_kdhevdh fbgmlfu lbohkb^_eb
Lu g_ ohq_rvihl_jylv k\hxykghklv"kdZaZe hg
\g_aZigh
>Z^hg OmZghl\_lbe y
Hg aZkf_yekyk y\gufm^h\hevkl\b_f
Ykghklv\lhjhc \jZ]q_eh\_dZ agZgbygZibkZgZ gZ
l_[_Lu g_[hbrvkykdZaZe hgm[_`^_gghgh l_i_jv lu
g_ ohq_rv ihl_jylv k\hxykghklvb lZddZd lu ^mjZdlu
gZau\Z_rv wlhkljZohf
Hg ^h\hevghaZkf_yeky
Ijbg_kb fg_m]ebijbdZaZe hg
?]h lhg [uefy]dbf bmkihdZb\ZxsbfY Z\lhfZlbq_kdb
\klZe b \ur_e aZ ^hfqlh[u kh[jZlv g_[hevrb_ dmkhqdb
]hjys_]h m]ey hl dhkljZiheh`be bogZ fZe_gvdmx iebldm
dZfgy b\_jgmeky \dhfgZlm
<uoh^b gZdjuevph]jhfdh iha\Ze^hg OmZgkgZjm`b
Hg iheh`bekhehf_ggmx ih^klbedmgZ f_klh]^_ yh[uqgh
kb^_eY iheh`bem]eb jy^hfk gbfb hgih^me gZgboqlh[u
jZa\_klb h]hgvY kh[bjZekyk_klvgh hghklZgh\be f_gy b
\_e_e fg_ k_klvgZ djZcpbgh\dbAZl_f hgiheh`be dmkhq_d
m]ey \ ljm[dm b\jmqbe __fg_Y \aye__Y [ue m^b\e_g
lbohc m[_^bl_evghklvxk dhlhjhc^hg OmZgmijZ\eye fghcY
g_ fh]ijb^mfZlvqlh kdZaZlvM f_gyg_ [uehZj]mf_glh\Y
[ue m[_`^_gqlh g_[hxkvgh lhevdhg_ijhba\hevghihl_jylv
k\hx ykghklv
>mc^mcijbdZaZe hgfg_ kihdhcghlhevdh h^gZ
qZrdZ
Y ihlygmeljm[dm bmkeurZe rmjrZgb_kf_kbaZgbfZ\r_cky
h]g_fY ihqm\kl\h\Zef]gh\_ggh oheh^\h jlmb \ghkmDh]^Z
y k^_eZe ihke_^gxx aZly`dmy
ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh \ky
\gmlj_gghklv fh_]h l_eZ [ueZ
ihdjulZ hkh[uf hsms_gb_f
oheh^gh]h l_ieZ
>hg OmZg \aye m f_gyljm[dm b ihklmqZe qZrdhc ih
eZ^hgbqlh[u \u[blvhklZlhdAZl_fdZd hg^_eZe \k_]^Zhg
kfhqbe k\hciZe_p kexghcb ijhl_jbf \gmljbqZrdb
Fh_ l_eh hg_f_ehgh y fh] ^\b]ZlvkyY baf_gbe
iheh`_gb_qlh[u k_klv[he__ m^h[gh
Qlh ^he`ghkemqblvky"kijhkbe y
Fg_ [uehg_kdhevdh ljm^gh]h\hjblv
>hg OmZg hq_gv [_j_`ghm[jZe k\hxljm[dm \ q_ohe b
aZ\_jgme _]h \^ebgguc dmkhdldZgbAZl_f hg \klZe ijyfh
ijhlb\ f_gyY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
]heh\hdjm`_gb_fhb ]eZaZ
g_ijhba\hevgh aZdjuebkv>hg OmZgwg_j]bqgh \kljyogmef_gy b
ijbdZaZe fg_g_ kiZlvHg kdZaZeqlh yagZx hq_gv ohjhrh
qlh _keby mkgmlh ymfjmWlh \kljyogmehf_gyFg_ ijbreh
\ ]heh\mqlh ^hgOmZg ]h\hjbefg_ wlhfh`_l [ulvqlh[u
khojZgblv f_gyijh[m`^_ggufghk ^jm]hcklhjhgufg_ lZd`_
ijbreh \ ]heh\mqlh hgfh] [ulvijZ\Y dZd fh`gh rbj_
jZkdjue k\hb]eZaZb wlhaZklZ\beh ^hgZOmZgZ jZkkf_ylvky
Hg kdZaZeqlh y^he`_g `^Zlvb g_aZdju\Zlv ]eZa\k_ \j_fy
b qlh \ hij_^_e_gguc fhf_gly kfh]m m\b^_lv ojZgbl_ey
^jm]h]h fbjZ
Y ihqm\kl\h\Zehq_gv g_ijbylguc`Zj \h\k_f fh_fl_e_
y ihiulZeky baf_gblviheh`_gb_gh yg_ fh]k^\bgmlvkyY
ohl_e h[jZlblvkyd ^hgmOmZgmgh keh\ZdZaZehkv[ueb lZd
]em[hdh \gmljbf_gyqlh yg_ fh]\ulygmlv boLh]^Z ymiZe
gZ e_\mxklhjhgm bh[gZjm`be k_[ykfhljysbf gZ^hgZ OmZgZk
iheZ
Hg gZdehgbeky bijbdZaZe fg_r_ihlhf g_ kfhlj_lv gZ
g_]hZ ijbklZevghkfhlj_lv \lhqdm gZpbgh\d_dhlhjZy [ueZ
ijyfh ijhlb\ fhbo]eZaHg kdZaZeqlh y ^he`_g kfhlj_lv
h^gbf ]eZahfe_\ufb qlhjZgh bebiha^gh y
m\ b` m
ojZgbl_ey
Y gZijZ\be ijbklZevguc \a]ey^gZ lhqdmdhlhjmx hg
mdZaZegh gbq_]hg_ \b^_e< g_dhlhjucfhf_glh^gZdhy
aZf_lbe fhrdme_lZ\rmx i_j_^fhbfb ]eZaZfbHgZ k_eZ gZ
pbgh\dmY ke_^beaZ __^\b`_gbyfbHgZ ijb[ebabeZkv hq_gv
[ebadh dh fg_lZd [ebadhqlh fh_ ajbl_evgh_ hsms_gb_
aZlmfZgbehkvB aZl_f\g_aZighy ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh y dZd
[u ih^gyekyWlh [uehhq_gv k[b\Zxs__k lhedm hsms_gb_ b
aZkem`b\Zeh g_dhlhjh]h h[tykg_gbygh ^eywlh]h g_ [ueh
\j_f_gbM f_gy [uehihegh_ hsms_gb_qlh y \b^_e ijyfh
\i_j_^ hl fh_]hh[uqgh]h mjh\gy]eZab lhqlh y m\b^_e
ihljykeh \k_ nb[ju fh_]h kms_kl\ZG_l kihkh[Zqlh[u
hibkZlv wfhpbhgZevguc lheqhddhlhjuc y i_j_`beIjyfh
i_j_^h
fghc
[ueh
]b]Zglkdh_qm^h\bsgh_
`b\hlgh_
>_ckl\bl_evgh qm^h\bsgZy \_svGbdh]^Z
\ kZfuo ^bdbo
nZglZabyo m f_gyg_ [uehklhedgh\_gbc gbk q_fih^h[guf
wlhfmY kfhlj_e gZg_]h \kh\_jr_gghfdjZcg_f aZf_rZ
l_evkl\_
I_j\hc \_svxdhlhjmx y^_ckl\bl_evgh aZf_lbe[ue _]h
jZaf_jY ih^mfZeih dZdhclh ijbqbg_qlh hgh^he`gh [ulv
[ueh hdhehklZ nmlh\\ukhlhcHghdZaZehkvklhyeh ijyfh
ohly yg_ fh]ihgylvdZd hghklhyehAZl_f yaZf_lbeqlh
hgh bf_ehdjuevy^\Z dhjhldborbjhdbo djueZ< wlhff_kl_
y klZe khagZ\Zlvqlh ygZklhcqb\h jZkkfZljb\Zx `b\hlgh_
dZd [m^lhhgh [uehh[uqgh]h \b^Zlh _klvy kfhlj_egZ g_]h
H^gZdhy g_fh] \^_ckl\bl_evghklb kfhlj_lvgZ g_]himl_f
dZdbf yijb\ud kfhlj_lvY ihgyeqlh ykdhj__aZf_qZe _]h
ih qZklyfdZd [m^lhdZjlbgZ klZgh\beZkv[he__ ykghcdh]^Z
^h[Z\eyebkv qZklb?]h l_eh[ueh ihdjulh imqdZfb q_jguo
\hehkM g_]h[ueh ^ebggh_juehdhlhjh_ khqbehkv?]h ]eZaZ
[ueb \uimdeu_b djm]eu_ih^h[gh ^\mfh]jhfguf [_eufrZjZf
AZl_f hghgZqZeh fZoZlvdjuevyfbWlh [uehg_ ^\b`_gb_
djuev_\dZd milbpZ lj_i_lZgb_\b[jZpbyHgh gZ[jZeh
kdhjhklv bgZqZeh djm`blvkyi_j_^h fghcwlh [ueg_ ihe_l
Zkdhj__lhjfh`_gb_
k
ihjZabl_evghc
kdhjhklvx
b
ijh\hjkl\hf\k_]h \g_kdhevdbo ^xcfZogZ^ a_fe_c< wlhl
fhf_gl y h[gZjm`be k_[yih]ehs_gguf \gZ[ex^_gb_ aZ _]h
^\b`_gb_fY ih^mfZeqlh _]h^\b`_gby [ueb[_ah[jZagugh
h^gZdh_]h kdhjhklvb e_]dhklv[ueb \_ebdhe_igu
Hgh ihdjm`behkv ^\Z`^ui_j_^h fghc\b[jbjmy k\hbfb
djuevyfbb \k_qlh khqbehkvba _]hjlZe_l_eh \h \k_o
gZijZ\e_gbyoAZl_f hghhibkZeh djm]b aZkdhevabehijhqv k
g_hibkm_fhc kdhjhklvxihdZ g_bkq_aeh ba\b^ZY ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_e \gZijZ\e_gbb\ dhlhjhfhgh me_l_ehlZd dZdgbq_]h
g_ [uehqlh yfh] [u^_eZlvM f_gy[ueh hq_gv kljZggh_
hsms_gb_ ly`_klbhsms_gb_ kms_kl\Zg_kihkh[gh]h kh[jZlv
k\hb fukeb k\yaghY g_fh] k^\bgmlvkyY [ue dZd [m^lh
ijbde__g df_klm
AZl_f y m\b^_e\^Zeb g_qlhihoh`__ gZiylghkimkly
f]gh\_gb_ ]jhfZ^guca\_jv kgh\Zdjm`beky gZiheghc kdhjhklb
i_j_^h fghc?]h djuevy [ueb\k_ [eb`_b [eb`_ d fhbf
]eZaZfihdZ g_ ^hklb]ebf_gyY ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh _]h
djuevy ^_ckl\b_levgh ^hklZeb f_gyhgb [ueb a^_kvY
ijhgabl_evgh aZdjbqZe kh\k_c k\h_ckbehckh[jZ\ \ h^gh
kZfu_ fmqbl_evgu_mkbebydhlhju_ ydh]^Zeb[h bf_e
Ke_^mxs_c \_svxdhlhjmx yhkhagZe[ueh lhqlh y
kb^_e gZk\h_c pbgh\d_b ^hgOmZg l_jfhc eh[Hg gZl_jfhb
jmdb b gh]bebklvyfbaZl_f hghl\_e f_gyd dZgZ\_ ihaZ^b
_]h ^hfZkgye kf_gy h^_`^mb iheghklvxhdmgme f_gy\ \h^m
aZl_f \ulZsbef_gy bhdmgme f_gykgh\Z bkgh\Z
Dh]^Z y e_`Ze\ f_edhcdZgZ\_^hg OmZg \ugbfZe fhx
e_\mx gh]m \j_fy hl \j_f_gbb ihoehiu\Ze hklhjh`gh ih
ih^hr\_Ihke_ wlh]hy qm\kl\h\Zes_dhlZgb_Hg aZf_lbewlh
b kdZaZeqlh y[ue \ihjy^d_Y h^_ekyb fu\_jgmebkv \
_]h ^hfY kgh\Zk_e gZk\hc khehf_ggucfZl b ihiulZeky
aZ]h\hjblvgh ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh g_fh] kdhgp_gljbjh\Zlvky
gZ lhfqlh yohl_e kdZaZlvohly fhb fukeb [ueb hq_gv
ykgufbY [ue m^b\e_gihgy\dZd fgh]h dhgp_gljZpbb
g_h[oh^bfhqlh[u ]h\hjblvY lZd`_aZf_lbeqlh ^ey lh]h
qlh[u kdZaZlv qlheb[hy hklZgZ\eb\Ze\a]ey^ gZ\_sZoM
f_gy [ueh \i_qZle_gb_qlh yaZimlZeky hq_gv ]em[hdhb
dh]^Z y ohl_e ]h\hjblvy ^he`_g [ue \kieulv ih^h[gh
\h^heZamy ^he`_g [ueih^gylvkydZd [m^lh ijblygmluc
k\hbfb keh\Zfb>\Z`^u iulZekyhldZreylvky h[uqgufkihkh[hf
Y fh] kdZaZlv lh]^Z \k_qlh yohl_egh y g_ fh]Y
ij_^ihqblZe hklZ\ZlvkygZ g_h[uqghfmjh\g_ lbrbgu]^_ yfh]
lhevdh kfhlj_lvM f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hqlh yihklmqZeky \lh
qlh ^hg OmZggZau\Ze \b^_gb_b wlhk^_eZeh f_gy hq_gv
kqZkleb\uf
Ihlhf ^hgOmZg ^Zefg_ kmib e_i_rdbb \_e_efg_ _klv
Y fh]_klv [_adZdh]heb[h mkbebyb [_aihl_jb lh]hqlhy
^mfZe[ueh fh_c kbehc
\b^_gbyY nhdmkbjh\Ze k\hc
ijbklZevguc \a]ey^gZ \k_f\hdjm] f_gyY [uem[_`^_gqlh y
fh] \b^_lv\k_bl_f g_f_g__\_kv fbj\u]ey^_e lZdbf
`_gZkdhevdh yhp_gb\ZeY klZjZeky\b^_lv^h l_o ihj
ihdZ g_ klZeh kh\_jr_ggh
l_fghGZdhg_py i_j_klZe
klZjZlvkye_] baZkgme
Y ijhkgmekydh]^Z ^hgOmZg ihdju\Zef_gy h^_yehfM
f_gy [he_eZ ]heh\Z blhrgbehIhlhf y ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
emqr_ bdj_idh aZkgme^h ke_^mxs_]h^gy
Mljhf y [uekh[hc kgh\ZY g_l_ji_eb\h kijhkbe ^hgZ
OmZgZ
Qlh ijhbkoh^behkh fghc"
>hg OmZgkdjhfgh aZkf_yeky
Lu oh^bekfhlj_lv ojZgbl_eybdhg_qghlu gZr_e
_]hkdZaZe hg
Gh qlhwlh [ueh^hg OmZg"
KljZ`ojZgbl_evqZkh\hc ^jm]h]hfbjZkdZaZe ^hg
OmZg m[_^bl_evgh
Y gZf_j_\Zeky jZkkdZaZlv _fm
ih^jh[ghklb h[ wlhf
aeh\_s_f b[_ah[jZaghf a\_j_gh hgg_ h[jZlbe\gbfZgby gZ
fhx ihiuldmkdZaZ\qlh fh_i_j_`b\Zgb_ g_[ueh hkh[_gguf
qlh ex[hcq_eh\_d fh]i_j_`blv wlh
Y kdZaZe _fmqlh ojZgbl_ev\ua\Ze \hfg_ lZdhc rhd
qlh y^_ckl\bl_evgh g_[ue _s_kihkh[_g ^mfZlvh[ wlhf
>hg OmZg jZkkf_yeky b \ukf_yelhqlh hg gZau\Ze
k\_jo^jZfZlbq_kdhc gZdehgghklvxfh_c gZlmju
WlZ \_svq_f [uhgZ gb[ueZaZ^_eZ f_gykdZaZe
ywlh [uehlZd j_ZevghdZd lub y
Dhg_qghwlh [uehj_ZevghIjbqbgbeZ ebhgZ \Zf[hev
beb g_l"
Dh]^Z y \kihfbgZek\hb i_j_`b\Zgbyfh_ \ha[m`^_gb_
jhkeh>hg OmZg \_e_efg_ mkihdhblvkyAZl_f hg kijhkbe
f_gy^_ckl\bl_evgh eby [hyeky_]hhg ih^q_jdgme keh\Z
^_ckl\bl_evgh
Y [uehr_ehfe_gkdZaZe yGbdh]^Z \fh_c `bagbm
f_gy g_[ueh i_j_`b\ZgbylZdh]h [eZ]h]h\_cgh]hkljZoZ
;jhkvkdZaZe hgkf_ykvL_[_ [ueh g_q_]h
[hylvky
Y deygmkvl_[_kdZaZe yf bkdj_gg_ckljZklvx
qlh _keb[u yfh] ^\b]Zlvkyy m[_`Ze[u \bkl_jbd_
Hg gZr_efh_ ml\_j`^_gb_hq_gv aZ[Z\gufb aZohohlZe\h
\k_ ]hjeh
Qlh `_aZklZ\beh f_gy\b^_lv wlhqm^h\bs_^hg OmZg"
Hg klZek_jv_aguf bijbklZevgh ihkfhlj_egZ f_gy
Wlh [ue kljZ`kdZaZe hg_keb lu ohq_rv
\ b^ _l vlu ^he`_gih[_^blv kljZ`Z
Gh dZdy fh]mih[_^blv _]h^hg OmZg"Hg\hafh`gh
klh nmlh\\ukhlhc
>hg OmZgaZkf_yeky lZdkbevghqlh ke_auihl_deb ba_]h
]eZa
Ihq_fm lug_ iha\hey_rvfg_ jZkkdZaZlvl_[_ h lhf
qlh y \b^_elZdbf h[jZahf
a^_kv g_ [ueh [u gbq_]h
g_ihgylgh]h"kdZaZe y
?keb
wlh
^_eZ_l
l_[y
kqZkleb\ufijh^he`Zc
jZkkdZau\Zc fg_
Y jZkkdZaZe\k_qlh yfh] \kihfgblvgh wlhdZaZehkv
g_ baf_gbeh_]h gZkljh_gby
H^gZdh\ wlhfgbq_]h gh\h]hkdZaZe hgmeu[Zykv
Gh dZd lu h`b^Z_rvqlh y kfh]m ih[_^blv \_sv
ih^h[gmx wlhc"Q_f"
Hg aZfheqZe
b
kh\_jr_ggh
mkihdhbekyAZl_f hg
ih\_jgmeky dhfg_ bkdZaZe
Lu [hyeky\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb"L_[_ [ueh[hevghgh lu
g_ [hyeky
Hg hldbgmekygZ dZdb_lh maeub aZdbgmejmdb aZ]heh\m
Y ih^mfZeqlh hghklZ\be wlhljZa]h\hj
Lu agZ_rvkdZaZe hgg_h`b^Zgghkfhljy gZ djurm
jZfZ^udZ`^uc q_eh\_dfh`_l \b ^_ lv
kljZ`ZKljZ`
bgh]^Z y\ey_lkyg_dhlhjuf bagZk mkljZrZxsbfa\_j_f \ukhlhc
^h g_[ZLu kqZkleb\_p^ey l_[yhg [uelhevdh klh nmlh\
\ukhlhcB \k_`_ _]hk_dj_l hq_gvijhkl
Hg aZfheqZe gZ f]gh\_gb_b aZfmjeudZe f_dkbdZgkdmx
i_k_gdm
KljZ` ^jm]h]hfbjZ [uedhfZjkdZaZe hg f_^e_ggh
dZd [m^lhbaf_jyy ^_ckl\b_k\hbo keh\
Ba\bgbl_
KljZ` ^jm]h]hfbjZ dhfZjih\lhjbe hglhk
q_f lu\klj_lbeky \q_jZ[ue dhfZjb wlhlfZe_gvdbc dhfZj
g_ ijhimklbll_[yihdZ lug_ ih[_^brv_]h
< wlhlfhf_gl yg_ ohl_e\_jblv \lhqlh ]h\hjbe ^hg
OmZgghijbihfgb\ ihihjy^dm k\hx\klj_qmy ^he`_g [ue
kh]eZkblvkyqlh \ h^bg fhf_gly kfhlj_e gZ dhfZjZZ
f]gh\_gb_ kimklyijhbahr_e \b^fbjZ`Zb ym\b^_e a\_jy
Gh dZdfh] dhfZjih\j_^blv fg_^hg OmZg"kijhkbe
y^_ckl\bl_evgh k[bluck lhedm
Hg [ueg_ dhfZjhfdh]^Z ijbqbgyel_[_ [hevkdZaZe
hghg [uekljZ`_f ^jm]h]hfbjZ<hafh`ghh^gZ`^u lu
kh[_j_rvky k fm`_kl\hfih[_^blv _]hG_ l_i_jvy ^mfZx
l_i_jv hg ^eyl_[y klhnmlh\uc[jua]Zxsbc a\_jvGh g_q_]h
]h\hjblv h[wlhfKlhylv i_j_^gbf wlh g_ih^\b]ihwlhfm
_keb luohq_rv agZlv[hevr_ h[wlhflu ^he`_ggZclb kljZ`Z
kgh\Z
>\Z ^gy kimklyghy[jyy kgh\Zdmjbe kf_kv ^hgZ
OmZgZ
Y ihijhkbe^hgZ OmZgZ^Zlv fg_ihdmjblv _s_jZaqlh[u
gZclb kljZ`ZY ihijhkbe_]h g_kjZamZ ihke_ ^he]h]h
jZafure_gbyFhy aZbgl_j_kh\ZgghklvkljZ`_f [ueZ gZfgh]h
[hevr_ fh_]hkljZoZ bebg_m^h[kl\Z ihl_jylvk\hx ykghklv
Ijhp_^mjZ [ueZ lZdhc `_>hg OmZggZ[be ljm[dmb
dh]^Z ydhgqbe \k_kh^_j`bfh_hg \aye__ bkijylZe
Wnn_dl [ue aZf_lgh f_^e_gg__Dh]^Z y ihqm\kl\h\Ze
g_[hevrh_ ]heh\hdjm`_gb_^hg OmZgih^hr_e dhfg_ b\ay\
fhx ]heh\mjmdZfbihfh] fg_e_qv gZe_\uc [hdHg \_e_efg_
\ulygmlv gh]b bjZkkeZ[blvkyZ aZl_fihfh] fg_ ihklZ\blv
fhx ijZ\mx jmdmi_j_^ kh[hcgZ mjh\g_fh_c ]jm^bHg lZd
ih\_jgme fhxeZ^hgvqlh[u yhi_jky gZpbgh\dmb iha\hebe
[u hl^hogmlvfh_fm l_emY gbq_]hg_ ^_eZeqlh[u ihfhqvbeb
ihf_rZlv _fmlZd dZdy g_agZeqlh hgkh[bjZ_lky ^_eZlv
Hg k_e gZijhlb\ f_gy b \_e_e fg_ gb gZ q_f g_
dhgp_gljbjh\ZlvkyHg kdZaZeqlh ojZgbl_evkh[bjZeky ijbclb
b qlhy ^he`_gkfhlj_lv \hdjm]qlh[u m\ b^ _l v
_]h
Hg lZd`_ kdZaZe fg_ g_[j_`ghqlh kljZ` fh] ijbqbgblv
[hevrmx [hevgh qlh[ue h^bgkihkh[ ij_^hl\jZlblvwlhHg
kdZaZeqlh ^\Z^gy gZaZ^hg aZklZ\bef_gy kb^_lvihlhfm
qlh hgkqblZeqlh wlh]hk f_gy^hklZlhqghHg mdZaZegZ fhx
ijZ\mx jmdmb kdZaZeqlh hggZf_j_ggh ihklZ\be__ \ lZdh_
iheh`_gb_qlh[u yfh] ihevah\Zlvky_cdZd juqZ]hfqlh[u
ijh^\b]Zlvkydm^Z [uy gbih`_eZe
Dh \j_f_gbdh]^Z hgdhgqbe ]h\hjblvfg_ \k_wlhfh_
l_eh kh\k_f hg_f_ehY ohl_eh[jZlblv _]h\gbfZgb_ gZ lh
qlh fg_[m^_l g_\hafh`ghijh^\b]Zlvkyihlhfm qlhy ihl_jye
dhgljhev gZ^fhbfb fmkdmeZfbY iulZekyijhbag_klb keh\Zgh
g_ fh]HgdZaZehkvij_^\b^_e wlhh^gZdhb h[tykgbeqlh
\ky obljhklv [ueZ \`_eZgbbHg m[_`^Ze f_gy \kihfgblv
\j_fyg_kdhevdh e_lgZaZ^dh]^Z y\i_j\u_ dmjbe]jb[u<
wlhf kemqZ_y iZ^ZegZ a_fexb \kdZdb\ZegZ gh]bkgh\Z ijb
^_ckl\bb lh]hqlh hggZau\Ze \lh \j_fyfhbf `_eZgb_fy
\u^mfu\Ze kZfHg kdZaZeqlh
wlh [ue _^bgkl\_ggh
\hafh`guc kihkh[\klZlv
Lhqlh hg]h\hjbe[ueh [_kihe_agh^ey f_gyihlhfm
qlh y g_ihfgbeqlh y\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb^_eZe ij_`^_M
f_gy [ueh\k_ih]ehsZxs__ qm\kl\h[_agZ^_`ghklbb y aZdjue
]eZaZ
>hg OmZg ko\Zlbef_gy aZ\hehkuwg_j]bqgh \kljyogme
fhx ]heh\mb ih\_ebl_evghijbdZaZe fg_g_ aZdju\Zlv]eZaZY
g_ lhevdhhldjue ]eZaZgh k^_eZeqlhlhqlhy ^mfZe[ueh
m^b\bl_evgufY ^_ckl\bl_evghkdZaZe
Y g_agZxdZd y\klZ\Ze lh]^Z
Y [ue kbevghm^b\e_gQlhlh hq_gvfhghlhggh_ [ueh \
jblf_ fh_]h]hehkZgh wlh[ue ^_ckl\bl_evghfhc ]hehkb
l_f g_ f_g__y q_klgh\_jbeqlh yg_ fh] kdZaZlv wlh
ihlhfm qlhfbgmlhc jZgvr_y g_[ue kihkh[_g]h\hjblv
Y ihkfhlj_egZ ^hgZOmZgZHg hl\_jgmekyb aZkf_yeky
Y g_]h\hjbe wlh]hkdZaZe y
Y hiylvkbevgh m^b\bekyk\h_fm ]hehkmY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
h[h^j_gb_=h\hjblv ijbwlbo mkeh\byoklZeh jZa\e_dZl_evguf
ijhp_kkhfFg_ ohl_ehkv ihijhkblv^hgZ OmZgZqlh[u hg
h[tykgbe fhc jZa]h\hjgh yh[gZjm`beqlh kgh\Z g_ [ue
kihkh[_g ijhbag_klb gb_^bgh]h keh\ZY g_bklh]h klZjZeky
\ukdZaZlv k\hbfukebgh [_kihe_aghY hldZaZekyhl wlh]hb
\ wlhlfhf_glihqlb g_ijhba\hevghijhbag_k
Dlh ]h\hjbldlh ]h\hjbl"
Wlhl \hijhk lZd jZkkf_rbe
^hgZ OmZgZqlh hg
ih^iju]gme gZf_kl_
Hq_\b^ghy fh]\ukdZau\Zlv ijhklu_\_sb_keb y agZe
lhqgh lhqlh yohl_e kdZaZlv
Y eb]h\hjx"Y eb]h\hjx"kijhkbe y
>hg OmZgkdZaZe fg_qlh _keby g_hklZgh\exkvlh hg
mc^_l b hl^hog_lih^ jZfZ^Zb hklZ\blf_gy h^gh]h k fhbf
^mjZq_kl\hf
Wlh g_^mjZq_kl\hkdZaZe y
Y ]h\hjbehq_gv k_jv_aghFhb fukeb[ueb hq_gvykgufb
fh_ l_ehh^gZdhhg_f_eh y g_qm\kl\h\Ze _]hY g_
aZ^uoZekylZd dZd y [ueh^gZ`^u \ ijhrehf \ ih^h[guo
mkeh\byofg_ [ueh m^h[ghihlhfm qlhy g_ fh] gbq_]h
qm\kl\h\Zlvm f_gyg_ [uehdhgljhey gZ^khagZgb_fgh\k_
`_y fh] ]h\hjblvFg_ ijbreZfukevqlh _keb y fh]m
]h\hjblv\hafh`ghy fh]mb \klZlvdZd ]h\hjbe^hg OmZg
<klZxkdZaZe yihZg]ebckdbb k f_jpZgb_f \
]eZaZo\klZe>hg OmZgihdZqZe ]heh\hcg_^h\_jqb\h b\ur_e
ba ^hfZ
>hg OmZgiha\Ze yljb jZaZ
Hg \_jgmeky
Iheh`b f_gykdZaZe y
Iheh`b k_[ykZfkdZaZe hgdZ`_lkylu ^_eZ_rv
ijZ\bevgh
Y kdZaZeeh`mkvb \g_aZighy ihl_jye dhfgZlm ba
\b^ZY gbq_]hg_ \b^_eQ_j_a k_dmg^mdhfgZlZ b^hg OmZg
ihy\bebkv hiylv \ ihe_fh_]h aj_gbyY ih^mfZeqlh y
^he`gh [ulve_`Ze ebphf\gbab hg\aye f_gyaZ \hehku b
ih^gye fhx]heh\m
KiZkb[hkdZaZe yhq_gv f_^e_ggh
Ih`ZemcklZhl\_lbe hgih^jZ`Zy fg_b k^_j`b\Zy
kf_o
AZl_f hgijbg_k ebklvyb gZqZejZklbjZlv bfbfhb jmdbb
gh]b
Qlh lu^_eZ_rv"kijhkbe y
Y jZklbjZxl_[ykdZaZe hgbfblbjmy fhx ly`_emx
fhghlhgghklv
Hg kh^jh]gmeky hlkf_oZ?]h ]eZaZ[ueb [e_klysbfb b
hq_gv ^jm`_ex[gufbY ihgjZ\beky_fmY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh ^hg
OmZg [ue khqm\kl\mxsbfq_klguf b^h\hevgufY g_ fh]
kf_ylvky kgbfgh fg_[ueh ijbylgh>jm]h_ qm\kl\hjZ^hklb
ho\Zlbeh f_gyb yaZkf_yekywlh [uelZdhc m`Zkguc a\md
qlh ^hgOmZg ihiylbeky
Y emqr_hl\_^m l_[yd dZgZ\_kdZaZe hgbeb lu
m[v_rv k_[y^mjZq_kl\hf
Hg ihklZ\be f_gy gZgh]b baZklZ\be ijh]meylvky ih
dhfgZl_FZehihfZem
y
gZqZe
ijboh^blv
\
qm\kl\h
ihqm\kl\h\Ze k\hbgh]bbgZdhg_p\k_ k\h_l_ehFhb mrb
jZaju\Zebkv hl g_h[uqgh]h
^Z\e_gbyWlh [ueh ih^h[gh
hsms_gbx jmdbbeb gh]bdhlhjZy [ueZaZkgm\r_cY qm\kl\h\Ze
h]jhfgmx ly`_klv\ aZlued_b gZfZdmrd_
>hg OmZg ihlZsbe f_gy ddZgZ\_ ihaZ^b _]h ^hfZ b
iheh`be f_gy lm^Z kh\_jr_ggh
jZa^_lh]hOheh^gZy \h^Z
mf_gvrbeZ ^Z\e_gb_[hevb ihkl_i_ggh\k_ ijhreh
Y i_j_h^_eky \
^hf_k_e
b kgh\Z ihqm\kl\h\Ze
hlqm`^_gghklvlh `_`_eZgb_ hklZ\ZlvkykihdhcgufH^gZdh
gZ wlhl jZa yaZf_lbeqlh wlh[ueZ g_ ykghklv mfZ beb
kihkh[ghklv dkhkj_^hlhq_gbxkdhj__wlh [ue\b^ f_eZgohebb
beb nbabq_kdhcmklZehklbGZdhg_py aZkgme
ghy[jy ]
< wlh mljh ^hg OmZgb y ihreb gZ khk_^gb_ ohefu
kh[bjZlv jZkl_gbyFu ijhrebhdheh r_klbfbev ihqj_a\uqZcgh
g_jh\ghc f_klghklbY hq_gvmklZeFu k_eb hl^hogmlvih
fh_c bgbpbZlb\_b hggZqZe jZa]h\hjkdZaZ\qlh hg^h\he_g
fhbf ijh]j_kkhf
Y agZxl_i_jvqlh wlh]h\hjbe ykdZaZe ygh
lh]^Z yfh] ihdeyklvkyqlh wlh[ue dlhlh ^jm]hc
Dhg_qghwlh [uelukdZaZe hg
DZd `_kemqbehkvqlh yg_ fh]magZlv k_[y"
Wlh ^_eZ_l^ufhdFh`gh ]h\hjblvb g_aZf_lblv wlh]h
beb fh`gh ijhclb lukyqbfbev bg_ aZf_lblv gbq_]hWlh
aZ\bkbl hl lh]hdZd
dlheb[h
fh`_l ijbgbfZlv \_sb
FZe_gvdbc ^ufhd mkljZgy_l l_ehb ^Z_l k\h[h^mih^h[gh
\_ljmemqr_q_f \_l_j\_l_j fh`_l[ulv hklZgh\e_gkdZehc
kl_ghc beb]hjhcFZe_gvdbc ^ufhd^_eZ_l q_eh\_dZk\h[h^guf
dZd \ha^mo\hafh`gh^Z`_ k\h[h^g__\ha^moZ fh`_lg_ [ulv
\ a_fe_ bhg fh`_lklZlv aZloeufgh kihfhsvx fZe_gvdh]h
^ufdZ q_eh\_dg_ fh`_l[ulv hklZgh\e_gbeb aZi_jl
Keh\Z ^hgOmZgZ \uk\h[h^bebkf_kv wcnhjbbb khfg_gbyY
qm\kl\h\Ze ihljykZxs__[_kihdhckl\hhsms_gb_ g_hij_^_e_gghc
\bgu
Lh]^Z hgfh`_l ^_ckl\bl_evghk^_eZlv \k_wlb \_sb
^hg OmZg"
: qlh^mfZ_rv lu"Lu ih^mfZ_rvkdhj__qlh y\ey_rvky
g_ghjfZevgufbeb g_l"kdZaZe hgya\bl_evgh
>ey l_[ye_]dh ijbgbfZlv\k_ wlb\_sb>ey f_gy wlh
g_\hafh`gh
Fg_ wlhg_e_]dhM f_gyg_ [hevr_ijb\be_]bcq_f m
l_[yWlb \_sb jZ\ghljm^gu ^eyl_[y b^ey f_gy beb ^ey
ex[h]h ^jm]h]hqlh[u boijbgylv
Gh lu^hfZ kh\k_f wlbf^hg OmZg"
>Zgh wlh fg_fgh]h klhblY ^he`_g [hjhlvky
\hafh`gh[hevr_q_f ludh]^Zeb[h ohl_eM l_[y ljm^guc
imlv ihemq_gby \k_]h \jZ[hl_Lu g_ ij_^klZ\ey_rvdZd
ly`_eh y ^he`_g [uejZ[hlZlvqlh[u k^_eZlv lhqlh lu
k^_eZe \q_jZM l_[y_klv qlhlhqlh ihfh]Z_l l_[_ gZ
dZ`^hf ^xcf_
imlbG_l
^jm]h]h
\hafh`gh]h
kihkh[Z
h[tykg_gbydjhf_ kihkh[Zdhlhjuf lumagZ_rv hkbeZoLu
^_eZe wlh ij_`^_ k f_kdZeblhl_i_jv lu ^_eZ_rv wlh k
fZe_gvdbf ^ufdhfLu ^he`_gkhkj_^hlhqblvky gZnZdl_qlh lu
bf__rv [hevrhc ^Zjb
hl[jhkblv ^jm]b_ khh[jZ`_gby \
klhjhgm
Lu ijhbaghkbrv wlh lZde_]dhgh wlh g_ lZdY
jZaju\Zxkv \gmljb
Lu [m^_rv p_evguf kgh\Z ^h\hevgh kdhjhLu g_
aZ[hlbrvky h k\h_f l_e_ baaZ h^ghc\_sbLu lZdhc `_
lheklucY g_ ohl_egbq_]h ]h\hjblvl_[_ ij_`^_DZ`^uc
^he`_g \k_]^Z iha\heylv^jm]bf ^_eZlvlhqlh hgb ^he`gu
^_eZlvL_[y ^he]hg_ [uehY kdZaZel_[_qlh lu\_jg_rvky
h^gZdhb lu\_jgmekyLZ `_\_sv kemqbeZkvkh fghcY mr_e
gZ iylvk iheh\bghce_l
Ihq_fm lug_ ijboh^be^hg OmZg"
Ih lhc`_ ijbqbg_qlh bluY g_ihex[be wlh
Ihq_fm `_lu \_jgmeky"
Ih lhc `_ijbqbg_ih dhlhjhc\_jgmeky lu kZf ihlhfm qlhg_ [ueh^jm]h]h imlbqlh[u `blv
Wlh aZy\e_gb_ bf_eh[hevrh_ \ha^_ckl\b_gZ f_gyb y
ih^mfZeqlh\hafh`ghg_ [ueh^jm]h]h imlb `bagbY
gbdh]^Z g_\ukdZau\Ze wlmfukev dhfmgb[m^vh^gZdh ^hgOmZg
\ukdZaZe __ijZ\bevgh
Ihke_ hq_gv^he]h]h fheqZgbyy kijhkbe_]h
Qlh y^_eZe \q_jZ^hg OmZg"
Lu \klZ\Zedh]^Z luohl_e
Gh yg_ agZxdZd y^_eZe wlh
Kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zgb_ wlhcl_ogbdb hlgbfZ_l\j_fy<Z`gZy
\_svh^gZdhwlh lhqlh luagZ_rvdZd ^_eZlvwlh
Gh yg_ agZxWlh \hijhky ^_ckl\bl_evghg_ agZx
Dhg_qghlu agZ_rv
>hg OmZgy m\_jyxl_[yy deygmkvl_[_
Hg g_^Ze fg_dhgqblvhg \klZeb \ur_e
Iha`_ fukgh\Z [_k_^h\Zebh kljZ`_^jm]h]h fbjZ
?keb y\_jxqlh \k_qlh ybkiulZe^_ckl\bl_evgh
j_ZevghkdZaZe ylh]^Z kljZ` y\ey_lky ]b]Zglkdbf
kha^Zgb_fdhlhjh_ fh`_lijbqbgblv g_\_jhylgmx nbabq_kdmx
[hevb _keby \_jxqlh hgfh`_l ^_ckl\bl_evghiml_r_kl\h
\Zlv gZh]jhfgu_ jZkklhygbyihkj_^kl\hf ^_ckl\by\heblh]^Z
eh]bq_kdb aZdexqblvqlh yfh] [ulZd`_ `_eZgb_f aZklZ\blv
qm^h\bs_ bkq_agmlvLZd ebwlh"
G_ lhqghkdZaZe hgLu g_fh`_rv aZohl_lvqlh[u
kljZ` bkq_aH^gZdhl\h_ `_eZgb_fh`_l hklZgh\blv_]h hl
\j_^Z l_[_Dhg_qgh_keb ludh]^Zgb[m^v \uihegbrvwlhlh
^hjh]Z l_[_hldjulZLu ^_ckl\bl_evghkfh`_rv ijhclbkljZ`Z
b hg gbq_]h g_ kfh`_lk^_eZlv^Z`_ _keb [m^_l [_r_gh
djm`blvky \hdjm]
DZd `_y fh]mkh\_jrblv wlh"
Lu m`_agZ_rvdZd<k_\ q_flu gm`^Z_rvkywlh \
ijZdlbd_
Y kdZaZe _fmqlh mgZk [uehg_ijZ\bevgh_ ihgbfZgb_
dhlhjh_ ijhbkoh^beh hlgZr_c jZagbpu\ \hkijbylbbfbjZY
kdZaZeqlh ^eyf_gy agZlvqlhgb[m^v ih^jZamf_\Zehlhqlh
y ^he`_giheghklvx khagZ\Zlvh lhfqlh y^_eZeb qlhy fh]
ih\lhjblv lhqlh yagZeih `_eZgbxgh \wlhf kemqZ_y gb
khagZ\Ze h lhfqlh y^_eZe ih^\ebygb_f ^ufZgb fh]
ih\lhjblv wlh_keb [ufhy `bagvaZ\bk_eZ hlwlh]h
>hg OmZgihkfhlj_e gZf_gy bgd\bablhjkdbHgdZaZehkv
aZ[Z\eyeky l_fqlh y]h\hjbeHg kgyek\hx reyimb ihq_kZe
\bkdbdZd hg^_eZedh]^Z ohl_eijbdbgmlvky kfms_gguf
Lu ^_ckl\bl_evghagZ_rvdZd jZkkdZaZlvgbq_]h g_
]h\hjy"kdZaZe hgkf_ykvY ^he`_gkdZaZlv l_[_qlh lu
^he`_g bf_lvg_ij_dehggmx j_rbfhklvqlh[u klZlv q_eh\_dhf
agZgbyGh ludZ`_lkybf_e
g_ij_dehggmx j_rbfhklv
kfmlblvky aZ]Z^dZfblu gZklZb\Z_rvgZ h[tykg_gbb\k_]hdZd
[m^lh \_kv fbj khklZ\e_g ba\_s_cdhlhju_ fh]ml [ulv
h[tykg_guL_i_jv lu klhbrvebphf debpm khkljZ`_f b k
ijh[e_fhc ^\b`_gby ijbbkihevah\Zgbb k\h_]h`_eZgbyL_[_
dh]^Zeb[h ijboh^behgZ mfqlh lhevdhg_fgh]b_ \_sb\ wlhf
fbj_ fh]ml[ulv h[tykg_gul\hbf kihkh[hf"Dh]^Z y ]h\hjbe
qlh kljZ` ^_ckl\bl_evgh ij_]jZ`^Z_ll_[_ ijhoh^ b fh`_l
^_ckl\bl_evgh \u[blv ^vy\heZ ba l_[yy agZeqlh y
ih^jZamf_\ZeY ohl_e
gZmqblv
l_[y
fZehihfZemdZd
^\b]Zlvkygh aZl_fy ihgyeqlh luagZ_rvdZd wlh^_eZlv
ohly lub ]h\hjbrvqlh g_agZ_rv
Gh y^_ckl\bl_evgh g_agZxdZdaZijhl_klh\Ze y
Lu agZ_rvlu ^mjZdkdZaZe hgg_mfhebfh b aZl_f
meu[gmekyWlh gZihfbgZ_lfg_ \j_fydh]^Z dlhlh ihkZ^be
wlh]h iZjgy OmebhgZ m[hjhqgmxfZrbgmhg agZedZd \_klb
__ohly hggbdh]^Z g_ijh[h\Ze wlh]hjZgvr_
Y agZxqlh lubf__rv \\b^m^hg OmZgh^gZdhy \k_
_s_ qm\kl\mxqlh g_fh]m k^_eZlvwlh kgh\Zihlhfm qlhy g_
bf_x m\_j_gghklb\ lhfqlh y^_eZe
NZevrb\uc \her_[gbdiulZ_lky h[tykgblv\k_ \ fbj_
h[tykg_gbyfb\ dhlhjuo hgg_ m\_j_gkdZaZe hgb
ihwlhfm \k_y\ey_lky dhe^h\kl\hfGh hlwlh]h l_[_g_ emqr_
Lu lZd`_ ohq_rv h[tykgblv\k_ k\hbfkihkh[hfgh lu g_
m\_j_g \dZ`^hf k\h_fh[tykg_gbb
=eZ\Z
\h kv fZ y
>hg OmZg kijhkbe f_gy\g_aZigh^mfZe eb y m_a`Zlv
^hfhc \dhgp_ g_^_ebY kdZaZeqlh ygZf_j_\Zeky m_oZlv \
ihg_^_evgbd mljhfFu kb^_ebih^ _]hjZfZ^Z \ ihe^_gv \
km[[hlmyg\Zjyhl^uoZy
ihke_
^he]hc ijh]medb ih
hdj_klguf ohefZf>hg OmZg\klZe b\hr_e \ ^hfG_fgh]h
ih]h^yhg iha\Zef_gy \gmljvHg kb^_eihkj_^b dhfgZlu b
iheh`be fhxkhehf_ggmx pbgh\dmi_j_^ kh[hcHg ij_^eh`befg_
k_klv bg_ ]h\hjygb keh\ZjZa\_jgme k\hxljm[dm\ugme __
ba nmleyjZgZihegbe __qZrdm k\h_cdmjbl_evghc kf_kvx b
aZ`_] __Hg ^Z`_ ijbg_k
\ dhfgZlm ]ebgyguc ih^ghk
gZiheg_gguc f_edbfbm]eyfb
Hg g_kijhkbe f_gyohqm eby dmjblvHg lhevdh\jmqbe
fg_ ljm[dm b\_e_e fg_dmjblvY g_dhe_[Zeky>hg OmZg
hq_\b^ghhij_^_ebe fh_gZkljh_gb_ \_jghfh_ g_ij_h^hebfh_
ex[hiulkl\h d kljZ`m^he`gh [ueh[ulv hq_\b^guf_fmY g_
gm`^Zeky \dZdhfeb[h m]h\Zjb\Zgbbb g_l_ji_eb\h\udmjbe \kx
ljm[dm
J_Zdpbbdhlhju_ ybf_e[ueb ih^h[gul_fqlh y bf_e
jZgvr_>hg OmZglZd`_ \hah[gh\be\h fgh]hf\ lhc`_ fZg_j_
GZ wlhljZah^gZdh\f_klh lh]hqlh[u ihfh]Zlvfg_ ^_eZlv
wlhhg lhevdh\_e_e fg_hi_j_lv fhxijZ\mx jmdmgZ pbgh\dm
b e_qvgZ e_\uc[hdHg ij_^eh`beqlh[u yk`Ze dmeZd_keb
wlh ^Zklfg_ emqrbcmihj
Y k`ZedmeZd fh_cijZ\hc jmdblZd dZdy gZr_eqlh wlh
[ueh e_]q_q_f ih\_jgmlvd ihemeZ^hgvdh]^Z e_`brvk\hbf
\_khf gZ g_cY g_ kiZey qm\kl\h\Ze kbevgh_ l_ieh
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fyZ aZl_fihl_jye \kydh_qm\kl\h
>hg OmZge_] khk\h_c klhjhgugZijhlb\ f_gy_]h ijZ\h_
ij_^ie_qv_ hibjZehkv gZ_]h ehdhlvb ih^ibjZeh_]h ]heh\m
ih^h[gh ih^mrd_<k_ [uehkh\_jr_ggh kihdhcgh^Z`_ fh_
l_eh\ dhlhjhflh]^Z hlkmlkl\h\ZeblZdlbevgu_ hsms_gbyY
qm\kl\h\Ze [hevrh_m^h\e_l\hj_gb_
OhjhrhkdZaZe y
>hg OmZgihki_rgh \klZe
G_ kf_c gZqbgZlv k
wlhc q_imobkdZaZe hg
m[_^bl_evghG_ ]h\hjb=h\hjylu kh\_jr_ggh ihl_jy_rv
wg_j]bxb lh]^ZkjZ` jZa^Z\bll_[ydZd lu ijboehiu\Z_rv
dhfZjZ
Hg^he`gh [ulvih^mfZeqlh _]hmeu[dZ [ueZaZ[Z\ghc
ihlhfm qlhhg gZqZekf_ylvkygh \g_aZighhklZgh\beky
G_ jZa]h\Zjb\Zcih`ZemcklZg_ jZa]h\Zjb\Zc
kdZaZe hgk k_jv_aguf\ujZ`_gb_f ebpZ
Y g_ kh[bjZekygbq_]h ]h\hjblvkdZaZe yb y
^_ckl\bl_evgh g_ohl_e ]h\hjblvwlh
>hg OmZg\klZeY \b^_e_]h moh^ysbfd aZiZ^ghcklhjhg_
_]h ^hfZF]gh\_gb_f iha`_y aZf_lbeqlh gZ fhx pbgh\dm
k_eZ fhrdZb wlhgZihegbeh f_gylZdhc lj_\h]hcdZdhc yg_
bkiulu\Ze ij_`^_Wlh [ueZkf_kv ijbih^gylh]h gZkljh_gby
kljZ^Zgby b kljZoZY iheghklvxkhagZ\Zeqlh i_j_^h fghc
kh[bjZehkv jZa\_jgmlvkyqlhlh ljZgkm_g^_glZevgh_fhrdZ
dhlhjZy hojZgyeZ ^jm]hc fbjWlh [ueZ g_e_iZy fukevy
ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[y ih^h[gh ]jhfdhkf_xs_fmkygh aZl_f y
hkhagZeqlh fh_ijbih^gylh_ gZkljh_gb_hl\e_deh f_gyb y
]hlh\ [ue mimklblv i_j_oh^guc i_jbh^dhlhjuc y ohl_e
k^_eZlv ykguf< fh_cij_^u^ms_c ihiuld_m\b^_lv kljZ`Z y
kfhlj_e gZ fhrdm \gZqZe_k\hbf e_\uf]eZahfZ aZl_f y
ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh y\klZe bkfhlj_e gZg__ h[hbfb ]eZaZfb
gh yg_ khagZ\ZedZd ijhbahr_ewlhl i_j_oh^
Y m\b^_efhrdmdjm`b\rmxky \hdjm]pbgh\db i_j_^ fhbf
ebphfb ihgyeqlh kfhljxgZ g__ h[hbfb ]eZaZfbHgZ
ih^e_l_eZ hq_gv [ebadh\ wlhlfhf_gl yg_ fh] \b^_lv __
h[hbfb ]eZaZfb [hevr_b i_j_\_eaj_gb_ gZfhc e_\uc ]eZa
dhlhjuc [ue gZmjh\g_ a_feb< f]gh\_gb_dh]^Z y baf_gbe
nhdmky lZd`_ ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh y \uijyfbe fh_ l_eh
iheghklvx \\_jlbdZevgh_ iheh`_gb_b kfhlj_egZ g_\_jhylgh
h]jhfgh_ `b\hlgh_Hgh [ueh[e_klys_ q_jguf?]h i_j_^ [ue
ihdjul ^ebggufbq_jgufbdh\Zjgufb
\hehkZfbdhlhju_
\u]ey^_eb ih^h[gh rbiZfijhoh^ysbf kd\hav s_eb dZdhclh
[e_klys_cehkgys_cky
q_rmb<hehku
[ueb jZkiheh`_gu
imqdZfb?]h l_eh[ueh fZkkb\guflhekluf b djm]euf?]h
djuevy [uebrbjhdbfb bdhjhldbfb ihkjZ\g_gbx k^ebghc _]h
l_eZM g_]h[ueb ^\Z\uimdeuo ]eZaZb ^ebggh_jueh< wlh
\j_fy hgh kfhlj_eh gZ
f_gy
ih^h[gh Zeeb]ZlhjmHgh
dZaZehkvbf_eh ^ebggu_ mrbbeb\hafh`ghjh]Zb hgh
khqbehkv
Y klZjZeky bah\k_o kbenbdkbjh\Zlv k\hc ijbklZevguc
\a]ey^ gZ g_fb aZl_fklZe iheghklvxkhagZ\Zlvqlh y g_
fh] kfhlj_lv gZ g_]hl_f `_kZfuf iml_fdZdbf y h[uqgh
kfhlj_e gZ \_sbY bf_ekljZggmx fukev]ey^y gZ l_eh
kljZ`Zy qm\kl\h\Zeqlh dZ`^Zyhl^_evgZy qZklv_]h [ueZ
g_aZ\bkbfh `b\hcdZd [ueb`b\ufb ]eZaZex^_cY ihgyelh]^Z
\ i_j\uc jZa \fh_c `bagbqlh ]eZaZ [ueb _^bgkl\_gghc
qZklvx q_eh\_dZdhlhjZy fh]eZihdZaZlv fg_`b\hc hg beb
g_lKljZ`k ^jm]hcklhjhgubf_e fbeebhg ]eZa
Y ih^mfZeqlh wlh[ueh aZf_qZl_evghcgZoh^dhcI_j_^
wlbf hiulhfy jZafureyeh kjZ\g_gbyodhlhju_ fh]ebhibkZlv
bkdZ`_gbywlh]h ij_\jZs_gbyfhrdb \]b]Zglkdh]h a\_jyb y
ih^mfZeqlh ohjhrbfkjZ\g_gb_f [ueh[u dZd [m^lhkfhljbrv
gZ gZk_dhfh_q_j_a m\_ebqbl_evgu_ebgau fbdjhkdhiZGh wlh
[ueh g_lZdHq_\b^gh\b^ kljZ`Z[ue gZfgh]h[he__ keh`guf
q_f \u]ey^_ehm\_ebq_ggh_ gZk_dhfh_
KljZ` gZqZe djm`blvkyi_j_^h fghcGZ h^bgfhf_gl hg
hklZgh\bekyb yihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh hgkfhljbl gZf_gyLh]^Z
y aZf_lbeqlh hgg_ ijhba\h^bea\mdZLZg_p kljZ`Z [ue
fheqZeb\uf;eZ]h]h\_cghklv [ueZ \_]h ihy\e_gbb\ _]h
\uimdeuo ]eZaZo\ _]hm]jh`Zxs_c fhj^_\ _]hkhqeb\hklb\
_]h dh\Zjguo \hehkZob [hevr_\k_]h \ _]h g_\_jhylghf
jZaf_j_Y hq_gv[ebadh gZ[ex^ZedZd hg^\b]Ze djuevyfb
dZd hg\b^jbjh\Ze bfb[_a a\mdZY gZ[ex^ZedZd hglhjfhabe
gZ^ a_fe_cih^h[gh g_h[uqghfmdhgvdh[_`pm
JZkkfZljb\Zy wlh dhrfZjgh_ kha^Zgb_i_j_^h fghcy
^_ckl\bl_evgh qm\kl\h\Zeebdh\Zgb_Y ^_ckl\bl_evgh \_jbe
qlh y hldjuelZcgm h^he_lv_]hY ih^mfZeqlh kljZ` [ue
lhevdh ^\b`ms_cky dZjlbghc gZ g_fhfwdjZg_hg g_ fh]
ijbqbgblv fg_\j_^ hg lhevdh\u]ey^_e m`ZkZxsbf
KljZ` klhyel_f g_
f_g__ih\_jgm\rbkv dh fg_
\g_aZigh hg aZ\b[jbjh\Ze k\hbfb
djuevyfb b ih\_jgmeky
djm]hf?]h kibgZ\u]ey^_eZ ih^h[gh[e_klys_fm hdjZr_gghfm
iZgpbjx__ kbygb_ [ueh hke_ibl_evgufgh hll_ghd [ue
hl\jZlbl_evguf wlh [uefhc g_[eZ]hijbylgucp\_l
KljZ` g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy hklZ\Zeky ih\_jgmluc dh fg_
kibghcZ aZl_faZfZoZ\ k\hbfbdjuevyfbkgh\Z mkdhevagme
ba \b^Z
Y [ue ihklZ\e_g i_j_^hq_gv g_h[uqghc ^be_ffhcY
q_klgh \_jbeqlh yh^he_e _]hihgbfZgb_f lh]hqlh hg
bah[jZ`Ze lhevdh dZjlbgmyjhklbFhy \_jZ[ueZ\hafh`gh
[eZ]h^Zjy gZklhcqb\hfm ml\_j`^_gbx^hgZ OmZgZqlh y agZe
[hevr_q_f y ohl_e ijbagZlvky<h \kydhf kemqZ_y
qm\kl\h\Zeqlh y ih[_^bekljZ`Zb imlv [ue k\h[h^_g
H^gZdhy g_agZedZd ijh^he`Zlv>hg OmZgg_ kdZaZe fg_
qlh ^_eZlv \ lZdhf kemqZ_Y ihiulZeky ih\_jgmlvky b
ihkfhlj_lv kaZ^bgh yg_ fh]^\b]ZlvkyH^gZdhy hq_gv
ohjhrh fh]\b^_lv ]eZ\gmxqZklv ]jZ^mkgh]h ijhkljZgkl\Z
i_j_^ fhbfb ]eZaZfbY lhqlh y \b^_e[ueh g_ykguf
[e_^gh`_eluf ]hjbahglhfhg dZaZeky]ZahfEbfhgguc hll_ghd
h^ghh[jZagh aZdju\Ze\k_qlh yfh] \b^_lvDZaZehkvqlh y
[ue gZieZlhgZiheg_gghf iZjZfbk_ju
<g_aZigh kljZ`ihdZaZeky kgh\Zlhqdhc gZ]hjbahgl_Hg
k^_eZe rbjhdbc djm]ij_`^_ q_fhklZgh\blvky i_j_^h fghc
_]h jhl [uerbjhdh hldjulih^h[gh h]jhfghci_s_j_hg g_
bf_e am[h\Hg \b[jbjh\Zek\hbfb djuevyfbf]gh\_gb_Z aZl_f
ZlZdh\Ze f_gyHg ^_ckl\bl_evghZlZdh\Ze f_gyih^h[gh [udm
b k\hbfb ]b]Zglkdbfb djuevyfbhg aZfZoZem fhbo ]eZaY
aZdjbqZe k[hevxZ aZl_f\ae_l_ebebkdhj__ihqm\kl\h
\Zeqlh y [jhkbeky\\_jo bijhr_eiZjyaZ kljZ`ZaZ
`_elh\Zlh_ ieZlh \^jm]hc fbj\ fbjex^_cb y h[gZjm`be
k_[y klhysbfihkj_^b dhfgZlu^hgZ OmZgZ
yg\Zjy ]h^Z
Y ^_ckl\bl_evgh^mfZeqlh yh^he_e kljZ`ZkdZaZe
y ^hgmOmZgm
Lu^he`gh [ulvhrb[Z_rvkykdZaZe hg
>hg OmZgg_ ]h\hjbegb h^gh]hkeh\Z fg_k ijhreh]h^gy
b yg_ ihgbfZewlh]hY [ueih]jm`_g \jh^ f_qlZl_evghklby
kgh\Z ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh _keb[u ykfhlj_e \gbfZl_evghlh y
[ue [u kihkh[_g\b^_lvGh g_\b^_e gbq_]h hkh[_ggh]h
FheqZgb_h^gZdhqj_a\uqZcgh jZkkeZ[eyehf_gy
>hg OmZgihijhkbe jZkkdZaZlvihjy^hd fh_]hi_j_`b\Zgby
b lhqlh hkh[_gghbgl_j_kh\Zeh _]hwlh p\_ldhlhjuc y
\b^_e gZ kibg_kljZ`Z>hg OmZg\a^hogme bdZaZehkv[ue
^_ckl\bl_evgh haZ[hq_g
L_[_ ih\_aehqlh gZkibg_ kljZ`Z[ue p\_lkdZaZe
hg kk_jv_aguf ebphf[m^v hggZ i_j_^g_cqZklb _]h l_eZ
beb_s_ om`_gZ _]h]heh\_lu [ue[u f_jl\l_i_jvLu g_
^he`_g iulZlvky \b ^_ lv
kljZ`Zdh]^Zeb[h kgh\ZG_
^ey l\h_]hl_fi_jZf_glZ ijhoh^blvwlm iehkdhklvh^gZdhy
m[_`^_gqlh lufh] ijhclbq_j_a g__Gh g_[m^_f ]h\hjblv
h[ wlhf[hevr_Wlh [uelhevdh h^bgba \hafh`guoiml_c
Y h[gZjm`beg_h[uqgmx ly`_klv\ lhg_^hgZ OmZgZ
Qlh kemqblky kh fghc_keb y ihiulZxkv
m\ b
^ _l v
kljZ`Zkgh\Z"
KljZ` m^Zebll_[ykdZaZe hgHg \havf_ll_[y \
k\hc jhl b mg_k_l l_[y\ lhlieZg b hklZ\bl l_[y lZf
gZ\k_]^ZHq_\b^ghqlh kljZ`agZeqlh wlhg_ ^ey l\h_]h
l_fi_jZf_glZb ij_^mij_^bel_[y g_y\eylvky
DZdlu ^mfZ_rvkljZ` magZewlh"
>hg OmZg ihkfhlj_e
gZ
f_gy
^he]bfijbklZevguf
\a]ey^hfHg iulZekykdZaZlv qlhlhgh hldZaZekydZd [m^lh
hg g_fh] gZclbijZ\bevguo keh\
Y \k_]^Z iZ^Zx hll\hbo \hijhkh\kdZaZe hg
meu[Zykvlu ^_ckl\bl_evghg_ ^mfZ_rvdh]^Z kijZrb\Z_rv
f_gy wlhlZd"
Y ijhl_klh\Zeb \gh\vih^l\_j^beqlh yhaZ^Zq_g l_f
qlh kljZ`agZe fhcl_fi_jZf_gl
>hg OmZg bf_e g_h[uqguc [e_kd\ ]eZaZodh]^Z hg
]h\hjbe
B lu^Z`_ gbq_]hg_ mihfygmeh k\h_f l_fi_jZf_gl_
kljZ`m"
?]h lhg [uegZklhevdh dhfbq_kdbk_jv_a_gqlh fu h[Z
jZkkf_yebkvIhke_ wlh]hh^gZdhhg kdZaZeqlh kljZ`
[m^mqb ojZgbl_e_fdZjZmevguf
lh]h
fbjZagZe fgh]h
k_dj_lh\dhlhjufb [jmohbf_e ijZ\h^_eblvky
Wlh h^bgimlv [jmoh \b ^_ lv kdZaZe hg
Gh wlhg_ [m^_ll\h_c h[eZklvxihwlhfm g_lkfukeZ ]h\hjblv
h[ wlhf
Dmj_gb_ _^bgkl\_gguc kihkh[ \b ^_ lv
kljZ`Z"
kijhkbe y
G_lLu fh`_rvlZd`_ \b ^_ lv
_]hb [_awlh]h
?klv fgh`_kl\h ex^_cdhlhju_
fh]ml
^_eZlv
wlhY
ij_^ihqblZx dmjblvihlhfm qlh wlh [he__ wnn_dlb\gh b
gZbf_g__ hiZkgh ^eyf_gy?keb luiulZ_rvky
\b ^_ lv
kljZ`Z [_aihfhsb dmj_gby_klv \hafh`ghklvqlh lu fh`_rv
aZ^_j`Zlvky \ \uoh^_ ba wlh]h
imlb< l\h_f kemqZ_
gZijbf_jhq_\b^ghqlh kljZ`ij_^mij_^be l_[ydh]^Z hg
ih\_jgmeky k\h_ckibghc lZdqlh[u lufh] \b^_lv\jZ`^_[guc
p\_lAZl_f hgme_l_eghdh]^Z hgijbe_l_e gZaZ^lu [ue
_s_ lZfihwlhfm hg gZiZe
gZ
l_[yH^gZdhlu [ue
ih^]hlh\e_g biju]gme>ufhd ^Zel_[_ aZsblm\ dhlhjhc lu
gm`^Zeky_keb [ulu ihr_e\ lhlfbj [_a_]h ihfhsblu g_
kfh] [uba[Z\blvky hlko\Zlu\Zgby kljZ`_f
Ihq_fm g_kfh] [u"
L\hb ^\b`_gby [ueb[u kebrdhf f_^e_ggufbQlh[u
mp_e_lv \ lhffbj_lu ^he`_g[ulv lZdbf`_ [ukljufdZd
fhegbyWlh [uehfh_c hrb[dhcmclb badhfgZlugh yg_ ohqm
l_[_ ]h\hjblvgbq_]h [hevr_Lu [helmgihwlhfm lu]h\hjbrv
^Z`_ ijhlb\k\h_]h `_eZgby;m^v ylZf klh[hcy [uhlhj\Ze
l\hx ]heh\mLu \uiju]gmekZfqlh [ueh^Z`_ emqr_h^gZdh
ykdhj__g_ jbkdh\Ze[u lZdkljZ` wlh g_qlhgb[m^vk
q_f [ulu fh]aZ[Z\eylvky
=eZ\Z
^_ \y lZ y
< l_q_gb_lj_o f_kyp_\^hg OmZgkbkl_fZlbq_kdb ba[_]Ze
jZa]h\hjZ hkljZ`_Y ihk_lbe_]h q_luj_jZaZ \l_q_gb_ wlbo
f_kyp_\hg \h\e_dZe f_gy\ l_dmsb_ ihjmq_gby ^ey g_]h
dZ`^uc jZab dh]^Zy \uihegyeihjmq_gbyhg ijhklh \_e_e
fg_ m_a`Zlv^hfhcZij_ey ]h^Zdh]^Z y\ q_l\_jluc
jZa [ue\ _]h^hf_ygZdhg_paZ]h\hjbe kgbf ihke_lh]h
dZd fu ih_ebb kb^_eb\hae_ _]h]ebgyghc i_qdbY kdZaZe
_fmqlh hg^_eZe qlhlh g_khhl\_lkl\_ggh_fg_y [ue]hlh\
mqblvkybl_f g_f_g__hg ^Z`_g_ ohl_ef_gy \_jgmlvY
^he`_g [ue hq_gvkbevgh gZijy]Zlvkyqlh[u ih[hjhlv k\h_
hl\jZs_gb_ d bkihevah\Zgbx ]Zeexpbgh]_gguo ]jb[h\b y
qm\kl\h\ZedZd hgkZf kdZaZeqlh yg_ ^he`_gl_jylv \j_fy
>hg OmZgy\gh kemrZefhb `Zeh[u
Lu _s_keZ[kdZaZe hglu lhjhibrvkydh]^Z lu
^he`_g `^Zlvgh lu`^_rvdh]^Z lu^he`_g lhjhiblvkyLu
kebrdhf fgh]h^mfZ_rvL_i_jv lu^mfZ_rvqlh g_evayl_jylv
\j_fyG_^Z\gh lu ^mfZeqlh lug_ ohl_e dmjblv gbq_]h
[hevr_L\hy `bagvlZdZy `_ijhdeylZy g_hij_^_e_gghklvlu
g_^hklZlhqgh iehl_gqlh[u \klj_lblvkyk ^ufdhfY hl\_qZx
aZ l_[yb yg_ ohqmqlh[u lumf_jih^h[gh ijhdeylhfm
^mjZdm
Y ihqm\kl\h\Zekfms_gb_
Qlh y fh]m k^_eZlv^hg OmZg"M f_gy [hevrh_
g_l_ji_gb_
@b\bdZd \hbgY ]h\hjbel_[_ m`_qlh \hbg [_j_l
hl\_lkl\_gghklv aZ k\hb^_ckl\byaZ kZfu_ljb\bZevgu_ ba
k\hbo ^_ckl\bcLu ijhy\ey_rvk\hb fukebb wlhg_ijZ\bevgh
Lu ihl_ji_eg_m^Zqm khkljZ`_f baaZ k\hbofuke_c
DZd yihl_ji_e g_m^Zqm^hg OmZg"
Lu ^mfZ_rvh[h \k_fLu ^mfZeh kljZ`_b ihwlhfmlu
g_ kfh]ih[_^blv _]h< i_j\mxhq_j_^vlu ^he`_g`blvdZd
\hbgY ^mfZxqlh luihgye wlhhq_gv ohjhrh
Y ohl_e \klZ\blv qlhgb[m^v \k\hx aZsblmgh hg
ihdZaZe `_klhfqlh[u yfheqZe
L\hy `bagv ^h\hevgh ljm^gZijh^he`Ze hg
NZdlbq_kdbl\hy `bagvljm^g__q_f mq_gbdh\O_gZjh IZ[eblh
beb G_klhjZb \k_ `_hgb \b^ylZ lu g_lL\hy `bagv
ljm^g__q_f mWebobhZ hg\_jhylghm \b ^b l
jZgvr_
l_[yWlh jZkkljZb\Z_lf_gy>Z`_ O_gZjhg_ fh`_l i_j_`blv
wlh]hLu q_klgh\uihegbe \k_qlh y]h\hjbe l_[_ ^_eZlv
<k_q_fm fhc [_g_nZdlhjgZmqbe f_gy gZ i_j\hc klmi_gb
h[_q_gbyy i_j_^Zel_[_IjZ\beh \_jgh_rZ]b g_fh]ml [ulv
baf_g_guLu k^_eZe\k_qlh gm`gh[ueh k^_eZlvb \k_`_ lu
g_
\b ^b rv gh l_fdlh
\b ^b lih^h[gh
O_gZjhdZ`_lky[m^lh lu \b ^b rv Y iheZ]Zxkv gZ
wlhb yh[fZgu\ZxkvLu \_jlbrvky\hdjm] b\_^_rv k_[ydZd
b^bhldhlhjuc g_
\b ^b lqlhdhg_qghy\ey_lky
ijZ\bevguf ^eyl_[y
Keh\Z ^hgZOmZgZ ijbqbgbebfg_ ]em[hdh_kljZ^Zgb_Y g_
agZxihq_fmgh y[ue [ebadhd ke_aZfY gZqZejZkkdZau\Zlv
h k\h_f^_lkl\_b \hegZ`Zehklb dk_[_ ho\ZlbeZf_gy>hg
OmZg ijbklZevghihkfhlj_e gZf_gy gZk_dmg^m bhl\_e ]eZaZ
< gbo [ue ijhgabl_evguc [e_kdY ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh hg
aZo\Zlbe f_gyk\hbfb ]eZaZfbM f_gy[ueh hsms_gb_qlh ^\_
jmdb eZkdh\h k`Zebf_gyb yhsmlbe g_ihgylgh_ \heg_gb_
g_l_ji_eb\h_ `_eZgb_ijbylgh_ hlqZygb_\ h[eZklb fh_]h
kheg_qgh]h kie_l_gbyY klZekhagZ\Zlv k\hx[jxrgmx h[eZklv
Y hsmlbe lZf `ZjY g_fh] ]h\hjblv k\yagh [hevr_ b
aZ[hjfhlZeaZl_f yi_j_klZe ]h\hjblvkh\k_f
<hafh`ghwlh h[_sZgb_kdZaZe ^hg OmZg ihke_
^he]hc iZmau
Ba\bgbl_
H[_sZgb_dhlhjh_ lu^Ze h^gZ`^u^Z\guf ^Z\gh
DZdh_ h[_sZgb_"
Lufh`_l [ulvfh`_rv kdZaZlvfg_ wlhLu ihfgbrv
wlhg_l"
G_l
Lu h[_sZeqlhlh hq_gv\Z`gh_ h^gZ`^uY ^mfZeqlh
fh`_l [ulvlu h[_sZehojZgylv k_[yhl \b ^_ gb y
Y g_agZxh q_flu ]h\hjbrv
Y ]h\hjx h[h[_sZgbbdhlhjh_ lu ^ZeLu ^he`_g
ihfgblv _]h
?keb lu agZ_rvqlh [uehh[_sZgb_ihq_fm lu g_
kdZ`_rv fg_^hg OmZg"
G_lG_ [m^_lgbdZdhc ihevaukdZaZlv l_[_wlh
;ueh ebwlh h[_sZgb_fdhlhjh_ yk^_eZe k_[_"
GZ f]gh\_gb_y ih^mfZeqlh hgfh`_l [ulvkkueZ_lky
gZ fh_j_r_gb_ hklZ\blvmq_gbq_kl\h
G_lWlh qlhlhqlh bf_ehf_klh hq_gv ^Z\gh
kdZaZe hg
Y aZkf_yekyihlhfm qlhy [uem\_j_gqlh ^hg OmZg
b]jZ_l kh fghcdZdmxlh b]jmY ihqm\kl\h\Ze hahjkl\hM
f_gy [uehhsms_gb_ ijbih^gylh]hgZkljh_gby ijbfukebqlh y
fh]m ^mjZqblv^hgZ OmZgZdhlhjucdZd y[ue m[_`^_gagZe
lZd `_ fZehdZd byh ih^haj_\Z_fhf h[_sZgbbY [ue
m\_j_gqlh hgeh\be ju[m\ l_fghl_b iulZeky bfijh\babjh
\ZlvFukev ihlZdZlv_fm ^hklZ\eyeZfg_ m^h\hevkl\b_
;ueh ebhgh q_flhqlh yh[_sZe fh_fm^_^mrd_"
G_lkdZaZe hgb ]eZaZ_]h aZ[e_kl_ebLZd`_ g_
lhqlh luh[_sZe k\h_c[Z[mrd_
Kf_rgZy bglhgZpbydhlhjmx hgijb^Ze keh\m [Z[mrdZ
aZklZ\beZ f_gy aZkf_ylvkyY ih^mfZeqlh ^hgOmZg klZ\be
fg_ eh\mrdmgh y ohl_eb]jZlv b]jm^h dhgpZY gZqZe
i_j_qbkeylv \k_o \hafh`guo ex^_cdhfm yfh] [u h[_sZlv
qlhgb[m^v hq_gv \Z`gh_H dZ`^hfhg kdZaZeg_lAZl_f hg
i_j_\_e jZa]h\hjd fh_fm^_lkl\m
Ihq_fm l\h_^_lkl\h [uehi_qZevguf"kijhkbe hg k
k_jv_aguf \ujZ`_gb_f
Y kdZaZe_fmqlh fh_^_lkl\h \^_ckl\bl_evghklb [ueh
g_ i_qZevgufghfh`_l [ulvg_fgh]h ljm^guf
DZ`^h_ hsms_gb_wlh imlvkdZaZe hgihkfhlj_\ gZ
f_gy kgh\Zy lZd`_[ue hq_gvg_kqZkleb\ b[hyaeb\dh]^Z
y [ue j_[_gdhfLjm^gh [ulv bg^_ckdbf j_[_gdhfhq_gv
ljm^ghGh iZfylvh lhf\j_f_gb g_bf__l [hevr_agZq_gby ^ey
f_gyjZgvr_ [uehljm^ghY i_j_klZe^mfZlv hljm^ghklb fh_c
`bagb dZdjZa i_j_^l_fdZd ygZmqbeky \b ^_ lv Y lZd`_g_ ^mfZxh k\h_f^_lkl\_kdZaZe y
Lh]^Z ihq_fmwlh ^_eZ_ll_[y i_qZevguf"Ihq_fm lu
ohq_rv ieZdZlv"
Y g_ agZx<hafh`ghdh]^y y^mfZx hk_[_dZd h
j_[_gd_y qm\kl\mx`Zehklv dk_[_ bdh \k_f[ebadbf ex^yf
Y qm\kl\mxk_[y [_kihfhsgufb i_qZevguf
Hg ijbklZevgh ihkfhlj_e gZf_gyb kgh\Z \ h[eZklb
`b\hlZ y hlf_lbeg_h[uqZcgh_ hsms_gb_^\mo jmdk`bfZxsbo
_]hY hl\_ek\hb ]eZaZZ aZl_f[ukljh \a]eygmegZaZ^ gZ
g_]hHg kfhlj_e\ ijhkljZgkl\hfbfh f_gy_]h ]eZaZ [ueb
aZlmfZg_gu[_a nhdmkZ
Wlh [uehh[_sZgb_f l\h_]h^_lkl\ZkdZaZe hgihke_
dhjhldh]h fheqZgby
Qlh yh[_sZe"
Hg g_ hl\_qZe?]h ]eZaZ[ueb aZdjuluY g_\hevgh
meu[gmekyy agZeqlh hgqm\kl\h\Ze k\hcimlv \ l_fghl_
h^gZdhy g_kdhevdhihl_jye k\h_i_j\hgZqZevgh_ klj_fe_gb_
rmlblv kgbf
Y [uelhsbf j_[_gdhfijh^he`Ze hgb y \k_]^Z
[hyeky
LZdbf `_[ue ykdZaZe y
Lhqlh yihfgx [hevr_\k_]hwlh m`Zk b i_qZev
dhlhju_ yqm\kl\h\Zedh]^Z f_dkbdZgkdb_khe^Zlu m[beb fhx
fZlvkdZaZe hg lbohdZd [m^lh_]h iZfylv [ueZ _s_
fmqbl_evghchgZ [ueZ[_^ghc bihdhjghc bg^bZgdhcFh`_l
[ulvwlh [uehemqr_qlh __`bagv [ueZdhgq_gZ lh]^ZY
ohl_e [ulv m[bluf kg_cihlhfm qlhy [ue j_[_gdhfGh
khe^Zlu ihcfZebb ba[bebf_gyDh]^Z y[jhkbeky gZl_eh fh_c
fZl_jbhgb m^Zjbebf_gy ihjmdZf oeuklhfb jZa[bebiZevpu
Y g_qm\kl\h\Ze gbdZdhc[hebgh yg_ fh]o\ZlZlv [hevr_Z
aZl_f hgbhllZsbeb f_gy
Hg i_j_klZe]h\hjblv?]h ]eZaZ[ueb _s_aZdjulub y
fh] h[gZjm`blvhq_gv g_aZf_lgh_^jh`Zgb_ _]h]m[=em[hdZy
i_qZev gZqZeZ ho\Zlu\Zlvf_gyDZjlbgu fh_]h kh[kl\_ggh]h
^_lkl\Z gZoeugmebgZ f_gy
Kdhevdh e_l[ueh l_[_^hg OmZg"kijhkbe yijhklh
qlh[u \haf_klblvi_qZev \hfg_
Fh`_l [ulvk_fvWlh [ueh\j_fy \_ebdbo\hcg ydb
F_dkbdZgkdb_ khe^Zlu gZiZebgZ gZkg_h`b^Zgghdh]^Z fhy
fZlv ]hlh\beZibsmHgZ [ueZ[_kihfhsghc `_gsbghcHgb m[beb
__ [_ah\kydh]h ih\h^ZG_ [uehgbdZdhc jZagbpu\ lhfqlh
hgZ mf_jeZ lZdb ^_ckl\bl_evghg_lbl_f g_f_g__^ey
f_gy hgZ_klvY g_fh]m kdZaZlvk_[_ihq_fmh^gZdhhgZ
ijhklh _klvY ^mfZeqlh hgbm[beb fh_]hhlpZ lZd`_gh wlh
[ueh g_lZdHg [uejZg_gIha`_ hgbihkZ^beb gZk\ ih_a^
ih^h[gh kdhlmb aZdjueb^\_jvG_kdhevdh ^g_chgb ^_j`Zeb
gZk lZf \ l_fghl_dZd `b\hlguoHgb ^_j`Zeb gZk `b\ufb
dmkdZfb ibsbdhlhju_ hgb[jhkZeb \j_fyhl \j_f_gb\ \Z]hg
Fhc hl_pmf_j hljZg \wlhf \Z]hg_Hg klZe[j_^blv hl
[heb b ebohjZ^dbb ijh^he`Ze]h\hjblv fg_qlh y ^he`_g
\u`blvHg ijh^he`Ze]h\hjblv fg_wlh ^hkZfh]h ihke_^g_]h
fhf_glZ k\h_c`bagb
Ex^b ihaZ[hlbebkvh[h fg_hgb gZdhjfbebf_gyklZjZy
`_gsbgZ agZoZjdZkdj_ibeZ kehfZggu_dhklb fh_cjmdbBdZd
lu \b^brvy `b\@bagv [ueZgb ohjhr_cgb iehohc^ey f_gy
`bagv [ueZljm^ghc@bagv ljm^gZb ^eyj_[_gdZ hgZ bgh]^Z
kZf m`Zk
Fu hq_gv^he]h fheqZeb<hafh`ghqZk ijhr_e\ iheghc
lbrbg_M f_gy[ueb hq_gvkimlZggu_ qm\kl\ZY [ueg_kdhevdh
m^jmq_gghh^gZdhy g_fh] kdZaZlvihq_fmY i_j_`b\Ze
qm\kl\h m]jua_gbykh\_klbI_j_^ wlbfy ohl_eihlZdZlv ^hgm
OmZgmgh hg\g_aZigh ihf_gyekyjheyfb d_]h ijyfhc\u]h^_
Wlh [uehijhklh b\ujZabl_evgh bijhba\_eh \hfg_ g_h[uqgh_
qm\kl\hFukev hj_[_gd_bkiulu\Zxs_f [hev\k_]^Z [ueZ
ih\ur_ggh qm\kl\bl_evgufij_^f_lhf ^eyf_gy< f]gh\_gb_fhb
qm\kl\Z ijhgbdgh\_gby d^hgm OmZgmhldjueb imlv hsms_gbx
hl\jZs_gby dk_[_Y ^_ckl\bl_evghijbgyedZd [m^lh `bagv
^hgZ OmZgZ[ueZ ijhklhdebgbq_kdbf kemqZ_fY [uegZ ]jZgb
\kdjulby fhboaZf_lhddh]^Z ^hgOmZg ldgmef_gy iZevp_f \
bdjm gh]bqlh[u ijb\e_qvfh_ \gbfZgb_Hg kdZaZeqlh hg
\b^_ek\_l gZkbeby \hdjm]f_gyb ihbgl_j_kh\Zekyg_
kh[bjZxkv eb y gZqZlv[blv _]h?]h kf_o \hkoblbl_evgh
ij_j\ZekyHg kdZaZeqlh y ih^^Z\Zeky \kiurdZf gZkb
evkl\_ggh]h ih\_^_gbygh qlh\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklby g_[ue
iehobf bqlh ^he]h_\j_fy gZkbeb_[ueh ijhlb\f_gy kZfh]h
Lu ijZ\^hg OmZgkdZaZe y
Dhg_qghkdZaZe hgkf_ykv
Hg m[_^be f_gy jZkkdZaZlvh k\h_f^_lkl\_Y gZqZe
jZkkdZau\Zlv _fmh k\hbo]h^Zo kljZoZb h^bghq_kl\Zm\e_dky
hibkZgb_f lh]hqlhy ^mfZe[ueh fh_cihljykZxs_c [hjv[hc
qlh[u \u`blv b ml\_j^blv k\hc ^moHg jZkkf_yeky ijb
f_lZnhj_ h[ml\_j`^_gbb fh_]h^moZ
Y jZkkdZau\Ze^he]hHg kemrZek k_jv_aguf\ujZ`_gb_f
AZl_f\ h^bgfhf_gl _]h]eZaZ ijb`Zebf_gy kgh\Zb y
i_j_klZe ]h\hjblvIhke_ k_dmg^ghciZmau hg kdZaZeqlh
gbdlh gbdh]^Zg_ mgb`Zef_gy bqlh [ueZijbqbgZ lh]hqlh y
g_ [ue\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbiehobf
Lu g_ihl_ji_e ihjZ`_gby\k_ `_kdZaZe hg
Hg ih\lhjbeml\_j`^_gb_ q_luj_beb iylvjZaihwlhfm
y ihqm\kl\h\Ze
g_h[oh^bfhklv
kijhkblv
_]hqlh
hg
ih^jZamf_\Ze ih^wlbfHg h[tykgbeqlh ihl_ji_lvihjZ`_gb_
[ueh mkeh\b_f `bagbdhlhjh_ [ueh g_ba[_`gufEx^b beb
ih[_`^Zebbeb l_ji_ebihjZ`_gb_b\ aZ\bkbfhklbhl wlh]h
hgb klZgh\bebkv ij_ke_^h\Zl_eyfb beb `_jl\ZfbWlb ^\Z
mkeh\by ij_h[eZ^ZebihdZ q_eh\_dg_ gZqbgZe \b ^_ lv \ b^ _g b_
jZkk_b\Zeh beexabxih[_^uihjZ`_gby beb
kljZ^ZgbyHg ^h[Z\beqlh ygZmqmkv \b ^_ lv dh]^Z
y h^_j`mih[_^m gZ^iZfylvx mgb`_ggh]hkms_kl\Z
Y aZijhl_klh\Zeqlh y g_ [ue b gbdh]^Z g_ [ue
ih[_^bl_e_f \ q_fgb[m^vb qlhfhy `bagv [ueZih`Zemc
ihjZ`_gb_f
Hg aZkf_yekyb [jhkbek\hx reyimgZ ihe
?keb l\hy`bagv y\ey_lkylZdbf ihjZ`_gb_fgZklmib gZ
fhx reyim\ua\Ze hgf_gy \rmldm
Y qbklhk_j^_qgh
^hdZau\Ze
k\h_>hg
OmZg klZe
k_jv_aguf?]h ]eZaZkmabebkv ^hlhgdbo s_ehdHg kdZaZe
qlh y ^mfZeqlh fhy`bagv [ueZ ihjZ`_gb_fih ^jm]bf
ijbqbgZfg_`_eb kZfh
ihjZ`_gb_AZl_f
hg [ukljh b
kh\_jr_ggh g_h`b^Zggh \ayefhx ]heh\m\ k\hb jmdbaZ`Z\
eZ^hgyfb fhb \bkdb?]h ]eZaZklZeb kbevgufbdh]^Z hg
\a]eygme \f_gy;_a bkim]Zy k^_eZe]em[hdbc \^hojlhfHg
iha\hebe fh_c ]heh\_hldbgmlvky ijhlb\ kl_guijbklZevgh
]ey^y gZf_gyHg \uihegbek\hb ^\b`_gbyk lZdhckdhjhklvx
qlh g_dhlhjh_\j_fyihdZ hgg_ hkeZ[beb g_hldbgme m^h[gh
ijhlb\ kl_guy [ue_s_ gZk_j_^bg_ ]em[hdh]h \^hoZY
ihqm\kl\h\Ze ]heh\hdjm`_gb_g_eh\dhklv
Y \b `m
fZe_gvdh]hfZevqbdZkdZaZe ^hg OmZg
ihke_ iZmau
Hg ih\lhjbewlh g_kdhevdhjZadZd [m^lhy g_ihgbfZe
M f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hqlh hg]h\hjbe h[hfg_dZd hfZe_gvdhf
djbqZs_f fZevqbd_ihwlhfm yg_ h[jZlbe ^_ckl\bl_evgh]h
\gbfZgby gZwlh
WckdZaZe hglj_[my fh_]hihegh]h \gbfZgbyy
\ b` m
fZe_gvdh]hdjbqZs_]h fZevqbdZ
Y kijhkbe _]h[ue ebwlhl fZevqbdfghcHg kdZaZe
g_lLh]^Z ykijhkbe _]h[ueh ebwlh \b^_gb_fh_c `bagbbeb
ijhklh iZfylvxba _]hkhkl\_gghc `bagbHg g_hl\_lbe
Y \b `m
fZe_gvdh]hfZevqbdZijh^he`Ze hg
hg djbqblb djbqbl
Y agZxwlh]h fZevqbdZ"kijhkbe y
>Z
Hg fhcfZe_gvdbc fZevqbd"
G_l
Hg djbqbll_i_jv"
Hg djbqbll_i_jvkdZaZe hgk m\_j_gghklvx
Y ih^mfZeqlh ^hgOmZg \b^_edh]hlhdh]h yagZedlh
[ue fZe_gvdbffZevqbdhf bdlh \wlhl kZfucfhf_gl djbqZeY
gZa\Ze ihbf_gZf \k_o^_l_cdhlhjuo yagZegh hg kdZaZe
qlh l_^_lb g_bf_eb hlghr_gbyd fh_fmh[_sZgbxZ j_[_ghd
dhlhjuc djbqZebf_e hq_gv[hevrh_ hlghr_gb_d g_fm
Ml\_j`^_gb_ ^hgZOmZgZ dZaZehkvg_e_iufHg kdZaZeqlh
y h[_sZe qlhlh dhfmlh \fh_f ^_lkl\_ b qlh j_[_ghd
dhlhjuc djbqZe\ wlhlkZfuc fhf_glbf_e [hevrh_hlghr_gb_ d
fh_fm h[_sZgbxY ]h\hjbe_fmqlh \wlhf g_l kfukeZHg
kihdhcgh ih\lhjyeqlh hg \b^_efZe_gvdh]h fZevqbdZ
djbqZs_]h \ wlhl fhf_glb qlhfZe_gvdhfm fZevqbdm [ueh
[hevgh
Y klZjZekyih^h]gZlv _]hml\_j`^_gby ih^ dZdhcgb[m^v
\b^ ijZ\bevgh]h h[jZaZgh yg_ fh]mklZgh\blv bok\yav k
q_fgb[m^vqlh ykhagZ\Ze
Y hldZau\ZxkvkdZaZe yihlhfm qlhy g_ ihfgx
qlh y ^Z\Ze \Z`gh_ h[_sZgb_ dhfmgb[m^vf_gvr_ \k_]h
j_[_gdm
Hg ijbsmjbe ]eZaZkgh\Z bkdZaZeqlh wlhl hkh[_gguc
j_[_ghddhlhjuc djbqZelhqgh \wlhl fhf_gl[ue j_[_ghd
fh_]h ^_lkl\Z
Hg [uej_[_ghd \h\j_fy fh_]h^_lkl\Zb hgl_f g_
f_g__djbqbl l_i_jv"kijhkbe y
Hg j_[_ghddhlhjuc djbqbll_i_jvgZklZb\Ze hg
Lu ihgbfZ_rvqlh lu]h\hjbrv^hg OmZg"
IhgbfZx
Wlh g_ bf__lkfukeZDZd fh`_l hg [ulv j_[_gdhf
l_i_jv_keb hg[ue j_[_gdhfdh]^Z ykZf [uej_[_gdhf"
Wlh j_[_ghdb hgdjbqbl l_i_jvkdZaZe hgmihjgh
H[tykgb wlhfg_^hg OmZg
G_lL u
^he`_gh[tykgblv wlhfg_
Ohlv m[_cy g_fh] ihgylvlh]hh q_fhg ]h\hjbe
Hg djbqblHg djbqbl^hg OmZgijh^he`Ze ]h\hjblv\
]bighlbabjmxs_f lhg_B hg^_j`bl l_[yl_i_jvHg dj_idh
k`bfZ_lHg h[gbfZ_lHg kfhljblgZ l_[yLu qm\kl\m_rv_]h
]eZaZ"Hg klZgh\blkygZ dhe_gbb h[gbfZ_ll_[yHg fheh`_
l_[yHg ih^[_]Z_l d l_[_Gh _]h jmdZ kehfZgZLu
qm\kl\m_rv _]h jmdm"M
wlh]h fZe_gvdh]h fZevqbdZ ghk
\u]ey^bl ih^h[ghim]h\bp_>ZWlh ghkim]h\bp_c
< fhbo mrZo ihy\beky ]meb y ihl_jye hsms_gb_
kms_kl\h\Zgby ^hfZ^hgZ OmZgZKeh\Z ghk im]h\bp_c[jhkbeb
f_gy kjZam \ kp_gmba fh_]h^_lkl\ZY agZe fZevqbdZ k
ghkhfim]h\bp_c>hg OmZgg_aZf_lgh ijh^\bgmek\hc imlv \
h^gh bagZb[he__ l_fguof_kl fh_c`bagbY agZeh[_sZgb_h
dhlhjhf hg ]h\hjbeM f_gy [ueh hsms_gb_ ijbih^gylh]h
gZkljh_gbyhlqZygby[eZ]h]h\_gby i_j_^^hghf OmZghfb _]h
\_ebdhe_iguf fZg_\jhfDZdq_jl \havfbhg agZ_lh fZevqbd_
k ghkhfim]h\dhc bafh_]h ^_lkl\Z"Y klZe lZd \a\hegh\Zg
\hkihfbgZgb_fdhlhjh_ ^hgOmZg \ua\Ze\h fg_qlh fhykbeZ
\kihfgblv i_j_g_keZ f_gygZaZ^ dh\j_f_gbdh]^Z fg_ [ueh
\hk_fv e_lFhy fZlvhklZ\beZ f_gy^\Z ]h^Z gZaZ^b y
ijh\h^be gZb[he__Z^kdb_ ]h^ufh_c `bagbpbjdmebjmy kj_^b
k_kl_j fh_c fZl_jbdhlhju_
kem`beb bkihegyxsbfb ^he]
aZf_klbl_e_c fZl_jb b aZ[hlbebkv h[h fg_ iZjm f_kyp_\
h^gh\j_f_gghM dZ`^hcba fhbol_lhd [ueZ[hevrZy k_fvyb
[_ajZaebqghdZd aZ[hleb\ubeb ihdjh\bl_evkl\_ggu[ueb l_ldb
dh fg_kh fghckhi_jgbqZeb ^\Z^pZlv^\Z jh^kl\_ggbdZBo
[_kk_j^_qghklv [u\ZeZ bgh]^Z
^_ckl\bl_evgh kljZgghcY
qm\kl\h\Ze lh]^Zqlh f_gyhdjm`Zeb \jZ]bb \ ihke_^mxsb_
fmqbl_evgu_ ]h^u y mr_e \ hlqZyggmx b ]jyagmx \hcgm
GZdhg_pihkj_^kl\hf kihkh[h\dhlhju_ y\k_ _s_g_ agZx^h
wlh]h ^gyy ^h[bekymki_oZ \ihdhj_gbb \k_ofhbo ^\hxjh^guo
jh^kl\_ggbdh\Y ^_ckl\bl_evgh[ue ih[_^bl_e_fY g_ bf_e
[hevr_ khi_jgbdh\dhlhju_ [ubf_eb agZq_gb_H^gZdhy g_
agZe wlh]hb g_agZedZd hklZgh\blvfhx \hcgmdhlhjZy
jZkijhkljZgbeZkv gZrdhevgmx ihq\m
DeZkku k_evkdhcrdheudm^Z yoh^be[ueb kf_rZggufbb
i_j\uc b lj_lbcdeZkku [uebjZa^_e_gu lhevdh jZkklhygb_f
f_`^m iZjlZfbWlh lZfy \klj_lbefZe_gvdh]h fZevqbdZ k
iehkdbf ghkhfdhlhjh]h ^jZagbebijha\bs_f im]h\bqguc ghk
Hg [ue
i_j\hdeZkkgbdY
\u[jZe
_]h
kemqZcgh[_a
ki_pbZevgh]h gZf_j_gbyGh
hgdZaZehkvex[be f_gy
g_kfhljy gZ \k_qlh y^_eZe _fmHg ijb\ud ke_^h\Zlv aZ
fghc ih\kx^mb ^Z`_ojZgbe lZcgmqlh y[ue hl\_lkl\_g_gaZ
^hkdmdhlhjZy ihklZ\beZ\ lmibd^bj_dlhjZB h^gZdhy \k_
`_ ^jZagbe_]hH^gZ`^u ygZjhqgh hijhdbgmeklhy\rmx ly`_emx
deZkkgmx ^hkdmhgZ miZeZgZ g_]hiZjlZaZ dhlhjhc hg
kb^_ekfy]qbeZ m^Zjgh \k_`_ m^ZjkehfZe _fmdexqbpmHg
miZeY ihfh]_fm \klZlvb m\b^_e[hev bbkim] \_]h ]eZaZo
dh]^Z hgkfhlj_e gZf_gy b^_j`Zeky aZf_gyM^Zj ijb \b^_
_]h [hebb bkdZe_q_gghcjmdb [ue[hevr_q_f yfh] \ug_klb
=h^u y m`Zkgh [hjheky ijhlb\ fhbo jh^kl\_ggbdh\b y
ih[_^bey ihdhjbek\hbo \jZ]h\y [uekbevguf \lhl fhf_gl
dh]^Z \b^ djbqZs_]hfZe_gvdh]h fZevqbdZ k ghkhfim]h\dhc
jZajmrbe fhbih[_^uIjyfh lZfy hklZ\be[bl\mEx[uf iml_f
gZ dZdhc y [uekihkh[_gy j_rbe g_ \h_\Zlv dh]^Zeb[h
kgh\ZY ih^mfZeqlh _fmfh`_l [ulvhlj_`ml jmdmb y
h[_sZeqlh _keb fZe_gvdbcfZevqbd \ue_qblkyy gbdh]^Z
[hevr_ g_[m^m ih[_^bl_e_fY hl^Zek\hb ih[_^u_fmWlh [ue
imlvb yihgye wlhlh]^Z
>hg OmZg hldjue ]ghysmxky jZgm
\ fh_c `bagbY
ihqm\kl\h\Ze
]heh\hdjm`_gb_[ue
ihljyk_gBklhqgbd
g_hkeZ[e_gghc i_qZebaZkljmbeky \hfg_y [ueih[_`^_g bfY
qm\kl\h\Ze ly`_klvk\hbo ^_ckl\bcgZ k_[_<hkihfbgZgb_ h[
wlhf fZe_gvdhf dmjghkhf fZevqbd_qv_ bfy [ueh OhZdbg
ijhba\_eh gZf_gy lZdmxy\gmx [hevqlh yaZieZdZeY kdZaZe
^hgm OmZgm h fh_ci_qZeb baaZ wlh]h fZevqbdZdhlhjuc
gbdh]^Z g_ bf_e gbq_]hwlhl fZe_gvdbcOhZdbg g_ bf_e
^_g_]qlh[u ihclbd \jZqmb _]hjmdZ lZdb g_ kjhkeZkv
ijZ\bevghB \k_qlh y^he`_g [ue^Zlv _fmwlh fhb^_lkdb_
ih[_^uIhwlhfm yqm\kl\h\Ze klu^
;m^v \fbj_qm^ZdkdZaZe ^hgOmZg ih\_ebl_evgh
lu hl^Ze^hklZlhqghL\hb ih[_^u[ueb kbevgufbb hgb [ueb
l\hbfbLu hl^Ze^hklZlhqghL_i_jv lu^he`_g baf_gblvk\h_
h[_sZgb_
DZd ybaf_gx _]h"Y ijhklhkdZ`m lZd"
H[_sZgb_ g_fh`_l [ulvbaf_g_gh ijhklh ]h\hj_gb_f
lZdFh`_l [ulvhq_gv kdhjhlu kfh`_rvmagZlvqlh gZ^h
^_eZlvqlh[u baf_gblv_]hLh]^Z\hafh`ghlu ^Z`_[m^_rv
\ b^ _l v
Fh`_rv lu^Zlv fg_dZdb_gb[m^v mdZaZgby^hg OmZg"
Lu ^he`_g l_ji_eb\h`^ZlvagZyqlh lu `^_rvb
agZyaZq_f lu`^_rvWlh imlv\hbgZB _keb_klv ih\h^^ey
\uiheg_gby l\h_]hh[_sZgbylh]^Z lu^he`_g khagZ\Zlvqlh
lu \uihegy_rv_]hLh]^Z ijb^_l\j_fydh]^Z l\h_ h`b^Zgb_
dhgqblkyb lug_ ^he`_g[m^_rv [hevr_qlblv k\h_h[_sZgb_
Lu gbq_]h g_ fh`_rvk^_eZlv ^ey `bagb wlh]h fZe_gvdh]h
fZevqbdZLhevdh hgfh] Zggmebjh\Zlvwlh ^_ckl\b_
Gh dZdhg fh`_l"
Ihkj_^kl\hf magZ\Zgbyqlh[u k\_klb_]h `_eZgby d
gmexIhdZ hg^mfZ_lqlh hg[ue `_jl\hc_]h `bagv [m^_l
Z^hfIhdZ lu ^mfZ_rv
lZd
`_l\h_ h[_sZgb_ [m^_l
^_ckl\bl_evgufLhqlh ^_eZ_l
gZk g_kqZklgufb wlh
`_eZgb_H^gZdh_keb fugZmqbfky k\h^blvk\hb `_eZgby d
gmexfZe_crZy \_svdhlhjmx fuihemqbf[m^_l bklbgguf
^Zjhf;m^v \ fbj_lu k^_eZe^h[juc ^Zj OhZdbgm;ulv
[_^guf bebohl_lv wlh lhevdhfukevb lhqghlZd `_ fukev
g_gZ\b^_lv beb[ulv ]heh^gufbeb kljZ^Zxsbfhl [heb
Y g_ fh]m\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbih\_jblv wlhfm^hg
OmZgDZd fh`_l]heh^ beb[hev [ulvlhevdh fukevx"
L_i_jv ^ey f_gyhgb lhevdhfukebWlh \k_qlh y
agZxY ijhr_ewlm klmi_gvKbeZ h^he_lv_]h wlh \k_qlh
fu bf__f^ey lh]hqlh[u ijhlb\hklhylvkbeZf `bagb[_a wlhc
kbeu fuy\ey_fky lhevdhfmkhjhfiuevx gZ\_ljm
M f_gyg_l khfg_gbyqlh lu^h[beky wlh]h^hg OmZg
gh dZd fh`_l ijhklhcq_eh\_d \jh^_ f_gy beb fZe_gvdh]h
OhZdbgZ ^h[blvkywlh]h"
Wlh gZrZ
aZ^ZqZdZd
hl^_evguo
ebqghkl_c ijhlb\hklhylv kbeZf gZr_c `bagbY ]h\hjbewlh l_[_ m`_
g_kq_lgh_ qbkehjZalhevdh \hbgfh`_l \u`blv<hbg agZ_l
qlh hg`^_lb hgagZ_lq_]h hg`^_lb dh]^Zhg `^_lhg
gbq_]h g_ ohq_lihwlhfmdZdmx [ufZe_gvdmx \_sv hg gb
ihemqbehgZ [hevr_q_f hgfh`_l \aylv?keb hgohq_l _klv
hg gZc^_l imlvihlhfm qlhhg g_]heh^_g_keb qlheb[h
jZgbl _]h l_ehhg gZoh^blkihkh[qlh[u hklZgh\blv wlh
ihlhfm qlh hg g_ kljZ^Z_lhl [heb;ulv ]heh^guf beb
kljZ^Zlv hl[heb hagZqZ_lqlh q_eh\_dihdbgme kZfh]hk_[y b
[hevr_ m`_ g_ \hbgb kbeZ _]h ]heh^Z beb _]h [heb
mgbqlh`Z_l _]h
Y ohl_ehlklZb\Zlv k\h_fg_gb_gh hklZgh\bekyihlhfm
qlh yihgyeqlh kihjhfy kha^Zx[Zjv_jqlh[u aZsblblvk_[y
hl jZajmrbl_evghckbeu \_ebe_ighcih[_^u ^hgZOmZgZdhlhjZy
aZljhgmeZ f_gylZd ]em[hdhb klZdhc kbehcDZd hgagZ_l"Y
ih^mfZeqlhfh`_l [ulvy jZkkdZaZe_fm bklhjbxh dmjghkhf
fZevqbd_ \h \j_fy h^gh]h
ba
fhbo ]em[hdbo khklhygbc
g_h[uqghc j_ZevghklbY g_ijbihfbgZeqlh y]h\hjbe _fmgh
fh_ g_ijbihfbgZgb_ijb lZdbomkeh\byo [uehij_^iheZ]Zxsbfky
DZd lumagZe hfh_f h[_sZgbb^hg OmZg"
Y \b ^_ e
_]h
Lu \b ^_ e
_]hdh]^Z bijbgbfZe f_kdZeblhbeb
dh]^Z ydmjbe l\hxkf_kv"
Y \b ^_ e
_]hk_cqZkK_]h^gy
Lu \b ^_ e
\kx\_sv"
Lu kgh\Z gZqZeY `_kdZaZe l_[_qlh g_l kfukeZ
]h\hjblv hlhfgZ qlhihoh`_ \b^_gb_Wlh imklh_
Y g_gZklZb\Ze [hevr_WfhpbhgZevgh y[ue m[_`^_g
Y lZd`_^Ze deyl\mh^gZ`^ug_h`b^Zggh kdZaZe ^hg
OmZg
A\md _]h]hehkZ aZklZ\bef_gy \a^jh]gmlv
Y h[_sZehlpmqlh y[m^m `blvqlh[u mgbqlh`blv_]h
m[bcpY ghkbe wlhh[_sZgb_ kkh[hc ^he]b_ ]h^uL_i_jv
h[_sZgb_ baf_g_ghY g_bgl_j_kmxkv [hevr_ mgbqlh`_gb_f
dh]hgb[m^vy g_g_gZ\b`m f_dkbdZgp_\Y g_g_gZ\b`m gbdh]h
Y magZeqlh [_kqbke_ggu_ imlb dZ`^h]h i_j_k_dZxlky \
kh[kl\_gghc `bagb \k_ jZ\guM]g_lZl_ev b m]g_lZ_fuc
\klj_qZxlky \
dhgp_b
_^bgkl\_ggZy
\_svdhlhjZy
ij_h[eZ^Z_lwlh lhqlh `bagv[ueZ \p_ehf kebrdhfdhjhldhc
^ey h[hboK_]h^gy yqm\kl\mx i_qZevg_ ihlhfmqlh fhyfZlv
b hl_p mf_jeb lZdbfiml_fdZdbf hgbmf_jeby qm\kl\mx
i_qZev ihlhfmqlh hgb [ueb bg^_cpZfbHgb `bebdZd
bg^_cpub mf_jebdZd bg^_cpub gbdh]^Zg_ agZebqlh hgb
[uebij_`^_ \k_]hex^vfb
=eZ\Z
h^ bg gZ ^p Zl Zy
Y kgh\Z ihk_lbe^hgZ OmZgZfZy ]h^Z b ijyfh
kdZaZe _fmqlh yohl_e ijhgbdgmlv\ \b^_gb_Hg ihdZqZe
]heh\hc hljbpZl_evgh
b
aZkf_yekyb
y ihqm\kl\h\Ze
g_h[oh^bfhklv ijhl_klh\ZlvHg kdZaZefg_qlh y^he`_g [ulv
l_ji_eb\ b[ueh g_ih^oh^ys__\j_fygh ymijyfh gZklZb\Ze
qlh y[ue ]hlh\
Hg g_dZaZeky jZa^jZ`_gguffhbfb ba\h^ysbfbijhkv[Zfb
Hg klZjZekyl_f g_f_g__kf_gblv l_fmY g_ ih^^Zeky b
ihijhkbe _]hihkh\_lh\Zlvqlh fg_^_eZlvqlh[u ij_h^he_lv
fh_ g_l_ji_gb_
Lu ^he`_g^_ckl\h\ZlvdZd \hbgkdZaZe hg
DZd"
DZ`^uc mqblky^_ckl\h\ZlvdZd \hbg^_ckl\b_fZ g_
jZa]h\hjhf
Lu ]h\hjbeqlh \hbg^mfZ_l hk\h_c kf_jlbY ^_eZx
wlh \k_\j_fyghhq_\b^ghwlh]h g_^hklZlhqgh
DZaZehkvqlh m g_]h \aju\g_l_ji_gbyb hg ^Z`_
aZqfhdZe ]m[ZfbY kdZaZe_fmqlh yg_ ohl_e_]h jZkk_j^blv
b qlh_keb yg_ gm`_g_fm a^_kv\ _]h^hf_lh y ]hlh\
m_oZlv h[jZlgh\ Ehk:g^`_e_k>hg OmZgfy]dh ih]eZ^bef_gy
ih kibg_b kdZaZeqlh yagZeqlh agZqbl[ulv \hbghf
Qlh y^he`_g ^_eZlvqlh[u `blvdZd \hbg"kijhkbe
y
Hg kgyereyim bihq_kZe \bkdbHg ijbklZevghihkfhlj_e
gZ f_gyb meu[gmeky
Lu ex[brv\k_\ujZ`_ggh_ \keh\Zog_ lZdeb"
Fh_ khagZgb_jZ[hlZ_l lZdbfiml_f
Hgh g_^he`gh lZdjZ[hlZlv
Y g_agZxdZd baf_gblvky<hl ihq_fmy ijhrm l_[y
jZkkdZaZlv fg_ lhqghqlh gm`gh^_eZlvqlh[u `blvdZd
\hbg_keb [uy agZewlhy fh][u gZclbkihkh[ ijbkihkh
[blvky dwlhfm
Hg^he`gh [ulvih^mfZeqlh fh_aZy\e_gb_ aZ[Z\gh b
^he]h ohohlZeoehiZy f_gyih kibg_
M f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hqlh hgkh[bjZ_lky ihijhkblv f_gy
m_oZlv \ ex[mx fbgmlmihwlhfm
y [ukljh k_e gZ fhc
khehf_gguc fZl ebphf dg_fm bgZqZe aZ^Z\Zlv \hijhkuY
ohl_e agZlvihq_fm y^he`_g `^Zlv
Hg h[tykgbeqlh _keb
y
[m^m iulZlvky \b^_lv
[_kihjy^hqguf h[jZahfij_`^_q_f aZe_qm jZgudhlhju_ y
ihemqbe \[bl\_ khkljZ`_ffh]eh kemqblvkyqlh y \klj_qm
kljZ`Z kgh\Z^Z`_ ohly yb g_h`b^Ze wlh]h>hg OmZg
aZ\_jbe f_gyqlh gbdlh\ lZdhfiheh`_gbb g_[ue [ukihkh[_g
i_j_g_klb lZdmx\klj_qm
Lu ^he`_gkh\_jr_ggh aZ[ulvkljZ`Zij_`^_ q_f lu
fh`_rv kgh\Z\klmiblv gZihbkd \b ^_ gb ykdZaZe
hg
DZd fh`_ldlhgb[m^v aZ[ulvkljZ`Z"
Lu gZqZemqblvky imlyffZ]h\Lu g_ bf__rv [hevr_
\j_f_gb ^eyhlklmie_gbc beb^ey kh`Ze_gbcM l_[y_klv \j_fy
lhevdh ^ey lh]hqlh[u `blvdZd \hbgb jZ[hlZlv ^ey
^hklb`_gby l_ji_gbyb \hebgjZ\blky l_[_wlh bebg_l
DZd \hbgjZ[hlZ_l jZ^bgbo"
>hg OmZgaZ^mfZeky i_j_^hl\_lhf
Y ^mfZxqlh g_limlb ]h\hjblvh[ wlhfkdZaZe hg
gZdhg_phkh[_ggh h \he_<hey wlh g_qlh \_kvfZ
hkh[_ggh_HgZ ihy\ey_lkyaZ]Z^hqghG_l j_Zevgh]h kihkh[Z
jZkkdZaZlvdZd __bkihevamxldjhf_ lh]hqlh j_amevlZlu
bkihevah\Zgby \hebihjZabl_evguFh`_l [ulvi_j\hc \_svx
qlh gm`gh ^_eZlvwlh agZlvqlh \hexfh`gh jZa\blv<hbg
agZ_l wlhb ijh^he`Z_l`^Zlv \hexL\hy hrb[dZ\ lhfqlh lu
g_ agZ_rvqlh luh`b^Z_rv k\hx\hex
Fhc [_g_nZdlhj]h\hjbeqlh \hbgagZ_lqlh hg`^_lb
agZ_lq_]h hg `^_l< l\h_fkemqZ_qlh agZ_rvqlh lu
`^_rvlu [uea^_kv khfghc ]h^ub \k_`_ lu g_ agZ_rv
q_]h lu `^_rvHq_gv ljm^gh_keb g_ g_\hafh`gh^ey
kj_^g_]h q_eh\_dZ agZlvq_]h hg`^_l<hbgh^gZdhg_
bf__l ijh[e_fhg agZ_lqlh hg`^_l k\hx\hex
Q_f lhqgh y\ey_lky\hey"Mklj_fe_gghklv eb wlh
ih^h[gh mklj_fe_gghklbl\h_]h \gmdZExkbh bf_lvfhlhpbde"
G_lkdZaZe ^hgOmZg fy]dhb mkf_ogm\rbkvwlh g_
\heyExkbh lhevdhij_^Z_lky m^h\hevkl\bx<hey wlh g_qlh
^jm]h_g_qlh hq_gvykgh_ bfhsgh_qlh fh`_l gZijZ\eylv
gZrb ihklmidb<hey wlh g_qlh lZdh_qlh bkihevam_l
q_eh\_dgZijbf_jqlh[u \ub]jZlv[bl\mdhlhjmx hgih \k_f
jZkq_lZf^he`_g [uijhb]jZlv
Lh]^Z \hey^he`gh [ulvlhqlh fu gZau\Z_f
fm`_kl\hfkdZaZe y
G_lFm`_kl\h wlh g_qlh^jm]h_Fm`_kl\_ggu_ ex^b
wlh aZ\bkbfu_ ex^b[eZ]hjh^gu_ ex^bba ]h^Z \ ]h^
hdjm`_ggu_ ex^vfbdhlhju_ lheiylky\hdjm] gbob \hkobsZxlky
bfbh^gZdhhq_gv fZehfm`_kl\_gguo ex^_c bf_xl \hex
H[uqgh hgb[_kkljZrgu bhq_gv kihkh[gud kh\_jr_gbx kf_euo
ihklmidh\hl\_qZxsbo a^jZ\hfm
kfukem[hevr_c qZklvx
fm`_kl\_gguc q_eh\_dlZd`_ \gmrZ_lb kljZo<heyk ^jm]hc
klhjhgubf__l ^_eh k ihjZabl_evgufb aZ^ZqZfbdhlhju_
ih[_`^Zxl gZra^jZ\uc kfuke
Y\ey_lky eb \heydhgljhe_fdhlhjuc fu bf__f gZ^
kZfbfb kh[hc"kijhkbe y
Lu fh`_rvkdZaZlvqlh wlhjZagh\b^ghklv dhgljhey
Lu ^mfZ_rvqlh yfh]m mijZ`gylvk\hx \hexgZijbf_j
hldZau\Zy k_[_\ g_dhlhjuo\_sZo"
< lZdbodZd aZ^Z\Zgb_\hijhkh\"\klZ\be hg
Hg kdZaZewlh \lZdhf hahjghflhg_qlh yhklZgh\beky
qlh[u \a]eygmlvgZ g_]hFu h[ZaZkf_yebkv
G_lkdZaZe hghldZau\Zlv k_[_\ q_feb[h wlh
ihlZdZgb_ k_[_b yg_ kh\_lmxgbq_]h ih^h[gh]h< wlhf
ijbqbgZihq_fm yiha\heyx l_[_aZ^Z\Zlv \k_\hijhkudZdb_
lu ohq_rv
?keb [uy kdZaZel_[_ ij_djZlblvaZ^Z\Zlv \hijhkulh
lu fh][u ihjZgblvk\hx \hexiulZykv k^_eZlvwlhIhlZdZgb_
k_[_ ijb hldZa_\ q_flh gZfgh]hom`_hgh aZklZ\ey_l gZk
\_jblvqlh fukh\_jrZ_f \_ebdh_^_eh \lh \j_fydZd\
^_ckl\bl_evghklbfu ijhklhaZklueb \gmljbk_[yI_j_klZlv
aZ^Z\Zlv \hijhkuwlh g_\heyh dhlhjhcy ]h\hjx<hey wlh kbeZB ihkdhevdmwlh kbeZlh ^he`gZ[ulv dhgljhebjm_
fhc b gZkljh_gghcZ wlhlj_[m_l \j_f_gbY agZxwlhb y
l_ji_eb\ klh[hcDh]^Z y[ue \l\h_f \hajZkl_y [uelZd`_
bfimevkb\_gdZd b luH^gZdhy baf_gbekyGZrZ \hey
^_ckl\m_l g_aZ\bkbfh hlgZr_]h ihlZdZgby k_[_GZijbf_j
l\hy \heym`_ ijbhldju\Z_ll\hc ijhk\_lfZehihfZem
H dZdhfijhk\_l_ lu]h\hjbrv"
< gZk_klv ijhk\_lih^h[gh fy]dhfmf_klm gZ ]heh\_
j_[_gdZdhlhjh_ aZdju\Z_lky k \hajZklhfwlhl ijhk\_l
hldju\Z_lkydh]^Z jZa\b\Z_rvk\hx \hex
=^_ wlhlijhk\_l"
< f_kl_ l\hbo k\_lysboky\hehdhgkdZaZe hg
ihdZau\Zy gZk\hx [jxrgmxihehklv
Q_fm hgih^h[_g">ey q_]hhg"
Wlh hl\_jklb_Hgh ^Z_lf_klh ^ey\hebqlh[u lZ
fh]eZ \ue_l_lvih^h[gh klj_e_
<hey wlh ij_^f_l"Beb ih^h[gZij_^f_lm"
G_lY ijhklhkdZaZeqlh[u lufh] ihgylvLhqlh
fZ] gZau\Z_l \he_c_klv kbeZ\gmljb gZk kZfboWlh g_
fukevg_ ij_^f_lg_ `_eZgb_I_j_klZlv aZ^Z\Zlv\hijhku wlh g_y\ey_lky \he_cihlhfm qlh^ey wlh]hgm`gh ^mfZlv b
ohl_lv<hey wlh lhqlh aZklZ\ey_ll_[y ih[_`^Zlvdh]^Z
l\hb fukeb]h\hjyl l_[_qlh luih[_`^_g<hey wlh lhqlh
^_eZ_l l_[y g_mya\bfuf<hey wlh lhqlh iha\hey_l fZ]m
ijhoh^blv kd\havkl_gmq_j_a ijhkljZgkl\hgZ emgm_keb hg
ohq_l
Y gbq_]h [hevr_g_ ohl_ekijZrb\ZlvY [uemklZeuc b
g_kdhevdh gZijy`_gY [hyekyqlh ^hg OmZg kh[bjZ_lky
ihijhkblv f_gymclbb wlhjZa^jZ`Zeh f_gy
Ihc^_f gZohefukdZaZe hgg_h`b^Zggh b\klZe
Ih imlbhg kgh\ZgZqZe ]h\hjblvh \he_b kf_ylvky gZ^
fhbf aZf_rZl_evkl\hfbaaZ lh]hqlh yg_ fh]aZibku\Zlv gZ
oh^mHg hibkZe\hexdZd kbemdhlhjZy [ueZbklbgguf a\_ghf
f_`^m ex^vfbb fbjhfHg hq_gvlsZl_evgh hlf_lbeqlh fbj
wlh lhqlh fuhsmsZ_fdZdbf [ukihkh[hf fugb ^_eZebwlh
>hg OmZg ih^q_jdgmeqlh hsms_gb_fbjZ aZdexqZ_l \ k_[_
ijhp_kk \hkijbylby\k_]h lh]hqlh ij_^klZ_li_j_^ gZfbWlh
hij_^_e_ggh_ hsms_gb_kh\_jrZ_lky gZrbfbqm\kl\Zfb bgZr_c
\he_c
Y kijhkbe _]hg_ [ueZeb \heyr_kluf qm\kl\hfHg
kdZaZeqlh hgZkdhj__hlghr_gb_ f_`^m gZfb kZfbfb b
hsmsZ_fuf fbjhf
Y ij_^eh`beqlh[u fuhklZgh\bebkvqlh[u yfh] k^_eZlv
aZf_ldb \[ehdghl_gh hgaZkf_yeky bijh^he`Ze b^lb
Wlhc ghqvx hg hklZ\bef_gy kkh[hc ghq_\ZlvZ gZ
ke_^mxsbc ^_gvihke_ aZ\ljZdZhg kZfih^gye jZa]h\hjh \he_
Lhqlh lukZf gZau\Z_rv\he_cwlh oZjZdl_j b
kbevgh_ klj_fe_gb_kdZaZe hgLhqlh fZ] gZau\Z_l
\he_c_klv kbeZdhlhjZy \uoh^blbagmljb bijb\yau\Z_l d
\g_rg_fm fbjmHgZ \uoh^blq_j_a `b\hlijyfh a^_kv]^_
gZoh^ylky k\_lysb_ky\hehdgZ
Hg ihl_jk\hc imihdmdZau\Zy f_klh
Y ]h\hjxqlh hgZ
\uoh^bl hlkx^Zihlhfm qlh
qm\kl\m_rv __\uoh^ys_c
Ihq_fm lugZau\Z_rv wlh\he_c
Y gZau\Zx__ gbdZdFhc [_g_nZdlhjgZau\Ze __\he_c"
<q_jZ lukdZaZeqlh fh`ghhsmsZlv fbjdZd qm\kl\Zfb
lZd b\he_cDZd wlh\hafh`gh"
Kj_^gbc q_eh\_dfh`_l ko\Zlblv\_sb fbjZ lhevdh
k\hbfb jmdZfb]eZaZfb bebmrZfbgh fZ]fh`_l ko\Zlu\Zlvbo
lZd`_ k\hbf ghkhfyaudhf bebk\h_c \he_chkh[_ggh k\h_c
\he_cY g_fh]m j_ZevghhibkZlv wlhdZd ^_eZ_lkygh lu
kZfgZijbf_jg_ fh`_rvhibkZlv fg_dZd lukeurbrvLZd
kemqZ_lkyqlh y lh`_ fh]m keurZlvihwlhfm fu fh`_f
]h\hjblv h lhfqlh fukeurbfZ g_h lhfdZd fu keurbf
FZ] bkihevam_l k\hx \hex ^eylh]hqlh[u hsmsZlv fbj
H^gZdhwlh hsms_gb_g_ ihoh`_gZ keurZgb_Dh]^Z fukfhljbf
gZ fbj bebdh]^Z fukemrZ_f _]hfu ihemqZ_f \i_qZle_gb_
qlh hg\g_ gZkb qlhhg j_Ze_gDh]^Z fuhsmsZ_f fbj gZr_c
\he_cfu agZ_fqlh hgg_ lZdhcdZd \g_ gZkb fbj g_
lZd j_Ze_gdZd fu^mfZ_f
Y\ey_lky
eb
\hey
l_f
`_
kZfufqlh
b
\ b^ _g b_ "
G_l\hey wlh kbeZwg_j]by< b^ _g b_
wlh
g_ kbeZghkdhj__kihkh[ ijhoh`^_gbykd\hav \_sbFZ]
fh`_l bf_lv hq_gv kbevgmx\hexgh hg\k_ `_fh`_l g_
\ b^ _l vqlh hagZqZ_lqlh lhevdh q_eh\_d agZgby
hsmsZ_l fbj k\hbfbqm\kl\Zfb bk\h_c \he_cZ lZd`_ k\hbf
\ b^ _g b_ f
Y kdZaZe_fmqlh y_s_ [hevr_kfms_gq_f lh]^Zijb
jZa]h\hj_ h lhfdZd bkihevah\Zlvfhx \hexqlh[u aZ[ulv
kljZ`ZWlh aZy\e_gb_b fh_g_^hmf_gb_dZaehkvjZa\_k_ebeb
_]h
Y m`_]h\hjbe l_[_qlhdh]^Z lu]h\hjbrvlu lhevdh
aZimlu\Z_rvkykdZaZe hgb aZkf_yekyGhih djZcg_c
f_j_l_i_jv luagZ_rvqlh lu`^_rv k\hx\hexGh lu \k_
_s_ g_ agZ_rvqlh wlhlZdh_ bebdZd wlh fh`_l k lh[hc
kemqblvkyIhwlhfm lsZl_evghke_^b aZl_fqlh lu ^_eZ_rv
LZ kZfZy\_svdhlhjZy fh`_lihfhqv l_[_jZa\blv k\hx\hex
gZoh^blky kj_^b\k_o f_edbo\_s_cdhlhju_ lu^_eZ_rv
>hg OmZgmr_e gZ\k_ mljhhg \_jgmekyjZgh ihke_h[_^Z
kh k\yadhc kmobojZkl_gbcHg ihdZaZefg_ ]heh\hc ihfhqv
_fmb fu jZ[hlZeb \iheghf fheqZgbb g_kdhevdh qZkh\
khjlbjmy jZkl_gbyDh]^Z fudhgqbebfu k_ebhl^hogmlvb hg
^h[jh`_eZl_evgh meu[gmekyfg_
Y kdZaZe _fmhq_gv k_jv_aghqlh y i_j_qblu\Ze k\hb
aZibkb bqlh ylZd bg_ fh]mihgylvqlh agZqbl[ulv \hbghf
b qlhij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hcb^_y \heb
<hey wlh g_b^_ykdZaZe hg
Wlh [uei_j\uc jZadh]^Z hgjZa]h\Zjb\Ze khfghc p_euc
^_gv
Ihke_ ^he]hciZmau hgijh^he`Ze
Fu jZaebqgulu byGZrb oZjZdl_jug_ihoh`bL\hy
ijbjh^Z [he__gZkbevkl\_ggZyq_f fhyDh]^Z y[ue \ l\h_f
\hajZkl_y [ue g_ gZkbevkl\_ggufgh kdjhfguflu `_
gZh[hjhlFhc [_g_nZdlhj [ue
lZdbf_]h [u iheghklvx
mkljhbeh [ulvl\hbf mqbl_e_fHg [ue\_ebdbf fZ]hfgh hgg_
\ b^ _e dZd
\b `m
ybeb \b ^b l
O_gZjhY
ihgbfZx fbjb `b\mjmdh\h^kl\mykv fhbf \b ^_ gb _f Fhc [_g_nZdlhjk ^jm]hcklhjhgu^he`_g [ue`blvdZd \hbg
?keb q_eh\_d \b ^b llh _fmgm`gh `blvdZd \hbgmbeb
dZd q_fmgb[m^v _s_lZd dZdhg fh`_l \b ^_ lv
\_sb
lZdbfbdZdb_ hgb_klv \^_ckl\bl_evghklbb khhl\_lkl\_ggh
gZijZ\eylv k\hx `bagvGhijbgbfZy \h \gbfZgb_ l\hc
oZjZdl_jy kdZaZe[uqlh lufh`_rv gbdh]^Zg_ gZmqblvky
\ b^ _l v\ lZdhfkemqZ_ l_[_ijb^_lky ijh`blv \kx
k\hx `bagvdZd \hbgm
Fhc [_g_nZdlhj]h\hjbeqlh q_eh\_d\klmib\rbc gZimlv
fZ]bbihkl_i_ggh gZqbgZ_lhkhagZ\Zlvqlh h[uqgZy `bagv
gZ\k_]^Z hklZ\e_gZihaZ^bqlh agZgb_\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb
wlh im]Zxs__ im]Zehqlh kj_^kl\Zh[uqgh]h fbjZ[hevr_ g_
[m^ml kj_^kl\Zfb^ey g_]hb qlhhg ^he`_gijbkihkh[blvky d
gh\hfm h[jZam`bagb_keb hgkh[bjZ_lky \u`blvI_j\Zy \_sv
dhlhjmx _fmgZ^h k^_eZlvwlh aZohl_lvklZlv \hbghfwlh
hq_gv \Z`guc rZ] bj_r_gb_Im]ZxsZy ijbjh^Z agZgby g_
hklZ\ey_l gbdZdhcZevl_jgZlb\u lhevdh klZlv\hbghf
D lhfm \j_f_gb agZgb_klZgh\blky im]Zxsbf ^_ehfb
q_eh\_d lZd`_ hkhagZ_lqlh kf_jlv y\ey_lky g_aZf_gbfuf
iZjlg_jhfdhlhjuc kb^bl jy^hfk gbf gZ h^ghc pbgh\d_
DZ`^Zy dZieyagZgbydhlhjZy klZgh\blkykbehcbf__l k\h_c
p_gljZevghc kbehckf_jlvKf_jlv ^_eZ_laZ\_jrZxsbc fZahdZ
\k_qlh ljh]Z_lkykf_jlvx^_ckl\bl_evgh klZgh\blkykbehc
Q_eh\_ddhlhjuc ke_^m_limlyfb fZ]bb\klj_qZ_lky k
\hafh`ghklvx ihegh]hmgbqlh`_gby gZdZ`^hf ih\hjhl_imlbb
h[yaZl_evghhg gZqbgZ_lhkljh hkhagZ\Zlvk\hx kf_jlv;_a
hkhagZgby kf_jlb hg
[m^_l
lhevdh
h[uqguf q_eh\_dhf
ih]jyarbf \ h[uqguoihklmidZoM g_]h[m^_l hlkmlkl\h\Zlv
g_h[oh^bfZy ihl_gpbyg_h[oh^bfZy
dhgp_gljZpbydhlhjZy
ij_h[jZam_l _]hh[uqgh_ \j_fygZ a_fe_\ \her_[gmxkbem
LZdbf h[jZahfqlh[u [ulv\hbghfq_eh\_d ^he`_gij_`^_
\k_]hb ihijZ\mhkljh hkhagZ\Zlvk\hx kh[kl\_ggmxkf_jlv
Gh dhgp_gljZpby gZ
kf_jlb
aZklZ\ey_l
ex[h]h ba gZk
nhdmkbjh\Zlvky gZ kZfhf k_[_Z wlh y\ey_lky kgb`_gb_f
Ihwlhfmke_^mxsZy \_svdhlhjZy g_h[oh^bfZqlh[u klZlv
\hbghfwlh hlj_r_gghklvFukev hg_fbgm_fhc kf_jlb\f_klh
lh]hqlh[u klZlvij_iylkl\b_fklZgh\blky [_ajZaebqb_f
>hg OmZg i_j_klZe ]h\hjblvb \a]eygmegZ f_gyHg
dZaZehkvh`b^Ze aZf_qZgbc
Lu ihgbfZ_rv"kijhkbe hg
Y ihgbfZe lhqlh hg]h\hjbegh y ebqgh g_ fh]
m\b^_lvdZd dlheb[h fh`_lijbclb dqm\kl\m hlj_r_gghklbY
kdZaZeqlh klhqdb aj_gbyfh_]h kh[kl\_ggh]hmq_gbq_kl\Zy
m`_ i_j_`be
fhf_gldh]^Z
agZgb_
klZgh\blky
lZdbf
mkljZrZxsbf ^_ehfY fh]lZd`_ ijZ\^b\h kdZaZlvqlh y
[hevr_ g_ gZoh^be ih^^_j`db
\
h[uqguo aZgylbyo fh_c
ih\k_^g_\ghc `bagbB yohl_ebebfh`_l [ulv^Z`_ [he__
q_f ohl_ey gm`^Zeky\ lhfqlh[u `blvdZd \hbg
L_i_jv lu^he`_g hlj_rblvkykdZaZe hg
Hl q_]h"
Hlj_rblvky hl\k_]h
Wlh g_\hafh`ghY g_ohqm [ulvhlr_evgbdhf
;ulv hlr_evgbdhfwlh ihlZdZgb_k_[_b ygbdh]^Z g_
bf_e wlh]h \ \b^mHlr_evgbd g_hlj_r_glZd dZd hg ih
k\h_fm
`_eZgbx
ihdb^Z_l
kZfh]h
k_[yqlh[u
klZlv
hlr_evgbdhf
Lhevdh fukev h kf_jlb
^_eZ_l q_eh\_dZ ^hklZlhqgh
hlj_r_gguflZd qlhhg g_fh`_l hldZaZlvk_[_ \ q_feb[h
Q_eh\_d lZdh]hkhjlZh^gZdhg_ fm^jkl\m_lihlhfm qlh hg
ijbh[j_e fheqZeb\mxkljZklv d`bagb bdh \k_f\_sZf \`bagb
Hg agZ_lqlh _]hkf_jlv ih^]hgy_l_]h bg_ ^Zkl_fm \j_f_gb
ijbebigmlv d
q_fmeb[hihwlhfm
hg
bkiulu\Z_l[_a
fm^jkl\h\Zgbc\k_ h[h\k_f
Hlj_r_gguc q_eh\_ddhlhjuc agZ_lqlh hg g_ bf__l
gbdZdhc \hafh`ghklbhl[blvky hlk\h_c kf_jlbbf__l lhevdh
h^gm \_svqlh[u ih^^_j`b\Zlvk_[y kbem k\h_]hj_r_gbyHg
^he`_g [ulvlZd kdZaZlvfZkl_jhf k\h_]h\u[hjZHg ^he`_g
iheghklvx ihgbfZlvqlh hgkZf iheghklvxhl\_qZ_l aZ k\hc
\u[hjb _kebhg h^gZ`^uk^_eZe _]hlh mg_]h g_l [hevr_
\j_f_gb ^ey kh`Ze_gbc
beb
mdhjh\
k_[y?]h j_r_gby
hdhgqZl_evgu ijhklh ihlhfmqlh _]hkf_jlv g_ ^Z_l _fm
\j_f_gb ijbebigmlvd q_fmgb[m^v
BlZdbf h[jZahfk hkhagZgb_fk\h_c kf_jlbk\h_c
hlj_r_gghklvx b kbehc k\hboj_r_gbc \hbg jZaf_qZ_l k\hx
`bagv kljZl_]bq_kdbf h[jZahfAgZgb_ hk\h_c kf_jlb \_^_l
_]h b^_eZ_l _]hhlj_r_gguf bfheqZeb\h kljZ`^msbfkbeZ _]h
hdhgqZl_evguo j_r_gbc ^_eZ_l _]hkihkh[guf \u[bjZlv [_a
kh`Ze_gbcb lhqlh hg\u[bjZ_lkljZl_]bq_kdb \k_]^ZkZfh_
emqr__b ihwlhfmhg \uihegy_l\k_ kh\dmkhf b kljZklghc
wnn_dlb\ghklvx
Dh]^Z q_eh\_d \_^_l k_[y lZdbf h[jZahflh fh`gh
kijZ\_^eb\h kdZaZlvqlh hg\hbg bqlh hg^hklb] l_ji_gby
>hg OmZg kijhkbe f_gyg_ ohqm eb y q_]hgb[m^v
kdZaZlvb y aZf_lbeqlh aZ^ZqZdhlhjmx hg hibkZe
hlgbfZ_l \kx `bagvHg
kdZaZeqlh y kebrdhf fgh]h
ijhl_klh\Ze _fmb hgagZeqlh y\_e k_[ybebih djZcg_c
f_j_klZjZeky \_klb
k_[ygZ
yaud_
\hbgZ \ fh_c
ih\k_^g_\ghc `bagb
M l_[y^hklZlhqgh ohjhrb_dh]lbkdZaZe hgkf_ykv
IhdZau\Zc bofg_ \j_fyhl \j_f_gbWlh ohjhrZyijZdlbdZ
Y k^_eZe `_kl gZih^h[b_ dh]l_c
b aZjuqZeb hg
aZkf_yekyAZl_f hghldZreyeky bijh^he`Ze
Dh]^Z \hbg^hklb] l_ji_gbylh hggZ imlb d k\h_c
\he_Hg agZ_ldZd `^Zlv?]h kf_jlvkb^bl jy^hfk gbf gZ
_]h pbgh\d_hgb ^jmavy?]h kf_jlv aZ]Z^hqguf h[jZahf
kh\_lm_l _fmdZd \u[bjZlvdZd `blvkljZl_]bq_kdbB \hbg
`^_lY [ukdZaZeqlh \hbgmqblky [_a\kydhc ki_rdbihlhfm
qlh hgagZ_lqlh hg`^_l k\hx\hexb h^gZ`^uhg ^h[v_lky
mki_oZ \ \uiheg_gbb
q_]heb[hqlh h[uqgh kh\_jr_ggh
g_\hafh`gh \uihegblvHg fh`_l^Z`_ g_ aZf_lblv k\h_]h
g_h[uqgh]h ihklmidZGh ihf_j_ lh]hdZd hg ijh^he`Z_l
kh\_jrZlv g_h[uqgu_ ihklmidbbeb
ih
f_j_ lh]hdZd
g_h[uqgu_ \_sb ijh^he`Zxl kemqZlvkyk gbfhg gZqbgZ_l
hkhagZ\Zlvqlh ijhy\ey_lky dZdh]hlh jh^Z kbeZKbeZ
dhlhjZy bkoh^bl ba _]h l_eZih
f_j_ lh]hdZd hg
ijh^\b]Z_lky ih imlb agZgbyKgZqZeZ hgZih^h[gZ am^m \
`b\hl_beb l_iehfmf_klmdhlhjh_ g_evaymkihdhblvaZl_f
wlh klZgh\blky [hevx[hevrbf g_m^h[kl\hfBgh]^Z [hev b
g_m^h[kl\h lZd \_ebdbqlh m\hbgZ [u\Zxl dhg\mevkbb \
l_q_gb_ f_kyp_\bq_f kbevg__dhg\mevkbbl_f emqr_ ^ey
g_]hHlebqghc \he_\k_]^Z ij_^r_kl\m_lkbevgZy [hev
Dh]^Z dhg\mevkbb bkq_aZxl\hbg aZf_qZ_lqlh m g_]h
ihy\behkv kljZggh_qm\kl\h hlghkbl_evgh\_s_cHg aZf_qZ_l
qlh hg fh`_lnZdlbq_kdbljh]Zlv \k_qlh hg ohq_ll_f
qm\kl\hfdhlhjh_ bkoh^blba _]hl_eZba lhqdbgZoh^ys_c
ijyfh ih^beb ijyfhgZ^ imidhfWlh qm\kl\h_klv \heyb
dh]^Z hg kihkh[_g ko\Zlu\Zlvkybflh fh`gh kijZ\_^eb\h
kdZaZlvqlh \hbgfZ] bqlh hg^hklb] \heb
>hg OmZghklZgh\beky bdZaZehkv`^Ze fhbo aZf_qZgbc
beb \hijhkh\Fg_ g_q_]h[ueh kdZaZlvY [uekebrdhf aZgyl
fukevxqlh fZ]^he`_g bkiulu\Zlv[hev bdhg\mevkbbgh fg_
[ueh g_m^h[gh kijZrb\Zlv_]h^he`_g eby lZd`_ ijhoh^blv
q_j_a wlhGZdhg_pihke_ ^he]h]hfheqZgby ykijhkbe _]hb
hg jZkkf_yekydZd [m^lhhg `^Zefh_]h \hijhkZHg kdZaZe
qlh [hevg_ [ueZZ[khexlgh g_h[oh^bfZhggZijbf_jgbdh]^Z
g_ bf_e__b \heyijhklh ijbreZd g_fm
H^gZ`^u y[ue \]hjZokdZaZe hgb y gZldgmeky
gZ imfmkZfdmhgZ [ueZ[hevrZy b]heh^gZyY ih[_`Zeb
hgZ ih[_`ZeZaZ fghcY \e_agZ kdZemb hgZhklZgh\beZkv \
g_kdhevdbo nmlZo]hlh\Zy dgZiZ^_gbxY [jhkZedZfgyfb \
g__HgZ aZjuqZeZb kh[bjZeZkvZlZdh\Zlv f_gyB lh]^Z fhy
\hey iheghklvx \ureZb yhklZgh\be __\he_c ^hlh]hdZd
hgZ iju]gmeZ gZ f_gyY
iheZkdZe __ k\h_c \he_cY
^_ckl\bl_evgh ihljh]Ze__ khkdb_xHgZ ihkfhlj_eZgZ f_gy
khggufb ]eZaZfb b e_]eZZ yih[_`ZedZd kmdbg kug^h
lh]hdZd hgZhijZ\beZkv
>hg OmZgk^_eZe hq_gvdhfbqguc `_klqlh[u bah[jZablv
q_eh\_dZdhlhjhfm ^hjh]Z`bagv[_]ms_]h bijb^_j`b\Zxs_]h
k\hx reyim
Y kdZaZe_fmqlh fg_g_eh\dh ^mfZlvqlh f_gyh`b^Zxl
lhevdh kZfdb]hjguo ev\h\beb dhg\mevkbb_keb yohl_e \hex
Fhc [_g_nZdlhj [ue fZ]hf k [hevrbfb kbeZfb
ijh^he`Ze hgHg [ue\hbg ^hfha]Z dhkl_c?]h \hey[ueZ
^_ckl\bl_evgh_]h kZfufqm^_kguf ^hklb`_gb_fGh q_eh\_d
fh`_l ihclb _s_ ^Zevr_wlh]h q_eh\_d fh`_l gZmqblvky
\ b^ _l vIhke_ lh]hdZd hggZmqblky \b ^_ lv _fm g_ gm`gh [m^_l `blvdZd \hbgm beb [ulv fZ]hf
GZmqb\rbkv
\b ^_ lv q_eh\_d
klZgh\blky
\k_f
[eZ]h^Zjy lhfmqlh hgklZgh\blky gbq_fHglZd kdZaZlv
bkq_aZ_lbl_f g_f_g__hg a^_kvY [ukdZaZeqlh wlhlh
\j_fydh]^Z q_eh\_dfh`_l [ulv\k_f bebihemqblv \k_qlh
hg ih`_eZ_lGh hggbq_]h g_`_eZ_lb \f_klhlh]hqlh[u
b]jZlv hdjm`Zxsbfb_]h ex^vfbdZd b]jmrdZfbhg \klj_qZ_lky
k gbfb\ p_glj_bo ]emihklb?^bgkl\_ggZy jZagbpZf_`^m gbfb
khklhbl \
lhfqlh
q_eh\_ddhlhjuc
\b ^b l
dhgljhebjm_l k\hx]emihklv\ lh\j_fydZd hdjm`Zxsb_ _]h
ex^b wlh]h g_ fh]mlQ_eh\_ddhlhjuc
\b ^b lg_
bf__l [hevr_ Zdlb\gh]h bgl_j_kZ\ hdjm`Zxsbo _]h ex^yo
< b^ _g b_
m`_hlj_rbeh _]hZ[khexlgh hl\k_]hqlh hg
agZe ij_`^_
H^gZ ebrvfukev hkms_kl\_hlj_r_gghf hl\k_]hqlh
y agZx\]hgy_l f_gy\ ^jh`v
Lu ^he`gh[ulv rmlbrv<_svdhlhjZy \]hgy_ll_[y \
^jh`vwlh g_bf_lv gbq_]hgZ qlhfh`gh [ueh[u kfhlj_lv
\i_j_^bZ lhevdh\kx k\hx`bagv ^_eZlvlh `_kZfh_qlh lu
^_eZe jZgvr_Ih^mfZc hq_eh\_d_dhlhjuc ba]h^Z \]h^ k__l
a_jgh^h l_oihjihdZ hgg_ klZgh\blkykebrdhf klZjuf b
mklZeufqlh[u ih^gylvkyihwlhfm hg\Zey_lkydZd klZjZy
kh[ZdZ?]h fukeb b qm\kl\Z emqr__ \ g_f iheaml
[_kp_evgh d_^bgkl\_gghc \_sbdhlhjmx hgdh]^Zeb[h ^_eZe
k_ylv a_jgh>ey f_gywlh kZfZyim]ZxsZy ljZlZ
Fu ex^bb gZrZ km^v[Z wlh mqblvky b [ulv
\h\e_dZ_fufb \g_hsmlbfu_ gh\u_fbju
>_ckl\bl_evgh eb_klv dZdb_gb[m^v gh\u_ fbju ^ey
gZk"kijhkbe yihemrmleb\h
Fu g_
bkq_jiZeb
gbq_]h]emi_pkdZaZe hg
ih\_ebl_evgh\ b^ _g b_
wlhg_ ^eyf_ehqguo ex^_c
GZkljZb\Zc k\hc ^mo l_i_jvklZgv \hbghfmqbkv
\b
^ _l vb lh]^Zlu magZ_rvqlh g_ldhgpZ gh\uf fbjZf
^ey gZr_]h\hkijbylby
=eZ\Z
>hg OmZg g_hlijZ\be f_gyihke_ lh]hdZd y \uihegbe
ihjmq_gbydZd hg ^_eZe g_^Z\ghHg kdZaZeqlh y fh]
hklZlvkyb gZke_^mxsbc ^_gvbxgy ]h^ZdZd jZa
i_j_^ ihem^g_fhg kdZaZefg_qlh[u y kh[bjZeky dmjblv
kgh\Z
Kh[bjZlvky ebfg_ kgh\Z \b ^_ lv
kljZ`Z"
G_l[_a wlh]h?klv g_qlh^jm]h_
>hg OmZg kihdhcgh gZihegbek\hx ljm[dm dmjbl_evghc
kf_kvxaZ`_] __b ijhlygmefg_Y g_ hiZkZekyIjbylgZy
khgeb\hklv kjZam`_ ho\ZlbeZf_gyDh]^Z ydhgqbe dmjblv\kx
qZrdm kf_kb^hg OmZg\aye k\hxljm[dm bihfh] fg_ \klZlv
Fu k_eb ebphf ^jm] d^jm]m gZ ^\_ khehf_ggu_ pbgh\db
dhlhju_ hg iheh`begZ k_j_^bg_dhfgZluHg kdZaZeqlh fu
ihc^_f gZ dhjhldmx ijh]medmb ij_^eh`be fg_ ih]meylv
ke_]dZ ih^lhedgm\f_gyY rZ]gmeb fhbgh]b ih^h]gmebkvY
g_ ihqm\kl\h\ZegbdZdhc [hebdh]^Z fhbdhe_gb m^Zjbebkv h
ihe>hg OmZg \ayef_gy aZjmdm bkgh\Z ih^lhedgme f_gy
\klZlv gZgh]b
Lu ^he`_gb^lbkdZaZe hgl_f `_kZfuf iml_f
dZdbf lu \klZ\Ze^jm]hc jZaLu ^he`_g bkihevah\Zlv k\hx
\hex
YdZaZehkvijbebi da_fe_Y ihiulZekyrZ]gmlv ijZ\hc
gh]hc bihqlb ihl_jyejZ\gh\_kb_>hg OmZgihfh] fg_ijZ\hc
jmdhc ih^furdhcb ke_]dZlhedgme f_gy\i_j_^gh fhbgh]b g_
^_j`Zeb f_gyb y[u miZeebphf_keb [u^hg OmZgg_ ko\Zlbe
f_gy aZ jmdmb g_m^_j`Ze hliZ^_gbyHg ^_j`Ze f_gy ih^
ijZ\mx jmdmb gZdehgbed k_[_Y gbq_]hg_ fh]qm\kl\h\Zlv
gh y[ue m\_j_gqlh fhy]heh\Z e_`ZeZgZ _]hie_q_y \b^_e
dhfgZlm \ gZdehgghci_jki_dlb\_Hg ijhlZsbef_gy \ wlhf
iheh`_gbb hdhehdjuevpZFu h[hreb_]h ^\Z`^ukZfuf ly`_euf
h[jZahfgZdhg_py iheZ]Zxfhc \_kklZe lZdbf[hevrbfqlh
hg [ue \ugm`^_ghimklblv f_gygZ a_fexY agZeqlh hg g_
fh] k^\bgmlvf_gyG_dhlhjuf h[jZahfdZd [m^lhqZklv f_gy
gZf_j_ggh ohl_eZ klZlv ly`_ehcdZd k\bg_p>hg OmZg g_
^_eZe gbdZdbo mkbebcqlh[u ih^gylvf_gyHg gZ f]gh\_gb_
\a]eygme gZf_gyy e_`ZegZ kibg_ebphf dg_fmY ihiulZeky
meu[gmlvky _fmb hg aZkf_yekyaZl_f hg gZdehgbeky b
ihoehiZe f_gyih `b\hlmM f_gy\hagbdeh g_h[uqgh_hsms_gb_
Hgh g_ [ueh[he_ag_gguf bebijbylgufbeb q_fgb[m^v _s_
qlh y fh] ^h^mfZlvWlh [uehkdhj__lheqdhf>hg OmZg
gZqZe f_^e_ggh\jZsZlv f_gydjm]hfY gbq_]hg_ qm\kl\h\Ze
y ij_^iheh`beqlh hg\jZsZe f_gydjm]hf ihlhfmqlh fhc\b^
djuevpZ baf_gyeky \khhl\_lkl\bb k djm]h\ufb ^\b`_gbyfb
Dh]^Z ^hgOmZg hklZ\bef_gy \iheh`_gbbdhlhjh_ hg ohl_e
hg hlhr_e
<klZgvijbdZaZe hgfg_ ih\_ebl_evgh<klZgvdZd
lu ^_eZe wlh jZgvr_G_ aZgbfZcky imklydZfb \hdjm]Lu
agZ_rvdZd \klZ\ZlvL_i_jv \klZgv
Y gZklhcqb\h iulZeky \kihfgblv^_ckl\bydhlhju_ y
\uihegye \lZdbo kemqZyogh yg_ fh]ykgh ^mfZlv[ueh lZd
dZd [m^lh fhb fukebohl_eb k\h_]hg_kfhljy gZ lhdZd
kbevgh ygb klZjZekydhgljhebjh\Zlv boGZdhg_pfg_ ijbreZ
fukevqlh_keb ykdZ`m \klZxdZd y^_eZe jZgvr_y
g_ij_f_ggh \klZgmY kdZaZe\klZx]jhfdh bhlq_leb\hgh
gbq_]h g_kemqbehkv
>hg OmZg ihkfhlj_egZ f_gyk y\gufg_m^h\hevkl\b_f b
aZl_f ih\_ef_gy d^\_jbY e_`ZegZ e_\hf[hdm biheghklvx
\b^_e ijhkljZgkl\h i_j_^_]h ^hfhfy [uekibghc d ^\_jb
ihwlhfmdh]^Z hg
h[hr_e
\hdjm]
f_gyy g_f_^e_ggh
ij_^iheh`beqlh hgmr_e \^hf
>hg OmZgiha\Ze y]jhfdhgh hgg_ hl\_qZe
M f_gy[ueh g_ij_h^hebfh_qm\kl\h [_kkbebyb hlqZygby
Y ohl_e \klZlvY ]h\hjbe\klZlvkgh\Z b kgh\ZdZd
[m^lh wlh[ueh fZ]bq_kdh_keh\hdhlhjh_ aZklZ\beh[u f_gy
k^\bgmlvkyGbq_]h g_kemqbehkvY jZkkljhbekyb bkiulu\Ze
jZa^jZ`_gb_Fg_ ohl_ehkv[blvky ]heh\hch ^\_jvb ieZdZlv
Y ijh\h^be fmqbl_evgu_ fhf_glu\ dhlhju_ fg_ ohl_ehkv
^\b]Zlvky beb ]h\hjblvb yg_ fh]gb lh]hgb ^jm]h]hY
[ue ^_ckl\bl_evhg_ih^\b`_giZjZebah\Zg
>hg OmZgihfh]b fg_kmf_e ygZdhg_pijhfuqZlv
>hg OmZg\_jgmeky bk_e i_j_^hfghckf_ykvHg kdZaZe
qlh yklZe bkl_jbqgufb qlh\k_qlh yi_j_`b\Zeg_ bf_eh
agZq_gbyHg ih^gye ]heh\m bihkfhlj_e ijyfh gZ f_gy
kdZaZ\qlh gZf_gy gZiZeihahjguc kljZoHg \_e_efg_ g_
[_kihdhblvky
L\hy `bagv mkeh`g_gZkdZaZe hgBa[Z\vky hl
\k_]hqlh aZklZ\ey_ll_[y \uoh^blvfa k_[yHklZ\Zcky a^_kv
b \gh\vijb\_^b k_[y\ ihjy^hd
Hg iheh`befhx ]heh\mgZ a_fexHg rZ]gmeq_j_a f_gyb
\k_qlh yfh] hsmlblvwlh rZjdZgv__]h kZg^Zebcdh]^Z hg
moh^be
Fhbf i_j\ufih[m`^_gb_f kgh\Z[ueh [_kihdhckl\hgh y
g_ fh] kh[jZlv wg_j]bxqlh[u ijb\_klbk_[y \ ^_ckl\b_
<f_klh wlh]h yh[gZjm`be k_[yi_j_r_^rbf \ g_h[udgh\_ggh_
khklhygb_ ykghklb[hevrh_ qm\kl\he_]dhklb hdmlZehf_gyY
agZedZdZy keh`ghklv [ueZ \fh_c `bagbWlh [ue fhc
fZe_gvdbc fZevqbdY ohl_e [ulv_]h hlphf [hevr_q_f
qlhgb[m^v _s_ gZ wlhc a_fe_Fg_ gjZ\beZkv fukev h
nhjfbjh\Zgbb _]h oZjZdl_jZ bh lhfqlh y[u [jZe _]h \
iml_r_kl\by bmqbe [u_]h dZd `blvb \k_`_ y g_gZ\b^_e
fukev h ih^qbg_gbb_]h fh_fm`bag_gghfm imlbgh wlh [ueh
bf_ggh lhqlh y^he`_g [uek^_eZlvih^qbgblv _]h kbehc
beb l_fjy^hf bkdmkguoZj]mf_glh\ bih\lhj_gbcdhlhju_ fu
gZau\Z_f ihgbfZgb_f
Y ^he`_g\udbgmlv _]hba ]heh\uih^mfZe yY g_
^he`_g p_ieylvkyaZ g_]hY ^he`_ghk\h[h^blv _]h
Fhb fukeb\ua\Zeb \hfg_ m`Zkgh_qm\kl\h f_eZgohebbY
aZieZdZeFhb ]eZaZ gZihegbebkv ke_aZfb b \b^ djuevpZ
jZkieueky<g_aZigh mf_gy ihy\beZkv [hevrZy ihlj_[ghklv
\klZlv b m\b^_lv ^hgZOmZgZqlh[u h[tykgblv_fm h fh_f
fZe_gvdhf fZevqbd_b ke_^mxs_c\_svxdhlhjmx yagZe[ueh
lhqlh ykfhlj_e gZdjuevph klhyY ih\_jgmeky d nZkZ^m
^hfZ b gZr_e^hgZ OmZgZklhysbf i_j_^hfghcHq_\b^ghhg
klhye a^_kvihaZ^b f_gy\k_ \j_fy
Ohly yg_ qm\kl\h\Zek\hbo gh]y ^he`_g[ue ih^hclbd
g_fmihlhfm qlh y ^\b]Zeky>hg OmZg ih^hr_e dh fg_
meu[Zykv bih^^_j`Ze f_gyih^ furdZfb?]h ebph[ueh hq_gv
[ebadh dhfg_
Ohjhrhohjhrh jZ[hlZ_rvkdZaZe hgm[_`^Zxs_
< wlh f]gh\_gb_ yhkhagZeqlh qlhlh qj_a\uqZcgh_
kemqbehkv ijyfh a^_kvKgZqZeZ mf_gy [uehqm\kl\hqlh y
lhevdh qlh \kihfgbe kh[ulb_dhlhjh_ kemqbehkv ]h^Zfb
jZgvr_H^gZ`^u \ijhrehf y\b^_e ^hgZOmZgZ hq_gv[ebadhy
dmjbe _]hkf_kvb mf_gy [uehqm\kl\h lh]^Zqlh ebph^hgZ
OmZgZ ih]jmabehkv \ [Zd k\h^hcHgh [ueh h]jhfguf b
k\_lysbfky b^\b]ZehkvBah[jZ`_gb_ [uehlZdbf g_^he]bfqlh
y g_ bf_e\j_f_gb khojZgblv_]hGZ wlhljZah^gZdh^hg
OmZg ^_j`Zef_gyb mf_gy [ueh\j_fy jZkkfhlj_lv_]hDh]^Z
y \klZe bih\_jgmekylh yhij_^_e_ggh \b^_e ^hgZ OmZgZ
^hg OmZgdhlhjh]h yagZxhij_^_e_ggh ih^hr_edh fg_ b
^_j`Ze f_gyGhdh]^Z yknhdmkbjh\Ze ]eZaZgZ _]hebp_y
g_ m\b^_e ^hgZOmZgZ lZddZd yijb\ud _]h\b^_lv\f_klh
wlh]h ym\b^_e [hevrhcij_^f_l i_j_^k\hbfb ]eZaZfbY agZe
qlh wlh [uehebphf ^hgZOmZgZgh\k_ `_wlh agZgb_ g_
jmdh\h^beh fhbf \hkijbylb_fwlh [uehkdhj__eh]bq_kdh_
aZdexq_gb_ k fh_c klhjhgub \dhgp_ dhgph\fhy iZfylv
ih^l\_j^beZ wlh f]gh\_gb_fjZgvr_^hg OmZgdhlhjh]h y
agZx^_j`Ze
f_gy
ih^
furdZfbIhwlhfm g_h[uqguc
k\_lysbcky ij_^f_lgZijhlb\ f_gy^he`_g [ue[ulv ebphf^hgZ
OmZgZwlh [ueh[ebadh dwlhfmghh^gZdhwlh g_ihoh^beh
gZ lhqlh yfh] [ugZa\Zlv gZklhysbfebphf ^hgZ OmZgZ
LhgZ qlhy kfhlj_e[ueh djm]eufij_^f_lhfdhlhjuc bf_e
k\h_ kh[kl\_ggh_k\_q_gb_DZ`^Zy qZklv\ g_f^\b]ZeZkvY
hsmsZe k^_j`Zggh_\heghh[jZagh_jblfbq_kdh_ l_q_gb_wlh
[uehdZd [m^lhl_dmq_klv aZdexqZeZkv\gmljb g_]h kZfh]h
gbdh]^Z g_ ^\b]Zykv aZ_]h ij_^_eZfbb\k_ `_h[t_dl
i_j_^ fhbfb]eZaZfb f_^e_gghl_d ^\b`_gb_f\ ex[hff_kl_ _]h
ih\_joghklbFg_ ijbreZ fukevqlh wlh f_^e_ggh l_dmsZy
`bagv< ^_ckl\bl_evghklbwlh [uehlZdbf `b\ufqlh [ue
ih]ehs_g
jZkkfZljb\Zgb_f
wlh]h
^\b`_gbyWlh
[ueh
]bighlbabjmxsbf \heg_gb_fHgh \k_[hevr_ b[hevr_ ih]ehsZeh
f_gy ^h l_o ihjihdZ yg_ fh][hevr_ jZaebqZlvqlh aZ
n_ghf_g [uei_j_^ fhbfb]eZaZfb
Y i_j_`be \g_aZiguclheqhdk\_lysbcky ij_^f_l klZe
g_ykgufdZd [m^lhqlhlh \hegh\Zeh_]hb aZl_fhg ihl_jye
k\h_ k\_q_gb_ bklZe iehlgufb lheklufB aZl_f y m\b^_e
agZdhfh_ l_fgh_ebph ^hgZOmZgZHg kihdhcghmeu[Zeky<b^
_]h gZklhys_]hebpZ khojZgyekyf]gh\_gb_Z aZl_f ebph
kgh\Z ijbh[j_ehk\_q_gb_[e_kd bi_j_eb\qZlhklvWlh [ueg_
k\_ldZdbf y ijb\udhsmsZlv k\_lb ^Z`_ g_ k\_q_gb_
kdhj__wlh [ueh^\b`_gb_g_ijZ\^hih^h[gh [ukljh_f_jpZgb_
q_]hlhK\_lysbcky ij_^f_lgZqZe ih^kdZdb\Zlv\\_jo b\gba
kgh\Zb wlhjZajmrZeh _]h\heghh[jZagmx p_ehklghklv?]h
k\_q_gb_ mf_gvrZehkv dZd[u lheqdZfb^h l_oihjihdZ hg
kgh\Z g_ klZeiehlgufebphf ^hgZOmZgZlZdbfdZdbf y
\b^_e _]h \h[uqghc `bagb< wlhlfhf_gl y g_hij_^_e_ggh
ihgyeqlh ^hgOmZg ljykf_gyHg lZd`_]h\hjbe fg_qlhlh
Y g_ihgbfZeqlh hg]h\hjblgh lZddZd hgijh^he`Ze ljyklb
f_gyygZdhg_pmkeurZe _]h
G_ kfhljbgZ f_gyG_ kfhljbgZ f_gyijh^he`Ze hg
]h\hjblvM[_jb k\hc\a]ey^M[_jb k\hc\a]ey^I_j_\_^b
k\hb ]eZaZ
LjykdZ fh_]hl_eZdZaZehkvaZklZ\beZ f_gym[jZlv k\hc
ihklhygguc ijbklZevguc \a]ey^hq_\b^ghdh]^Z
y g_
\kfZljb\Zeky \gbfZl_evgh \ ebph^hgZ OmZgZy g_ \b^_e
k\_lys_]hky ij_^f_lZDh]^Z yhl\_e k\hb]eZaZ hl_]h ebpZb
\b^_e wlh m]hedhffh_]h ]eZaZlZd kdZaZlvy fh] hsmsZlv
_]h iehlghklvlh _klvy fh]hsmsZlv lj_of_jgh]h q_eh\_dZ
g_ kfhljy^_ckl\bl_evgh gZg_]hy fh]nZdlbq_kdbhsmsZlv
\k_ _]h l_ehgh dh]^Zy nhdmkbjh\Ze k\hc ijbklZevguc
\a]ey^ebph _]hklZgh\behkv kjZamk\_lysbfky ij_^f_lhf
G_ kfhljbgZ f_gy\hh[s_kdZaZe ^hgOmZg k_jv_agh
Y hl\_e]eZaZ bihkfhlj_e gZa_fex
G_ nbdkbjmck\hc \a]ey^gb gZq_fih\_ebl_evgh
kdZaZe ^hgOmZg brZ]gme \klhjhgmqlh[u ihfhqvfg_ b^lb
Y g_ qm\kl\h\Ze k\hbo gh]b g_fh] ihgylvdZd y
\uihegye ^\b`_gbyh^gZdhk ihfhsvx^hgZ OmZgZdhlhjuc
^_j`Ze f_gyih^ furdmfu ijhreb\_kv imlvd aZ^g_cklhjhg_
_]h ^hfZFu hklZgh\bebkvm dZgZ\u
L_i_jv kfhljbgZ \h^mijbdZaZe fg_^hg OmZg
Y ihkfhlj_e gZ \h^mgh g_fh] \]ey^_lvky \ g__
Ihq_fmlh ^\b`gb_
l_q_gby
hl\e_dZeh
f_gy>hg OmZg
gZklhcqb\h m[_`^Ze f_gy \rmleb\hc fZg_j_ mijZ`gylv fh_
\]ey^u\Zgb_ kbeugh
y
g_
fh] khkj_^hlhqblvkyY
ijbklZevgh ihkfhlj_egZ ebph^hgZ OmZgZ_s_ jZagh k\_q_gb_
g_ klZgh\behkvhq_\b^guf kdhevdhgb[m^v [hevr_
Y gZqZebkiulu\Zlv g_h[uqgucam^ gZfh_f l_e_hsms_gb_
qe_gh\dhlhju_
aZkgmebfmkdmeu
fhbo
gh]
gZqZeb
ih^_j]b\Zlvky>hg OmZgklhedgme f_gy\ \h^mb ymiZe gZ
^ghHgih\b^bfhfm^_j`Ze fhxijZ\mx jmdmdh]^Z lhedZe
f_gyb dh]^Z ym^Zjbeky hf_edh_ ^ghhg \ulygme f_gy
hiylv
Fg_ ihlj_[h\Zehkv^he]h_ \j_fyqlh[u ^hklbqvdhgljhey
gZ^ kh[hcDh]^Z fu\_jgmebkv q_j_ag_kdhevdh qZkh\d _]h
^hfmy ihijhkbe _]hh[tykgblv fh_i_j_`b\Zgb_Dh]^Z y
h^_eky \ kmomxh^_`^my \ha[m`^_gghhibkZe _fmlhqlh y
hsmsZegh hghl[jhkbe \_kvfhc hlq_lkdZaZ\qlh \wlhf g_
[ueh gbq_]h\Z`gh]h
;hevrh_ ^_ehkdZaZe hgkf_ykv gZ^hfghcLu
\b^_e k\_q_gb_[hevrh_ ^_eh
Y gZklZb\ZegZ h[tykg_gbbgh hg\klZe bkdZaZeqlh hg
^he`_g mclb;ueh ihqlbiylv qZkh\ihihem^gb
GZ ke_^mxsbc^_gv ykgh\Z gZklZb\ZegZ h[km`^_gbbfh_]h
g_h[uqgh]h i_j_`b\Zgby
Wlh [ueh \b ^_ gb _^hg OmZg"kijhkbe y
Hg [uekihdh_g blZbgkl\_ggh meu[Zeky\ lh\j_fy dZdy
aZklZ\eye _]hhl\_lblv fg_
Fh`gh kdZaZlvqlh \b ^_ gb _
^h g_dhlhjhc
kl_i_gb ih^h[ghwlhfmkdZaZe hggZdhg_pLu ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_e gZfh_ ebphb m\b^_e_]h kbyxsbfgh wlh[ueh\k_
`_fh_ ebphLZd ijhbkoh^blqlh ^ufhdaZklZ\ey_l dZ`^h]h
ijbklZevgh kfhlj_lvih^h[gh wlhfmWlh imklydb
Gh dZdhfkihkh[hf hlebqblv \b ^_ gb _"
Dh]^Z lu \b ^b rv lh g_l [hevr_ ijb\uqguo
q_jl \ fbj_<k_ y\ey_lkygh\uf<k_ gbdh]^Zg_ kemqZehkv
ij_`^_Fbj klZgh\blkyg_ijZ\^hih^h[guf
Ihq_fm lu]h\hjbrv g_ijZ\^hih^h[guf^hg OmZg"Qlh
^_eZ_l _]hg_ijZ\^hih^h[guf"
G_l [hevr_ gbq_]h
agZdhfh]h<k_gZ qlh lu
ijbklZevgh kfhljbrvklZgh\blky
gbq_f<q_jZ
lu g_
\ b^ _e Lu ijbklZevghkfhlj_e gZfh_ ebphblZd dZdy
gjZ\exkv l_[_lu aZf_lbefh_ k\_q_gb_Y [ueg_ qm^h\bs_f
ih^h[gh kljZ`mgh djZkb\uf
b
bgl_j_kgufGh lu g_
\ b^ _e
f_gyY g_klZe gbq_fi_j_^ lh[hcGhh^gZdh
lu k^_eZe ohjhrhLu
k^_eZe
i_j\uc gZklhysbc rZ] d
\ b^ _g bx ?^bgkl\_gguf g_^hklZldhf[ueh lhqlh lu
khkj_^hlhqbeky gZ fg_b \wlhf kemqZ_y [ue^ey l_[y g_
emqr_q_f kljZ`Lu g_\u^_j`Ze \h[hbo kemqZyo b g_
\ b^ _e <_sb bkq_aZxl"DZd hgbklZgh\ylky gbq_f"
<_sb g_bkq_aZxlHgb g_ijhiZ^Zxl_keb wlhlhqlh
lu bf__rv \\b^mhgb ijhklhklZgh\ylky gbq_fbl_f g_
f_g__hgb \k_`_ a^_kv
DZd wlhfh`_l [ulv\hafh`guf^hg OmZg"
Lu q_jlh\kdbgZklhcqb\ \jZa]h\hj_\hkdebdgme ^hg
OmZg kk_jv_aguf ebphfy ^mfZxqlh fug_ gZrebijZ\bevgh
l\h_ h[_sZgb_<hafh`ghlhqlh luh[_sZe[ueh gbdh]^Zg_
hklZgZ\eb\Zlv jZa]h\hj
Lhg ^hgZ OmZgZ[ue kljh]bc<ujZ`_gb_ _]h ebpZ [ueh
haZ[hq_ggufY ohl_emeu[gmlvkygh g_ihkf_eY ^mfZeqlh
^hg OmZg[ue k_jv_a_ggh hgg_ [uek_jv_a_gHg jZkkf_yeky
Y kdZaZe _fmqlh _keby g_]h\hjbey klZgh\beky hq_gv
g_j\guf
Lh]^Z ihc^_f]meylvkdZaZe hg
Hg ijb\_ef_gy dh\oh^m \dZgvhg mih^gh`by ohefh\Wlh
[ueZ ijbf_jghqZkh\Zy ijh]medZFu hl^hogmebdhjhldh_ \j_fy
b aZl_f hg ih\_ef_gy q_j_a]mklhc imklugguc ih^e_khd d
f_klm k \h^hclh _klvd f_klm]^_dZd hg kdZaZe[ueh
\h^gh_ hl\_jklb_Hgh [uehlZdbf `_kmobfdZd ex[h_^jm]h_
f_klh \hdjm]_
Ky^v \p_glj_ \h^gh]hhl\_jklbyijbdZaZe hgfg_
Y ih\bgh\Zekyb k_e
Lu lZd`_ kh[bjZ_rvkyk_klv a^_kv"kijhkbe y
Y \b^_eqlh hgkh[bjZeky k_klv\ ^\Z^pZlb yj^Zo hl
f_gyY k_edhe_gyfb i_j_^]jm^vxHg ihijZ\befh_ iheh`_gb_
b \_e_efg_ k_klvlZdqlh[u yih^h]gme fhxe_\mx gh]m ih^
k_[yZ ijZ\mxkh]gme gZijhlb\__ dhe_ghf\\_joFhy ijZ\Zy
jmdZ ^he`gZ [ueZ e_`ZlvdmeZdhf gZa_fe_Z e_\Zy jmdZ
i_j_k_dZeZ fhx]jm^vHg \_e_efg_ ih\_jgmlvkyebphf dg_fm
b hklZ\Zlvky \ wlhf
iheh`_gbbjZkkeZ[b\rbkvgh g_
g_ijbgm`^_gghAZl_f hg\ugme [_eh\Zlucrgmjhd ba k\h_]h
f_rdZHg \u]ey^_eih^h[gh [hevrhci_le_Hg aZdj_ibe _]h
i_le_c \hdjm]k\h_c r_bb gZlygmee_\hc jmdhcihdZ hglm]h
g_ gZlygmekyHg ^_jgmegZlygmluc rgmjhdijZ\hc jmdhcLhl
ba^Ze fhghlhgguc\b[jbjmxsbc a\md
Hg hkeZ[beaZ`Zlb_ihkfhlj_e gZf_gy bkdZaZe fg_qlh
y ^he`_g \udjbdgmlvhkh[h_ keh\h_keb y ihqm\kl\mxqlh
qlhlh gZiZehgZ f_gydh]^Z hg^_j]Ze rgmjhd
Y kijhkbeqlh ^he`gh [uehgZiZklv gZ f_gyb hg
hl\_lbeqlh[u yaZfheqZeHg ihdZaZefg_ k\h_cjmdhcqlh
hg kh[bjZeky gZqZlvGh hgg_ gZqZe\f_klh wlh]hhg ^Ze
fg_ _s_ h^ghij_^hkl_j_`_gb_Hg kdZaZeqlh _keb qlhlh
gZiZ^_l gZf_gy hq_gvm]jh`Zxsbf h[jZahfy ^he`_g ijbgylv
[h_\h_ iheh`_gb_dhlhjh_ hgihdZau\Ze fg_ g_kdhevdh e_l
gZaZ^ b dhlhjh_aZdexqZehkv \lhfqlh yieykZelhiZy ih
a_fe_ e_\hcgh]hc\ lh`_ \j_fywg_j]bqgh oehiZyih k\h_fm
ijZ\hfm [_^jm;h_\h_ iheh`_gb_[ueh qZklvx h[hjhgbl_evghc
l_ogbdbdhlhjZy
bkihevah\ZeZkv
\
kemqZyo
djZcg_c
g_h[oh^bfhklb ijbhiZkghklb
M f_gyihy\behkv fjZqgh_ij_^qm\kl\b_Y ohl_emagZlv h
lhfihq_fm fuijbreb kx^Zgh hgg_ ^Zefg_ \j_f_gbb gZqZe
^_j]Zgv_ rgmjdZHg ^_eZe
wlh
\ jZaebqguo l_fiZo k
j_]meyjgufb bgl_j\ZeZfb ijbf_jgh \
^\Z^pZlv k_dmg^Y
aZf_lbeqlhdh]^Z hg
^_j]Ze
rgmjhdhg m\_ebqb\Ze
gZly`_gb_Y fh]ykgh \b^_lvqlh _]hjmdb br_y ^jh`Zebhl
gZijy`_gbyA\md klZe[he__ ykgufb yihgye lh]^Zqlh hg
^h[Z\eye kljZgguc\udjbd dZ`^ucjZadh]^Z hg^_j]Ze rgmjhd
H[s__ a\mqZgb_ gZlygmlh]h rgmjdZb q_eh\_q_kdh]h ]hehkZ
ijhba\h^beb kljZggh_lZbgkl\_ggh_ hljZ`_gb_
Y g_ qm\kl\h\Ze gbq_]hgZiZ^Zxs_]h gZf_gygh \b^
gZijy`_gby ^hgZOmZgZ b`mldbc a\mddhlhjuc hgijhba\h^be
ijb\_eb f_gyihqlb \khklhygb_ ljZgkZ
>hg OmZg hkeZ[bek\h_ gZly`_gb_b ihkfhlj_egZ f_gy
Dh]^Z hg b]jZehg [uekibghc dhfg_b _]hebph [ueh gZ
x]h\hklhddZd bfh_dh]^Z hghkeZ[behg ih\_jgmekyebphf
dh fg_
G_ kfhljb gZf_gydh]^Z yb]jZxkdZaZe hg
h^gZdhg_ aZdju\Zc]eZaZGb aZqlhKfhljb gZa_fex i_j_^
lh[hc bkemrZc
Hg kgh\ZgZlygme k\hx[_q_\dm bgZqZe b]jZlvY kfhlj_e
\ a_fexb dhgp_gljbjh\ZekygZ a\md_dhlhjuc hgijhba\h^be
Y gbdh]^Zij_`^_ \`bagb g_keurZe lZdh]ha\mdZ
Y hq_gvbkim]Zeky@mldh_ wohgZihegbeh madbcdZgvhg b
gZqZeh hljZ`ZlvkyGZ kZfhf^_e_a\mddhlhjuc ijhba\h^be
^hg OmZg\ha\jZsZeky dhfg_ wohfhlh \k_ohdjm`Zxsbo kl_g
dZgvhgZ>hg OmZg^he`gh [ulvaZf_lbe wlh b m\_ebqbe
gZly`_gb_ k\h_]hrgmjdZOhly ^hgOmZg baf_gbe\ukhlm lhgZ
wohdZaZehkvihgbabehkvb
aZl_f
hghdZaZehkv
kdhgp_gljbjh\Zehkv \h^ghc lhqd_d x]h\hklhdm
>hg OmZg mf_gvrbegZly`_gb_ rgmjdZihkl_i_ggh ^h l_o
ihjihdZ yg_ mkeurZeaZdexqbl_evguc lmihca\mdHg iheh`be
rgmjhd \k\hc f_rhdb ih^hr_edh fg_Hg ihfh]fg_ \klZlv
Lh]^Z y aZf_lbeqlh fmkdmeufhbo jmdb gh] h^_j_\_g_eb
ih^h[gh dZfgxy [ue[md\Zevgh ijhiblZgihlhfY g_ fh]
ih^mfZlvqlh y fh]m lZd kbevgh \kihl_lvDZieb ihlZ
gZ[_`Zeb fg_\ ]eZaZb boaZ`]eh
>hg OmZgnZdlbq_kdb\ulZsbe f_gyba f_klZY iulZeky
kdZaZlv qlhgb[m^vgh hgiheh`be jmdmgZ fhcjhl
<f_klh lh]hqlh[u ihdbgmlvdZgvhg l_f`_ iml_fdZdbf
fu ijbreb\ g_]h^hg OmZgihr_e \h[oh^Fu \kdZjZ[dZebkv
ih kl_g_ ]hju b \urebgZ ohefu hq_gv ^Ze_dh hl mklvy
dZgvhgZ
Fu reb \f_jl\hc lbrbg_d _]h^hfmDh]^Z fu ^hreb
[ueh m`_ l_fghY ihiulZekyaZ]h\hjblv kgh\Zgh ^hg OmZg
hiylv iheh`bek\hx jmdmgZ fhcjhl
Fu g_ _ebb g_aZ`b]Zeb d_jhkbgh\hceZfiu>hg OmZg
iheh`be fhx pbgh\dm\ k\h_cdhfgZl_ bmdZaZe gZg__ k\hbf
ih^[hjh^dhfY ihgyewlhdZd agZdqlh y^he`_g e_qvkiZlv
Y ohqmqlh[u luk^_eZe ijZ\bevgmx\_svkdZaZe fg_
^hg OmZgdZd lhevdhy ijhkgmekygZ ke_^mxs__mljhLu
gZqg_rv __k_]h^gyWlh g_aZcf_l fgh]h\j_f_gblu agZ_rv
Ihke_ hq_gv ^he]hc g_eh\dhc
iZmau y ihqm\kl\h\Ze
ihlj_[ghklv kijhkblv_]h
Wlh lhqlh lu^_eZe khfghc \dZgvhg_ \q_jZ"
>hg OmZgaZobobdZedZd j_[_ghd
Y ijhklhihklmqZe ^momlh]h \h^gh]hf_klZkdZaZe
hgwlhl \b^^moZ fh`_l[ulv \ua\Zgdh]^Z \h^gh_ f_klh
kmoh_dh]^Z ^mom_^bgbeky \]hj_<q_jZ yfh`gh kdZaZlv
ijh[m^be _]hba _]hkgZGh hgg_ bf_egbq_]h ijhlb\wlh]h b
mdZaZe l_[_m^Zqgh_ gZijZ\e_gb_?]h ]hehkbkoh^be bawlh]h
gZijZ\e_gby^hg OmZgmdZaZe gZx]h\hklhd
Qlh wlh[ue aZrgmjhdgZ dhlhjhflu b]jZe^hg OmZg"
Eh\bl_ev ^moh\
Fh]m yihkfhlj_lv gZg_]h"
G_lGh yk^_eZx l_[_lZdhcBeb_s_ emqr_lu kZf
k^_eZ_rv _]h ^ey k_[y
dZdgb[m^vdh]^Z lu gZmqbrvky
\ b^ _l v
Ba q_]hhg k^_eZg^hg OmZg"
Fhc ba dZ[ZgZDh]^Z luihemqbrv _]hlu ihcf_rv
qlh hg`b\hc bfh`_l gZmqblvl_[y jZaebqgufa\mdZfdhlhju_
_fm gjZ\ylkyK ijZdlbdhclu magZ_rvk\h_]h eh\bl_ey ^moh\
lZd ohjhrhqlh \f_kl_k gbflu [m^_rvba^Z\Zlv a\mdbiheghc
kbeu
Ihq_fm lu\aye f_gyh`b^Zlv ^moZ\h^gh]h f_klZ^hg
OmZg"
Lu hq_gvkdhjh magZ_rvwlh
Hdheh lh]h `_^gy fukb^_eb ih^_]h jZfZ^Z]^_
hg ijb]hlh\eyek\hx ljm[dmfg_ ^eydmj_gby
Hg \_e_e fg_ \klZlvdh]^Z
fh_ l_eh kh\_jr_ggh
hp_i_g_ehy k^_eZewlh k[hevrhc e_]dhklvxHg ihfh] fg_
ijhclbkvY m^b\bekyk\h_fm dhgljhexy ^_ckl\bl_evgh^\Z`^u
h[hr_e \hdjm] jZfZ^ZkZf>hg OmZggZoh^beky jy^hfgh g_
jmdh\h^be fghxb g_ih^^_j`b\Ze f_gyAZl_f hg\aye f_gyih^
jmdm bhl\_e ddZgZ\_ k\h^hcHg mkZ^bef_gy gZdjZc dZgZ\u
b ijbdZaZefg_ ih\_ebl_evghijbklZevgh kfhlj_lvgZ \h^mb gb
h q_f[hevr_ g_^mfZlv
Y iulZeky knhdmkbjh\Zlv k\hcijbklZevguc \a]ey^ gZ
\h^_gh __ ^\b`_gb_hl\e_dZeh f_gyFhc mfb fhb ]eZaZ
gZqZeb hldehgylvky gZ ^jm]b_ ij_^f_lu g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh]h
hdjm`_gby>hg OmZg ihljyk fhx]heh\m \\_jo b \gba b
ijbdZaZe fg_kgh\Z ijbklZevghkfhlj_lv lhevdhgZ \h^mb g_
^mfZlv \hh[s_Hg kdZaZeqlh ijbklZevgh kfhlj_lv gZ
^\b`msmxky \h^m [ueh ljm^ghgh qlh gm`gh ijh^he`Zlv
ijh[h\ZlvY ijh[h\Zeljb jZaZb dZ`^ucjZa y hl\e_dZeky
q_flh>hg OmZghq_gv mihjghljyk fhx]heh\m dZ`^uc jZa
GZdhg_py aZf_lbeqlh fhcmf bfhb ]eZaZ knhdmkbjh\Zebkv
gZ \h^_g_kfhljy gZ__ ^\b`_gb_y ih]jmabeky\ gZ[ex^_gb_
l_dmq_klb<h^Z klZeZg_kdhevdh ^jm]hcHgZdZaZehkv[ueZ
ly`_e__ bh^ghh[jZag__ [e_^gha_e_ghcY fh]aZf_lblv jy[v
ijb __^\b`_gbbJy[v [ueZqj_a\uqZcgh hlq_leb\hc: aZl_f
\g_aZighm f_gyihy\behkv hsms_gb_qlh ykfhlj_e g_ gZ
fZkkm ^\b`ms_cky \h^uZ gZdZjlbgm \h^uy \b^_e i_j_^
k\hbfb ]eZaZfb aZklu\rbc dmkhdl_dms_c \h^uJy[v [ueZ
g_ih^\b`ghcY fh]jZkkfhlj_lv dZ`^mxqZklbqdm __AZl_f hgZ
gZqZeZ ijbh[j_lZlva_e_gmx nhknhj_kp_gpbxb bag__ f_^e_ggh
bkl_dZe dZdhclh ]mklhclmfZg a_e_gh]hp\_lZ=mklhc lmfZg
jZkoh^beky ih jy[b bdh]^Z
hg ^\b]Zeky__ a_e_gv
klZgh\beZkv [he__ k\_jdZxs_c^h l_oihjihdZ g_ klZeZ
hke_ibl_evguf kbygb_fdhlhjh_ ihdjueh\k_
Y g_agZedZd ^he]hy gZoh^bekym dZgZ\u>hg OmZgg_
ij_ju\Ze f_gyY [ueih]jm`_g \a_e_gh_ k\_q_gb_ jy[bY
qm\kl\h\Zeqlh hgh\k_ \hdjm]f_gyHgh mkihdZb\Zehf_gyM
f_gy g_[ueh gbfuke_cgb qm\kl\<k_qlh mf_gy [uehwlh
kihdhcgh_ agZgb_agZgb_ hk\_jdZxs_cmkihdZb\Zxs_c a_e_gb
Qj_a\uqZcguc oheh^ b kujhklv[ueh ke_^mxs_c \_svx
dhlhjmx yklZe hkhagZ\ZlvIhkl_i_ggh yhkhagZeqlh y [ue
ih]jm`_g \dZgZ\m< wlhlfhf_gl \h^ZihiZeZ fg_\ ghkb y
aZdZreyekyijh]ehlb\ __M f_gy\ ghkm [ue jZa^jZ`Zxsbc
am^b yg_kdhevdh jZaqbogmeY \klZeb lZdkbevgh ba\mqgh
aZqboZeqlh ^Z`_ imdgme>hg OmZg aZoehiZe jmdZfb b
jZkohohlZeky
?keb l_ehimdZ_llh hgh`b\h_kdZaZe hg
Hg ihdZaZefg_ ke_^h\ZlvaZ gbfb fuihreb d_]h ^hfm
Y ^mfZe hkhojZg_gbb ihdhy< g_dhlhjhf hlghr_gbb y
h`b^Zeqlh y [m^m\ hkh[hfb fjZqghfgZkljh_gbbgh\
^_ckl\bl_evghklby g_qm\kl\h\Ze mklZehklbbeb f_eZgohebb
Y qm\kl\h\Zekdhj__`bag_jZ^hklghklvb hq_gv [ukljh
kf_gbe k\hxh^_`^mY klZegZk\bklu\Zlv>hg OmZgex[hiulgh
ihkfhlj_e gZf_gy bijbl\hjbeky m^b\e_ggufhg hldjuejhl b
\uimqbe ]eZaZ?]h nb]mjZ[ueZ hq_gvaZ[Z\ghcb y kf_yeky
g_fgh]h ^hevr_q_f lj_[h\Zehkv
Lu rmlbrvkdZaZe hgb aZkf_yekyhq_gv kbevghkZf
Y h[tykgbe _fmqlh yg_ ohl_eijb\udZlv d fjZqghfm
qm\kl\m ihke_mihlj_[e_gby _]hdmjbl_evghc kf_kbY kdZaZe
_fmqlh ihke_lh]hdZd hg\ulZkdb\Ze f_gyba dZgZ\u \h
\j_fy fhboihiulhd \klj_lblvkljZ`Zy klZem[_`^_gqlh y
fh] \b^_lv_keb y
ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_e \hdjm] f_gy
^hklZlhqgh ^he]h
< b^ _g v_
wlh g_kfhlj_gb_ bg_ khojZg_gb_
ihdhykdZaZe hg\ b^ _g v_
wlh l_ogbdZ
dhlhjmx gm`ghbamqZlvBebfh`_l [ulvwlh l_ogbdZdhlhjmx
g_dhlhju_ bagZk m`_agZxl
Hg \kfZljb\Z_lky\ f_gydZd [m^lhqlh[u gZf_dgmlvqlh
y [ueh^gbf bal_odlh m`_agZe l_ogbdm
Lu ^hklZlhqghkbevgucqlh[u ijh]meylvky"kijhkbe
hg
Y kdZaZeqlh qm\klk\h\Zek_[y ij_djZkghb qlhfh]mY
g_ [ue ]heh^_gohly yg_ _e\_kv ^_gv>hg OmZg iheh`be
oe_[ bg_kdhevdh dmkdh\kmr_gh]h fykZ\ jxdaZd\jmqbe _]h
fg_ bihdZaZe fg_]heh\hc ke_^h\ZlvaZ gbf
Dm^Z fub^_f"kijhkbe y
Hg mdZaZe keZ[uf ^\b`_gb_f]heh\u ih gZijZ\e_gbx d
ohefZfFu gZijZ\eyebkvd lhfm`_ dZgvhgm]^_ [ueh \h^gh_
f_klhgh g_\hreb \g_]h>hg OmZg\e_a gZkdZeu kijZ\Zhl
gZkm kZfh]hmklvy dZgvhgZFu ih^gyebkvgZ ohefKhegp_
[ueh ihqlb gZ]hjbahgl_;ue mf_j_gguc^_gvgh fg_ [ueh
`Zjdh by aZ^uoZekyY _^\Zfh] ^urZlv
>hg OmZg gZfgh]h
hi_j_^be
f_gy
b [ue \ugm`^_g
hklZgh\blvkyqlh[u iha\heblvfg_ ^h]gZlv_]hHg kdZaZe
qlh y [ue\ m`Zkghfnbabq_kdhf khklhygbbb qlh\hafh`gh
[ueh g_[eZ]hjZamfgh \hh[s_ b^lb^Zevr_Hg iha\hebe fg_
hl^hogmlv hdhehqZkZHg \u[jZe]eZ^dbcihqlb djm]euc\Zemg
b \_e_e fg_e_qv lZfHg jZkiheh`befh_ l_ehgZ dZfg_Hg
\_e_e fg_\ulygmlv jmdbb gh]bb himklblvbo k\h[h^ghFhy
kibgZ ke_]dZbah]gmeZkv br_y jZkkeZ[eZlZd qlhfhy ]heh\Z
lZd`_ k\h[h^gh ih\bkeZHg hklZ\bef_gy \ wlhf iheh`_gbb
ijbf_jgh gZ iylgZ^pZlvfbgmlAZl_f hg\_e_e fg_ hldjulv
`b\hlHg aZ[hleb\h hlh[jZe dZdb_lh \_ldb b ebklvy b
gZeh`be bo gZfhc ]heuc`b\hlY ihqm\kl\h\Ze f]gh\_ggmx
l_iehlm \h\k_f fh_fl_e_>hg OmZgaZl_f \ayef_gy aZgh]m
b ih\hjZqb\Zef_gy ^hl_o ihjihdZ fhy]heh\Z g_hdZaZeZkv
d x]h\hklhdm
L_i_jv ^Z\Zc ihah\_flh]h ^moZ \h^gh]h f_klZ
kdZaZe hg
Y ihiulZekyih\_jgmlv k\hx]heh\mqlh[u ihkfhlj_lvgZ
g_]hHg kkbehc m^_j`Zef_gy aZ\hehku bkdZaZeqlh y[ue
\ hq_gv mya\bfhf iheh`_gbbb \m`Zkgh keZ[hf nbabq_kdhf
khklhygbb b ^he`_ghklZ\Zlvky kihdhcgufb g_ih^\b`gufHg
iheh`be \k_ wlbhkh[u_ \_ldbgZ fhc`b\hlqlh[u aZsblblv
f_gyb kh[jZekyhklZ\Zlvky jy^hfkh fghcgZ kemqZc_keb y
g_ ihaZ[hqmkvh k_[_
Hg klhyem fZdmrdbfh_c ]heh\ub_keb y ih\hjZqb\Ze
k\hb ]eZaZy fh]\b^_lv _]hHg \ayek\hc rgmjhdb gZlygme
_]hgh aZl_fihgyeqlh ykfhlj_e gZg_]hih\_jgm\ fhb
]eZaZ dh e[mHg e_]dhklmdgme f_gy ih ]heh\_ k\hbfb
iZevpZfb bijbdZaZe fg_kfhlj_lv gZg_[hg_ aZdju\Zlv]eZa
b dhgp_gljbjh\Zlvky gZa\md_Hg ^h[Z\bedZd [u ih^mfZ\
qlh[u y g_kl_kgyeky \udjbdgmlvkeh\hdhlhjhfm hg gZmqbe
f_gy_keb yihqm\kl\mxqlh qlhlh gZiZ^Z_lgZ f_gy
>hg OmZg b _]h eh\bl_ev ^moh\gZqZeb k gbadh
gZlygmlh]h a\mdZHg f_^e_gghm\_ebqb\Ze gZly`_gb_b y
gZqZe keurZlvlZdh_ `_hljZ`_gb_b aZl_fykgh_ wohdhlhjh_
bkoh^beh
ba
x]h\hklhqgh]h
gZijZ\e_gbyGZly`_gb_
m\_ebqbehkv>hg OmZg b_]h eh\bl_ev ^moh\kh\_jr_ggh
khhl\_lkl\h\Zeb ^jm] ^jm]mRgmjhd ba^Z\Zegbadmx ghlmb
^hg OmZgm\_ebqb\Ze __mkbeb\Zy _]hgZly`_gb_ ^hl_o ihj
ihdZ ghlZg_ klZgh\beZkvijhgbdZxsbf \gmljva\mdhf\hxsbf
ah\hf<_jrbghc [ue`mldbc \ba]g_ihklb`bfuc klhqdb aj_gby
fh_]h kh[kl\_ggh]hhiulZ
A\md hljZ`Zeky\ ]hjZob hl^Z\Zekywohf gZaZ^d gZfY
ij_^klZ\be k_[_qlh
hg
ijboh^be
ijyfh
dh fg_Y
ihm\kl\h\Zeqlh hg^he`gh
[ulvqlhlh
k^_eZe k
l_fi_jZlmjhc fh_]hl_eZI_j_^ l_fdZd ^hgOmZg gZqZek\hb
ah\ufg_ [ueh hq_gvl_ieh bm^h[ghgh \h \j_fy \ukr_c
lhqdb _]h ah\h\y klZeaZf_jaZlvfhb am[u g_ijhba\hevgh
klmqZebb mf_gy ^_ckl\bl_evgh[ueh hsms_gb_qlh qlhlh
gZiZ^Z_l gZ f_gy< h^bgfhf_gl yaZf_lbeqlh g_[h klZeh
hq_gv l_fgufY g_khagZ\Ze g_[Zohly ykfhlj_e gZg_]hM
f_gy [ue fhf_gl kbevghc iZgbdbb y \udjbdgme keh\h
dhlhjhfm ^hgOmZg gZmqbef_gy
>hg OmZg f_^e_ggh gZqZe ihgb`Zlv gZijy`_gb_ k\hbo
`mldbo ah\h\gh wlhg_ ijbg_kehfg_ gbdZdh]hh[e_]q_gby
AZdjhc k\hb]eZaZih\_ebl_evgh ijh[hjfhlZe ^hg
OmZg
Y aZdjue bo jmdZfbQ_j_a g_kdhevdhfbgml ^hg OmZg
kh\k_f hklZgh\bekyb ih^hr_edh fg_k[hdmIhke_ lh]hdZd
hg m[jZe\_ldb bebklvy kfh_]h `b\hlZhg ihfh]fg_ \klZlv
b [_j_`ghiheh`be bogZ dZf_gv]^_ ye_`ZeHg aZ`_]bo b
dh]^Z hgbaZ]hj_ebkvjZkl_j fhc`b\hl ^jm]bfbebklvyfb ba
k\h_c kmfdb
Hg iheh`be k\hx jmdm gZ fhc jhldh]^Z y ohl_e
jZkkdZaZlv _fmqlh mf_gy [ueZm`ZkgZy ]heh\gZy[hev
Fu hklZ\ZebkvlZfihdZ \k_ebklvy g_k]hj_ebD lhfm
\j_f_gb klZehkh\_jr_ggh l_fghFu kimklbebkvk ohefZb y
^Ze \hexk\h_fm `_em^dm
Dh]^Z fu reb \^hevdZgZ\u^hg OmZg kdZaZeqlh y
k^_eZe ^hklZlhqgh bg_ ^he`_ghklZgZ\eb\ZlvkyY ihijhkbe
_]h h[tykgblvdZdbf [ue^mo \h^gh]hf_klZgh hg `_klhf
ihdZaZe fg_fheqZlvHg kdZaZeqlh fuih]h\hjbf h[wlhf \
^jm]h_ \j_fyaZl_f hgmfure_ggh kf_gbel_fm b ^Ze fg_
^he]h_ h[tykg_gb_ h \b ^_ gb bY kdZaZeqlh [ueh
ijbkdhj[ghqlh y g_fh] khkj_^hlhqblvky\ l_fghl_Hg
dZaZehkv[ue hq_gvjZ^b kdZaZeqlh [hevrmxqZklv \j_f_gb
y g_ m^_eyx \gbfZgbylhfmqlh hg]h\hjblihlhfm qlh y
ijbgye j_r_gb_aZibku\Zlv \k_
Hg ]h\hjbe h
\b ^_ gb bdZd h ijhp_kk_g_
aZ\bkys_f hl heebb hll_ogbdb fZ]bbFZ] wlh q_eh\_d
dhlhjuc fh]dhfZg^h\Zlv heebblZdbf h[jZahffZgbimebjh
\Zlv kbehc heeb k_[_ gZ ihevamgh lhl nZdlqlh hg
dhfZg^h\Ze heebg_ hagZqZeqlh hgfh] \b ^_ lv Y
gZihfgbe _fmqlh hg]h\hjbe fg_jZgvr_qlh g_\hafh`gh
\b^_lv_keb g_ bf__rvheeb>hg OmZg hq_gv kihdhcgh
aZf_lbeqlh hg ijbr_e dm[_`^_gbxqlh \hafh`gh [ueh
\b^_lvb \k_`_ g_dhfZg^h\Zlv heebHg qm\kl\h\Zeqlh
g_l ijbqbguihq_fm [ug_ lZdlZd dZd\b^_gv_g_ bf__l
gbq_]h h[s_]h k fZgbimeypbhgghcl_ogbdhc fZ]bbdhlhjZy
kem`bl lhevdh^ey lh]hqlh[u \ha^_ckl\h\ZlvgZ hdjm`Zxsbo
gZk ex^_cL_ogbdZ \b^_gvyk ^jm]hcklhjhgug_ bf__l
\ha^_ckl\by gZex^_c
Fhb fukeb [uebykgufbY g_bkiulu\Ze mklZehklb beb
khgeb\hklb b g_ bf_e[hevr_ g_ijbylgh]hqm\kl\Z \ k\h_f
`_em^d_dh]^Z fureb k^hghf OmZghfY [uem`Zkgh ]heh^_g
b dh]^Zfu ^h[jZebkv^h _]h^hfZy h[t_eky
Ihlhf y ihijhkbe_]h jZkkdZaZlvfg_ [hevr_h l_ogbd_
\b^_gvyHg rbjhdhmeu[gmeky fg_b kdZaZeqlh y[ue kgh\Z
kh[hc
DZd wlhlZdkdZaZe yqlh l_ogbdZ\b^_gvyg_
bf__l \ha^_ckl\bygZ hdjm`ZxsbogZk ex^_c"
Y m`_]h\hjbe l_[_kdZaZe hg\b^_gv_wlh g_
fZ]byB \k_ `_bo e_]dhkimlZlvihlhfm qlh q_eh\_d
dhlhjuc \b^blfh`_l
gZmqblvkykh\k_f fhf_glZevgh
mijZ\eylv heeb b fh`_l klZlvfZ]hfK ^jm]hc klhjhgu
q_eh\_d fh`_lgZmqblvky hij_^_e_gghcl_ogbd_ ^eylh]hqlh[u
dhfZg^h\Zlv heeb b lZdbfh[jZahf klZlvfZ]hfbl_f g_
f_g__hg fh`_lgbdh]^Z g_gZmqblvky \b^_lv
Djhf_ lh]h\b^_gv_ijhlb\hiheh`gh fZ]bb<b^_gv_
aZklZ\ey_l ihgylvg_agZqbl_evghklv \k_]hwlh]h
G_agZqbl_evghklv q_]h^hg OmZg"
G_agZqbl_evghklv \k_]h
Fu g_]h\hjbeb gbq_]h[hevr_Y qm\kl\h\Zek_[y hq_gv
jZkkeZ[e_gguf bg_ ohl_e]h\hjblv gbq_]h[hevr_Y e_`ZegZ
kibg_ gZ khehf_gghc pbgh\d_Fg_ kem`beZ ih^mrdhc fhy
g_ijh^m\gZy dmjldZY qm\kl\h\Zek_[y m^h[ghb kqZkleb\h b
ibkZe fhb aZf_ldb \l_q_gb_ qZkh\ijb k\_l_ d_jhkbgh\hc
eZfiu
<g_aZigh ^hgOmZg kgh\ZaZ]h\hjbe
K_]h^gy luk^_eZe hq_gvohjhrhkdZaZe hglu
hq_gv ohjhrh k^_eZe k
\h^hc>mom \h^gh]h f_klZ lu
gjZ\brvkyb hgihfh]Ze l_[_\kx ^hjh]m
Lh]^Z y ihgyeqlh
y
aZ[ue jZkkdZaZlv _fm fh_
i_j_`b\Zgb_Y gZqZehibku\Zlv kihkh[dhlhjuf y\hkijbgbfZe
\h^mHg g_^Ze fg_ijh^he`ZlvHg kdZaZeqlh hgagZeqlh
y \hkijbgbfZx]mklhc a_e_guclmfZg
Y ihqm\kl\h\Zeihlj_[ghklv kijhkblv
DZd lumagZe wlh^hg OmZg"
Y \b ^_ e
l_[y
Qlh y^_eZe"
Gbq_]hlu kb^_ea^_kv bijbklZevgh kfhlj_egZ \h^m
bgZdhg_plu hsmlbea_e_guc lmfZg
Wlh [ueh \b ^_ gv _"
G_lGh wlh[ueh hq_gv[ebadhLu ijb[eb`Z_rvky
Y klZehq_gv \a\hegh\ZgY ohl_eagZlv [hevr_h[ wlhf
Hg aZkf_yeky b ihrmlbegZ^ fhbfj\_gb_fHg kdZaZeqlh
\kydbc fh] hsmlblv a_e_guc lmfZgihlhfm qlh wlh [ueh
ih^h[gh kljZ`mqlhlhqlh [uehg_ba[_`gh lZfihwlhfm\
hsms_gbb wlh]hg_ [ueh[hevrh]h ^hklb`_gby
Dh]^Z ykdZaZe l_[_qlh luk^_eZe ohjhrhy bf_e \
\b^mqlh lug_ [_kihdhbekykdZaZe hglZd dZd lh]^Z
dh]^Z lubf_e ^_ehkh kljZ`_f?keb [ulu klZe[_kihdhblvky
y ^he`_g [ue [u\kljyogmlv l\hx]heh\m b ijb\_klb l_[y
gZaZ^Dh]^Z q_eh\_db^_l \a_e_guc lmfZg_]h [_g_nZdlhj
^he`_g gZoh^blvky ijb g_f gZ kemqZc_keb lhl gZqg_l
aZfZgb\Zlv _]hLu fh`_rv\ukdhqblv baij_^_eh\ ^hky]Z_fhklb
kljZ`Z kZfgh lug_ fh`_rvkZf ba[_`Zlv dh]l_c a_e_gh]h
lmfZgZIh djZcg_c f_j_g_ \gZqZe_Iha`_ lu kfh`_rv
gZmqblvky kihkh[m ^_eZlv wlhL_i_jv fu iulZ_fky magZlv
g_qlh ^jm]h_
Qlh `_fu iulZ_fkymagZlv"
Fh`_rv eblu \b ^_ lv
\h^m
DZd `_ ymagZxqlh y \b ^_ e
__beb qlh y
\ b` m
__"
Lu magZ_rvLu imlZ_rvkylhevdh dh]^Zlu ]h\hjbrv
=eZ\Z
^\ _g Z^ pZ lZ y
JZ[hlZy gZ^ k\hbfb
aZf_ldZfby
gZlhedgmeky gZ
jZaebqgu_ \hijhku
?klv eb a_e_guc lmfZgdZd b kljZ`g_qlhqlh
g_h[oh^bfh ih[_^blv ^ey lh]hqlh[u
\b ^_ lv "
kijhkbe y ^hgZOmZgZdZd lhevdhfu k_ebih^ _]hjZfZ^Z Z\]mklZ ]h^Z
>ZGm`gh ih[_`^Zlv\k_
DZd yfh]m ih[_^blva_e_guc lmfZg"
L_f `_kihkh[hfdZdbf luih[_^be kljZ`Ziha\heblv
_fm h[jZlblvky\ gbqlh
Qlh `_y ^he`_gk^_eZlv"
Gbq_]h>ey l_[ya_e_guc lmfZggZfgh]h e_]q_q_f
kljZ`>mom \h^gh]h f_klZlu gjZ\brvky\ lh \j_fydZd
dhg_qghg_ kl\hbf l_fi_jZf_glhfbf_lv ^_ehkh kljZ`_fLu
gbdh]^Z j_Zevghg_ \b ^_ e
kljZ`Z
Fh`_l [ulvwlh [uehihlhfmqlh hgg_ gjZ\bekyfg_"
Qlh_keb [u y\klj_lbe kljZ`Zdhlhjuc fg_ ihgjZ\beky"
>he`gh [ulvg_dhlhju_ ex^bfh]ml ihkqblZlvkljZ`Zdhlhjh]h
y \klj_lbedjZkb\uf kms_kl\hfIh[_^beb [uhgb _]hihlhfm
qlh hgihgjZ\beky bf"
G_lLu \k_`_ g_ihgbfZ_rvG_ bf__l agZq_gby
gjZ\blky eb l_[_ bebg_ gjZ\blkykljZ`?keb lu bf__rv
qm\kl\h d g_fmkljZ` hklZg_lkyl_f `_kZfufqm^h\bsguf
ij_djZkguf bebex[uf ^jm]bf?keb ml_[y g_lqm\kl\Z dg_fm
k ^jm]hc klhjhgukljZ` klZg_lgbq_f b[m^_l \k_ `_ lZf
i_j_^ lh[hc
Fukevqlh g_qlhlZdh_ ]jhfZ^gh_dZd kljZ`fh]eh
klZlv gbq_f b \k_ `_ [ulv i_j_^ fhbfb ]eZaZfb[ueZ
Z[khexlgh [_kkfuke_gghcY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh wlh[ueh h^ghcba
Zeh]bqguo ij_^ihkuehd agZgby^hgZ OmZgZH^gZdhy lZd`_
qm\kl\h\Zeqlh_keb [uhg aZohl_ehg fh][u h[tykgblvwlh
fg_Y gZklZb\ZekijZrb\Zy _]hh lhfqlh hgbf_e \ \b^m
ih^ wlbf
Lu ^mfZ_rvqlh kljZ`[ue q_flhqlh luagZewlh
lhqlh ybf_x \\b^m
Gh yg_ ^mfZeqlh wlh[ueh qlhlhqlh yagZe
Lu ^mfZeqlh hg[ue [_ah[jZaguf?]h jZaf_ju [ueb
ihljykZxsbfbWlh [ueh qm^h\bs_Lu agZe wlb \k_ \_sb
IhwlhfmkljZ` [ue\k_]^Z q_flhqlh luagZeb ihdZhg [ue
q_flhqlh luagZelZ g_ \b ^_ e
_]hY ]h\hjbel_[_
m`_qlh kljZ` ^he`_gklZlv gbq_fb\k_ `_hg ^he`_g
hklZ\Zlvky i_j_^ lh[hcHg ^he`_g[ulv lZfb hg\ lh `_
kZfh_ \j_fy^he`_g [ulvgbq_f
DZd `_wlh fh`_l[ulv^hg OmZg"Lu ]h\hjbrvZ[kmj^
>ZGh wlhb _klv \b ^_ gv _< ^_ckl\bl_
evghklb[_kihe_agh ]h\hjblv h[wlhf<b^_gv_dZd y
]h\hjbe ij_`^_magZ_lky ihkj_^kl\hf\b^_gvy
Hq_\b^ghm l_[y g_lijh[e_f k \h^hcLu ihqlb
\b^_e__ gZ^gyo<h^Z wlh l\hcdZj^bgZevguc imgdl
<k_qlh l_i_jv gm`gh l_[_wlh kh\_jr_gkl\h\Zlv k\hx
l_ogbdm \b^_gvyLu bf__rvkbevgh]h ihfhsgbdZ \ ^mo_
\h^gh]h f_klZ
Wlh ^jm]hcfhc `]mqbc\hijhk^hg OmZg
Lu fh`_rvbf_lv \k_`]mqb_ \hijhkudZdb_ ohq_rvgh
fu g_ fh`_f]h\hjblv h^mo_ \h^gh]hf_klZ \_]h jZchg_<
^_ckl\bl_evghlbemqr_ g_^mfZlv h[wlhf kh\k_fG_ ^mfZlv
kh\k_f< ijhlb\ghfkemqZ_ ^moaZfZgbl l_[yb_keb wlh
kemqZ_lkyg_l gbq_]hqlh `b\hcq_eh\_d fh`_l k^_eZlv
qlh[u ihfhqv l_[_Ihwlhfm^_j`b k\hc jhl aZdjulufb
m^_j`b\Zc k\hbfukeb gZq_fgb[m^v _s_
Hdheh ^_kylb qZkh\gZ ke_^mxs__mljh ^hg OmZg \ugme
k\hx ljm[dm ba nmleyjZgZihegbe __ dmjbl_evghc kf_kvx
aZl_f \jmqbe__ fg_b \_e_efg_ hlg_klb__ gZ[_j_] jmqvy
>_j`Z ljm[dm^\mfy jmdZfby kmf_ejZkkl_]gmlv k\hxjm[Zrdm
iheh`blv ljm[dm\gmljv bdj_idh ^_j`Zlv__>hg OmZgijbg_k
^\Z khehf_gguofZlZ bg_[hevrhc ih^ghkk m]eyfb;ue l_ieuc
^_gvFu k_eb gZpbgh\db \l_gb g_[hevrhc jhsb ^_j_\v_\
[ j_ Z
mkZfh]h djZy\h^u>hg OmZgiheh`be m]hev\ qZrdm
ljm[db b\_e_e fg_dmjblvM f_gyg_ [uehgbdZdh]h hiZk_gby
beb dZdh]hgb[m^v
qm\kl\Z
ijbih^gylh]h
gZkljh_gbyY
\kihfgbeqlh \h\j_fy fh_c\lhjhc ihiuldb\b^_lvkljZ`Z
ihke_ lh]hdZd ^hgOmZg h[tykgbe_]h ijbjh^mm f_gy [ueh
hkh[h_ hsms_gb_ m^b\e_gby b[eZ]h]h\_gbyGZ wlhl jZa
h^gZdhohly ^hg OmZg
ij_^mij_^be f_gy h \hafh`ghklb
^_ckl\bl_evgh]h \b^_gvy\h^um f_gyg_ [ueh wfhpbhgZ
evgh]h m\e_q_gbym f_gy[ueh lhevdhex[hiulkl\h
>hg OmZg aZklZ\be
f_gy
dmjblv
^\Z`^u \h \j_fy
ij_^u^msbo ihiulhd< ^Zgguc
fhf_gl
hg gZdehgbeky b
ijhr_ilZe \fh_ ijZ\h_mohqlh hgkh[bjZ_lky gZmqblvf_gy
dZd bkihevah\Zlv \h^m
^ey
lh]hqlh[u ^\b]ZlvkyY
qm\kl\h\Ze _]h ebphhq_gv [ebadhdZd [m^lh hg ijbklZ\be
k\hc jhl d fh_fmmomHg kdZaZefg_qlh[u y g_ kfhlj_e
ijbklZevgh gZ\h^mZ knhdmkbjh\Zek\hb ]eZaZgZ ih\_joghklb
b \gbfZl_evghkfhlj_e ^hl_o ihjihdZ \h^Zg_ ij_\jZlblky\
a_e_guc ]mklhc lmfZgHg ih\lhjbe_s_ b_s_qlh y ^he`_g
khkj_^hlhqblv k\h_ \gbfZgb_gZ lmfZg_^h l_oihjihdZ g_
h[gZjm`m q_]hgb[m^v _s_
Kfhljb gZ\h^m i_j_^kh[hckeurZe y_]h ]hehk
gh g_ iha\heyc__ a\mdmmg_klb l_[ydm^Zgb[m^v?keb lu
iha\hebrv a\mdm\h^u mg_klbl_[yy g_kfh]m gbdh]^Z gZclb
l_[y b ijb\_klb h[jZlghL_i_jv \hc^b\ a_e_guc lmfZg b
ijbkemrZcky dfh_fm ]hehkm
Y kemrZeb ihgbfZe_]h kqj_a\uqZcghc ykghklvxY gZqZe
\gbfZl_evgh kfhlj_lvgZ \h^mb bf_ehq_gv g_h[uqgh_hsms_gb_
nbabq_kdh]h m^h\hevkl\by am^g_hij_^_e_ggh_ kqZklv_Y
^he]h_ \j_fyijbklZevgh kfhlj_egh g_h[gZjm`b\Ze a_e_gh]h
lmfZgZY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh fhb]eZaZ \uoh^bebba nhdmkZb y
^he`_g [ue[hjhlvkyqlh[u m^_j`b\Zlvk\hc \a]ey^gZ \h^_
gZdhg_py [hevr_g_ kfh]dhgljhebjh\Zlv k\hb]eZaZ b [ue
\ugm`^_g aZdjulv bobeb fb]gmlvbeb\hafh`ghy ijhklh
ihl_jye k\hxkihkh[ghklv nhdmkbjh\Zlvky\h \kydhfkemqZ_\
wlhl kZfuc
fhf_gl
\h^Z
hklZgh\beZkvhgZ i_j_klZeZ
^\b]ZlvkyHgZdZaZehkvklZeZ
dZjlbghcJy[v [ueZ
g_ih^\b`ghcAZl_f \h^ZgZqZeZ keZ[hrbi_lvdZd [m^lh\ g_c
[ueb qZklbqdb dZj[hgZlZdhlhju_ kjZam \aju\ZebkvQ_j_a
f]gh\_gb_ y m\b^_eqlh rbi_gb_ f_^e_ggh jZkrbjbehkv \
a_e_gh_ \_s_kl\hWlh [ue[_afhe\guc \aju\\h^Z \ahj\ZeZkv
k\_jdZxsbf a_e_guflmfZghfdhlhjuc jZkijhkljZgyeky^h l_o
ihjihdZ g_ho\Zlbe f_gy
Y hklZ\Zeky\a\_r_gguf \g_f ^hl_o ihjihdZ hkljuc
g_ij_ju\guc j_adbc rmf g_ihljyk \k_lmfZgdZaZehkv
aZklue \ h[uqgu_q_jlu \h^ghcih\_joghklbJ_adbc rmf [ue
\udjbdhf ^hgZOmZgZ hdhehfh_]h moZo_ccccHg \_e_efg_
ijbkemrb\Zlvky d _]h ]hehkmb \_jgmlvkygZaZ^ \ lmfZg b
`^Zlv lZf ^hl_o ihjihdZ hgg_ ihah\_lf_gyY kdZaZe
htd_cihZg]ebckdbb mkeurZe]h]hqmsbc rmf_]h kf_oZ
Ih`ZemcklZg_ jZa]h\Zjb\ZckdZaZe hgG_
\u^Z\Zc fg_[hevr_ gbdZdbohtd_c
Y fh] keurZlv_]h hq_gvohjhrhA\md _]h ]hehkZ [ue
f_eh^bqguf b]eZ\guf h[jZahf^jm`_kl\_ggufY agZewlhg_
^mfZywlh [uehm[_`^_gb_dhlhjh_ ijbrehfg_ \]heh\mZ
aZl_f ijhreh
=hehk ^hgZ OmZgZijbdZaZe fg_khkj_^hlhqblv \k_ fh_
\gbfZgb_ gZ lmfZg_gh g_ij_^Z\Zlvky _fmHg ih\lhjgh
kdZaZeqlh \hbgg_ ^he`_gij_^Z\Zlv k_[ygbq_fm^Z`_ k\h_c
kf_jlbY ih]jmabeky\ lmfZgkgh\Z baZf_lbeqlh wlh [ue
kh\k_f g_lmfZg bebih djZcg_cf_j_wlh g_[ueh l_fqlh
dZd y [ue m[_`^_g[ueh ih^h[gh lmfZgmLmfZghih^h[guc
n_ghf_g khklhyeba djhr_qguoimaujvdh\djm]euo ij_^f_lh\
dhlhju_ \oh^beb \ h[eZklvaj_gbyb m^Zeyebkv ba g__
mieu\ZyY g_dhlhjh_\j_fy gZ[ex^Zebo ^\b`_gb_Z aZl_f
]jhfdbchl^Ze_gguc rmf\kljyogme fh_\gbfZgb_b yihl_jye
kihkh[ghklv khkj_^hlhqb\Zlvkyb g_fh] [hevr_ \hkijbgbfZlv
djhr_qgu_ imaujvdb<k_qlh ykhagZ\Ze aZl_fwlh a_e_guc
ZfhjnguclmfZghih^h[guc k\_lY mkeurZe]jhfdbc rmfkgh\Z
b _]h \kljykdZkjZam jZah]gZeZlmfZgb y h[gZjm`beqlh
kfhlj_e gZ\h^m \hjhkbl_evghc dZgZ\_AZl_f ymkeurZe _]h
kgh\Zfgh]h [eb`_wlh [ue]hehk ^hgZOmZgZHg ]h\hjbe
fg_qlh[u yh[jZlbe \gbfZgb_gZ g_]hihlhfm qlh_]h ]hehk
[ue _^bgkl\_gguf ijh\h^gbdhf ^eyf_gyHg ijbdZaZe fg_
kfhlj_lv gZ[_j_] bgZ jZklbl_evghklvijyfh i_j_^kh[hcY
\b^_e ljhklgbd b ijhkljZgkl\hdhlhjh_ [ueh k\h[h^gh hl
ljhklgbdZWlh [ueZfZe_gvdZy [molhqdZ\ [_j_]_f_klhdm^Z
^hg OmZg ijboh^be himkdZlv\_^jh bgZihegylv _]h \h^hc
Q_j_a g_dhlhjh_\j_fy ^hgOmZg ijbdZaZefg_ \_jgmlvky\gh\v
d lmfZgm b kgh\Zihijhkbe f_gyh[jZsZlv \gbfZgb_ gZ _]h
]hehkihlhfm qlhhg kh[bjZekyjmdh\h^blv fghclZdqlh[u y
fh] gZmqblvkydZdbf h[jZahf^\b]Zlvkyhg kdZaZeqlh jZa
y m\b^_e imaujvdby ^he`_g\aylv h^bgba gbob iha\heblv
_fm mg_klbf_gy
Y ih\bgh\Zeky_fm b[ue kjZamhdjm`_g a_e_guflmfZghf
Z aZl_fy m\b^_edjhr_qgu_ imaujvdbY kgh\ZmkeurZe ]hehk
^hgZ OmZgZdZd hq_gvg_h[uqgh_ bim]Zxs__ ]jhohlZgb_KjZam
`_ aZ wlbf ygZqZe l_jylvk\hx kihkh[ghklv \hkijbgbfZlv
imaujvdb
<a[_jbkv gZh^bg bawlbo imaujvdh\mkeurZe y _]h
]hehk
Y klZjZekym^_j`Zlv k\h_\hkijbylb_ a_e_guoimaujvdh\ b
\ lh `_ \j_fykemrZlv _]h]hehkY g_agZedZd ^he]h y
klZjZeky ^_eZlv wlhdh]^Z \g_aZighy hkhagZeqlh y fh]
keurZlv _]h b \k_ `_khojZgylv \b^ imaujvdh\dhlhju_
ijh^he`Zeb ijhoh^blvf_^e_ggh
mieu\Zy
ba fh_]h ihey
\hkijbylby=hehk ^hgZ OmZgZih[m`^Ze f_gy ke_^h\Zlv aZ
h^gbf bagbo b\ah[jZlvky gZg_]h
Y m^b\bekydZd
y
ij_^iheZ]Ze
k^_eZlv
wlhb
Z\lhfZlbq_kdb ijhbag_k keh\h dZdY ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh
keh\h [uehhq_gv ]em[hdh\gmljb f_gybdh]^Z hgh\urehhgh
ihg_keh f_gyd ih\_joghklbKeh\h [uehih^h[gh [mxdhlhjuc
\ur_e ba fh_c]em[bguY keurZeqlh ykdZaZe dZdb y
ba^Ze a\mdih^h[gh \hxs_ckh[Zd_>hg OmZglh`_ aZ\uelZd
`_ dZd kh[ZdZZ aZl_fhg ba^Zeg_kdhevdh a\mdh\dhchlZ b
aZkf_yekyY ih^mfZeqlh wlhhq_gv aZ[Z\ghb ^_ckl\bl_evgh
aZkf_yeky
>hg OmZg kdZaZefg_ hq_gvkihdhcghqlh[u y iha\hebe
k_[_ ijbdj_iblvkyd imaujvdmb ke_^h\ZlvaZ gbf
<_jgbkv kgh\ZkdZaZe hg<hc^b \lmfZg< lmfZg
Y \_jgmeky
b
aZf_lbeqlh
^\b`_gb_
imaujvdh\
aZf_^ebehkvb hgbklZeb [hevr_dZd [Zkd_l[hevgu_fyqb<
^_ckl\bl_evghklbhgb [ueblZdbfb [hevrbfbb f_^e_ggufbqlh
y fh] jZkkfhlj_lvdZ`^uc bagbo \h\k_o ih^jh[ghklyoWlh
[ueb g_imaujvdb\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbb g_[ueb ih^h[gu gb
iZjys_fm imaujxgb \ha^mrghfmrZjmgb ex[hfm ^jm]hfm
kn_jbq_kdhfm dhgl_cg_jmHgb g_[ueb khkm^Zfbb\k_ `_
hgb [ueb khkm^ZfbG_ [uebhgb bdjm]eufbohlydh]^Z y
\i_j\u_ \hkijbgye boy fh][u ihdeyklvkyqlh hgb [ueb
djm]eufbb h[jZadhlhjuc ijbr_e
fg_ gZ mf[ue imaujvdbY jZkkfZljb\Ze bodZd [m^lh kfhlj_e kd\hav
kl_dehlh _klvdZd [ujZfZ hdgZg_ iha\heyeZfg_ ke_^h\Zlv
aZ gbfbgh lhevdhgZ[ex^Zlv aZbo ijboh^hfb moh^hf ba
kn_ju fh_]h\hkijbylby
Dh]^Z y i_j_klZe jZkkfZljb\Zlv
bodZd imaujvdb
h^gZdhy [uekihkh[_g ke_^h\ZlvaZ gbfbke_^my aZgbfby
ijbdj_ibeky dh^ghfm bagbo bihieue kgbfY ^_ckl\bl_evgh
qm\kl\h\Zeqlh
y
^\b]ZekyYnZdlbq_kdb[ ue
imaujvdhf beblhc \_svxdhlhjZy ihoh^beZgZ g_]h
AZl_f ymkeurZe gZklhcqb\uca\md ]hehkZ^hgZ OmZgZWlh
\kljyogmeh f_gyb yihl_jye k\h_qm\kl\h [ulvbfA\md [ue
qj_a\uqZcgh bkim]Zggucwlh [uehl^Ze_gguc ]hehkhq_gv
f_lZeebq_kdbcdZd [m^lhhg ]h\hjbeq_j_a ]jhfdh]h\hjbl_ev
Y jZah[jZeg_dhlhju_ bakeh\
Ihkfhljb gZ[_j_]]h\hjbe hg
Y m\b^_ehq_gv [hevrmxfZkkm \h^u<h^Z g_keZkvY fh]
keurZlv rmf__ ^\b`_gby
Ihkfhljb gZ[_j_]kgh\Z ijbdZaZefg_ ^hgOmZg
Y m\b^_e[_lhggmx kl_gm
A\md \h^uklZe m`Zkgh]jhfdbfa\md \h^uih]ehsZe f_gy
AZl_f hgf]gh\_ggh i_j_klZedZd [m^lh[ue h[j_aZgM f_gy
[ueh hsms_gb_l_fghlukgZ
Y klZekhagZ\Zlvqlh yih]jm`_g \hjhkbl_evgmx dZgZ\m
>hg OmZg ie_kdZe \h^hc fg_\ ebphb ]h\hjbeAZl_f hg
ih]jmabe f_gy \dZgZ\mHg \ulygmefhx ]heh\m \\_jogZ^
ih\_joghklvxb iha\hebefg_ iheh`blv__ gZ [_j_]^_j`Z
f_gy kaZ^b aZ\hjhlgbd jm[Zrdb< fhbojmdZo bgh]Zo [ueh
hq_gv ijbylgh_ hsms_gb_Y \ulygmeboFhb ]eZaZmklZeb b
am^_eby ih^gyek\hx ijZ\mxjmdmqlh[u ihl_j_lvboWlh
[ueh ljm^guf^\b`_gb_fFhy jmdZdZaZehkv[ueZ ly`_ehcY
fh] _^\Z\ugmlv __ba \h^ughdh]^Z yk^_eZe wlhfhy jmdZ
\ureZ ihdjulhckZfhc m^b\bl_evghcfZkkhc a_e_gh]hlmfZgZY
^_j`Ze k\hxjmdm i_j_^]eZaZfbY fh]\b^_lv __dhglmjdZd
l_fg_xsmx fZkkm
a_e_gbhdjm`_ggmx
hq_gv bgl_gkb\guf
a_e_gh\Zluf lmfZghfY \ki_rd_ ^h[jZeky^h gh]b \klZe \
kj_^bg_ l_q_gbyb ihkfhlj_egZ k\h_l_ehfhy ]jm^vjmdb b
gh]b [ueb
a_e_gufb]mklha_e_gufbP\_l
[ue lZdbf
bgl_gkb\gufqlh fg_i_j_^Zehkv qm\kl\h\yadh]h \_s_kl\ZY
\u]ey^_e ih^h[gh klZlmwld_dhlhjmx ^hgOmZg k^_eZe fg_
g_kdhevdh e_lgZaZ^ badhjgy ^mjfZgZ
>hg OmZg\_e_e fg_\uclbY aZf_lbegZklhcqb\hklv \_]h
]hehk_
Y a_e_guckdZaZe y
;jhkv wlhkdZaZe hgih\_ebl_evghM l_[y g_l
\j_f_gb<ue_aZc hllm^Z<h^Z aZfZgb\Z_ll_[y<ue_aZc ba
g__<ue_aZc<ue_aZc
Y \ukdhqbe\ iZgbd_
GZ wlhl jZa lu^he`_g jZkkdZaZlv fg_ \k_qlh
ijhbkoh^behkdZaZe hggZ kZfhf^_e_dZd lhevdhfu k_eb
ebphf ^jm]d ^jm]m\ _]hdhfgZl_
Hg
g_
bgl_j_kh\Zeky
ihke_^h\Zl_evghklvx
fh_]h
i_j_`b\Zgbyhg ohl_eagZlv lhevdhlhk q_fy \klj_lbeky
dh]^Z hg \_e_efg_ ihkfhlj_lvgZ [_j_]Hg bgl_j_kh\Zeky
ih^jh[ghklyfbY hibkZe kl_gmdhlhjmx y\b^_e
;ueZ ebkl_gZ kijZ\Zbeb ke_\Z"kijhkbe hg
Y kdZaZe_fmqlh kl_gZ[ueZ \^_ckl\bl_evghklb i_j_^h
fghcGh hggZklZb\Zeqlh hgZ^he`gZ [ueZ[ulv bebkijZ\Z
beb ke_\Z
Dh]^Z lu\i_j\u_ m\b^_e__]^_ hgZ[ueZ"AZdjhc k\hb
]eZaZ bg_ hldju\ZcboihdZ g_\kihfgbrv
Hg \klZeb ih\hjZqb\Zefh_ l_ehdh]^Z yaZdjue ]eZaZ
^h l_o ihjihdZ g_ih\_jgme f_gyebphf gZ\hklhd \ lhf
gZijZ\e_gbb\ dhlhjhfy [uedh]^Z kb^_ei_j_^ l_q_gb_fHg
kijhkbe f_gy\ dZdhfgZijZ\e_gbb y^\b]Zeky
Y kdZaZeqlh ybf_e ^\b`_gb_\i_j_^\i_j_^b i_j_^h
fghcHg gZklZb\Zeqlh y^he`_g \kihfgblvb khkj_^hlhqblvky
gZ \j_f_gbdh]^Z y\k_ _s_\b^_e \h^mdZd imaujvdb
DZdbf iml_fhgb l_deb"kijhkbe hg
>hg OmZg m[_`^Ze f_gy
\kihfgblvbgZdhg_py
ijbagZekyqlh imaujvdbdZaZehkv^he`gu [ueb^\b]Zlvky dh
fg_ kijZ\ZH^gZdhy g_[ue kh\_jr_ggh m\_j_gdZd hg
ohl_eIh^ _]hjZkke_^h\Zgb_f ygZqZe hkhagZ\Zlvqlh y g_
[ue kihkh[_g deZkkbnbpbjh\Zlv k\h_ \hkijbylb_Imaujvdb
^\b]Zebkv dhfg_ kijZ\Zdh]^Z y\i_j\u_ \b^_ebogh dh]^Z
hgb klZeb [hevr_hgb l_deb \kx^mG_dhlhju_ ba gbo
dZaZehkvreb ijyfhgZ f_gy^jm]b_dZaZehkv^\b]Zebkv \h
\k_o \hafh`guo
gZijZ\e_gbyo;ueb
imaujvdbdhlhju_
^\b]Zebkv \ur_ b gb`_f_gyNZdlbq_kdbhgb [ueb \_a^_
\hdjm] f_gyY \kihfgbeqlh keurZebo rbi_gb_ihwlhfm y
^he`_g [ue \hkijbgbfZlv bo k\hbfbmrZfb lZd `_dZd b
]eZaZfb
Dh]^Z imaujvdb klZeb lZdbfb [hevrbfbqlh y kfh]
\ah[jZlvkygZ h^bgba gboy m\b^_eqlh hgb l_jebkv
^jm] h^jm]Z ih^h[gh\ha^mrguf rZjZf
Fh_ \ha[m`^_gb_mkbebehkvdh]^Z y\kihfgbe ih^jh[ghklb
fh_]h \hkijbylby>hg
OmZgh^gZdhkh\_jr_ggh
g_
bgl_j_kh\Zeky wlbfY kdZaZe
_fmqlh \b^_e rbiysb_
imaujvdbWlh g_[ue qbklhkemoh\hc beb qbklh \bamZevguc
wnn_dlgh wlh[ueh qlhlh g_jZaebqbfh_djbklZevgh ykgh_
imaujvdb l_jebkv ^jm]h ^jm]ZY g_\b^_e bg_ keurZe bo
^\b`_gby y qm\kl\h\Ze_]hy [ueqZklvx a\mdZb ^\b`_gby
Dh]^Z y jZkkdZaZe h
fh_f i_j_`b\Zgbby ]em[hdh
jZa\hegh\ZekyY ^_j`Ze _]h jmdmb ljyk __ \ [hevrhf
\heg_gbbY ihgyeqlh imaujvdbg_ bf_eb\g_rg_]h ij_^_eZ
l_f g_f_g__hgb \f_sZeb\ k_[yb bodjZy f_gyebnhjfm b
[ueb g_jh\gufb
am[j_ggufbImaujvdb keb\Zebkv b
jZa^_eyebkv k[hevrhc kdhjhklvxh^gZdhbo ^\b`_gb_g_ [ueh
hke_ieyxsbf [e_kdhfBo ^\b`_gb_[ueh mklhcqb\ufb\ lh`_
kZfh_ \j_fyf_^e_gguf
>jm]hc \_svxdhlhjmx y\kihfgbedh]^Z jZkkdZau\Ze
k\h_ i_j_`b\Zgb_[ueh dZq_kl\hp\_lZdhlhjuf imaujvdb
dZaZehkvh[eZ^ZebHgb [uebijhajZqgufb bhq_gv yjdbfb b
dZaZebkv ihqlb a_e_gufbohly wlh[ue g_ p\_ldZdbf y
ijb\ud \hkijbgbfZlvp\_lZ
Lu mdehgy_rvkykdZaZe ^hgOmZgWlb \_sb g_
y\eyxlky \Z`gufbLu
aZ^_j`b\Z_rvky
gZ
g_ijZ\bevguo
ij_^f_lZoGZijZ\e_gb_ _^bgkl\_ggh \Z`guc\uoh^
Y fh]lhevdh \kihfgblvqlh y^\b]Zeky [_a dZdhceb[h
lhqdb hlghr_gbygh ^hgOmZg aZdexqbeqlh lZddZd imaujvdb
ieueb ihke_^h\Zl_evghdh fg_kijZ\Zk x]Z\gZqZe_lh wlhl
x] [uegZijZ\e_gb_fk dhlhjufy ^he`_g[ue bf_lv^_ehHg
gZqZe ih\_ebl_evghih[m`^Zlv f_gy\kihfgblv[ueZ eb kl_gZ
hl f_gykijZ\Z bebke_\ZY klZjZeky\kihfgblv
Dh]^Z ^hgOmZg iha\Ze f_gyb y\kieuelZd kdZaZlvy
^mfZeqlh kl_gZ[ueZ hlf_gy ke_\ZY [uehq_gv [ebadh d
g_c b fh]jZaebqblv `_eh[dbb \uklmiu^_j_\ygghc ZjfZlmju
beb hiem[db\ dhlhjmx[ue aZebl[_lhgHq_gv lhgdb_ihehkdb
^_j_\Z [ueb bkihevah\Zgub jbkmghddhlhjuc hgb kha^Zeb
[ue dhfiZdlgufKl_gZ [ueZhq_gv \ukhdhcFg_ [ue\b^_g h^bg
dhg_p __b yaZf_lbeqlh hgg_ bf_em]eZhg [ue \kx^m
bah]gml
Hg kb^_e\ lbrbg_g_dhlhjh_ \j_fydZd [uaZ^mfZ\rbkv h
lhfdZd jZkrbnjh\Zlvkfuke fh_]hi_j_`b\ZgbybgZdhg_p
kdZaZeqlh yg_ ^hklb]fgh]h]h bqlh yg_ ^hklb]lh]hqlh
hg h`b^Zehl f_gy
Qlh `_fg_ iheZ]Zehkvk^_eZlv"
Hg g_hl\_lbegh kfhjsbe]m[u
Lu ^_eZe hq_gvohjhrhkdZaZe hgK_]h^gy lu
magZeqlh [jmohbkihevamxl \h^mqlh[u ^\b]Zlvky
Gh \b^_eeb y"
Hg ihkfhlj_egZ f_gyk ex[hiulkl\hfHg ih\_jgme]eZaZ
b kdZaZeqlh y^he`_g \oh^blv\ a_e_guclmfZg hq_gv fgh]h
jZaihdZ g_hl\_qm gZk\hc \hijhkHg baf_gbe gZijZ\e_gb_
gZr_]h jZa]h\hjZ lhgdbf
kihkh[hfkdZaZ\qlh y\
^_ckl\bl_evghklbg_
magZedZd
^\b]Zlvkyqlh[u
bkihevah\Zlv \h^mgh ymagZeqlh [jmohfh] ^_eZlvwlhb
hg mfure_gghkdZaZe fg_ihkfhlj_lv gZ[_j_] ihlhdZqlh[u y
fh] hklZgh\blvk\h_ ^\b`_gb_
Lu ^\b]Zeky hq_gv[ukljhkdZaZe hglZd `_
[ukljhdZd q_eh\_ddhlhjuc agZ_ldZd \uihegylv wlm
l_ogbdmFg_ ly`_ehg_ hlklZ\Zlvhl l_[y
Y ihijhkbe _]h h[tykgblvqlh kemqbehkvkh fghck
gZqZeZHg aZkf_yekyke_]dZ ihdZqZ\k\h_c ]heh\hcdZd [m^lh
k g_^h\_jb_f
Lu \k_]^Z gZklZb\Z_rv gZagZgbb \_s_c k kZfh]h
gZqZeZkdZaZe hgGh lZfg_l gZqZeZgZqZeh _klvlhevdh
m l\h_cfukeb
Y ^mfZxqlh gZqZeh[uehdh]^Z ykb^_e gZ [_j_]m b
dmjbekdZaZe y
Gh ij_`^_q_f ludmjbey ^he`_g[ue jZa]Z^Zlvqlh
^_eZlv klh[hckdZaZe hgy ^he`_g[ue jZkkdZaZlvl_[_
qlh y ^_eZeZ yg_ fh]mk^_eZlv wlh]hihlhfm qlh wlh
ijb\_^_l f_gy_s_ d^jm]hfm ^_emIhwlhfmfh`_l [ulv\_sb
[m^ml ykg__l_[__keb lug_ [m^_rv^mfZlv hgZqZeZo
Lh]^Z kdZ`b fg_qlh ijhbahrehihke_ lh]hdZd y
kb^_e gZ[_j_]m bdmjbe
Y ^mfZxqlh lujZkkdZaZe m`_fg_ wlhkdZaZe hg
jZkkf_y\rbkv
;ueh ebqlhgb[m^v \Z`gh]h\ lhfqlh y^_eZe^hg
OmZg"
Hg ih`Zeie_qZfb
Lu ke_^h\Ze fhbf mdZaZgbyf
hq_gv ohjhrh b g_
aZljm^gyeky \oh^blv b \uoh^blv
ba
lmfZgZAZl_flu
ijbkemrb\Zeky d fh_fm]hehkm b\ha\jZsZeky d ih\_joghklb
dZ`^uc jZadh]^Z y a\Ze l_[yWlh [ueh mijZ`g_gb_f
HklZevgh_ [uehhq_gv e_]dhLu ijhklhiha\hebe lmfZgmmg_klb
l_[yLu \_ek_[ydZd [m^lhlu agZeqlh ^_eZlvDh]^Z lu
[ue hq_gv^Ze_dhy iha\Zel_[y kgh\Zb \_e_el_[_ kfhlj_lv
gZ [_j_]ihwlhfmlu ^he`_gagZlvdZd ^Ze_dh lu mr_e
AZl_f y\ulygme l_[ygZaZ^
Lu bf__rv \\b^m^hg OmZgqlh y ^_ckl\bl_evgh
iml_r_kl\h\Ze \\h^_"
>ZB hq_gv^Ze_dhd lhfm`_
DZd ^Ze_dh"
Lu g_ih\_jbrv wlhfm
Y ihiulZeky m[_^blv_]h kdZaZlvfg_gh hg ij_djZlbe
ij_^f_l bkdZaZeqlh hg^he`_g mclbgZ \j_fyY gZklZb\Ze
qlh[u hgih djZcg_cf_j_gZf_dgme fg_
Fg_ g_gjZ\blky hklZ\Zlvky\ l_fghl_kdZaZe y
Lu kZf^_j`brv k_[y\ l_fghl_kdZaZe hg^mfZc h
kl_g_dhlhjmx lu \b^_eKy^v a^_kvgZ k\hx pbgh\dm b
\kihfgb dZ`^mx ih^jh[ghklvwlh]hLh]^Z\hafh`ghlu kZf
kfh`_rv hldjulvdZd ^Ze_dhlu mr_e<k_qlh yagZx l_i_jv
wlh lhqlh luiml_r_kl\h\Ze hq_gv^Ze_dhY agZx wlh
ihlhfm qlh mf_gy [uehm`Zkgh_ \j_fyijb \uly]b\Zgbb l_[y
gZaZ^?keb [uy g_[ue jy^hflu fh][u kh\k_faZ[em^blvky
b gbdh]^Zg_ \_jgmlvky\ lZdhfkemqZ_\k_qlh hklZehkv[u
hl l_[y l_i_jvwlh f_jl\h_l_eh gZ [_j_]m jmqvyBeb
\hafh`ghlu fh] \_jgmlvkykZfgh \wlhf y g_ m\_j_g
Ihwlhfmhp_gb\ ihiuldmwlh]hy ^he`_g[ue ijb\_klb l_[y
gZaZ^y kdZaZel_[_ hq_gvykgh \
Hg k^_eZe ^he]mx iZmam b ijbklZevgh b ^jm`_ex[gh
ihkfhlj_e gZf_gy
Y ^hc^m^h ]hjp_gljZevghc F_dkbdbkdZaZe hgy
g_ agZxdZd ^Ze_dhlu mr_e\hafh`gh^h EhkZg^`_e_kZZ
\hafh`gh^Z`_ ^h;jZabebb
>hg OmZg\_jgmeky gZke_^mxsbc ^_gviha^gh ihke_h[_^Z
D lhfm \j_f_gby aZibkZe\k_qlh yfh] \kihfgblv h fh_f
\hkijbylbbDh]^y y ibkZefg_ ijbrehgZ mf ijhclbkv ih
[_j_]Zf jmqvy \\_jo b\gba bih^l\_j^blv\b^_e eb y \
^_ckl\bl_evghklb ^_lZeb gZdZ`^hc klhjhg_dhlhju_ fh]eb
\ua\Zlv \hfg_ h[jZakl_guY k^_eZeij_^iheh`_gb_qlh ^hg
OmZg fh]aZklZ\blv f_gyijhclbkv \khklhygbb hp_i_g_gbyb
aZl_f fh] aZklZ\blv f_gykhkj_^hlhqblv fh_ \gbfZgb_ gZ
dZdhcgb[m^v kl_g_ ihimlb< qZkudhlhju_ ijhreb f_`^m
\j_f_g_fdh]^Z y\i_j\u_ h[gZjm`belmfZgb \j_f_g_fdh]^Z
y \ue_a badZgZ\u b\_jgmeky \_]h ^hfmy \uqbkebeqlh
_keb hg aZklZ\be f_gyijhclbkvfu fh]eb ijhclbkZfh_
[hevr__^\_ kiheh\bghc fbebIhwlhfmy h[hr_e[_j_]Z ih
jmqvx hdheh lj_o fbev\ dZ`^hf gZijZ\e_gbb\gbfZl_evgh
jZkkfZljb\Zy dZ`^mx^_lZevdhlhjZy fh]eZ[u bf_lvhlghr_gb_
d fh_fm \b^m kl_guJmq_c [uegZkdhevdh y fh] kdZaZlv
ijhkluf dZgZehfbkihevah\Z\rbfky ^eyhjhr_gbyHg [ue hl
q_luj_o ^h iylb nmlh\rbjbghc ih\k_c ^ebg_b y g_ fh]
gZclb gbdZdbo \b^bfuo^_lZe_c \g_fdhlhju_ gZihfgbeb [u
fg_ bebgZ\yaZeb [uh[jZa [_lhgghckl_gu
Dh]^Z ^hg OmZgijbr_e \^hf iha^ghihke_ ihem^gyy
aZ]h\hjbe kgbf bgZklhye gZijhql_gbb _fmfh_]h hlq_lZHg
hldZaZeky kemrZlvb aZklZ\bef_gy k_klvHg kb^_eebphf dh
fg_Hg g_
meu[ZekyHgdZaZehkv^mfZehp_gb\Zy
ijhgbdZxsbf \gmljv\a]ey^hf k\hbo]eZadhlhju_ hklZgh\bebkv
gZ^ ]hjbahglhf
Y ^mfZeqlh lu^he`_g [uehkhagZlv dwlhfm \j_f_gb
kdZaZe hglhghfdhlhjuc [ueg_h`b^Zgghhq_gv kmjh\uf
qlh \k_y\ey_lky kf_jl_evghhiZkguf<h^Z y\ey_lkylZdhc `_
kf_jl_evghcdZd b kljZ`?keb lug_ hkl_j_`_rvky\h^Z
aZfZgbl l_[yHgZ ihqlbk^_eZeZ wlh\q_jZGh ^ey lh]h
qlh[u ihiZklvky \eh\mrdmq_eh\_d ^he`_gohl_lv< wlhf
l\h_ aZljm^g_gb_Lu ohq_rvihdbgmlv k_[y
Y g_agZeh q_fhg ]h\hjbe?]h gZiZ^_gb_gZ f_gy[ueh
lZdbf g_h`b^Zggufqlh y[ue k[blk lhedmY keZ[hihijhkbe
_]h h[tykgblv fg_Hg kg_hohlhc mihfygmeqlh hgoh^be d
\h^ghfm dZgvhgmb \b^_e^moZ \h^gh]hf_klZ bbf_e ]em[hdh_
m[_`^_gb_qlh mf_gy [uebkeZ[u_ \hafh`ghklb\b^_lv\h^m
DZd"kijhkbe y^_ckl\bl_evgh jZkkljh_gguc
>mo wlh kbeZkdZaZe hgbdZd lZdh\hchg
hlau\Z_lky lhevdhgZ kbemLu g_fh`_rv ihlZdZlvk_[_ \_]h
ijbkmlkl\bb
DZd yihlZdZe k_[_"
<q_jZdh]^Z lu[ue \\h^_
Y g_ihlZdZe k_[_Y ^mfZeqlh wlh[ue hq_gv\Z`guc
fhf_glb yjZkkdZau\Ze l_[_lhqlh ijhbkoh^behkh fghc
Dlh lulZdhcqlh[u ^mfZlvbeb j_rZlvqlh y\ey_lky
\Z`guf"Lu gbq_]h g_agZ_rv hkbeZodhlhju_ aZfZgb\Zxl
l_[y>mo \h^ygh]hf_klZ kms_kl\m_l\g_ wlh]hf_klZ bfh`_l
ihfhqv l_[_\ ^_ckl\bl_^vghklbhg ihfh]Zel_[_ihdZ lug_
[ue keZ[L_i_jv yg_ agZxdZdh]h [m^_lihke_^kl\b_ l\hbo
^_ckl\bcLu mklmibekbe_ ^moZ\h^ygh]h f_klZb l_i_jvhg
fh`_l \aylvl_[y \ex[h_ \j_fy
JZa\_ [uehg_ijZ\bevgh kfhlj_lvgZ k_[yh[_jgm\r_
]hky a_e_guf"
Lu ihdbgmekZfh]h k_[yWlh [uehg_ijZ\bevghY m`_
]h\hjbe l_[_ wlhb ih\lhjxwlh kgh\ZLu fh`_rv \u`blv \
fbj_ [jmohlhevdh _keblu \hbg<hbg h[jZsZ_lkykh \k_f k
m\Z`_gb_f b g_lhiq_l gbq_]h_keb hgg_ \ugm`^_g ^_eZlv
wlhLu g_h[jZsZeky k\h^hc km\Z`_gb_f \q_jZH[uqgh lu
\_^_rv k_[y hq_gvohjhrhH^gZdh\q_jZ luihdbgme kZfh]h
k_[y jZ^b k\h_c kf_jlbdZd ijhdeyluc ^mjZd<hbg g_
ihdb^Z_l kZfh]h k_[ygb ^eyq_]h^Z`_ ^ey k\h_c kf_jlb
<hbg wlh g_klZjZl_evguc iZjlg_j\hbg g_^hklmi_gb _keb
hg \h\e_dZ_lk_[y \hqlhlhlh lufh`_rv [ulvm\_j_gqlh
hg khagZ_llhqlh ^_eZ_l
Y g_agZeqlh kdZaZlv>hg OmZg[ue ihqlbk_j^blWlh
jZkkljhbeh f_gy>hg OmZgj_^dh \_ek_[y kh fghc lZdbf
h[jZahfY ^_ckl\bl_evghg_ bf_efukebqlh yk^_eZe qlhlh
g_ijZ\bevgh_Ihke_ g_kdhevdbofbgml gZijy`_ggh]h fheqZgby
hg kgye k\hxreyimmeu[gmeky bkdZaZe fg_qlh y ^he`_g
mclb b g_ \ha\jZsZlvky\ _]h^hf ^hl_o ihjihdZ y g_
ihqm\kl\mxqlh ijbh[j_edhgljhev gZ^k\hbf ihlZdZgb_fk_[_
Hg ih^q_jdgmeqlh y^he`_g klhjhgblvky\h^u bg_ dZkZlvky
_x ih\_joghklbfh_]h l_eZljb bebq_luj_ f_kypZ
Y g_ ^mfZxqlh yfh]m oh^blvg_ ijbgy\ ^mr
kdZaZe y
>hg OmZgaZohohlZe ^hke_aiheb\rboky ba_]h ]eZa
Lu g_fh`_rv oh^blv[_a ^mrZ\j_f_gZfb lulZd keZ[
qlhy ^mfZxlu ih[m`^Z_rvf_gyGh wlhg_ rmldZ<j_f_gZfb
lu ^_ckl\bl_evgh g_ bf__rvdhgljheyb kbeu l\h_c `bagb
k\h[h^gh [_jmll_[y
Y ih^gye \hijhk
h
lhfqlh wlh ihq_eh\_q_kdb
g_\hafh`gh dhgljhebjh\Zlv k_[y\k_ \j_fyHg gZklZb\Ze
qlh ^ey \hbgZg_l gbq_]h\g_ dhgljheyY ih^gye \hijhk h
kemqZcghklb b kdZaZeqlh lhqlh kemqbehkv kh fghc m
\h^gh]h dZgZeZfh`gh [uehdhg_qghdeZkkbnbpbjh\ZlvdZd
kemqZcghklvldy g_bf_e wlh]h\ \b^m b g_ khagZ\Ze
k\h_]h g_ijZ\bevgh]hih\_^_gbyY ]h\hjbeh jZaebqguoebpZo
bf_\rbo g_kqZklvydhlhju_
fh]eb
[ulv h[tykg_gudZd
kemqZcghklby ]h\hjbe hkh[_gghh EmdZk_klZjhfhq_gv
ijbylghf bg^_cp_ ie_f_gbydbdhlhjuc k_jv_agh ihkljZ^Ze
dh]^Z ]jmah\bddhlhjuc hg\_ei_j_\_jgmeky
Fg_ dZ`_lkyg_\hafh`gh ba[_`Zlv kemqZcghkl_c
kdZaZe yGbdlh g_fh`_l dhgljhebjh\Zlv\k_ \hdjm]k_[y
<_jghkdZaZe ^hgOmZg j_adhGh g_\k_ y\ey_lky
g_ba[_`ghc kemqZcghklvxEmdZk g_`b\_ldZd \hbg?keb [u
hg `belZdlh hg[u agZeqlh hg`^_l bq_]h hg`^_lb hg
g_ \_e [u]jmah\bd[m^mqb ivygufHg gZkdhqbegZ kdZem m
^hjh]bihlhfm qlhhg [ueivygb bkdZe_qbek\h_ l_ehgb aZ
qlh
@bagv ^ey \hbgZ_klv mijZ`g_gb_\ kljZl_]bb
ijh^he`Ze ^hgOmZgGh luohq_rv gZclbkfuke `bagb<hbg
g_ aZ[hlblkyh kfukeZo?keb [uEmdZk `bedZd \hbgZ hg
bf_e dwlhfm \hafh`ghklvld\k_ fubf__f \hafh`ghklv
hg jZaf_lbe[u k\hx`bagv kljZl_]bq_kdbLZdbf h[jZahf_keb
[u hg g_ fh]ba[_`Zlv kemqZcghklbdhlhjZy ihehfZeZ _fm
j_[jZhg gZr_e[u kihkh[uhkeZ[blv wlh ijhbkr_kl\b_ beb
ba[_`Zlv _]hihke_^kl\bcbeb [hjhlvkyijhlb\ gbo?keb [u
EmdZk [ue \hbghflh hgg_ kb^_e[u \k\h_f jZa\Zeb\r_fky
^hf_mfbjZy hl]heh^ZHg [u[beky ^hdhgpZ
Y baeh`be Zevl_jgZlb\m ^hgmOmZgmbkihevamy _]h \
dZq_kl\_ ijbf_jZb kijhkbe_]hqlh [m^_l \ j_amevlZl_
_keb [u hgkZf [ue[u \h\e_q_g\ g_kqZklguckemqZcb _fm
hlj_aZeh [ugh]b
?keb [u yg_ kfh]ihfhqv wlhfmb ihl_jye [u k\hb
gh]bkdZaZe hgy
g_ kfh] [u [ulv q_eh\_dhf
kdhevdhgb[m^v ^hevr_bihwlhfmy kh_^bgbeky[u kl_fdlh
`^_l f_gy\g_ wlh]hf_klZ
Hg k^_eZerbjhdbc `_klk\h_c jmdhcqlh[u ihdZaZlv\k_
\hdjm] k_[yY aZkihjbeqlh hgg_ijZ\bevgh ihgyef_gyY
gZf_j_\Zeky mdZaZlvqlh
[ueh
g_\hafh`gh
^ey ex[h]h
hl^_evgh]h q_eh\_dZ ij_^\b^_lv\k_ i_j_f_gu\dexq_ggu_ \
_]h ih\k_^g_\guo^_ckl\byo
<k_qlh yfh]m l_[_kdZaZlvkdZaZe ^hgOmZg
wlh lhqlh \hbg\k_]^Z g_^hklmi_ghg gbdh]^Zg_ klhbl gZ
^hjh]_h`b^Zyqlh[u _]hklmdgmeb ih]heh\_LZdbf h[jZahf
hg k\h^bld fbgbfmfmk\hb \hafh`ghklbg_ij_^\b^_ggh]hLh
qlh lugZau\Z_rv kemqZcghklvx\ [hevrbgkl\_kemqZ_\ hq_gv
e_]dh ba[_`Zlv_keb g_[ulv b^bhlhf`b\msbf kimklyjmdZ\Z
=eZ\Z
lj bg Z^ pZ lZ y
Fhy ke_^mxsZyihiuldZ \b^_gvybf_eZ f_klhk_gly[jy
]h^Z>hg OmZgaZklZ\be f_gy\udmjblv ^\_qZrdb kf_kb
G_f_^e_ggu_ j_amevlZlu[ueb ZgZeh]bqguj_amevlZlZfdhlhju_
y bkiulu\Ze\h \j_fyij_^u^msbo ihiulhdY ihfgbelhqlh
dh]^Z fh_ l_eh kh\k_f
hg_f_eh^hg OmZg ihfh] fg_
ih^^_j`b\Zy f_gy ih^ jmdm\hclb
\ ]mklhc imklugguc
qZiiZjZevdhlhjuc jhkgZ g_kdhevdhfbev \hdjm]_]h ^hfZY
g_ fh]ijbihfgblv lhqlh ybeb ^hgOmZg ^_eZeihke_ lh]h
dZd fu \hreb\ aZjhkeby g_fh] \kihfgblvdZd ^he]h fu
reb\ g_dhlhjucfhf_gl yh[gZjm`beqlh ykb^_e gZ\_jrbg_
g_[hevrh]h ohefZ>hg OmZgkb^_e ke_\Zhl f_gydZkZykv
f_gyY g_fh] qm\kl\h\Zlv_]hgh yfh] \b^_lv_]h m]hedhf
]eZaZM f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hqlh hg]h\hjbe khfghcohly y
g_ fh]\kihfgblv _]hkeh\<k_ `_y qm\kl\h\Zeqlh yagZe
lhqghqlh hg]h\hjbeg_kfhljy gZlhl nZdlqlh yg_ fh]
\kihfgblv wlh]h ykghM f_gy[ueh hsms_gb_qlh _]h keh\Z
[ueb ih^h[gu \Z]hgZf ih_a^Zdhlhjuc m^Zeyekyb _]h
ihke_^g__ keh\h
[ueh
ih^h[gh
ihke_^g_fm
d\Z^jZlghfm
kem`_[ghfm \Z]hgmY agZeqlh wlhihke_^g__ keh\hhagZqZeh
gh y g_fh] kdZaZlv_]h bebih^mfZlv hg_f ykghWlh [ueh
khklhygb_ ihem[h^jkl\h\Zgbyk ijbajZqgufh[jZahf ih_a^Z ba
keh\
AZl_fhq_gv keZ[hy mkeurZe]hehk ^hgZOmZgZdhlhjuc
]h\hjbe fg_
L_i_jv lu^he`_g ihkfhlj_lvgZ f_gykdZaZe hg
ih\_jgm\ fhx]heh\m dk\h_fm ebpmHg ih\lhjbeh[jZs_gb_ ljb
beb q_luj_jZaZ
Y ihkfhlj_eb kjZamh[gZjm`be lhl`_ kZfuc k\_lysbcky
wnn_dldZdhc y\hkijbgbfZe ij_`^_dh]^Z kfhlj_e gZ _]h
ebphwlh [ueh
]bighlbabjmxs__ ^\b`_gb_\heghh[jZagh_
i_j_f_s_gb_ k\_lZ \gmljb\f_sZxsbo kn_jLZff_`^m wlbfb
kn_jZfbg_ [uehhij_^_e_gguo ]jZgbpbh^gZdh\hegbkluc
k\_l gbdh]^Z g_jZaeb\Zekygh ^\b]Zeky \gmljb g_\b^bfuo
ij_^_eh\
Y ijbklZevgh jZa]ey^u\Ze k\_lysbcky ij_^f_l i_j_^h
fghcb g_f_^e_ggh hg gZqZe
l_jylv k\h_ k\_q_gb_b
ihy\bebkv h[uqgu_q_jlu ebpZ^hgZ OmZgZbebkdhj__klZeb
gZdeZ^u\Zlvky gZ aZlmoZxs__k\_q_gb_AZl_f y ^he`_g [ue
knhdmkbjh\Zlv k\hcijbklZevguc \a]ey^kgh\Zhq_jlZgby ^hgZ
OmZgZ ih[e_debZ k\_q_gb_
mkbebehkvY i_j_g_k k\h_
\gbfZgb_ gZ h[eZklvdhlhjZy ^he`gZ[ueZ [ulv _]h e_\uf
]eZahfY aZf_lbeqlh lZf^\b`_gb_ k\_q_gbyg_ k^_j`b\Z
ehkvY h[gZjm`beg_qlh\hafh`ghihoh`__ gZ\kiurdb bkdj
<kiurdb [ueb jblfbqgufb b^_ckl\bl_evgh bkimkdZeb g_qlh
ih^h[gh_ qZklbqdZf k\_lZdhlhju_ e_l_ebk y\ghckbehc dh
fg_Z aZl_f m^ZeyebkvdZd [m^lh hgb [ueb j_abgh\ufb
gblyfb
>hg OmZg ^he`_g [ue ih\_jgmlv fhx ]heh\m \hdjm]
<g_aZighy h[gZjm`beqlh ykfhlj_e gZ\kiZoZggh_ ihe_
L_i_jv kfhljb\i_j_^mkeurZe y]hehk ^hgZOmZgZ
I_j_^h fghc\hafh`ghgZ ^\_klbyj^h\[ue [hevrhc
^he]bc ohef\_kv _]hkdehg [ue \kiZoZg=hjbahglZevgu_
ihehku [_`ZebiZjZee_eevgh ^jm]d ^jm]mhl ih^gh`vy^h kZfhc
\_jrbgu ohefZY aZf_lbeqlh gZ \kiZoZgghf ihe_ [ueb
g_[hevrb_ dZfgb b ljb h]jhfguo \ZemgZdhlhju_ f_rZeb
ebg_cghklb [hjha^Ijyfh i_j_^hfghc [ueb dmkludhlhju_
f_rZeb fg_\b^_lv ih^jh[ghklbh\jZ]Z beb\h^gh]h dZgvhgZ m
ih^gh`by ohefZHldm^Z ykfhlj_edZgvhg dZaZeky ]em[hdbf
jZaj_ahfaZf_lgh hlebqZxsbfkya_e_ghc jZklbl_evghklvx hl
[_kieh^gh]h ohefZA_e_gvdZaZehkv[ueZ ^_j_\vyfbdhlhju_
jhkeb gZ ^g_dZgvhgZY qm\kl\h\Zee_]dbc \_l_jhd^m\rbc
fg_ \ ]eZaZM f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hfbjZ biheguc ihdhcG_
[ueh a\mdh\gb ilbpgb gZk_dhfuo
>hg OmZg aZ]h\hjbe khfghc kgh\Z< wlhl fhf_gl y
ihgbfZe lhqlh hg]h\hjbe
<b^brv eblu q_eh\_dZgZ wlhfihe_"ijh^he`Ze hg
kijZrb\Zlv
Y ohl_ehl\_lblv _fmqlh gZihe_ g_[ueh q_eh\_dZgh
y g_fh] ijhbag_klbkeh\Z>hg OmZg\aye fhx]heh\m \ k\hb
jmdb kaZ^by fh]\b^_lv _]hiZevpu gZ^fhbfb [jh\yfbb gZ
fhbo smdZo b aZklZ\bef_gy ihkfhlj_lvq_j_a \k_ ihe_
i_j_^\b]Zy f_^e_ggh fhx ]heh\mkijZ\Z gZe_\hZ aZl_f \
ijhlb\hiheh`ghf gZijZ\e_gbb
GZ[ex^Zc dZ`^mx^_lZevL\hy `bagvfh`_l aZ\bk_lvhl
wlh]hkeurZe y_]h]h\hjb\r_]h wlhkgh\Z bkgh\Z
Hg aZklZ\be f_gyq_luj_ jZaZ h[haj_lv ]jZ^mkguc
\bamZevguc ]hjbahgl i_j_^hfghc< h^bgfhf_gldh]^Z hg
^\b]Ze fhx]heh\m ihkfhlj_lvdjmlh gZe_\hy ih^mfZeqlh y
h[gZjm`be qlhlh ^\b`ms__ky
\
ihe_Y bf_e djZldh_
\hkijbylb_ ^\b`_gby m]hedhffh_]h ijZ\h]h]eZaZHg gZqZe
i_j_^\b]Zlv fhx]heh\m gZaZ^\ijZ\hb ykfh] knhdmkbjh\Zlv
k\hc ijbklZevguc \a]ey^ gZ
\kiZoZgghf ihe_Y m\b^_e
q_eh\_dZb^ms_]h \^hev [hjha^Hg [ue ijhklhc q_eh\_d
h^_lucdZd f_dkbdZgkdbc dj_klvygbghg ghkbe kZg^Zebb
e_]db_ k_ju_ rlZgu[_`_\mx jm[Zrdmk ^ebggufbjmdZ\Zfb b
khehf_ggmx reyim b g_ke_]dmx dhjbqg_\mxkmfdm k j_fg_f
q_j_a ijZ\h_ie_qh
>hg OmZg^he`gh [ulvaZf_lbeqlh ym\b^_e q_eh\_dZ
Hg ih\lhjgh kijhkbef_gykfhlj_e ebq_eh\_d gZf_gy b dh
fg_ ebhg r_eY ohl_ekdZaZlv _fmqlh q_eh\_dm^Zeyeky b
qlh dhfg_ [ueZih\_jgmlZ _]hkibgZgh yfh] lhevdhkdZaZlv
g_l>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh _kebq_eh\_d ih\_jg_lkyb ihc^_l
dh fg_y djbdgmb hgjZa\_jg_l fhx]heh\m ^eylh]hqlh[u
aZsblblv f_gy
M f_gy [ueh
hsms_gb_
kljZoZ
beb hiZk_gbybeb
aZljm^gbl_evgh]h iheh`_gbyY jZ\gh^mrgh gZ[ex^Ze kp_gm
Q_eh\_d hklZgh\beky gZ k_j_^bg_iheyHg ihklZ\be k\hx
ijZ\mx gh]m gZ djZc[hevrh]h djm]eh]h\ZemgZdZd [m^lh
aZrgmjh\u\Ze k\hx kZg^ZebxAZl_f hg \uijyfbeky\ugme
\_j_\dm bak\h_c kmfdbb h[_jgme__ \hdjm]k\h_c e_\hcjmdb
Hg ih\_jgmekykibghc dhfg_ bih\_jgm\rbkv ebphfd \_jrbg_
ohefZgZqZe h]ey^u\ZlvijhkljZgkl\h i_j_^kh[hcY ih^mfZe
qlh hgjZa]ey^u\Z_l\ke_^kl\b_ kihkh[Zdhlhjuf hg ^\b]Ze
fhx ]heh\mdhlhjmx hgf_^e_ggh ih\hjZqb\Ze\ijZ\hy \b^_e
_]h \ijhnbevZ aZl_fhg gZqZeih\hjZqb\Zlv \k_k\h_ l_eh
^h l_o ihjihdZ g_hdZaZeky kfhlj_\rbfgZ f_gyHg\
^_ckl\bl_evghklb j_adh^\b]Ze k\h_c]heh\hcbeb ^\b]Ze _x
lZdbf kihkh[hfqlh yagZe [_akhfg_gbyqlh hg\b^_e f_gy
Hg \ulygme i_j_^kh[hc e_\mxjmdmmdZau\Zy gZ a_fexb
^_j`Z k\hxjmdm \wlhf iheh`_gbbgZqZe b^lbdh fg_
Hg ijb[eb`Z_lkydjbdgme
y [_a dZdhceb[h
ljm^ghklb
>hg OmZg^he`_g [ueih\_jgmlv fhx]heh\m \klhjhgmb
aZl_f y kfhlj_e gZqZiiZjZevHg \_e_e fg_ g_ kfhlj_lv
ijbklZevghgh kfhlj_lvke_]dZgZ \_sbb h]ey^u\Zlvq_j_a
gboHg kdZaZeqlh hg kh[bjZ_lky \klZlv gZ dhjhldhf
jZkklhygbb i_j_^h fghcb aZl_fih^oh^blv dhfg_b qlh y
^he`_g ijbklZevgh kfhlj_lv gZ g_]hihdZ g_ m\b`m _]h
k\_q_gb_
Y \b^_eqlh ^hgOmZg ^\b]Zekyhl f_gy^h jZkklhygby
ijbf_jgh^\Z^pZlv yj^h\Hg
r_e k lZdhc g_\_jhylghc
kdhjhklvx b ijh\hjkl\hfqlh y_^\Z fh]ih\_jblvqlh wlh
[ue ^hg OmZgHg ih\_jgmekyebphf dhfg_ b ijbdZaZe fg_
ijbklZevgh kfhlj_lvgZ g_]h
?]h ebph[ueh k\_lysbfkyhgh \u]ey^_ehih^h[gh iylgm
k\_lZK\_ldZaZehkvjZaeb\Zeky q_j_a_]h ]jm^vihqlb d
k_j_^bg_ _]hl_eZWlh [uehlZddZd [m^lhy kfhlj_egZ k\_l
kd\hav
k\hb
ihemaZdjulu_
\_dbK\_q_gb_dZaZehkv
jZkrbjyehkv bm^ZeyehkvHg^he`gh [ulvgZqZe ih^oh^blvdh
fg_ihlhfm qlh k\_l klZe
[he__ bgl_gkb\guf b [he__
jZaebqbfufHg qlhlh kdZaZefg_Y iulZekyihgylv bihl_jye
\b^ k\_q_gbyZ aZl_fy kdZaZe^hgm OmZgmdZd y\b`m _]h \
ih\k_^g_\ghc `bagbhg [ue\ ^\morZ]Zo hlf_gyHg k_e
ebphf dhfg_
Dh]^Z ylhqgh khkj_^hlhqbek\h_ \gbfZgb_gZ _]hebp_y
gZqZe \hkijbgbfZlv g_ykgh_k\_q_gb_?]h ebph[ueh dZd [u
i_j_dj_s_gh lhgdbfbemqZfb k\_lZEbph ^hgZOmZgZ \u]ey^_eh
lZddZd [m^lhdlhlh [e_kl_edjhr_qgufb a_jdZeZfbgZ g_]h
dh]^Z k\_l klZe [he__ bgl_gkb\gufebph ihl_jyeh k\hb
dhglmju b kgh\Z klZehZfhjnguf k\_lysbfky ij_^f_lhfY
\hkijbgbfZe _s_ jZa wnn_dl imevkbjmxsbo \kiur_d k\_lZ
bkoh^ysbo bah[eZklb]^_ ^he`_g[ulv _]he_\uc ]eZaY g_
khkj_^hlhqbe k\h_\gbfZgb_ gZg_fgh mfure_ggh ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_e gZ khk_^gxxh[eZklvdhlhjZydZd y ij_^iheZ]Ze
[ueZ _]hijZ\uf ]eZahfY ihcfZekjZam \b^ykghcijhajZqghc
aZ\h^b k\_lZWlh [ue`b^dbc k\_l
Y aZf_lbeqlh hsms_gb_[ueh [hevr_q_f gZ[ex^_gb_
wlh [ueh qm\kl\hEm`Z
l_fgh]h`b^dh]h k\_lZ bf_eZ
qj_a\uqZcgmx ]em[bgmHgZ [ueZ^jm`_kl\_gghc^h[jhc
K\_ldhlhjuc baemqZekyba g__g_ \aju\Zekygh djm`beky
f_^e_ggh \gmlj_gg_kha^Z\Zy ij_e_klgu_hl[e_kdbK\_q_gb_
kihkh[hfdhlhjuc ^Z\Zefg_ hsms_gb_ij_e_klb
Y \b^_ekbff_ljbqguc djm]k\_jdZxsbo \kie_kdh\ k\_lZ
dhlhjuc jZkrbjyeky jblfbq_kdb
\ \_jlbdZevghc iehkdhklb
k\_lys_]hky ijhkljZgkl\ZDjm] jZkrbjyekyqlh[u aZdjulv
ihqlb \kx k\_lysmxky ih\_joghklvZ aZl_f khdjZsZeky ^h
lhqdb k\_lZ\ k_j_^bg_k\_jdZxs_c em`bY \b^_ejZkrbj_gb_ b
khdjZs_gb_ djm]Z g_kdhevdhjZaAZl_f ymfure_ggh i_j_\_e
]eZaZg_ l_jyy ijbklZevgh]h\a]ey^Zb kfh] \b^_lv h[Z
]eZaZY jZaebqZejblf h[hbo\b^h\ k\_lh\uo\kiur_dE_\uc
]eZa bkimkdZe
\kie_kdb
k\_lZdhlhju_
^_ckl\bl_evgh
\u^Z\Zebkv ba \_jlbdZevgh]hieZgZ\ lh\j_fydZd ijZ\uc
]eZa bkimkdZe \kie_kdbdhlhju_ g_\u^Z\ZebkvJblf h[hbo
]eZa [uei_j_f_ggufk\_l e_\h]h]eZaZ \kiuob\ZegZjm`m\
lh \j_fydZd baemqZxsb_kyk\_lh\u_ emqb ijZ\h]h ]eZaZ
kh[bjZebkv b djm`bebkv \gmljbAZl_f k\_l ijZ\h]h ]eZaZ
jZkrbjbekyqlh[u aZdjulv\kx k\_lysmxkyih\_joghklv\ lh
\j_fydZd \kiuob\Zxsbck\_l e_\h]h]eZaZ hlklmibe
>hg OmZg^he`_g [ueih\_jgmlv f_gy_s_ jZab y kgh\Z
kfhlj_e gZ \kiZoZggh_ihe_Y keurZeqlh hg ]h\hjbe fg_
gZ[ex^Zlv aZq_eh\_dhf
Q_eh\_d klhye m dZfgyb kfhlj_egZ f_gyY g_ fh]
jZaebqblv q_jlu_]h ebpZ_]h reyiZaZdju\ZeZ [hevrmxqZklv
_]h ebpZQ_j_a fhf_glhg ih^kmgmek\hx kmfdm ih^ ijZ\mx
jmdm b gZqZeb^lb \ijZ\hhl f_gyHg ^hr_eihqlb ^h dhgpZ
\kiZoZgghc iehsZ^bbaf_gbe gZijZ\e_gb_b k^_eZe g_kdhevdh
rZ]h\ d h\jZ]mAZl_f
y
ihl_jye dhgljhev gZ^ k\hbf
khkj_^hlhq_gb_fb hg bkq_abihwlhfmhklZeky lhevdh
i_caZ`Bah[jZ`_gb_ imklugguodmklh\ gZeh`behkvgZ g_]h
Y g_ihfgx gblh]hdZd y\_jgmeky d^hfm ^hgZ OmZgZ
gb lh]hqlh hg^_eZe khfghcqlh[u ijb\_klb f_gygZaZ^
Dh]^Z yijhkgmekyy e_`ZegZ fh_fkhehf_gghf fZl_\ dhfgZl_
^hgZ OmZgZHg ih^hr_edh fg_b ihfh]fg_ \klZlvM f_gy
djm`beZkv ]heh\Z`_em^hd [uejZkkljh_g>hg OmZg hq_gv
[ukljh b mf_ehhl\_e f_gyd dmklZf\ klhjhg_hl _]h ^hfZ
F_gy klhrgbehb hgjZkkf_yeky
Ihlhf y ihqm\kl\h\Zek_[y emqr_Y ihkfhlj_egZ k\hb
qZku[ueh h^bggZ^pZlvqZkh\ ihihem^gbY \_jgmekykiZlv ^h
qZkZ ke_^mxs_]h^gydZd y^mfZeb [uekgh\Z kZfbfkh[hc
>hg OmZg ijh^he`Ze kijZrb\Zlv
f_gydZd y k_[y
qm\kl\h\ZeM f_gy [uehhsms_gb_ jZkk_ygghklbY g_ fh]
^_ckl\bl_evgh kdhgp_gljbjh\ZlvkyY
oh^be
\hdjm] ^hfZ
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy ih^\gbfZl_evguf gZ^ahjhf^hgZ OmZgZHg
ke_^h\Ze aZfghcY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh gbq_]hg_ fh]^_eZlvb
kgh\Z mkgmeY ijhkgmekyiha^gh ihke_ihem^gy b qm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y gZfgh]hemqr_Y h[gZjm`befgh]h jZa^Z\e_gguo ebklv_\
\hdjm] k_[y< ^_ckl\bl_evghklbdh]^Z yijhkgmekyy e_`Ze
gZ `b\hl_ gZdmq_ ebklv_\Bo aZiZo[ue hq_gv kbevgufY
\kihfgbeqlh klZe khagZ\ZlvaZiZo ^h_s_ ^h lh]hdZd
iheghklvx ijhkgmeky
Y \ur_e aZ ^hfb h[gZjm`be^hgZ OmZgZkb^_\r_]h m
hjhkbl_evghc dZgZ\uDh]^Z hgm\b^_e f_gyijb[eb`Zxsbfkyhg
g_bklh\h aZfZoZefg_ hklZgh\blvkyb \_jgmlvky\ ^hf
;_]b \gmljvdjbdgme hg
Y \[_`Ze \ ^hfb hg ijbkh_^bgbeky dh fg_ q_j_a
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy
Gbdh]^Z g_bsb f_gykdZaZe hg?keb lu ohq_rv
\b^_lv f_gylh `^bf_gy a^_kv
Y ba\bgbekyHg kdZaZeqlh[u yg_ bagmjye k_[y \
]emiuo ba\bg_gbyodhlhju_ g_bf_eb kbeuqlh[u Zggmebjh\Zlv
fhb ^_ckl\byHg kdZaZeqlh _fm[ueh hq_gvljm^gh ijb\_klb
f_gy gZaZ^b qlhhg oh^ZlZckl\h\ZeaZ f_gyi_j_^ \h^hc
Fu ^he`gu\aylv rZgkl_i_jv b\ufulv l_[y\ \h^_
kdZaZe hgHq_gv djZkb\hb g_`ghdZkZehkv f_gymkihdZb\Zeh
f_gyY aZ\_jbe _]hqlh qm\kl\h\Zek_[y ij_\hkoh^ghHg
^he]h_ \j_fyijbklZevgh kfhlj_efg_ \]eZaZ
Ihc^_f khfghckdZaZe hgy kh[bjZxkv hdmgmlv
l_[y \\h^m
Y a^hjh\kdZaZe ykfhljby ibrmaZf_ldb
Hg hlhj\Zef_gy hlpbgh\db khagZqbl_evghc kbehc
G_ ihlZdZck_[_kdZaZe hgfhf_glZevgh lu\h\k_
mkg_rv hiylvFh`_l [ulvy g_kfh]m jZa[m^blvl_[y gZwlhl
jZa
Hg ihlZsbe f_gy aZ^hfI_j_^ l_fdZd fu ^hklb]eb
\h^uhg \_e_efg_ hq_gv^jZfZlbq_kdbf lhghfiehlgh aZdjulv
]eZaZ b g_hldju\Zlv boihdZ hgg_ kdZ`_lfg_Hg kdZaZe
fg_qlh_keb y ijbklZevghihkfhljx gZ \h^m ^Z`_ gZ
f]gh\_gb_y fh]m mf_j_lvHg \_ef_gy aZjmdmZ aZl_f
klhedgme f_gy\ hjhkbl_evgmxdZgZ\m ]heh\hc\i_j_^
Y ^_j`Ze k\hb ]eZaZaZdjulufbdh]^Z hg ijh^he`Ze
ih]jm`Zlv b \ulZkdb\Zlv f_gy ba\h^u \ l_q_gb_ qZkh\
Baf_g_gb_dhlhjh_ ybkiulZe[ueh aZf_qZl_evguf<k_qlh
[ueh g_ijZ\bevgufkh fghc^h lh]hdZd y\hr_e \\h^m[ueh
lZdbf g_meh\bfufqlh y^_ckl\bl_evgh g_aZf_qZe wlh]hihdZ
g_ kjZ\gbe wlhk qm\kl\hf[eZ]hihemqby b`b\hklbdhlhjh_
[ueh m f_gydh]^Z ^hgOmZg ^_j`Ze f_gy \ hjhkbl_evghc
dZgZ\_
<h^Z ihiZeZ fg_ \ghkb ygZqZe qboZlv>hg OmZg
\ulZsbe f_gy bih\_e f_gy\k_ _s_k aZdjulufb]eZaZfb\
^hfHg \_e_efg_ kf_gblvh^_`^mZ aZl_fijh\_e f_gy\ k\hx
dhfgZlmihkZ^be gZfhc fZljZkiheh`be gZijZ\e_gb_ fh_]h
l_eZ b aZl_fkdZaZe fg_hldjulv ]eZaZY hldjuebob lh
qlh ym\b^_eaZklZ\beh f_gyhliju]gmlv bko\Zlblvky aZ_]h
gh]mY i_j_`be qj_a\uqZcghdhgnmaguc fhf_gl>hg OmZg
ke_]dZ ihklmqZef_gy k\hbfbiZevpZfb ihfZdmrd_ fh_c]heh\u
Wlh [ue [ukljuc
m^Zjdhlhjuc
g_
[ue kbevguf beb
[he_ag_ggufgh ihq_fmlh rhdbjmxsbf
Qlh klh[hc"Qlh lum\b^_e"kijhkbe hg
Ijb hldjuluo]eZaZo y\b^_e lm`_ kZfmxkp_gmdhlhjmx
y gZ[ex^Ze ij_`^_Y \b^_elh]h `_q_eh\_dZGZ wlhl jZa
h^gZdhhg ihqlbdZkZeky f_gyY \b^_e_]h ebphHgh [ueh
ohjhrh agZdhfhfg_Y ihqlbagZedlh hg[ueKp_gZ ijhiZeZ
dh]^Z ^hg OmZgklmdgme f_gyih ]heh\_Y ih^gye ]eZaZ gZ
^hgZ OmZgZHg [ue]hlh\ klmdgmlvf_gy kgh\ZHg aZkf_yekyb
kijhkbeohq_lky ebfg_ ihemqblvm^Zj _s_Y hlhj\Zeky hl
_]h gh]b b jZkkeZ[beky
gZ
pbgh\d_Hg ijbdZaZe fg_
ihkfhlj_lv ijyfh \i_j_^ bg_ ih\hjZqb\Zlvkygb ih dZdhc
ijbqbg_ \gZijZ\e_gbb \h^uihaZ^b _]h^hfZ
Lh]^Z y\ i_j\ucjZa aZf_lbeqlh \dhfgZl_ [uehhq_gv
l_fghG_dhlhjh_ \j_fyy g_[ue m\_j_gqlh fhb]eZaZ [ueb
hldjuluY ihljh]Zebo k\hbfbjmdZfb bm[_^bekyY ]jhfdh
iha\Ze ^hgZOmZgZ bkdZaZe _fmqlh kfhbfb ]eZaZfb qlhlh
g_ lhy kh\k_fg_ fh]\b^_lvohly i_j_^wlbf y\b^_e _]h
]hlh\uf m^Zjblv f_gyY mkeurZe_]h kf_ogZ^ fh_c ]heh\hc
kijZ\ZZ aZl_fhg aZ`_]k\hx d_jhkbgh\mxeZfimFhb ]eZaZ
ijb\udeb d k\_lm q_j_a g_kdhevdhk_dmg^<k_ [ueh dZd
h[uqghie_l_gu_ b hrlmdZlmj_ggu_ kl_gu _]h dhfgZlu b
g_h[uqgh
bkdjb\e_ggu_
kmr_gu_
e_dZjkl\_ggu_
dhjgb
jZa\_r_ggu_ gZ gbok\yadb
ljZ\ljhklgbdh\Zy djurZ
d_jhkbgh\Zy eZfiZijbdj_ie_ggZy gZ[Zed_Y \b^_e dhfgZlm
khlgb jZah^gZdh\ wlhljZa yihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh lZf [ueh
qlhlh g_h[uqZcgh_\ g_cb \hfg_< i_j\ucjZa yg_ \_jbe\
hdhgqZl_evgmx j_Zevghklvfh_]h \hkijbylbyY [uehkljuf d
wlhfm qm\kl\mb\hafh`ghbgl_ee_dlmZebabjh\Ze bf\ jZagh_
\j_fygh dh]^Zy g_[ue gZdjZx k_jv_agh]h khfg_gbyGZ
wlhl jZah^gZdhy g_\_jbeqlh dhfgZlZ[ueZ j_Zevghcb
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fym f_gy[ueh kljZggh_hsms_gb_qlh wlh[ueh
kp_ghcdhlhjZy ijhiZ^_l_keb ^hgOmZg klmdg_lih fZdmrd_
fh_c ]heh\uk\hbfb iZevpZfb
Y gZqZe^jh`Zlvohly g_[ueh oheh^ghG_j\gu_ kiZafu
ijh[_`Zeb ihfh_c kibg_< ]heh\_ihqm\kl\h\ZeZkv ly`_klv
hkh[_ggh \h[eZklb kijZ\ZgZ^ r__c
Y h[tykgbeqlh yg_ qm\kl\h\Zek_[y ohjhrhb kdZaZe
_fmqlh y\b`mHg jZkkf_yekygZ wlhkdZaZ\qlh mklmiZlv
bkim]m [ueh`Zedbf ihlZdZgb_fk_[_
Lu im]Z_rvkyg_ [m^mqbbkim]ZggufkdZaZe hgLu
\b^_e heebijbklZevgh kfhlj_\r_]hgZ l_[y[hevrh_ ^_eh
@^bihdZ lubf__rv _]hebphf debpmij_`^_ q_fgZeh`blv \
k\hb rlZgu
Hg \_e_e fg_ \klZlv b
b^lb
d fh_c fZrbg_g_
ih\hjZqb\Zykv \ gZijZ\e_gbb \h^ub `^Zlv _]hihdZ hg
\havf_l \_j_\dmb ehiZlmHg \_e_efg_ _oZlvd f_klm]^_ fu
gZreb i_gv^_j_\ZFu ijh^he`Zeb\udZiu\Zlv _]h\ l_fghl_Y
m`Zkgh ljm^ghjZ[hlZe \l_q_gb_ qZkh\Fu g_^hklZeb i_gv
gh yihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[yfgh]h emqr_Fu \_jgmebkvd _]h^hfm
ih_ebb \_sb
klZeb
kgh\Z
kh\_jr_ggh j_Zevgufbb
[ZgZevgufb
Qlh ijhbkoh^behkh fghc"kijhkbe yQlh y ^_eZe
\q_jZ"
Lu dmjbef_gyZ aZl_flu dmjbeheebkdZaZe hg
Ba\bgb"
>hg OmZg jZkkf_yekyb kdZaZeqlh l_i_jvy kh[bjZxkv
ihlj_[h\Zlvqlh[u hggZqZe jZkkdZau\Zlvfg_ \k_k kZfh]h
gZqZeZ
Lu dmjbef_gyih\lhjbe hgLu ijbklZevghkfhlj_e
\ fh_ ebph\
fhb
]eZaZLu
\b^_e h]gbdhlhju_
oZjZdl_jbamxl ebph q_eh\_dZY fZ]lu \b^_ewlh \ fhbo
]eZaZoLuh^gZdhg_ agZewlh]hihlhfm qlhlu ^_eZewlh \
i_j\uc jZa=eZaZ ex^_cg_ y\ey_lky\k_ h^bgZdh\ufbLu
kdhjh magZ_rvwlhAZl_f ludmjbe heeb
Lu bf__rv\ \b^mq_eh\_dZ \ihe_"
Wlh [ueg_ q_eh\_dwlh [ueheeb^_eZ\rbc l_[_agZd
=^_ fu oh^beb"=^_ fu[uebdh]^Z y \b^_e wlh]h
q_eh\_dZy bf_x\ \b^mwlh]h heeb"
>hg OmZg k^_eZe `_klk\hbf ih^[hjh^dhfmdZaZ\ gZ
ijhkljZgkl\h i_j_^_]h ^hfhfb kdZaZeqlh hg[jZe f_gygZ
\_jrbgm g_[hevrh]h ohefZY kdZaZeqlh kp_gZdhlhjmx y
gZ[ex^Zeg_ bf_eZgbdZdh]h hlghr_gbyd imklugghfmqZiiZjZex
\hdjm] _]h ^hfZb hghl\_lbeqlh heebdhlhjuc ^_eZe
agZdfg_g_ [ueba hdj_klghklb
Hldm^Z hg"
Y \havfml_[y lm^Zhq_gv kdhjh
< q_fkfuke lh]hqlh y\b^_e"
Lu mqbeky \b^_lvwlh [ueh\k_gh l_i_jv lu
kh[bjZ_rvky ihl_jylv k\hbrlZguihlhfm qlh lu ihlZdZ_rv
k_[_lu ihdbgmek_[y jZ^bk\h_]h bkim]ZFh`_l [ulvlu
hibr_rv \k_qlh lu\b^_e"
Dh]^Z y gZqZe hibku\ZlvdZdbf h[jZahf _]h ebph
ihdZaZehkv fg_hg aZklZ\bef_gy hklZgh\blvkyb kdZaZeqlh
\k_ wlhg_ [ueh\Z`gufY kdZaZe_fmqlh ihqlb\b^_e_]h
dZd k\_lys__ky ycphHg
kdZaZeqlh ihqlb[ueh
g_^hklZlhqgh bqlh \b^_gv_ihlj_[m_l hlf_gy fgh]h\j_f_gb
b jZ[hlu
Hg bgl_j_kh\Zeky kp_ghc \kiZoZggh]h ihey b dZ`^hc
^_lZevxdhlhjmx yfh] \kihfgblvh q_eh\_d_
Wlhl heeb^_eZe l_[_agZdkdZaZe hgY ^\b]Ze
l\hx ]heh\mdh]^Z hg r_e dl_[_g_ ihlhfmqlh hg
ih^\_j]Ze l_[yhiZkghklbgh ihlhfmqlh emqr_`^ZlvLu g_
lhjhibrvky<hbg gbdh]^Z g_[_a^_evgbqZ_l b gbdh]^Z g_
lhjhiblky<klj_lblvky kheebg_ [m^mqb ih^]hlh\e_gguf
ih^h[gh \klj_q_gZiZ^Zxs_]h ev\Zk\hbf imdZgv_f
Fg_
ihgjZ\beZkv
f_lZnhjZFu
k
gZkeZ`^_gb_f
jZkkf_yebkv
Qlh kemqbehkv[u_keb [ulu g_hl\_e fhx]heh\m"
Lu ^he`_g[ue [ui_j_^\bgmlv k\hx]heh\m kZf
: _kebg_l"
Heeb ih^hr_e[u dl_[_ b^h kf_jlbgZim]Ze [u l_[y
?keb [u lu[ue h^bghg fh][u m[blvl_[yG_[eZ]hjZamfgh
l_[_ [ulv h^ghfm \]hjZo bebimklug_ihdZ lu g_ fh`_rv
aZsblblv k_[yHeeb fh`_lko\Zlblv l_[yh^gh]h lZfb k^_eZlv
ba l_[ydhle_lm
DZdh\h agZq_gb_^_ckl\bcdhlhju_ hg\uihegye"
Kfhljy gZl_[yhg bf_e\ \b^mqlh hg ijb\_lkl\m_l
l_[yHg ihdZau\Zel_[_qlh l_[_gm`_g eh\bl_ev ^moh\ b
kmfdZgh g_ba wlh]hjZchgZ_]h kmfdZ[ueZ ba^jm]hc qZklb
kljZguLu bf__rv ljbdZfgy ij_ldgh\_gbygZ k\h_f imlb
dhlhju_ aZklZ\eyxll_[y hklZgZ\eb\Zlvkyl_ \ZemguB lu
hij_^_e_ggh kh[bjZ_rvkyijbh[j_klb k\hbemqrb_ kbeu\ \h^guo
dZgvhgZo bh\jZ]Zoheeb mdZaZeh\jZ] l_[_HklZevgZy kp_gZ
hagZqZeZihfhqv l_[_hij_^_eblv lhqgh_f_klhqlh[u gZclb
_]hY agZxl_i_jv]^_ wlhf_klhY \havfml_[y lm^Zhq_gv
kdhjh
Lu bf__rv \ \b^mqlh i_caZ`dhlhjuc y \b^_e
^_ckl\bl_evgh kms_kl\m_l"
Dhg_qgh
=^_"
Y g_fh]m kdZaZlvl_[_ wlhlZd`_b g_ihlhfmqlh y
g_ ohqmgh ihlhfmqlh yijhklh g_agZxdZd kdZaZlvl_[_
Y ohl_eagZlv agZq_gb_\b^Z lhc`_ kZfhckp_gudh]^Z y
[ue \_]h dhfgZl_>hg OmZgjZkkf_yeky bbah[jZabe f_gydZd
y ^_j`ZekyaZ _]hgh]m
Wlh [uehgh\uf ih^l\_j`^_gb_fqlh heeb`_eZ_l l_[y
KdZaZe hgHg h[_ki_qb\Zeqlh[u lub yagZebqlh hg
ijb\_lkl\h\Ze l_[y
Qlh aZebph y\b^_e"
Hgh agZdhfhl_[_ ihlhfmqlh luagZ_rv _]hLu \b^_e
_]h ij_`^_Fh`_l [ulvwlh ebphl\h_c kf_jlbLu bkim]Zeky
gh wlh[ueZ l\hyg_[j_`ghklvHg `^Zel_[yb ludh]^Z hg
g_h`b^Zggh ihy\bekyih^^Zeky bkim]mD kqZklvxy [ue
a^_kvqlh[u klmdgmlv l_[ybgZq_ hgh[_jgmeky [u ijhlb\
l_[yqlh [ueh [ulhevdh ijZ\bevghQlh[u \klj_lblvky k
heebq_eh\_d ^he`_g[ulv [_amij_qguf\hbghfbgZq_ heeb
fh`_l h[_jgmlvkyijhlb\ g_]hb mgbqlh`blv_]h
>hg OmZgihkh\_lh\Ze fg_\ha\jZsZlvky \Ehk:g`_e_k gZ
ke_^mxs__ mljhHq_\b^ghhg ^mfZeqlh y_s_ g_ \iheg_
hijZ\bekyHg gZklhyeqlh[u yk_e \_]h dhfgZl_ebphf gZ
x]h\hklhd^ey lh]hqlh[u khojZgblvk\hx kbemHg k_e
ke_\Z hlf_gy\jmqbe fg_fhx aZibkgmxdgb`dm bkdZaZeqlh
gZ wlhljZa yk\yaZe _]hhg g_lhevdh ^he`_g[ue hklZ\Zlvky
kh fghchg lZd`_^he`_g [uejZkkdZau\Zlv fg_
Y ^he`_g\aylv l_[yd \h^_kgh\Z \kmf_jdZokdZaZe
hglu _s_g_ l\_j^b g_^he`_g [ulv h^bg k_]h^gyY
khklZ\ex l_[_dhfiZgbx gZ\k_ mljhihke_ h[_^Zlu [m^_rv\
emqr_c nhjf_
?]h hlghr_gb_aZklZ\beh f_gyihqm\kl\h\Zlv k_[y hq_gv
lj_\h`gh
Qlh g_ijZ\bevghkh fghc"ijhkbe y
Lu ihklmqZekyd heeb
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m ih^wlbf"
Fu g_^he`gu ]h\hjblvh[ heebk_]h^gyIh]h\hjbf h
q_fgb[m^v _s_
< ^_ckl\bl_evghklby g_ohl_e ]h\hjblvkh\k_fY gZqZe
qm\kl\h\Zlv k_[ylj_\h`gh b[_kihdhcgh>hg OmZghq_\b^gh
gZr_e kblmZpbxdjZcg_ kf_rghchg jZkkf_yeky^h ke_a
G_ ]h\hjb fg_qlh \
lh `_ \j_fydh]^Z lu
aZ]h\hjbrvlu g_kh[bjZ_rvky gZoh^blvgbq_]hqlh kdZaZlv
kdZaZe hgb _]h]eZaZ aZ[e_kl_ebhahjguf [e_kdhf
?]h gZkljh_gb_hq_gv mkihdZb\Zehf_gy
;ue lhevdh h^bgij_^f_ldhlhjuc bgl_j_kh\Ze f_gy \
wlhl fhf_glheeb?]h ebph[ueh lZdbfagZdhfufgh hgh g_
[uehdZd [m^lhy agZe_]h bebdZd [m^lhy \b^_e_]h ij_`^_
Wlh [ueh qlhlh _s_<kydbc jZadh]^Z ygZqbgZe ^mfZlv h
_]h ebp_fhc mfi_j_`b\Ze [hf[Zj^bjh\dm^jm]bo fuke_cdZd
[m^lh dZdZylh qZklv f_gyagZeZ lZcgmgh g_ iha\heyeZ
hklZevghfm \hfg_ ih^hclbd g_cHsms_gb_ ebpZheebdhlhjh_
[ueh agZdhfuf[ueh lZdbf `mldbfqlh ijb\_eh f_gy \
khklhygb_ m`Zkghcf_eZgohebb>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh wlhfh]eh
[ulv ebph fh_c kf_jlbY
^mfZxqlh wlh ml\_j`^_gb_
hdhgqZl_evgh ijb[behf_gyY ohl_e\ hlqZygbbkijhkblv _]h
h[ wlhfgh m f_gy[ueh ykgh_ hsms_gb_qlh ^hg OmZg
k^_j`b\Ze f_gyY k^_eZeiZjm ]em[hdbo\^hoh\ b \uiZebe
\hijhk
Qlh y\ey_lkykf_jlvx^hg OmZg"
Y g_agZxkdZaZe hgmeu[Zykv
Y bf_e\ \b^mdZd [ulu hibkZekf_jlv"Y ohqmagZlv
l\h_ fg_gb_Y ^mfZxqlh dZ`^ucbf__l hij_^_e_ggh_fg_gb_ h
kf_jlb
Y g_agZxh q_flu ]h\hjbrv
Y bf_elb[_lkdmx dgb]mf_jl\uom k_[y\ fZrbg_Fg_
kemqbehkv bkihevah\Zlv__ \dZq_kl\_ l_fu^ey jZa]h\hjZlZd
dZd hgZ bf_eZ ^_ehkh kf_jlvxY kdZaZeqlh kh[bjZxkv
ijhqblZlv ___fmb gZqZe\klZ\Zlv>hg OmZgaZklZ\be f_gy
k_klv b\ur_e bijbg_k dgb]mkZf
Mljh iehoh_ \j_fy^ey fZ]h\kdZaZe hgh[tykgyy
fg_ lhqlh yhklZeky kb^_lvlu _s_keZ[qlh[u \uoh^blv
ba fh_c dhfgZluA^_kv \gmljblu aZsbs_g?keb lu \uc^_rv
hlkx^Z l_i_jv_klv rZgkqlh lugZc^_rv m`Zkgh_g_kqZklv_
Heeb fh`_lm[blv l_[yih ^hjh]_beb \dmklZoZ iha`_dh]^Z
hgb gZc^ml l\h_l_ehhgb kdZ`mlqlh lu beb lZbgkl\_ggh
mf_jbeb ijhbahr_eg_kqZklguc kemqZc
Y g_ [ue \^he`ghf khklhygbbbeb gZkljh_gbbqlh[u
kijZrb\Zlv _]h j_r_gbcihwlhfm ykb^_e \k_ mljh ihqlb
qblZy bh[tykgyy _fmg_dhlhju_ qZklbdgb]bHg \gbfZl_evgh
kemrZe bkh\k_f g_i_j_[b\Ze f_gy>\Z`^u y hklZgZ\eb\Zeky
gZ dhjhldh_ \j_fydh]^Z hgijbghkbe \h^mbeb _^mgh dZd
lhevdh hg kgh\Zhk\h[h`^Zekyhg ih[m`^Zef_gy ijh^he`Zlv
ql_gb_HgdZaZehkv[ue hq_gvaZbgl_j_kh\Zg
Dh]^Z ydhgqbehg ihkfhlj_egZ f_gy
Y g_ihgbfZxihq_fm l_ex^b ]h\hjylh kf_jlbdZd
[m^lh kf_jlvih^h[gZ `bagbkdZaZe hgfy]dh
Fh`_l [ulvwlh kihkh[dZdbf hgbihgbfZxl __DZd lu
^mfZ_rvlb[_lpu \b^yl"
?^\Z ebDh]^Z q_eh\_dgZmqbeky \b^_lvlh g_l gb
h^ghc \_sbdhlhjmx hgagZ_ldhlhjZy kms_kl\m_lG_l gb
h^ghc?keb [lb[_lpu fh]eb\b^_lvhgb fh]eb[u kjZam`_
kdZaZlvqlh gbh^gZ \_svg_ y\ey_lky\hh[s_ [hevr_lhc `_
kZfhcKlhbl gZfm\b^_lvb gbqlhg_ y\ey_lkyba\_klguf
gbqlh g_hklZ_lky lZdbfdZdbf fuijb\udeb agZlvwlhdh]^Z
fu g_\b^_eb
Fh`_l [ulv^hg OmZg\b^_gv_g_ h^bgZdh\h ^ey
dZ`^h]h"
<_jghHgh g_lh `_kZfh_H^gZdhwlh g_ hagZqZ_l
qlh kfukeu `bagb
kms_kl\mxlDh]^Z
q_eh\_d gZmqbeky
\b^_lvgb h^gZ\_sv g_y\ey_lky lhc`_ kZfhc
Lb[_lpuhq_\b^gh^mfZxlqlh kf_jlvih^h[gZ `bagb
Qlh ^mfZ_rvlu kZfq_fm ih^h[gZkf_jlv"kijhkbe y
Y g_ ^mfZxqlh kf_jlvih^h[gZ q_fmgb[m^vb y
^mfZxqlh lb[_lpu^he`gh [ulv]h\hjbeb hq_fgb[m^v _s_
<h \kydhfkemqZ_lhh q_fhgb ]h\hjylwlh g_kf_jlv
DZd lu^mfZ_rvh q_fhgb ]h\hjyl"
Fh`_l [ulvlu fh`_rvkdZaZlv fg_wlh"Lhevdh lu
qblZ_rv
Y iulZekykdZaZlv qlhgb[m^v _s_gh hgaZkf_yeky
Fh`_l [ulvlb[_lpu
^_ckl\bl_evgh
\b^yl
ijh^he`Ze ^hg OmZgb \lZdhf kemqZ_ hgb ^he`gu [ueb
ihgylvqlh \lhfqlh hgb\b^yl\h\k_ g_lkfukeZb hgb
gZibkZeb wlm dmqmq_imob ihlhfmqlh wlhg_ bf__l gbdZdhc
jZagbpu ^ey gbo\ lZdhfkemqZ_lhqlh hgb gZibkZeb
\h\k_ g_q_imoZ
Y ^_ckl\bl_evgh g_ aZ[hqmkvh lhfqlh lb[_lpu
gZf_j_\Zebkv kdZaZlvkdZaZe ygh yg_khfg_ggh aZ[hqmkv
h lhfqlh ]h\hjbrvluY ohqmmkeurZlvqlh lu^mfZ_rv h
kf_jlb
Hg ijbklZevgh kfhlj_e gZ f_gy f]gh\_gb_Z aZl_f
aZobobdZeHg jZkdjuek\hb ]eZaZb ih^gye[jh\b \dhfbq_kdhf
m^b\e_gbb
Kf_jlv wlh dhevphebklv_\kdZaZe hgKf_jlv wlh ebphheebkf_jlv wlh [e_klys__h[eZdh gZ^]hjbahglhf
kf_jlv wlh r_ihl f_kdZeblh\ l\hbmrbkf_jlv wlh
[_aam[uc jhlkljZ`Zkf_jlv wlh O_gZjhklhysbc gZ k\h_c
]heh\_kf_jlv wlh fhcjZa]h\hjkf_jlv wlh lub l\hc
[ehdghlkf_jlv wlh imklydbf_ehqbHgZ a^_kvb\k_ `_
hgZ kh\k_fg_ a^_kv
>hg OmZg jZkkf_yekyk [hevrbfgZkeZ`^_gb_f?]h kf_o
[ue ih^h[_gi_gbxwlh [ue\b^ lZgp_\Zevgh]hjblfZ
Y ]h\hjx[_kkfukebpm"kdZaZe ^hgOmZgy g_fh]m
kdZaZlv l_[_gZ qlhihoh`Z kf_jlvGh\hafh`ghy fh]m
kdZaZlv l_[_h l\h_ckh[kl\_gghc kf_jlbG_l kihkh[ZmagZlv
q_fm hgZ [m^_lih^h[gZ \^_ckl\bl_evghklbh^gZdhy fh]m
kdZaZlv l_[_gZ qlhhgZ fh`_l[ulv ihoh`Z
Y bkim]Zekywlhfm b\hajZabeqlh yohl_e lhevdhagZlv
gZ qlh kf_jlv _fm dZaZeZkvihoh`_cy ih^q_jdgmeqlh
bgl_j_kh\Zeky _]hfg_gb_f hkf_jlb \h[uqghf kfuke_gh g_
klj_fbeky agZlv hih^jh[ghklyo qv_cgb[m^v ebqghc kf_jlb
hkh[_ggh fh_ckh[kl\_gghc
Y g_fh]m ]h\hjblvh kf_jlb[_a ebqguol_jfbgh\
kdZaZe hgLu ohl_eqlh[u yjZkkdZaZe l_[_ h kf_jlb
OhjhrhLh]^Z g_[hcky mkeurZlvh k\h_ckh[kl\_gghc kf_jlb
Y ijbagZekyqlh y[ue kebrdhfg_j\gufqlh[u ]h\hjblv
h[ wlhfY kdZaZeqlh yohl_e ih]h\hjblvh kf_jlb\ h[uqguo
\ujZ`_gbyo\ dhlhjuohg ]h\hjbekZfdh]^Z jZkkdZau\Zefg_
h^gZ`^u h kf_jlbk\h_]h kugZ_\eZebh]h\hjyqlh `bagv b
kf_jlv kf_rb\Zxlkyih^h[gh lmfZgm\ djbklZeeZo
Y ]h\hjbeqlh `bagvfh_]h kugZjZkrbjbeZkv \h\j_fy
_]h ebqghc kf_jlbkdZaZe hgY g_]h\hjbe h kf_jlb
\hh[s_gh hkf_jlb fh_]hkugZKf_jlvq_f [uhgZ gb[ueZ
aZklZ\beZ _]h`bagv jZkrbjblvky
Y hij_^_e_ggh ohl_e gZijZ\blvjZa]h\hj \g_ h[eZklb
ih^jh[ghkl_c b mihfygmeqlh y ijhqblZe fg_gby ex^_c
dhlhju_ [uebf_jl\ufb g_kdhevdhfbgml bh`b\e_gu [eZ]h^Zjy
f_^bpbgkdhc l_ogbd_<h \k_okemqZyo ex^bml\_j`^Zebqlh g_
fh]eb ijbihfgblv gbq_]h\hh[s_qlh mfbjZgb_ [ueh ijhklh
hsms_gb_f aZl_fg_gbykhagZgby
Wlh \iheg_ihgylghkdZaZe hgKf_jlv bf__l ^\_
klZ^bbI_j\Zy wlh aZl_fg_gb_Wlh [_kkfuke_ggZy klZ^by
hq_gv ihoh`Zy gZ i_j\h_ ^_ckl\b_ f_kdZeblh\ dhlhjhc
i_j_`b\Z_lky e_]dhklvaZklZ\eyxsZy qm\kl\h\Zlv kqZklv_
ihegh_b lhqlh \k_\ fbj_ kihdhcghGh wlh lhevdh
ih\_joghklgh_ khklhygb_hgh \kdhj_bkq_aZ_lb q_eh\_d
\oh^bl \ gh\mx h[eZklvh[eZklv `_klhdhklb b kbeuWlZ
\lhjZy klZ^byy\ey_lky ^_ckl\bl_evghc\klj_q_c kf_kdZeblh
Kf_jlv hq_gvkbevgh ihoh^blgZ wlhI_j\Zy klZ^by y\ey_lky
ih\_joghklguf aZl_fg_gb_f khagZgby<lhjZyh^gZdhwlh
^_ckl\bl_evgh klZ^by]^_ dZ`^uc\klj_qZ_lky khkf_jlvxwlh
g_^he]bc fhf_glihke_ i_j\h]haZl_fg_gbydh]^Z fugZoh^bf
qlh fu y\ey_fkydZdlhkgh\Z kZfbkh[hcB lh]^Z kf_jlv
jZa[b\Z_l gZkkh kihdhcghcyjhklvxihdZ hgZg_ jZkl\hjy_l
gZrm `bagv\ gbqlh
DZd lufh`_rv [ulvm\_j_gqlh ]h\hjbrvh kf_jlb"
Y bf_xk\h_]h heeb>ufhd ihdZaZefg_ [_ahrb[hqghfhx
kf_jlv k[hevrhc ykghklvx<hl ihq_fmy fh]m]h\hjblv lhevdh
h ebqghckf_jlb
Keh\Z ^hgZ OmZgZ\ua\Zeb \hfg_ ]em[hdh_ hiZk_gb_ b
^jZfZlbq_kdmx ^\hckl\_gghklvM f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hqlh hg
kh[bjZeky hibkZlvg_ijbdjulu_[ZgZevgu_ ^_lZebfh_c kf_jlb
b kdZaZlvfg_dZd bebdh]^Z y^he`_g mf_j_lvIjhklZy fukev
magZlv wlh\ua\ZeZ \hfg_ hlqZygb_b \lh `_\j_fy \ha[m^beZ
fh_ ex[hiulkl\hDhg_qghy fh]kijhkblv _]h hibkZlv _]h
kh[kl\_ggmx kf_jlvgh yqm\kl\h\Zeqlh lZdZyijhkv[Z [ueZ
[u g_kdhevdh]jm[hcb yZ\lhfZlbq_kdb bkdexqbe__
>hg OmZgdZaZehkvgZkeZ`^Zeky fhbfdhgnebdlhf?]h
l_eh kh^jh]Zehkvhl kf_oZ
Ohq_rv eblu agZlvgZ qlhfh`_l [ulv ihoh`Z l\hy
kf_jlv"kijhkbe hgf_gy kg_\bgguf m^h\hevkl\b_fgZ ebp_
Y gZr_e_]h hahjgh_m^h\hevkl\b_ \ih^^jZagb\Zgbb f_gy
g_kdhevdh mkihdZb\ZxsbfHgh ihqlbih^klj_dZeh fh_hiZk_gb_
OhjhrhkdZ`b fg_kdZaZe yb fhc]hehk ^jh]gme
Ihke_^h\Ze \gmrbl_evguc \aju\kf_oZHg ^_j`Zeky aZ
`b\hlih\_jgmeky gZ[hd bi_j_^jZagb\Zyih\lhjye ohjhrh
kdZ`b fg_ehfZxsbfky ]hehkhfAZl_f hg\uijyfbeky b k_e
gZimklb\ gZk_[y ijbl\hjgmxklhjh]hklvb k^jh`vx \]hehk_
kdZaZe
<lhjZy klZ^byl\h_c kf_jlbfh`_lkZfh_ emqr__[ulv
ke_^mxs_c
?]h ]eZaZbamqZeb f_gyk y\ghbkdj_ggbf ex[hiulkl\hfY
aZkf_yekyY ihgyeqlh
_]h
\urmqb\Zgb_ [ueh lhevdh
kj_^kl\hfdhlhjh_
fh]eh
ijblmiblv
hkljhlm
fukeb h
kh[kl\_gghc kf_jlb
Lu kbevgh]hgbrvijh^he`Ze hg]h\hjblvihwlhfm
lu fh`_rvgZclb k_[y\ ^Zggucfhf_glkgh\Z aZjme_fWlh
[m^_l hq_gvdhjhldh_ hsms_gb_dhlhjh_ g_^Zkl l_[_\j_f_gb
^mfZlvG_h`b^ZgghkdZ`_flu h[gZjm`brvk_[y _^msbfdZd
lu ^_eZe lZkyqbjZaGh ij_`^_q_f lu kfh`_rv m^b\blvky
k_[_lu aZf_qZ_rv g_h[uqgh_h[jZah\Zgb_ i_j_^ \_ljh\uf
kl_dehf?keb lu ihkfhljbrv[eb`_lu ihcf_rvqlh wlh
h[eZdhdhlhjh_ \u]ey^blih^h[gh [e_klys_fmdhevpm ebklv_\
Hgh ihoh^blkdZ`_fgZ ebphijyfh ihkj_^bg_[Z i_j_^lh[hc
Dh]^Z lugZ[ex^Z_rv _]hlu m\b^brvqlh hgh^\b`_lky gZaZ^
ihdZ g_klZgh\blky lhevdhk\_jdZxs_c lhqdhcgZ jZkklhygbbZ
aZl_f lu aZf_lbrvqlh hghgZqZeh ^\b]Zlvkyd l_[_ kgh\Z
hgh ijbh[j_lZ_l kdhjhklv b
\ f]gh\_gb_ hdZ \^j_[_a]b
jZa[b\Z_l kl_dehl\h_c fZrbguLu kbevgucb ym\_j_gqlh
kf_jlb ihlj_[m_lky^\Z m^ZjZqlh[u ^h[jZlvky^h l_[y
D lhfm \j_f_gblu magZ_rv]^_ lub qlh kemqbehkv k
lh[hcebph hlklmiblkgh\Z ^h]hjbahglZgZ[_j_l kdhjhklvb
khdjmrbl l_[yEbph \hc^_l\gmljv l_[yb lh]^Zlu magZ_rv
hgh [uehebphf heebbeb hgh[ueh fghc]h\hjysbfbeb lh[hc
ibsmsbfKf_jlv [ueZimklydhf \k_\j_fyF_ehqvxHgZ [ueZ
djhr_qghc lhqdhcaZl_jy\r_cky gZebklZo l\h_]h[ehdghlZB
\k_ `_hgZ \hreZ \gmljv l_[y k g_m^_j`bfhc kbehc b
aZklZ\beZ l_[y jZkrbjblvkyhgZ aZklZ\bl l_[y k^_eZlvky
jh\guf b jZkijhkljZgblvkyih g_[mb a_fe_b aZgbfbB lu
[m^_rv ih^h[_glmfZgm \f_evqZcrbo djbklZeeZo^\b`msboky
m^Zeyxsboky
F_gy hq_gv aZo\ZlbehhibkZgb_ fh_ckf_jlbY h`b^Ze
mkeurZlv g_qlh lZdh_ hlebqgh_Y g_fh] ]h\hjblv gbq_]h
^he]h_ \j_fy
Kf_jlv \oh^blq_j_a `b\hlijh^he`Ze hgIjyfh
q_j_a hdgh \hebWlh f_klhy\ey_lky gZb[he__ \Z`ghc b
qm\kl\bl_evghc qZklvx q_eh\_dZWlh h[eZklv\heb b lZd`_
h[eZklvq_j_a dhlhjmx\k_ fumfbjZ_fY agZxwlhihlhfm
qlh fhc
heeb
ijb\h^be
f_gy
d
wlhc
klZ^bbFZ]
ijbkihkZ[eb\Z_l k\hx \hexiha\heyy k\h_ckf_jlb h\eZ^_lv
bfZ dh]^Zhg klZgh\blkyiehkdbf bgZqbgZ_l jZkrbjylvky
_]h g_ih]j_rbfZy\hey [_j_l\_jo bkh[bjZ_l lmfZg\ ^jm]h]h
q_eh\_dZ kgh\Z
>hg OmZg k^_eZekljZgguc `_klHg jZkdjue k\hb jmdb
ih^h[gh ^\mf \__jZfih^gye bagZ mjh\_gv k\hbo ehdl_c
ih\_jgme boihdZ _]h[hevrb_ iZevpug_ dhkgmebkv[hdh\Z
aZl_f i_j_g_k bof_^e_ggh \f_kl_d p_gljml_eZ gZ^ k\hbf
imidhfHg ^_j`Zebo lZfg_dhlhjh_ \j_fy?]h jmdb ^jh`Zeb
hl gZijy`_gbyAZl_f hg ih^gyebo b dhgqbdZfb kj_^gbo
iZevp_\ dhkgmekye[ZZ aZl_fhimklbe bo\ lh`_ iheh`_gb_d
p_gljm k\h_]hl_eZ
Wlh [ue kljZrguc`_kl>hg OmZg\uihegbe _]hk lZdhc
kbehc bdjZkhlhcqlh y[ue hqZjh\Zg
Wlh fZ]kh[bjZ_l k\hx\hexkdZaZe hggh dh]^Z
klZjhklv ^_eZ_l _]h keZ[uf_]h \heykeZ[__l b ijboh^bl
g_ba[_`guc fhf_gldh]^Z hgg_ fh`_l[hevr_ mijZ\eylvk\h_c
\he_cLh]^Z hg
g_
bf__l
gbq_]hqlh[u ijhlb\blvky
[_afhe\ghc kbe__]h kf_jlbb _]h`bagv klZgh\blky ih^h[gZ
`bagb \k_o hdjm`Zxsbo_]h ex^_cjZkrbjyxsbfky lmfZghf
^\b`msbfky aZ_]h ij_^_eu
>hg OmZgijbklZevgh ihkfhlj_egZ f_gyb hklZgh\bekyHg
^jh`Ze
Lu fh`_rvb^lb ddmklZf l_i_jvkdZaZe hgm`_
ihke_ihem^_ggh_ \j_fy
Fg_ gm`gh[ueh b^lbgh yg_ hl\Z`b\ZekyY qm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y\hafh`ghkdhj__ g_j\ghq_f bkim]ZgghH^gZdhm f_gy
g_ [ueh[hevr_ fjZqgh]hij_^qm\kl\by h[heeb
>hg OmZg kdZaZeqlh wlhg_ bf_eh agZq_gbydZd y
qm\kl\mx k_[y_keb y[ue l\_j^Hg aZ\_jbef_gyqlh y
[ue \iheghc nhjf_b fh][_ahiZkgh b^lb\ dmkluihdZ y g_
ijb[eb`Zeky d\h^_
Wlh ^jm]h_^_ehkdZaZe hgFg_ gm`gh bkdmiZlv
l_[y _s_jZaihwlhfm ^_j`bkvih^Zevr_ hl\h^u
Iha^g__ hgih`_eZeqlh[u yhl\_a _]h\ khk_^gbc]hjh^
Y mihfygmeqlh ih_a^dZ[m^_l ijbylghci_j_f_ghc ^ey f_gy
ihlhfm qlhy [ue\k_ _s_keZ[fukevqlh fZ]^_ckl\bl_evgh
b]jZe khk\h_c kf_jlvx[ueZ kh\_jr_gghm`Zkghc ^eyf_gy
;ulv fZ]hfwlh m`Zkguc]jmakdZaZe hgm[_`^_gguf
lhghfY ]h\hjbe l_[_qlh gZfgh]h emqr_ gZmqblvky
\b^_lvQ_eh\_ddhlhjuc \b^blwlh \k_\ kjZ\g_gbbk
gbf fZ]wlh [_^gucq_eh\_d
Qlh lZdh_fZ]by^hg OmZg"
Hg kfhlj_e gZ f_gy^he]h_ \j_fy b ihqlb g_aZf_lgh
ihljyk ]heh\hc
FZ]by wlh agZqblijbeh`blv k\hx\hex d dexq_\hfm
a\_gmkdZaZe hgfZ]by wlh \f_rZl_evkl\hFZ] bs_lb
gZoh^bl dexq_\h_a\_gh \h\k_fgZ qlhhg ohq_l\ha^_ckl\h
\Zlvb aZl_f hgijbeZ]Z_l lm^Zk\hx \hexFZ]m g_ gZ^h
\b^_lvqlh[u [ulvfZ]hf<k_qlh _fmgZ^h agZlvwlh
dZd ihevah\Zlvkyk\h_c \he_c
Y ihijhkbe _]h h[tykgblvqlh hgbf__l \ \b^m ih^
dexq_\uf a\_ghfHg aZ^mfZekygZ f]gh\_gb_Z aZl_fkdZaZe
qlh hgagZeq_f [ueZfhy fZrbgZ
Wlh y\ghfZrbgZkdZaZe y
Y bf_x\ \b^mqlh l\hyfZrbgZ wlh aZiZevgu_k\_qb
Wlh dexq_\h_ a\_gh^ey f_gyY fh]mijbeh`blv d g_fm fhx
\hexb l\hyfZrbgZ g_[m^_l jZ[hlZlv
>hg OmZgk_e \fhx fZrbgmHg ihdZaZefg_ k^_eZlv lZd
`_dZd hgkZfb m^h[ghk_klv
GZ[ex^Zc aZ l_fqlh y^_eZxkdZaZe hgY \hjhgZihwlhfm\ i_j\mxhq_j_^v yjZkimsm k\hbi_jvy
Hg aZ^jh`Ze \k_fk\hbf l_ehf?]h ^\b`_gby gZihfgbeb
fg_ \hjh[vykfZqb\Zxs_]h k\hbi_jvy \em`_Hg himklbek\hx
]heh\mih^h[gh ilbp_fZdZxs_c k\hcdex\ \\h^m
Wlh ^_ckl\bl_evghohjhrh qm\kl\m_lkykdZaZe hg b
aZkf_yeky
?]h kf_o [ue kljZggufHg
bf_e hq_gv g_h[uqgh_
]bighlbq_kdh_ \ha^_ckl\b_ gZf_gyY \kihfgbeqlh keurZe
lZdhc `__]h kf_ofgh]h jZaij_`^_<hafh`ghqlh ijbqbghc
ihq_fm y gbdh]^Zhldjulh g_khagZ\Ze _]h[ueh lhqlh hg
gbdh]^Z g_kf_yeky ih^h[ghwlhfm \fh_f ijbkmlkl\bb
AZl_f \hjhgZ jZkkeZ[ey_lk\hx r_xkdZaZe hg b
gZqZe djmlblvk\h_c r__cb l_j_lvkys_dZfb hk\hb ie_qb
AZl_f hgZkfhljbl gZfbj h^gbf]eZahfZ ihlhf^jm]bf
?]h ]heh\Z \kljyob\ZeZkvdh]^Z
hg ml\_j^bl_evgh
i_j_deZ^u\Ze k\hc \a]ey^gZ fbjk h^gh]h]eZaZ gZ ^jm]hc
A\md _]hkf_oZ ih\ukbekyM f_gy[ueh g_e_ih_qm\kl\hqlh
hg kh[bjZ_lkyij_\jZlblvky \\hjhgm ijyfhgZ fhbo]eZaZoY
ohl_e hl^_eZlvky kf_ohfgh y[ue ihqlb iZjZebah\ZgY
^_ckl\bl_evgh qm\kl\h\ZedZdmxlh ho\Zlu\Zxsmxkbem \hdjm]
f_gyY g_ qm\kl\h\Zegb kljZoZgb ]heh\hdjm`_gbygb
khgeb\hklbFhb kihkh[ghklb g_[ueb aZljhgmluih fh_fm
fg_gbx
AZ\h^b k\hxfZrbgm l_i_jvkdZaZe ^hgOmZg
Y \dexqbeklZjl_j bZ\lhfZlbq_kdb gZ`ZegZ i_^Zev]ZaZ
KlZjl_j aZ\jZsZekygh aZ`b]ZgbyfhlhjZ g_[ueh>hg OmZg
aZkf_yeky lbobfjblfbqguf obobdZgv_fY ihijh[h\Ze\dexqblv
kgh\Z[ueh lh`_ kgh\ZY ihljZlbe\hafh`gh^_kylv fbgml
\jZsZy klZjl_jfh_c fZrbgu>hg OmZgobobdZe \k_wlh \j_fy
Lh]^Z yhldZaZeky bkb^_e lZfk ly`_ehc]heh\hc
Hg dhgqbe kf_ylvky bjZkkfZljb\Ze f_gyb y agZe
lh]^Zqlh _]hkf_o \\h^bef_gy \]bighlbq_kdbc ljZgkOhly
y \iheg_khagZ\Ze lhqlh ijhbkoh^behy qm\kl\h\Zeqlh y
g_ [ue kZfbf kh[hc< l_q_gb_\j_f_gbdh]^Z y g_ fh]
aZ\_klb k\hx fZrbgmy [uehq_gv ihkemrgufihqlb hg_f_e
>hg OmZgdZd [m^lhk^_eZe qlhlh g_lhevdh kfh_c fZrbghc
gh bkh fghclh`_Dh]^Z hgdhgqbe obobdZlvy [uem[_`^_g
qlh dhe^h\kl\h dhgqbehkvb klj_fbl_evghgZ`Ze gZ klZjl_j
kgh\ZY [uem\_j_gqlh ^hgOmZg lhevdh]bighlbabjh\Ze f_gy
k\hbf kf_ohfb aZklZ\eyef_gy ih\_jblvqlh yg_ fh]aZ\_klb
fZrbgmM]hedhf ]eZaZ y \b^_eqlh hg k ex[hiulkl\hf
gZ[ex^Ze aZfghcdh]^Z y\dexqZe fhlhjb g_bklh\hgZdZqb\Ze
]Za
>hg OmZgfy]dh ihoehiZef_gy bkdZaZeqlh g_bklh\kl\h
k^_eZ_l f_gy l\_j^ufb\hafh`ghfg_ g_ gm`gh [m^_l
dmiZlvky \ \h^_ kgh\ZQ_f [he__g_bklh\uf y [m^ml_f
kdhj__ ykfh]m hijZ\blvkyhl fh_c\klj_qb kheeb
G_ kfmsZckykdZaZe ^hgOmZg>Z\b gh]hcfZrbgm
Hg jZajZabeky _kl_kl\_gguf
h[uqguf
kf_ohfb y
ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[ykf_rgh b]emih\Zlh aZkf_yeky
Q_j_a g_dhlhjh_\j_fy ^hgOmZg kdZaZeqlh hghk\h[h^be
fZrbgmB hgZaZ\_eZkv
=eZ\Z
q_ lu jg Z^ pZ lZ y
k_gly[jy ]h^Z
<hdjm] ^hfZ ^hgZ OmZgZ[ueh qlhlh `mldh_< wlhl
fhf_gl y ^mfZeqlh hg kijylZeky ]^_lh ih[ebahklb b
gZ[ex^Ze aZfghcY ihdjbqZe_fmZ aZl_fkh[jZe ^hklZlhqgh
fm`_kl\Zqlh[u \hclb \gmljv>hgZ OmZgZlZf g_ [uehY
ihklZ\be ^\_kmfdb [ZdZe_cguolh\Zjh\dhlhju_ yijb\_agZ
dmqm ^jh\b k_e^h`b^Zlvky _]hdZd ^_eZefgh]h jZajZgvr_
Gh \ i_j\uc jZaaZ \k_]h^u fh_ck\yab k^hghf OmZghf y
bkim]Zeky hklZ\Zlvky h^bg
\
_]h
^hf_Y qm\kl\h\Ze
ijbkmlkl\b_ dh]hlh g_\b^bfh]h a^_kv kh fghcLh]^Z y
\kihfgbeqlh g_kdhevdhe_l gZaZ^m f_gy[ueh lh`_ kZfh_
g_ykgh_ qm\kl\hqlh qlhlh g_ba\_klgh_[jh^beh \hdjm]f_gy
dh]^Z y[ue h^bgY \kdhqbeb \u[_`Zeba ^hfZ
Y ijb_oZeqlh[u m\b^_lv^hgZ OmZgZb jZkkdZaZlv _fm
qlh gZdhie_ggu_wnn_dlu aZ^Zqb\b^_gvygZeh`beb k\hx^Zgv
gZ f_gyY
gZqZe
qm\kl\h\Zlv
[_kihdhckl\hg_ykgh
\hkijbgbfZ_fh_ [_adZdhceb[h hq_\b^ghcijbqbgumklZehklv
g_ [m^mqb mlhfe_ggufAZl_f fhy j_Zdpby gZ ijbkmlkl\b_
h^ghfm \^hf_ ^hgZOmZgZ \ua\ZeZ\h fg_h[smx iZfylvh lhf
dZd kljhbekyfhc kljZo\ ijhrehf
KljZo i_j_g_k f_gygZ g_kdhevdhe_l gZaZ^dh]^Z ^hg
OmZg
gZ\yaZe
fg_
hq_gv
g_h[uqgh_
kjZ\g_gb_
f_`^m
`_gsbghcfZ]hfdhlhjmx hggZau\Ze eZ DZlZebgZb fghc
Wlh gZqZehkvghy[jy ]h^Zdh]^Z ygZr_e _]h\ ^hf_k
\u\bogmlhc eh^u`dhcHg h[tykgbeqlh mg_]h [ue \jZ] \_^vfZdhlhjZy fh]eZh[_jgmlvky q_jguf^jha^hf b dhlhjZy
iulZeZkv m[blv_]h
DZd lhevdhy kfh]moh^blvy ihdZ`ml_[_dlh wlZ
`_gsbgZkdZaZe ^hgOmZgLu ^he`_gagZlvdlh hgZ_klv
Ihq_fm hgZohq_l m[blvl_[y"
Hg g_l_ji_eb\h ih`Ze ie_qZfb b hldZaZeky hl\_qZlv
qlhgb[m^v _s_
Y \_jgmekym\b^_lv _]h^_kylv ^g_ckimkly bgZr_e _]h
kh\_js_ggh a^hjh\ufHg ihdjmlbe k\h_c eh^u`dhcqlh[u
ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Zlv fg_qlh hgZ\ ij_djZkghfkhklhygbbb
ijbibkZe k\h_
[ukljh_
\ua^hjh\e_gb_
ijbjh^_ ]bikh\hc
ih\yadbdhlhjmx hgkZf k^_eZe
Ohjhrhqlh lu a^_kvkdZaZe hgK_]h^gy y
kh[bjZxkv \aylvl_[y \g_[hevrh_ iml_r_kl\b_
AZl_f hg gZijZ\be f_gy_oZlv \[_aex^gh_ f_klhFu
hklZgh\bebkv lZf^hg OmZg \ulygmek\hb gh]b b m^h[gh
mkljhbeky gZ \b^_gvbdZd [m^lhkh[bjZykv \a^j_fgmlvHg
\_e_e fg_jZkkeZ[blvky bhklZ\Zlvky kh\_jr_gghkihdhcgufhg
kdZaZeqlh fu ^he`gu
[ulv
dZd fh`gh g_aZf_lg__ ^h
gZklmie_gby kmf_j_dihlhfm qlhiha^gbc \_q_j [ue hq_gv
hiZkguf \j_f_g_f^ey ^_eZdhlhjuf fuaZgbfZ_fky
DZdbf ^_ehffu aZgbfZ_fky"kijhkbe y
Fu a^_kv ^eylh]hqlh[u hlf_lblveZ DZlZebgm
kdZaZe hg
Dh]^Z klZeh agZqbl_evghl_fghfu g_aZf_lgh\ureb ba
fZrbgu b hq_gv f_^e_ggh b [_krmfgh \hreb \ imklugguc
qZiiZjZev
K f_klZ]^_ fuhklZgh\bebkvy fh]jZa]ey^_lv l_fgu_
kbemwlu ohefh\ ih h[_bf klhjhgZfFu [ueb \ iehkdhf
djZkb\hfrbjhdhf dZgvhg_>hg OmZg ^Ze fg_ ih^jh[gmx
bgkljmdpbx h lhfdZd hklZ\Zlvkykebluf k qZiZjZe_fb
gZmqbe f_gykihkh[m kb^_lv\ [h^jkl\h\ZgbbdZd hggZau\Ze
wlhHg \_e_efg_ ih^h]gmlvfhx ijZ\mxgh]m ih^fh_ e_\h_
[_^jh bkhojZgylv fhxe_\mx gh]m\ keh`_gghfiheh`_gbbHg
h[tykgbeqlh ih^h]gmlZy gh]Zbkihevah\ZeZkv \ dZq_kl\_
ijm`bgu ^eylh]hqlh[u \klZlvk [hevrhckdhjhklvx_keb wlh
[m^_l g_h[oh^bfufAZl_f hg\_e_e fg_kb^_lv ebphfgZ aZiZ^
ihlhfm qlhwlh [uehgZijZ\e_gb_ ^hfZ`_gsbguHg k_e jy^hf
kh fghckijZ\Zb r_ihlhfkdZaZe fg_^_j`Zlv fhb ]eZaZ
knhdmkbjh\Zggufb gZ a_fexbsZbebkdhj__h`b^Zy \hegm
\_ljZdhlhjZy ijhba\_^_l\heg_gb_ \dmklZoDh]^Z \heg_gb_
dhkg_lky dmklh\gZ dhlhju_y nhdmkbjh\Zefhc ijbklZevguc
\a]ey^y ^he`_g[ue \a]eygmlv\\_jo bm\b^_lv dhe^mgvx \h
\k_f
__
\_ebdhe_ighf
aeh\_s_f
[e_kd_>hg
OmZg
^_ckl\bl_evgh bkihevah\Ze wlbkeh\ZDh]^Z yihijhkbe _]h
h[tykgblvqlh hg bf__l\ \b^mhg kdZaZeqlh_keb y
h[gZjm`m \heg_gb_\ dmklZoy ijhklh^he`_g ihkfhlj_lv\\_jo
b m\b^_lv kZfihlhfm qlhdhe^mgvy \ihe_l_bf_eZ lZdhc
g_h[udgh\_gguc \b^qlh wlhg_ ih^^Z\Zehkvh[tykg_gbyf
>me qbkluckihdhcguc \_l_jb y^mfZeqlh yh[gZjm`be
\heg_gb_ \ dmklZofgh]h jZaY ih^gbfZe]eZaZ dZ`^uc jZa
]hlh\ykv dljZgkp_g^_glZevghfm i_j_`b\Zgbxgh ygbq_]h g_
\b^_eDZ`^uc jZadh]^Z \_l_jjZa^m\Ze dmklu^hg OmZg
wg_j]bqgh m^Zjye gh]hc iha_fe_ih\hjZqb\Zykv djm]hf b
^\b]Zy jmdZfbdZd [m^lhhgb [bebKbeZ _]h^\b`_gbc [ueZ
qj_a\uqZcghc
Ihke_ g_kdhevdbog_m^Zq m\b^_lvdhe^mgvx \ ihe_l_y
m\_jbekyqlh g_[m^m k\b^_l_e_f gbdZdh]h ljZgkp_g^_glZ
evgh]h kh[ulbyh^gZdh^hg OmZgihdZau\Ze kbemlZd hkljh
qlh yg_ ihfgbedZd ijh\_eghqv
GZ jZkk\_l_^hg OmZgih^k_e dhfg_HgdZaZehkv[ue
kh\_jr_ggh bagmj_gHg _^\Zfh] ^\b]ZlvkyHg e_]gZ kibgmb
ijh[hjfhlZeqlh _fmg_ m^Zehkvijhgablv `_gsbgmY [ue
kbevgh aZbgljb]h\Zg wlbf
aZy\e_gb_fhg ih\lhjbe _]h
g_kdhevdh jZab dZ`^ucjZa _]hlhg klZgh\beky \k_ [he__
mgueuf[he__ hlqZyggufY
gZqZe i_j_`b\Zlv g_h[uqgh_
[_kihdhckl\hFg_ [uehhq_gv e_]dhijh_pbjh\Zlv fhbqm\kl\Z
gZ gZkljh_gb_^hgZ OmZgZ
>hg OmZg gbq_]h g_ mihfbgZeh[ wlhf kemqZ_ beb h
`_gsbg_ g_kdhevdh f_kyp_\Y ^mfZeqlh hgbeb aZ[ue beb
j_rbe \k_ ^_ehH^gZdhh^gZ`^u y gZr_e _]h \ hq_gv
\a\hegh\Zgghf gZkljh_gbbb
\
fZg_j_dhlhjZy [ueZ
kh\_jr_ggh g_k\hckl\_ggZ_]h _kl_kl\_gghfmkihdhckl\bxhg
kdZaZe fg_qlh q_jguc ^jha^kb^_e i_j_^gbf ij_^u^ms_c
ghqvxb qlhhg ^Z`_g_ aZkgmeBkdmkkl\h `_gsbgu[ueh lZdbf
[hevrbfqlh hg kh\k_fg_ qm\kl\h\Ze__ ijbkmlkl\byHg
kdZaZeqlhd kqZklvxhg ijhkgmeky\ hij_^_e_ggucfhf_gl
qlh[u ih^]hlh\blvkyd kZfhfmm`Zkghfm [hxaZ k\hx`bagvLhg
^hgZ OmZgZ [ue
\a\hegh\Zggucihqlb
iZl_lbq_kdbcY
ihqm\kl\h\Ze g_ij_h^hebfmx\hegm `Zehklbb [_kihdhckl\Z
< fjZqghfb ^jZfZlbq_kdhflhg_ hg\gh\v ih^l\_j^beqlh
m g_]hg_ [uehkihkh[Z hklZgh\blv__ bqlh \ke_^mxsbc jZa
dh]^Z hgZ ijb^_ld g_fmwlh [m^_l_]h ihke_^gbc ^_gv gZ
a_fe_Y klZe mgueufb [ue_^\Z g_\ ke_aZo>hg OmZg
dZaZehkvaZf_lbe fh_]em[hdh_ [_kihdhckl\hb aZkf_yekydZd
y ih^mfZeojZ[jhHg ihoehiZef_gy ihkibg_ bkdZaZeqlh[u
y g_l_jaZekyqlh hg_s_ g_\iheg_ ihl_jygihlhfm qlhbf_e
h^gm ihke_^gxxdZjlmdhaujgmx dZjlm
<hbg `b\_lkljZl_]bq_kdbkdZaZe hgmeu[Zykv
<hbg gbdh]^Z g_ [_j_lky aZ]jmadhlhjuc hg g_ fh`_l
m^_j`Zlv \jmdZo
Meu[dZ ^hgZ OmZgZbf_eZ kbemjZah]gZlv aeh\_sb_ lmqb
km^v[uY \g_aZighihqm\kl\h\Ze ijbih^gylh_gZkljh_gb_b fu
h[Z aZkf_yebkvHg ihoehiZef_gy ih]heh\_
Lu agZ_rvba \k_o\_s_c gZa_fe_lu wlh fhy
ihke_^gyy dZjlZkdZaZe hghlju\bklh\a]eygm\ fg_ijyfh \
]eZaZ
Qlh"
Lu y\ey_rvkyfh_c dhaujghcdZjlhc \fh_f [hx ijhlb\
wlhc \_^vfu
Y g_ ihgyeqlh hgbf__l \\b^mb hg h[tykgbeqlh
`_gsbgZ g_agZeZ f_gyb qlh_keb yku]jZx k\h_cjmdhc lZd
dZd hg mdZ`_lfg_m f_gy[m^_l [he__q_f ohjhrbcrZgk
ijhgablv __
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m ih^wlbf ijhgablv __"
Lu g_fh`_rv m[blv__gh lu^he`_g ijhgablv__dZd
\ha^mrguc rZj?keb lu k^_eZ_rvwlhhgZ hklZ\bl f_gy
h^gh]hGh g_ ^mfZc h[wlhf l_i_jvY kdZ`m l_[_qlh
^_eZlvdh]^Z ijb^_l\j_fy
Ijhreb f_kypuY aZ[uekemqZc b[ue m^b\e_gdh]^Z y
ijb[ue h^gZ`^u \ _]h^hf^hg OmZg\u[_`Ze bg_ ^Ze fg_
\uclb bafZrbgu
Lu ^he`_g m_oZlv g_f_^e_gghijhr_ilZe hg kh
kljZrghc [_ahleZ]Zl_evghklvxKemrZc \gbfZl_evghDmib
jm`v_beb ^hklZgv_]h ex[uf\hafh`guf iml_fg_ ijbghkbfg_
k\h_ kh[kl\_ggh_jm`v_lu ihgbfZ_rv"Ijbg_kb ex[h_ jm`v_
aZ bkdexq_gb_f k\h_]h kh[kl\_ggh]hb ijbg_kb _]h kx^Z
g_f_^e_ggh
AZq_f l_[_jm`v_"
HlijZ\eycky k_cqZk`_
Y \_jgmekyk jm`v_fM f_gyg_ [ueh^hklZlhqgh ^_g_]
qlh[u dmiblv_]hgh fhc^jm] ^Zefg_ k\h_klZjh_ jm`v_>hg
OmZg g_ihkfhlj_e gZg_]hhg h[tykgbekf_ykvqlh hg [ue
j_ahd khfghcihlhfm qlhq_jguc ^jha^[ue gZdjur_ _]h^hfZ
b hgg_ ohl_eqlh[u hgZ\b^_eZ f_gy
H[gZjm`b\ q_jgh]h^jha^Z gZdjur_m f_gy \hagbdeZ
fukevqlh lufh] ijbg_klbjm`v_ bijhgablv __ba g_]h
kdZaZe ^hg OmZg \ujZabl_evghY g_ohqmqlh[u k lh[hc
qlhgb[m^v kemqbehkvihwlhfm yihkh\_lh\Zeqlh[u ludmibe
jm`v_ beb^hklZe _]hdZdbfgb[m^v ^jm]bfiml_f<b^brv eb
lu ^he`_gmgbqlh`blv jm`v_ihke_ \uiheg_gbyaZ^Zqb
H dZdhcaZ^Zq_ lu]h\hjbrv"
Lu ^he`_g ihiulZlvkyijhgablv `_gsbgm ba k\h_]h
jm`vy
Hg aZklZ\bef_gy gZqbklblvjm`v_gZl_j_\ _]h k\_`bfb
ebklvyfb bkl_[eyfb hkh[hiZogms_]h jZkl_gbyHg kZfijhl_j
h[Z iZljhgZ b\eh`be bo\ kl\heuAZl_f hgkdZaZeqlh y
^he`_g kijylZlvky aZ _]h^hfhf b`^Zlv ^hl_o ihjihdZ
q_jguc ^jha^ g_ ky^_l
gZ
djurmb aZl_flsZl_evgh
ijbp_eb\rbkvy ^he`_g[ue \uiZeblvba h[_bokl\heh\Wnn_dl
m^b\e_gby[hevr_q_f ^jh[vijhgabl `_gsbgmb_keb y[ue
kbevguf b j_rbl_evgufy fh]aZklZ\blv __hklZ\blv _]h \
ihdh_LZdbf h[jZahffhy jmdZ^he`gZ [ulv [_amij_qghc b
lZdbf `_fh_ j_r_gb_ijhgablv __
Lu ^he`_gijhgabl_evgh aZdjbqZlv\ fhf_gl\uklj_eZ
kdZaZe hgWlh ^he`_g[ulv m[_^bl_evgucb ijhgabl_evguc
\udjbd
AZl_f hgkeh`be dmqmba imqdh\[Zf[mdZ b^jh\ \^_kylb
nmlZo hl jZfZ^Z _]h^hfZHg \_e_efg_ hi_j_lvky gZ wlm
dmqmIheh`_gb_ [uehhq_gv m^h[gufY ihemkb^_efhy kibgZ
[ueZ ohjhrhih^i_jlZb mf_gy [ueohjhrbc h[ahjdjurb
Hg kdZaZeqlh \_^vf_[ueh _s_kebrdhf jZghihy\blvky b
qlh ^hl_fghlu fukfh`_f k^_eZlv\k_ ijb]hlh\e_gbyaZl_f hg
ijbl\hjblkyqlh hgaZi_jky \^hf_^ey lh]hqlh[u ijb\e_qv
__ b\ua\Zlv _s_h^gh gZiZ^_gb_gZ k\hxebqghklvHg \_e_e
fg_ jZkkeZ[blvky b gZclbm^h[gh_ iheh`_gb_qlh[u y fh]
\uklj_eblv [_a ^\b`_gbyHg aZklZ\bef_gy ijbp_eblvky gZ
djurm iZjmjZa baZdexqbeqlh ^_ckl\b_ih^gbfZgb_ jm`vy d
fh_fm ie_qm b ijbp_eb\Zgb_
[ueb kebrdhf f_^e_ggufb b
g_kdeZ^gufbAZl_f hgihkljhbe ih^ihjdm^ey jm`vyHg k^_eZe
^\Z ]em[hdbohl\_jklby `_e_aguf[jmkdhfihf_klbe \gbo ^\_
jh]mevdb b ijb\yaZe ^ebggmx`_j^v f_`^m bo jZa\bebgZfb
Dhgkljmdpby ^Z\ZeZfg_ mihj^ey klj_ev[ub iha\heyeZ^_j`Zlv
jm`v_ gZp_e_ggufgZ djurm
>hg OmZgihkfhlj_e gZg_[h bkdZaZeqlh _fm[ueh \j_fy
b^lb \^hfHg \klZeb f_^e_gghb kihdhcghihr_e \gmljv^Z\
fg_ ihke_^g__ ij_^hkl_j_`_gb_qlh fh_klZjZgb_ g_ [ueh
rmldhc bqlh y^he`_g [ueihjZablv ilbpmk i_j\h]h\uklj_eZ
Ihke_ lh]hdZd ^hgOmZg mr_e\k_]h ebrv g_kdhevdh
fbgml [ueb kmf_jdbZ
aZl_f
klZeh kh\_jr_ggh l_fgh
DZaZehkvdZd [m^lh l_fghlZ `^ZeZ^h l_o ihjihdZ y
hklZgmkv h^bgb \g_aZighkimklbeZkv gZf_gyY iulZeky
knhdmkbjh\Zlv fhb]eZaZ gZdjur_dhlhjZy \ujbkh\u\ZeZkvgZ
nhg_ g_[ZgZ \j_fygZ ]hjbahgl_[ueh ^hklZlhqgh k\_lZ
ihwlhfm hq_jlZgbydjurb [ueb_s_ \b^bfugh aZl_fg_[h klZeh
q_jgufb y _^\Zfh] \b^_lv^hfY khojZgye k\hb ]eZaZ
knhdmkbjh\Zggufb gZdjur_ qZkug_ aZf_qZykh\k_f gbq_]hY
\b^_e iZjmkh\ijhe_l_\rbo dk_\_jmjZafZo bodjuev_\ [ue
kh\_jr_ggh m^b\bl_evgufb bog_evay [uehijbgylv aZq_jguo
^jha^h\< hij_^_e_ggucfhf_glh^gZdhy hlq_leb\haZf_lbe
q_jgmx l_gv fZe_gvdhc
ilbpuk_\r_c
gZ
djurmWlh
hij_^_e_ggh ilbpZFh_ k_j^p_gZqZeh kbevgh klmqZlvy
ihqm\kl\h\Ze ]me\ fhbomrZoY ijbp_ebeky\ ilbpmb kimklbe
h[Z dmjdZJZa^Zeky hq_gv]jhfdbc \uklj_eY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
kbevgmx hl^Zqm jm`_cgh]hijbdeZ^Z \fh_ ie_qhb \lhl `_
kZfuc fhf_gl y mkeurZehq_gv ijhgabl_evguc b m`ZkZxsbc
q_eh\_q_kdbc djbdHg [ue]jhfdbc b`mldbc bdZaZehkvr_e
k djurbM f_gy[ue fhf_glihegh]h aZf_rZl_evkl\ZAZl_f y
\kihfgbeqlh ^hg OmZgmdZau\Ze fg_ aZdjbqZlv \ fhf_gl
\uklj_eZZ yaZ[ue wlhk^_eZlvY ih^mfZei_j_aZjy^blv fh_
jm`v_dh]^Z ^hg OmZghldjue ^\_jvb \u[_`ZeHg ^_j`Ze
d_jhkbgh\mx eZfimHg dZaZekyhq_gv \a\hegh\Zgguf
Y ^mfZxlu ihiZe\ g__kdZaZe hgfu ^he`gu
l_i_jv gZclbf_jl\mx ilbpm
Hg ijbg_ke_klgbpm b\_e_e fg_aZe_alv bihkfhlj_lv gZ
jZfZ^Zgh ygbq_]h g_gZr_e lZfHg \e_ab ihkfhlj_ekZfk
jZ\gh hljbpZl_evgufbj_amevlZlZfb
Fh`_l [ulvlu jZag_kilbpm gZdmkdbkdZaZe ^hg
OmZg\ lZdhfkemqZ_fu ^he`gugZclbih djZcg_c f_j_
i_jvy
KgZqZeZ fugZqZeb hkfZljb\Zlv\hdjm] jZfZ^ZZ aZl_f
\hdjm] ^hfZFu hkfZljb\Zebijb k\_l_eZfiu ^hmljZAZl_f
fu kgh\ZgZqZeb hkfZljb\Zlv\kx iehsZ^vdhlhjmx fuihdjueb
\ l_q_gb_ghqbHdheh ^hg OmZgij_djZlbe gZrbihbkdb
Hg k_em^jmq_gguc]emih\Zlh meu[gmekyfg_ bkdZaZeqlh fg_
g_ m^Zehkv ijbdhgqblv_]h \jZ]Zb qlhl_i_jv[he__q_f
dh]^Zeb[h ij_`^__]h `bagvg_ klhbeZdjbdZ kh\uihlhfm
qlh `_gsbgZ[ueZ g_khfg_gghjZa^jZ`_gZ b`Z`^ZeZ hlhfklblv
Lu \ [_ahiZkghklbh^gZdhkdZaZe ^hg OmZg
m\_j_ggh`_gsbgZ g_agZ_l l_[y
Dh]^Z y r_ed k\h_cfZrbg_qlh[u \_jgmlvky^hfhcy
kijhkbe _]h^he`_g eby mgbqlh`Zlvjm`v_Hg kdZaZeqlh
jm`v_ g_k^_eZeh gbq_]hb qlhy fh]\_jgmlv _]h\eZ^_evpmY
aZf_lbe ]em[hdh_ hlqZygb_\ ]eZaZo^hgZ OmZgZIjb wlhf y
ihqm\kl\h\Ze lZdh_\heg_gb_qlh ykh[bjZeky aZieZdZlv
Q_f yfh]m ihfhqvl_[_"kijhkbe y
Lu gbq_]hg_ fh`_rvk^_eZlvkdZaZe ^hgOmZg
Fu fheqZebg_dhlhjh_ \j_fyY ohl_em_oZlv g_f_^e_ggh
Y qm\kl\h\Ze]g_lmsmx fmdmFg_ [uehg_ ihk_[_
Ohl_e [ulu ^_ckl\bl_evghihiulZlvky ihfhqvfg_"
kijhkbe ^hgOmZg ijhklh^mrguflhghf
Y kgh\Z kdZaZe _fmqlh
y
\_kv p_ebdhf \ _]h
jZkihjy`_gbbqlh fhy ijb\yaZgghklv d g_fm [ueZ lZdhc
]em[hdhcqlh yfh] [uij_^ijbgylv ex[hc\b^ ^_ckl\byqlh[u
ihfhqv _fm
>hg OmZgmeu[gmeky b\gh\v kijhkbe^_ckl\bl_evgh eby
bf_x lZdh_ gZf_j_gb_b ykljZklgh \gh\v ih^l\_j^be k\h_
`_eZgb_ ihfhqv_fm
?keb lu^_ckl\bl_evgh gZf_j_gkdZaZe hgm f_gy
_klv _s_h^bg rZgk
HgdZaZehkv[ue m^h\e_l\hj_gHg rbjhdhmeu[gmeky b
ihoehiZe k\hbfbjmdZfb g_kdhevdhjZa wlh [uehlhqlh hg
\k_]^Z ^_eZedh]^Z ohl_e\ujZablv qm\kl\h m^h\hevkl\by
Baf_g_gb_ _]h gZkljh_gby[ueh lZdbfm^b\bl_evgufqlh hgh
lZd`_ aZo\Zlbehf_gyY \g_aZighihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh ]g_lms__
gZkljh_gb_kljZ^Zgb_[ueh ij_h^he_ghb `bagv[ueZ kgh\Z
g_h[tykgbfh ijh[m`^_gZ>hg OmZgk_eb y k^_eZe lh `_
kZfh_Hg kfhlj_egZ f_gy^he]h_ \j_fyb aZl_f ijh^he`Ze
]h\hjblv fg_ hq_gv kihdhcgh bhklhjh`ghqlh y [ue\
^_ckl\bl_evghklb_^bgkl\_gguf q_eh\_dhfdhlhjuc fh]ihfhqv
_fm \ wlhlfhf_glb ihwlhfmhg kh[bjZeky ihijhkblv f_gy
k^_eZlv g_qlhhq_gv hiZkgh_b hq_gvhkh[_ggh_
Hg ij_j\Zeky gZ fhf_gldZd
[m^lh ohl_e gh\h]h
ih^l\_j`^_gby kfh_c klhjhguy \gh\vih^l\_j^be fh_l\_j^h_
`_eZgb_ k^_eZlvqlhgb[m^v ^eyg_]h
Y kh[bjZxkv^Zlv l_[_hjm`b_qlh[u ijhgablv__
kdZaZe hg
Hg \aye ^ebggucij_^f_l bak\h_c kmfdbb \jmqbe _]h
fg_Y \aye_]h bhkfhlj_eY ihqlbhl[jhkbe _]h
Wlh dZ[Zgijh^he`Ze hgLu ^he`_gijhgablv __
wlbf
Ij_^f_ldhlhjuc y^_j`Ze[ue kmohc i_j_^g_c gh]hc
dZ[ZgZRdmjZ [ueZhllZedb\Zxs_cZ s_lbgZ [ueZ hl\jZlb
l_evghc gZhsmivDhiulh [uehp_eufb _]h^\_ iheh\bgu[ueb
jZa\_jgmludZd [m^lhgh]Z [ueZgZijy`_gZWlh [ueZ m`Zkgh
\u]ey^_\rZy \_svHgZ ihqlb
aZklZ\beZ f_gy bkiulu\Zlv
lhrghlmHg [ukljh\aye __gZaZ^
Lu ^he`_gaZ[blv dZ[ZgZijyfh \__ imihdkdZaZe
^hg OmZg
Qlh"kijhkbe ykeZ[uf ]hehkhf
Lu ^he`_g\aylv dZ[ZgZ\ k\hxe_\mx jmdmb aZdhehlv
__ bfHgZ dhe^mgvyb dZ[Zg\hc^_l _c\ `b\hlb gbdlhgZ
k\_l_aZ bkdexq_gb_f^jm]h]h fZ]Zg_ m\b^bl_]h \hldgmluf
lZfWlh g_h[uqgZy [bl\Zgh ^_ehfZ]h\Lu ^he`_gba[_`Zlv
lhc hiZkghklbqlh_keb l_[_g_ m^Zklkyijhgablv __hgZ
fh`_l [_a ijhf_^e_gby kf_jl_evgh m^Zjblv l_[ybeb __
dhfiZgvhgu beb jh^kl\_ggbdbaZklj_eyl bebaZj_`ml l_[yK
^jm]hc klhjhgulu fh`_rvmclb [_apZjZibgu
?keb l_[_ m^Zklky wlhm g__[m^_l m`Zkgh_ \j_fy k
dZ[Zghf \k\h_f l_e_b hgZhklZ\bl f_gy\ ihdh_
=g_lmsZy [hev ho\ZlbeZ f_gy kgh\ZY [ue ]em[hdh
ijb\yaZg d ^hgm OmZgmY \hkobsZekybf<h \j_fy wlhc
m`ZkZxs_c ijhkv[u y m`_gZmqbeky kfhlj_lvgZ _]h kihkh[
`bagb b gZ_]h agZgb_dZd gZ\ukr__ ^hklb`_gb_DZd fh]
dlhlh iha\heblv mf_j_lvq_eh\_dmih^h[ghfm wlhfm"B \k_
`_dZd dlheb[h fh]mfure_ggh jbkdh\Zlv_]h `bagvx"Y lZd
ih]jmabeky \k\hb jZafure_gbyqlh g_aZf_lbeqlh ^hgOmZg
\klZe bklhye hdhehf_gyihdZ hgg_ ihoehiZef_gy ihie_qm
Y ih^gye]eZaZhg [eZ]h`_eZl_evghmeu[Zeky
Dh]^Z lu ihqm\kl\m_rvqlh ^_ckl\bl_evgh ohq_rv
ihfhqv fg_lu \_jg_rvkykdZaZe hggh g_jZgvr_?keb
lu \_jg_rvkyy agZxqlh
fu
[m^_f ^_eZlvL_i_jv
hlijZ\eycky?keb lu g_aZohq_rv \_jgmlvkyy ihcfm wlh
lZd`_
Y Z\lhfZlbq_kdbih^gyekyk_e \k\hx fZrbgmb ih_oZe
>hg OmZg^_ckl\bl_evgh aZimklbe\ f_gy^Zevgbc djxqhdY fh]
m_oZlv b gbdh]^Z g_
\ha\jZsZlvkygh ihq_fmlh fukev
k\h[h^gh m_oZlvg_ mkihdZb\ZeZf_gyY _oZe^he]h_ \j_fyZ
aZl_f bfimevkb\ghih\_jgme bih_oZe gZaZ^d ^hfm^hgZ OmZgZ
Hg \k_ _s_ kb^_e ih^ k\hbf jZfZ^Z b g_ dZaZeky
m^b\e_ggufm\b^_\ f_gy
KZ^bkvkdZaZe hgGZ aZiZ^_ ij_djZkgu_ lmqb
<kdhj_ [m^_l l_fghKb^b
kihdhcgh b iha\hev kmf_jdZf
ho\Zlblv l_[yK_cqZk ^_eZc\k_qlh ohq_rvghdh]^Z y
kdZ`m l_[_ihkfhljb ijyfhgZ l_[e_klysb_ h[eZdZb ihijhkb
kmf_jdb ^Zlvl_[_ kbemb kihdhckl\b_
Y kb^_eebphf daZiZ^guf h[eZdZfiZjm qZkh\>hg OmZg
\hr_e \ ^hf b hklZekybagmljbDh]^Z klZeh l_fghhg
\_jgmeky
Kmf_jdb ijbrebkdZaZe hg<klZgvG_ aZdju\Zc
k\hb ]eZaZkfhljb ijyfhgZ h[eZdZih^gbfb k\hbjmdb b k
ih^gylufb jmdZfbb jZklhiuj_ggufbiZevpZfb [_]bgZ f_kl_
Y ihke_^h\Ze_]h bgkljmdpbyfy ih^gyejmdb gZ^]heh\hc
b gZqZe[_`Zlv>hg OmZgih^hr_e k[hdmb dhjj_dlbjh\Ze fhb
^\b`_gbyHg \eh`begh]m dZ[ZgZ\ eZ^hgvfh_c e_\hcjmdb b
\_e_e fg_ ko\Zlblv__ iZevpZfbAZl_f hghimklbe fhb jmdb
\gbaihdZ hgb g_klZeb mdZau\ZlvgZ hjZg`_\u_ b q_jgu_
fjZqgu_ lmqb gZ^]hjbahglhf gZaZiZ^_Hg jZklhiujbe fhb
iZevpu ih^h[gh \__jmb \_e_efg_ g_k]b[Zlv boWlh [ueh
j_rZxs_c
\Z`ghklvxqlh[u
y
khojZgye
k\hb
iZevpu
jZklhiuj_ggufbihlhfm qlh_keb yaZdjhx boy g_ kfh]m
ihijhkblv kmf_jdbh kbe_b kihdhckl\bbgh [m^mm]jh`Zlv bf
Hg lZd`_ dhjj_dlbjh\Zefhc [_]Hg kdZaZeqlh hg ^he`_g
[ulv kihdhcgufb h^ghh[jZagufdZd [m^lh[u y^_ckl\bl_evgh
[_`Ze dkmf_jdZf kijhlygmlufb jmdZfb
Y g_ fh] aZkgmlv\ l_q_gb_wlhc ghqbG_kfhljy gZ
mkihdZb\Zgb_ f_gykmf_jdbdZd [m^lh\ha[m^beb \h fg_
[_r_gkl\h
M f_gy lZdfgh]h _s_g_aZdhgq_gguo \_s_c \ fh_c
`bagbkdZaZe yLZd fgh]hg_jZaj_r_gguo \_s_c
>hg OmZgobobdgme fy]dh
Gbqlh \fbj_ g_aZdhgq_ghkdZaZe hggbqlh g_
dhgq_ghh^gZdh gbqlhg_ y\ey_lkyg_jZaj_r_ggufB^b kiZlv
Keh\Z ^hgZOmZgZ [uebmkihdZb\Zxsbfb
Hdheh ^_kylbqZkh\ gZke_^mxs__ mljh^hg OmZg^Ze fg_
qlhlh ih_klvb aZl_ffu hlijZ\bebkv\ imlvHg ijhr_ilZe
qlh fu ^he`guih^hclb d`_gsbg_ hdhehihem^gybeb i_j_^
ihem^g_f_keb \hafh`ghHg kdZaZeqlh b^_Zevguf \j_f_g_f
[ueb jZggb_qZku ^gyihlhfm qlh\_^vfZ \k_]^Zbf__l f_gvr_
kbeu bf_gvr_ agZ_lmljhfgh hgZ\k_]^Z hojZgy_lk\hc ^hf\
wlb qZkuY g_aZ^Z\Ze gbdZdbo\hijhkh\Hg gZijZ\bef_gy d
rhkk_b \ hij_^_e_gghff_kl_ hg\_e_e fg_ hklZgh\blv b
ihklZ\blv fZrbgmk[hdm hl^hjh]bHg kdZaZeqlh fu ^he`gu
`^Zlv a^_kv
Y ihkfhlj_egZ k\hbqZku [ueh iylvfbgml h^bggZ^pZ
lh]hY g_ij_ju\gha_\ZeY [ue\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb khgguc
fhc mf[_kp_evgh [em`^Ze
<g_aZigh ^hgOmZg \uijyfbekyb lhedgmef_gyY \kdhqbe
gZ k\h_fkb^_gvb
HgZ a^_kvkdZaZe hg
Y m\b^_e `_gsbgmb^msmx drhkk_ ihdjZx \kiZoZggh]h
iheyHgZ g_keZdhjabgmaZdj_ie_ggmx i_le_c\ k\h_cijZ\hc
jmd_>h wlh]h\j_f_gb yg_ aZf_qZeqlh fu hklZgh\bebkv
ih[ebahklb hl i_j_dj_kldZ>\_ madb_ ljhibgdb ijhoh^beb
iZjZee_evgh h[_bf klhjhgZfrhkk_hq_\b^ghex^bdhlhju_
bkihevah\Zeb wlm ljhim^he`gu [ueb i_j_k_dZlv fhs_gmx
^hjh]m
Dh]^Z `_gsbgZ [ueZ_s_ gZ]jmglh\hc ^hjh]_^hg OmZg
\_e_e fg_\uclb bafZrbgu
L_i_jv ^_eZcwlhkdZaZe hgl\_j^h
Y ih\bgh\Zeky _fm@_gsbgZ [ueZihqlb gZ rhkk_Y
ih[_`Ze b ^h]gZe __Y [uelZd [ebadh d g_cqlh y
qm\kl\h\Ze __h^_`^m gZk\h_f ebp_Y \ugmedZ[Zgv_ dhiulh
baih^ k\h_c jm[Zrdb bihjZabe __bfY g_ ihqm\kl\h\Ze
gbdZdh]h khijhlb\e_gbyd lmihfmij_^f_lmdhlhjuc y^_j`Ze \
k\h_c jmd_Y \b^_e[ukljh f_evdgm\rmxl_gv i_j_^ kh[hc
ih^h[gh ihjlv_j_fhy ]heh\Zih\_jgmeZkv gZijZ\hb ym\b^_e
`_gsbgmklhy\rmx \iylb^_kylb nmlZohl f_gygZ ijhlb\hih
eh`ghc klhjhg_^hjh]bHgZ [ueZdjZkb\hcfheh^hc bl_fghc
k kbevguf ijba_fbklufl_ehfHgZ meu[gmeZkvfg_?_ am[u
[ueb [_eufb b djmigufbZ __meu[dZ [ueZ kihdhcghcHgZ
ihemaZdjueZ k\hb]eZaZdZd [m^lhqlh[u ij_^hojZgblvbo hl
\_ljZHgZ \k__s_ ^_j`ZeZk\hx dhjabgmaZdj_ie_ggmx i_le_c
gZ k\h_cijZ\hc jmd_
Lh]^Z mf_gy gZklmibefhf_gl ihegh]haZf_rZl_evkl\ZY
h[_jgmeky b ihkfhlj_e gZ^hgZ OmZgZHg ^_eZe g_bklh\u_
`_kluqlh[u iha\Zlvf_gy gZaZ^Y ih[_`ZeLjh_ bebq_l\_jh
fm`qbg \lhjhiyoijb[ebabebkv dhfg_Y \kdhqbe\ k\hxfZrbgm
b ^Zekdhjhklv \ijhlb\hiheh`ghf gZijZ\e_gbb
Y iulZekykijhkblv ^hgZOmZgZ hlhfqlh kemqbehkvgh
y g_ fh] ]h\hjblvfhb
mrb ehiZebkv hl ihljykZxs_]h
gZijy`_gbyy qm\kl\h\Zeqlh aZ^uoZekyHgdZaZehkv[ue
m^h\e_l\hj_g b gZqZe kf_ylvkyFhy g_m^ZqZdZd [m^lh g_
[_kihdhbeZ _]hFhb jmdbgZ jme_\hf dhe_k_ [ueb lZdbfb
ly`_eufbqlh yg_ fh]^\bgmlv bfbhgb [uebaZklu\rbfbfhb
jmdb [uebg_]gmsbfbky blZdbfb `_[ueb fhbgh]bNZdlbq_kdb
y g_fh] hlhj\Zlvk\hx gh]mhl i_^Zeb]ZaZ
>hg OmZg ihoehiZe
f_gy
ih
kibg_
b k_e_e fg_
jZkkeZ[blvkyFZehihfZem ^Z\e_gb_\ fhbomrZo hkeZ[eh
Qlh kemqbehk[lZf"gZdhg_p kijhkbey
Hg aZohohlZedZd j_[_ghdg_ hl\_qZyAZl_f hgkijhkbe
f_gyg_ aZf_lbeeb ykihkh[dhlhjuf `_gsbgZ i_j_fZogmeZ
^hjh]mHg \hkobsZeky__ ij_\hkoh^ghckdhjhklvxJZa]h\hj
^hgZ OmZgZ dZaZeky lZdbf g_mf_klgufqlh y g_ fh] \
^_ckl\bl_evghklb ke_^h\Zlv_fmHg \hkobsZeky`_gsbghcHg
kdZaZeqlh __ kbeZ [ueZ [_amij_qghc b qlh hgZ [ueZ
[_a`Zehklguf \jZ]hf
Y kijhkbe ^hgZOmZgZihfgbe ebhg hfh_c g_m^Zq_Y
[ue bkdj_gg_
m^b\e_g
b
jZa^hkZ^h\Zg
i_j_f_ghc
_]h
gZkljh_gbyHgdZaZehkv[ue ^_ckl\bl_evghjZ^
Hg \_e_e fg_hklZgh\blvkyY hklZgh\beky gZ h[hqbg_
^hjh]bHg iheh`bek\hx jmdmgZ fh_ie_qh b ijhgbpZl_evgh
ihkfhlj_e \fhb ]eZaZ
<k_qlh y^_eZe k_]h^gyk lh[hc[ueh obljhklvx
kdZaZe hg ijyfhKms_kl\m_l ijZ\behqlh q_eh\_d agZgby
^he`_g h[fZgu\Zlvk\h_]h mq_gbdZK_]h^gy yh[fZgme l_[y b
h[fZghf aZklZ\bemqblvky
Y [uehr_ehfe_gY g_fh] kh[jZlvk\hb fukeb>hg OmZg
h[tykgbeqlh \k_aZljm^gbl_evgh_ iheh`_gb_k `_gsbghc[ueh
obljhklvxqlh hgZgbdh]^Z g_[ueZ m]jhahc_fmb qlh _]h
aZ^Zq_c [ueh\\_klb f_gy\ bkiulZgb_k g_cijb ki_pbnbq_kdbo
mkeh\byo g_ijbgm`^_gghklbb kbeudhlhju_ yi_j_`b\Zedh]^Z
iulZeky ijhgablv__Hg iho\Zebefhx j_rbfhklvb gZa\Ze __
Zdlhf kbeudhlhjuc ijh^_fhgkljbjh\Ze`_gsbg_qlh y [ue
kihkh[_g gZ[hevrh_ mkbeb_>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh^Z`_ ohly
y b g_ khagZ\Ze wlh]h\k_qlh y ^_eZe^he`gh [ueh
ihdZaZlv f_gy\ \u]h^ghfk\_l_ i_j_^g_c
Lu gbdh]^Zg_ fh]dhkgmlvky __kdZaZe hggh lu
ihdZaZe _ck\hb dh]lbL_i_jv hgZagZ_lqlh lug_ [hbrvky
Lu [jhkbe \uah\ _cY bkihevah\Ze__qlh[u i_j_obljblv
l_[yihlhfm qlh hgZkbevgZ b[_a`ZehklgZ b gbdh]^Z g_
aZ[u\Z_lEx^b
h[uqgh
kebrdhf
aZgyluqlh[u
[ulv
[_a`Zehklgufb \jZ]Zfb
Y ihqm\kl\h\Zem`Zkguc ]g_\Y kdZaZe_fmqlh gbdlhg_
^he`_g b]jZlvk ]em[hdbfbqm\kl\Zfb bij_^Zgghklvx ^jm]bo
>hg OmZgkf_yeky ^hl_o ihjihdZ ke_aug_ ihdZlbebkvm
g_]h ihs_dZfZ yg_gZ\b^_e _]hY [uei_j_iheg_g `_eZgb_f
m^Zjblv _]h b m_oZlvh^gZdh\ _]h kf_o_ [ue lZdhc
g_h[uqguc jblfqlh hgihqlb iZjZebah\Zef_gy
G_ gZ^h[ulv lZdbfk_j^blufkdZaZe hgmkihdZb\Zx
s_
AZl_f ^hgOmZg kdZaZeqlh _]h^_ckl\by gbdh]^Zg_ [ueb
nZjkhfqlh hg lZd`_hl[jZku\Ze k\hx`bagv ^he]h_ \j_fy
ij_`^_dh]^Z _]h kh[kl\_gguc[_g_nZdlhj h[fZgu\Ze _]h
lhqgh lZd`_dZd hgh[fZgme f_gy>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh _]h
[_g_nZdlhj [ue [_a`Zehklgufq_eh\_dhfdhlhjuc g_^mfZe h
g_f lZdbf`_ h[jZahfdZd hg^hg OmZg^mfZ_l h[hfg_Hg
^h[Z\be hq_gv kmjh\hqlh `_gsbgZ bkiulu\ZeZ k\hx kbem
ijhlb\ g_]hb ^_ckl\bl_evghiulZeZkv m[blv_]h
L_i_jv hgZagZ_lqlh yb]jZe kg_ckdZaZe hg
kf_ykvb hgZ\hag_gZ\b^bl l_ [y
aZwlhHgZ gbq_]h
g_ fh`_l k^_eZlvfg_gh hgZ\uf_klbl wlhgZ l_[_HgZ g_
agZ_l _s_kdhevdh ml_[y kbeuihwlhfm hgZ[m^_l ijboh^blv
bkiulu\Zlv l_[yfZehihfZemL_i_jv ml_[y g_l\u[hjZb lu
^he`_g mqblvkyqlh[u aZsblblvk_[ybeb lu k^_eZ_rvky
`_jl\hc wlhce_^bHgZ g_rmlbl
>hg OmZggZihfgbe fg_kihkh[dhlhjuf hgZi_j_e_l_eZ
G_ gZ^h k_j^blvkykdZaZe hgwlh g_ h[uqgZy
obljhklvWlh ijZ\beh
< kihkh[_dhlhjuf `_gsbgZhliju]gmeZ hl f_gy[ueh
qlhlhihbklbg_ k\h^ys__k mfZY [uekZf wlhfmk\b^_l_e_f
hgZ i_j_iju]gmeZ rbjbgmrhkk_ \f]gh\_gb_ hdZY g_ bf_e
kihkh[Z ba[_`Zlv wlhc g_khfg_gghklbK wlh]h fhf_glZ y
kdhgp_gljbjh\Ze \k_ fh_
\gbfZgb_
gZ
wlhf kemqZ_ b
fZehihfZemgZdhibe ^hdZaZl_evkl\Zqlh hgZ^_ckl\bl_evgh
ij_ke_^h\ZeZ f_gyHdhgqZl_evguc j_amevlZl[ue lhlqlh y
^he`_g [ue hldZaZlvkyhl mq_gbq_kl\Zih^ ^Z\e_gb_f fh_]h
bjjZpbhgZevgh]h kljZoZ
Y \_jgmeky d^hfm ^hgZOmZgZ g_kdhevdhqZkh\ kimkly
jZgh ihke_ihem^gyHghq_\b^ghh`b^Ze f_gyHg ih^hr_edh
fg_dh]^Z y \ur_e bafh_c fZrbgub hkfhlj_e f_gy k
ex[hiulkl\hf \]eZaZoh[hc^y \hdjm]f_gy iZjmjZa
Ihq_fm \a\hegh\Zgghklv"kijhkbe hgij_`^_ q_f y
bf_e \j_fykdZaZlv qlhgb[m^v
Y h[tykgbeqlh qlhlh bkim]Zehf_gy wlbfmljhf bqlh y
gZqZe qm\kl\h\Zlv qlhlh djZ^ms__ky\hdjm] f_gydZd \
ijhrehf>hg OmZgk_e bdZaZehkv[ue ih]ehs_gfukeyfb?]h
ebph bf_ehg_h[uqgh k_jv_agh_\ujZ`_gb_HgdZaZehkv[ue
mklZ\rbfY k_ehdheh g_]hb ijb\h^be\ ihjy^hdk\hb aZibkb
Ihke_ hq_gv ^he]hciZmau _]hebph ijhykgbehkvb hg
meu[gmeky
Lhqlh luqm\kl\h\Ze wlbfmljhf[ue ^mo \h^yghc
^ujukdZaZe hgY
kdZ`m l_[_qlh lu ^he`_g
ih^]hlh\blvky ^ey g_h`b^Zgghc \klj_qbk wlbfb kbeZfbY
^mfZxlu ihgye
>Z
Lh]^Z ihq_fmkljZo"
Y g_fh] hl\_lblv
Wlhl ^mo gZ l\h_cljhi_kdZaZe hghg m`_
ihoehiZe l_[y \\h^_Y m\_jyxl_[yqlh hgihklmqbl l_[_
kgh\Zb\_jhylghlu g_[m^_rv ih^]hlh\e_gb wlZ\klj_qZ
[m^_l l\hbfdhgphf
Keh\Z ^hgZOmZgZ aZklZ\bebf_gy ihqm\kl\h\Zlvbkdj_gg__
[_kihdhckl\hH^gZdhfhb qm\kl\Z[ueb g_h[uqgufby [ue
h[_kihdh_ggh g_[hyekyQlh [ugb kemqbehkvkh fghcwlh
g_ fh]eh\ua\Zlv \hfg_ klZjuoqm\kl\ ke_ih]hkljZoZ
Qlh y^he`_g ^_eZlv"kijhkbe y
Lu kebrdhf e_]dhaZ[u\Z_rvkdZaZe hgljhiZ
agZgby wlh ljhiZkbeu>ey lh]hqlh[u mqblvkyfu ^he`gu
ki_rblvGZ ljhi_ agZgby fu \k_]^Z [hj_fky k q_flh
ba[_]Z_f q_]hlh]hlh\bfky dq_fmlhb wlhqlhlh \k_]^Z
y\ey_lky g_h[tykgbfuf\_ebdbf[he__ kbevgufq_f fu
G_h[tykgbfu_ kbeu [m^mlijboh^blv dl_[_L_i_jv wlh ^mo
\h^ghc ^ujuiha^g__ wlh [m^_l l\hc kh[kl\_gguc heeb
ihwlhfm lu gbq_]h g_ fh`_rv ^_eZlv l_i_jvdjhf_ dZd
]hlh\blvky d [hjv[_Fgh]h e_lgZaZ^ eZDZlZebgZ lhjhibeZ
l_[yhgZ [ueZlhevdh dhe^mgv_ch^gZdhb wlh[ueZ obljhklv
^ey gh\bqdZ
Fbj ^_ckl\bl_evgh ihehg im]Zxsbo
\_s_cb fu [_kihfhsgu_ kha^Zgbyhdjm`_ggu_ kbeZfbdhlhju_ g_h[tykgbfu
b g_ij_dehgguH[uqguc q_eh\_d\ g_agZgbb\_jblqlh wlb
kbeu fh]ml [ulv h[tykg_gubeb baf_g_guhg \ ^_ckl\bl_
evghklb g_ agZ_ldZd wlhk^_eZlvgh hg h`b^Z_lqlh
^_ckl\by q_eh\_q_kl\Zh[tykgyl bobeb baf_gylbo jZgvr_beb
iha`_FZ]k ^jm]hcklhjhgug_ ^mfZ_lh[ h[tykg_gbbbeb h[
baf_g_gbb bo\f_klh wlh]hhg mqblky bkihevah\Zlv lZdb_
kbeui_j_gZijZ\eyy k_[y kZfh]hb ijbkihkZ[eb\Zykv d bo
gZijZ\e_gbxWlh _]hobljhklvHq_gv fZehhklZ_lky hlfZ]bb
_keb lumagZe __obljhklvFZ] lhevdhg_fgh]h emqr_\u^_e_g
q_f h[uqguc q_eh\_dFZ]by g_ihfh]Z_l _fm `blv emqr_c
`bagvx\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklby [ukdZaZe qlh fZ]by f_rZ_l
_fmhgZ ^_eZ_l_]h `bagvkeh`ghchiZkghcHldju\Zy k_[y
agZgbxfZ] klZgh\blky[he__ mya\bfufq_f h[uqgucq_eh\_d
K h^ghcklhjhguhdjm`Zxsb_ _]hex^b g_gZ\b^ylb [hylky_]h
b [m^ml klZjZlvky dhgqblv_]h `bagvk ^jm]hc klhjhgu
g_h[tykgbfu_ bg_ij_dehggu_ kbeudhlhju_ hdjm`Zxl dZ`^h]h
ba gZkih ijZ\mlh]hqlh fu`b\_fy\eyxlky ^ey fZ]Z
bklhqgbdhf _s_[hevr_c hiZkghklb;ulv ijhga_ggufkh[jZlhf ^_ckl\bl_evgh [hevghgh wlhgbqlh ihkjZ\g_gbx kl_fqlh[u
[ulv ljhgmluf heebFZ]hldju\Zy k_[y agZgbxiZ^Z_l
`_jl\hc lZdbo kbe bbf__l lhevdh _^bgkl\_ggh_ kj_^kl\h
mjZ\gh\_kblv k_[y k\hx \hexlZdbf h[jZahfhg ^he`_g
qm\kl\h\Zlv b^_ckl\h\ZlvdZd \hbgY ih\lhjxwlh _s_jZa
lhevdh dZd \hbg fh`gh \u`blvgZ imlb agZgbyLhqlh
ihfh]Z_l fZ]m`blv emqr_c`bagvxwlh kbeZ`bagb \hbgZ
Wlh fh_ h[yaZl_evkl\h gZmqblv l_[y \b^_lvG_
ihlhfmqlh yebqgh ohqmk^_eZlv lZdgh ihlhfmqlh lu[ue
\u[jZglu [ue mdZaZgfg_ f_kdZeblhH^gZdhfh_ ebqgh_
`_eZgb_ aZklZ\ey_l
f_gy
gZmqblv
l_[y
qm\kl\h\Zlv b
^_ckl\h\ZlvdZd \hbgEbqgh y\_jxqlh [ulv\hbghf [he__
ih^oh^ys__q_f qlheb[h _s_Ihwlhfm yklZjZeky ihdZaZlv
l_[_ wlb kbeudZd fZ]\hkijbgbfZ_l boihlhfm qlh lhevdh
ih^ bo mkljZrZxsbf
\ha^_ckl\b_f
fh`gh
klZlv \hbghf
<b^_lvij_`^_ q_f[ulv \hbghfwlh k^_eZ_ll_[y keZ[uf
wlh ^Zkll_[_ eh`gmxkeZ[hklv`_eZgb_ hlklmiblvl\h_ l_eh
[m^_l jZajmrZlvkyihlhfm qlhlu klZg_rv[_ajZaebqgufWlh
fh_ ebqgh_gZf_j_gb_ k^_eZlv l_[y\hbghflZdbf h[jZahflu
g_ kehfZ_rvky
Y keurZeqlh lu]h\hjbe m`_fgh]h jZaqlh lu \k_]^Z
]hlh\ mf_j_lvY
g_
jZkkfZljb\Zx
wlh
qm\kl\hdZd
g_h[oh^bfh_Y
^mfZxqlh
hgh
y\ey_lky [_kihe_aguf
ihlZdZgb_f k_[_<hbg ^he`_g[ulv ]hlh\lhevdh d[bl\_Y
keurZe lZd`_qlh lu ]h\hjbeh lhfqlh l\hb jh^bl_eb
ihjZgbeb l\hc ^moY ^mfZxqlh ^mo q_eh\_dZ y\ey_lky
q_flhqlh fh`_l [ulv
e_]dh
jZg_ghohly g_ l_fb
kj_^kl\Zfbdhlhju_ lukZf gZau\Z_rvjZgysbfbY iheZ]Zx
qlh l\hb jh^bl_eb bkdZe_qbebl_[y l_fqlh k^_eZeb l_[y
ihlZdZxsbf k_[_fy]dbf bij_^Zxsbfky ijhay[Zgbx
>mo \hbgZg_ k\yau\Z_lkygb ihlZdZgb_fk_[_ b`Zeh[Zfb
g_ k\yau\Z_lky hg ih[_^Zfb beb ihjZ`_gbyfb>mo \hbgZ
k\yau\Z_lky lhevdh k [hjv[hcb
dZ`^h_ mkbeb_ wlh
ihke_^gyy [bl\Z \hbgZgZ a_fe_LZdbf h[jZahfj_amevlZl
bf__l hq_gvfZeh agZq_gby^ey g_]h< k\h_cihke_^g_c [bl\_
gZ a_fe_\hbg iha\hey_lk\h_fm ^moml_qv k\h[h^ghb ykghB
dh]^Z hgijh\h^bl k\hx[bl\magZyqlh _]h\hey [_amij_qgZ
\hbg kf__lkyb kf__lky
Y dhgqbe ibkZlvb ih^gye]eZaZ>hg OmZg ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_e gZf_gyHg ihdZqZe]heh\hc baklhjhgu \klhjhgm b
meu[gmeky
Lu ^_ckl\bl_evgh \k_aZibku\Z_rv"kijhkbe hg k
g_^h\_jb_fO_gZjh ]h\hjbeqlh hggbdh]^Z g_fh`_l [ulv
k_jv_aguf klh[hcihlhfm qlhlu \k_]^Zibr_rvHg ijZ\dZd
fh`_l dlhgb[m^v [ulvk_jv_aguf_keb lu\k_]^Z ibr_rv"
Hg mkf_ogmekyb yihiulZeky hlklhylvk\hx ihabpbx
Wlh g_ bf__l agZq_gbykdZaZe hg?keb lu
dh]^Zeb[h gZmqbrvky
\b ^_ lv lhy iheZ]Zxlu
^he`_g ^_eZlvwlh l\hbfkh[kl\_gguf iml_fkm^v[u
Hg \klZe bihkfhlj_e gZg_[h;ueh hdhehihem^gyHg
kdZaZeqlh _s_[ueh \j_fyih_oZlv ihhohlblvky\ ]hjZo
GZ dh]hfu kh[bjZ_fkyhohlblvky"kijhkbe y
GZ hkh[h_`b\hlgh_beb gZhe_gybeb gZdZ[ZgZbeb
^Z`_ gZ]hjgh]h ev\Z
Hg hklZgh\beky gZfhf_glZ aZl_f^h[Z\be^Z`_ gZ
hjeZ
Y \klZeb ihke_^h\ZeaZ gbfd fh_cfZrbg_Hg kdZaZe
qlh gZwlhl jZafu kh[bjZebkvlhevdh gZ[ex^Zlvb magZlvgZ
dZdbo `b\hlguofu ^he`guhohlblvkyHg kh[bjZekyk_klv \fhx
fZrbgmdh]^ZdZaZehkv\kihfgbe qlhlhHg meu[gmeky b
kdZaZeqlh iml_r_kl\b_ ^he`gh[ulv hleh`_ghihdZ y g_
magZx g_qlh[_a q_]hgZrZ hohlZ[m^_l g_\hafh`gZ
Fu \_jgmebkv b k_ebkgh\Z ih^_]h jZfZ^ZY ohl_e
fgh]h_ kijhkblvgh hgg_ ^Zefg_ \j_fygbq_]h kdZaZlv b
aZ]h\hjbe kgh\Z
Wlh ijb\h^blgZk dihke_^g_fm fhf_glmdhlhjuc lu
^he`_g agZlvh \hbg_kdZaZe hg<hbg hl[bjZ_lhl^_evgu_
ij_^f_ludhlhju_ kha^Zxl_]h fbj
< lhl ^_gvdh]^Z lu\klj_lbeky k heebb y [ue
\ugm`^_g ^\Z`^uihehkdZlv l_[y\ \h^_lu agZ_rvqlh [uehk
lh[hc g_lZd"
G_l
Lu ihl_jyek\hb sblu
DZdb_ sblu"H q_flu ]h\hjbrv"
Y kdZaZeqlh \hbghl[bjZ_l \_sbdhlhju_ kha^Zxl_]h
fbjHg hl[bjZ_lgZf_j_gghlZd dZddZ`^Zy \_svdhlhjmx hg
\u[bjZ_ly\ey_lky sblhfdhlhjuc aZsbsZ_l_]h hlgZiZ^_gbc
kbedhlhju_
hg
klj_fblky
bkihevah\Zlv<hbg [m^_l
bkihevah\Zlv k\hbsbluqlh[u aZsblblvkyhl heebgZijbf_j
H[uqguc q_eh\_ddhlhjuc \jZ\ghc f_j_hdjm`_g wlbfb
g_h[tykgbfufb kbeZfbg_^hklmi_g ^eygboihlhfm qlh hg
bf__l ^jm]b_\b^u hkh[uosblh\ ^eyaZsblu k_[y
Hg k^_eZe iZmam b ihkfhlj_egZ f_gy k \hijhkhf \
]eZaZoY g_ihgbfZeqlh hgbf__l \\b^m
Qlh wlhaZ sblu"gZklZb\Ze y
Lhqlh ^_eZxlex^bih\lhjbe hg
Qlh `_hgb ^_eZxl"
Ohjhrhihkfhljb \hdjm]Ex^b aZgylu^_eZgv_f lh]h
qlh ^_eZxl ex^bWlh b_klv bosbluDh]^Z [ufZ] gb bf_e
klhedgh\_gby k ex[ufbba wlbog_h[tykgbfuo b g_ij_dehgguo
kbeh dhlhjuofu ]h\hjbf_]h ijhk\_lhldju\Z_lky^_eZy
_]h [he__^hklmiguf kf_jlbq_f h[uqghy ]h\hjbel_[_qlh
fu mfbjZ_fq_j_a lhlijhk\_lihwlhfm_keb hghldju\Z_lky
g_h[oh^bfh bf_lvk\hx \hex]hlh\hc aZihegblv_]hwlh \lhf
kemqZ__keb q_eh\_d \hbg?keb q_eh\_d g_ y\ey_lky
\hbghfdZd lulh]^Z mg_]h g_lbgh]h imlb hlklmie_gby
djhf_ dZd\hkihevah\Zlvky ^_yl_evghklvxih\k_^g_\ghc `bagb
qlh[u m^Zeblvba k\h_]hmfZ kljZo\klj_qb blZdbf h[jZahf
iha\heblv k\h_fmijhk\_lm aZdjulvkyLu jZkk_j^bekygZ f_gy
\ lhl^_gvdh]^Z \klj_lbekyk heebY jZkk_j^bel_[ydh]^Z
hklZgh\be l\hx fZrbgmb yhklm^be l_[ydh]^Z y himkdZe
l_[y \ \h^mLhqlh lu[ue \fhdjhc h^_`^__s_ [he__
hklm^beh l_[yLhqlh lu[ue k_j^blb aZf_jaiha\hebeh
l\h_fm ijhk\_lm aZdjulvkyb lu[ue aZsbs_g< wlh \j_fy
l\h_c `bagbh^gZdhlu g_fh`_rv [hevr_bkihevah\Zlv wlb
sblu klhev `_wnn_dlb\ghdZd h[uqgucq_eh\_dLu kebrdhf
fgh]h agZ_rvh[ wlbokbeZob l_i_jvgZdhg_plu gZ ]jZgb
lh]hqlh[u qm\kl\h\Zlvb ^_ckl\h\ZlvdZd \hbgL\hb klZju_
gblb g_y\eyxlky [hevr_gZ^_`gufb
Qlh `_hl f_gyh`b^Z_lky"
>_ckl\mcdZd \hbgb hl[bjZcqZklbpu k\h_]hfbjZLu
g_ fh`_rv[hevr_ hdjm`Zlvk_[y \_sZfbdZd ihiZehY ]h\hjx
l_[_ wlh kZfufk_jv_aguf h[jZahfL_i_jv lu\i_j\u_ g_ \
[_ahiZkghklb ijbl\h_f klZjhfh[jZa_ `bagb
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m ih^hl[hjhf qZklbpfh_]h fbjZ"
<hbg \klj_qZ_lwlb g_h[tykgbfu_b g_ij_dehggu_kbeu
ihlhfm qlhhg gZf_j_gghbs_l boihwlhfm hg\k_]^Z ]hlh\ d
\klj_q_LugZijhlb\gbdh]^Z g_]hlh\ dg_cNZdlbq_kdb
_keb wlb kbeuy\ylky dl_[_hgb aZo\Zlyl l_[y \jZkieho
bkim] hldjh_l l\hcijhk\_lb l\hy`bagv [_kij_iylkl\_ggh
mkdhevag_l kd\hav g_]hI_j\hc \_svxdhlhjmx luaZl_f
^he`_g ^_eZlvwlh
[ulv
]hlh\uf>mfZcqlh heeb
kh[bjZ_lky \ukdhqblvi_j_^ l\hbfb]eZaZfb \ex[mx fbgmlm b
lu ^he`_g [ulv ]hlh\ dwlhfm<klj_qZ kheeb wlh g_
\_q_jbgdZ gZ \hkdj_kghf ibdgbd_b \hbg [_j_l gZ k_[y
hl\_lkl\_gghklv ih aZsbl_
k\h_c
`bagbIhwlhfm_keb
dZdZyeb[h ba wlbo kbeklmqblky dl_[_ b hldju\Z_l l\hc
ijhk\_llu ^he`_ggZf_j_ggh [hjhlvkyaZ lhqlh[u aZdjulv
_]h kZfhfm>ey wlhcp_eb lu^he`_g bf_lv ba[jZgguc jy^
\_s_cdhlhju_ ^Zxll_[_ [hevrh_kihdhckl\b_ bm^h\hevkl\b_
\_s_cdhlhju_ lufh`_rv gZf_j_gghbkihevah\Zlv ^ey lh]h
qlh[u m[jZlvk\hb fukebhl bkim]Zb aZdjulvk\hc ijhk\_l b
k^_eZlv k_[yp_evguf
Qlh wlhaZ \_sb"
G_kdhevdh e_l gZaZ^y ]h\hjbel_[_qlh \ k\h_c
ih\k_^g_\ghc `bagb \hbg \u[bjZ_lk_[_ ^hjh]m k k_j^p_f
Bf_ggh ihke_^h\Zl_evguc \u[hjimlb kk_j^p_f ^_eZ_l \hbgZ
hlebqguf hl kj_^g_]h q_eh\_dZHg agZ_lqlh imlv bf__l
k_j^p_dh]^Z hg _^bgk wlbfiml_fdh]^Z hg i_j_`b\Z_l
h]jhfgh_ kihdhckl\b_ b m^h\hevkl\b_b^y ih g_fm<_sb
dhlhju_ \hbg hl[bjZ_lqlh[u k^_eZlvk\hb sbluwlh
qZklbpu imlbk k_j^p_f
Gh lukdZaZeqlh yg_ \hbgihwlhfmdZd `_y fh]m
\u[jZlv imlvk k_j^p_f"
Wlh l\hyih\hjhlgZy lhqdZFh`gh kdZaZlvqlh jZgvr_
l_[_ g_ [ueh^_ckl\bl_evghc g_h[oh^bfhklb`blvdZd \hbg
L_i_jv bgZq_l_i_jv lu^he`_g hdjm`blvk_[y ij_^f_lZfbimlb
k k_j^p_f b ^he`_ghldZaZlvky hlhklZevgh]hbeb `_ lu
ih]b[g_rv ijb ke_^mxs_c\klj_q_Y fh]m^h[Z\blvqlh lu
fh`_rv g_ijhkblv h\klj_q_ [hevr_L_i_jv heebfh`_l ijbclb
d l_[_\h kg_\h \j_fyl\h_]h jZa]h\hjZk ^jmavyfbdh]^Z
lu ibr_rv
Y m`_ ]h^Zfbbkdj_gg_ klZjZeky`blv \ kh]eZkbb k
l\hbfb ihmq_gbyfbkdZaZe yHq_\b^ghy g_^_eZe wlh]h
^hklZlhqgh ohjhrhDZd yfh]m ^_eZlvemqr_ l_i_jv"
Lu ^mfZ_rvb jZa]h\Zjb\Z_rvkebrdhf fgh]hLu ^he`_g
ij_djZlblv jZa]h\hjk kZfbfkh[hc
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m"
Lu kebrdhffgh]h jZa]h\Zjb\Z_rvk kh[hcLu \wlhf g_
bkdexq_gb_DZ`^uc bagZk ^_eZ_lwlhFu \_^_f \gmlj_ggbc
jZa]h\hjIh^mfZc h[wlhfDh]^Z luh^bgqlh lu^_eZ_rv"
Y jZa]h\Zjb\Zxk kZfbfkh[hc
H q_flu jZa]h\Zjb\Z_rvk kh[hc"
Y g_agZxh q_fm]h^ghy iheZ]Zx
Y kdZ`ml_[_h q_ffu jZa]h\Zjb\Z_fkZfb kkh[hcFu
jZa]h\Zjb\Z_f hgZr_f fbj_NZdlbq_kdbfu kha^Z_fgZr fbj
k\hbf \gmlj_ggbfjZa]h\hjhf
DZd fuwlh ^_eZ_f"
Dh]^Z fujZa]h\Zjb\Z_f kkh[hcfbj \k_]^Z lZdhc
dZdbf hg ^he`_g [ulvFu h[gh\ey_f_]hfu gZqbgy_f _]h
`bagvxfu ih^^_j`b\Z_f_]h k\hbf\gmlj_ggb jZa]h\hjhfG_
lhevdh wlhgh fulZd`_ \u[bjZ_fk\hb imlblZd `_dZd fu
]h\hjbf k_[_LZdfb h[jZahffu ih\lhjy_flhl `_kZfuc \u[hj
_s_ b _s_ ^h l_oihjihdZ g_ mfbjZ_fihlhfm qlh fu
ijh^he`Z_f ih\lhj_gb_lh]h `_kZfh]h \gmlj_gg_]h jZa]h\hjZ
_s_ b_s_ ^hl_o ihjihdZ g_mfbjZ_f
<hbg khagZ_lwlh bklj_fblky hklZgh\blvwlhl jZa]h\hj
Wlh ihke_^gyylhqdZdhlhjmx lu^he`_g agZlv_keb luohq_rv
`blvdZd \hbg
DZd yfh]m i_j_klZlv]h\hjblv kkZfbf kh[hc"
Ij_`^_ \k_]hlu ^he`_gbkihevah\Zlv k\hbmrbqlh[u
kgylv qZklv gZ]jmadbkh k\hbo]eZaFu k kZfh]h jh`^_gby
bkihevah\Zeb k\hb ]eZaZ^ey lh]hqlh[u km^blvh fbj_Fu
]h\hjbf k^jm]bfb bk kh[hc]eZ\guf h[jZahfh lhfqlh fu
\b^bf<hbg khagZ_l wlh b
ijbkemrb\Z_lky d fbjmhg
ijbkemrb\Z_lky da\mdZf fbjZ
Y hleh`bek\hb aZibkb>hg OmZgaZkf_yeky bkdZaZeqlh
hg g_bf_e \\b^m gZ\yaZlvfg_ j_amevlZlqlh ijbkemrb\Zgb_
d a\mdZffbjZ ^he`gh[ulv ]Zjfhgbqgufb k[hevrbf l_ji_gb_f
<hbg khagZ_lqlh fbjbaf_gblkydZd lhevdh hg
i_j_klZg_l ]h\hjblv k kZfbfkh[hckdZaZe hgb hg
^he`_g [ulv]hlh\ dwlhfm g_h[uqZcghfmlheqdm
Qlh lubf__rv \\b^m^hg OmZg"
Fbj lZdhclh beblZdhclh lhevdh ihlhfmqlh fu
kdZaZeb k_[_qlh hglZdhc?keb fu i_j_klZg_f ]h\hjblv
k_[_qlh fbjlZdhclhlh fbji_j_klZg_l [ulvlZdbf< wlhl
fhf_gl y g_ ^mfZxqlh lu]hlh\ d lZdhfm fhf_glZevghfm
m^Zjmihwlhfm lu
^he`_g
f_^e_ggh
gZqZlv mgbqlh`Zlv
hldju\Zlvfbj
Y\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbg_ ihgbfZxl_[y
L\hy [_^Z\ lhfqlh lukf_rb\Z_rv fbjk l_fqlh
^_eZxl ex^bb hiylv`_lu g_h^bghd \wlhfDZ`^uc bagZk
^_eZ_l wlh<_sbdhlhju_ ^_eZxl ex^by\eyxlky sblZfb
ijhlb\ kbedhlhju_ gZkhdjm`Zxllhqlh fu ^_eZ_fdZd
ex^b^Z_l gZf m^h[kl\hb qm\kl\h[_ahiZkghklblhqlh
^_eZxl ex^bih ijZ\mhq_gv \Z`ghgh lhevdhdZd sblFu
gbdh]^Z g_ agZ_fqlh \k_qlh fu^_eZ_fdZd ex^bwlh
lhevdh sblub fuiha\hey_f bf]hkih^kl\h\Zlv b ihibjZlv
gZrb `bagbNZdlbq_kdby
^he`_g
kdZaZlvqlh ^ey
q_eh\_q_kl\Z lhqlh ^_eZxlex^b[he__ \_ebdh b [he__
\Z`ghq_f kZffbj
Qlh lugZau\Z_rv fbjhf"
Fbj wlh \k_qlh aZdexq_gha^_kvkdZaZe hg b
lhigme ih a_fe_`bagvkf_jlvex^bheeb b \k_
hklZevgh_qlh hdjm`Z_lgZkFbj g_h[tyl_gFu gbdh]^Z g_
kfh`_f ihgylv _]hfu gbdh]^Z g_ jZa]Z^Z_f _]h lZcg
Ihwlhfmfu ^he`guhlghkblvky dg_fmdZd dlhfmqlh hg
_klvdZd dqm^_kghc aZ]Z^d_
H^gZdhh[uqguc q_eh\_dg_ ^_eZ_lwlh]hFbj gbdh]^Zg_
y\ey_lky aZ]Z^dhc ^ey g_]hbdh]^Z hg ijb[eb`Z_lky d
klZjhklbhg m[_`^Z_lkyqlh hgg_ bf__l[hevr_ gbq_]h^ey
q_]h `blvKlZjbd g_bkq_jiZe fbjZHg bkq_jiZelhevdh lh
qlh ^_eZxlex^bGh \k\h_f ]emihfaZf_rZl_evkl\_ hg\_jbl
qlh fbjg_ bf__l[hevr_ aZ]Z^hd^ey g_]h<hl m`ZkgZyp_gZ
dhlhjmx ijboh^blkyieZlblv aZgZrb sblu
<hbg hkhagZ_lwlm imlZgbpmb mqblkyhlghkblvky d\_sZf
ijZ\bevgh<_sbdhlhju_ ^_eZxlex^bgb ijbdZdbo mkeh\byo
g_ fh]ml[ulv [he__\Z`guq_f fbjBlZdbf h[jZahf\hbg
hlghkblky d fbjmdZd d[_kdhg_qghc lZcg_Z d lhfmqlh
^_eZxl ex^bdZd d[_kdhg_qghc ]emihklb
=eZ\Z
iy lg Z^ pZ lZ y
Y gZqZemijZ`gylvky \ijbkemrb\Zgbb da\mdZf fbjZb
ijh^he`Ze wlh\ l_q_gb_^\mo f_kyp_\dZd lhqghmdZaZe ^hg
OmZgKgZqZeZ [uehfmqbl_evgh keurZlvb g_\b^_lvgh _s_
[he__ fmqbl_evguf [uehg_ jZa]h\Zjb\Zlvk kZfbf kh[hcD
dhgpm ^\mof_kyp_\ y[ue kihkh[_g\udexqZlv k\hc\gmlj_ggbc
^bZeh] gZ dhjhldb_i_jbh^u i_jbh^u\j_f_gb bfh] h[jZsZlv
\gbfZgb_ gZa\mdb
Y ijb[ue d ^hfm ^hgZ
OmZgZ d qZkZf ghy[jy
]h^Z
Fu gZqg_f ih_a^dmijyfh k_cqZkkdZaZe hgdZd
lhevdh yih^t_oZe d_]h ^hfm
Y hl^hogme\ l_q_gb_qZkZZ aZl_ffu ih_oZebd gbadbf
kdehgZf ]hjgZ \hklhd_Fu hklZ\bebfhx fZrbgmgZ ihi_q_gb_
h^gh]h ba_]h ^jma_cdhlhjuc `be\ wlhff_kl_Z kZfbihreb
i_rdhf \ ]hju>hg OmZgiheh`be kmoh_i_q_gv_ b keZ^db_
[mehqdb \jxdaZd ^eyf_gyIjh\babb [ueh^hklZlhqgh gZ^_gv
beb gZ^\ZY kijhkbe^hgZ OmZgZg_ \aylveb gZf[hevr_gh
hg hljbpZl_evghihljyk ]heh\hc
Fu rebi_rdhf \k_mljh;ue ^h\hevghl_ieuc ^_gvY g_k
h^gm ney]mk \h^hcba dhlhjhc[hevr_c qZklvxibe ykZf>hg
OmZg ibe lhevdh^\Z`^uDh]^Z \h^ZdhgqbeZkvhg aZ\_jbe
f_gyqlh [ueh[u hq_gvohjhrh gZiblvkyba ihlhdZdhlhjuc
fu gZc^_f gZgZr_f imlbHg jZkkf_yekygZ fh_ g_`_eZgb_
Q_j_a dhjhldh_ \j_fyfhy `Z`^Z\ugm^beZ f_gyih[hjhlv fhb
kljZob
JZgh ihke_ihem^gy fuhklZgh\bebkv \g_[hevrhc ^hebg_m
ih^gh`vy dZdbolh khqguoa_e_guo ohefh\IhaZ^b ohefh\gZ
\hklhd_gZ h[eZqghfg_[_ \ujbkh\u\Zebkv\ukhdb_ ]hju
Lu fh`_rv^mfZlvqlh lufh`_rv gZibkZlvh lhfqlh
fu ]h\hjbfbeb hlhfqlh lu\hkijbgbfZ_rvgh lugbq_]h g_
fh`_rv gZibkZlvh lhf]^_ fugZoh^bfkykdZaZe hg
Fu hklZgh\bebkv gZ \j_fyb aZl_f hg \ugme ma_ehd
baih^ k\h_c jm[ZrdbHg jZa\yaZe_]h bihdZaZe fg_ k\hx
ljm[dmHg gZihegbe__ qZr_qdmdmjbl_evghc kf_kvxaZ`_]
kibqdm b ih^`_] g_[hevrmxkmomx \_ldmiheh`be ]hjysmx
\_lhqdm \gmljv qZrdbb \_e_efg_ dmjblvG_ bf_y dmkhqdZ
m]ey \gmljb qZrdb[ueh ljm^ghjZa`_qv ljm[dmfu ^he`gu
[ueb ^_j`Zlv ]hjysb_ \_ldb ^hl_o ihjihdZ kf_kv g_
jZa]hj_eZkv
Dh]^Z ydhgqbe dmjblvhg kdZaZeqlh fu[ueb a^_kv^ey
lh]hqlh[u y fh]jZaukdZlv lhl\b^ ^bqbgZ dhlhjmx y
ij_^iheZ]Ze hohlblvkyHg aZ[hleb\hih\lhjbe fg_ ljb beb
q_luj_ jZaZqlh gZb[he__\Z`guf Zki_dlhffh_c ihiuldb[ueh
gZclb dZdb_gb[m^v yfuHg ih^q_jdgmekeh\h yfub kdZaZe
qlh \gmljbbo fZ]fh] gZclb\k_ \b^ukhh[s_gbc bmdZaZgbcY
ohl_e kijhkblvdZdh]h jh^Z yfu
wlh [ueb^hg OmZg
dZaZehkvhl]Z^Ze fhc \hijhk
b
kdZaZeqlh bo [ueh
g_\hafh`gh hibkZlv bqlh hgb[ueb \h[eZklb \b^_gvyHg
ih\lhjbe g_kdhevdhjZaqlh y^he`_g khkj_^hlhqblv\k_ k\h_
\gbfZgb_ gZkemrZgvb a\mdh\b k^_eZlv\k_ \hafh`gh_qlh[u
gZclb ^ujuf_`^m a\mdZfbHg kdZaZeqlh hgkh[bjZeky b]jZlv
gZ k\h_f eh\bl_e_ ^moh\
q_luj_
jZaZY ^he`_g [ue
bkihevah\Zlv wlb`mldb_ ah\u\ dZq_kl\_ijh\h^gbdh\ dheeb
dhlhjuc ijb\_lkl\h\Ze f_gywlhl
heeb lh]^Z ^Zkl fg_
khh[s_gb_dhlhjh_ ybkdZe>hg OmZg\_e_e fg_gZoh^blvky \
iheghc [^bl_evghklblZd dZdhg g_agZedZdbf h[jZahfheeb
ijhy\bl k_[yih hlghr_gbxdh fg_
Y \gbfZl_evgh
ijbkemrb\ZekyY
kb^_e
kibghc d
dZf_gbklhc klhjhg_ ohefZY bkiulu\Zemf_j_ggh_ hg_f_gb_
>hg OmZg ij_^mij_^be f_gy g_aZdju\Zlv ]eZaZY gZqZe
kemrZlv bfh] jZaebqblvihk\bklu\Zgb_ ilbpr_e_kl ebklv_\
hl \_ljZ`m``Zgb_ gZk_dhfuoDh]^Z yihf_klbe \k_ k\h_
\gbfZgb_ \wlb a\mdby fh]^_ckl\bl_evgh jZah[jZlv q_luj_
jZaguo lbiZ ihk\bklu\ZgbyilbpY fh]jZaebqblv f_^e_ggu_
beb [uklju_ kdhjhklb\_ljZy fh]lZd`_ keurZlv jZaebqguc
r_e_kl lj_o
lbih\
ebklv_\@m``Zgb_
gZk_dhfuo [ueh
ihjZabl_evgufBo [uehlZd fgh]hqlh yg_ fh]khkqblZlv bo
beb ijZ\bevghjZa^_eblv bo
Y [ueih]jm`_g \g_h[uqguc fbja\mdh\dhlhjh]h gbdh]^Z
g_ [ueh \fh_c `bagbY gZqZekdhevablv \ijZ\h>hg OmZg
k^_eZe ^\b`_gb_qlh[u hklZgh\blvf_gygh ykZf m`_k^_j`Ze
k_[yY \uijyfbekyb k_eijyfh kgh\Z>hg OmZg i_j_^\bgme
fh_ l_ehihdZ g_ih^i_j f_gy\ s_ebdZf_gghc kl_guHg
jZkqbklbe f_edb_dZfgb baih^ fhbogh] bmeh`be aZluehdfh_c
]heh\u gZdZf_gv
Hg ih\_ebl_evghkdZaZe fg_qlh[u ykfhlj_e gZ]hju d
x]h\hklhdmY khkj_^hlhqbefhc ijbklZevguc\a]ey^ \^Zevgh
hg bkijZ\be f_gy b kdZaZeqlh y g_ ^he`_g kfhlj_lv
ijbklZevghgh jZa]ey^u\Zlvohefu i_j_^hfghc b jZklbl_
evghklv gZ gboHg ih\lhjbekgh\Z bkgh\Zqlh y ^he`_g
khkj_^hlhqblv \k_k\h_ \gbfZgb_gZ kemrZgvb
A\mdb gZqZeb ijhklmiZlvkgh\ZBo g_ [ueh gZklhevdh
fgh]hqlh[u y ohl_e kemrZlvbokdhj__hgb dZdbflh
kihkh[hf aZklZ\eyeb f_gydhgp_gljbjh\Zlvky gZ gbo<_l_j
r_e_kl_e ebklvyfb<_l_j ijhr_e\\_jom gZ^^_j_\vyfb baZl_f
\lygmeky \ ^hebgm]^_ fu[uebHimkdZykvhg dhkgmeky
kgZqZeZ ebklv_\ gZ\_jomrdZo ^_j_\v_\hgb ba^Zeb hkh[uc
a\mddhlhjucdZd yij_^klZ\be[ue gbadbf^j_[_a`Zsbf
khqguf a\mdhfAZl_f \_l_j lhedgmedmklub bo ebklvy
aZa\mqZeb ih^h[ghfgh`_kl\m f_edboij_^f_lh\wlh [ueihqlb
f_eh^bqguc a\mdhq_gv ih]ehsZxsbcb \_kvfZlj_[h\Zl_evguc
hgdZaZehkvfh] aZ]emrblv\k_ hklZevgh_Y gZr_e _]h
g_ijbylgufY ihqm\kl\h\Zek_[y \aZljm^g_gbbihlhfm qlh
fg_ ijbreh gZ mfqlh y [ue ih^h[_g rmjrZgbx dmklh\
jZa^jZ`Zxs_fm blj_[mxs_fmA\md [uelZd [ebahddh fg_qlh
y bkiulu\Zeg_eh\dhklvAZl_f ymkeurZeqlh \_l_jijhr_eky
ih a_fe_Wlh g_[ue [hevr_r_e_klysbc a\mdgh [hevr_
ihk\bklu\Zgb_ihqlb gbadh_
beb h^ghh[jZagh_ `m``Zgb_
Ijbkemrb\Zykv d a\mdZf\_ljZy ihgyeqlh \k_ljb ba gbo
kemqbebkv kjZamY [uem^b\e_g l_fqlh y [ue kihkh[_g
hlebqblv boh^bg hl^jm]h]hdh]^Z ykgh\Z gZqZe khagZ\Zlv
ihk\bklu\Zgb_ ilbpb `m``Zgb_gZk_dhfuo< h^bgfhf_gl [ueb
lhevdh a\mdb \_ljZZ \ke_^mxsbc fhf_gl]b]Zglkdbc ihlhd
^jm]bo a\mdh\ kjZam
\hagbd
\
kn_j_ fh_]h khagZgby
Eh]bq_kdb\k_ kms_kl\h\Z\rb_a\mdb ^he`gu[ueb ihklhyggh
ba^Z\Zlvky \l_q_gb_ \j_f_gbdh]^Z ykeurZe lhevdh\_l_j
Y g_fh] khkqblZlv\k_o ihk\blu\Zgbcilbp beb`m``Zgbc
gZk_dhfuoh^gZdhy [ue m[_`^_gqlh y keurZe dZ`^uc
hl^_evguc a\mddh]^Z hg ijhba\h^beky<k_ \f_kl_ hgb
kha^Z\Zeb hq_gv g_h[uqguc ihjy^hdY g_fh] gZa\Zlv wlh
bgZq_q_f ihjy^hdWlh [ueihjy^hd a\mdh\dhlhju_ bf_eb
kljhclh _klvdZ`^uc a\mdijhbkoh^be \ihke_^h\Zl_evghklb
AZl_f ymkeurZe bkdexqbl_evgh^he]bc \hcHg aZklZ\be
f_gy aZ^jh`Zlv<k_ ^jm]b_a\mdb \f]gh\_gb_ ij_djZlbebkvb
^hebgZ [ueZf_jl\hcihdZ hljZ`_gb_\hy g_^hklb]eh ^jm]hc
klhjhgu ^hebguaZl_f rmfu\hagbdeb hiylvY kjZam`_ ihcfZe
bo kljhcQ_j_a fhf_glgZijy`_ggh]h kemrZgbyy ih^mfZeqlh
y ihgye j_dhf_g^Zpbx^hgZ OmZgZgZ[ex^Zlv aZ^ujZfb f_`^m
a\mdZfbKljhc rmfh\bf_e bgl_j\Zeuf_`^m a\mdZfbGZijbf_j
hkh[u_ ihk\bklu\Zgbyilbp [uebjZkkqblZgu ih\j_f_gb bbf_eb
iZmau f_`^mkh[hcb lh`_ bf_eb\k_ ^jm]b_a\mdbdhlhju_ y
\hkijbgbfZeR_e_kl ebklv_\[ue ih^h[_g\yadhfm de_xqlh
khklZ\eyeh bo h^ghjh^gh_ `m``Zgb_>_eh [ueh\ lhfqlh
kbgojhgghklv dZ`^h]ha\mdZ [ueZp_ehc \h[s_f kljh_a\mdh\
LZdbf h[jZahfbgl_j\Zeu bebiZmau f_`^ma\mdZfb_keb y
h[jZsZe \gbfZgb_ gZgbo[ueb ^ujZfb\ kljmdlmj_Y kgh\Z
mkeurZe ijhgabl_evguc\hc eh\bl_ey^moh\ ^hgZOmZgZHg g_
ihljyk f_gygh a\mdbkgh\Z ij_djZlbebkv\ f]gh\_gb_b y
\hkijbgye lZdhc i_j_ju\dZd ^ujmhq_gv [hevrmx ^ujm<
wlhl kZfucfhf_gl yi_j_f_klbe k\h_\gbfZgb_ hlkemrZgvy d
kfhlj_gbxY kfhlj_egZ kdhie_gb_gbadbo ohefh\ k iurghc
a_e_ghc jZklbl_evghklvxKbemwlu ohefh\ [ueb jZkiheh`_gu
lZdbf h[jZahfqlh kf_klZhldm^Z ykfhlj_egZ kdehg_
h^gh]h baohefh\dZaZehkv[ueZ \b^gZ^ujZ
Wlh [uehf_klh f_`^m^\mfy ohefZfbb [eZ]h^Zjywlhfm y
fh] \b^_lv gbadb_q_jgu_k k_jufhll_gdhf ]hju\^Zeb<
wlhl fhf_gl yg_ agZeqlh wlh[ueh;ueh lZddZd [m^lh
^ujZdhlhjmx y \b^_e[ueZ ^ujhc\ a\md_AZl_f rmfu
gZqZebkv kgh\Zgh \bamZevgh_bah[jZ`_gb_ h]jhfghc ^uju
hklZ\ZehkvDhjhldh_ \j_fykimkly yklZe _s_ [he__ hkljh
hkhagZ\Zlv kljhc a\mdh\ bbo ihjy^hdb jZkij_^_e_gb_ bo
iZmaFhc mf [uekihkh[_g jZaebqZlvb \u^_eylv h]jhfgh_
dhebq_kl\h hl^_evguoa\mdh\Y fh]^_ckl\bl_evgh ke_^blvaZ
\k_fb a\mdZfbihwlhfm dZ`^ZyiZmaZ f_`^m a\mdZfb [ueZ
hij_^_e_gghc ^ujhc< hij_^_e_ggucfhf_gl iZmaukdjbklZeeb
ah\Zebkv \fh_f mf_b h[jZah\Zebl\_j^mx j_r_ldmkljmdlmjm
Y g_\b^_e bg_ keurZeboY qm\kl\h\Zekljmdlmjm dZdhclh
g_ba\_klghc qZklvxk_[y
>hg OmZg aZb]jZe gZ k\h_c[_q_\d_ _s_ jZaa\mdb
ij_djZlbebkvdZd bij_`^_kha^Z\ h]jhfgmx^ujm \a\mdh\hc
kljmdlmj_H^gZdhgZ
wlhl
jZa
wlZ
[hevrZy iZmaZ
]Zjfhgbjh\ZeZ k ^ujhc \ ohefZodhlhjmx y \b^_ehgb
gZeh`bebkv ^jm]gZ ^jm]ZWnn_dl \hkijbylby^\mo ^uj^ebeky
lZdh_ ^he]h_\j_fyqlh yfh] \b^_lvb keurZlvbo dhglmju
lZd dZdhgb khhl\_lkl\h\Zeb^jm] ^jm]mAZl_f kgh\ZgZqZebkv
^jm]b_ a\mdbb kljmdlmjZiZma boklZeZ hlq_leb\ufihqlb
\b^bfuf hsms_gb_fY klZe \b^_lv
a\mdblZd dZd hgb
kha^Z\Zeb kljhcb aZl_f\_kv wlhlkljhc klZegZdeZ^u\Zlvky
gZ hdjm`Zxs__ l_f `_ kZfufiml_fdZdbf y \hkijbgbfZe
gZeh`_gb_ ^\mo[hevrbo ^ujY g_kfhlj_e bg_ kemrZedZd y
ijb\ud wlh ^_eZlvY ^_eZeqlhlhqlh [ueh kh\_jr_ggh
hlebqgufy khklZ\eyek\hckl\Z h[hboIh dZdhclh ijbqbg_
fh_ \gbfZgb_[ueh khkj_^hlhq_ghgZ [hevrhc^uj_ \ohefZoY
qm\kl\h\Zeqlh ykeurZe __b \lh `_kZfh_ \j_fyy \b^_e
__< g_c[ueh qlhlh kh[eZagyxs__HgZ \k_p_eh ih]ehlbeZ
fh_ ihe_ \hkijbylbyb dZ`^uchl^_evguc a\mdh\hc kljhc
dhlhjuc kh\iZ^Zek hkh[_gghklyfbhdjm`_gbyaZ\bk_e hlwlhc
^uju
Y _s_jZa mkeurZe`mldbc \hceh\bl_ey ^moh\^hgZ OmZgZ
\k_ a\mdb ij_djZlbebkv^\_
[hevrb_
^ujudZaZehkv
k\_lbebkvb lh]^Zy kgh\Zm\b^_e \kiZoZggh_ihe_lZf klhye
heebdZd y \b^_e_]h ij_`^_<b^ \k_ckp_gu klZe hq_gv
ykgufY fh]\b^_lv _]hijyfhdZd [m^lhhg [ue\ iylb^_kylb
yj^ZoY g_fh] \b^_lv_]h ebphreyiZ kdju\ZeZ_]hAZl_f
hg gZqZeijb[eb`Zlvky dhfg_f_^e_ggh ih^gbfZygZ oh^mk\hx
]heh\my fh]ihqlb \b^_lv_]h ebphb wlhm`Zkgmeh f_gyY
agZeqlh y ^he`_g[ue hklZgh\blv _]h [_a ijhf_^e_gby
G_h[uqZcgZy \hegZ ijhreZ ih
fh_fm l_emy qm\kl\h\Ze
bkl_q_gb_ kbeuY ohl_ehl\_klb ]eZaZ\ klhjhgmqlh[u
hklZgh\blv aj_ebs_gh y g_fh] k^_eZlv wlh]h< wlhl
djblbq_kdbc fhf_glfg_ \]heh\m ijbreZfukevY agZelhqlh
bf_e \ \b^m ^hgOmZgdh]^Z ]h\hjbeh qZklbpZo imlb k
k_j^p_fdhlhju_ [ueb sblZfb;ueh qlhlhqlh y ohl_e
ke_^Zlv \ k\h_c
`bagbqlhlh
hq_gv
ih]ehsZxs__ b
bgljb]mxs__qlhlhqlh
gZihegyeh
f_gy
h]jhfguf
kihdhckl\b_f b m^h\hevkl\b_fY agZeqlh heeb g_ fh]
ih[_^blv f_gyY ih\_jgme]heh\m [_ah\kydh]h [_kihdhckl\Z
ij_`^_ q_fy fh]m\b^_lv \k__]h ebph
Y gZqZe kemrZlv\k_ ^jm]b_a\mdbhgb \g_aZigh klZeb
hq_gv ]jhfdbfbb gZklhcqb\ufbdZd [m^lhhgb ^_ckl\bl_evgh
k_j^bebkv gZ f_gyHgb ihl_jyebk\hc kljhc b hdZaZebkv
Zfhjnguf dhg]ehf_jZlhfj_adbo[he_ag_gguo djbdh\Fhb mrb
gZqZeb ]m^_lvih^ bo^Z\e_gb_fY qm\kl\h\Zeqlh fhy]heh\Z
jZaju\Z_lkyY \klZeb aZdjuemrb eZ^hgyfb
>hg OmZg ihfh] fg_
^hclb ^h g_[hevrh]h jmq_cdZ
aZklZ\be f_gykgylv h^_`^mb hdmgmef_gy \\h^mHg aZklZ\be
f_gy e_qvgZ ihqlbkmoh_ jmkehjmqvyZ aZl_fkh[jZe \h^m\
k\hx reyimb ie_kgmegZ f_gy_c
>Z\e_gb_ \ fhbomrZo kiZehhq_gv [ukljhb dmiZgb_
hlgyeh lhevdhg_kdhevdh fbgml>hg OmZgihkfhlj_e gZ f_gy
h^h[jbl_evgh ihljyk ]heh\hc bkdZaZeqlh y k^_eZe k_[y
l\_j^ufg_h[udgh\_ggh [ukljh
Hg h^_ef_gy bhl\_e f_gygZaZ^ df_klm]^_ ykb^_eY
qm\kl\h\Ze k_[yg_h[udgh\_ggh kbevguf[h^juf bykguf
Hg ohl_e agZlv \k_ ih^jh[ghklb fh_]h aj_ebsZHg
kdZaZeqlh ^uju\ a\mdZobkihevah\Zebkv fZ]Zfbqlh[u
magZlv hkh[u_\_sbHeeb fZ]ZihdZau\Z_l keh`gu_^_eZ q_j_a
wlb ^uju\ a\mdZoHg hldZaZeky[he__ ih^jh[ghjZkkdZaZlv h
^ujZob hl[jhkbefhb \hijhkukdZaZ\qlhldy g_bf_e
heeblZdZy bgnhjfZpby[m^_l lhevdh\j_^gZ fg_
<k_ bf__lagZq_gb_ ^eyfZ]ZkdZaZe hgA\mdb
bf_xl ^uju \k_[_b lZd`_ ^_eZxl\k_ \hdjm]k_[y>_eZy
h[uqguf iml_fq_eh\_d g_bf__l kdhjhklbqlh[u ko\Zlblv
^ujub ihwlhfm hgb^_l kd\hav`bagv [_a aZsbluQ_j\b
ilbpu^_j_\vy \k_ hgbfh]ml ]h\hjblvgZf g_\hh[jZabfu_
\_sb_keb lhevdh bf__rv
kdhjhklvqlh[u ko\Zlblv bo
khh[s_gby>ufhd fh`_l^Zlv gZfwlm ko\Zlu\Zxsmx kdhjhklv
Gh fu^he`gu [ulv\ ohjhrbohlghr_gbyo kh\k_f `b\uf\ wlhf
fbj_< wlhfijbqbgZ lh]hihq_fm fu^he`gu jZa]h\Zjb\Zlvk
jZkl_gbyfbdh]^Z fukh[_j_fky kj_aZlvbob ba\bgylvky
ijbqbgyy bf\j_^lh `_kZfh_ fu^he`gu ^_eZlvih hlghr_gbx
d `b\hlgufdhlhjuo fukh[bjZ_fky m[blvFu ^he`gu [jZlv
lhevdh lhqlh ^hklZlhqgh^ey gZrbogm`^bgZq_ jZkl_gby b
`b\hlgu_b q_j\bdhlhjuo fum[bebh[_jgmlky ijhlb\gZk b
[m^ml ijbqbghcgZr_c [he_agbb g_kqZklvy<hbg hkhagZ_lwlh
b klZjZ_lky mkihdhblv bolh]^Zdh]^Z hg \kfZljb\Z_lky
q_j_a ^uju^_j_\vyilbpu
b
q_j\b ^Zxl _fm \_jgu_
khh[s_gby
Gh \k_wlh l_i_jvg_\Z`gh<Z`gh lhqlh lu\b^_e heeb
<hl l\hy^bqvY ]h\hjbel_[_qlh fukh[bjZebkv gZ qlhlh
hohlblvkyY ^mfZeqlh wlh[m^_l `b\hlgh_Y jZkkqblu\Ze
qlh lum\b^brv `b\hlgh_gZ dhlhjh_fu kh[bjZ_fkyhohlblvky
KZf y\b^_e dZ[ZgZfhc eh\bl_ev^moh\ wlh dZ[Zg
Ihq_fm fuijbreb kx^Zhohlblvky"
Heeb ihdZaZel_[_ eh\bl_ev^moh\dhlhjuc hg ^hklZe
ba k\h_c kmfdbL_[_
gm`gh
ijbh[j_klb _]h_keb lu
kh[bjZ_rvky \uau\Zlvheeb
Qlh lZdh_eh\bl_ev ^moh\"
Wlh gblv?x yfh]m \uau\Zlvheebfh_]h kh[kl\_ggh]h
heebbeb yfh]m \uau\Zlv^moh\ \h^guo^uj^moh\ j_d^moh\
]hjFhc wlh dZ[Zgb a\mqblih^h[gh dZ[ZgmY bkihevah\Ze
_]h ^\Z`^u^ey l_[yqlh[u \ua\Zlv^moZ \h^ghc^ujuqlh[u
ihfhqv l_[_>mo ijboh^bed l_[_dZd heebijboh^be d l_[_
k_]h^gyH^gZdhlZ g_fh] \b^_lv_]hihlhfm qlhm l_[yg_l
kdhjhklbh^gZdh\ lhl^_gvdh]^Z y\aye l_[y \ \h^guc
dZgvhg biheh`be l_[ygZ dZf_gvlu agZeqlh ^mo[ue ihqlb
gZ^ lh[hcb lu\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbg_ \b^_e_]hWlb ^mob
ihfhsgbdbHgb l\_j^u_qlh[u bo^_j`Zlv jmdZfbb dZd [u
hiZkguGm`gZ [_amij_qgZy
\heyqlh[u
^_j`Zlv bo \
[_a\uoh^ghf iheh`_gbb
GZ qlhhgb ihoh`b"
Hgb jZaebqgu ^eydZ`^h]h q_eh\_dZb lZd`_ heeb>ey
l_[y heebhq_\b^gh\u]ey^bl ih^h[ghq_eh\_dmdhlhjh]h lu
ij_`^_ agZebeb ih^h[gh q_eh\_dmdhlhjh]h lu \k_]^Z
klZjZ_rvky magZlvwlh kdehgghklvl\h_c gZlmjuLu kdehg_gd
lZcgZf bk_dj_lZfY g_ihoh` gZl_[yihlhfm qlhheeb ^ey
f_gy wlh qlhlh hq_gvykgh_
>mob \h^guo^uj \eZ^_evpu hkh[uof_klLhldhlhjh]h
y \uau\Zeqlh[u ihfhqv l_[_ba\_kl_g fg_ kZfhfmHg
ihfh]Ze fg_fgh]h jZaHg h[blZ_l\ wlhfdZgvhg_< lhljZa
dh]^Z y\uau\Ze _]hqlh[u ihfhqvl_[_lu g_[ue kbevgufb
^mo ijbgye l_[ykmjh\hWlh g_[ueh _]hgZf_j_gb_ m gbo
g_l wlh]h gh lue_`Ze lZfhq_gv keZ[uckeZ[__q_f y
ih^haj_\ZeIha`_ ^mo_^\Z g_gZ\e_d gZl_[y l\hxkf_jlv\
\h^_ hjhkbl_evgh]hdZgZeZ lunhknhj_pbjh\Ze>mo \aye l_[y
m^b\e_gb_fb lu_^\Z g_mf_jJZa ^mo^_eZ_l wlhhg \k_]^Z
\ha\jZsZ_lky aZk\h_c `_jl\hcY [uem\_j_gqlh hg\_jg_lky
aZ lh[hcD g_kqZklvxlu gm`^Z_rvky\ \h^_qlh[u klZlv
dj_idbf kgh\Zdh]^Z lubkihevam_rv ^ufhdwlh aZ]hgy_ll_[y
\ m`Zkghg_\u]h^gh_ iheh`_gb_?keb lug_ bkihevam_rv\h^m
lh lu\_jhylghmfj_rvgh _keblu bkihevam_rvf_gylh ^mo
\havf_l l_[y
Fh]m eby bkihevah\Zlv\h^m \^jm]hf f_kl_"
Wlh g_bf__l gbdZdhcjZagbpu>mo \h^ghc^uju \[ebab
fh_]h ^hfZ fh`_lij_ke_^h\Zlv l_[y]^_ m]h^gh_keb lu g_
bf__rv eh\bl_ey^moh\<hl ihq_fmheeb ihdZaZewlh l_[_Hg
kdZaZe l_[_qlh lugm`^Z_rvky \g_fHg h[_jgme_]h \hdjm]
k\h_c e_\hc jmdbb ihr_ed l_[_mdZaZ\ gZ\h^guc dZgvhg
K_]h^gy hgkgh\Z ohl_eihdZaZlv l_[_eh\bl_ev ^moh\dZd b\
i_j\uc jZadh]^Z lu \klj_lbeky kgbfB lhqlh lu
ij_djZlbe[ueh [eZ]hjZamfghheeb r_ekebrdhf l\_j^h ^ey
l\h_c kbeub ijyfh_ klhedgh\_gb_k gbf [ueh [u hq_gv
\j_^guf ^eyl_[y
DZd yfh]m ^hklZlveh\bl_ev ^moh\l_i_jv"
Hq_\b^ghheeb kh[bjZ_lky^Zlv l_[__]h kZf
DZd"
Y g_ agZxLu ^he`_g[m^_rv ihclbd g_fmhg m`_
kdZaZe l_[_]^_ kfhlj_lv_]h
=^_"
LZfgZ\_jomgZ l_oohefZo]^_ lu\b^_e ^ujm
>he`_g eby m\b^_lvkZfh]h heeb"
G_lGh hgm`_ ijb\_lkl\m_ll_[y>ufhd hldjue l_[_
imlv d g_fmAZl_fiha`_lu \klj_lbrvkyk gbf ebphf d
ebpmgh wlhijhbahc^_l lhevdhihke_ lh]hdZd lu magZ_rv
_]h hq_gvohjhrh
=eZ\Z
r_ kl gZ ^p Zl Zy
Fu ijb[ueb \lm `_kZfmx ^hebgmiha^gh ihke_ ihem^gy
^_dZ[jy ]h^Z>hg OmZgih\lhjgh gZihfgbefg_dh]^Z
fu ^\b]Zebkv kd\havdmklZjgbdqlh gZijZ\e_gby beb lhqdb
hjb_glZpbb [ueb j_rZxs_ \Z`gufb
\ ihiuld_dhlhjmx y
kh[bjZeky ij_^ijbgylv
Lu ^he`_ghij_^_eblv \_jgh_gZijZ\e_gb_ g_f_^e_gghih
ijb[ulbb gZ\_jrbgm ohefZkdZaZe ^hgOmZgDZd lhevdh
lu [m^_rv gZ\_jrbg_ ohefZkdZaZe ^hgOmZgh[jZlbkv
ebphf \wlhf gZijZ\e_gbbhg mdZaZegZ x]h\hklhdWlh
l\h_ [eZ]hijbylgh_ gZijZ\e_gb_b lu\k_]^Z ^he`_g [ulv
h[jZs_g ebphf dg_fmhkh[_gghdh]^Z lu \ [_kihdhckl\_
Ihfgb wlh
Fu hklZgh\bebkvm hkgh\Zgbyohefh\]^_ y \hkijbgbfZe
^ujmHg mdZaZegZ hkh[h_f_klh]^_ y^he`_g [uekb^_lvhg
k_e jy^hf kh fghc b hq_gv kihdhcguf ]hehkhf ^Ze fg_
ih^jh[gu_ bgkljmdpbbHg kdZaZeqlhdZd lhevdhy ^hklb]gm
\_jrbgu ohefZy ^he`_gijhlygmlv i_j_^kh[hc k\hx ijZ\mx
jmdm eZ^hgvx \gba bjZklhiujb\ iZevpuih^h[gh \__jmaZ
bkdexq_gb_f [hevrh]hiZevpZdhlhjuc ^he`_g[ulv ih^h]gmld
eZ^hgbAZl_f y^he`_g ih\_jgmlv]heh\m dk_\_jm b ijb`Zlv
jmdm d]jm^bmdZau\Zy jmdhclZd`_ gZk_\_jaZl_f y^he`_g
lZgp_\ZlvihklZ\b\ fhxe_\mx gh]mihaZ^b ijZ\hcb m^Zjyy\
a_fex ghkdhfe_\hc gh]bHg kdZaZeqlhdh]^Z yihqm\kl\mx
l_iehih^gbfZxs__ky ihfh_c e_\hcgh]_y ^he`_g gZqZlv
f_^e_ggh i_j_ghkblvfhx jmdmk k_\_jZgZ x]Z aZl_fkgh\Z d
k_\_jm
F_klhgZ^ dhlhjufeZ^hgv l\h_c jmdb ihqm\kl\m_l
l_iehdh]^Z luijhghkbrv jmdmwlh f_klh]^_ lu ^he`_g
kb^_lvb wlh y\ey_lkylZd`_ gZijZ\e_gb_f\ dhlhjhf lu
^he`_g kfhlj_lvkdZaZe hg?keb f_klhd x]h\hklhdm beb
_keb hgh \ wlhf gZijZ\e_gbbhg kgh\Z mdZaZe gZ
x]h\hklhdj_amevlZlu [m^mlij_\hkoh^gufb?keb f_klh
]^_ l\hy jmdZklZgh\blky l_iehcd k_\_jmlh lu ihemqbrv
kbevgh_ ihjZ`_gb_gh lufh`_rv ih\_jgmlvl_q_gb_ \ k\hx
ihevam?keb f_klhd x]mlu [m^_rvbf_lv ly`_emx[hjv[m
L_[_ gm`gh[m^_l ijh\_klbjmdm kgZqZeZq_luj_ jZaZgh
dh]^Z luklZg_rv [he__agZdhf k^\b`_gb_fl_[_ gZ^h [m^_l
ijh\_klb lhevdh jZaqlh[u agZlvkh[bjZ_lky bebg_l l\hy
jmdZ klZlvl_iehc
JZa lu mklZgh\be f_klh]^_ l\hy jmdZ klZgh\blky
l_iehckZ^bkv lZfwlh l\hyi_j\Zy lhqdZ?keb lu h[jZs_g
ebphf gZx] bebgZ k_\_jlu ^he`_gj_rblvqm\kl\m_rv eblu
^hklZlhqgh kbeuqlh[u hklZlvky?keb lubf__rv khfg_gby \
k_[_lh \klZgvb mc^bG_l g_h[oh^bfhklbhklZ\Zlvky_keb
lu g_ m\_j_g?keb luj_rbe g_moh^blvhqbklv ^hklZlhqgh
[hevrh_ f_klhqlh[u jZa\_klbh]hgvijbf_jgh \iylb nmlZo
hl l\h_ci_j\hc lhqdbH]hgv ^he`_g[ulv gZijyfhc ebgbb k
gZijZ\e_gb_f\ dhlhjhflu kfhljbrvF_klh]^_ lujZa\h^brv
h]hgvwlh l\hy\lhjZy lhqdZAZl_f kh[_jb \k_ \_ldb
dZdb_ kfh`_rvf_`^m wlbfb^\mfy lhqdZfbb jZa\_^b h]hgv
Ky^v gZl\hx i_j\mxlhqdm bkfhljb gZh]hgvJZgh bebiha^gh
^mo ijb^_lb lum\b^brv _]h
?keb l\hyjmdZ kh\k_fg_ ihemqZ_ll_ieh ihke_ q_luj_o
^\b`_gbcf_^e_ggh ijh\_^bk\h_c jmdhck k_\_jZgZ x]Z
aZl_f ih\_jgbkvdjm]hf bijh\_^b __gZ aZiZ^?keb l\hyjmdZ
ihemqZ_l l_ieh \ex[hf f_kl_d aZiZ^m[jhkv \k_ b [_]b
;_]b \gba gZjh\gh_ f_klhb g_h[hjZqb\Zckyqlh [ulu gb
mkeurZe beb gb ihqm\kl\h\ZeihaZ^b k_[yDZd lhevdh lu
^hklb]g_rv jh\gh]hf_klZdZd [ulu gb[ue bkim]Zgij_djZlb
[_`ZlviZ^Zc gZa_fexkgbfZc k\hxdmjldmih^[_jb __ d
`b\hlmb kdjmlbkvdZd fyqih^h]gm\ dhe_gbd `b\hlmLu
^he`_g lZd`_aZdjulv ]eZaZjmdZfbZ jmdbiehlgh ijb`Zlv d
[_^jZfLu ^he`_ghklZ\Zlvky \wlhf iheh`_gbb^h mljZ?keb
lu ihke_^m_rv wlbf ijhkluf f_jZfk lh[hc g_ kemqblky
gbdZdh]h \j_^Z
< kemqZ__keb lug_ kfh`_rv^hklbqv jh\gh]h f_klZ
\h\j_fyiZ^Zc gZa_fex ijyfhlZf]^_ gZoh^brvkyM l_[y
[m^_l m`Zkgh_ \j_fylZfL_[y [m^mlba\h^blvgh_keb lu
khojZgbrv kihdhckl\b_b g_[m^_rv ^\b]Zlvkybeb kfhlj_lvlu
\uc^_rv bawlh]h [_a_^bghc pZjZibgu
L_i_jv_keb l\hyjmdZ g_ihemqbl l_ieZkh\k_fdh]^Z
lu ijh\h^brv__ daZiZ^mkgh\Z ih\_jgbkvebphf d\hklhdm b
[_]b \ \hklhqghf gZijZ\e_gbb ^h l_o ihjihdZ o\Zlbl
^uoZgbyHklZgh\bkv lZfb ih\lhjbl_ `_^\b`_gbyLu ^he`_g
ijh^he`Zlv [_`Zlv d\hklhdmih\lhjyc wlb^\b`_gby ^h l_o
ihjihdZ l\hyjmdZ g_ihemqbe l_ieh
>Z\ fg_wlb bgkljmdpbbhg aZklZ\beih\lhjylv f_gy bo
^h l_oihjihdZ yg_ aZmqbebo gZbamklvAZl_f fukb^_eb \
fheqZgbb ^he]h_\j_fyY ihiulZeky\hah[gh\blv jZa]h\hjiZjm
jZagh hgdZ`^uc jZaaZklZ\eye f_gyfheqZlv ih\_ebl_evguf
`_klhf
KlZeh l_fghdh]^Z ^hgOmZg \klZeb gZqZe\a[bjZlvky gZ
ohefY ihke_^h\ZeaZ gbfGZ \_jrbg_ohefZ ybkihegbe \k_
^\b`_gbydhlhju_ hghibkZe>hg OmZgklhye g_^Ze_dhhl f_gy
b khojZgye gZfg_ hkljuc\a]ey^Y [uehq_gv klZjZl_e_g b
mfure_ggh f_^ebl_e_gY iulZeky ihqm\kl\h\Zlv dZdh_eb[h
hsmsZ_fh_ baf_g_gb_ l_fi_jZlmjugh yg_ fh] h[gZjm`blv
qlh[u eZ^hgvfh_c jmdbklZeZ l_iehcD wlhfm\j_f_gb klZeh
kh\_jr_ggh l_fghh^gZdhy \k_`_ fh][_`Zlv \ \hklhqghf
gZijZ\e_gbbg_ gZludZykvgZ dmkluY hklZgh\bekydh]^Z
aZiuoZekyb [ueg_ kebrdhf^Ze_dh hlfh_c lhqdbhlijZ\e_gby
Y qm\kl\h\Ze qj_a\uqZcgmx mklZehklv
b gZijy`_gb_Fhb
ij_^ie_qvy bbdju [he_eb
Y ih\lhjbelZf \k_lj_[m_fu_ ^\b`_gbyb kgh\Z ihemqbe
lhl `_ hljbpZl_evgucj_amevlZlY [_]Ze\ l_fghl__s_ ^\Z
jZaZb aZl_fdh]^Z yijh\h^be k\h_cjmdhc \lj_lbc jZa
jmdZ klZeZ l_iehc gZ^lhqdhc d\hklhdmWlh [ueh lZdh_
hij_^_e_ggh_ baf_g_gb_l_fi_jZlmjuqlh ybkim]ZekyY k_eb
^h`^Zeky ^hgZOmZgZY kdZaZe_fmqlh h[gZjm`be baf_g_gb_
l_fi_jZlmju \ fh_c jmd_Hg \_e_efg_ ijh^he`Zlvb y
ih^h[jZe \k_kmob_ \_ldbdZdb_ fh]gZclbb jZa`_] h]hgv
Hg k_e\ iZj_nmlh\ hlf_gyke_\Z
IeZfy jbkh\Zehg_h[uqgu_ lZgpmxsb_kbemwlu<j_f_gZfb
ieZfy klZgh\behkvjZ^m`gufhgh \ujZklZehdjZkgufZ aZl_f
klZgh\behkv k\_jdZxs_[_eufY h[tykgyewlm g_h[uqgmx b]jm
p\_lh\ l_fqlh wlhijhba\h^behkv dZdbfblh obfbq_kdbfb
k\hckl\Zfb hkh[uokmobo \_l\_cb \_lhq_ddhlhju_ ykh[jZe
>jm]hc hq_gvg_h[uqghc hkh[_gghklvxh]gy [uebbkdjuGh\u_
\_ldbdhlhju_ yijh^he`Ze ^h[Z\eylvkha^Z\Zeb qj_a\uqZcgh
[hevrb_ bkdjuY ih^mfZeqlh hgb[ueb ih^h[gu l_ggbkguf
fyqZfdhlhju_dZaZehkv\aju\Zebkv \ukhdh\ \ha^mo_
Y ijbklZevghb khkj_^hlhq_gghkfhlj_e gZh]hgvlZdbf
kihkh[hfdZdbfdZd yiheZ]Ze^hg OmZg kh\_lh\Ze fg_
kfhlj_lvb mf_gy aZdjm`beZkv]heh\ZHg \jmqbefg_ k\hx
[mluev ba lud\u k \h^hc
b ihdZaZe fg_ \uiblv<h^Z
jZkkeZ[beZ f_gy b
ijb^ZeZ
fg_ \hkoblbl_evgh_ qm\kl\h
[h^jhklb
>hg OmZggZdehgbeky \i_j_^b ijhr_ilZefg_ gZmohqlh
y g_^he`_g ijbklZevghkfhlj_lv gZieZfyZ lhevdhgZ[ex^Zlv
\ gZijZ\e_gbb h]gyFg_ klZehhq_gv oheh^ghb kujh ihke_
lh]hdZd ygZ[ex^Ze ihqlbqZk< fhf_gldh]^Z ykh[bjZeky
gZdehgblvky bih^h[jZlv \_ldbqlhlhih^h[gh_ fhluevdmbeb
iylgurdm \ fh_c k_lqZld_ijhg_kehkv i_j_^h fghc kijZ\Z
gZe_\h f_`^m fghc b h]g_fY g_f_^e_ggh hlrZlgmekyY
\a]eygme gZ ^hgZOmZgZb hgihdZaZe fg_^\b`_gb_f k\h_]h
ih^[hjh^dZ hiylvkfhlj_lv gZieZfyFhf_gl kimklylZ `_l_gv
ijhg_keZkv \ijhlb\hiheh`ghf gZijZ\e_gbb
>hg OmZg ihki_rgh\klZe bgZqZe gZdeZ^u\Zlvfmkhj gZ
\_jrbgm ]hjysbo\_lhdihdZ kh\_jr_gghg_ ih]ZkbeieZfyHg
\uihegbe lmr_gb_dhkljZ k]jhfZ^ghc kdhjhklvxDh \j_f_gb
dh]^Z y ^\bgmekyqlh[u ihfhqv_fmhg m`_ dhgqbeHg
gZ[jhkZe ]jyavgZ \_jole_xsbo \_lhdZ aZl_fihlZsbe f_gy
\gba d \uoh^m ba ^hebguFu reb hq_gv [ukljhHg g_
h[hjZqb\Zeky bg_ iha\heyefg_ aZ]h\hjblv\h\k_
Dh]^Z fu ^h[jZebkv ^h fh_cfZrbgu qZku kimklyy
kijhkbe _]hqlh wlh[ueZ aZ\_svdhlhjmx y \b^_eHg
ih\_ebl_evgh ihljyk]heh\hcb fuih_oZeb \iheghf fheqZgbb
Dh]^Z fu ih^t_oZeb d_]h ^hfmjZgh mljhfhg ihr_e
ijyfh \gmljvb kgh\Zg_ iha\hebefg_ ]h\hjblv
>hg OmZgkb^_e kgZjm`b\hae_ k\h_]h^hfZHgdZaZehkv
`^Zedh]^Z yijhkgmkvihlhfm qlhhg aZ]h\hjbedZd lhevdh
y \ur_e ba ^hfZHg kdZaZeqlh l_gvdhlhjmx y \b^_e
ij_^u^ms_c ghqvx[ue ^mokbeu dhlhjh]hijbgZ^e_`bl hkh[hfm
f_klm]^_ y\b^_e _]hHg kdZaZeqlh wlhhkh[h_ kms_kl\h
[_kihe_agh
Hgh lhevdh`b\_l lZfkdZaZe hghgh g_ bf__l
k_dj_lh\ kbeuihwlhfm g_[ueh kfukeZhklZ\Zlvky lZfLu
\b^_e lhevdh [ukljh f_evdgm\rmxl_gvijhoh^ysmx \aZ^ b
\i_j_^ \kxghqvH^gZdh_klv ^jm]b_\b^u kms_kl\dhlhju_
fh]ml ^Zlvl_[_ k_dj_lukbeu_keb l_[_ihkqZkleb\blky gZclb
bo
AZl_f fukt_eb mlj_ggbcaZ\ljZd bkh\k_f g_ ]h\hjbeb
Ihke_ _^ufu k_ebi_j_^ _]h^hfhf
?klv ljb\b^Z kms_kl\kdZaZe hg\g_aZighl_
dhlhju_ g_ fh]ml ^Zlv gbq_]hihlhfm qlh hgb g_ bf_xl
gbq_]hqlh [u hgbfh]eb ^Zlvl_dhlhju_ fh]ml lhevdh
\uau\Zlv kljZob l_dhlhju_ bf_xlkihkh[ghklbLhqlh lu
\b^_e ijhrehc ghqvx[ueh fheqZeb\hhgh g_ fh`_l gbq_]h
^Zlvwlh lhevdhl_gv;hevrmx qZklv\j_f_gbh^gZdh^jm]hc
lbi
kms_kl\
k\yau\Z_lky
k
fheqZeb\uf
kms_kl\hf
hl\jZlbl_evguc ^moqv_ _^bgkl\_ggh_dZq_kl\h \uau\Zlv
kljZo bdhlhjuc \k_]^Z[helZ_lky \hdjm]`bebsZ fheqZeb\h]h
kms_kl\Z<hl ihq_fm yj_rbe [uklj__ mclb hllm^ZWlhl
aeh[guc lbi ij_ke_^m_l ex^_cijyfh \bo ^hfZob ^_eZ_l
`bagv g_\hafh`ghc ^ey gboY agZx ex^_cdhlhju_ [ueb
\ugm`^_gu kt_a`Zlvkh k\hbof_kl baaZ gboGh \k_]^Z _klv
ex^bdhlhju_ \_jylqlh hgbfh]ml fgh]h_ihemqblv hllZdh]h
kms_kl\Zb ijhklhcnZdlqlh ^moijbkmlkl\m_l hdheh ^hfZ
g_ bf__l gbdZdh]hagZq_gbyEx^b iulZxlkykh[eZagblv _]h
beb hgbfh]ml ke_^h\ZlvaZ gbf\hdjm] ^hfZih^ \i_qZle_gb_f
qlh hgfh`_l hldjulvlZcgu bfGh _^bgkl\_ggZy\_svdhlhjmx
ihemqZxl ex^bwlh im]Zxs__i_j_`b\Zgb_Y agZx ex^_c
dhlhju_ ihhq_j_^ghgZ[ex^Zeb h^gh]hba wlbo hl\jZlbl_evguo
kms_kl\dhlhju_ ij_ke_^h\Zebbo \bo ^hf_Hgb gZ[ex^ZebaZ
^mohf f_kypZfb\ dhgp_dhgph\ dlhgb[m^v ^jm]hc^he`_g [ue
\f_rZlvky b \ulZkdb\Zlvex^_c babo ^hfZhgb klZgh\bebkv
keZ[ufb bbklhs_ggufbIhwlhfm_^bgkl\_ggZy [eZ]hjZamfgZy
\_svdhlhjmx fh`ghk^_eZlv ihhlghr_gbx dwlhfm aeh[ghfm
lbimaZ[ulv hg_f bhklZ\blv _]hh^gh]h
Y kijhkbe_]hdZd ex^bkh[eZagyxl ^moZHg kdZaZeqlh
ex^b klZjZxlkyjZa]Z^Zlv kgZqZeZ]^_ ^mogZb[he__ \_jhylgh
ihy\blkyZ aZl_fhgb deZ^mlhjm`b_ gZ_]h imlb\ gZ^_`^_
qlh hg fh`_l dhkgmlvky hjm`byihlhfm qlh ^mob ex[beb
ijbgZ^e_`ghklb \hcgu>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh ex[h_ kms_kl\h
beb ex[hc ij_^f_ldhlhjh]h
dhkgmeky
^moih ijZ\m
klZgh\blky ij_^f_lhfkbeuH^gZdhaeh[gh_ kms_kl\hgbdh]^Z
gbq_]h g_ dZkZehkvZ lhevdhijhba\h^beh kemoh\mx beexabx
rmfZ
AZl_f ykijhkbe ^hgZOmZgZ hkihkh[_dhlhjuf wlb^mob
\uau\Zxl kljZoHg kdZaZeqlh bogZb[he__ ijhklufkihkh[hf
im]Zlv ex^_c[ueh ihdZau\Zlvkyl_fghc l_gvx\ \b^_q_eh\_dZ
dhlhjuc [jh^bl \hdjm] ^hfZijhba\h^y im]Zxsbc klmd beb
a\mdb ]hehkh\beb l_fghcl_gvxdhlhjZy g_h`b^ZgghrZlZykv
\uoh^bl bal_fgh]h m]eZ
>hg OmZg kdZaZeqlh lj_lbclbi ^moZ [ue gZklhysbf
heebdhlhjuc hldju\Z_l lZcguwlhl hkh[uc lbi `b\_l \
m_^bg_gbb\ aZ[jhr_gguof_klZo\ f_klZodhlhju_ ihqlb
g_^hklmiguHg kdZaZeqlh q_eh\_ddhlhjuc ohq_l gZclb
h^gh]h bawlbo kms_kl\^he`_g iml_r_kl\h\Zlv^Ze_dh bb^lb
d g_fmkZf< hl^Ze_gghfb m_^bg_gghff_kl_ q_eh\_d ^he`_g
ij_^ijbgbfZlv \k_g_h[oh^bfu_ f_juh^bgHg ^he`_gkb^_lv m
k\h_]h dhkljZb_keb m\b^bll_gvhg ^he`_g g_f_^e_ggh
mclbH^gZdhhg ^he`_g
hklZlvky_keb hg g_h`b^Zggh
\klj_lbeky k^jm]bfb mkeh\byfblZdbfbdZd kbevguc \_l_j
dhlhjuc ]Zkbl_]h dhkl_jb g_^Z_l _fm\hafh`ghklb jZa`_qv
_]h kgh\Z\ l_q_gb_q_luj_o ihiulhdbeb _kebgZ [eb`Zcr_f
^_j_\_ kehfZ_lky\_ldZ<_ldZ ^he`gZ^_ckl\bl_evgh kehfZlvky
b q_eh\_d ^he`_g [ulv m\_j_gqlh wlh g_ ijhklh a\md
ehfZxs_cky \_ldb
>jm]bfb mkeh\byfb [uehlhqlh hg^he`_g khagZ\Zlv h
ihdZlb\rboky dZfgyobeb h[meu`gbdZodhlhju_ [jhr_gu\ _]h
h]hgvbeb hdZdhfgb[m^v ihklhygghfrmf_b lh]^Zhg ^he`_g
b^lb \ gZijZ\e_gbb\ dhlhjhfijhbahr_e ex[hc ba wlbo
n_ghf_gh\ihdZ ^mog_ ihdZ`_lkykZf
;ueh fgh]hkihkh[h\dhlhjufb lZdh_kms_kl\h ih^\_j]Z_l
\hbgZ bkiulZgbxHgh fh]eh\g_aZigh \uiju]gmlvi_j_^ gbf \
hq_gv m]jh`Zxs_f\b^_beb hghfh]eh ko\Zlblvq_eh\_dZ kaZ^b
bg_ ^Z\Zy_fm ih\_jgmlvky^_j`Zlv _]hk\yaZgguf qZkZfb
Hgh fh]ehlZd`_ k\Zeblv^_j_\h gZg_]h>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh
wlh [ueb ^_ckl\bl_evghhiZkgu_ kbeubohly hgbg_ fh]eb
m[blv q_eh\_dZebqghhgb fh]eb\ua\Zlv _]hkf_jlvgZim]Z\
_]hbeb ^_ckl\bl_evghiha\heb\ ij_^f_lZfmiZklv gZ g_]h
bebihy\b\rbkv g_h`b^Zggh b aZklZ\b\ _]h kihldgmlvky
khj\Zlvky kh[ju\Z
Hg kdZaZefg_qlh_keb ygZc^m h^gh]hba wlbokms_kl\
ijb g_ih^oh^ysbo h[klhyl_evkl\Zoy
gbdh]^Z g_ ^he`_g
iulZlvky [hjhlvky k gbfihlhfm qlhhg m[v_l f_gyHg
hlgbf_l fhx ^mrmIhwlhfm y^he`_g [jhkblvkygZ a_fex b
l_ji_lv _]h^h mljZ
Dh]^Z q_eh\_dklZedb\Z_lky kheeb^Zjbl_e_f lZcghg
^he`_g kh[jZlv\k_ k\h_fm`_kl\h bko\Zlblv _]hij_`^_ q_f
lhl ko\Zlbl_]hbeb ij_ke_^h\Zlv_]hij_`^_ q_flhl gZqg_l
ij_ke_^h\Zlv _]hIj_ke_^h\Zgb_ ^he`gh[ulv g_hlklmigufb
lh]^Z ijhbkoh^bl[hjv[ZQ_eh\_d ^he`_gijb`Zlv ^moZd a_fe_
b ^_j`Zlv_]h ^hl_o ihjihdZ lhlg_ ^Zkl_fm kbem
Y kijhkbe _]h[ueb ebwlb kbeufZl_jbZevgu_keb bo
fh`gh [ueh^_ckl\bl_evgh dhkgmlvkyHg kdZaZeqlh kZfZb^_y
h ^mo_hagZqZeZ qlhlh wn_f_jgh_^ey f_gy
G_ gZau\Zcbo ^moZfbkdZaZe hggZau\Zc boheeb
gZau\Zc bog_h[tykgbfufb kbeZfb
Hg fheqZeg_dhlhjh_ \j_fyaZl_f e_]gZ kibgmb ih^i_j
]heh\m keh`_ggufb jmdZfbY gZklZb\Ze b `_eZe magZlv
fZl_jbZevgu ebwlb kms_kl\Z
;m^v lu ijhdeylhgb fZl_jbZevgukdZaZe hg
ihfheqZ\ g_fgh]hDh]^Z dlhgb[m^v [hj_lkyk gbfbhgb
l\_j^u_gh wlhqm\kl\h ^eblkylhevdh fhf_glWlb kms_kl\Z
iheZ]Zxlky gZ q_eh\_q_kdbc kljZoihwlhfm_keb q_eh\_d
[hj_lky k h^gbf bagbodZd \hbgkms_kl\h l_jy_l k\h_
gZijy`_gb_ hq_gv[ukljh\ lh\j_fydZd q_eh\_dklZgh\blky
[he__ kbevgufFh`gh ^_ckl\bl_evghih]ehlblv kbem^moZ
DZdhc wlh\b^ gZijy`_gby"kijhkbe y
KbeZDh]^Z dZkZ_rvkybohgb \b[jbjmxldZd [m^lh
hgb ]hlh\u jZahj\Zlv gZqZklbGh wlh lhevdh \b^bfhklv
GZijy`_gb_ dhgqZ_lkydh]^Z q_eh\_dm^_j`b\Z_l k\hxo\Zldm
Qlh ijhbkoh^bldh]^Z hgbl_jyxl k\h_ gZijy`_gb_"
KlZgh\ylky ebhgb ih^h[gu\ha^mom"
G_lhgb ijhklhklZgh\ylky [_kkbevgufbHgbl_f g_
f_g__bf_xl fZl_jbZevghklvh^gZdhGh hgZg_ ihoh`Zgb gZ
qlhq_]h dZ`^ucdh]^Zeb[h dZkZeky
Iha`_\_q_jhfy kdZaZe_fmqlh\hafh`ghlhqlh y
\b^_e ij_^u^ms_c ghqvxfh]
[ulv
lhevdh fhlue_dHg
aZkf_yeky b hq_gvl_ji_eb\h h[tykgbeqlh fhluevdb e_lZxl
\aZ^ b\i_j_^ lhevdh\hdjm] we_dljbq_kdboeZfiihlhfm qlh
eZfiZ g_ k`b]Z_lbo djuev_\IeZfygZijhlb\k`b]Z_l bo
kjZam `_dZd lhevdhhgb ih^e_lZxl[ebadh dg_fmHg lZd`_
mdZaZeqlh l_gvaZdju\ZeZ \_kvh]hgvDh]^Z hgmihfygme h[
wlhfy \kihfgbeqlh wlh[ueZ ^_ckl\bl_evghhq_gv [hevrZy
l_gv b qlhhgZ ^_ckl\bl_evghaZdjueZ h]hgv gZ f]gh\_gb_
H^gZdhwlh ijhbahrehlZd [ukljhqlh yg_ ijb^Ze hkh[h]h
agZq_gby wlhfm\kihfbgZy h[wlhf jZgvr_
AZl_f hgmdZaZeqlh bkdju[ueb hq_gv[hevrb_ be_l_eb
ke_\ZY bkZf wlhaZf_lbeY kdZaZeqlh\hafh`gh\_l_j
^me \wlhf gZijZ\e_gbb>hg OmZghl\_lbeqlh lZfkh\k_f g_
[ueh \_ljZWlh [ueh\_jgh<kihfbgZy fh_i_j_`b\Zgb_y fh]
\kihfgblvqlh ghqv[ueZ [_a\_lj_gghc
>jm]hc \_svxdhlhjmx ykh\_jr_ggh g_ aZf_lbe[ue
a_e_gh\Zluc p\_l ieZf_gbdhlhjuc yh[gZjm`bedh]^Z ^hg
OmZg ihdZaZefg_ khojZgylv\a]ey^ gZh]g_ihke_ lh]hdZd
l_gv i_j\uc jZa i_j_k_deZ ihe_fh_]h aj_gby>hg OmZg
gZihfgbe fg_h[ wlhfHg lZd`_\hajZ`Ze ijhlb\lh]hqlh[u y
gZau\Ze wlh l_gvx ijbajZdhfHg kdZaZeqlh hgZ [ueZ
djm]ehc b[he__ ihoh^beZgZ imaujv
>\Z ^gy kimkly^_dZ[jy ]h^Z^hg OmZg hq_gv
g_[j_`guf lhghf kdZaZeqlh y agZe \k_ ih^jh[ghklb b
g_h[oh^bfmx l_ogbdm^ey lh]hqlh[u ihclb\ ohefukZfhfm b
ihemqblv ij_^f_l kbeueh\bl_ev ^moh\Hg ih[m`^Ze f_gy
hlijZ\blvky h^ghfmb ml\_j`^Zeqlh _]hh[s_kl\h lhevdh [u
ihf_rZeh fg_
Y [ue]hlh\ hlijZ\blvkydh]^Z hgdZaZehkvi_j_^mfZe
Lu g_^hklZlhqghkbe_gkdZaZe hgY ihc^mk lh[hc
d ih^gh`vxohefh\
Dh]^Z fu[ueb \g_[hevrhc ^hebg_]^_ y\b^_e heebhg
bamqbe k jZkklhygby f_klghklvdhlhjmx ygZa\Ze ^ujhc \
ohefZob kdZaZeqlh fu^he`gu b^lb_s_ ^Zevr_gZ x] d
^Zevgbf ]hjZf@bebs_ heeb [ueh kZfhc ^Zevg_c lhqdhc
dhlhjmx fufh]eb \b^_lvq_j_a ^ujm
Y ihkfhlj_e gZ jZkiheh`_gb_b
\k_qlh y fh]
jZaebqblvwlh ]hem[h\ZlmxfZkkm ^Zevgbo]hjHg ih\_ef_gy
h^gZdh\ x]h\hklhqghf gZijZ\e_gbbb q_j_ag_kdhevdh qZkh\
oh^v[u fu ^hklb]eb lhqdbdhlhjZydZd hg kdZaZe[ueZ
^hklZlhqgh ]em[hdhc\ f_klhij_[u\Zgbbheeb
Fu hklZgh\bebkviha^gh ihke_ihem^gyFu k_ebgZ dZfgb
Y mklZe b[ue ]heh^_g\k_qlh y_e \l_q_gb_ ^gy[ueh
g_kdhevdh e_i_r_d b \h^Z>hg OmZg kh\_jr_ggh \g_aZigh
\klZeihkfhlj_e gZg_[h b\_e_e fg_ ih\_ebl_evguf lhghf
\u[jZlv gZijZ\e_gb_dhlhjh_ [ueh
emqrbf
^ey f_gy b
m[_^blvkyqlh yfh] \kihfgblvlhqdm]^_ fu[ueb \ wlhl
fhf_glqlh[u y fh]\_jgmlvky lm^Zdh]^Z y aZdhgqmHg
kdZaZe \gh\v m\_j_gghqlh hg[m^_l `^Zlvf_gy^Z`_ _keb
wlh aZcf_l\k_ fh_\j_fy
Y kijhkbe hq_gv lj_\h`gh\_jbe ebhgqlh ^_eh ih
^h[uq_ eh\bl_ey^moh\ fh]eh[u hlgylvfgh]h \j_f_gb
Dlh agZ_l"kdZaZe hglZbgkl\_ggh meu[gm\rbkv
Y ihr_e d x]h\hklhdmh[_jgm\rbkv iZjm jZaqlh[u
ihkfhlj_lv gZ ^hgZ OmZgZHg
hq_gv
f_^e_ggh r_e \
ijhlb\hiheh`ghf gZijZ\e_gbbY \ah[jZekygZ \_jrbgm[hevrh]h
ohefZ b ihkfhlj_egZ ^hgZOmZgZ _s_jZahg [ue \ ^h[juo
^\moklZo yj^Zohl f_gyHg g_h[hjZqb\Zeky bg_ kfhlj_e gZ
f_gyY k[_`Zed ih^gh`vx\ g_[hevrmxqZr_h[jZagmx \iZ^bgm
f_`^m ohefZfb b\g_aZigh h[gZjm`bek_[y h^gh]hY k_e gZ
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fyb gZqZem^b\eylvky lhfmqlh y^_eZe a^_kv
Y ihqm\kl\h\Ze g_e_ihklvihbkdZ eh\bl_ey^moh\Y \a[_`Ze
gZaZ^ gZ\_jrbgm ohefZqlh[u ihemqr_jZa]ey^_lv ^hgZOmZgZ
gh y g_ fh]m\b^_lv _]hgb]^_Y ih[_`Ze d ih^gh`vx\
gZijZ\e_gbb]^_ y ihke_^gbc jZa
\b^_e _]hY ohl_e
ij_djZlblv \k_ ^_eh b m_oZlv^hfhcY qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
kh\_jr_ggh hp_i_g_\rbfb mklZ\rbf
>hg OmZgdjbqZe ykgh\Z bkgh\Z
?]h gb]^_ g_[ueh \b^ghY kgh\Z\a[_`Ze gZ \_jrbgm
^jm]h]h \ukhdh]h ohefZy g_m\b^_e _]hb hllm^ZlZd`_Y
[_]Ze \_a^_\ukfZljb\Zy _]hgh hgbkq_aY \_jgmeky b
ijbr_e gZaZ^d i_j\hgZqZevghfmf_klm]^_ hghklZ\be f_gyM
f_gy [ueZg_e_iZy m\_j_gghklvqlh ygZc^m _]hkb^ysbf lZfb
kf_xsbfky gZ^fh_c g_ihke_^h\Zl_evghklvx
< dZdhcZ^ yihiZe"
Y agZe lh]^Zqlh g_[ueh kihkh[ZhklZgh\blv \k_ lh
qlh y ^_eZelZfY ^_ckl\bl_evghg_ agZedZd \_jgmlvky d
fh_c fZrbg_>hg OmZgfgh]h jZa baf_gye gZijZ\e_gb_Z
hkgh\ghc hjb_glZpbb gZq_luj_ lhqdb[ueh g_^hklZlhqghY
bkim]Zekyqlh aZ[em`mkv\ ]hjZoY k_eb \i_j\uc jZa \
k\h_c `bagby bf_eg_h[uqgh_ qm\kl\hqlh ^_ckl\bl_evgh g_
[ueh imlb\_jgmlvky dbkoh^ghc lhqd_hlijZ\e_gby>hg OmZg
]h\hjbeqlh y\k_]^Z gZklZb\ZegZ hlijZ\ghclhqd_dhlhjmx
y gZau\Ze gZqZehflh]^Z dZd\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbgZqZeZ g_
kms_kl\m_lB lZfkj_^b wlbo]hjy ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh y
ihgye lhqlh hg bf_e\ \b^mWlh [ueh lZddZd [m^lh
bkoh^gZy lhqdZ\k_]^Z [ueZfghc kZfbfdZd [m^lh^hgZ OmZgZ
gbdh]^Z \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb g_
[ueh
lZfb dh]^Z y
\ukfZljb\Ze _]hhg klZel_fq_f hg\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb[ue
fZe_gvdbf h[jZahfdhlhjuc bkq_aaZ ohefhf
Y mkeurZe lbobc r_e_klebklv_\b g_h[uqguc ZjhfZl
hdjm`be f_gyY ihqm\kl\h\Ze\_l_j ^Z\e_gb_fgZ fhb ]eZaZ
ih^h[gh hklhjh`ghfm`m``ZgbxKhegp_ kh[bjZehkvkdjulvky aZ
iehlgufb lmqZfb gZ^]hjbahglhfdhlhju_ \u]ey^_eb ih^h[gh
]mklh hdjZr_gghc hjZg`_\hc klZ_dh]^Z hgh bkq_aZeh aZ
ly`_euf ihdjh\hf gbadbolmqfhf_gl kimkly hgh ihy\behkv
kgh\ZdZd l_fghdjZkguc rZjieu\msbc \ ^ufd_Hgh
dZaZehkv[hjhehkv g_dhlhjh_\j_fyqlh[u \hclb \ dehqhd
]hem[h]h g_[Zgh lmqbdZd [m^lhg_ ^Z\Zebkhegpm \j_f_gbZ
aZl_f hjZg`_\Zy klZy b
l_fgu_ kbemwlu ]hjdZaZehkv
ih]ehlbeb _]h
Y e_] gZkibgmFbj \hdjm]f_gy [uelZdbf kihdhcguf
lZdbf [_afyl_`gufgh\ lh`_ kZfh_\j_fylZdbf qm`^uf
qlh yihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[yih^Z\e_ggufY g_ohl_e ieZdZlvgh
ke_au ihdZlbebkvkZfb
Y hklZ\Zeky \wlhf iheh`_gbbg_kdhevdh qZkh\Y [ue
ihqlb g_kihkh[_g \klZlvDZfgb ih^hfghc [uebl\_j^ufbb
ijyfh lZf]^_ y e_`Ze[ueZ j_^dZy jZklbl_evghklv\
dhgljZkl k khqgufba_e_gufb dmklZfb\_a^_ \hdjm]Hllm^Z
]^_ y [uey fh]\b^_lv \_jomrdb \ukhdbo ^_j_\v_\ gZ
\hklhqguo ohefZo
GZdhg_pklZeh kh\_jr_gghl_fghY ihqm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
emqr_\
^_ckl\bl_evghklby
qm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y ihqlb
kqZkleb\uf>ey
f_gy
ihemlvfZ
[ueZ
gZfgh]h
[he__
ihmqbl_evghc baZsbsZxs_cq_f [_a`Zehklguc^g_\ghc k\_l
Y \klZe\e_a gZ\_jrbgm g_[hevrh]h ohefZ b gZqZe
ih\lhjylv ^\b`_gbydhlhjuf ^hgOmZg gZmqbef_gyY ijh[_]Ze
d \hklhdm k_fv jZab lhevdhlh]^Z y aZf_lbe baf_g_gb_
l_fi_jZlmju \fh_c jmd_Y jZa\_eh]hgv bklZe \gbfZl_evgh
gZ[ex^ZlvdZd kh\_lh\Ze ^hg OmZgjZkkfZljb\Zy dZ`^mx
^_lZevIjhreb qZkub ygZqZe qm\kl\h\Zlv k_[y hq_gv
mklZ\rbf b aZf_jarbfY kh[jZep_emx dmqmkmobo \_lhdy
ih^^_j`b\Ze h]hgvb ih^\bgmekyd g_fm[eb`_;h^jkl\h\Zgb_
[ueh lZdbf mk_j^gufb lZdbfgZijy`_ggufqlh hgh bagmjbeh
f_gyb ygZqZe de_\ZlvghkhfY ^\Z`^uaZkuiZe bijhkuiZeky
lhevdh lh]^Zdh]^Z fhy]heh\Z dZqZeZkv\ klhjhgmY [ue
lZdhf khggufqlh g_fh] [hevr_gZ[ex^Zlv aZh]g_fY ihibe
\h^u b ^Z`_ ih[jua]Ze _xgZ ebphqlh[u g_ kiZlvFg_
m^Zehkv ih[hjhlvfhx khgeb\hklvlhevdh gZdhjhldh_ \j_fyY
klZe dZdbflh mgueuf bjZa^jZ`_ggufy qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y
djZcg_ [_kihfhsguf kms_kl\hf lZfb wlh \ua\Zeh \h fg_
hsms_gb_ bjjZpbhgZevgh]h jZkljhckl\Z
b
mgugbyY [ue
mklZeuf]heh^gufkhgguf bg_e_ih jZa^jZ`_ggufkZfbf kh[hc
GZdhg_py hldZaZeky[hjhlvky khkghfY ^h[Z\be ih[hevr_
kmobo \_lhd\ dhkl_jb e_]kiZlvIh]hgy aZheeb beh\bl_e_f
^moh\ [ueZ \ wlhl
fhf_gl
gZb[he__ g_e_iuf b qm`^uf
klj_fe_gb_fY [uelZdbf khggufqlh g_fh] ^Z`_^mfZlv beb
jZa]h\Zjb\Zlv kkh[hcY aZkgme
<g_aZigh y[ue jZa[m`_g]jhfdbf lj_kdhfDZaZehkvqlh
rmfq_f [uhg gb[uejZa^Zeky dZdjZa gZ^fhbf e_\ufmohf
lZd dZd y e_`Ze gZ
ijZ\hf
[hdmY k_ekh\_jr_ggh
ijhkgm\rbkvFh_ e_\h_moh ]m^_ehb [uehh]emr_gh [ebahklvx
b kbehca\mdZ
Y^he`gh [ulvkiZe lhevdhdhjhldh_ \j_fykm^y ih
dhebq_kl\m kmobo\_lhddhlhju_ \k__s_ ]hj_eb\ dhklj_Y
g_ keurZegbdZdbo ^jm]bormfh\gh hklZ\ZekygZklhjh`_gguf b
ih^^_j`b\Ze h]hgv
< fh_f mf_ ijhf_evdgmeZfukevqlh\hafh`ghf_gy
jZa[m^be ^Zevgbc\uklj_e\hafh`ghdlhlh jy^hfke_^be aZ
fghc b\uklj_ebe \f_gyWlZ fukevklZeZ hq_gvfmqbl_evghc b
\ua\ZeZ ihlhd jZpbhgZevguo kljZoh\Y [ue m\_j_gqlh
dZdb_lh ex^b\eZ^_eb wlhca_fe_cb_keb wlh[ueh lZdhgb
fh]eb ijbgylvf_gy aZ\hjZ bm[blv f_gybeb hgbfh]eb m[blv
f_gyqlh[u h]jZ[blvg_ agZyqlh mf_gy g_l gbq_]hY
i_j_`b\Ze fhf_glm`Zkgh]h [_kihdhckl\ZaZ k\hx[_ahiZkghklv
Y ihqm\kl\h\ZegZijy`_gb_ \k\hbo ie_qZob r__Y ih^\b]Ze
]heh\hc \\_job \gbadhklb fh_cr_b ijhba\h^beblj_kdZxsbc
a\mdY \k_ _s_ kfhlj_e \h]hgvgh g_ \b^_e gbq_]h
g_h[uqgh]h \g_f bg_ keurZe[hevr_ gbdZdbormfh\
Ihke_ lh]hdZd yg_fgh]h jZkkeZ[bekyfg_ ijbreh gZ
mfqlh\hafh`ghijbqbghc \k_]h[ue ^hgOmZgY [ukljh
klZe m[_`^_gqlh wlhlZd b[uehWlZ fukevaZklZ\beZ f_gy
jZkkf_ylvkyM f_gy\hagbd gh\ucihlhd jZpbhgZevguo fuke_c
aZdexq_gbcgZ wlhljZa \_k_euoY ih^mfZeqlh ^hg OmZg
^he`gh [ulv ih^haj_\Zeqlh yfh] i_j_^mfZlv hlghkbl_evgh
lh]hqlh[u hklZlvky\ ]hjZobeb hg^he`gh [ulv\b^_e
qlh y[_]Ze ke_^hfaZ gbfb kijylZeky\ kdjulhci_s_j_ beb
aZ dmklhfAZl_f hgihke_^h\Ze aZfghc baZf_lb\qlh y
aZkgmejZa[m^be f_gy lj_kdhf\_ldb hdheh fh_]h moZY
^h[Z\be _s_\_lhd \h]hgv bgZqZe hkfZljb\Zlvky\hdjm] dZd
[u kemqZcgh b g_aZf_lghqlh[u m\b^_lvg_ fh]m eb y
aZf_lblv _]h^Z`_ ohlyy agZeqlh_keb hg kdju\Zeky
ih[ebahklby g_kfh] [uh[gZjm`blv _]h
<k_
[ueh
kh\_jr_ggh
kihdhcghk\_jqdb\_l_j
h[t_a`Zxsbc ^_j_\vy gZ kdehgZoohefh\hdjm`Zxsbo f_gy
lbobcihlj_kdb\Zxsbc a\md\_lhdho\Zq_gguo h]g_fBkdju
e_l_eb \hdjm]gh wlh[ueb lhevdhh[uqgu_ bkdju
<g_aZigh y mkeurZe ]jhfdbcrmf hl \_ldbkehfZgghc
ihiheZfA\md bkoh^beke_\Z hlf_gyY aZlZbe^uoZgb_lZd
dZd y kemrZe kij_^_evguf \gbfZgb_fF]gh\_gb_ kimkly y
mkeurZe lj_kd^jm]hc \_ldbkijZ\Z hlf_gy
AZl_f ymkeurZe keZ[uchl^Ze_gguc a\mdehfZ_fuo \_lhd
dZd [m^lh dlhlh rZ]Ze ihgbf b ehfZe boA\mdb [ueb
h[bevgu_ bihegu_hgb [uebhlq_leb\u_Hgb lZd`_dZaZehkv
ijb[eb`Zebkv dhfg_M f_gy[ueZ hq_gvaZf_^e_ggZy j_Zdpby
b yg_ agZekemrZlv ebfg_ beb\klZ\ZlvY h[^mfu\Zeqlh
^_eZlvdh]^Z \g_aZigha\mdb ehfZxsboky\_lhd klZeb \_a^_
\hdjm] f_gyY [ueih]ehs_g bfblZd [ukljhqlh _^\Z mki_e
\kdhqblv gZgh]b baZdb^Zlv dhkl_j
Y ih[_`Ze \gba ih kdehgm \ l_fghlm< fh_f mf_
ijhf_evdgmeZ fukevdh]^Z y[_`Ze kd\havdmkluqlh lZf g_
[ueh jh\gh]hf_klZY [_`Zeb iulZekyij_^hojZgblv fhb]eZaZ
hl \_lhdY ijh[_`Zeiheimlb \gbad ih^gh`vxohefZdh]^Z
ihqm\kl\h\Ze qlhlh ihaZ^bf_gyqlh ihqlbdZkZehkv f_gy
Wlh [ueZ g_ \_ldZwlh [ueh qlhlhqlh y bglmblb\gh
qm\kl\h\Ze b qlh^h]hgyeh f_gyHkhagZgb_ wlh]h aZklZ\beh
f_gy ihoheh^_lvY kdbgmek\hx dmjldmkdZlZe __\ ma_e d
`b\hlmih^`Ze gh]bb aZdjue]eZaZ jmdZfbdZd ij_^ibku\Ze
^hg OmZgY aZf_j\ wlhfiheh`_gbb gZdhjhldh_ \j_fydh]^Z
ihgyeqlh \k_\hdjm] f_gy[ueh [_a`bag_gghlbohG_ [ueh
gbdZdbo a\mdh\Y qj_a\uqZcgh\klj_\h`bekyFmkdmeu fh_]h
`b\hlZ khdjZsZebkv b^jh`Zeb \km^hjh]ZoAZl_f y mkeurZe
^jm]hc lj_kgm\rbca\mdHgdZaZehkvijbr_e ba^Ze_dZgh hg
[ue kh\_jr_ggh ykguf bhlq_leb\ufHg kemqbeky _s_ jZa
[eb`_ dh fg_GZklmibe fhf_gl lbrbguZ aZl_f qlhlh
\ahj\Zehkv dZd jZagZ^ fh_c]heh\hcG_h`b^Zgghklv wlh]h
rmfZ aZklZ\beZ f_gy
g_\hevgh
\a^jh]gmlvb y ihqlb
hijhdbgmeky gZ kibgmWlh [ue hij_^_e_ggh a\md \_ldb
kehfZgghc ihiheZfA\md jZa^ZekylZd [ebadhqlh y keurZe
r_e_kl ebklv_\gZ \_ld_dh]^Z hgZehiZeZkv
AZl_f ihke_^h\Ze
]jZ^
ehfZxsboky
\aju\h\\_ldb
ehiZebkv k[hevrhc kbehc\_a^_ \hdjm]f_gy< wlhlfhf_gl m
f_gy [ueZ g_khhl\_lkl\mxsZyj_Zdpby gZwlh g_h[udgh\_ggh_
y\e_gb_\f_klh lh]hqlh[u m`Zkgmlvkyy aZkf_yekyY
bkdj_gg_ ih^mfZeqlh ygZr_e ijbqbgmijhbkoh^ys_]hY [ue
m[_`^_gqlh ^hgOmZg kgh\Zrmlbe gZ^hfghcJy^ eh]bq_kdbo
aZdexq_gbc aZdj_ibe
fhx
m\_j_gghklvy
ihqm\kl\h\Ze
ijbih^gylh_ gZkljh_gb_Y [uem\_j_gqlh y fh] ko\Zlblv
wlh]h obljh]hklZjh]h ^hgZOmZgZ \ke_^mxs_c _]h obljhklb
Hg [ue hdhehf_gyehfZy \_ldbb agZeqlh yg_ hl\Z`mkv
ih^gylv ]eZaZhg [ue\ [_ahiZkghklbb [ue\he_g ^_eZlvlh
qlh hgohl_e
Y ij_^klZ\bek_[_qlh hg[ue h^bg\ ]hjZolZd dZd y
[ue k gbf ihklhyggh g_kdhevdh^g_cM g_]h g_ [ueh gb
\j_f_gbgb \hafh`ghklb\h\e_qv dZdbogb[m^v khljm^gbdh\
?keb hg ijylZekydZd y ^mfZehg ijylZeky h^bgb
eh]bq_kdbhg fh]ijhba\h^blv lhevdhh]jZgbq_ggh_ dhebq_kl\h
rmfh\LZd dZdhg [ueh^bgrmfu ^he`gu[ueb ijhbkoh^blv \
ebg_cghc ihke_^h\Zl_evghklb\h \j_f_gblh _klvh^gh\j_f_ggh
h^bgbebkZfh_ [hevr__^\Z bebljb h^gh\j_f_gghDjhf_
lh]hjZaghh[jZab_ rmfh\lZd`_ ^he`gh[ueh [ulv h]jZgbq_gh
f_oZgbdhc h^gh]hq_eh\_dZY [ueZ[khexlgh m\_j_glZd dZdy
hklZ\Zeky ijb`Zluf da_fe_ bkihdhcgufqlh \k_ bkiulZgb_
[ueh b]jhc bqlh _^bgkl\_gguckihkh[ \uclbih[_^bl_e_f ba
wlh]h wfhpbhgZevgh m^Zeblvk_[y bawlh]hY iheh`bl_evgh
gZkeZ`^Zeky wlbfY ihcfZek_[y gZlhfqlh jZ^h\Zekyfukeb
qlh yfh] ij_^\b^_lvke_^mxs__ ^\b`_gb_fh_]h ijhlb\gbdZY
klZjZeky ij_^klZ\blv k_[_qlh [uke_^mxs__ k^_eZe y gZ
f_kl_ ^hgZOmZgZ
A\md q_]hlh qfhdZxs_]h
\uljyogme
f_gy ba fh_]h
f_glZevgh]h mijZ`g_gbyY
gZijy`_ggh ijbkemrZekya\md
ih\lhjyeky kgh\Z b kgh\Zy g_fh] hij_^_eblvqlh wlh
lZdh_Hg a\mqZedZd [m^lhdZdh_lh `b\hlgh_oexiZeh \h^m
Hg jZa^Zeky kgh\Z hq_gv[ebadhWlhl jZa^jZ`Zxsbc a\md
gZihfbgZe fg_ oexiZxsbca\md bahjlZ xghc^_\mrdb`mxs_c
j_abgdmY [uem^b\e_gdZd ^hgOmZg fh]ijhba\h^blv lZdhc
a\mddh]^Z a\mdih\lhjbeky kgh\Zijb^y kijZ\ZKgZqZeZ [ue
_^bgkl\_gguc a\mdZ aZl_f
y
mkeurZe jy^ oexiZxsbo
re_iZxsbo a\mdh\dZd [m^lhdlhlh oh^beih ]jyabRmfu
ij_djZlbebkv gZ fhf_glZ aZl_fjZa^Zebkv _s_ jZa hq_gv
[ebadh ke_\Z\hafh`ghlhevdh \^_kylb nmlZohl f_gyWlh
[ue ihqlbhsmsZ_fucjZa^jZ`Zxsbc a\mdrZ]h\re_iZxsbo ih
]em[hdhc ]jyabL_i_jv a\md[ue lZdhcdZd [m^lh dlhlh
ly`_euc [_]Zejukvx \kZih]Zo ih]jyabY m^b\beky[h]Zlkl\m
a\mdh\Y g_fh] ij_^klZ\blvk_[_ dZdh]heb[h ijbfblb\gh]h
bah[j_l_gbydhlhjh_ y kZf fh] [u bkihevah\Zlvqlh[u
ijhba\h^blv lZdhc a\mdY mkeurZe gh\uc jy^ [_]Zxsbo
oexiZxsbo a\mdh\m k_[yaZ kibghcZ aZl_fhgb jZa^Zebkv\k_
kjZamkh \k_o klhjhgDlhlhdZaZehkvoh^be[_]Ze
ghkbeky ih]jyab \hdjm]f_gy
Eh]bq_kdh_ khfg_gb_ ijbreh fg_gZ mf?keb \k_ wlh
ijhba\h^be ^hg OmZghg ^he`_g
[ue [_]Zlv djm]Zfb k
g_\_jhylghc
kdhjhklvx;ukljhlZ
a\mdh\
^_eZeZ
wlm
Zevl_jgZlb\m g_\hafh`ghcLh]^Z yih^mfZeqlh ^hg OmZg
^he`_g [uebf_lv khh[sgbdh\\ dhgp_dhgph\Y ohl_e\u\_klb
ij_^iheh`_gb_d_f fh]eb[ulv _]hkhh[sgbdbgh bgl_gkb
\ghklv a\mdh\aZo\ZlbeZ \k_fh_ \gbfZgb_< ^_ckl\bl_evgh
klby g_ fh]^mfZlv ykghh^gZdhy g_[ue bkim]Zgy
\hafh`gh[ue lhevdhhr_ehfe_g g_h[uqgufk\hckl\hf a\mdh\
OexiZgvy ^_ckl\bl_evgh\b[jbjh\ZebNZdlbq_kdbbo kljZggu_
\b[jZpbbdZaZehkv[ueb gZijZ\e_gu \ fhc `b\hlbeb
\hafh`ghy \hkijbgbfZebo \b[jZpbbgb`g_c qZklvx k\h_]h
`b\hlZ
Wlh hkhagZgb_ ih\e_deh aZkh[hc g_f_^e_ggmx ihl_jx
fh_]h qm\kl\Zh[t_dlb\ghklb bjZ\gh^mrbyA\mdb gZiZ^ZebgZ
fhc `b\hlM f_gy\hagbd \hijhkqlh_keb wlh g_ ^hg
OmZg"bkim]Zeky yY gZijy]fmkdmeu `b\hlZ b iehlgh
ih^h]gme [_^jZd maemfh_c dmjldb
A\mdb \hajhkeb ih qbkemb kdhjhklbdZd [m^lh hgb
agZebqlh y ihl_jyek\hx m\_j_gghklvbo \b[jZpbb [ueb
lZdbfb bgl_gkb\gufbqlh f_gylhrgbehY [hjhekyk qm\kl\hf
lhrghluY i_j_\_e^mo bgZqZe i_lvfhb i_chlgu_i_kgbF_gy
klhrgbehb oexiZxsb_a\mdb kjZam`_ ij_djZlbebkva\mdb
k\_jqdh\\_ljZ b^Zevgbc eZcdhchlh\ gZeh`bebkv gZ \k_
<g_aZiguc i_j_ju\iha\hebe fg_i_j_^hogmlvb yijb]ey^_eky
d k_[_Lhevdh g_aZ^he]h
^h
wlh]h
y [ue \ emqr_f
jZkiheh`_gbb ^moZkZfhgZ^_ygguc b\ klhjhg_hq_\b^ghy
ihl_ji_e `Zedmxg_m^Zqm \hp_gd_ kblmZpbb>Z`_ _kebm ^hgZ
OmZgZ [ueb khh[sgbdb^ey gbo[ueh f_oZgbq_kdb g_\hafh`gh
ijhba\_klb a\mdbdhlhju_ \ha^_ckl\h\ZebgZ fhc`b\hlQlh[u
ijhba\h^blv a\mdblZdhc bgl_gkb\ghklbbf [ueh[u g_h[oh^bfh
ijbkihkh[e_gb_ aZ ij_^_eZfb bokj_^kl\ b bo ihgbfZgby
Hq_\b^ghg_h[udgh\_ggh_ y\e_gb_dhlhjh_ yi_j_`b\Zeg_
[ueh b]jhcb _s_ h^ghcrmldhc ^hgZOmZgZwlZ l_hjby[ueZ
lhevdh fhbfijbfblb\guf h[tykg_gb_f
M f_gy[ueb km^hjh]bb g_h^hebfh_`_eZgb_ hijhdbgmlvky
b ijhlygmlv gh]bY j_rbei_j_^\bgmlvky \ijZ\h ^ey lh]h
qlh[u hl\_jgmlvky hlf_klZ]^_ f_gy klhrgbehF]gh\_gb_
kimklydh]^Z ygZqZe ihealby mkeurZehq_gv fy]dbc kdjbi
ijyfh gZ^ fhbf e_\uf mohfY aZklue gZ f_kl_Kdjbi
ih\lhjbeky k
^jm]hc
klhjhgu
fh_c
]heh\uWlh [ue
_^bgkl\_gguc a\mdY ih^mfZeqlh hgihoh^be gZkdjbi ^\_jb
Y `^Zegh g_ keurZe [hevr_ gbq_]hihwlhfm y j_rbe
^\bgmlvky kgh\ZDZd lhevdhy gZqZei_j_^\b]Zlv hklhjh`gh
k\hx ]heh\m \ijZ\hy ihqlb ih^iju]gmeIhlhd kdjbih\
ih]ehlbe f_gykjZamHgb [uebih^h[gu bgh]^Zkdjbim ^\_j_c
Z \ ^jm]hcjZa ihoh^bebgZ ibkdbdjuk bebfhjkdbo k\bghd
Hgb g_[ueb ]jhfdbfbbeb kbevgufbgh [uebhq_gv fy]dbfb b
ih^djZ^u\Zxsbfbky b\uau\Zeb fmqbl_evgu_kiZafu lhrghlu \h
fg_Hgb ij_djZlbebkvdZd bgZqZebkvm[u\Zy ihkl_i_ggh
ihdZ y g_ fh] keurZlv
lhevdh
h^bg beb ^\Z ba gbo
h^gh\j_f_ggh
AZl_f ymkeurZe qlhlh ih^h[gh_djuevyf [hevrhcilbpu
ijhg_kr_cky gZ^ \_jomrdZfbdmklh\HghdZaZehkve_lZeh
djm]Zfb gZ^ fh_c]heh\hcFy]db_ kdjbiugZqZeb \hajZklZlv
kgh\Zb lZd `_ \hajZklZehoehiZgv_ djuev_\GZ^ fh_c
]heh\hcdZaZehkv[ueh qlhlhih^h[gh_ klZ_ ]b]Zglkdbo
ilbpfZoZ\rbo k\hbfbfy]dbfb djuevyfbH[Z a\mdZ kebebkv
ijhba\h^y ho\Zlu\Zxsmx \hegm\hdjm] f_gyY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
qlh ieZ\Ze\a\_r_gguc \h]jhfghc \heghh[jZaghc imevkZpbb
Kdjbiu b oehiZgv_ [ueb
lZdbfb
ieZ\gufbqlh y fh]
qm\kl\h\Zlv bo \k_f l_ehfOehiZgv_ djuev_\ klZb ilbp
dZaZehkvih^ly]b\Zeh f_gy \\_jo\ lh\j_fydZd ibkdb
djukdZaZehkvlhedZeb f_gykgbam b\hdjm] fh_]hl_eZ
Y m`_ g_khfg_\Zekyqlh[eZ]h^Zjy k\h_c g_mf_klghc
]emihklby kimklbe kijb\yab qlhlh m`Zkgh_gZ k_[yY
klbkgme am[ub]em[hdh \a^hogm\aZi_e i_chlgu_i_kgb
A\mdb ijh^he`Zebkv hq_gv^he]h_ \j_fyb y khijhlb
\eyeky bf kh \k_ck\h_c kbehcDh]^Z hgb mfhedebkgh\Z
gZklmibeZ lbrbgZlZdZydZdhc y ijb\ud \hkijbgbfZlv
lbrbgmlh _klvy fh]h[gZjm`blv lhevdh_kl_kl\_ggu_ a\mdb
gZk_dhfuo b \_ljZWlh \j_fylbrbgu [ueh^ey f_gy [he__
\j_^gufq_f \j_fyrmfh\Y gZqZe^mfZlv b hp_gb\Zlv fh_
iheh`_gb_b fh_h[^mfu\Zgb_ [jhkbehf_gy \iZgbdmY agZe
qlh y ih]b[m f_gyg_ [uehgb agZgbygb \ughkeb\hklb
qlh[u hljZablvlhqlh ijbklZ\Zehdh fg_Y [ue kh\_jr_ggh
[_kihfhs_gijbiZ\ da_fe_ gZ^k\h_c kh[kl\_gghcj\hlhcY
ih^mfZeqlh ijbr_edhg_p fh_c`bagbb aZieZdZeY ohl_e
ih^mfZlv hk\h_c `bagbgh g_agZek q_]hgZqZlvGbqlh ba
lh]hqlh y^_eZe \k\h_c `bagbg_ [ueh\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb
^hklhcgh wlh]hihke_^g_]h dhg_qgh]h\ujZ`_gbyihwlhfm fg_
g_ hq_f [ueh^mfZlvWlh [uehhkljh_ hkhagZgb_Y baf_gbeky
k l_o ihjdZd ihke_^gbcjZa i_j_`b\Zeih^h[guc bkim]GZ
wlhl jZa y[ue [he__imklhcY bf_ef_gvr_ ebqguo qm\kl\
qlh[u mg_klbk kh[hc
Y kijhkbe k_[yqlh
k^_eZe
[u \hbg \ ih^h[ghf
iheh`_gbbb ijbr_e
d
jZaebqguf
aZdexq_gbyfQlhlh
qj_a\uqZcgh \Z`gh_ [ueh \hdjm]fh_c imihqghc h[eZklb\
a\mdZo [uehqlhlh k\_jo_kl_kl\_ggh_hgb [uebgZp_e_gu gZ
fhc `b\hlb fukevqlh ^hgOmZg h[fZgu\Ze f_gy[ueZ
kh\_jr_ggh g_khklhyl_evgZ
Fmkdmeu fh_]h`b\hlZ [uebhq_gv gZijy`_guohly mf_gy
g_ [ueh[hevr_ gbdZdbokm^hjh]Y ijh^he`Zei_lv b ]em[hdh
^urZlvb ihqm\kl\h\ZemkihdZb\Zxs__ l_iehaZihegyxs__ \k_
fh_ l_ehFg_ klZehykghqlh_keb ykh[bjZxkv \u`blvy
^he`_g ijh^he`Zlv lZddZd f_gymqbe ^hgOmZgY ih\lhjbe
_]h bgkljmdpbb \ mf_Y ihfgbelhqgmx lhqdm]^_ khegp_
kdjuehkv aZ ]hjZfb \hlghr_gbb dohefm]^_ y [ueb d
f_klm]^_ ymiZe gZa_fexY i_j_hjb_glbjh\Zekybdh]^Z y
m[_^bekyqlh fhyhp_gdZ hkgh\guolhq_d [ueZ ijZ\bevghc
gZqZe f_gylv k\h_iheh`_gb_qlh[u fhy]heh\Z mdZau\ZeZ \
gh\hfemqr_fgZijZ\e_gbbgZ x]h\hklhdY f_^e_gghgZqZe
i_j_^\b]Zlv k\hb gh]b \e_\h^xcf aZ^xcfhfihdZ y g_
ih^h]gme bo \bdjZfAZl_f ygZqZe \ujZ\gb\Zlv k\h_ l_eh
gh]Zfbgh dZdlhevdh ygZqZe i_j_iheaZlv]hjbahglZevghy
ihqm\kl\h\Ze g_h[uqguc lheqhdm f_gy [ueh ^_ckl\bl_evgh
nbabq_kdh_ hsms_gb_ dZdh]hlh ijbdhkgh\_gby d g_aZdjulhc
ih\_joghklb aZ^g_c klhjhgu fh_cr_bWlh kemqbehkv lZd
[ukljhqlh yg_\hevgh \kdjbdgmeb kgh\ZaZf_jY gZijy]
fmkdmeu fh_]h `b\hlZb gZqZe]em[hdh ^urZlvb aZi_e fhb
i_chlgu_ i_kgbF]gh\_gb_ kimklyy _s_ jZa ihqm\kl\h\Ze
lZdhc `_ e_]dbcm^Zj ihk\h_c r__Y kt_`bekyFhy r_y g_
[ueZ aZdjulZb yg_ fh]gbq_]h k^_eZlvqlh[u aZsblblv
k_[yIh fg_kgh\Z ihklmqZebFh_c r_bdZkZeky hq_gvfy]dbc
ihqlb r_edh\bklucij_^f_lih^h[gh f_oh\hceZid_ ]jhfZ^gh]h
djhebdZHg dhkgmekyf_gy kgh\ZZ aZl_fhg gZqZei_j_k_dZlv
fhx r_x\aZ^ b\i_j_^ ^hl_o ihjihdZ mf_gy g_ \uklmibeb
ke_auWlh [uehlZddZd [m^lhklZ^h fheqZeb\uofy]dbo
g_\_khfuo d_g]mjmklmiZeb gh]Zfbih fh_cr__Y fh] magZlv
fy]dbc [hevrhciZe_p boeZidh]^Z hgbg_`gh klmiZebih fg_
Wlh \h\k_g_ [ueh[he_ag_gguf hsms_gb_fghl_f g_ f_g__
wlh jZa^jZ`ZehY agZeqlh_keb yg_ aZcfmkvdZdbfgb[m^v
^_ehfy khc^mk mfZ\kdhqm bih[_]mIhwlhfm y f_^e_ggh
gZqZe kgh\ZfZg_\jbjh\Zlv k\hbfl_ehf \gh\h_ iheh`_gb_Fhy
ihiuldZ ^\bgmlvkydZaZehkvmkbebeZ ihoehiu\Zgb_ih fh_c
r__HghgZdhg_p^hklb]eh lZdh]h[_r_gkl\Zqlh y^_jgmeky
\k_f k\hbfl_ehf bkjZam \ujh\gye_]h \gh\hf gZijZ\e_gbbM
f_gy g_ [uehgbdZdhc fukebhlghkbl_evgh j_amevlZlZ fh_]h
^_ckl\byY ijhklh^_ckl\h\Zeqlh[u aZsblblvkyhl ihegh]h
[mcgh]h kmfZkr_kl\by
DZd lhevdhy baf_gbegZijZ\e_gb_ihoehiu\Zgb_ ihfh_c
r__ ij_djZlbehkvIhke_ ^he]hcfmqbl_evghc iZmauy mkeurZe
ehfZxsb_ky \ hl^Ze_gbb\_ldbRmf g_ijb[eb`ZekyHg dZd
[m^lh hlklmiZe \ ^jm]h_iheh`_gb_ ^Ze_dh hl f_gyA\md
lj_kdZ\rboky \_lhd q_j_a
f]gh\_gb_
kebeky
kh a\mdhf
khj\Zgguor_e_kl_\rbo ebklv_\dZd [m^lh kbevguc \_l_j
ijhg_kky ih \k_fmohefm<k_ dmklu\hdjm] f_gydZaZehkv
aZlj_i_lZebh^gZdh\_ljZ g_[uehR_e_klysbc a\mdb lj_kd
\_lhd \ua\Ze\h fg_qm\kl\hqlh \_kvohef [ue\ h]g_Fh_
l_eh [ueh l\_j^ufdZd dZf_gvY kbevgh\kihl_eY gZqZe
qm\kl\h\Zlv k_[y \k_l_ie__ bl_ie__< wlhlfhf_gl y [ue
kh\_jr_ggh m[_`^_gqlh ohef ]hj_eY g_ \kdhqbe b g_
ih[_`Zeihlhfm qlhy lZdhp_i_g_eqlh [ue iZjZebah\Zg
nZdlbq_kdby g_ fh]^Z`_ hldjulv]eZaZ<k_qlh bf_eh
agZq_gb_ ^eyf_gy \wlhl fhf_glwlh \kdhqblvb m[_`Zlv hl
h]gyM f_gy\ `b\hl_[ueb m`Zkgu_kiZafudhlhju_ gZqZeb
hlj_aZlv fg_ ih]ehs_gb_ \ha^moZFg_ klZeh hq_gv ljm^gh
^urZlvIhke_ ^he]hc[hjv[u y[ue kihkh[_g kgh\Z ]em[hdh
^urZlv b fh]lZd`_ aZf_lblvqlh r_e_klmlbo[ue lhevdh
\j_fy hl\j_f_gb ihlj_kdb\Zxsbca\mdA\md ehfZxsboky\_lhd
klZgh\beky \k_ [he__b [he__hl^Ze_gguf b kihjZ^bq_kdbf
ihdZ kh\_js_gghg_ ij_djZlbeky
Y fh] hldjulv]eZaZY ihkfhlj_ekd\hav ihemhldjulu_
\_db gZa_fex i_j_^kh[hc;ue m`_jZkk\_lY ^he]h_ \j_fy
`^Zeg_ ^\b]ZykvZ aZl_fgZqZe \uly]b\Zlvk\h_ l_ehY
i_j_dZlbeky gZkibgmGZ \hklhd_gZ^ ohefZfb[ueh khegp_M
f_gy aZgyehqZku \uijyfblvgh]b bihlZsblvky \gbaih kdehgm
Y ihr_e df_klm]^_ ^hgOmZg ihdbgmef_gydhlhjh_ [ueh
\hafh`ghlhevdh \fbe_d ihem^gxy [uelhevdh gZ himrd_
e_kZ\k_ _s_\ ^h[jhcq_l\_jlb fbebhl g_]h
Y g_fh] [hevr_b^lbgh g_ih dZdhcgb[m^v ijbqbg_Y
ih^mfZe h]hjguo ev\Zob ihiulZeky\ah[jZlvky gZ^_j_\hgh
fhb jmdbg_ fh]ebm^_j`Zlv fhc\_kY ijbkehgbekyd kdZe_b
ijbfbjbeky kfukevx mf_j_lva^_kvY [uem[_`^_gqlh klZgm
ibs_c ^ey]hjguo ev\h\beb ^jm]boobsgbdh\M f_gyg_ [ueh
kbeu ^Z`_[jhkblv dZf_gvY g_[ue ]heh^_gb g_ohl_e iblv
Hdheh ihem^gyy gZr_efZe_gvdbc jmq__db \uibefgh]h \h^u
gh \h^Z g_ihfh]eZ fg_\hkklZgh\blv kbeuLZd dZdy kb^_e
lZf \ kh\_jr_gghc[_kihfhsghklby qm\kl\h\Zek_[y [hevr_
ih^Z\e_ggufq_f bkim]ZggufY [uelZdbf mklZ\rbfqlh g_
aZ[hlbeky hk\h_c km^v[_b aZkgme
Y ijhkgmeky hldZdhclh \kljykdb>hg OmZg kdehgbeky
gZ^h fghcHg ihfh]fg_ k_klvb ^Zefg_ \h^ub `b^dhcdZrb
Hg aZkf_yeky bkdZaZeqlh y`Zedh \u]ey^_eY ihiulZeky
jZkkdZaZlv _fmh lhfqlh kemqbehkvgh hgg_ klZekemrZlv b
kdZaZeqlh y g_ aZf_lbek\hx hlf_ldm f_klh]^_ y
ij_^iheZ]Ze \klj_lblvkyk gbf[ueh \khlg_ yj^h\\ klhjhg_
AZl_f hgihqlb ihg_kf_gy \gbaHg kdZaZeqlh hg\_e f_gyd
[hevrhfm ihlhdmb kh[bjZekybkdmiZlv f_gy\ g_fIh imlbhg
aZldgme fg_ mrbdZdbfblh ebklvyfbdhlhju_ [uebm g_]h \
kmfd_Z aZl_faZ\yaZe fg_]eZaZgZeh`b\ ihh^ghfm ebklmgZ
dZ`^uc ]eZa bijbfhlZ\ badmkdhf ldZgbHg aZklZ\be f_gy
kgylv h^_`^mb \_e_efg_ iheh`blvjmdb gZ]eZaZ bmrbqlh[u
[ulv m\_j_ggufqlh yg_ fh]\b^_lv bkeurZlv gbq_]h
>hg OmZggZl_j fh_l_eh ebklvyfbZ aZl_fk[jhkbe f_gy
\ j_dmY ihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh wlh[ueZ [hevrZy j_dZ;ueh
]em[hdhY klhyeb g_fh] ^hklZlv^gZ>hg OmZg^_j`Ze f_gy
aZ ijZ\ucehdhlvKgZqZeZ yg_ ihqm\kl\h\Zeoheh^Z \h^ugh
fZehihfZem y gZqZe
aZklu\ZlvZ
aZl_f
oheh^ klZe
g_kl_jibfuf>hg OmZg \ulZsbe
f_gy b h[l_j dZdbfblh
ebklvyfbdhlhju_ bf_ebki_pbnbq_kdbc aZiZoHg h^_ef_gy b
ih\_e ijhqvfu ijhreb[hevrh_ jZkklhygb_ij_`^_q_f hg
kgye ebklvy kfhbo ]eZab bafhbo mr_c>hg OmZg kijhkbe
f_gyqm\kl\mx eby k_[y^hklZlhqgh kbevgufqlh[u \_jgmlvky
d k\h_cfZrbg_;ueZ kljZggZy\_svy qm\kl\h\Zek_[y hq_gv
kbevgufY ^Z`_\a[_`Ze gZdjmlhc ohefqlh[u m^hklh\_jblvky
\ wlhf
Ih imlbd k\h_cfZrbg_ ygZoh^beky hq_gv[ebadh d^hgm
OmZgmY kihludZekyfgh`_kl\h jZaZ hgkf_yekyY aZf_lbe
qlh _]hkf_o [uehkh[_ggh mdj_ieyxsbfb hgklZe p_gljZevghc
lhqdhc fh_]h ihiheg_gbykbeuq_f [hevr_hg kf_yekyl_f
emqr_ yk_[y qm\kl\h\Ze
GZ ke_^mxsbc ^_gvy jZkkdZaZe^hgm OmZgm ihke_^h\Z
l_evghklv kh[ulbc kh \j_f_gbdh]^Z hghklZ\be f_gyHg
kf_yeky \k_ \j_fy ijb fh_f
hlq_l_hkh[_ggh dh]^Z y
jZkkdZaZe _fmqlh y ^mfZeqlh wlh [ueZ h^gZ ba _]h
obljhkl_c
Lu \k_]^Z^mfZ_rvqlh gZ^lh[hc rmlylkdZaZe hg
lu \_jbrvk_[_ kebrdhffgh]hLu ^_ckl\m_rvlZddZd [m^lh
lu agZ_rv \k_hl\_luLu g_agZ_rv gbq_]hfhc fZe_gvdbc
^jm]gbq_]h
< i_j\ucjZa ^hgOmZg gZa\Zef_gy fZe_gvdbf ^jm]hf
Wlh aZo\Zlbehf_gy \jZkiehoHg aZf_lbewlh bmeu[gmeky<
_]h ]hehk_ [ueZ h]jhfgZyl_iehlZb wlh aZklZ\beh f_gy
kbevgh hi_qZeblvkyY kdZaZe_fmqlh y[ue [_aaZ[hlguf b
g_kihkh[guf ihlhfmqlh wlh[ueZ \jh`^_ggZykdehgghklv fh_c
ebqghklbb qlhy gbdh]^Zg_ ihcfm_]h fbjZY qm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y ]em[hdh\a\hegh\ZggufHg [uehq_gv h[h^j_gb aZy\be
qlh yk^_eZe ohjhrh
Y kijhkbe_]h hagZq_gbb fh_]hi_j_`b\Zgby
Wlh g_bf_eh agZq_gbyhl\_lbe hglZ `_ kZfZy
\_sv fh]eZkemqblvky kdZ`^ufhkh[_ggh kih^h[guf l_[_dlh
bf__l k\hc ijhk\_lm`_ hldjulufWlh hq_gv h[uqghEx[hc
\hbgdhlhjuc hlijZ\ey_lkygZ ihbkdbheebjZkkdZ`_l l_[_h[
bo ^_ckl\byoLhqlh hgb^_eZeb k lh[hc[ueh fy]dbf
H^gZdhl\hc ijhk\_lhldjulb \hlihq_fm lulZdhc g_j\guc
Gbdlh g_fh`_l ij_\jZlblvky\ \hbgZkjZamL_i_jv lu^he`_g
hlijZ\eylvky ^hfhc bg_ \ha\jZsZlvky^h l_oihjihdZ g_
bae_qbrvky bihdZ l\hcijhk\_l g_aZdjh_lky
=eZ\Z
k_ fg Z^ pZ lZ y
Y g_ \ha\jZsZeky \
F_dkbdm g_kdhevdh f_kyp_\y
bkihevah\Ze wlh\j_fyqlh[u jZ[hlZlvgZ^ k\hbfbaZibkyfbb
\i_j\u_ aZe_lk l_oihjdZd gZqZemq_gbq_kl\hmq_gb_
^hgZ OmZgZgZqZeh ijbh[j_lZlvj_Zevguc kfukeY qm\kl\h\Ze
qlh ^he]b_ i_jbh^u\j_f_gbdh]^Z y^he`_g [ue hklZ\Zlvky
\^Ze_d_ hl mq_gbq_kl\Zijhba\h^beb hq_gv hlj_a\eyxs__ b
[eZ]hl\hjgh_ ^_ckl\b_ gZ
f_gyhgb ij_^hklZ\eyeb fg_
\hafh`ghklv ijh\_jblv
k\_^_gby
b
jZkiheh`blv
bo
\
bgl_ee_dlmZevghf ihjy^d_k\hckl\_gghf fh_fm\hkiblZgbx b
bgl_j_kmH^gZdhkh[ulbydhlhju_
bf_eb f_klh \ fhc
ihke_^gbc \bablgZ ihe_^_ckl\bymdZau\Zeb gZ hrb[hqghklv
fh_]h hilbfbafZih hlghr_gbxd ihgbfZgbxagZgby ^hgZOmZgZ
Y k^_eZeihke_^gxx aZibkv\ k\hboaZf_ldZo hdly[jy
]h^ZKh[ulbydhlhju_ bf_ebf_klh \ wlhf kemqZ_
hlf_lbeb i_j_oh^guc i_jbh^Hgb g_ lhevdh aZdjueb pbde
h[mq_gbygh hgb lZd`_hldjueb gh\uc pbdedhlhjuc lZd
kbevgh hlebqZeky hl lh]hqlh y^_eZe ^hkbo ihjqlh y
qm\kl\mxqlh wlhlhqdZ]^_ y^he`_g dhgqblvfhc j_ihjlZ`
Dh]^Z y ijb[ebabekyd ^hfm^hgZ OmZgZy m\b^_e _]h
kb^ys_f gZ _]h h[uqghf f_kl_ih^ jZfZ^Z ih^ ^\_jvxY
ihklZ\be fZrbgm\ l_gb^_j_\Z\aye k\hcihjln_ev bq_fh^Zg
k [ZdZe_cgufb lh\ZjZfbba fZrbgub ih^hr_ed g_fm]jhfdh
iha^hjh\Z\rbkv kgbfAZl_f yaZf_lbeqlh hg[ue g_ h^bg
IhaZ^b \ukhdhc dmqb ^jh\kb^_e ^jm]hc q_eh\_dHgb h[Z
kfhlj_eb gZf_gy>hg OmZgihfZoZe fg_jmdhc blZd `_k^_eZe
^jm]hc q_eh\_dKm^y ih_]h gZjy^mhg g_[ue bg^_cp_fZ
[ue f_dkbdZgp_f k x]haZiZ^ZHg [ueh^_ldZd e_\bk\
[_`_\mx jm[Zrdml_oZkkdmx dh\[hckdmxreyim b dh\[hckdb_
[hlbgdb
Y aZ]h\hjbe k ^hghf OmZghf b aZl_f ihkfhlj_e gZ
q_eh\_dZhg meu[Zeky fg_Y ijbklZevghkfhlj_e gZ g_]h
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy
A^_kv fZe_gvdbcDZjehkkdZaZe q_eh\_d^hgm OmZgm
B hgkh\k_f g_jZa]h\Zjb\Z_l khfghcG_ ]h\hjbfg_qlh
hg k_j^blgZ f_gy
Ij_`^_q_f y
fh]
kdZaZlv
qlhgb[m^vhgb h[Z
jZajZabebkv kf_ohfb lhevdhlh]^Z yihgyeqlh g_agZdhf_p
[ue ^hgO_gZjh
Lu g_magZe f_gy^Z"kijhkbe hg\k_ _s_kf_ykv
Y ^he`_g [ue ijbagZlvkyqlh _]hgZjy^ k[be f_gy k
lhedm
Qlh lu ^_eZ_rv\ wlhcqZklb fbjZ^hg O_gZjh"
kijhkbe y
Hg ijb[uegZkeZ^blvky l_ieuf\ha^mohfkdZaZe ^hg
OmZgg_ ijZ\^Zeb"
<_jgh\lhjbe ^hgO_gZjhLu g_ ij_^klZ\ey_rv
qlh fh`_lk^_eZlv l_ieuc\ha^mo ^eyl_eZ klZjh]h q_eh\_dZ
ih^h[gh]h fg_
Y k_ef_`^m gbfb
Qlh ^_eZ_lhg kl\hbf l_ehf"kijhkbe y
L_ieuc \_l_j]h\hjbl qj_a\uqZcgu_\_sb fh_fml_em
kdZaZe hg
Hg ih\_jgmekyd ^hgmOmZgm b]eZaZ _]haZ[e_kl_eb
G_ lZdeb"
>hg OmZgdb\gme _fm]heh\hc ml\_j^bl_evgh
Y kdZaZe bfqlh wlh\j_fy ]hjyqbo \_ljh\ kZglZZgZ
[ueh om^r_c qZklvx]h^Z ^eyf_gy bihwlhfm hq_gv kljZggh
qlh ^hgO_gZjh ijb_oZebkdZlv l_ieuc\_l_j\ lh\j_fy dZdy
m[_]Ze hlg_]h
DZjehk g_ i_j_ghkbl`ZjukdZaZe ^hg OmZg ^hgm
O_gZjhdh]^Z gZklmiZ_l`ZjZhg klZgh\blkydZd j_[_ghd
b aZ^uoZ_lky
AZQlh"
AZ^uoZ_lky
Fhc [h]kdZaZe
^hg
O_gZjhijbdbgm\rbkv
h[_kihdh_ggufb
k^_eZe
`_kl
hlqZygbydhlhjuc [ue
g_hibkm_fh aZ[Z\guf
AZl_f ^hgOmZg h[tykgbe_fmqlh f_gyg_ [uehg_kdhevdh
f_kyp_\ baaZ g_m^Zqgh]hkemqZy kheeb
BlZdlu gZdhg_pklhedgmeky kheebkdZaZe ^hg
O_gZjh
Y ^mfZx^ZkdZaZe yhklhjh`gh
Hgb ]jhfdhjZkohohlZebkv>hg O_gZjh^\Z bebljb jZaZ
ihoehiZe f_gy ih kibg_Wlh [ueh e_]dh_ ihoehiu\Zgb_
dhlhjh_ y \hkijbgyedZd ^jm`_kdh_\ujZ`_gb_ mqZklbyHg
aZ^_j`Ze k\hx jmdmgZ fh_fie_q_ bihkfhlj_e gZf_gyb y
ihqm\kl\h\Ze kihdhcgmx m^h\e_l\hj_gghklvdhlhjZy ^ebeZkv
lhevdh fhf_glZ aZl_f^hg O_gZjhk^_eZe kh fghc qlhlh
g_h[tykgbfh_Y \g_aZighihqm\kl\h\Zeqlh hgiheh`be \Zemg
gZ fhx kibgmM f_gy[ueh hsms_gb_qlh hg m\_ebqbe \_k
k\h_c jmdbdhlhjZy e_`ZeZgZ fh_fijZ\hf ie_q_lZdqlh hg
aZklZ\be f_gykh]gmlvky \gbab m^Zjblvky]heh\hc ha_fex
Fu ^he`gu ihfhqvDZjemr_kdZaZe ^hg O_gZjh b
[jhkbe aZ]h\hjsbkdbc\a]ey^ gZ^hgZ OmZgZ
Y kgh\Z \uijyfbekyb ih\_jgmekyd ^hgmOmZgmgh hg
kfhlj_e \ klhjhgmM f_gy\hagbdeh dhe_[Zgb_ b ^hkZ^gZy
fukevqlh ^hg OmZg \_ek_[y lZddZd [m^lh hg [ue \
klhjhg_hl^_evgh hlf_gy>hg O_gZjhkf_yekyhgdZaZehkv
`^Ze fh_cj_Zdpbb
Y ihijhkbe_]h iheh`blvk\hx jmdmgZ fh_ie_qh _s_jZa
gh hgg_ ohl_e^_eZlv wlh]hY m[_`^Ze_]h ihdjZcg_c f_j_
h[tykgblv fg_qlh
hg
^_eZe
kh
fghcHg ^h\hevgh
ihkf_b\ZekyY kgh\Zih\_jgmeky d^hgm OmZgmb kdZaZe _fm
qlh \_kjmdb ^hgZO_gZjh _^\Zg_ jZa^Z\bef_gy
Y gbq_]hg_ agZxh[ wlhfkdZaZe ^hg OmZg kZfuf
dhfbq_kdbf lhghfhg g_deZe k\hxjmdm gZfh_ ie_qh
Lml hgbh[Z jZkohohlZebkv
Qlh lu^_eZe khfghc^hg O_gZjh"kijhkbe y
Y ijhklhiheh`be k\hxjmdm gZl\h_ ie_qhkdZaZe hg
g_\bggh
Iheh`b __kgh\ZkdZaZe y
Hg hldZaZeky>hg OmZg\klmibe \wlhf f_kl_b ihijhkbe
f_gy hibkZlv^hgm O_gZjhlhqlh yhsmsZe \fh_f ihke_^g_f
i_j_`b\ZgbbY ih^mfZeqlh hgohl_eqlh[u y^h[jhkh\_klgh
hibkZe lhqlh ijhbkoh^beh kh fghcgh q_f k_jv_ag__
klZgh\behkv fh_ hibkZgb_l_f
[hevr_ hgb kf_yebkvY
hklZgZ\eb\Zeky ^\Z beb ljb jZaZgh hgb m[_`^Zeb f_gy
ijh^he`Zlv
Heeb y\bekyd l_[_g_ kqblZykvk l\hbfbqm\kl\Zfb
kdZaZe ^hgOmZgdh]^Z ydhgqbe k\h_ih\_kl\h\Zgb_y bf_x
\ \b^mqlh lug_ k^_eZ_rvgbq_]hqlh[u kh[eZagblv_]hLu
fh`_rv kb^_lv[_a^_evgbqZy beb^mfZy h`_gsbgZoZ aZl_f
\g_aZigh e_]dbc m^Zjih l\h_fmie_qmlu ih\hjZqb\Z_rvky
b heebklhbl i_j_^lh[hc
Qlh yfh]m k^_eZlv_keb kemqZ_lkyqlhlhih^h[gh_
wlhfm"kijhkbe y
WcWcIh^h`^b fbgmldmkdZaZe ^hgO_gZjhwlh
g_ohjhrbc \hijhkG_ kijZrb\Zch lhfqlh lufh`_rv k^_eZlv
Hq_\b^ghqlh lug_ fh`_rvk^_eZlv gbq_]hKijhkb h lhf
qlh fh`_lk^_eZlv \hbg
Hg ih\_jgmekydh fg_ijbsmjb\rbkv?]h ]heh\Z ke_]dZ
gZdehgbeZkv \ijZ\hZ _]hjhl kfhjsbeky
Y ihkfhlj_e gZ^hgZ OmZgZqlh[u hggZf_dgme fg_g_
[ueh ebwlh iheh`_gb_rmldhcgh hgkhojZgye g_ijhgbpZ_fh_
ebph
OhjhrhkdZaZe yqlh fh`_lk^_eZlv \hbg"
>hg O_gZjh ijbsmjbekyb aZqfhdZek\hbfb ]m[ZfbdZd
[m^lh bsZih^oh^ysb_ keh\ZHg \a]eygmegZ f_gyijbklZevgh
ih^^_j`b\Zy k\hcih^[hjh^hd
<hbg fhqbl \k\hb rlZgukdZaZe hg k bg^_ckdbf
kihdhckl\b_f
>hg OmZg aZdjuek\h_ ebphZ ^hgO_gZjh oehigmeky gZ
a_fexjZajZab\rbkv \hxsbfkf_ohf
Bkim] wlh g_qlhlZdh_hl q_]h gbdh]^Z g_evay
gZ\k_]^Z ba[Z\blvkykdZaZe ^hgOmZgdh]^Z kf_omlbo
Dh]^Z \hbg ihiZ^Z_l\ lZdh_ljm^gh_ iheh`_gb_hg ijhklh
ih\_jg_lky d heebkibghcg_ ^mfZy^\Z`^u<hbg g_ fh`_l
ihlZdZlv k_[_ihwlhfm hgg_ fh`_lmf_j_lv hlbkim]Z<hbg
iha\hey_l heebijbclb lhevdhlh]^Zdh]^Z hg\ ohjhr_cnhjf_
b ]hlh\Dh]^Z hg^hklZlhqgh kbe_gqlh[u kjZablvkyk heeb
hg hldju\Z_l k\hcijhk\_l\ufZgb\Z_l heebo\ZlZ_l _]h
^_j`bl _]h ijb`Zlufd a_fe_b khojZgy_l k\hc ijbklZevguc
\a]ey^ gZ g_f jh\ghklhevdhkdhevdh _fmgZ^haZl_f hg
hl\h^bl k\hb]eZaZhk\h[h`^Z_l heebb hlimkdZ_l_]h<hbg
fhc ^jm`hdwlh fZkl_j\ ex[h_\j_fy
Qlh kemqblky_keb lu[m^_rv kebrdhf^he]h ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_lv gZheeb"kijhkbe y
>hg O_gZjh ihkfhlj_egZ f_gyb bah[jZabe dhfbq_kdbc
`_kl \ukfZljb\Zgby
Dlh agZ_l"kdZaZe ^hgOmZgfh`_l [ulvO_gZjh
jZkkdZ`_l l_[_qlh kemqbehkvk gbf
Fh`_l [ulvkdZaZe ^hgO_gZjh baZobobdZe
Lu jZkkdZ`_rvfg_ih`ZemcklZ"
>hg O_gZjh \klZeihlj_sZe dhklyfb\uijyfeyy k\hb
jmdbb hldjuek\hb ]eZaZ^h lZdhckl_i_gbqlh hgb klZeb
djm]eufb b\u]ey^_eb [_amfgh
O_gZjh kh[bjZ_lkyijhba\_klb ^jh`vimklugbkdZaZe
hg bihr_e \qZiZjZev
O_gZjh j_rbe ihfhqv
l_[_kdZaZe ^hg OmZg
^h\_jbl_evguf lhghfhg ^_eZelh `_kZfh_ ^eyl_[y \k\h_f
^hf_b luihqlb \b ^_ e
Y ih^mfZeqlh hgkkueZeky gZlhqlh kemqbehkv m
\h^hiZ^Zgh hg]h\hjbe hlZbgkl\_gguo ]jhohqmsbo a\mdZo
dhlhju_ ykeurZe m^hfZ ^hgZO_gZjh
F_`^m ijhqbfqlh wlh[ueh"kijhkbe yfu
kf_yebkv gZ^ wlbfgh lugbdh]^Z g_h[tykgye fg_qlh wlh
[ueh
Lu gbdh]^Zg_ kijZrb\Ze
KijZrb\Ze
G_lLu kijZrb\Zef_gy h[h \k_faZ bkdexq_gb_f
wlh]h
>hg OmZgh[\bgyxs_ ihkfhlj_egZ f_gy
>Z
Wlh [ueh bkdmkkl\hO_gZjhkdZaZe hglhevdh
O_gZjh fh`_l^_eZlv wlhLu ihqlb \b ^_ e
lh]^Z
Y kdZaZe _fmqlh fg_gbdh]^Z g_ijboh^beh \ ]heh\m
k\yaZlv \b^_gv_k g_h[uqgufbrmfZfbdhlhju_ y keurZe
lh]^Z
: ihq_fmlu g_k\yau\Ze"kijhkbe hgj_rbl_evgh
<b^_lvwlh agZqbl]eZaZfb ^eyf_gykdZaZe y
Hg jZkkfZljb\Zef_gy g_dhlhjh_\j_fydZd [m^lhkh fghc
[ueh qlhlh g_lZd
Y gbdh]^Z g_]h\hjbeqlh \b^_gv_wlh lhevdh
]eZaZfbkdZaZe hgihdZqZ\ kg_^h\_jb_f ]heh\hc
DZd hg^_eZ_l wlh"gZklZb\Ze y
Hg m`_kdZaZe l_[_dZd hg^_eZ_l wlhj_adh kdZaZe
^hg OmZg
< wlhlkZfuc fhf_gly mkeurZeg_h[uqZcguc ]jhohl
Y \kdhqbeZ ^hg OmZggZqZe kf_ylvky=jhohl [ue
ih^h[_g ]jhfm eZ\bguIjbkemrZ\rbkv
d g_fmy k^_eZe
aZ[Z\gh_
aZdexq_gb_qlh
\hkijbgbfZ_fu_
fghx
a\mdb
hij_^_e_ggh ijhbkoh^beb \ dbghGbadbc ]medhlhjuc y
keurZeihoh^be gZa\mdh\hc ljxddbghdh]^Z p_eZy klhjhgZ
]hju jmrblky\ ^hebgm
>hg OmZg ^_j`Zeky aZ[hdZdZd [m^lhhgb [he_eb hl
kf_oZ=jhohqmsbc ]m^ ihljykZe a_fex]^_ y klhyeY
hlq_leb\h mkeurZe m^Zj
q_]hlhqlhdZaZehkv[ueh
m\_kbkluf [meu`gbdhfdhlhjuc dZlbeky\gbaY mkeurZe jy^
khdjmrbl_evguo m^Zjh\qlh kha^Zehm f_gy\i_qZle_gb_qlh
\Zemg g_mfhebfh dZlbekydh fg_Y bkiulZefhf_gl djZcg_]h
aZf_rZl_evkl\ZFhb fmkdmeugZijy]ebkv\k_ fh_l_eh [ueh
]hlh\h d[_]kl\m
Y \a]eygme gZ ^hgZOmZgZHg ijbklZevgh kfhlj_e gZ
f_gyAZl_f y mkeurZe kZfuc
m`ZkZxsbc m^ZjdZdhc y
dh]^Zeb[h keurZe \fh_c `bagbDZd [m^lh h]jhfguc \Zemg
ijba_febeky ijyfh ihaZ^b^hfZ<k_ kh^jh]gmehkvb \ wlhl
fhf_gl m f_gy \hagbdehgZb[he__ g_h[uqgh_ hsms_gb_GZ
f]gh\_gb_ y ^_ckl\bl_evghm\b^_e\Zemg \_ebqbghck ]hjm
ijyfh ihaZ^b ^hfZWlh g_[ueh h[jZahfgZeh`_gguf gZ
dZjlbgm ^hfZgZ dhlhjucy kfhlj_eWlh lZd`_g_ [ueh\b^hf
gZklhys_]h [meu`gbdZWlh [uehkdhj__l_fdZd _keb[u rmf
kha^Z\Ze h[jZa\ZemgZdZlys_]hky gZk\hbo h]jhfguo[hdZoY
^_ckl\bl_evgh \b^_ermfG_h[tykgbfuc
h[jZa
fh_]h
\hkijbylby ijb\_e f_gy d]em[hdhfm hlqZygbx b aZf_rZl_
evkl\mGbdh]^Z \ `bagby g_ij_^klZ\eye k_[_qlh fhb
qm\kl\Z fh]eb \hkijbgbfZlv lZdbfh[jZahfGZ f_gy gZiZe
jZpbhgZevguc kljZob yj_rbe kiZkZlvky [_]kl\hfqlh[u
khojZgblv k\hx `bagv>hg OmZg
ko\Zlbe f_gy jmdhc b
ih\_ebl_evgh ijbdZaZe fg_g_ m[_]Zlvb lZd`_g_ h]ey^u\Z
lvkygh ih\_jgmlvky ebphf\ gZijZ\e_gbbdm^Z mr_e ^hg
O_gZjh
Y mkeurZe ke_^mxsmxk_jbx rmfh\dhlhju_ ihoh^beb gZ
a\md dZfg_ciZ^Zxsbo b]jhfha^ysboky ^jm]gZ ^jm]ZZ aZl_f
\k_ kgh\ZklZeh kihdhcghQ_j_a g_kdhevdhfbgml ^hg O_gZjh
\_jgmeky b k_eHg kijhkbe\b^_eeb yY g_ agZeqlh
kdZaZlvY ih\_jgmeky d ^hgm OmZgm aZ mdZaZgbyfbHg
ijbklZevgh kfhlj_egZ f_gy
Y ^mfZxqlh hg\b^_ekdZaZe hgb aZkf_yeky
Y ohl_ekdZaZlvqlh g_ihgbfZxh q_fhgb ]h\hjylY
qm\kl\h\Ze k_[ym`Zkgh jZkkljh_ggufM f_gy[ueh nbabq_kdh_
hsms_gb_ \hafms_gbydjZcg_]h g_m^h[kl\Z
Y ^mfZxfu hklZ\bf_]h a^ _k v
kb^_lvh^gh]h
kdZaZe ^hgOmZg
Hgb \klZebb ijhrebfbfh f_gy
DZjehk ihlZdZ_lk_[_ \k\h_f aZf_rZl_evkl\_kdZaZe
^hg OmZghq_gv ]jhfdh
Y hklZ\Zekyh^bg g_kdhevdhqZkh\ bbf_e \j_fygZibkZlv
k\hb aZf_ldbb h[^mfZlvg_e_ihklv fh_]hi_j_`b\Zgby>mfZy
h[ wlhffg_ klZehykghqlh klh]h kZfh]hfhf_glZdh]^Z y
m\b^_e ^hgZ O_gZjhkb^_\rbf ih^jZfZ^ZkblmZpby ijbgyeZ
g_e_iuc \b^Q_f [hevr_y jZa^mfu\ZegZ^ wlbfl_f [hevr_
m[_`^Zekyqlh ^hg OmZgmklmibe dhgljhevgZ^h fghc ^hgm
O_gZjhb wlZfukev gZihegbeZf_gy fjZqgufij_^qm\kl\b_f
>hg OmZg b^hg O_gZjh\_jgmebkv \kmf_jdZoHgb k_eb
jy^hf khfghck[hdm hlf_gy>hg O_gZjhkb^_e [eb`_b ihqlb
ijbkehgbeky dh fg_?]h om^h_ b ojmidh_ ie_qh ke_]dZ
dZkZehkv f_gyb ybkiulu\Ze lh`_ kZfh_qm\kl\hdhlhjh_ m
f_gy [uehdh]^Z hgihoehiZe f_gyKhdjmrbl_evgZy ly`_klv
gZ\ZebeZkv gZf_gyb ymiZe gZdhe_gh ^hgZOmZgZHg ihfh]
fg_ k_klvijyfh bkijhkbe \rmleb\hf lhg_g_ iulZekyeb y
mkgmlv gZ_]h dhe_g_
>hg O_gZjhdZaZehkvgZkeZ`^Zeky_]h ]eZaZ[e_kl_eb
Fg_ ohl_ehkv aZieZdZlvM f_gy[ueh qm\kl\hqlh y [ue
ih^h[_g `b\hlghfmdhlhjh_ [uehaZ]gZgh \aZ]hg
Y im]Zx l_[yDZjemrZ"kijhkbe ^hg O_gZjh
dZaZehkv^_ckl\bl_evgh haZ[hq_gghLu \u]ey^brv ih^h[gh
^bdhc ehrZ^b
JZkkdZ`b _fmkdZadmkdZaZe ^hgOmZgLhevdh wlh
mkihdZb\Z_l _]h
Hgb i_j_^\bgmebkv b k_eb
gZijhlb\ f_gyHgb h[Z
gZ[ex^Zeb aZ fghc k ex[hiulkl\hf< ihemlvf_ bo ]eZaZ
dZaZebkv a_jdZevgufbdZd h]jhfgu_l_fgu_ em`b \h^uBo
]eZaZ \gmrZebkljZowlh g_[ueb ]eZaZex^_cFu ijbklZevgh
kfhlj_eb ^jm]gZ ^jm]Zg_dhlhjh_ \j_fyZ aZl_fy hl\_ek\hb
]eZaZY aZf_lbeqlh yg_ [hyekybobl_f g_f_g__bo
]eZaZ gZim]Zeb f_gy ^hlZdhc kl_i_gbqlh y aZ^jh`ZeY
ihqm\kl\h\Ze hq_gvg_m^h[gh_ aZf_rZl_evkl\h
IhfheqZ\ g_fgh]h^hg
OmZg
m[_^be
^hgZ O_gZjh
jZkkdZaZlv fg_h lhfqlh kemqbehkvk gbfh^bg jZadh]^Z hg
ihijh[h\Ze i_j_kfhlj_lv k\h_]h heeb>hg O_gZjh kb^_e \
g_kdhevdbo nmlZo hl f_gyebphf dh fg_hg gbq_]h g_
]h\hjbeY \a]eygmegZ g_]h_]h ]eZaZdZaZehkv[ueb \
q_luj_ beb\ iylvjZa [hevr_h[uqguo q_eh\_q_kdbo]eZahgb
kbyeb b g_ij_h^hebfhijbly]b\ZebLhqlhdZaZehkv[ueh
k\_lhf _]h]eZa]hkih^kl\h\Zeh gZ^\k_f \hdjm]g_]hL_eh
^hgZ O_gZjhdZaZehkvkt_`behkv b\u]ey^_eh ih^h[gh l_em
dhrdbY aZf_lbe^\b`_gb_ _]hdhrZqv_]h l_eZb bkim]Zeky
Kh\_jr_ggh Z\lhfZlbq_kdbdZd [m^lhy ^_eZewlh \kx k\hx
`bagvy ijbgye[h_\mx ihamb gZqZejblfbqgh [blvih k\h_c
ijZ\hc bdj_Dh]^Z y klZe khagZ\Zlv k\hb ^_ckl\byy
kfmlbeky b\a]eygme gZ^hgZ OmZgZHg \kfZljb\Zeky\ f_gy
dZd hg^_eZe h[uqgh_]h ]eZaZ[ueb ^h[jufbb mkihdZb\Zxsb
fbHg ]jhfdhaZkf_yeky>hg O_gZjhba^Ze fmjeudZxsbca\md
\klZe b\hr_e \^hf
>hg OmZgh[tykgbe fg_qlh ^hgO_gZjh [uehq_gv kbevguf
b g_ ex[beaZgbfZlvky imklydZfbb qlhhg ijhklh ^jZagbe
f_gy k\hbfb ]eZaZfbHg kdZaZeqlhdZd h[uqghy agZe
[hevr_q_f h`b^ZekZfHg k^_eZeaZf_qZgb_qlh dZ`^ucdlh
[ue k\yaZgk fZ]b_c[ue m`ZkghhiZk_g \qZku kmf_j_db qlh
fZ]bih^h[gu_ ^hgmO_gZjhfh]eb kh\_jrZlvqm^_kZ \ wlh
\j_fy
Fu fheqZeb g_kdhevdhfbgmly qm\kl\h\Zek_[y emqr_
JZa]h\hj k ^hghfOmZghf jZkkeZ[bef_gy b \hkklZgh\be fhx
m\_j_gghklvAZl_f hgkdZaZeqlh hgohl_e ih_klvqlhgb[m^v
b qlhfu kh[bjZ_fkyijh]meylvky ^eylh]hqlh[u ^hg O_gZjh
fh] ihdZaZlvfg_ l_ogbdmijylZgvy
Y ihijhkbe _]h h[tykgblvqlh hg ih^jZamf_\Z_l ih^
l_ogbdhc ijylZgvyHg kdZaZeqlh hgaZdhgqbe kh[tykg_gb_f
\_s_c fg_ihlhfm qlh h[tykg_gb_ lhevdh mkbeb\Zeh fh_
ihlZdZgb_ k_[_
Fu \hreb\ ^hf>hg O_gZjhijb k\_l_d_jhkbgh\hc eZfiu
i_j_`_\u\Ze ibsm
Ihke_ _^u fuljh_ ihreb\ ]mklhcimklugguc qZiZjZev
>hg OmZg r_e ihqlbjy^hf khfghc>hg O_gZjh [ue i_j_^h
fghc\ g_kdhevdboyj^Zo \i_j_^bf_gy
;ueZ ykgZyghqv[ueb ly`_eu_lmqbgh [ueh^hklZlhqgh
emggh]h k\_lZqlh[u ykghij_^klZ\eylv k_[_hdjm`Zxs__<
h^bg fhf_gl^hg OmZghklZgh\beky bkdZaZe fg_qlh[u y r_e
\i_j_^ b ^h]hgye ^hgZ O_gZjhY aZdhe_[Zekyhg g_`gh
ih^lhedgme f_gyb aZ\_jbeqlh \k_ohjhrhHg kdZaZeqlh y
\k_]^Z ^he`_g [ulv
]hlh\
b
\k_]^Z
^he`_g ^h\_jylv
kh[kl\_gghc kbe_
Y ^h]hgye ^hgZ O_gZjhke_^mxsb_ ^\ZqZkZ b iulZeky
ihjZ\gylvky k gbfgh dZdkbevgh ygb klZjZekyy g_ fh]
^h]gZlv _]hKbemwl ^hgZO_gZjh [ue\k_]^Z \i_j_^b f_gy
Bgh]^Z hgbkq_aZedZd [m^lhiju]Ze \klhjhgm hl ljhibgdb
lhevdh qlh[u kgh\Z ihy\blvky\i_j_^b f_gyQlh dZkZehkv
f_gylh wlhdZaZehkv[ueZ kljZggZy[_kkfuke_ggZy oh^v[Z
\ l_fghl_Y r_eihlhfmqlh yg_ agZedZd \_jgmlvky d
^hfmY g_fh] ihgylvqlh ^_eZe^hg O_gZjhY ih^mfZeqlh
hg \_e f_gyd dZdhfmlh g_ykghfmf_klm \ qZiZjZe_qlh[u
ihdZaZlv fg_ l_ogbdmh dhlhjhc]h\hjbe ^hgOmZg< h^ghf
f_kl_h^gZdhm f_gy\hagbdeh g_h[uqgh_hsms_gb_qlh ^hg
O_gZjh [ue ihaZ^b f_gyY ih\_jgmeky b f_evdhf m\b^_e
q_eh\_dZ \ g_dhlhjhf hl^Ze_gbbihaZ^b f_gyWnn_dl [ue
ihljykZxsbfY bah\k_o kbeklZjZeky m\b^_lv\ l_fghl_ b
\_jbeqlh fh]jZaebqblv kbemwlq_eh\_dZklhy\r_]h ijbf_jgh
\ iylgZ^pZlb yj^Zo hl f_gyNb]mjZ ihqlb keb\ZeZkv k
dmklZfbhgZ dZd [m^lh
ohl_eZ kdjulvkyY ijbklZevgh
\]ey^u\Zeky fhf_gl b fh]^_ckl\bl_evgh jZah[jZlv kbemwl
q_eh\_dZ \ ihe_fh_]h \hkijbylby^Z`_ ohlyhg b klZjZeky
kijylZlvky aZ l_fgufbhq_jlZgbyfb dmklh\Lh]^Z eh]bqgZy
fukev ijbreZ fg_\ ]heh\mwlbf q_eh\_dhf^he`_g [ulv ^hg
OmZgdhlhjuc ^he`_g [ue ke_^h\ZlvaZ gZfb \k_ \j_fy
F]gh\_ggh yklZe m[_`^_gqlh wlh[ueh lZdy lZd`_ ihgye
qlh y g_ fh][hevr_ jZaebqZlv_]h kbemwl\k_qlh [ueh
i_j_^h fghcwlh g_jZaebqbfZy
l_fgZy fZkkZ imkluggh]h
qZiZjZey
Y ihr_ed f_klm]^_ y\b^_e q_eh\_dZgh g_fh] gbdh]h
gZclb>hgZ O_gZjhlZd`_ gb]^_g_ [ueh\b^ghblZd dZd y
g_ agZe ^hjh]by k_e`^ZlvQ_j_a iheqZkZ^hg OmZgb ^hg
O_gZjh ijbrebHgb ]jhfdha\Zeb f_gyih bf_gbY \klZe b
ijbkh_^bgbeky dgbf
Fu reb d^hfm \iheghc lbrbg_Y ijb\_lkl\h\Ze wlhl
ZgljZdl lbrbguihlhfm qlhy qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y kh\_jr_ggh
^_ahjb_glbjh\ZggufNZdlbq_kdby
qm\kl\h\Ze
k_[y
g_ba\_klguf kZfhfmk_[_>hg O_gZjhk^_eZe qlhlh ^eyf_gy
qlhlhqlh m^_j`b\Zehf_gy hlnhjfmebjh\Zgby fhbo fuke_c
l_f iml_fdZbf yijb\ud wlh^_eZlvFg_ klZehwlh hq_\b^gh
dh]^Z ykb^_e gZljhibgd_Y Z\lhfZlbq_kdbijh\_jbe \j_fy
dh]^Z k_eb aZl_fhklZ\Zeky kihdhcgufdZd [m^lhfhc mf[ue
\udexq_g<k_ `_y kb^_e\ khklhygbbgZklhjh`_gghklbdZdmx
y gbdh]^Zg_ bkiulu\Zeij_`^_Wlh [uehkhklhygb_ [_afukeby
\hafh`ghkjZ\gbfh_ k
[_aaZ[hlghklvx
dh
\k_fmFbj
dZaZehkv[ue \
l_q_gb_
wlh]h
\j_f_gb\ kljZgghf
jZ\gh\_kbby gbq_]hg_ fh]^h[Z\blv dg_fm bgbq_]h g_fh]
\uq_klv bag_]h
Dh]^Z fuijbreb d^hfm^hg O_gZjhjZkdZlZe khehf_gguc
fZl b e_]kiZlvY qm\kl\h\Zeg_h[oh^bfhklv \hkijhba\_klb
k\hb i_j_`b\Zgby^hgm OmZgmGh hgg_ iha\hebefg_ ]h\hjblv
hdly[jy ]h^Z
Y ^mfZxqlh yihgye lhqlh ^hg O_gZjh iulZeky
k^_eZlv ijhrehcghqvxkdZaZe y^hgm OmZgm
Y kdZaZewlh ^eylh]hqlh[u \uau\Zlv_]h gZjZa]h\hj
?]h ihklhyggu_hldZau jZa]h\Zjb\ZlvebrZeb f_gyijbkmlkl\by
^moZ
>hg OmZg meu[gmeky bf_^e_ggh ihdZqZe ]heh\hcdZd
[m^lh kh]eZrZykvkh fghcY ^he`_g[ue ijbgylvwlhl `_kldZd
ih^l\_j`^_gb__keb [ug_ kljZgguc[e_kd \_]h ]eZaZo?]h
]eZaZ dZd[m^lh kf_yebkvgZ^h fghc
Lu ^mfZ_rvy
g_
ihgbfZx^Z"kijhkbe y
g_ijb^m`^_ggh
Y iheZ]Zx^ZIhgbfZ_rvgZ kZfhf ^_e_lu
ihgbfZ_rvqlh O_gZjh[ue ihaZ^bl_[y \lh \j_fyH^gZdh
ihgbfZgb_ wlh g_gZklhys__ ^_eh
?]h ml\_j`^_gb_qlh ^hgO_gZjh [ueihaZ^b f_gy \k_
\j_fyihljykeh f_gyY ihijhkbe_]h h[tykgblvwlh
L\hc mfgZijZ\e_g lZdqlh bs_llhevdh h^gm klhjhgm
wlh]hkdZaZe hg
Hg \ayekmomx \_ldmb klZe^\b]Zlv _xih \ha^momHg g_
[jhkZe __ \ha^mo bg_ jbkh\Zenb]mjulhqlh hg ^_eZe
ihoh^beh gZ ^\b`_gbydhlhju_ hg^_eZ_l k\hbfb iZevpZfb
dh]^Z \uqbsZ_lkhj badmqb a_jgZ?]h ^\b`_gby[ueb ih^h[gu
fy]dhfm mdhembeb pZjZiZgvx\ha^moZ \_ldhc
Hg h[_jgmekyb ihkfhlj_egZ f_gyZ yfZrbgZevgh ih`Ze
ie_qZfb \g_^hmf_gbbHg klZeq_jlblv [eb`_b ih\lhjylvk\hb
^\b`_gbyk^_eZ\ \hk_fv lhq_dgZ a_fe_Hg h[\_e i_j\mx
lhqdm
Lu a^_kvkdZaZe hg<k_ fua^_kv wlh qm\kl\h
b fu^\b]Z_fky hlkx^Zkx^Z
Hg hibkZe\lhjmxdhlhjmx hggZq_jlbe ijyfhgZ^ i_j\hc
lhqdhcAZl_f hgklZe ^\b]Zlvk\h_c \_ldhc\aZ^ b \i_j_^
f_`^m ^\mfylhqdZfbqlh[u bah[jZablvly`_eh_ ^\b`_gb_
H^gZdhq_eh\_d bf__l_s_ r_klvlhq_ddhlhjufb hg
kihkh[_g mijZ\eylvkdZaZe hg;hevrbgkl\h ex^_cgbq_]h
g_ agZxlh gbo
Hg ihf_klbek\hx \_ldmf_`^m i_j\hcb \lhjhclhqdZfb b
ldgme a_fex_x
>\b`_gb_ f_`^m wlbfb^\mfy lhqdZfb lu gZau\Z_rv
ihgbfZgb_fLu ^_eZewlh \kxk\hx `bagvDh]^Z lu]h\hjbrv
qlh ihgbfZ_rvfh_ agZgb_lu g_^_eZ_rv gbq_]hgh\h]h
AZl_f hg kh_^bgbeg_dhlhju_ ba\hkvfb lhq_d ebgbyfb
ihemqbeZkv \ulygmlZy ljZi_p_\b^gZynb]mjZdhlhjZy bf_eZ
\hk_fv p_gljh\k g_jh\gufbemqZfb
DZ`^Zy ba wlbor_klb hklZ\rbokylhq_d wlh fbj
lhqgh lZd`_dZd qm\kl\hbeb ihgbfZgb_wlh ^\ZfbjZ ^ey
l_[ykdZaZe hg
Ihq_fm a^_kv \hk_fvlhq_d"Ihq_fm g_ [_kdhg_qgh_
qbkehdZd \djm]_"kijhkbe y
Y gZq_jlbedjm] gZa_fe_>hg OmZgmeu[gmeky
GZkdhevdh yagZx_klv lhevdh\hk_fv lhq_ddhlhjufb
q_eh\_d kihkh[_g
mijZ\eylv<hafh`ghex^b g_ fh]ml
ij_\ukblv wlh]hB ykdZaZe mijZ\e_gb_fg_ ihgbfZgb_fqlh
lu ihemqbe"
?]h lhg [ue lZdbf aZ[Z\gufqlh y aZkf_yekyHg
ih^jZ`Ze bebkdhj__i_j_^jZagb\Ze fh_ gZklZb\Zgb_ gZ
lhqghf mihlj_[e_gbbkeh\
L\hy ijh[e_fZ\ lhfqlh luohq_rv \k_ihgylvZ wlh
g_\hafh`gh?keb lu gZklZb\Z_rv
gZ
ihgbfZgbblu g_
mqblu\Z_rv \kxk\hx km^v[mdZd q_eh\_q_kdh]hkms_kl\ZL\hc
dZf_gv ij_ldgh\_gbyp_eIhwlhfmlu g_k^_eZe ihqlbgbq_]h
aZ \k_ wlb]h^uLuijZ\^Z\uljyogmeky ba k\h_c iheghc
^j_fhlugh wlh]h fh`gh [ueh^hklbqv ijb ex[uo ^jm]bo
h[klhyl_evkl\Zo
Ihke_ iZmau^hg OmZg\_e_e fg_ih^gylvkyihlhfm qlhfu
kh[bjZebkv d \h^ghfm dZgvhgmDh]^Z fu kZ^bebkv \ fhx
fZrbgmbaaZ ^hfZ\ur_e ^hgO_gZjh bijbkh_^bgbeky d gZf
Fu ijh_oZeb qZklv imlbZ aZl_fihreb i_rdhf \ ]em[hdhf
ms_ev_>hg OmZg\u[jZe f_klh\ l_gb[hevrh]h ^_j_\Zqlh[u
hl^hogmlv
Lu h^gZ`^umihfygmegZqZe ^hgOmZgqlh l\hc
^jm] kdZaZedh]^Z \ugZ[ex^Zeb ebkliZ^Z\rbc k kZfhc
\_jrbgu kbdhfhjZqlh lhl`_ kZfucebkl g_miZ^_l kgh\Z k
lh]h `_kZfh]h kbdhfhjZgbdh]^Z \\_qghklbihfgbrv"
Y \kihfgbeqlh jZkkdZau\Ze_fm h[wlhf kemqZ_
Fu m[hevrh]h ^_j_\Zijh^he`Ze hgb l_i_jv
_keb fu ihkfhljbf gZ^jm]h_ ^_j_\hi_j_^ gZfbfu fh`_f
m\b^_lv ebkliZ^Zxsbc k kZfhc\_jrbguHg mdZaZe fg_
kfhlj_lvGZ ^jm]hcklhjhg_ h\jZ]Z[ueh [hevrh_^_j_\h_]h
ebklvy [uebih`_el_\rbfb bkmobfbHg ih[m^bef_gy ^\b`_gb_f
k\h_c k\h_c ]heh\u khojZgylv
\a]ey^ gZ ^_j_\_Ihke_
g_kdhevdbo fbgml h`b^Zgbyk \_jrbgukhj\Zeky ebklb gZqZe
iZ^Zlv gZa_fexhg m^Zjbekyh ^jm]b_ebklvy b\_ldb ^_j_\Z
ljb jZaZij_`^_ q_fmiZe gZ\ukhdbc ih^e_khd
Lu \b^_e_]h"
>Z
Lu kdZ`_rvqlh lhl`_ kZfucebkl gbdh]^Zkgh\Z g_
miZ^_l klh]h `_kZfh]h ^_j_\ZijZ\^Z"
IjZ\^Z
GZkdhevdh luihgbfZ_rv wlh bklbgZGh wlh lhevdh
gZkdhevdh luihgbfZ_rvKfhljb kgh\Z
Y fZrbgZevgh \a]eygme b m\b^_e iZ^Zxsbc ebklHg
^_ckl\bl_evgh m^Zjyekyh l_`_ kZfu_ebklvy b\_ldbqlh b
ij_^u^msbc ebklY dZd[m^lh kfhlj_el_dmsmx l_e_\babhggmx
i_j_^ZqmY ijhke_^beaZ \heghh[jZagufiZ^_gb_f ebklZihdZ
hg g_ miZe gZa_fexY ih^gyekymagZlv[ueb eb wlh ^\Z
ebklZgh \ukhdbcih^e_khd \hdjm]^_j_\Z ij_iylkl\h\Ze fg_
jZkkfhlj_lv]^_ ebkl^_ckl\bl_evgh ijba_febeky
>hg OmZgjZkkf_yeky b\_e_e fg_k_klv
KfhljbkdZaZe hgmdZaZ\ k\h_c]heh\hc gZ \_jrbgm
^_j_\ZLZf iZ^Z_llhl `_kZfuc ebklkgh\Z
Y _s_jZa m\b^_eebkliZ^Zxsbc lhqghlZdbf `_h[jZahf
qlh b^\Z ij_^u^msb_
Dh]^Z hgmiZey agZeqlh ^hgOmZg kh[bjZ_lkymdZaZlv
fg_ kgh\Z ihkfhlj_lvgZ \_jrbgm^_j_\Zgh ij_`^_q_f hg
k^_eZe wlhy ih^gye]eZaZEbkl iZ^Zekgh\ZLh]^Z yihgye
qlh lhevdh \b^_e i_j\uckhj\Z\rbcky ebklbebkdhj__
i_j\uc jZa ebklmiZedh]^Z y\b^_e _]hk lh]h f]gh\_gby
dh]^Z hg hl^_ebekyhl \_ldb^jm]b_ ljbjZaZ ebkl[ue m`_
miZ\rbfdh]^Z yih^gbfZe ]heh\mihkfhlj_lv
Y kdZaZewlh ^hgmOmZgm bgZklZb\Zeqlh[u hgh[tykgbe
fg_ lhqlh hg^_eZe
Y g_ ihgbfZxdZd
lu aZklZ\ey_rv f_gy \b^_lv
ih\lhj_gb_ lh]hqlh y\b^_e ij_`^_Qlh luk^_eZe khfghc
^hg OmZg"
Hg aZkf_yekygh g_hl\_qZeb ygZklZb\Zeqlh hg
^he`_g kdZaZlv fg_dZd yfh] \b^_lvwlhl ebkliZ^Zxsbf
kgh\Z b kgh\ZY kdZaZeqlhih fh_fm fg_gbxwlh
g_\hafh`gh
>hg OmZgkdZaZeqlh _]hjZamf ]h\hjbl_fm lh`_ kZfh_
h^gZdhy [uek\b^_l_e_f iZ^_gbyebklZ kgh\Zb kgh\ZAZl_f
hg ih\_jgmekyd ^hgmO_gZjh
G_ lZdeb"kijhkbe hg
>hg O_gZjhg_ hl\_lbe?]h ]eZaZ[ueb khkj_^hlhq_gugZ
fg_
Wlh g_\hafh`ghkdZaZe y
Lu ijb\yaZg\hkdebdgme ^hgOmZgLu ijb\yaZg d
k\h_fm jZamfm
Hg h[tykgbeqlh ebkliZ^Ze kgh\Zb kgh\Zk lh]h `_
kZfh]h ^_j_\Z_keb lhevdhy hklZgh\ex ihiuldb ihgylv
>h\_jbl_evguf lhghf hg kdZaZefg_qlh \ky \_sv m f_gy
ijhreZ m^Zqghghh^gZdhfhy fZgby\k_]^Z hke_ieyeZf_gy \
dhgp_
< wlhfg_q_]h ihgbfZlvIhgbfZgb_ wlh lhevdhhq_gv
g_[hevrh_ ^_ehhq_gv fZe_gvdh_kdZaZe hg
< wlhlfhf_gl ^hgO_gZjh \klZeHg [jhkbehkljuc \a]ey^
gZ ^hgZOmZgZbo ]eZaZ\klj_lbebkv b^hg OmZgihkfhlj_e gZ
a_fex i_j_^ kh[hc>hg O_gZjhklhye i_j_^hfghc b gZqZe
jZafZob\Zlv k\hbfbjmdZfb \klhjhgu\aZ^ b\i_j_^ jblfbqgh
KfhljbDZjemrZkdZaZe hgKfhljbKfhljb
Hg ba^Ze qj_a\uqZcghj_adbck\bklysbc a\mdWlh [ue
a\md q_]hlh j\ms_]hkyLhqgh \lh f]gh\_gb_dh]^Z jZa^Zeky
a\mdy ihqm\kl\h\Zehsms_gb_ imklhlu\gbam fh_]h `b\hlZ
Wlh
[ueh
m`Zkgh
fmqbl_evgh_
hsms_gb_
iZ^_gbyg_
[he_ag_ggh]hghkdhj__g_ijbylgh]h bih]ehsZxs_]hWlh
ijh^he`Zehkv g_kdhevdh k_dmg^Z
aZl_f kiZehhklZ\b\
kljZgguc am^ \ fhbo dhe_gyo< lh \j_fydZd ^ebehkv
hsms_gb_y i_j_`b\Ze^jm]hc g_\_jhylgucn_ghf_gY m\b^_e
^hgZ O_gZjhgZ \_jrbg_]hjdhlhju_ [ueb\hafh`gh\ ^_kylb
fbeyo<hkijbylb_ ^ebehkv
lhevdh
g_kdhevdh
k_dmg^ b
kemqbehkv lZd g_h`b^Zgghqlh m f_gy g_ [ueh \j_f_gb
^_ckl\bl_evgh jZkkfhlj_lv_]hY g_fh] \hkdj_kblv\b^_e eb
y q_eh\_q_kdmx nb]mjdm gZ
\_jrbg_
]hju beb wlh [ue
mf_gvr_gguc h[jZa^hgZ O_gZjhY g_fh] ^Z`_\kihfgblv[ue
eb wlh^hg O_gZjhbeb g_lH^gZdh\ wlhlfhf_gl ^eyf_gy g_
[ueh gbdZdh]hkhfg_gbyqlh y\b^_e _]hklhysbf gZ\_jrbg_
]hjH^gZdh\ lhlfhf_gl yih^mfZeqlh yg_ fh]jZaebqblv
q_eh\_dZ \^_kylb fbeyob \hkijbylb_bkq_aeh
Y ih\_jgmekyqlh[u ihkfhlj_lvgZ ^hgZO_gZjhgh _]h
g_ [ueh
G_^hmf_gb_dhlhjh_ y
i_j_`b\Ze[ueh
lZdbf `_
m^b\bl_evgufdZd \k_^jm]h_qlh kemqZehkvkh fghcFhc mf
kh]gmeky hl gZijy`_gbyY
qm\kl\h\Ze k_[y kh\_jr_ggh
^_ahjb_glbjh\Zgguf
>hg OmZg\klZe b\_e_e fg_aZdjulv gb`gxxqZklv fh_]h
`b\hlZ jmdZfbb iehlghijb`Zlv gh]bd l_em\ wlhfiheh`_gbb
Fu \ fheqZgbb g_dhlhjh_ \j_fyZ aZl_f hg kdZaZeqlh
^_ckl\bl_evgh
kh[bjZeky
\ha^_j`Zlvky
hl
h[tykg_gby
q_]hgb[m^v fg_ihlhfm qlhlhevdh ^_ckl\myq_eh\_d fh`_l
klZlv fZ]hfHg ihkh\_lh\Zefg_ g_f_^e_gghm_oZlvbgZq_ ^hg
O_gZjh\hafh`ghm[v_l f_gy\ k\h_fmkbebb ihfhqvfg_
Lu kh[bjZ_rvkybaf_gblv gZijZ\e_gb_kdZaZe hgb
lu jZah[v_rvk\hb hdh\u
Hg kdZaZeqlh fg_g_q_]h [uehihgbfZlv \^_ckl\byo _]h
b ^hgZ O_gZjh bqlh fZ]b[ueb \iheg_ kihkh[gu kh\_jrZlv
g_h[udgh\_ggu_ ijhy\e_gby
O_gZjh by ^_ckl\m_fhlkx^ZkdZaZe hgb mdZaZegZ
h^bg bap_gljh\ gZk\h_c ^bZnjZ]f_Z wlhp_glj ihgbfZgby
b \k_`_ luagZ_rvqlh wlhlZdh_
Y ohl_e kdZaZlvqlh y\ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbg_ agZeh
q_f hg]h\hjbegh hgg_ ^Zefg_ \j_f_gb\klZe bmdZaZe fg_
ke_^h\Zlv aZgbfHg gZqZeb^lb [ukljhg_h[udgh\_gghb y
iuoly bihl_yklZjZeky g_hlklZ\Zlv hlg_]h
Dh]^Z fuk_eb \fZrbgmy h]ey^_ekybsZ ^hgZO_gZjh
=^_ hg"kijhkbe y
Lu agZ_rv]^_ hgj_adh hl\_lbe^hg OmZg
Ij_`^_q_f m_oZlvy ihkb^_ek gbfdZd y ^_eZe
\k_]^ZM f_gy [ueh
g_ij_h^hebfh_ ih[m`^_gb_ kijhkblv
jZatykg_gbcDZd ]h\hjbl ^hgOmZgh[tykg_gby wlh \
^_ckl\bl_evghklb fh_ihlZdZgb_ k_[_
=^_ ^hgO_gZjh"hklhjh`gh kijhkbey
Lu agZ_rv]^_kdZaZe hg\k_ `_lu dZ`^uc jZa
l_jibrv ihjZ`_gb_ihlhfm qlhlu gZklZb\Z_rvgZ ihgbfZgbb
GZijbf_jlu agZe\ lmghqvqlh O_gZjh[ue ihaZ^bl_[y \k_
\j_fylu ^Z`_ih\_jgmeky bm\b^_e _]h
G_laZijhl_klh\Ze yg_ly g_agZe wlh]h
Y [uebkdj_g_g \wlhfFhc mfhldZau\Zeky ijbgylvwlhl
\b^ \ebygbydZd j_Zevgh_bh^gZdhihke_ ^_kylb e_l
mq_gbq_kl\Z k^hghf OmZghffhc mfg_ fh][hevr_ aZsbsZlvfhb
klZju_ h[uqgu_djbl_jbb lh]hqlh y\ey_lkyj_ZevgufH^gZdh
\k_ ij_^iheh`_gbydhlhju_ y^h kboihj \ha[m`^Zeh ijbjh^_
j_Zevghklb[ueb
ijhklh
bgl_ee_dlmZevguf
fZobgZpbyfb
^hdZaZl_evkl\hf lhfm [uehlhqlh ih^ ^Z\e_gb_f ^_ckl\bc
^hgZ OmZgZb ^hgZO_gZjhfhc mfaZr_e \lmibd
>hg OmZgihkfhlj_e gZf_gyb \_]h ]eZaZo[ueZ lZdZy
i_qZevqlh yaZieZdZeKe_au ihl_debkZfb< i_j\ucjZa \
k\h_c `bagb y qm\kl\h\Zeh[j_f_gyxsbc \_k fh_]h jZamfZ
G_hibkm_fZy fmdZ h\eZ^_eZfghcY g_\hevghaZ\ue b h[gye
_]hHg [ukljhklmdgme f_gykmklZ\Zfb iZevp_\ ih fZdmrd_
fh_c ]heh\uY ihqm\kl\h\Ze
wlh
dZd
\hegm \gba ih
iha\hghqgbdmWlh bf_ehhlj_a\eyxs__ ^_ckl\b_
Lu kebrdhffgh]h ihlZdZ_rvk_[_kdZaZe hgfy]dh
Wibeh]
>hg OmZg f_^e_ggh oh^be\hdjm] f_gyHgdZaZehkv
jZa^mfu\Ze]h\hjblv bebg_ ]h\hjblvqlhlh fg_>\Z`^u hg
hklZgZ\eb\Zeky bdZaZehkvi_j_^mfu\Ze
<_jg_rvky lu bebg_l wlh kh\_jr_ggh g_\Z`gh
gZdhg_pkdZaZe hgh^gZdhl_i_jv l_[_g_h[oh^bfh `blv
dZd \hbgmLu \k_]^ZagZe wlhl_i_jv luijhklh \iheh`_gbb
qlh \ugm`^_gbkihevah\Zlv g_qlhq_f luij_g_[j_]Ze ij_`^_
Gh lu ^he`_g [hjhlvkyaZ wlhagZgb_hgh g_ ijhklh ^Zgh
l_[_hgh g_ijhklh \jmq_ghl_[_ k\ur_Lu ^he`_g\u[blv _]h
ba k_[y<k_ `_lu \k__s_ k\_lys__kykms_kl\hLu \k__s_
kh[bjZ_rvky mf_j_lvih^h[gh \k_f^jm]bfY h^gZ`^u ]h\hjbe
l_[_qlh gbq_]hg_evay baf_gblv\ k\_lys_fkyycp_
Hg ihfheqZefhf_glY agZeqlh hgkfhlj_e gZf_gygh
y ba[_]Ze_]h ]eZa
Gbqlh j_Zevghg_ baf_gbehkv\ l_[_kdZaZe hg
Скачать